Sunteți pe pagina 1din 30

!

# "
$%

! " # !$ % & ' # (


! .(/ - ) * *)( * +( , *)
) 4 001 2+ # 3 4
5 & 5& $ 5 6 7 .(
% 18 * 5 90 ! : ! 9
=5 # % ' ; " <&, (
< ! 0 " : ,6> ? 6
@ # % .(/ 1
! 5 0 1 A (
, / ( B 2+ # ) #+ A
2 ! * 6< ( $ = 6 ) * :# 3 4!6
+) :% : $ A C :D 3 *1 ( 0
= % 9 9 E ) (
9 F *1 ,
< ) % % 0 03 ' # 0/ !
* 6,
G '# / <!6 A! <!6 0! '
5 A! ! 03 ( 4
= * ?, ( % F ' * 2+ 4
This study tackles two aspects of the issues of contemporary
Arabic critical discourse ; namely, the theory and the approach.
Both are well-represented by two common trends: traditional and
new. The former belongs to our heritage focusing on the
possibility of re-reading all that has been inherited making use of
the western approaches after having them adapted to the extent
they can match with the contemporary mental and cultural
Arabic vision.
The second trend has completely departed from the heritage.
Moreover, it follows the western modernistic approach instead.
It undertakes all western theoretical principles, mechanisms, and
terminologies. The application of the modernistic western
approach to the reading of Arabic literature as well as the
innovation of Arab men of literature that have turned their
literary work into a phenomenon which is a mere mimicry of the
western phenomenon if not an appendix or an extension of it.
As a matter of fact, a critical theory should reflect literature
and literary creative aspects since a literary theory of this type
must be the gist of the features of the Arabic literature including
its syntactic, stylistic and aesthetic components.
In conclusion, the present study is a practical attempt calling
for re-visiting the western literary critical approaches and making all
possible use of them on the condition that one should reserve the
identity of Arabic literature including its thought and aesthetics.
!" *+ " ( ")% '
5 3 & 3 $ , 6 "0 *
4!6 G * ' * % # % 9 6! #
&, 6 H! + * F 1* $5 6
I : 4 1 6 6 : H 6 40 1 + 2+ I 6
= 0E ) $ J ' : 1*
9 9 K 1 4 & / 6 "0 * *+B *1
#–+ ) ' ' * 6 + * I . 1
*D % * # –* *
= % F(E '
* !H01 4!6 $/ – 0 .+) # – * +
* 6 $ F6 / 2 + *># 7 3 # !H03
( 9 ( ( % !H01 + = '
( + 3 5F H 6 E ( % #
2 ! < 0 4 & H , %
9 ) 3 ' # 09 # (
< 1 !$ F !H01 *># 65 L @ 9
9 / 5 5 (9 0 = M * 5 (9
* $, *1 !6 + = 6 E $ *6 5
(0 # 5 (9 2! *># %D 6 9 $,6 N E
+ ) = 09 4!6 H9 $,6 1 O # # G H ) G; 0 *
= 9 #7 0 % :6 '
P 01 $– ' #–< *1 $
* 6 9 6 : H 3 < 9 , * 1

&
: * G $, * #* . A $ 9 9 :
# 09 0 6 E ! 6 '
( 9 ; / + A :9 ! (0 H '
) G LS @ Q R "' 1 0
:6 # # ( ( FF 6 # 6 6 E ( #
# R # B 6 * 1 U 0 T: # *6
) =U< 1 T* H * : F
< 5H 0 9 $ 0 6/ + 1 G # J G A G( 6
$– 0 1 # 2+ = ' & ' # (
H 61 * G$, * P01 + &F – 2+
*6 *+ ) 6 $ 0 ! ( #
V 1 $ ( 9 ! $ *
0 ( # 1 # 0 01 6 6 $ 0 3
=G $ 6 0* %3
0, ! W ) *1 H .+ : 61 *
6F ( * ! ! ; *6 " ( 3
) 6 E 3 *1 !% ! 0 . ) ( X
3 #* / !% : 1 +) 7 . '$ * 0 E ( *6
* 6 # * : ># 0E : ( *6
= ( ' . 1 # 6 E 6 '

- ). " / 0. ")% '


