Sunteți pe pagina 1din 8

by Adam Neville

Creep of Concrete
and Behavior of
Structures—
Part I: Problems
concrete and thus apply the and Structural Concrete,3 which was
knowledge of concrete to construc- published in 1983.
tion. To give more credence to my I am mentioning all of the previ-
view, I would like to cite some ous not to boast (especially as, in
examples of design in which specific recent years, I have not studied the
values of some properties of topic of creep) but to justify my
concrete—in particular, creep and choice of the topic of the present
shrinkage—are essential. I will do so article. I should explain that this is
in two parts. This part deals with not a scientific paper explaining and
problems caused by creep; in the discussing creep, but only an
second part, to be published in CI in attempt to persuade the readers of
June 2002, I will consider how to deal CI of the importance of concrete
with creep in design and construction. technology in design and possibly to
encourage designers to improve
Why discuss creep? their knowledge of the properties of
My choice is the creep of concrete. concrete. My contention is that a

I n a previous article titled,


“Concrete Technology and
Design—The Twin Supports of
The reason for this choice is that,
some time ago, I undertook consider-
number of designers rely on standard-
ized values of creep; they assume
able research on creep and pub- those values in their analysis and
Structures,” published in the April lished numerous papers. Some of often cannot verify them in terms of
2002 issue of Concrete International, them dealt with laboratory tests and the actual properties of concrete in
I expressed the view that “a good measurements of creep of concrete the structure. If the discrepancy is
knowledge of concrete technology as a material, both under uniaxial large, the structure may behave in a
is just as important as a good and triaxial compressive stress and way different from that assumed in
knowledge of structural analysis under tensile stress. Other papers the design.
and design.”1 My intention and dealt with the effects of creep in
hope was to encourage more civil reinforced and prestressed concrete. What is creep?
engineers to concentrate on I also wrote, in 1970, what was Creep is a nonelastic deforma-
probably the first major book on all tion of concrete under sustained
This point of view article is pre-
aspects of creep titled, Creep of stress. It occurs in addition to
sented for reader interest by the
Concrete: Plain, Reinforced, and stress-induced elastic deformation
editors. However, the opinions
Prestressed, to which Walter Dilger and also stress-independent strains
expressed are not necessarily those of made a contribution.2 He and J. J. known as shrinkage and thermal
the American Concrete Institute. Brooks were my coauthors of the movement. Creep occurs under
Reader comment is invited. second book titled, Creep of Plain both a compressive stress and a

