Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
indications and social conventions, and finally the them had vocational training (Fig. 1); regarding
security of shopping and consumer services’ their sex structure, 52 per cent were females and 48
(Michalko, 2003, p. 162). per cent males.
1% 15%
DATA AND METHODS 20%
In order to have a comprehensive view of the
issue of tourism safety and security in Romania, the
analysis followed two main directions. First, we
analyse Romania’s travel and tourism
competitiveness index, with special focus on the
third pillar – Safety and Security; secondly, we
64%
discuss the results of a Leonardo daVinci transfer of
innovation project carried out in four European secondary vocational
countries, entitled Training Safety and Security in BA master, Ph.d.
Tourism, where the questionnaire method was used.
The method of controlled interview was chosen in Fig. 1 Education level of the respondents
order to analyse, map and draw some conclusions Most of them (41%) were working in the current
about the aspects of safety and security in tourism tourism company for less than 3 years (this fact is in
programs and products offered by tourism operators close connection to the age of the respondents,
and agencies. The experts’ answers to open almost 40 per cent of them declaring to be 21 to 30
questions were compiled and summarised. There years of age), almost a third for 4 to 7 years, and
were two questionnaires, one filled in by 200 people just 10 per cent of the respondents for more than 10
working in the Romanian hospitality sector, made years (Fig. 2).
up of 23 questions; the other one was addressed to
specialists in the tourism domain, including 10%
managers of SMEs, representatives of regional 14%
tourism organizations as well as academic 41%
personnel. The two questionnaires were very
important for gathering relevant information on the
theoretical and practical background in the domain.
One of the major objectives of the research was
to have a clear situation regarding the perception 35%
and attitudes of the managers and employees in the 1-3 years
hospitality sector concerning the influence of safety 4-7 years
8-10 years
and security aspects upon their activities. The more than 10 years
survey within the project was targeted towards the Fig. 2 Respondents’ work experience in the field
managers and employees of hotels and other
accommodation facilities, tour operators, tourism RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
agencies, charter companies and tourist information
In 2009, World Economic Forum published the
centres. The online questionnaire was published on
third edition of the Travel & Tourism
the TSST project web-site. It was short, with clear
Competitiveness Report which aimed at providing an
and simple language, with friendly interface. The
analysis of the travel and tourism competitiveness of
questions aimed at highlighting the following
133 countries worldwide. The rankings are based on
aspects: the importance of the safety and security
the Travel & Tourism Competitiveness Index
issues in tourism activities as perceived and met by
(TTCI), which measures the different regulatory and
tourism SMEs, the need for improving training
business-related issues that have been identified as
programmes and new methods in tourism services,
levers for improving travel and tourism
as well as the necessity to offer a more unified
competitiveness in countries around the world.
European quality tourism product that meets the
safety standards. The travel and tourism competitiveness index
mainly mirrors the economy’s performance, hinting
Sample characteristics at T&T regulatory framework (the third pillar of
which is Safety and Security), T&T business
More than half of the respondents to the first environment infrastructure, as well as T&T human,
questionnaire had a BA diploma and 15 per cent of cultural and natural resources.
As stated in the report, Safety and Security is a Serbia, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Morocco, being
critical factor determining the competitiveness of a ranked 69th, better than Bulgaria (Table 1).
country’s T&T industry, because "tourists are likely Table 1 Travel and tourism competitivess index
to be deterred from travelling to dangerous countries Rank
or regions, making it less attractive to develop the Indicator
RO BG HU SE UKR MO
T&T sector in those places". There were analysed the Travel and tourism
66 50 38 88 77 93
costs of terrorism (threat of terrorism in the country) competitiveness index
as well as of common crime and violence (the Safety and security 62 87 41 85 86 52
Business cost of
incidence of common crime and violence in the terrorism
57 104 21 90 67 31
country, varying from 1 = imposes significant costs Reliability of police
74 111 46 67 105 112
on business to 7 = does not impose significant costs services
on businesses), and the reliability of police services Business costs of crime
69 99 45 64 61 46
(1 = cannot be relied upon to enforce law and order; and violence
Road traffic accidents 80 52 n/a 101 45
7 = can be relied upon to enforce law and order).