+ – Y ) ' *
* 4!6 Z 0 ) * : 61 – % <
/ ! * ! $ [:9 1* * 4
,
! ' 9 F 0 *6
2 ! 1 $ = ?! ( '$ , 0/ '$ #
' F3 ) D * H 0 *6 4 (
A 5 ' 4!6 X 9 / * /* # * $ 6 ! 6
$1 ? ! * ! % ! * # # % * 5 #E
* 9 * 9% * * ( *6 ,
G '# A 4 *
< 0 %3 # 5 6 03 A $ *+ * 0 0
0( < 6 A G ' G$ G ( :9 A 4 3 :( #
1 )* = ?! F ( #,
G 1 : '
9 O 9 # ( + * "0 ' K
4 !6 G 6 &] G 09 GZ # \ $ *0E : * + # %
&L ( ' % + * 5 0 *1 + 7 0
= A # % FA
: R # %* 1 6 0 G Z 9 + *
: * <Z 4!6 ' # % .F( / < 1 9
# % 4!6 X 9 / 5 # *># + = F1 * 3 1
!Z1 7 H % ' ( 0 4 *6 0 A
* *1 : # A * + $ # * *9% * 9
; 0
L( ! 6 ; *6 8 # % WF ) 6 LB !
* ! # & 3 * = ' : Z& ' #
# % 4!6 – A # % 4!6 < ( 0/ 2!
# # ( 0/ 2! !( $ = M J 3
+ *% & .F 3 * ( & ?$
( ? ' ) * : : 3 ( 6
! # U^a`^[^__` T * ( ! * (* =& ! (
# 3 * ! 4 3 ! ' *+ * (
< 5 6 ) : * ! & 3 5 : () < ! * (
4 !6 A A! 4 : 0 #: ' !01 b
! 1= !03 # 6 *6 G ? *1 6
% ( 4 : 6 $ # U^ade[^_`cT
&
1 () # : * 0 #&
6 1 ^af` U A T : 6
@ + H
,
:H B # gh' g %1 0 ! .+ 03 * # #
& F 4 . . ( : ,61 A 3 . %D . $ $
$ A 3 <,6D # * 3 * * * <% * : ,61
/ = I 5 ( < )9 0 R * P 1& 0 < 01
? L F( 6 * 3 2+ / 2+ 49
% $,6 4!6 ) * <S * ! /5 6 # 6
* 6* $* # * ?D :! ( 6 2! 3
< 6 )& ! * 6 0,0 ! %1 D <
$/ 0,0 0 : 1 ' < ) 1*
1 I ! *1 (1 * = ' < A!
= ' & < A! I *1 : !6 *># A i
: ' * / :% 9 ( (1 * 9! 5 1 A! *1 2 +
< < # ? P *1 + A!
< * ( 9 9 * S 1G ( 1/ 5 %G
1
4 &P @ < : ># – 7 –8 1= < #
= <6 N 1 4 & 01 #
5 < # & * : ,61 1 1
* % 1 < %Z *1 2+ H 1 A & <) G & F
1
? 4 < G 1 # *1 4 * < 1/ …< 0
FA 6 2H 1 0 0 ( # P )
, 1 E 2 0 "$ # * 5,9 & 'D
3 2
7 F
9$ * 6 & B # + 6F 4!(
1 4 !6 G# 0 G G () % + ^afd U * T #
4 !6 ) & R 2! I 0 # : 6 0 *1 Z G ) $
%D ! G 9 ! 5
: 1 +) G G F! E 3 . (6
P 6 * # ( 4 5 6 4!6 : , 8 #
* < ! , # %D $ F .
3 4
* A 6 # % )( : F! / A
:( 0 ># * 4 : ,61 6 E ( * ! +
!( A # % ( + : 6 9 I0 2+
3 6: 6 #? / ) # 3
4!6 )( A 4 6 # %
A *1 2 + A :( 3 % *6 8 6E
* 3 * 9 R +A + / * *
$ + ( 6 G 0. 1 P !# 4 0
4!6 < 6, <Z * & 3 *D 2 + 09 = 3
*D 2+ # D X I64 * 9 ! $ A 9
!% *1 * ZE # % ! < 3 0 #
6 0 < 1 * 0 *1 * % 4!6 :D ; + # B
3
! # % Y A : ') 3
*6 – A % %D $ ) – +A j 6 ?$ ?! /
: #& 0 % #: 0 + % &F : 0
& B* * :# ! + U 9 H T
* 0 ( G ( ( 2+ * 0 (& B ( <F
! :H F *6 – W * – :# + UQ h T: # <1
0 /
G 0 ()
D # 6 Y "! + ( - # 9! : 9
G ' G * . 1 4 F# # 9! 4 * 9
# 9! 4 !6 : !\Z 4 ( hL( P6 # (
)+ 4 ! < *F I # 5
6 ' + 9! X ( ( I + ( (
&
= 3 Q! (
+ % # 3 .(/ +A < + /
$[ +A )(
L – A % *3 9! 4 * 9
.(, +A < # 0 k 0 9! J A! 1 4!6
% # 9! . ( / *3 G G #* < + 9! J 3
( * /
\ 4 0 < 9(* $ ( :!% +
4 !6 P 4 4 !6 < 4 6 *3
0 +) ( UI # T # 4
= < 9 #5 0! : !6
2 ! – % 4 : 0 #–P 1
*D G 6 ) ) # C 9 ( 0/
* # % 1 *1 2 + 8 1 4!6 / < *1 * / %
6 / ! < 4 * Q! + / F ( : + #

