Sunteți pe pagina 1din 38

Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 1 of 38

!     ! 


 !   
 "

0'22,75""#** 0-%#0#5',% 
2-,71+'2& ",'#*&22#, 
"-3%*1120'.*#22 #0')*#5'1  - 
&#,"#01-, 2&-+1&-*"#0 ;H>
(+0!31"4'1 CH>CPC>O;FFS;H>IH<?B;F@
I@;=F;MMI@;FFINB?LMMCGCF;LFSMCNO;N?>  3:20-cv340-TSL-RHW
.:.0(8.323%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

.F;CHNC@@M 

P

2-++727*-0 CHBCMI@@C=C;F=;J;=CNS;M
'HN?LCG!IGGCMMCIH?LI@NB?+CMMCMMCJJC
"?J;LNG?HNI@!ILL?=NCIHM0-,)',% CHBCM
I@@C=C;F=;J;=CNS;M1OJ?LCHN?H>?HNI@!?HNL;F
+CMMCMMCJJC!ILL?=NCIH;F$;=CFCNS;H>(-#
#00',%2-, CHBCMI@@C=C;F=;J;=CNS;M
1OJ?LCHN?H>?HNI@1IONB+CMMCMMCJJC!ILL?=NCIH;F
'HMNCNONCIH 

"?@?H>;HNM

  


 $! "



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 2 of 38

$   

 2BCM=;M?CM;=B;FF?HA?NINB?CH;>?KO;N?L?MJIHM?NINB?!-4'" J;H>?GC=;N

+CMMCMMCJJC\MNQIF;LA?MNJLCMIHMX!?HNL;F+CMMCMMCJJC!ILL?=NCIH;F$;=CFCNS!+!$ ;H>1IONB

+CMMCMMCJJC !ILL?=NCIH;F 'HMNCNON? 1+!' XQBC=B NIA?NB?L BIOM? ;JJLIRCG;N?FS   QIG?H

;H>G?H

 .LCILNINB?!-4'" J;H>?GC= +CMMCMMCJJC\MJLCMIHMQ?L?CH;MN;N?I@=LCMCM

.?IJF?>C?CHIOLJLCMIHM;N;L;N?NB;N@;L?R=??>MNB?H;NCIH;F;P?L;A?+CMMCMMCJJCB;MNB?M?=IH>

BCAB?MN L;N? I@ CH=;L=?L;NCIH CH NB? H;NCIH  BIF>CHA G;HS CH =OMNI>S QBI >I HIN H??> NI <?

CH=;L=?L;N?> .LCMIHM FCE? !+!$ ;H> 1+!' ;L? @OH=NCIH;FFS IP?L=LIQ>?> NB?CL BIOMCHA OHCNM

IJ?L;N?;NJBSMC=;F=;J;=CNS<ONQCNBB;F@NB?L?KOCL?>MN;@@-@N?HIHFSIH?I@@C=?L;N!+!$IL

1+!'CMIH>ONSNIMOJ?LPCM?BOH>L?>MI@L?MC>?HNM MIG?NCG?MCH>C@@?L?HNFI=;NCIHM0?MC>?HNM

MJ?H>GIMNI@NB?CLNCG?CH;H><?NQ??H=L;GJ?>LIQMI@<OHE<?>MJF;=?>;<ION@IOL@??N;J;LN

!?LN;CHBIOMCHAOHCNM;N!+!$;H>1+!'BIF>=IH=?HNL;N?>=BLIHC==;L?JIJOF;NCIHMXI@?F>?LFS 

CFF ;H>>CM;<F?>CH>CPC>O;FM;NBCAB?LLCMEI@BIMJCN;FCT;NCIH;H>>?;NB>O?NI!-4'" CH@?=NCIH

#P?H CH NB?M? =LIQ>?>  J?LMIH >IO<F? <OHE?> TIH?M  JLCMIH I@@C=C;FM B;P? HIN ;>?KO;N?FS

CGJF?G?HN?>LO>CG?HN;LSJ;H>?GC=L?MJIHM?JLINI=IFM MO=B;M@L?KO?HN=F?;HCHA;H>>CMCH@?=NCIH

I@FCPCHAOHCNM;H>JLIPCMCIHI@MO@@C=C?HN=F?;HCHAMOJJFC?M0?MC>?HNML?AOF;LFSLOHIONI@MI;J

;H> =;HHIN Q;MB NB?CL B;H>M 1IG? OM? OHF;OH>?L?> J?LMIH;F NIQ?FM NI NLS ;H> =F?;H =IGGIH

;L?;M 'H>CPC>O;FM B;P? L?JILN?> B;PCHA MSGJNIGM I@ =ILIH;PCLOM <ON Q?L? HIN CGG?>C;N?FS

CMIF;N?>ILN?MN?>1SMN?GQC>? +"-!B;MN?MN?>F?MMNB;HIH?B;F@I@IH?J?L=?HNI@CNMJIJOF;NCIH

@IL!-4'" XIHFS;@?Q>IT?HI@NB?IP?L CH>CPC>O;FMCNBIF>MCH=OMNI>S

 +"-!\M@;CFOL?NI;>?KO;N?FSCGJF?G?HN<;M?FCH?JLIN?=NCP?G?;MOL?M;N!+!$

;H> 1+!' GIHNBM CHNI NB? J;H>?GC= PCIF;N?M NB? G?LC=;HM QCNB "CM;<CFCNC?M =N ;H> NB?

0?B;<CFCN;NCIH =NX@?>?L;F F;QM NB;N JLIN?=N QIG?H ;H> G?H CH JLCMIH QBIM? >CM;<CFCNC?M JON


Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 3 of 38

NB?G ;N ;H CH=L?;M?> LCME I@ =IHNL;=NCHA  <?=IGCHA M?P?L?FS CFF @LIG  ;H> >SCHA ;M ; L?MOFN I@

!-4'" CH@?=NCIH+"-!\M@;CFOL?;FMIPCIF;N?MNB?LCABNI@;FFL?MC>?HNM;N!+!$;H>1+!'

NI<?@L??@LIG=IH>CNCIHMI@=IH@CH?G?HNNB;N=L?;N?;MO<MN;HNC;FLCMEI@M?LCIOMB;LGNINB?CL

B?;FNB;H>M;@?NS ;MAO;L;HN??>OH>?LNB?#CABNBG?H>G?HNI@NB?3HCN?>1N;N?M!IHMNCNONCIH

 1I=C;F>CMN;H=CHACM?RNL?G?FS>C@@C=OFNCHNB?M?IP?L=LIQ>?>JLCMIHM ;H>MN?JMNI

L?>O=?NB;NIP?L=LIQ>CHAQIOF>B?FJNI;G?FCIL;N?NB?>;HA?LMJIM?><S!-4'" NNB?M;G?

NCG?  L?G?>C;F MN?JM NI GCNCA;N? ;H> G;H;A? NL;HMGCMMCIH I@ !-4'"  GOMN <? CGJF?G?HN?>

CGG?>C;N?FS  CH=FO>CHA G?;MOL?M JLIPC>?> <S NB? !?HN?LM @IL "CM?;M? !IHNLIF ;H> .L?P?HNCIH

!"! CHCNMAOC>;H=?NI=ILL?=NCIH;F@;=CFCNC?M'HNBCM=;M? .F;CHNC@@MM??E;=IOLNIL>?LL?KOCLCHA

;>?KO;N?CGJF?G?HN;NCIHI@G?;MOL?MH?=?MM;LSNIGCHCGCT?;H>G;H;A?;HION<L?;EI@!-4'"

;N!+!$;H>1+!'

! "!

 2BCM!IOLNB;MDOLCM>C=NCIHJOLMO;HNNI31!UCHNB;NNBCMCM;=CPCF;=NCIH

;LCMCHAOH>?LNB?!IHMNCNONCIHI@NB?3HCN?>1N;N?M ;H>JOLMO;HNNI31!U; <?=;OM?

NBCM;=NCIHM??EMNIL?>L?MMNB?>?JLCP;NCIH OH>?L=IFILI@MN;N?F;Q I@LCABNMM?=OL?>NI.F;CHNC@@M

<SNB?!IHMNCNONCIH;H>F;QMI@NB?3HCN?>1N;N?M

 .F;CHNC@@M\=F;CGM;L?;FMI<LIOABNJOLMO;HNNINB?G?LC=;HMQCNB"CM;<CFCNC?M=N

"   31! U  ?N M?K  ;H> NB? 0?B;<CFCN;NCIH =N 0   31! U  ?N M?K

.F;CHNC@@M\=F;CGM@ILL?FC?@;L?;FMIJL?>C=;N?> CHJ;LN OJIH31!U QBC=B;ONBILCT?M

;=NCIHMNIL?>L?MMNB?>?JLCP;NCIH OH>?L=IFILI@MN;N?F;Q I@LCABNM JLCPCF?A?M ;H>CGGOHCNC?M

M?=OL?><SNB?!IHMNCNONCIHI@NB?F;QMI@NB?3HCN?>1N;N?M

 2BCM !IOLN B;M ;ONBILCNS NI AL;HN >?=F;L;NILS ;H> CHDOH=NCP? L?FC?@ OH>?L NI 

31!UU;H> ;MQ?FF;M$?>?L;F0OF?I@!CPCF.LI=?>OL?