Concrete international / MAY 2002 59


“It is not good enough for the designer to look up the value of the
creep coefficient in a design code or in a handbook...”
tensile stress. Upon removal of a place concurrently with sustained Supports of a turbo-alternator
sustained stress, there occurs a loading, there occurs in addition The first structure I came across
reverse strain known as creep the so-called drying creep, and of was a very wide beam supporting a
recovery; the two strains are not course shrinkage. The larger the very large turbo-alternator. The
equal and opposite, so that creep surface-volume ratio of a concrete beam rested on several supports,
is not a reversible phenomenon. member, the greater the proportion unevenly spaced and of varying
A further complication arises of concrete that undergoes drying; height depending on the equip-
from the fact that the magnitude and therefore, the larger the drying ment and arrangements under-
of creep is a function of the age creep and the shrinkage. It follows neath. The supports were made of
when the stress begins to act and that, other things being equal, a concrete, but they were not all of
also of the age when it ceases to smaller member with all its sur- the same size because of their
do so. Although creep is propor- faces drying exhibits a larger creep unequal spacing. They were also of
tional to the applied stress, it is a and a larger shrinkage. unequal height. Under the sus-
function of numerous variables, Creep is a dimensionless quantity, tained load of the turbo-alternator,
which can be expressed in a usually expressed in microstrain;
the supports underwent creep and,
that is, 10–6. Some people write “inch
variety of ways. Different researchers consequently, they became shorter.
per inch” or “mm per mm,” but this is
choose different groups of param- The amount of shortening was
superfluous and even unhelpful.
eters, and different codes give variable depending on the charac-
The magnitude of creep is small,
standard values of creep character- teristics of the supports. The main
but certainly not negligible. Creep
istics in terms of different factors. characteristics are height and
is usually at least as large as the
To give an example, creep may be volume-to-surface ratio, which
elastic strain, and can be two or
considered as a function of the controls the drying of the concrete
three times larger. I should add that
water-cement ratio or of the reinforcing steel modifies the strain that influences its drying creep and
strength of concrete at the time of actually developed. its shrinkage as well.
application of the sustained I do not propose to discuss Now, the operation of the turbo-
stress. Other features of the further the phenomenon of creep, alternator requires that the rotating
concrete mixture that influence but I shall give examples of several shaft remains perfectly straight and
creep relate to the aggregate: its types of structures and load situa- level at all times, so that unequal
type and density, its volume per tions in which the effects of creep shortening of the supports cannot
cubic meter of concrete, and its are significant. In addition to creep, be tolerated. When unequal shorten-
modulus of elasticity. I shall refer also, in some cases, to ing occurs, it is, of course, possible
The age of the concrete when the the effects of shrinkage. My treat- periodically to stop the turbo-
sustained load is applied is also a ment will be descriptive and alternator and to insert shims on
factor. It is worth remembering that qualitative. In the sequel to this top of the supports in order to
only sustained loads induce creep, article, I shall comment on the restore it to a level position. But
and such loads may begin and cease current development of creep such outage for a few hours inter-
to act at various ages. So overall, expressions and their relevance to rupts the electricity supply and
the situation is complicated. the needs of designers. represents a loss of revenue.
In addition to intrinsic factors in The question to consider is: how
the concrete itself, creep is affected Creep in supports to equalize the creep deformation
by extrinsic factors such as the of beams and also the shrinkage of the
relative humidity of the ambient Broadly speaking, we can various supports? I shall come to
medium and the temperature of the distinguish between supports of the answer after the next two
concrete. Specifically, concrete beams and columns, although examples, which show that the
under steady hygrometric condi- there is no fundamental difference problems arising from creep are not
tions only undergoes what is known between the behavior of the two very rare and are not limited to
as basic creep. When drying takes and between their consequences. horizontal beams. The point that I

60 MAY 2002 / Concrete international


“...the resulting expansion and contraction of the panels could not be
accommodated because each panel was connected to the building
frame at four corners.”
want to make at this stage is that, the supports undergo differential Creep in buildings
unless the designer is sufficiently settlement, and the continuous Like bridge piers, columns in
familiar with creep, he or she may beams resting over these supports buildings are subject to shortening
not even be aware of the seriousness will suffer parasitic bending by creep. In buildings of no more
of the potential problem. moments and associated shearing than several stories, problems arise
It is not good enough for the forces. The structural design must rarely, except when there is an
designer to look up the value of the provide for these induced stresses incompatibility between the
creep coefficient in a design code in the beams. To do so requires a deformation of load-bearing
or in a handbook: it is necessary calculation at the design stage of concrete members and of cladding.
also to have detailed information the differential shortening of the Problems with cladding
about the concrete mixture and piers exposed to different condi- Strictly speaking, cladding
the exposure conditions. tions. To estimate the magnitude of problems may occur even in low-
A bridge continuous over that shortening, it is necessary to rise buildings, but they are more
several supports be knowledgeable about creep. common in higher buildings and
This brings me to my second A suspension bridge where the appearance of the
example: a long bridge consisting of A long-span suspension bridge façade is of greater importance.
continuous beams over a number of has high towers supporting the From what I have already said, it
supports. In some cases, the bridge cables from which the bridge deck is obvious that columns carrying
runs not only over a river but also is suspended. There are various the dead load of the building will
over low ground, which may be ways of arranging the cables at the shorten due to creep and possibly
permanently dry or may be subject top of the towers. What matters is also shrinkage. This in itself need
to periodic flooding. The aspect of that if a tower shortens after the not create any problems. What
this situation that is of interest is initial installation of the cables, happens, however, when cladding is
that some bridge piers were perma- attached to the columns or to load-
this geometric change affects the
nently in water or in humid air; bearing walls? Cladding does not
force in the cables. How significant
other piers were in fairly dry air. carry a sustained load so that, even
this change is depends on the
Now, as I already mentioned, creep if it consists of concrete panels,
height of the towers and on the
of concrete that is undergoing creep does not enter the picture.
length of the bridge span.
drying is much larger than creep of Moreover, cladding is often made of
I was involved in a case concern-
concrete at a steady humidity. In a material that does not undergo
ing a very large bridge with towers creep: tiles, stone, or bricks. If the
addition to creep under a sustained
206 m (676 ft) high and a suspended cladding is applied in such a way
load, shrinkage takes place also
span of 1377 m (4197 ft). Four years that there are gaps provided to
when the concrete is drying; there is
no shrinkage under wet conditions. after the installation of the cables, accommodate the shortening of the
A further complication arose from the towers had shortened an load-bearing vertical concrete to
the fact that the piers were of additional 150 mm (6 in.). As this which the cladding is attached, no
unequal height; and therefore, at a was an important structure, the problems arise.
given magnitude of creep and designer was fully cognizant of the A competent contractor knows
shrinkage, the shortening over the phenomena involved. I am mention- that decorative precast concrete
whole height was variable. ing the relevant facts to illustrate panels should be suspended, and
Now, if the creep of the different the importance of creep; shrinkage not fixed rigidly at both the top
piers varies in magnitude, the piers of the massive concrete towers and the bottom. Moreover, the
will undergo different amounts of (with only a very small proportion contractor provides horizontal
shortening, even when all the piers of the cross section exposed to gaps in the cladding that can
are of equal height. If that happens, drying) was negligible. accommodate the shortening of