2
*1 4 !6 ( < + ) # : 09 * B 0
,
+ ) *)+ *1 ,
G )( ( # *)+ # 0
l ( ( N

7( 6 - 5 '&
% (+ * G' $ " ( 0 *
R .(/ 1 ,% * ) ( * G G) (
) : * 5 #E " 4 6 .( #
F F6 . ( / +) # W E 9
P 6* 0 6 0 * F6 F '
=5 F F 6 ? 49 5 3 : # 9 6 (
# – H (E J ( ( 0 4 3 .(/ * +
% *1 7 % . ( / *># "$ 4 A * – (
N 2 + F( * * < :1 / W'E ! $
F F ( < (; ' ' N * G&F( & # +
M) 5 0 ! ( $: *># ( 4!6 1 = X
= 6 E ( 4!6 B I A
*1 " 0 < ! *1 : , 0 * *
2 ! !6 < 3 A G H (E : ( P0;
* * "! + ); 1 5 ( 6 <Z (
' I G 4 G ' G6 '
= !
*1 7 0 .+) 1 4 6 +
! QH * ( 9 0 *1 A 3
) 4!6 < 3 ) ( *># < *0m ; C

4
& ' # ; *1 A ?H 6 H 3 )
7 0P 3 Y I 0 # 3 ?, *1 ; 2!
.+) Z :9 3 ) * 9 & B ?,
/ ( 7 0 *' Z
%D $, G 6 E 5 ) , *
= 6 E *
Z #* # F E *
= 3 6 Z FZ 6 6 :# ( + $ #
* * % 6 0 $ % +
4 G 9 $ 6 E 1 *># H (E
%* + =h, 5 Z F 6 E : H *># <% *
2 ! G 0$ G ( / ># 2! 15 ) .+)
3 *D 5F) ( Z 9 , $ # 5 )
# 3 5 ) 4!6 I *># + A C g :% : $
* 68 + ) 1 # ! % 4!6 I A 3
#. N !6 9 n : N m 6 Z5
: H * 6 E 1 ( *6 ,
G '# 6 E : 0 3
2 ! * !% 1 4 8 0 E .+) h ' = 0E
=

8) " 95 . ' '&


: " : " 95 ' ' '&
#–* 0 "# $ 5 6 1 ( <6*
3 N 3 + A h! < 0 4 – 3 (
A 6 E J ; & ' # 6 H A
3 N QH 6/ + 3 * ! H A
#–? ) – H A # ( ' : #
0 B $ – Lyrical verse A : 9
*1 Z $, 2! * , / : 0 0 $ 5 %
9# 2 + * < % 1 4 :D +
) U T ! .H $ "' 6 * !) (
* $ $ * # * . Z *6 : GF N 0 & E
+ . UM T40 B< 0 * 4 63
2 + H %0 2! *># L + lU (S T 0
1
+ H A h! *># 2 + = * #P 1 *1
Z // :3 ,
G !' G ! h : ># : ?
*0 8 :6 8 0 # + ! +
< 0 8 = ( # 0 < :1 Z U ( T
< 3 N +) QH *1 * <Z 4!6 U H A T h!
14 ! *1 4 5 * G$,
= A 3 %D 0 % 1N 1
: // . $ *># U ! T U ! T h! 1
J A ! QH + 0 3 ? 0 A
Q 8 ' 1 $ = 9 9 H
* ! G I$ Z 4!6 ! 2! 4
= U n (!( ! T2 + !% 1 * Q A Q *
! *1 )- ) )3 * 5 ( 4!6 ; 0 ( )*
U ) T ! P U 5+ E T ! " I n (!(
!6 + k 0 9 P 9 6 # 0 9 !
"H $ 1 6 1 4!6 ! ! ? L 0 () *1
1 4!6 < # + G $G * * $ 3
: # WF 1 !0D < 1 (1& # <) * 3 (
3 QH * 0 ? ) 5 03 Y "$
Z G * G $,
G * <!# U n (!( T 1 = !
=Q, < I R : %A0# * + 2 1 #: <0
%; !0D * ) ) 0 03 ! N ' *1 $ : 1
* + n (!( % 4 0 4 4!6 4!6
># + = 9 5 * $ :%!% 5 R 5 * . %!%
& # *0E 5 * F3 N 5 # % B (*
<H *0E # 4!( 4!6 R '$ & 9
2
4 5 0C $1 ) 3 Q +) *># + = ! *6
9 !! 0 3 ? I W " ! 1 1 !
= GF 1 0(
1 9 : ( 6 E 1P *1 A 1 2 + : 61 *
3 V F , * ( I# (
9 ; # ( H 3 2 + QH F 4!6 <
= 90!9