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 4 of 38

 4?HO?CMJLIJ?LCHNBCM>CMNLC=NJOLMO;HNNI31!UU< ;H>= ;M

"?@?H>;HNM>I<OMCH?MMCHNBCMDO>C=C;F>CMNLC=N;H>G;HSI@NB??P?HNMILIGCMMCIHMACPCHALCM?NI

NB?=F;CGMI==OLL?>CHNBCMDO>C=C;F>CMNLC=N

 

 
 

 LCNN;HS5;>>?FFCMCH=;L=?L;N?>;N!+!$1B?CMS?;LMIF> B;MNBL??=BCF>L?H 

;H>CMCH=;L=?L;N?>@IL;>LOA L?F;N?>I@@?HM?1B?FCP?MCH;OHCNNB;NBIOM?M;JJLIRCG;N?FS

QIG?HCHLIQMI@<OHE<?>MMJ;=?>;JJLIRCG;N?FS@IOL@??N;J;LN

 0IA?L#QCHACMCH=;L=?L;N?>CH!+!$&?CMS?;LMIF>&?OM?M;QB??F=B;CL;M

; L?MOFN I@ GOFNCJF? MNLIE?M &? B;M >C@@C=OFN MN;H>CHA OJ @LIG BCM QB??F=B;CL &? MO@@?LM @LIG

M?P?L?=BLIHC=;MNBG;;H>NB?<?ACHHCHAMN;A?MI@?GJBSM?G;NB;NG;E?CN>C@@C=OFN@ILBCGNI

<L?;NB?&?B;MB;>GOFNCJF?<IONMI@=;H=?L&?MO@@?LM@LIG<;>EC>H?SM;H>MNIH?M&?B;>

<ICFCHAQ;N?LNBLIQHIHBCGQB?HB?Q;MCH=;L=?L;N?>;N;HINB?LJLCMIHNB;N<OLH?>H?;LFSB;F@I@

BCM<I>S&?MO@@?LM@LIGH?LP?J;CHNB;NJL?P?HNMBCG@LIGMF??JCHAGIL?NB;H;@?QBIOLM;N

HCABN+L#QCHACM;KO;FC@C?>CH>CPC>O;FQCNB;>CM;<CFCNSOH>?LNB?G?LC=;HMQCNB"CM;<CFCNC?M

=NCHNB;NB?B;M;HCGJ;CLG?HNNB;NMO<MN;HNC;FFSFCGCNMG;DILFC@?;=NCPCNC?M CH=FO>CHA <ONHIN

FCGCN?> NI  MF??JCHA  Q;FECHA  MN;H>CHA  <L?;NBCHA  ;H> L?MJCL;NILS @OH=NCIH &? CM MCGCF;LFS ;

KO;FC@C?>CH>CPC>O;FQCNB;>CM;<CFCNS@ILJOLJIM?MI@1?=NCIHI@NB?0?B;<CFCN;NCIH=N&?CM

; G?G<?L I@ NB? "CM;<CFCNS 1O<=F;MM @IL L?;MIHM CH=FO>CHA  <ON HIN FCGCN?> NI  NB? @;=N NB;N BCM

>CM;<CFCNC?MJONBCG;NCH=L?;M?>LCMEI@=IHNL;=NCHA <?=IGCHAM?P?L?FSCFF@LIG ;H>IL>SCHA@LIG

!-4'" +L#QCHAFCP?MCHIH?I@NB?OHCNM;N!+!$NB;NCMBIG?NI;F;LA?JIJOF;NCIHI@

?F>?LFS;H>=BLIHC==;L?G?>C=;FJ;NC?HNMNB?;JJLIRCG;N?FSL?MC>?HNMMJ?H>GIMNI@NB?CLNCG?

CH;H>;GIHALIQMI@<OHE<?>MMJ;=?>;JJLIRCG;N?FS@IOL@??N;J;LN



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 5 of 38

 2IHS 1GCNB CM CH=;L=?L;N?> CH !+!$ &? CM  S?;LM IF> &? MO@@?LM @LIG BCAB

<FII>JL?MMOL? =BIF?MN?LIF ;H>;H?HF;LA?>JLIMN;N? ;FFI@QBC=BB?GOMNN;E?G?>C=;NCIH@IL&?

MO@@?LM@LIG;>?A?H?L;NCP?DICHN>CM?;M?&?B;M;>CM?;M?;@@?=NCHABCMMJCH?'@B?GCMM?MBCM

<FII>JL?MMOL?G?>C=;NCIH B?MO@@?LM@LIG<;>B?;>;=B?M;H>F?NB;LAS&?<LIE?BCMB;H><;>FS

CH"?=?G<?LI@&CM<LIE?HB;H>B?;F?>CH=ILL?=NFS ;H>B?CMMNCFFCHJ;CH&?CMQ;CNCHA@IL

IONMC>?G?>C=;F=;L?NI@CRBCMB;H> <ONNB?;JJICHNG?HNB;M<??H>?F;S?><SNB?J;H>?GC=+L

1GCNBCM;KO;FC@C?>CH>CPC>O;FQCNB;>CM;<CFCNSOH>?LNB?G?LC=;HMQCNB"CM;<CFCNC?M=NCHNB;N

B?B;M;HCGJ;CLG?HNNB;NMO<MN;HNC;FFSFCGCNMG;DILFC@?;=NCPCNC?M CH=FO>CHA <ONHINFCGCN?>NI 

Q;FECHA ;H> MN;H>CHA &? CM MCGCF;LFS ; KO;FC@C?> CH>CPC>O;F QCNB ; >CM;<CFCNS @IL JOLJIM?M I@

1?=NCIH  I@ NB? 0?B;<CFCN;NCIH =N +L 1GCNB CM ;N CH=L?;M?> LCME I@ =IHNL;=NCHA  <?=IGCHA

M?P?L?FSCFF@LIG ;H>IL>SCHA@LIG!-4'" +L1GCNBFCP?MCHIH?I@NB?OHCNM;N!+!$NB;N

CMBIG?NI;F;LA?JIJOF;NCIHI@?F>?LFS;H>=BLIHC==;L?G?>C=;FJ;NC?HNMNB?;JJLIRCG;N?FS

L?MC>?HNMMJ?H>GIMNI@NB?CLNCG?CH;H>;GIHALIQMI@<OHE<?>MMJ;=?>;JJLIRCG;N?FS@IOL@??N

;J;LN

 ";HC?F&;NN?HCMCH=;L=?L;N?>CH!+$!&?MO@@?LM@LIGBCAB<FII>JL?MMOL?&CM

BCAB<FII>JL?MMOL?F?;>MNI@L?KO?HNN?HMCIHB?;>;=B?MNB;NCGGI<CFCT?BCGIHBCM<?>&?Q;M

MN;<<?>CHNB??S?CH$?<LO;LSI@ QBC=BB?;F?>CGJLIJ?LFS&CM?S?CMJ;CH@OF B;MFCGCN?>

GIP?G?HN ;H>=;OM?MBCGNIM??>IO<F?&?MO@@?LM@LIGOF=?L;N?>B?GILLBIC>M+L&;NN?HCM;

KO;FC@C?>CH>CPC>O;FQCNB;>CM;<CFCNSOH>?LNB?G?LC=;HMQCNB"CM;<CFCNC?M=NCHNB;NB?B;M;H

CGJ;CLG?HN NB;N MO<MN;HNC;FFS FCGCNM G;DIL FC@? ;=NCPCNC?M  CH=FO>CHA  <ON HIN FCGCN?> NI  M??CHA 

Q;FECHA  ;H> MN;H>CHA &? CM MCGCF;LFS ; KO;FC@C?> CH>CPC>O;F QCNB ; >CM;<CFCNS @IL JOLJIM?M I@

1?=NCIHI@NB?0?B;<CFCN;NCIH=N+L&;NN?HCM;NCH=L?;M?>LCMEI@=IHNL;=NCHA <?=IGCHA

M?P?L?FSCFF@LIG ;H>IL>SCHA@LIG!-4'" 



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 6 of 38

 "IOAF;MM2LCJF?NNCMCH=;L=?L;N?>CH1+!'&?CMS?;LMIF>&?MO@@?LM@LIG&'4

;H>J;L;HIC>M=BCTIJBL?HC;FNBIOABB?CM=OLL?HNFSOH>?LNB?=;L?I@;JBSMC=C;H@ILBCM&'4 B?

B;MHINL?=?CP?>NL?;NG?HN@ILBCMJ;L;HIC>M=BCTIJBL?HC;@IL;JJLIRCG;N?FSNQ?HNSS?;LM&CM&'4

G;E?M BCG ?RNL?G?FS Q?;E  F?NB;LAC= ;H> CGGI<CFCT?> &? ;FMI B;M FCNNF? NI HI ;JJ?NCN? QCNB

N?LLC<F? J;CH CH BCM MNIG;=B ?=;OM? I@ NB?M? MSGJNIGM  B? =;HHIN ?R?L=CM? FCE? B? HILG;FFS

QIOF>&?;FMICMHINMOJJIM?>NI<?CHMOHFCABN MIB?=;HHINI@N?HAIIONMC>?+L2LCJF?NNCM;

KO;FC@C?>CH>CPC>O;FQCNB;>CM;<CFCNSOH>?LNB?G?LC=;HMQCNB"CM;<CFCNC?M=NCHNB;NB?B;M;H

CGJ;CLG?HN NB;N MO<MN;HNC;FFS FCGCNM G;DIL FC@? ;=NCPCNC?M  CH=FO>CHA  <ON HIN FCGCN?> NI  ?;NCHA 

Q;FECHA MN;H>CHA =IH=?HNL;NCHA NBCHECHA =IGGOHC=;NCHA CGGOH?MSMN?G@OH=NCIH H?OLIFIAC=;F

@OH=NCIH ;H><L;CH@OH=NCIH&?CMMCGCF;LFS;KO;FC@C?>CH>CPC>O;FQCNB;>CM;<CFCNS@ILJOLJIM?MI@

1?=NCIH  I@ NB? 0?B;<CFCN;NCIH =N &? CM ; G?G<?L I@ NB? "CM;<CFCNS 1O<=F;MM @IL L?;MIHM

CH=FO>CHA <ONHINFCGCN?>NI NB?@;=NNB;NBCM>CM;<CFCNC?MJONBCG;NCH=L?;M?>LCMEI@=IHNL;=NCHA 

<?=IGCHAM?P?L?FSCFF@LIG ;H>IL>SCHA@LIG!-4'" 

 I<&?H>?LMIHCMCH=;L=?L;N?>CH1+!'&?MO@@?LM@LIGH?OLI@C<LIG;NIMCM&CM

>CM?;M?=;OM?MNOGILMNIALIQIHBCMMJCH?;H>H?LPIOMMSMN?G ;MQ?FF;M<INBCHMC>?;H>IONMC>?