(Data source: Travel&Tourism Competitiveness Report,
Switzerland, Austria and Germany are the top 2009)
three countries in the world with the highest index
of T&T competitiveness. Compared to them, Compared to the neighbouring countries,
Romania has scored only 4.0, lying at the middle of Romania may held a good position, with better
the ranking (the 66th position), behind the score and rankings than all the five countries, but
neighbouring EU countries. Hungary, in terms of safety and security. However,
The first indicator for the matter of safety and for the overall travel and tourism competitiveness
security was the threat of terrorism in the country; index, Romania lags behind the European Union
this indicator is very important, since terrorism countries, far away from Hungary and Bulgaria.
against the tourism industry is not a recent The results to the online questionnaires, filled
phenomenon, but during the last decades, the in by tourism actors, including the representatives
linkage between tourism and terrorism became clear of accommodation facilities, restaurants, travel
(Laws and Prideaux, 2005; Tarlow, 2002; Mansfeld agencies, tourism organisations etc., reveal valuable
and Pizam, 2006; Tarlow, 2006; Henderson, 2007; information in support of the need for training
Edgell et. al., 2008), with attacks against all aspects safety and security in tourism.
of tourism industry, including accommodation According to WTO, safety and security are vital
facilities, transport means etc. (Tarlow, 2006). to ensure quality in tourism and should be one of
Moreover, once an atmosphere of fear was created the utmost importance objectives of tourism
and a destination is perceived as insecure, the destinations (UNWTO, 1997). However, only a
tourism industry is ruined. quarter of the Romanian respondents to the
Although no terrorist attacks were ever questionnaire consider that the syntagm ‘tourism
registered in Romania, the country has scored only safety’ is comparable to ‘the quality of a service or
5.9 for this indicator, coming on the 57th place in the product’, and 39% answering rather yes than no to
international hierarchy, well behind Hungary, but this question. This means that there is an urgent
much better placed than Bulgaria, the two EU need for changing mentalities, because only by
neighbouring countries. Despite the relatively high acknowledging the importance of tourism safety by
score (7 means that it does not impose significant the local actors, i.e. personnel working in tourism
costs), this indicator is seen as a competitive companies, Romania can begin to be perceived as a
disadvantage for Romania. safe destination.
The police services in the country are very The questionnaires’ results. Two thirds of the
important, because they must be relied upon to questioned persons agreed that there are different
enforce law and order. However, Romania has a ideas regarding the general safety and protection of
rather low score, being ranked the 74th, just like tourists put into practice in the company (35%
Thailand, Algeria, Madagascar, Tajikistan or Israel. answered yes and 32% rather yes than no), among
The incidence of common crime and violence the factors that would motivate companies to
must not be neglected, since visitors are vulnerable develop guidelines for the general safety and
both to be victims of crime (travellers are quite protection of the tourists during the trip, the most
often very easy to identify) and to become crime important being the increasing interest of the
perpetrators (Tarlow, P.E., 2006b, p. 97). Romania tourists in their personal safety during the trip
has a score very close to the average, just like (almost a third of the respondents), the importance
of safety as part of the trip destination marketing
(32%) and competitive conditions of tourism trip (49.5% answered rather yes than no and 26.7%
companies (Fig. 3). answered yes). This situation is a bit curios, since
only a third of the respondents say that education
13% 33% seminars regarding tourism safety are organized for
the company personnel once a year or more than
once a year, 37% admitting that this type of
32% seminars are being held less than once a year and
12% 10% 28% that no such seminars are being organized (Fig.
increasing interest of tourists in their personal safety during 5). This may indicate the fact that both managers
the trip
competitive conditions of tourism companies and personnel may overestimate their capacity to
react in a crisis situation.
experience of the travel agents in providing information
about travelling to dangerous destinations 28% 15%
safety as part of the destination marketing
should arrive safe and sound to the trip destination Possibilities for training specialists in the
and then take advantage of the services offered in tourism sector and for the development of a
that particular destination, in the same climate of skilled workforce
comfort and safety. Any inconvenience or In Romania, Tourism as main specialization is
discomfort as a result of the trip to the chosen taught in 30 universities (19 of them state-owned
destination will certainly influence, in a negative universities and 11 as private universities), spread
way, the way tourists perceive the next products throughout the country. Most often, the Faculties of
and services. Economics have a specialization named The
Defining new priorities of tourism safety is an economy of commerce, tourism and services or
important criterion for tourist destination Management of commercial companies and
marketing, which is not yet emphasized in tourism. It is also worth mentioning Business
Romania. The size of tourist flows and income management in the hotel industry (Cluj-Napoca
from touristic activities require a constant Business School), The University College for
reevaluation of the standards for the products the marketing in tourism and hotel activities (Arad), as
companies are offering and the quality of services, well as The Training Center for Tourism held by
since the final beneficiary – the tourist, is always Babeş-Bolyai University in Cluj-Napoca.