7 : * " / : ; " " 95 ' '&


3* ' 1 *
6 ( H+ 9 P ( 9 :/ 3
( 0 * , 3 ) / )
* &] ( : ; 3 9 5 ) 6 !( 4 3
; *6 L 6 + 0 <% <,0E G !) (
#= 0 # 3 : !6 5 A (
+> # 1Y 4!6 I < 3 4!6 I
" 0 * ? + & !% H E 5
0 I #: 1 * * 64 6
*> # % 5 ! G ! G % 5 2! + *
# G HF( 5 A ; , * 09 8 9 9 $
* * 1? 4 ! 5
,
G 5 Z % +
4
= U T ? 6 61 G '
& 3 * 4!6 – ) %D <Z – 2! *
; *6 , H *># – A 3 –
# 2! 0 <F! 0 + 3 0E H
0 !Z1 *1 , * 6 ' J $ 0
. 1 A 3 ' 1 $ 2!
# A // 3 + <)9 ! < 0 9
& E & # A 3 Y :D 3
& * 0 1 * 6 ( * 0, 1
, / 0 * < 3 <!0 < = * $
? P 1 $ H( 9 09 A ( + 0
l !) ( # F 0 0 +( P ! * )
<0 $ ) 4!6 0E * <0 $ %*
6F 14 ! J ! + ( !6 6F *6
0 F( 5 0/ : 4 0E # 0
* 0/ +) QH 4 *$ 0 % *
G $ 6 % 4!6 < 1 *1 0/ <% 0 # A

&
1 4!6 / : GH Z G < 1? < G 0 G ! G 1*
= 6 "0 * "! #* 0
[ 0 F( <)1 6 0 1 1 UQ T5 ) #
* 2+ < 0 * G 3 0, *3
# 0E #G G ( G / 7 0 % [
: ! 01 (F 17 % Q * !) ( +
# Z .L 6 ( ( ) 6: 8 )
( U ( A T * :% 3 * I!
# 0 6 :1 # 2 ) - ( ( U ( I T
2 < (63 * * 2 P 3 2 I …… * ? D
* & ( <% == '3 * 6 < H 2 ( #5
*1 2 + * 6 M G 7 G6 # 3 ! (# !#
QH . 0 $ Q : 0 * 5 6 6
8 # – :3 0 h, . # *># P ; 1 1l 0
9 9/ * G ( G6 ' G0 G9 G6 F NF $ – . H $
=,
G% P 9 ?
% / ! <)9 2! *1 # * A 6*
)( % 9 A! * * 5 QH
< 9 – H ' #– 90!9 ; 3 #
#–? UQ T !) ( 6 < 0# :9 3
: D ( #5 U <(63 I T h! – Z, #
= F 1G $* . 0 %D

,
7 =>" )? @ ". ' <&
* = 0E ( * 3 ) * *
( 2! 0 * I! *1 A 15 ) 1 0 *># <%
5 ) 0 # , * / 9 9 H 09o /
*1 Z ( 1 09 ' 0 <F! 0 ,
G% 0 3
[U ! T () A # % * %D *
$ U !6T # 4!6 < <) & G$ 0 2! *
2+ % % : B A M) ? 0
0 #* 0 : ( 3 ) 0 # ( I 0/
5F 0 ) 3 % # + E : FA 5 )
+ 3 Z # ( + !$ ( !0 * I! ! 0 Z
= 6 E . ) 3 09 # $ Z MH 4 : 4
( G %D + 5 ) *0 : #
( ) U 3 R Y T: #U T E
0 0 ) 6 #+ D U !6 T J 90!# ; 4 0
P #= J ! + 0E 6F 0 " $/
9 ( # 1 # 0 5D 6
% : 6F 0 QH 09 4!6 WL 6 <% 6 (/
% ( 1 *1 ? = 4 0D
; %D – ) 4 – 0E ) 0 #
7 1 6 ( 5 ) 8 4!6 )1 9' 90!9
4 $ ) 9 ( 0/ * G$, )1 *
* 0 W ) 0 0 QH *1 4
) 0 F ( 4 !6 1 0 0 3
0 0 ) 6 2! * I! <) D ) * 0
P F 6 ( 0 05 $4 !0 %D 0 #
G : !6 & ' (1 * * 0 h# + <! ,A 0/
< 4!6 $ = * $ # 0E < 6
6 2! < 0 9 # IL 6 +) $ * 0 0 *
* 6 p? F 6 % 6F < S 5 &F 0D
6F %1 ,
G 9A@ *' 1 # & / 4 r $q " (
9 0!9 %1 0 & !Z1 F 0E
<) < 5 ! < ; # U % ,#3 ,#/ T
( 9 51 ( 0
L( I! ( 5 9
G G6 F % + I! ( O ! ,#3 <!0 #4 3
*1 7 0 " * ! ,# ! < ; 1= 0E
=5 P * N ) ) % # % % j X