BCM<I>S'N;FMI=;OM?MBCAB<FII>JL?MMOL? ;FN?L?>PCMCIH >C@@C=OFNSQ;FECHA ;H>JLI<F?GMQCNB

QBCN?<FII>=?FFM&?CMHINL?=?CPCHANB?H?=?MM;LS+0'M;H>NL?;NG?HN@ILBCMH?OLI@C<LIG;NIMCM

;H>CMQ?;E =;HHINQ;FEILMN;H>@IL;JLIFIHA?>NCG? ;H>L?KOCL?MGIL?MCAHC@C=;HNFSGIL?MF??J

NB;H ;H ;P?L;A? J?LMIH &? B;M ;FMI MO@@?L?> @LIG >?JL?MMCIH +L &?H>?LMIH CM ; KO;FC@C?>

CH>CPC>O;FQCNB;>CM;<CFCNSOH>?LNB?G?LC=;HMQCNB"CM;<CFCNC?M=NCHNB;NB?B;M;HCGJ;CLG?HN

NB;N MO<MN;HNC;FFS FCGCNM G;DIL FC@? ;=NCPCNC?M  CH=FO>CHA  <ON HIN FCGCN?> NI  MF??JCHA  M??CHA 

Q;FECHA  MN;H>CHA  H?OLIFIAC=;F @OH=NCIH  ;H> =CL=OF;NILS @OH=NCIH &? CM MCGCF;LFS ; KO;FC@C?>

CH>CPC>O;FQCNB;>CM;<CFCNS@ILJOLJIM?MI@1?=NCIHI@NB?0?B;<CFCN;NCIH=N&?CM;G?G<?L



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 7 of 38

I@NB?"CM;<CFCNS1O<=F;MM@ILL?;MIHMCH=FO>CHA <ONHINFCGCN?>NI NB?@;=NNB;NBCM>CM;<CFCNC?MJON

BCG;NCH=L?;M?>LCMEI@=IHNL;=NCHA <?=IGCHAM?P?L?FSCFF@LIG ;H>IL>SCHA@LIG!-4'" 

 #LCE*?QCMCMCH=;L=?L;N?>CH1+!'&?CMS?;LMIF>&?MO@@?LM@LIG=BLIHC=

;MNBG;&?I@N?HMNLOAAF?MNI<L?;NB?>O?NIBCM;MNBG;&CM;MNBG;G;E?M;HS;=NCPCNS CH=FO>CHA

Q;FECHAILN;FECHA >C@@C=OFN&?MO@@?LM@LIGM?P?L?GCAL;CH?M+L*?QCMCM;KO;FC@C?>CH>CPC>O;F

QCNB ; >CM;<CFCNS OH>?L NB? G?LC=;HM QCNB "CM;<CFCNC?M =N CH NB;N B? B;M ;H CGJ;CLG?HN NB;N

MO<MN;HNC;FFS FCGCNM G;DIL FC@? ;=NCPCNC?M  CH=FO>CHA  <ON HIN FCGCN?> NI  Q;FECHA  MJ?;ECHA 

=IGGOHC=;NCHA <L?;NBCHA ;H>L?MJCL;NILS@OH=NCIH&?CMMCGCF;LFS;KO;FC@C?>CH>CPC>O;FQCNB;

>CM;<CFCNS@ILJOLJIM?MI@1?=NCIHI@NB?0?B;<CFCN;NCIH=N&?CM;G?G<?LI@NB?"CM;<CFCNS

1O<=F;MM@ILL?;MIHMCH=FO>CHA <ONHINFCGCN?>NI NB?@;=NNB;NBCM>CM;<CFCNC?MJONBCG;NCH=L?;M?>

LCMEI@=IHNL;=NCHA <?=IGCHAM?P?L?FSCFF@LIG ;H>IL>SCHA@LIG!-4'" 

 2BIG;M&IF>?LCMCH=;L=?L;N?>CH1+!'&?CMS?;LMIF>&?MO@@?LM@LIG@;=C;F

=;H=?L QBC=BB;M>CM@CAOL?>BCM@;=?&?B;M<??H>C;AHIM?>QCNB>C;<?N?M&?;FMIMO@@?LM@LIG

NSJ?IH?<CJIF;L>CMIL>?L QBC=BCMNB?GIMNM?P?L?@ILGI@NB?>CM?;M?&?<?=IG?MG;HC=C@BCM

<CJIF;L>CMIL>?LCMHINNL?;N?>ILB?<?=IG?MMNL?MM?>&CM<CJIF;L>CMIL>?L=;OM?MBCGNI<?=IG?

P?LS;ACN;N?>;H>B;P?NLIO<F?MF??JCHA+L&IF>?LCM;KO;FC@C?>CH>CPC>O;FQCNB;>CM;<CFCNSOH>?L

NB?G?LC=;HMQCNB"CM;<CFCNC?M=NCHNB;NB?B;M;HCGJ;CLG?HNNB;NMO<MN;HNC;FFSFCGCNMG;DIL

FC@?;=NCPCNC?M CH=FO>CHA <ONHINFCGCN?>NI MF??JCHA =IH=?HNL;NCHA NBCHECHA ;H><L;CH@OH=NCIH

&? CM MCGCF;LFS ; KO;FC@C?> CH>CPC>O;F QCNB ; >CM;<CFCNS @IL JOLJIM?M I@ 1?=NCIH  I@ NB?

0?B;<CFCN;NCIH=N&?CM;G?G<?LI@NB?"CM;<CFCNS1O<=F;MM@ILL?;MIHMCH=FO>CHA <ONHINFCGCN?>

NI NB?@;=NNB;NBCM>CM;<CFCNC?MJONBCG;NCH=L?;M?>LCMEI@=IHNL;=NCHA <?=IGCHAM?P?L?FSCFF@LIG 

;H>IL>SCHA@LIG!-4'" +L#QCHAFCP?MCHIH?I@NB?OHCNM;N1+!'NB;NCMBIG?NI;F;LA?



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 8 of 38

JIJOF;NCIHI@?F>?LFS;H>=BLIHC==;L?G?>C=;FJ;NC?HNMNB?;JJLIRCG;N?FSL?MC>?HNMMJ?H>

GIMNI@NB?CLNCG?CH;H>;GIHALIQMI@<OHE<?>MMJ;=?>;JJLIRCG;N?FS@IOL@??N;J;LN

 (;G;L=OM";PCMCMCH=;L=?L;N?>CH1+!'&?MO@@?LM@LIG;HRC?NS;H>>?JL?MMCIH

&CMMSGJNIGMB;P?<?=IG?GIL?M?LCIOMIP?LNB?=IOLM?I@NB?J;H>?GC=

 FFI@NB?M?.F;CHNC@@MFCP?CHJLCMIHMQB?L?NB?"?@?H>;HNM;H>NB?CL;A?HNMB;P?

HIN;>?KO;N?FSCGJF?G?HN?>M;@?AO;L>ML?A;L>CHA!-4'" CHPCIF;NCIHI@NB?!IHMNCNONCIH;H>

@?>?L;FF;QM;M>?M=LC<?>CHNBCM=IGJF;CHNM;L?MOFN NB?LCMEI@=IHNL;=NCHA;H>MO@@?LCHAIL

>SCHA@LIG!-4'" B;M>L;G;NC=;FFSCH=L?;M?>@IL?;=BI@NB?M?CH>CPC>O;FM





 "?@?H>;HN 2IGGS 2;SFIL CM NB? 'HN?LCG !IGGCMMCIH?L !IGGCMMCIH?L  @IL NB?

+CMMCMMCJJC"?J;LNG?HNI@!ILL?=NCIHM+"-! ;H>CMMO?>CHBCMI@@C=C;F=;J;=CNS0?@?L?H=?MNI

+"-!B?L?CH;FMIL?@?LNI!IGGCMMCIH?L2;SFILM!IGGCMMCIH?L 2;SFILCML?MJIHMC<F?@ILNB?

IJ?L;NCIH I@ NB? +"-!  +CMMCMMCJJC\M JLCMIH MSMN?G  ;H> CNM JLCMIHM  ;H> CM L?MJIHMC<F? @IL

CHMOLCHA=IGJFC;H=?QCNBNB?3HCN?>1N;N?M!IHMNCNONCIH;H>@?>?L;FF;QM

 "?@?H>;HN 0IH )CHA CM NB? 1OJ?LCHN?H>?HN I@ !+!$ ;H> CM MO?> CH BCM I@@C=C;F

=;J;=CNS 'H NB;N =;J;=CNS  B? CM L?MJIHMC<F? @IL NB? IJ?L;NCIH I@ !+!$ ;H> CM L?MJIHMC<F? @IL

CHMOLCHA=IGJFC;H=?QCNBNB?3HCN?>1N;N?M!IHMNCNONCIH;H>@?>?L;FF;QM;N!+!$0?@?L?H=?MNI

!+!$B?L?CH;FMIL?@?LNI"?@?H>;HN)CHA

 "?@?H>;HN(I?#LLCHANIHCMNB?1OJ?LCHN?H>?HNI@1+!';H>CMMO?>CHBCMI@@C=C;F

=;J;=CNS 'H NB;N =;J;=CNS  B? CM L?MJIHMC<F? @IL NB? IJ?L;NCIH I@ 1+!' ;H> CM L?MJIHMC<F? @IL

CHMOLCHA=IGJFC;H=?QCNBNB?3HCN?>1N;N?M!IHMNCNONCIH;H>@?>?L;FF;QM;N1+!'0?@?L?H=?MNI

1+!'B?L?CH;FMIL?@?LNI"?@?H>;HN#LLCHANIH

 +"-! !+!$ ;H>1+!';L?JO<FC=?HNCNC?MOH>?L2CNF?''I@NB?";H>L?=?CP?