judging and classifying things. Apart from the Universities, there are 14
Worldwide, the threats and dangers are more vocational and high schools which offer study
frequent and consequently, tourists are becoming programmes for tourism, the most frequent
more aware of the necessity of a safety destination. qualifications being tourism agent or technician in
The standards of the EU imply some demands that tourism.
should be met by any touristic activity. In order to There is also an institutionalized system for the
meet these demands, at least at a reasonable level, programmes of ‘adults’ continuous professional
there must be drawn an action plan that should training’, held by the National Center for Touristic
take into consideration the Romanian realities, Teaching, under the responsibility of the National
which are clearly influenced by the existing Authority for Tourism. One of the leading
economic conditions. Foreign tourists are educated institutions contracted by the Center for training
in the spirit of touristic safety, and when choosing courses is Tourism, Hotel & Restaurant Consulting
a particular destination, this aspect is of utmost Group (according to their presentation, there were
importance. The image of the country or any approximately 20,000 trained people in 10 years). It
touristic destination depends on the quality of the is worth mentioning the private initiative of the
touristic products, which include not only the Royal Institute of Hotel Management that created a
natural patrimony or the economic environment, post graduate diploma program in collaboration
but also the social and political climate, state order with École Hôtelière de Lausanne in Switzerland.
and citizens’ safety. With respect to the average number of graduates
According to the Romanian government and of colleges and universities in tourism area per year,
national agencies, tourism is a priority domain of there are no correct data at national level. Some
Romania’s economy. The quality of the touristic rough estimates indicate approximately 1600
products must be a strategic component and a key graduates on Bachelor Level, 200 on Master and
factor for the promotion of the country on the around 700 in high schools and vocational centers.
international market, in the present economic Although the number of graduates may seem
context, when there is a rapid and continuous high, it is estimated that less than 20 per cent of the
diversification of touristic destinations and graduates from universities or vocational schools
products. Most important, the tourists’ demands with touristic programmes end up working in the
for safety and security are ever higher. These sector of hospitality and tourism in Romania.
realities require more efforts for the tourist’s Recently, the need for qualified personnel has
protection, by guarantying both the quality and the increased on the one hand due to the high number of
security of the touristic destinations and packages. hotels and other accommodation establishments
The government has acknowledged this matter recently built, all of them requiring trained staff and
and there are various laws for the protection of to migration, on the other hand (more and more
tourists. Within the Ministry of Tourism, there is the persons with some experience in this sector choose
General Direction for Control and Tourists’ Safety. to work abroad, because they can earn more).
One of the objectives of the National Center for However, the formal education for hospitality
Touristic Teaching is also to ensure the safety of the services is not well developed, because the training
tourists as consumers of services and goods. courses are only partially included in the curricula
for vocational schools and universities. What is the one hand, at national level, by the police which
more, the training curricula for the hospitality sector must enforce the law and by other public bodies
do not include the practical knowledge and skills ensuring public safety, and on the other hand, at the
needed for this kind of activities. As shown in the local level: the managers of hotels and other
Master Plan for Tourism, ‘there is no premises must be well aware of the importance of
acknowledgment for the need of training and there having the proper equipment for guaranteeing their
is no educational culture’. guests the security, the proper procedures to react or
What is more, the issue of safety and security in prevent some accidents or crises, and not least, a
tourism is quite vaguely dealt with in the curricula well trained personnel, having the skills and
of the universities and vocational schools. Most knowledge to react in a crisis situation.
often, there is no subject directly addressing this In order to have personnel that is trained well
matter, but rather some optional courses regarding enough and motivated, there is an urgent need for
the quality of products and the protection of updated curricula and courses, as well as better
consumers, having as a special topic the protection informed and experienced training staff. The
of service consumers – the protection of tourists. results and experiences of other countries in this
Most important, the existing training curricula for domain may well be used, taking into
the hospitality sector are improper most of the time consideration some specific aspects of the country.
and the teaching staff lacks the qualifications and Romania is an emerging country from the
practical experience. Most of the training courses international tourist destinations point of view and
for tourism do not aim for practical skills. ‘Getting it can only assert its place among the main
the diploma is more important than the skills destinations in the continent if it is perceived as a
acquired’, due to the work legislation approved in safe destination, among other things.