/ @ B: C"D E A)
* G A : ; M *0 : M $
% + E : 1 # FA 5 ) A 0
% 1 *# : ,6D + Q 3 1* 6 : ,61 F 1
& # h +* P $ 5F6 L %o * ( X ! * P$
# #* + 1 #* * ' * E
4 G 0 – *0 : 7 =h +* P ( F(
<,0E # < 6 *D P 61 H $ * < 1 – * + 1
* = % !) ( 6 G G 9 9
M 0 *1 " 0 + # 3 * ( & 1 * <) % 1 * E &
< *1 – , *1 M 0 : k *0 : &0 k :! +) *

1
# 9 1 0 0 * !0 9 / # ) ( *1 * !0 ! h 9
F < 4 < F G G$ 9 (
#2 / *6 ? 1 # I 4 '
PD * GH 0 1 09 4!6 s # 5 ! Z # 5
& 01 … & * s L(
@ 09 7 3 !$ Z *F
* D ) + 1 0$ 5 ! ) ! # , < < & 9!
. * < 0 0 5 * PD *1 Z= ? * ! /< *
* # & % 6: #' . ( / +) 5 ! # <0
H! < 1 * % # 3 * ( & 1
&
< *6 ,
G '# h 9 < 1 < H B 4!6 j & #1 + & 9 +) * %
=G G <) & 9!
5 % 4 ! 5 * PD " ( + : 1 4 * 0 : Q!
* &/;) !# … : !6 ? ? 0E ! *( ># 4A
.+ ) *6 F ! # # 01 * 0H & Z3 ? 3
#: %1 1* 6D )* 5 #< 1
,
= == #: %1 * Q 3 D
< h <!# & # < * 0H # F( )1 1
*B <,0E %D $ !) ( < * < $ !
P Q ' P 7 * & <0 9 #D #
*6 P &/;) ? ,0 $ : # ( +0 : # * Q
4 <,0E # ! 5 *6 # !) ( <) 01 <
)F A *F * ! / A ! 0 !6 # < 09 1
1* ) * ) & F :9$ , 4 *0 : = ?
1
= 1 < 1 # 0 0 5 %B * g %1 1* *)(/
P 2 + *3 3 ! 0 0 Y $ 0
: ( *1 : 5 E ( *1 0 .+) N ' $,6 :
! / # ' "H $ ( ) [ ) [ *0
3 : M 0 !# 0 J 3 $ 4
( 5& ' 0/ " 09 6 E Q 0 4 @ *1 A
4!6 "H $ 2! %1 P 6 h'
? 0 9 $ U? 0T –,
G% – !0 + 6 E
: ( 0( : / 09@ / N 1 6* 4 )+
F ( 0 3 0 # 09 –
4 6 +) 6 09 *1 /
G P !# 0 0 Z : 61 J $
*F < 0 09 5 *6 M : 1 4!6 E FA * 2+
h, 2! / : *3 U & % 4!6 . # <Z T PD
4 !6 6 X, ! ( 09 ? / 09
k % 0
* 0 : I! ( *1 , 2+ (4
5 + # 9 : ; <(0 MH O ! G$ 0 0 $
IH !$ $ ( *1 )1 5 6 6 ' A% !!
%1 9Z1 ? 0!# ' # / ! 6 '
< ) ' # 3 * ( & 1 # <,0E
<, 0E # < 6 *D < P <) * %D ? k: <,0E 5
!) ( 6 G G 9 9 ) H *
k ! : $ <,0E %
U *F PD T 6 4A 1 $ * 0 : *># % ( 5 A% 1
*1 2 + !$ $ 9!01 # . %1 *)(/ #
0 *1 : # *F PD ! %1 / Q 3 1* 6
2
5+! 6 * A ! ) . ( / 2 + 4!6
? ' = . ( / +) # %1 *F PD * *1 0 !(
, # Q 4!6 < !A 4 ( $ *0 : ( *1 2 + 4
" ! G6 # 0 0 * ; G * 1* 6 *1 )
2 ! 9 3 Y * k 0 0 !0 1 Ft & 4 0 0
$ # ( * – !) ( + –. 1* #
8 # 4 ,
G % 1 ! ( +) 5 n ? :6 6
<% * 0 0 * ; < )/ *6 * 1 1 * *1
$ E . ( / *1 09 0 "H $ ! I 0
= $, 3 NF ?' & % ) * 0 01 * 6 # ' G( *
# 4!63 % 4 :$ 1 # : 6F *># + .(/ 1
# 01 * Z ! 5
G $, <,0E %1 L + PD *F 6 *
< < 3 <,0E * < !) ( 4 $1 < 1 4 )+ *0 : *
– 65 – ;0 * <% * = <,0E # *D < *
k* ( E 4 '9 PD *F & % ? *1 )
k 4!61 $, 1 % 4 "! 1 # 4 PD * # )
. ) 3 : 0 # *0 : ( # *
+ ! 6 ' J ! : 6F #* 6 E
+* *0E# ) 0 6 )F 9 + Z
u H u 6< 7 3 H % P :!%
= !0 1 6 F v H 6 '
1 0 # ( E *6 ? ): ' 1 *
A 3 ( R &L ( 6 E . )
I # F9 4 "# + 2+ 9 : B
4
% ) 6 4!6 : ) L 6 E 5 ) ! 6
0E : H N E # 0 5 4 '9
= 5F ( 9 :