@?>?L;F@CH;H=C;F;MMCMN;H=?QCNBCHNB?G?;HCHAI@NB?0 ;H>B;P?;N;FFL?F?P;HNNCG?M


Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 9 of 38

 N;FFL?F?P;HNNCG?M NB?;=NCIHMI@"?@?H>;HNM;H>NB?CL;A?HNMQ?L?MN;N?;=NCIH

;H>Q?L?N;E?HOH>?L=IFILI@MN;N?F;Q

 

 -*"&2)*1.(.2.77.77.44.&2)*<32)

 5? ;L? FCPCHA CH NB? GC>MN I@ ;H ?RNL?G?  OHJL?=?>?HN?> QILF>QC>? B?;FNB

?G?LA?H=S=;OM?><SNB?L;JC>MJL?;>I@NB?=ILIH;PCLOM !-4'" 

 -H +;L=B     +CMMCMMCJJC %IP?LHIL 2;N? 0??P?M CMMO?> ; JLI=F;G;NCIH

>?=F;LCHA ; >CM;MN?L CH NB? 1N;N? I@ +CMMCMMCJJC .L?MC>?HN 2LOGJ B;M >?=F;L?> !-4'"  ;

H;NCIH;F?G?LA?H=S2B?5ILF>&?;FNB-LA;HCT;NCIHB;M>?=F;L?>CNNI<?;AFI<;FJ;H>?GC=

 5ILF>QC>? H?;LFSGCFFCIHCH>CPC>O;FMB;P?=IH@CLG?>>C;AHIM?MI@!-4'"

;H>GIL?NB;H B;P?>C?>

 =LIMM NB? 3HCN?> 1N;N?M  NB?L? ;L? GIL? NB;H  GCFFCIH =IH@CLG?> =;M?M I@

!-4'" ;H>IP?L J?IJF?B;P?>C?>



 +CMMCMMCJJC -@@C=? I@ NB? %IP?LHIL  .LI=F;G;NCIH +;L     '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMQQQMIMGMAIP!IHN?HN>I=OG?HNM;<ION:OM5B;NM,?Q%IP?LHIL.LI=FIG;NCIH.O<FC=&?;FNBJ>
@

 .LI=F;G;NCIH IH "?=F;LCHA ; ,;NCIH;F #G?LA?H=S !IH=?LHCHA NB? ,IP?F !ILIH;PCLOM "CM?;M?
!-4'"  -ON<L?;E +;L     ;P;CF;<F? ;N BNNJMQQQQBCN?BIOM?AIPJL?MC>?HNC;F
;=NCIHMJLI=F;G;NCIH >?=F;LCHA H;NCIH;F ?G?LA?H=S =IH=?LHCHA HIP?F =ILIH;PCLOM >CM?;M? =IPC> 
ION<L?;E

 0IFFCHA 3J>;N?M IH !ILIH;PCLOM "CM?;M? !-4'"   5ILF> &?;FNB -LA  '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMQQQQBICHN?G?LA?H=C?M>CM?;M?MHIP?F =ILIH;PCLOM ?P?HNM ;M NB?S B;JJ?H F;MN PCMCN?>
JL  

 5&- !ILIH;PCLOM "CM?;M? !-4'"  ";MB<I;L>  5ILF> &?;FNB -LA  '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJM=IPC>QBICHNF;MNPCMCN?>+;S  

 !ILIH;PCLOM "CM?;M?  !-4'"   !IPC>  CH NB? 31  !?HN?LM @IL "CM?;M? !IHNLIF ;H>
.LIN?=NCIH  '<'/2'(2+ ': BNNJMQQQ=>=AIP=ILIH;PCLOM H=IP=;M?M OJ>;N?M=;M?M CH OMBNGF F;MN
PCMCN?>+;S  



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 10 of 38

 MI@+;S  NB?L?Q?L? I@!-4'" =;M?MCH+CMMCMMCJJC

J?IJF?CH+CMMCMMCJJCB;P?>C?>@LIGNB?>CM?;M?!;M?NIN;FMCH+CMMCMMCJJC;L?LCMCHA;=LIMMNB?

MN;N?QCNB?P?LSJ;MMCHA>;S

 !-4'" CM;H?RNL?G?FS>;HA?LIOMPCLOM'N=;HM?P?L?FS>;G;A?NB?FOHAM;H>

INB?LPCN;FILA;HM CH=FO>CHANB?B?;LN;H>FCP?L ;H>OFNCG;N?FS=;OM?>?;NB

 2B?L?CMHIEHIQHP;==CH? =OL? ILNL?;NG?HN,IIH?CMCGGOH?

 +;HSJ;NC?HNMQBI>IHIN>C?MNCFFL?KOCL?BIMJCN;FCT;NCIH2BIM?QCNBM?LCIOM=;M?M

G;S@;=?JLIFIHA?>L?=IP?LSJ?LCI>M;H>MO@@?L@LIGH?OLIFIAC=;F>;G;A?;H>J?LG;H?HNFIMMI@

L?MJCL;NILS=;J;=CNS

 2B?@;N;FCNSL;N?I@!-4'" CH=L?;M?MQCNB;A?1J?=C@C=;FFS J?IJF?IP?LQBI

=IHNL;=N!-4'" @;=?B?CABN?H?>LCMEMI@M?LCIOMCFFH?MMIL>?;NB

 !-4'" ;FMIJONM;NJ;LNC=OF;LLCMECH>CPC>O;FMQCNBOH>?LFSCHAB?;FNB=IH>CNCIHM

ILINB?L>CM;<CFCNC?MCH=FO>CHAFOHA>CM?;M? B?;LN>CM?;M? =BLIHC=FCP?LILEC>H?S>CM?;M? >C;<?N?M 

?JCF?JMS  =IGJLIGCM?> CGGOH? MSMN?GM MO=B ;M @LIG =;H=?L  &'4  IL ;ONICGGOH? >CM?;M? 

<FII>>CMIL>?LM CHB?LCN?>G?N;<IFC=>CMIL>?LM MNLIE? >?P?FIJG?HN;F>?F;S ;H>;MNBG;.?IJF?

QBI;L?JL?AH;HNG;S;FMI<?;NBCAB?LLCMEI@>?P?FIJCHAM?P?L?CFFH?MM@LIG!-4'" 



!ILIH;PCLOM"CM?;M?!-4'"  !IPC> CH+CMMCMMCJJC;H>NB?31 +CMMCMMCJJC1N;N?"?JN
I@&?;FNB '<'/2'(2+':BNNJMGM>BGMAIPGM>BMCN?:MN;NC=  BNGFF;MNPCMCN?>+;S  

*

*

*V

!ILIH;PCLOM"CM?;M?!-4'"  -F>?L>OFNM !?HN?LM@IL"CM?;M?!IHNLIF;H>.L?P?HNCIH
Y!"!Z  JL     '<'/2'(2+ ': BNNJMQQQ=>=AIP=ILIH;PCLOM H=IPH??> ?RNL;
JL?=;ONCIHMIF>?L ;>OFNMBNGF

 1++ !ILIH;PCLOM "CM?;M?  !-4'"   .?IJF? 5BI +;S ? ;N &CAB?L 0CME  !"! 
'<'/2'(2+ ': BNNJMQQQ=>=AIP=ILIH;PCLOM H=IPH??> ?RNL; JL?=;ONCIHMJ?IJF? ;N BCAB?L
LCMEBNGFF;MN;==?MM?>JL  


Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 11 of 38

 ON?P?LSIH?CM;NLCMEI@!-4'" 2B?PCLOMCMECFFCHA?P?HB?;FNBS;>OFNM

 !-4'"  CM ; J;LNC=OF;LFS =IHN;ACIOM >CM?;M?  L?=?HN MNO>S MBIQ?> NB;N NB?

PCLOM=;HMOLPCP?@ILOJNINBL??BIOLMCHNB?;CL @IOLBIOLMIH=IJJ?L OJNINQ?HNS @IOLBIOLMIH

=;L><I;L> ;H>OJNINQININBL??>;SMIHJF;MNC=;H>MN;CHF?MMMN??F

 !IHNLIFFCHANB?MJL?;>I@!-4'" CMG;>??P?HGIL?>C@@C=OFN<?=;OM?I@NB?

JLIGCH?H=?I@;MSGJNIG;NC=NL;HMGCMMCIH@LIGCH>CPC>O;FMQBI;L?=IHN;ACIOM<ONQBI?RBC<CN

HI MSGJNIGM MSGJNIG;NC= NL;HMGCMMCIH L?H>?LM CH?@@?=NCP? M=L??HCHA NIIFM NB;N >?J?H> IH

C>?HNC@SCHAMSGJNIGM

 2B? !"! ;H> INB?L JO<FC= B?;FNB ;A?H=C?M B;P? OHCP?LM;FFS JL?M=LC<?> MI=C;F

>CMN;H=CHA;H>LCAILIOMBSAC?H?;MNB?IHFSQ;SMNIG?;HCHA@OFFSGCNCA;N?NB?MJL?;>I@NBCMPCLOM

2IJLIJ?LFSJL;=NC=?MI=C;F>CMN;H=CHA ?P?LSJ?LMIHMBIOF>L?G;CH;N;>CMN;H=?I@;NF?;MNMCR@??N

@LIG?P?LSINB?LJ?LMIH0CAILIOMBSAC?H?MBIOF>CH=FO>?L?AOF;L;H>NBILIOABB;H>Q;MBCHA

QCNBMI;J;H>Q;N?L NB?OM?I@;F=IBIF <;M?>B;H>M;HCNCT?L JLIJ?LMH??T?;H>=IOAB?NCKO?NN? 