Concrete international / MAY 2002 61


and could have been readily avoided serious problems in the case in
by a provision for the differential which I was involved so that new
movement between the cladding cladding had to be provided, and
and the load-bearing members. this caused a disruption to the
A few years ago, I was involved operation of what was a prestigious
in a related problem with cladding building commanding a high rent.
panels made of glass-reinforced
Problems with vertical
cement. The panels were very thin
service attachments
and were of a fancy and complex
The shortening of reinforced
shape. They were exposed to large
concrete columns in a low-rise
temperature variations, but the
building, provided it is the same in
resulting expansion and
all the columns, does not lead to
contraction of the panels could
problems caused by creep. How-
not be accommodated because ever, in a tall, or high-rise, building,
each panel was connected to the problems may arise both when
building frame at four corners. In there is a uniform shortening of all
consequence, the highly the columns and when there is
restrained thermal expansion and differential shortening.
contraction resulted in the tearing Dealing first with the overall
of some of the panels. shortening, the columns will
The situation was particularly contract due to creep and shrink-
Fig. 1: Effects of creep in concrete columns
acute because glass-reinforced age. In a tall building, this shorten-
cement (which is an erroneous ing can be about 100 or 150 mm
the columns. It is up for discussion British name) has a higher content of (4 or 6 in.). Fintel, Ghosh, and Iyengar
whether the responsibility is solely hydrated cement paste than ordinary
quote figures of 180 to 230 mm (5 to
the contractor’s or whether the concrete. Because the coefficient of
7 in.) in an 80-story building.4 The
designer should establish the thermal expansion of hydrated
actual figure that matters is the
magnitude of the movement to be cement paste is about twice that of
shortening after the installation of
accommodated and specify the typical concrete, the coefficient of
the vertical attachments. Those of
necessary provisions. To do so, the thermal expansion of the glass-
interest are water and gas pipes, and
designer must be well versed in reinforced cement was higher, maybe
guide rails for elevators.
the relevant properties of the twice as high as in concrete. Thus, the
One example that I heard about
materials used. restrained thermal movement was
was a hotel in which the elevators
The fact is that I have seen on particularly high.
ran along rails that were fixed to the
numerous occasions ornamental Should this have been foreseen
lift shaft at quite a large spacing.
stone cladding or brickwork by the designer? In other words, was
When the building was more than a
applied without any provision for the designer sufficiently knowledge-
year old, some of the rails buckled.
accommodating the shortening of able about the influence of the
The explanation was that the creep
the columns or the walls behind. cement content in the mixture upon
of the concrete in the shaft walls
When this is done, something must thermal movement? Also, should
put the slender rails into compres-
“give.” First, the cladding cracks, someone—the designer or the
sion and induced buckling. That
and the tiles, stone slabs, or bricks, contractor—have paid attention to
mishap occurred a number of years
or their parts, may drop onto the the temperature, that is, the time of
ago, and I expect that designers are
ground below; this is clearly a the day when the panels were being
now aware of the situation; perhaps
hazard for pedestrians. fixed? And, of course, should the
it is more important that those
Secondly, depending on the fixing have allowed for thermal
installing the vertical attachments
details of fixing, the cladding may movement? I expect that some
are also aware.
bulge as shown in Fig. 1. This is a readers of CI will immediately point
potential hazard and is, of course, out that they are fully aware of the Problems with vertical
unsightly. The remedy is expensive. factors involved and would have architectural attachments
The situation should not have been avoided the problem. I am sure this I observed an unusual problem
allowed to develop in the first place, is so, but the fact is that there were when I stayed in a hotel in Rio de