% " "@ F G HIJ B ',


" 4 6 % & * + # O 9 *
* A # % 5 H 4!6 ! 9 .&, ( $
! 6 + ( A % 0 G+ D * +
*1 * % L! 6 ' Z 6/ G 6 #
3 h# + 3 ! G0 01 *L
9 0!9 9 % 0/ 4!6
' 90!9 ( 6 $ 1 ( B
# 6 0 J ? )3 ( 1
A H 4!6 A W 1 : ?+ *D G 0 4 40
<) – % 1 *1 2 + < )/ G $ GH# * *1
" A 5 ' QH * !) ( – 6 – <) A
A " ( X( A I 9 < *D QH .+ < !6
2
= , " ( 4!6 !A 4!6 < * E w!
– Z ) , Z<0 < 1– * % * <
J ) < 9 ' 0 * F 4!6 * $
9 ) * * * 0 ) ! J # %
" ( 4 Z F( 5 0 1 * E #* +>#
Z* + 6 D0 .+) : Z : I# : 0
2 ! * " ( :( W ! 40 4 /
J # % * *># Y < W ?+ ! 0 * F *3
J $, 1 + # % 9 # ?, / < ?! 9
) 09 3 !
# )F N 6 <3 #= ! 0 0 < $ 4 "'
? 0 J 9 7; *># + 6 ' :
– = " ( # #3 ?! < 3 * ?!
J ! * G&F( / 0 – 3 ! ( 9
= 0E ) 3 QH *6 L *1 A 0E
/ < #3 * 9 # % / *
A % / 65 (G #1 G $ F 9
5 0 / W 1 #2 /
< 9 =: 0 * * ? + A (
2 #40 )* 6 (/ . 4 5 * / % 9
?' ! ( 0 ) A % +( X ' 4 * 0 (
5 ( ! QH * :9 F< 9 # G G !01
( $ < 6 (/ 5 * ( * # % #
H0 " ( 1 , 0/ 1 6 " ( 1 40 )
4
= 0( 5 01 1 <,63
$ * 0 (2 # 6 A " ( QH *
C 9 4!6 ( % # 4!6 '
! 1 ( 2! #P 4 <! I! * E# :9
&
L $ " ( !$ # j 5 # –* – <! 5 #
/
\ . ) * #7 / !6 * G&F( :() 3
( * T 90!9 ; 2! & ' # 9H $,6
< 9 P =U 4 ( * ( Q 6# 4 ( *
, * ( 2! # % * G&F( :9 3 4!6 U , 0/ T
* N 1 4!6 – ) % # # – :9
: 0 * N 4 L + A! ! 1
&
U ) , T 0 6 ?$ *1 : @/ + * E
* E 2+ G 0 /
\ 0 ! */ !(
? $ / / 4 3 Q X 9 ( 0 + 0, )/
" ! : $ ?; & $ / F &A ' l !
) , // ?, / GH h : ( * Q
+ 2! 4!6 H , ! G ' U ' #/ T
Q ( 4 G < + ! ) ( 9 h 1
J % Z *># + 09 0 #2 )
&
= A < # $