;H>@L?KO?HN=F?;HCHAI@;FFMOL@;=?M



 1++ '295 CFF %;N?M  0?MJIH>CHA NI !IPC>  W  -H=? CH ; !?HNOLS .;H>?GC=  ,#5 #,% (
-$+#"$?<  

 2?MNM 1BIQ ,?Q 4CLOM *CP?M IH 1IG? 1OL@;=?M @IL 3J NI  ";SM  31 ,#51 +;L    
BNNJMQQQOMH?QM=IGH?QMB?;FNB H?QM;LNC=F?M  N?MNM MBIQ H?Q PCLOM FCP?M IH MIG?
MOL@;=?M @IL OJ NI  >;SMF;MNPCMCN?>JL  

 (IBHHS +CF;HI  'H@?=N?> <ON $??FCHA $CH? 2B? 3HQCNNCHA !ILIH;PCLOM 1JL?;>?LM  ,7 2CG?M 
BNNJMQQQHSNCG?M=IGB?;FNB=ILIH;PCLOM ;MSGJNIG;NC= NL;HMGCMMCIHBNGF F;MN PCMCN?>
JL  

 !ILIH;PCLOM "CM?;M?  !-4'"   1I=C;F "CMN;H=CHA  /O;L;HNCH?  ;H> 'MIF;NCIH  !"! 
'<'/2'(2+':BNNJMQQQ=>=AIP=ILIH;PCLOM H=IPJL?P?HN A?NNCHA MC=EMI=C;F >CMN;H=CHABNGF

 !ILIH;PCLOM "CM?;M?  !-4'"   &IQ NI .LIN?=N 7IOLM?F@  !"!  '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMQQQ=>=AIP=ILIH;PCLOM H=IPJL?P?HN A?NNCHA MC=EJL?P?HNCIHBNGF F;MN PCMCN?> JL  
 


Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 12 of 38

 2B?!"!B;MCMMO?>AOC>;H=?NB;NJ?IJF?MBIOF>MNLC=NFSFCGCNNB?CL=IHN;=NQCNB

INB?LM;H>;PIC>A;NB?LCHACHALIOJMI@GIL?NB;HN?H

 0?=IAHCTCHANB?OLA?HNH??>NIG;H>;N?MI=C;F>CMN;H=CHAMN;N?QC>?NIL?>O=?NB?

MJL?;>I@!-4'" CH+CMMCMMCJJC\M=IGGOHCNC?M IHJLCF  %IP?LHIL0??P?MCMMO?>;

Y1B?FN?L CH .F;=?Z ?R?=ONCP? IL>?L L?KOCLCHA ;FF L?MC>?HNM NI MN;S ;N BIG?  QCNB IHFS FCGCN?>

?R=?JNCIHM@ILY?MM?HNC;FZQILE?LM;H>;=NCPCNC?M

 %IP?LHIL0??P?MMO<M?KO?HNFSCMMO?>;Y1;@?L;N&IG?Z?R?=ONCP?IL>?LIHJLCF

  QBC=BL?F;R?>MIG?I@NB??G?LA?H=SG;H>;N?MCHJF;=?<ONOLA?>L?MC>?HNMNIL?G;CH

;N BIG? 2B? IL>?L ;FFIQ?> =?LN;CH HIH ?MM?HNC;F <OMCH?MM?M NI L?IJ?H QBCF? ;>IJNCHA MNLC=N

JL?=;ONCIH;LSG?;MOL?M CH=FO>CHAMI=C;F>CMN;H=CHA L?AOF;LM;HCN;NCIH OM?I@JLIN?=NCP?A?;L ;H>

L?>O=?> =;J;=CNS  %IP?LHIL 0??P?M ;G?H>?> BCM Y1;@?L ;N &IG?Z IL>?L IH +;S    NI

;ONBILCT?FCGCN?>CH BIOM?>CHCHA;NL?MN;OL;HNM;H><;LM&IQ?P?L B?;FMI;HHIOH=?>B?QIOF>

>?F;S@OLNB?LL? IJ?HCHAM =CNCHA;MJCE?CH=ILIH;PCLOM=;M?M;H>>?;NBM2B?;HHIOH=?G?HN

=;G?;@N?L+CMMCMMCJJCB?;FNBI@@C=C;FML?JILN?>H?QCH@?=NCIHM;H>H?Q>?;NBMIH+;S 



!ILIH;PCLOM"CM?;M?!-4'"  0?MIOL=?M@IL*;LA?#P?HNM;H>+;MM%;NB?LCHAM !"! 
'<'/2'(2+':BNNJMQQQ=>=AIP=ILIH;PCLOM H=IP=IGGOHCNSF;LA? ?P?HNMCH>?RBNGFF;MNPCMCN?>
JL  

"+++CMMCMMCJJC-@@C=?I@NB?%IP?LHIL #R?=ONCP?-L>?L,IJL  '<'/2'(2+':
BNNJMQQQGMMOJ?LPCMILMILAMCN?M>?@;OFN@CF?M#-1N;S;N&IG?J>@

"+++CMMCMMCJJC-@@C=?I@NB?%IP?LHIL #R?=ONCP?-L>?L,IJL  '<'/2'(2+':
BNNJMQQQMIMGMAIP=IHN?HN?R?=ONCP?IL>?LM#R?=ONCP?-L>?LMJ>@

*

"+++CMMCMMCJJC-@@C=?I@NB?%IP?LHIL #R?=ONCP?-L>?L,I+;S  '<'/2'(2+':
BNNJMMIMGMAIP=IHN?HN?R?=ONCP?IL>?LM#R?=ONCP?-L>?LMJ>@

5CFF+;LNCH +CMMCMMCJJC\MAIP?LHIL<;=ENL;=E?>IH?H>CHANB?MN;N?\MFI=E>IQH;@N?LNB?MN;N?
M;QCNM<CAA?MNCH=L?;M?CH=ILIH;PCLOM>?;NBM;H>=;M?M  OMCH?MM'HMC>?L+;S  '<'/2'(2+':
BNNJMQQQ<OMCH?MMCHMC>?L=IGGCMMCMMCJJC AIP?LHIL <;=EM >IQH IH L?IJ?HCHA ;@N?L <CAA?MN
=IPC> MJCE?  


Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 13 of 38

XNB?F;LA?MNMCHAF? >;SCH=L?;M?NII==OLCHNB?MN;N?-H+;S  %IP?LHIL0??P?M

?RN?H>?>BCMY1;@?L;N&IG?ZIL>?LNIL?G;CHCH?@@?=NNBLIOAB+;S 

 -*"&2)*1.(.26.7327

 2B?=ILIH;PCLOMB;MMJL?;>L;JC>FSCHP;LCIOMJLCMIH?HPCLIHG?HNM

 'H +CMMCMMCJJC\M 7;TII !CNS $?>?L;F !ILL?=NCIH;F !IGJF?R   CHG;N?M ;H> 

MN;@@G?G<?LM;L?L?JILN?>NIB;P?N?MN?>JIMCNCP?@IL!-4'" ;MI@+;S ;H>IH?

CHG;N?B;M>C?>

 S +;S     ;N F?;MN   CHG;N?M CH MN;N? ;H> @?>?L;F JLCMIHM B;> N?MN?>

JIMCNCP?@ILNB?CFFH?MM ;J?L=?HNCH=L?;M?@LIGNB?Q??E<?@IL?'HNB?@?>?L;FMSMN?G;FIH? 

  CHG;N?M ;H>  MN;@@ G?G<?LM B;P? =IH@CLG?> JIMCNCP? N?MN L?MOFNM @IL !-4'" 

H;NCIHQC>?I@NBIM? CHG;N?MB;P?>C?>I@!-4'" MSGJNIGM

 2B??RJ?LC?H=?I@INB?LMN;N?MMBIQMNB;NIH=?!-4'" <?ACHMMJL?;>CHAQCNBCH

;JLCMIH CNCMIHFS;G;NN?LI@NCG?OHNCFNB?ION<L?;EMJL?;>ML;JC>FS;H>BOH>L?>M;L?CH@?=N?>

 $IL?R;GJF? CHNB?$?>?L;F!ILL?=NCIH;F!IGJF?RCH-;E>;F? *IOCMC;H; NB?@CLMN

CHG;N? .;NLC=E(IH?M N?MN?>JIMCNCP?+;L=B;H>>C?>IH+;L=BMCH=?NB?H ;NF?;MNM?P?H



*

 "+++CMMCMMCJJC-@@C=?I@NB?%IP?LHIL #R?=ONCP?-L>?L,I+;S  '<'/2'(2+':
BNNJMQQQMIMGMAIP=IHN?HN?R?=ONCP?IL>?LM#R?=ONCP?-L>?LMJ>@

*

  1N;N? <S 1N;N? *IIE ;N !ILIH;PCLOM CH .LCMIHM  2B? +;LMB;FF .LID?=N  '<'/2'(2+ ':
.::69===:.+3'89.'226850+):58-  
'9:':+(?9:':+2551':)5854'</8;9/468/9549 F;MN
PCMCN?>+;S  

 !-4'"  !ILIH;PCLOM !-4'"  !;M?M  $?>?L;F OL?;O I@ .LCMIHM  '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMQQQ<IJAIP=ILIH;PCLOMF;MNPCMCN?>+;S  

 (;H?N0?CNG;H C"53+:./4-95/4-:5>625*+D&.+45854'</8;9":8/1+9'8/954 ,72'+#1
JL     '<'/2'(2+ ': BNNJMQQQHSNCG?M=IGG;A;TCH?I;E>;F? @?>?L;F JLCMIH
=ILIH;PCLOMBNGF;ONBFIACH ?G;CFFIACH?G;CF



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 14 of 38

GIL?CHG;N?MB;P?>C?>I@!-4'"  GIL?NB;H;>>CNCIH;FCHG;N?MB;P?<??HBIMJCN;FCT?> 

;H>;NF?;MNCHG;N?M;H>MN;@@G?G<?LMB;P?N?MN?>JIMCNCP?