62 MAY 2002 / Concrete international


Janeiro. Figure 2 shows external
vertical slats running on the
outside of hotel balconies.5 To the
uninitiated, they look like columns,
but they are not load-bearing and
therefore not subject to creep.
They are merely decorative slender
elements connected horizontally
at intervals. The inset in Fig. 2
illustrates my point; the slats do
not transfer any load downwards.
Now, the columns behind the
balconies, which are cantilevers,
are clearly load-bearing, and as
such they undergo creep, which
causes their shortening. This
shortening is also induced in the
slats, so that they are put into
compression. This compression
can be so large that the slender
slats buckle and spall. Fig. 2: General view of façade. Insert: detail seen from the balcony5
A purely architectural feature,
the slats must have become popular Strictly speaking, the shortening relative humidity of the different
with architects because, in my later of the columns is caused by elastic columns and use appropriate
travels, I saw very similar damage in deformation, as well as by shrinkage values of creep.
Turkey, Colombia, and Australia. and creep but, for simplicity, I will The second cause of differential
The failures were not dramatic, but limit myself to creep. Also, each creep arises from the fact that, as
were aesthetically unacceptable. floor, when placed, is in a horizontal discussed earlier, drying creep is
My point is that they indicate the position so that it is only affected affected by the ratio of the volume
designer’s lack of appreciation of by the strains induced subsequent to of concrete to the drying surface;
the effects of creep. the time of placing. This is not as the larger this ratio, the less drying
complicated as it may seem but, for that takes place because water
Differential creep in the purpose of the present article, a from the interior of the column
tall buildings qualitative description suffices. cannot readily reach the surface
Let me now consider the differen- Causes of differential creep and evaporate. Consequently, the
tial effects of creep; that is, a situa- There are five possible causes of concrete in the interior of a large
tion where supports of beams or differential creep in columns in tall column undergoes very little
slabs that were originally level are buildings. First, as I have already drying creep. Establishing the
no longer at the same level. Figure 3 mentioned, the relative humidity volume-to-surface ratio, which is
shows a schematic arrangement of a of the ambient medium affects the same as the ratio of the cross-
tall building with columns spaced at creep. Thus, if a building has sectional area to the perimeter of
6 m on center, but with some columns exposed external columns, they the columns, requires some care
omitted where a large uninterrupted may be at a high relative humidity, because the surfaces that are
area is required, as, for example, in a while the adjacent columns in the relevant are those that are allowed
hotel ballroom or in a major audito- air-conditioned interior may be to dry. Column surfaces that are
rium. If the different columns exposed to quite dry air. In the covered by an impermeable mate-
undergo unequal shortening, any simplest terms, we can say that the rial are not considered in the
horizontal members spanning external columns undergo only volume-to-surface ratio. In practice,
continuously over the columns will basic creep, while the interior there may be differences between
be subject to parasitic stresses of the columns undergo both basic and columns of the same size depend-
type I mentioned previously in drying creep. More accurately, we ing on where they are located: for
connection with bridges. could establish the average example, whether they are exterior