*+ "L K ? – B ',
2 ! * !! A % # * % ?! + )
5 !6 G # ) * 5 ) F(E
* 1 4 3 : # 9 6 (Q ' 6 ) l R
L A! L - # A % . !
) /
G 3 0E < ! 4 R 5 +
P0; ! 0 ! 5 6 ( ( I 4!6
3 &&
' 0E < ! * G !6 :9 3
$ : F( <! 0 0 ! 0/ ; *
* 3 4 0 * % 4 0 # 9 6 (Q #
A! 4!6 9'u1 E + * 0
@ $ E # 0
W 4 ) 1 !(E J ( 5 !
=U5 6 ( T4 '9 + I
"$ 1 $ & )( 5 6 *
5 L(* : <Z 4!6 A % 2 # BG 6G$
0 – :9 0 ( <!# & 0 ) ( I! 9
! 0 ! 0
@ $ ( I H # . I #–. 6
&,
8 I # ' < <) # ) 02 B
– + A j 6 – 6 ' < 1 09 < 1 o 2+
< ! M ) * + G :! 0 W+ *6 o 1o
=& () 4 !(1 P 3 61 L ( / P9 #N
5 (8
t 1 &x * 0 Z P3 61 ( * 93 *
$ 0 $ =* % !Z1 !% ) * R U # T )D <
(* ! ( +0 : # ! 0 *1 * 4 01 % *1
/
\ <L / .H * $/ R *' 1 # & / F
) UP3 61 T * 0 ,
G% 2! * 0 H + *6
– 2! *1 Z 6 H + " <&, 5 ( U 61TP Z 1
<)1 7 .+) P9 % H! G + 6G ) ! –
= ' ' 1
* 6 ' 61 * % 56 < # – *1 Z
' & 0 I! 5 < # * #
U 61 ( T %i# # : )< 4!6 * ( < +
* 9D < U % 61 T 1 UP 3 61 ( T 4!6 A
' + #=* 0 ( */ U # T 4!6 U <) # TN $
2 + # F - + A ( k ( : !$ +A 5 :6
( ( ( # : 0 j h # G+9 ( 4 N
&1
= G' G L 6 ' <!0 0 09

&
*/ M ) :09 : ( +A . ( + M *
) TQ I :09 A / :3 M 4 u 1
:' /Q h 4 :3 U 3 P /&
&
= :H
Q I 4 o/ ( * : +A : <9 0
% ( 0 0 % 3 P / :3
: ( * Q ( : U ?; T )
: ( : ' % # '$ +A *1 Z=
* 0 5 # : 5F 0 . 6 1 0 #
I # & 5 6 ) D :! 2 + - ( :
Q T *3 Q ) 09 09 )Q h +
U Q 4!6 G ! G 6 09 09 4!6 G ! G 6
&2
= 1 )
'/ * :! < : 0 : j h# +9 *1
( R I!$ # N $ * <!0 < ( : !$ F ( * # 5
, # 0 5 ) 6 0 F : $,6
$ ! 6 + D9 *6 0 J (
J +A 0 " # U H T* ! U 9 T
P ' 5 6 + 4!6 :@ b o< ( 2! *1 ,
*/ * 6G L : ( *6 L # Q
( * 0 0! *0 ( *
&4
61 ( T 0/ 4 ' !% Q! (
U5 5 T5 $ 4!6 + ( I : !6 + * UP3
1 U 9 H T 3 : UQ h T: # !
5 4 & 0D# Q / 09 % ( 46 0 #=: :1
,
Uh T 9 B // ' 0 * / 5
Q #UX T / H ' # 09 UX T
,
*1 7 * + $ # B $ 0 *6 ?! I 0 #
G /
G ( 1 F( * : L$ (1
,
= Q 4!6 F !
0 U 3 6 T < * % *
/T U A! ( /T U / O 9 T # !% * !A
: # . *1 1 : , D 3 *1 + U D H
1 6 1 +( 4 ! 6 ( 7
] $u A! # 4
* 9 H / EI % 3 7 *1
,
= +) A!
U 1 6 T 4!6 A % +
5 Z 1 3 Q! A! O 9 0 * !A
2+ :' ?
x < * * G' % *># /
: 3 6 E Q U<$T : > 6 + @ + M
JQ I,A M 2+ * *6 ,
G '# : *6 8A U ( T
: # P : 8 6 +) W *6 : , 0
* : U – A # 5 ) T
+ G # : + ( :09 4!6 I!A +< Q
,&
= // *6 ? 5 A #< 9
+ *6 + 40 + : (6 *1 / 2! / & *
$ +) ( " * A % X < 1F < 5 +( 6
# &' * (0 * :1 ( + : * 6 * &]
6 (/ ( 4 ! ' * @ @
! ) ( ( 1 0
! !( 0 * * Z * 0 :# ?B #
+ G !A G 6 3 Q 7 / M :6 M 9
+ 6 (/ ) : "0 1 < 6 4!6 h 9
*># A! h Q # : !6 # N 6
6 (/ h : !6 # N 6
5L 1 4 9 N 5L 1 4 * /Q # # 9
0 ; *6 L # 2+ :0L0; Q M + 6
,,
5 6 / 0 3 N E ! 6 *1 2 + 4!6 #
= 6 ( )+ :9 6