 NNB?2?LGCH;F'MF;H>$?>?L;F!ILL?=NCIH;F'HMNCNONCIHCH1;H.?>LI !;FC@ILHC; 

NB?HOG<?LI@=IH@CLG?>=;M?M=FCG<?>NIIH+;S  OJ@LIGNB?=;M?ML?JILN?>CH

GC> JLCF2B?HOG<?LI@CH@?=N?>CHG;N?MHIQ=IHMNCNON?MH?;LFSJ?L=?HNI@1;H.?>LI\M

J?HCN?HNC;LSJIJOF;NCIH

 NNB?$?>?L;F+?>C=;F.LCMIHCH$ILN5ILNB 2?R;M NB?HOG<?LI@=IH@CLG?>=;M?M

DOGJ?>@LIGNI<?NQ??HJLCF ;H>JLCF NB?HOG<?LB;MMCH=?CH=L?;M?>

NICHDOMNIP?LNBL??Q??EM

 'H,ILNB!;LIFCH; ;NNB?,?OM?!ILL?=NCIH;F'HMNCNONCIH NB?HOG<?LI@=IH@CLG?>

=;M?MI@!-4'" Q?HN@LIGNQINICHDOMNNQIQ??EM G?;HCHAGIL?NB;HB;F@I@CNMCHG;N?

JIJOF;NCIHCMHIQ=IH@CLG?>NIB;P?NB?PCLOM



 * !-4'"  !ILIH;PCLOM !-4'"  !;M?M  $?>?L;F OL?;O I@ .LCMIHM  '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMQQQ<IJAIP=ILIH;PCLOMF;MNPCMCN?>+;S  

 !-4'"  !ILIH;PCLOM !-4'"  !;M?M  $?>?L;F OL?;O I@ .LCMIHM  '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMQQQ<IJAIP=ILIH;PCLOMF;MN;==?MM?>+;S  +IL?NB;H2?LGCH;F'MF;H>JLCMIH
CHG;N?M N?MN JIMCNCP? @IL !-4'"   *IHA ?;=B .IMN JL     '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMF<JIMN=IGH?QMN?LGCH;F CMF;H> JLCMIH =ILIH;PCLOM B;F@ 

0C=B;L>5CHNIH !ILIH;PCLOMION<L?;E;N2?LGCH;F'MF;H>JLCMIHQILM?HM>?;NBM;H>CH@?=N?> 
* 2CG?M JL     '<'/2'(2+ ': BNNJMQQQF;NCG?M=IG=;FC@ILHC;MNILS  F;
=ILIH;PCLOM ION<L?;E N?LGCH;F CMF;H> JLCMIH QILM?HM

1=INN%IL>IH %
'9+9+'82? ;'*8;62+49/*+58:&58:.+*/)'28/954 , ! 
'<'/2'(2+':BNNJMQQQH<=>@Q=IGH?QM=ILIH;PCLOM=IPC>  =;M?M KO;>LOJF? NI  ;N @ILN QILNB
@?>?L;F JLCMIH

 !-4'"  !ILIH;PCLOM !-4'"  !;M?M  $?> OL?;O I@ .LCMIHM Y -.Z  '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMQQQ<IJAIP=ILIH;PCLOMF;MNPCMCN?>+;S  

 2?MN.IMCNCP?@IL!-4'" N,!.LCMIH,?;L%IF>M<ILI 557,?QMJL  
BNNJMQQQQQ;SNP=IG N?MN JIMCNCP? @IL =IPC>  ;N H= JLCMIH H?;L AIF>M<ILI


Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 15 of 38

 H>;NNB? ONH?L@?>?L;FJLCMIHCH,ILNB!;LIFCH; CNNIIEIHFS@CP?>;SM@ILNB?

HOG<?LI@=IH@CLG?>!-4'" =;M?MNIMOLA?@LIGMCHAF?>CACNMNIH?;LFS

 N2LIOM>;F?2OLH?L!ILL?=NCIH;F!?HN?LCH&;LNMPCFF? 2?HH?MM?? NB?HOG<?LI@

=IH@CLG?>=;M?MDOGJ?>@LIGMCHAF?>CACNMNI CHG;N?M;H>MN;@@G?G<?LMCHF?MMNB;HIH?

Q??E-P?LB;F@I@NB?JLCMIH\MJIJOF;NCIHCMCH@?=N?>;H>IH?CHG;N?B;M>C?>I@!-4'" 

MSGJNIGM

 2B?D;CFIH0CE?LM'MF;H>CH,?Q7ILE!CNSQ?HN@LIG;MCHAF?=IH@CLG?>=;M?NI

=;M?MCHDOMNIP?LNQIQ??EM

 'H!IIE!IOHNS 'FFCHICM NB?HOG<?LI@JIMCNCP?=;M?MCHNB?=IOHNSD;CFLIM?@LIG

NICHDOMNNQIQ??EM

 NIH?JICHN ;HION<L?;E;N+;LCIH!ILL?=NCIH;F'HMNCNONCIHCH-BCIQ;MNB?F;LA?MN

EHIQH MIOL=? I@ =ILIH;PCLOM CH@?=NCIHM CH NB? 3HCN?> 1N;N?M -P?L  I@ NB? CH>CPC>O;FM



 !-4'"  =;M?M ;N @?>?L;F JLCMIH CH ONH?L DOGJ @LIG  NI  CH @CP? >;SM  ! 1  JL  
  '<'/2'(2+ ': BNNJMQQQ=<M=IGH?QMFI=;F H?QM=IPC>  =;M?M ;N @?>?L;F JLCMIH CH
<ONH?L DOGJ @LIG  NI  CH @CP? >;SM

 2"-! 'HG;N?M 4-"'  2?MNCHA  2?HH?MM?? "?J;LNG?HN I@ !ILL?=NCIHM  '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMQQQNHAIP=IHN?HN>;GNH=ILL?=NCIH>I=OG?HNM2"-!'HG;N?M!-4'"J>@ F;MN PCMN?>
+;S     !IL?!CPC= 0?F?;M?M !-4'"  2?MNCHA 0?MOFNM @IL 2LIOM>;F? 2OLH?L !ILL?=NCIH;F
!?HN?L  !IL?!CPC=  '<'/2'(2+ ': BNNJMQQQ=IL?=CPC==IG=IL?=CPC= L?F?;M?M =IPC>  N?MNCHA
L?MOFNM @IL NLIOM>;F? NOLH?L =ILL?=NCIH;F =?HN?LF;MNPCMCN?>+;S  

*F;MNPCMCN?>+;S  

 !-4'"  'H@?=NCIH 2L;=ECHA CH ,7! (;CFM  2B? *?A;F C> 1I=C?NS  '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMF?A;F;C>HS=ILA=IPC>  CH@?=NCIH NL;=ECHA CH HS= D;CFMF;MNPCMCN?>JL  

 2SF?L )?H>;FF  A&+D8+ ': ='8 =/:. 45 =+'6549B 5854'</8;9 )'9+9 9;8-+ /49/*+ ./)'-5D9
551 5;4:? 0'/2  ! 1 ,#51 JL     ;P;CF;<F? ;N BNNJMQQQ=<MH?QM=IGH?QM=BC=;AI
=IIE =IOHNS D;CF =ILIH;PCLOM FC@? CHMC>? =IPC>  =;M?M

0C=E0ID;M;H>+C=B;?F!IIJ?L %?ILAC; 2?HH?MM??;H>1IONB!;LIFCH;1;S OMCH?MM?M!;H0?IJ?H
1IIH ,7 2'+#1JL  '<'/2'(2+':BNNJMQQQHSNCG?M=IGOM=ILIH;PCLOM OM
BIN MJINM L?IJ?HCHABNGF


Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 16 of 38

CH=;L=?L;N?>;N+;LCIH!'N?MN?>JIMCNCP?XCHINB?LQIL>M IP?L I@NB? CHG;N?M2B;N

=IOHNSCMHIQ?RJ?LC?H=CHA;<IP?;P?L;A?L;N?MI@=IGGOHCNSMJL?;>IONMC>?NB?JLCMIH

 'HLE;HM;M ;HION<L?;E;NNB?"?J;LNG?HNI@!ILL?=NCIHM\!OGGCHM3HCNMJL?;>

L;JC>FS2B?ION<L?;ECM<?FC?P?>NIB;P?MN;LN?>;@N?L;MCHAF?MN;@@G?G<?LN?MN?>JIMCNCP?CHF;N?

+;L=B S JLCF   NB? @;=CFCNS\M @CLMN CHG;N? N?MN?> JIMCNCP? 5CNBCH ; @?Q >;SM  CN Q;M

=IH@CLG?>NB;NIONI@NB?INB?LCHG;N?MBIOM?>CHNB;NCHG;N?\M<;LL;=EMQ?L?;FMICH@?=N?>

SJLCF NB?@;=CFCNSB;>IP?L=IH@CLG?>CH@?=NCIHM QBC=B;==IOHN?>@ILH?;LFSIH? NBCL>

I@;FF=IH@CLG?>=;M?MCHNB??HNCL?MN;N?

 -**6.397&61 -&8&"98'6*&/.2&.77.77.44.6.732#390)&97*

 H ION<L?;E CH +CMMCMMCJJC\M MN;N? JLCMIHM  QB?L? J?IJF? ;L? OH;<F? NI JL;=NC=?

MI=C;F>CMN;H=CHA;H>PCACF;HNBSAC?H? QIOF><?MCGCF;LFS>?P;MN;NCHA;H>OH=IHNLIFF;<F?

 !-4'"  CM MJL?;>CHA L;JC>FS ;=LIMM JLCMIH @;=CFCNC?M <?=;OM? CN CM ?RNL?G?FS

>C@@C=OFN NI G;CHN;CH NB? MI=C;F >CMN;H=CHA NB;N CM L?KOCL?> NI GCNCA;N? CN .LCMIH @;=CFCNC?M ;L?