Concrete international / MAY 2002 63


Ghali, Dilger, and Neville have
shown that a given load applied
gradually over one year would
result, in the long run, in one-half of
the creep that would be caused by
the same load applied all at once at
the age of 14 days.6
This begs the question of what
the designer should know about the
likely speed of construction.
Usually, the designer knows noth-
ing. It is arguable that, when the
system of design and construction
makes it possible for the designer to
be well informed, the process of
design may benefit from it. Specifi-
cally, I would suggest that, in the
case of important tall buildings, the
designer might—or even should—
lay down limits on construction
Fig. 3: Schematic plan of a tall building speed differentials.
or interior. The largest difference is significant wind and earthquake In particular, the designer
likely to be between the columns loads, which are not sustained loads. should recognize that, whereas
and the shear walls (Fig. 3), which The fourth factor influencing the columns are constructed floor-by-
have a much greater volume- shortening of a column is the floor, shearwalls are often con-
surface ratio. percentage of longitudinal reinforce- structed very rapidly using
The drying factors mentioned so ment in the column. This reinforce- slipforming. Consequently, when a
far apply as much to shrinkage as ment restrains the potential creep sustained load begins to act, the
to creep. of plain concrete. The percentage concrete in the shear wall may be
Now, the third cause of differ- of reinforcement may vary between much older than that in an adjacent
ential shortening of columns is columns because it is governed by column. On the other hand, the
limited to creep. This cause is the the total design load and not only column may be more heavily
elastic strain due to the sustained by the sustained load, which reinforced and, very likely, it will have
load on the concrete, excluding induces creep; this is similar to the a much lower volume-surface ratio.
other loads. Creep is proportional situation discussed in the Structural consequences of
to the applied stress, so that preceding paragraph. differential creep
columns carrying unequal The fifth and last important First of all, I should give an
sustained loads will undergo factor is the age at which the indication of the order of magnitude
differential shortening. However, sustained load begins to act. Creep of the differential shortening of
from the design standpoint, the is significantly larger in concrete adjacent columns. According to
total load, not the sustained load, first loaded at an early age. The age Fintel, Ghosh, and Iyengar,4 when all
governs column size and spacing. of concrete at which dead loads the factors influencing creep act in
Transient loads such as wind or begin to act varies from floor to the same direction, the differential
earthquakes do not induce creep, floor, and of course, the applica- strain can be 200 x 10–6. In a 50-story
but are relevant to the choice of tion of loads is incremental. This
building, this represents a difference
column size. Corner columns are has to be taken into account by
in level of nearly 40 mm (1-1/2 in.).
particularly relevant because, proper procedures.
This differential shortening has the
other things being equal, they Effects of speed of construction same effect on horizontal
carry only one-half of the It follows from the influence of members—beams or slabs—that
sustained load of other external age that the speed of construction are continuous over several spans as
columns; however, they may resist affects the magnitude of creep. the effect of differential settlement