E "D /F F B ',
4 !6 * 0 G < @< *1 Z
A G A % # ) %v 9 # % E 6
8 1 # 6 2 + 4!( = ' (
< % $ 9 2 1 + F F6 %1
< #U T * -: * % 6
G G ,
G 0 ,
G 6# / ,
G 9 :! 2 + , * * 3
" < # W * &( % ( *3 ,
G% /
* &( 3 % :!% ' 6 ( I 0*
,
= L! L L L 1I 0* " < W
% E 6 6 ; ? <!# 4 1
'$ 8 ( 2! 4 0 '$ A
U ( 0 T * Q 0 (
9 *1 G P !# <% * :( # <) 0 : ( &A
6 ( +# h# A Q * 0

1
N ?$ *6 ? –: # – ?$ +) = :( 4 Q
A % *1 2 + = ( % #" #
/ 1 9 / T 2 + *># # GF !A $ +
$ 0 5 ! * M P : * 9
+ )4 4!6 $ 1 :( Q * $, $ 4!6
,1
= U: +Q +) 4 W
% ! *6 ,
G – 4 ; 2! *
: Z # "$ A 6 *6 ? – Z
+) % 4 ( * %1 ! #* + = '
N @…. 01 P , . Z? #… 1Q Q / +
,
= : Y 4 0 4 0 * F 4!6 +#
– ' !H01 * G&F( % + – ;0 *
: ( #/ I : ( ( * – % #<
, 6 ?$ I 0 # 0E J 9 : 0 03 *L J
9 : # !\% +# # % ?! " 69
5 0 # '/ (( ' G# / 03 P # 0E
4 :6 ' *1 / 4 6' R 6
=
M @ "
* " 0 ( y 3 y 6 ?0 I9 = U^T
= fac Q y ^ y [
= fae Q y :09 UfT
= `df Q y :09 U`T
= `df Q y :09 UzT
= `df Q y :09 U{T
= z^ Q y ^a_`[ y # 00; y A y H UcT
=^d{ Q y :09 UeT
= ^^a Q y :09 U_T
y5 ) [ ' y* y UaT
= ec Q y fddc
y5 ) y ' y ( *F #y U^dT
= c`Q y ^aee
= c` Q y :09 U^^T
y ^a_{ y 5 ( 3 y 9 H y +A j 6 U^fT
= ^c ^{ Q
= ^d Q y :09 U^`T
y y # < 6 !0!0 y 5 y5 FF 6 U^zT
= zz Q y fdd^ P 0Z1
!6 U 0 T P 6 *0 0 ( 2! !% 1 * U^{T
= Uk *1 4 T Z 0 U* $h T
( U *# T # 0 3U TQ ! y * U^cT
.+) = fd^ Q y ^ae` y y # % y * 6
* 9 H * A + 9
= 90,9 * . Z *
2
= z` Q yfddf y A y # % * ; yn ! ! y $ : U^eT
= z` Q y :09 U^_T
Free A h! ! # ) h! * U^aT
5 QH * 6 S / I$ Z h! ) Verse
T* : 0 # + %
= U I! T U 0 T U (
y ' h y Z, 01 y ( ( ) 6 UfdT
= ^^^ Q y ^ae_ y y #
y *0 : # # 5& $ y5 ( y 9 6 ( Uf^T
= fz{ Q y ^aad y A y # % * ;
y y5 y y ,) Z "( UffT
= ^az Q y ^ae`
^W y ^aa` [ 5 ) y? y& 3 y *0 : Uf`T
= ^_a ^__ Q y
= ^_a Q y :09 UfzT
=^_a Q y :09 Uf{T
=^ad Q y :09 y UfcT
U 6 ( T # ?$ +) 4!( UfeT
T F ( 49 U 3 T F
4!6 U 3 T ,) Z U 6
= % 0
= `^ Q y I 0 y5 y5 FF 6 Uf_T
= c^ Q y I 0 UfaT
= {c Q y I 0 U`dT
& E F y 6 = y y */ U`^T
= `z Q y ^aaz y 0y '
4
= ee Q y :09 U`fT
^aaz y 5 ) y 5 03 y5 y 9 6 ( U``T
=fde Q
=cQyI 0 y 9 H y +A j 6 U`zT
= c Q y :09 U`{T
= c Q y :09 U`cT
= _e Q y :09 U`eT
= _a Q y I 0 U`_T
= fd^ [^{f Q :09 "( U`aT
y # , / *F T* 0 ! UzdT
y B JF y A y 6 I #B !( y 5& Q
= `f Q y ^aac
= _{ Q y I 0 y 9 H Uz^T
yI y # % 5 F y H% y 3 y * !A UzfT
=^{` Q y ^aa{
y A # 5 ) yP Uz`T
= f^ Q [^aea y [5 y
y (= y y* Z * 0 y "( UzzT
= `_ Q y ^a_c [ *
00; y * y ' F F6 Uz{T
= {{ Q y ^aae y 0 !
=zdQ y^a_z y y 5 ( I #R yQ # #y 4 UzcT
= z^ Q y :09 UzeT

&

S-ar putea să vă placă și