?HPCLIHG?HNMQB?L?J?IJF?<S>?@CHCNCIHFCP?CH=FIM?KO;LN?LM



1;L;B4IFJ?HB?CH '8/5468/954)5854'</8;95;:(8+'19++6/4-/4:52'8-+8)533;4/:? +0'-,
120JL  BNNJMQQQG;LCIHMN;L=IGMNILSH?QMFI=;FG;LCIH JLCMIH IBCI
=ILIH;PCLOM ION<L?;E M??JCHA CHNI F;LA?L =IGGOHCNS

*

(IBH+ILCNT 81'49'968/954,'83=581+8.'9)5</*
35,,/)/'29'?9 LE"?GI=L;N%;T?NN? JL
  BNNJMQQQ;LE;HM;MIHFCH?=IGH?QM;JLJLCMIH @;LG QILE?L B;M =IPC>  I@@C=C; 

+;R L;HNF?S 5854'</8;9;6*':+/-0;36/4;33/4968/954)'9+9'-5'25,(+-/44/4-'8+:;84
:5=581'? LE2CG?M JLCF  BNNJM;LENCG?M=IG;LE;HM;M <FIA=ILIH;PCLOM
OJ>;N? <CA DOGJ CH =OGGCHM JLCMIH =;M?M ; AI;F I@ <?ACHHCHA ; L?NOLH NI QILE G;S 

*

+?AB;H0IIM 4+81'49'98/954'1+$62359:'#./8*5,":':+D95854'</8;9'9+9 
,#515##)JL  '<'/2'(2+':BNNJMQQQH?QMQ??E=IGIH? ;LE;HM;M JLCMIH G;E?M ;FGIMN
NBCL> MN;N?M =ILIH;PCLOM =;M?M 



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 17 of 38

 #P?HCMIF;NCIHCHMCHAF?=?FFM@ILNBIM?QBIB;P?<??H=IH@CLG?>NIB;P?!-4'"

>I?MHIN?FCGCH;N?NB?LCMEI@=IHN;ACIH>O?NIMB;L?>P?HNCF;NCIHMSMN?GM;H>NB?H?=?MMCNSI@

J?LMIH;F=IHN;=NCHJL?J;LCHA;H>M?LPCHAG?;FM

 2B?LCMEI@=IHNL;=NCHA;HCH@?=NCIOM>CM?;M?CM;FMIBCAB?LCH=ILL?=NCIH;F@;=CFCNC?M

<?=;OM?NB?@;=CFCNC?M;L?HINM;HCN;LS?HPCLIHG?HNM.?IJF?MB;L?NICF?NM MCHEM ;H>MBIQ?LM ;H>

I@N?HB;P?FCGCN?>;==?MMNIMI;J B;H>M;HCNCT?L BINQ;N?L ;H>INB?LH?=?MM;LSBSAC?H?CN?GM

1OL@;=?M;L?CH@L?KO?HNFSQ;MB?> C@;N;FF ;H>=F?;HCHAMOJJFC?M;L?CHMBILNMOJJFS

 +IL?IP?L G;HS=ILL?=NCIH;F@;=CFCNC?MF;=ENB?;>?KO;N?G?>C=;F=;L?CH@L;MNLO=NOL?

NI;>>L?MMNB?MJL?;>I@CH@?=NCIOM>CM?;M?FCE?!-4'" ;H>NL?;NBCAB LCMEJ?IJF?CH=OMNI>S

.LCMIHB?;FNBOHCNM;L?I@N?HHIN?KOCJJ?>QCNBMO@@C=C?HNJ?LMIH;FJLIN?=NCP??KOCJG?HN@ILJ?IJF?

QBI;L?CH=;L=?L;N?>;H>=;L?ACPCHAMN;@@ CH=L?;MCHALCMEMI@;QC>?MJL?;>ION<L?;E+IMNJLCMIH

B?;FNB @;=CFCNC?M B;P? ?RNL?G?FS FCGCN?> ;==?MM NI ?G?LA?H=S G?>C=;F ?KOCJG?HN @IL J;NC?HNM CH

L?MJCL;NILS>CMNL?MM MO=B;MIRSA?HN;HEM

 $ILNB?M?L?;MIHM ;GIHAINB?LM ?RJ?LNMB;P?Q;LH?>NB;NQC>?MJL?;>=IGGOHCNS

NL;HMGCMMCIHI@!-4'" QCNBCH;JLCMIHCMFCE?FSNI=;OM?;>CMJLIJILNCIH;N?FSBCABGILN;FCNS

L;N?



*

*V

*

Y!ILL?=NCIH;F$;=CFCNC?M'H2B?1B;>IQ-@!-4'" 3HCKO?!B;FF?HA?MH>.LIJIM?>1IFONCIHM 
&?;FNB @@;CLM FIA +;L=B     '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMQQQB?;FNB;@@;CLMILA>IB<FIA@OFF

 Y!-4'"  CH !ILL?=NCIH;F 1?NNCHAM 3HCKO? !B;FF?HA?M ;H> .LIJIM?> 0?MJIHM?MZ +;L=B  
 '<'/2'(2+':BNNJM;G?H>OMQJ =IHN?HNOJFI;>M!-4'" CH !ILL?=NCIHM !B;FF?HA?M ;H>
1IFONCIHM J>@


Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 18 of 38

 .LCMIHM ;H> D;CFM I@N?H L?FS IH IONMC>? =IGGOHCNS BIMJCN;FM NI JLIPC>? GIL?

;>P;H=?>;H>CHN?HMCP?G?>C=;F=;L?"OLCHA;H?JC>?GC= NBCMQCFFFCE?FSHIN<?JIMMC<F? ;MNBIM?

IONMC>?@;=CFCNC?M<?=IG?;NILIP?L=;J;=CNSNB?GM?FP?M

 %CP?HNBCML?;FCNS MCAHC@C=;HNFSL?>O=CHANB?HOG<?LI@J?IJF?CH=;L=?L;N?>CMNB?

IHFSQ;SNIJL?P?HN>?P;MN;NCHAFIMM?MI@FC@?CHNB?JLCMIHMSMN?G

 +;HS DO>A?M B;P? L?=IAHCT?> NB? OLA?HN H??> NI L?F?;M? JLCMIH?LM <?=;OM?

=IHNCHO?>CH=;L=?L;NCIHLCMEM;>?;NBM?HN?H=?1?P?L;FL?=?HN@?>?L;F=IOLNLOFCHAMIL>?LCHAL?F?;M?

B;P??RJF;CH?>NB?B?;FNBLCMEMXNINBIM?QBI;L?>?N;CH?> MN;@@ ;H>NB?IONMC>?=IGGOHCNS;N

F;LA?X=L?;N?><SF;LA?>?N;CH??JIJOF;NCIHM

 0?=IAHCTCHA NB? OLA?H=S I@ NBCM LCME  G;HS DO>A?M  JLIM?=ONILM ;H> =ILL?=NCIH;F

;ONBILCNC?M;=LIMMNB?=IOHNLSB;P?;LL;HA?>L?F?;M?MNIJLIN?=NCH>CPC>O;FM;H>NB?JO<FC=B?;FNB

-H+;L=B NNILH?S%?H?L;F ;LLCMMO?>;>CL?=NCP?NINB? I;L>I@.LCMIHMOLACHAL?>O=NCIH

I@NB?JLCMIHJIJOF;NCIHNBLIOABNB?OM?I@BIG?=IH@CH?G?HN



1?? ?A /3+4+@<&52, ,I  +*5"+;MM+;L  IL>?LCHAL?F?;M?I@
>?N;CH?>CGGCAL;HNCHNB?GC>MNI@NB?!-4'" J;H>?GC=;H>HINCHANB;NY<?CHACH;D;CF?HB;H=?M
LCMEZ ;H> NB;N CH D;CF YMI=C;F >CMN;H=CHA CM >C@@C=OFN IL CGJIMMC<F?Z  '9'41 < +)1+8  ,I  =P
 2 1",7 +;L     IL>?LCHA NB? L?F?;M? I@ N?H J?IJF? @LIG NBL?? CGGCAL;NCIH
>?N?HNCIH@;=CFCNC?MCH,?Q(?LM?S<?=;OM?Y=IH@CHCHAPOFH?L;<F?CH>CPC>O;FMQCNBION?H@IL=?G?HN
I@;JJLIJLC;N?MI=C;F>CMN;H=CHA;H>QCNBIONMJ?=C@C=G?;MOL?MNIJLIN?=NNB?CL>?FC=;N?B?;FNB[JIM?8M9
;HOHL?;MIH;<F?LCMEI@M?LCIOM>;G;A?NI8NB?CL9@ONOL?B?;FNB\Z CHN?LH;F=CN;NCIHIGCNN?> #.'11+8<
522 ,I =P  (#( 5* ;N
+".;+;L  IL>?LCHAL?F?;M?I@
J?IJF?@LIGNBL??CGGCAL;NCIH>?N?HNCIH@;=CFCNC?MCH.?HHMSFP;HC;<?=;OM?YJL?P?HN;NCP?G?;MOL?MZ
;A;CHMNNB?YAL;P?=IHM?KO?H=?MZI@!-4'" =;HHIN<?JL;=NC=?>CHYNCABNFS=IH@CH?> OHBSAC?HC=
MJ;=?MZ 8'/.':<&52, ,I#"!4 2(&)1R !"!;F+;L  IL>?LCHAL?F?;M?
I@CH>CPC>O;F@LIGCGGCAL;NCIH>?N?HNCIH@;=CFCNS<?=;OM?!-4'" Y=;HMJL?;>OH=IHNLIFF;<FSQCNB
>?P;MN;NCHAL?MOFNMCH;=LIQ>?> =FIM?>@;=CFCNSZ $4/:+*":':+9<!'359 ,I !0 $"1 
5* ;N
"+;MM+;L  MN;NCHANB;NYCNCMHINJIMMC<F?@IL;G?>C=;FFS
POFH?L;<F?CHG;N?NICMIF;N?BCGM?F@CHNBCMCHMNCNONCIH;FM?NNCHA;ML?=IGG?H>?><SNB?!"! ;H>
AO;L>M;H>H?QFS;LL?MN?>CH>CPC>O;FMGOMN?HN?LNB?@;=CFCNSIH;>;CFS<;MCMZ 