64 MAY 2002 / Concrete international


of supports. Bending moments and The loss of prestress is a func- Yazdani, Mtenga, and Richardson.7
shearing forces are induced in the tion of the sustained stress in Generally, with very large pre-
horizontal member, and they concrete at the level of the tendon. stressed concrete units such as
produce stresses in concrete and in This stress induces creep. If the bridge beams, a high level of
the steel that are additional to sustained stress begins to act at an awareness of the importance of
those caused by design loads. The early age, the magnitude of creep creep is essential and nearly
moments and shearing forces are may be considerable; the resulting always exists. Nevertheless, special
greater the shorter the span is loss of prestress will be signifi- circumstances may result in
between the adjacent columns. cant, and some camber will be potential problems.
The situation is actually more lost. This loss of camber will be This was the case in Italy, when an
complicated because there is a larger than when a similar load is industrial dispute stopped the
redistribution of loads between applied at an advanced age. In the construction of a prestressed
supports (from the more highly case in question, soon after concrete box girder bridge,
loaded to the less-loaded sup- installation, some units were launched in segments, for nearly two
port) that, in turn, creates a new, subjected for several months to years. To allow for the differential in
modified level of stress that
induces creep. Thus, creep has “...in the case of important tall buildings, the
both harmful and beneficial
effects, and this is of fundamental designer might—or even should—lay down
importance. It follows that what
might be thought of as “erring on limits on construction speed differentials.”
the safe side” and overestimating
creep is conservative at one stage temporary loads of stored materials; creep between young and old
in the design but is not conserva- the remainder of the floor was concretes when the construction
tive at another stage. This is why unloaded. It is not surprising, restarted, it was necessary to make
the designer must consider both therefore, that, overall, the floor adjustments to the launching
was not level. The manufacturer bearings and to apply temporary
the upper and lower bounds of
of the units was not at fault. prestress.8 In the process of the
creep. Iteration may be necessary,
In another case, similar units resumed construction, it was
as I mentioned in a previous
confirmed that, after two years under
article.1 This approach is explic- were stored under varying condi-
load, the ratio of creep to the elastic
itly stated in the current British tions: some in the dry indoors,
strain (known as creep coefficient)
design code BS 8110:Part 2:1985: others outdoors in a humid atmo-
was twice as large as that after
“It may be advisable at the design sphere. When taken to be installed,
6 months.8
stage to consider a range of the units were chosen in a random
In 1998, I described a balanced
values to bracket the problem, manner from the two stockpiles.
cantilever box girder, with the
since an overestimate may be just Moreover, the age of the various main span of 241 m (1264 ft), in
as bad as an underestimate.” units varied considerably, so that which a creep-induced sag of
they had undergone different about 1 m (3 ft) occurred at
Problems with camber amounts of loss of camber. In this midspan; the consequences of the
of prestressed units case, it is arguable that the sag and of the remedial work were
In some countries, prestressed manufacturer of the floor units extremely serious. 9
concrete floor slab units are often should have been aware of creep
used. They are usually made with a effects in the units, and should have Dealing with problems
camber so that, after the early loss delivered them in a systematic This article has described
of prestress, they are level. There manner. The moral of this story is several examples of problems
have been cases of uneven deflec- that, when a very level floor is caused by creep of concrete,
tion in service, and complaints have required, a careful control of which may affect the behavior of
been leveled at the manufacturers various procedures is necessary. structures. The second article, to
about the uniformity of production. An increase in camber of 50% or be published in the June 2002
In one case, this accusation was more in large prestressed concrete issue of CI, will consider ways of
unjustified, and the following bridge girders, while in storage for dealing with these problems in
explanation was established. two months, was reported by design and construction.

Concrete international / MAY 2002 65


References 5. Neville, A. M., “Concrete Technol- 9. Neville, A. M., “Letters to the Editor,”
1. Neville, A. M., “Concrete Technology ogy—An Essential Element of Structural Concrete International, V. 20, No. 9, Sept.
and Design: Twin Supports of Structures,” Design,” Concrete International, V. 20, No. 7, 1998, p. 7.
Concrete International, V. 24, No. 4, Apr. 2002, July 1998, pp. 39-41. Selected for reader interest by the editors.
pp. 52-58. 6. Ghali, A.; Dilger, W.; and Neville, A. M.,
2. Neville, A. M. (with Chapters 17 to 20 “Time-Dependent Forces Induced by
written in collaboration with W. Dilger), Settlement of Supports in Continuous
Creep of Concrete: Plain, Reinforced, and Reinforced Concrete Beams,” ACI JOURNAL,
Prestressed, North-Holland Publishing Co., Proceedings V. 66, No. 11, Nov. 1969, ACI Honorary Member Adam Neville has
Amsterdam, 1970, 622 pp. pp. 907-915. been contributing to CI articles on various
3. Neville, A. M.; Dilger, W. H.; and 7. Yazdani, N.; Mtenga, P.; and topics, all aimed at facilitating the use of
Brooks, J. J., Creep of Plain and Structural Richardson, N., “Camber Variation in scientific knowledge to make better
concrete in practice. He is the recipient of
Concrete, Longman, Harlow, 1983, 361 pp. Precast Girders,” Concrete International,
several awards from ACI and other
4. Fintel, M.; Ghosh, S. K.; and Iyengar, H., V. 21, No. 6, June 1999, pp. 45-49.
organizations, as well as Commander of
Column Shortening in Tall Structures— 8. Rosignoli, M., “Creep Effects During the Order of the British Empire awarded
Prediction and Compensation, Portland Launch of the Serio River Bridge,” Concrete by the Queen for his contribution to
Cement Association, Skokie, Ill., 1987, 34 pp. International, V. 22, No. 3, Mar. 2000, pp. 53-58. science and technology.

66 MAY 2002 / Concrete international

S-ar putea să vă placă și