2006, stipulating that whoever intends to apply for a
function in the sector of hospitality and tourism ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
must hold a proper diploma or certificate. The present study was carried out within a
There is almost no separate and specialized Transfer of Innovation project entitled Training
formal training and education in the hospitality Safety and Security in Tourism, financed by the
sector. The training institutions are not accustomed European Union – Lifelong Learning Programme,
to the training depending on the demands, taking including research teams from Latvia, Bulgaria,
into consideration the needs of the market. Czech Republic and Romania.
Generally, the hired staff in travel and tourism
activities does not have the practical skills and REFERENCES
knowledge for carrying out activities at
international standards. The issue of safety and Breda, Zelia and Costa, C., (2006). Safety and
security in tourism in Romania is generally security issues affecting inbound tourism in
disregarded. Consequently, it is very important to PRC, in Y. Mansfeld, A. Pizam (eds),
have a good training for the safety and security in Tourism, Security and Safety: from Theory to
tourism. Practice, Elsevier Butterworht-Heinemann,
MA, pp. 187-208.
CONCLUSIONS Chiang, L.C., (2000). Strategies for Safety and
Crises can have a significant impact on tourist Security in Tourism: A conceptual framework for
inbound and outbound flows. Although Romania the Singapore Hotel Industry, in the Journal of
does not receive a high number of international Tourism Studies, vol. 11, no. 2.
tourists (around 1.5 million, which accounts for less
Edgell, D.L., DelMastro A., M., Smith, G.,
than 0.5% of the total number of international
Swanson, J.R., (2008). Tourism Policy and
tourists in Europe, while the proportion of nights
Planning: Yesterday, Today & Tomorrow,
spent in Romania by non-residents in the European
Elsevier, Oxford.
Union is only 1.4%), the lack of a proper safety
system may impinge on the future development of Freyer, W. and Schroder, A., (2007). Tourism and
the country as a main tourist destination. We must Terrorism: an Analytical Framework with
take into consideration that tourist destinations are Special Focus on the Media, in E. Laws, B.
now viewed as systems, made up of Prideaux, K.S. Chon, Crisis Management in
accommodation, attractions and transport (Chiang Tourism, CAB International, Oxon, pp. 129-141.
L.C., 2000). This means that safety in tourism must
be ensured at multiple levels at the same time: on
Henderson, J.C., (2007). Tourism Crisis: causes, turbulent times: towards safe experiences for
consequences and management, Butterworth- visitors, Elsevier Ltd, Oxford, pp. 79-92.
Heinemann, Oxford.
Tarlow, P.E., (2006b). Crime and Tourism, in J.
Mansfeld, Y., (2003). The role of security Wilks, D. Pendergast, P. Leggat, Tourism in
information in tourism crisis management: the turbulent times: towards safe experiences for
missing link, in Y. Mansfeld, A. Pizam (eds) visitors, Elsevier Ltd, Oxford, pp. 92-101.
Tourism, Security and Safety: from Theory to
Tarlow, P.E., (2009). Tourism Safety and Security,
Practice, Elsevier Butterworht-Heinemann, MA,
in T. Jamal, M. Robinson (eds), The SAGE
pp. 271-290.
Handbook of Tourism Studies, SAGE
Michalko, G., (2003). Tourism Eclipsed by Publications Ltd, London, pp. 464-480.
Crime: the Vulnerability of Foreign Tourists in
Wilks, J. and Page, S., (2003). Managing tourist
Hungary, in C.M. Hall, D.J. Timothy, D.T.
health and safety in the new millennium, Elsevier
Duvall (eds), Safety and security in tourism:
Science Ltd, Oxford.
relationships, management and marketing,
Haworth Hospitality Press, New York, pp. UNWTO, (1996). Tourist Safety and Security.
159-172. Practical Measures for Destinations, 179 p.
Laws, E. and Prideaux, B. (eds), (2005). Tourism World Economic Forum, (2009), The Travel and
Crisis. Management Responses and Theoretical Tourism Competitiveness Report 2009, Geneva.
Insight, Haworth Hospitality Press, New York. ***, (2010). Training safety and security in tourism
Tarlow, P.E., (2002). Event risk management and aspects. Comparative analysis for Bulgaria,
safety, John Wiley & Sons Inc, New York. Czech Republic, Latvia, Romania, Informa Print,
Burgas.
Tarlow, P.E., (2006a). Terrorism and Tourism, in J.
Wilks, D. Pendergast, P. Leggat Tourism in