2B?!ILIH;PCLOM0?MJIHM?1JINFCABNIH1N;N?;H>*I=;F%IP?LHG?HNM 2B?JJ?;F ;P;CF;<F?;N
BNNJMNB?;JJ?;FILAJIFCNC=;F L?JILN=ILIH;PCLOM L?MJIHM? MN;N? FI=;FF;MNPCMCN?>JL  

-@@C=?I@NB?NNILH?S%?H?L;F +?GIL;H>OG@IL"CL?=NILI@ OL?;O.LCMIHML?.LCILCNCT;NCIH
I@&IG?!IH@CH?G?HNMJJLIJLC;N?CH0?MJIHM?NI!-4'" .;H>?GC=+;L  '<'/2'(2+
':BNNJMQQQJIFCNC=I=IG@C>  >; ;> @>;


Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 19 of 38

 .LIM?=ONILM@LIG;LIOH>NB?=IOHNLS CH=FO>CHANBL??@LIG+CMMCMMCJJC B;P?CMMO?>

;MN;N?G?HNQ;LHCHANB;N;HYION<L?;EI@NB?=ILIH;PCLOMCH=OMNI>C;F@;=CFCNC?MQIOF>HINIHFS

GIP?@;MN CNQIOF>JIN?HNC;FFS<?=;N;MNLIJBC=Z2B?MN;N?G?HNL?=IAHCT?MNB;NYD;CFM;H>JLCMIHM

BIOM? >CMJLIJILNCIH;N?FS F;LA? HOG<?LM I@ J?IJF? QCNB =BLIHC= CFFH?MM?M ;H> =IGJF?R G?>C=;F

H??>MNB;NG;HS@;=CFCNC?M;L?;FL?;>SCFF ?KOCJJ?>NINL?;NZ2B?MN;N?G?HN;FMIL?=IAHCT?MNB;N

Y>L;G;NC=;FFS L?>O=8CHA9 NB? HOG<?L I@ CH=;L=?L;N?> CH>CPC>O;FMZ CM H?=?MM;LS NI ;PIC> MO=B

=IHM?KO?H=?MH>NB?&;LLCMIH!IOHNS +CMMCMMCJJC1B?LC@@2LIS.?N?LMIHB;ML?=IAHCT?>NB?

LCMENB;N=ILIH;PCLOMJIM?MNICH=;L=?L;N?>J?IJF? HINCHANB;NIH=?=ILIH;PCLOMCMCHNLI>O=?>CH;

D;CF YCHG;N?M AO;L>M;H>=ILL?=NCIHMI@@C=?LM ?P?LS<I>SZQCFF<??RJIM?>;H>NB;NYNL;A?>SZQCFF

L?MOFN

 #P?HJLCILNINB?!-4'" =LCMCM NB?+CMMCMMCJJCJLCMIHMSMN?GB;><??HOH>?L

@?>?L;F CHP?MNCA;NCIH <S NB? "?J;LNG?HN I@ (OMNC=? 2B? MSMN?G CM HINILCIOMFS IP?L=LIQ>?> 

OH>?LMN;@@?> ;H>CH;MN;N?I@>CML?J;CL

 -H(;HO;LS  @IFFIQCHAION<L?;EMI@PCIF?H=?QCNBCHNB?JLCMIHMSMN?G;H>

@CP?L?JILN?>>?;NBM F?;>?LMQCNBCHNB?MN;N?=;FF?>OJIHNB?"?J;LNG?HNI@(OMNC=?!CPCF0CABNM



 (ICHN 1N;N?G?HN @LIG #F?=N?> .LIM?=ONILM IH !-4'"  ;H> >>L?MMCHA NB? 0CABNM ;H> ,??>M
I@ 2BIM? CH !OMNI>S  ;N  +;L     '<'/2'(2+ ': BNNJM@;CL;H>DOMNJLIM?=ONCIHILAQJ
=IHN?HNOJFI;>M!ILIH;PCLOM 1CAH -H *?NN?LJ>@

*;N 

*;N

 +;LA;L?N ;E?L   5'9: 0'/29 8+2+'9+ 953+ /43':+9 *;8/4- :.+ )5854'</8;9 5;:(8+'1 +8+D9
=.?  13, &#0*" JL     '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMQQQMOHB?L;F>=IGH?QMFI=;F;LNC=F?BNGF

0C=E0ID;M ,:+8'5@+4+':.9;9:/)++6:4<+9:/-':+9/99/99/66/8/9549 ,72'+#1$?<
  '<'/2'(2+':BNNJMQQQHSNCG?M=IGOMJ;L=BG;H GCMMCMMCJJC JLCMIHMBNGF

*


Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 20 of 38

"CPCMCIH NI CHP?MNCA;N? =IH>CNCIHM I@ =IH@CH?G?HN QCNBCH +"-! 2B? F?NN?L C>?HNC@C?> YM?P?L?

OH>?LMN;@@CHA;H>BILLC@C==IH>CNCIHMZ;MNB?<;MCM@ILNB?CHP?MNCA;NCIH

 2B?"?J;LNG?HNI@(OMNC=?CHP?MNCA;NCIH ;HHIOH=?>$?<LO;LS  @I=OM?MIH

YQB?NB?LNB?"?J;LNG?HNI@!ILL?=NCIHM;>?KO;N?FSJLIN?=NMJLCMIH?LM@LIGJBSMC=;FB;LGZ;N@IOL

I@+CMMCMMCJJC\MJLCMIHM CH=FO>CHA!+!$;H>1+!'

 $LIG  NI   MN;N? MJ?H>CHA IH +CMMCMMCJJC\M =ILL?=NCIH;F @;=CFCNC?M B;M

>?=FCH?><SIP?LGCFFCIH

 2B?HOG<?LI@>?;NBMCHNB?+CMMCMMCJJCJLCMIHMSMN?GB;MMN?;>CFSCH=L?;M?>@LIG

NB?GC> M QCNB>?;NBMCH$7;H>>?;NBMCH$7

 MI@JLCF  ;NF?;MNCH=;L=?L;N?>J?LMIHMCHNB?MN;N?JLCMIHMSMN?G

B;P?>C?>NBCMS?;L

 2B?@ILG?L!IGGCMMCIH?LI@+"-!L?=IAHCT?>CH(;HO;LSI@NB;N;YMN;@@CHA

=LCMCMZ=L?;N?>;YJL?MMOL?=IIE?LNSJ?MCNO;NCIHZ;N.;L=BG;H !+!$ ;H>1+!'+"-!J;SM

NB?FIQ?MNM;F;LC?M@IL=ILL?=NCIH;FMN;@@I@;HSMN;N?CHNB?=IOHNLS'HJLCF NB?!CPCF0CABNM

"CPCMCIHI@NB?3HCN?>1N;N?M"?J;LNG?HNI@(OMNC=?CMMO?>;L?JILNCHQBC=BCN=CN?>NB?F;<;G;

"?J;LNG?HNI@!ILL?=NCIHMY"-!Z @ILY?AL?ACIOMZ;H>Y>;HA?LIOMZMSMN?GQC>?OH>?LMN;@@CHA



*?NN?L@LIG+CMMCMMCJJC=IGGOHCNSF?;>?LMNI#LC=1"L?C<;H> MMCMN;HNNNILH?S%?H?L;F !CPCF
0CABNM"CPCMCIH 31"?J\NI@(OMNC=? 8+!+7;+9:,5833+*/':+!4<+9:/-':/54/4:554*/:/5495,
54,/4+3+4: /4 :.+ /99/99/66/ +6'8:3+4: 5, 588+):/549  ;N  (;H     '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMCHNHSN=IG>;N;>I=OG?HNB?FJ?L L?KO?MN @IL =CPCF LCABNM
CHP?M;==>?<IJNCGCT?>@OFFJ>@Y!0'.*?NN?LZ 

(OMNC=?"?J;LNG?HNHHIOH=?M'HP?MNCA;NCIHCHNI!IH>CNCIHMCH$IOL+CMMCMMCJJC.LCMIHM 31"?J\N
I@(OMNC=?$?<  '<'/2'(2+':BNNJMQQQDOMNC=?AIPIJ;JLDOMNC=? >?J;LNG?HN ;HHIOH=?M
CHP?MNCA;NCIH =IH>CNCIHM @IOL GCMMCMMCJJC JLCMIHM

!0'.*?NN?L ;N

!0'.*?NN?L ;N

/99/99/66/8/954"?9:+3')+94<+9:/-':/54 ,.0

!0'.*?NN?L ;N

!0'.*?NN?L ;N


Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 21 of 38

NB;N =IHNLC<ON?> NI FCE?FS PCIF;NCIHM I@ NB? #CABNB G?H>G?HN LCABNM I@ F;<;G; JLCMIH?LM

"-!G;CHN;CHM;MN;@@CHAL;NCII@JLCMIH?LMJ?L=ILL?=NCIH;FI@@C=?LNNB??H>I@-=NI<?L

  ?;=B +"-! MN;N? LOH @;=CFCNS B;> L;NCIM QILM? NB;H F;<;G;\M  JLCMIH?LM J?L

=ILL?=NCIH;F I@@C=?L ;N .;L=BG;H  JLCMIH?LM J?L =ILL?=NCIH;F I@@C=?L ;N !+!$ ;H> ;H

CH=L?>C<F?JLCMIH?LMJ?L=ILL?=NCIH;FI@@C=?L;N1+!' QBC=B@ILG?L+"-!!IGGCMMCIH?L

0I<?LN*(IBHMIH=;FF?>YOH=IHM=CIH;<F?Z;H>OHM;@?@ILG?L+"-!!IGGCMMCIH?LB;MF?>

NB?L;NCII@=ILL?=NCIH;FI@@C=?LMNICH=;L=?L;N?>J?LMIHMCHNB?MN;N?YOH=IHM=CIH;<F?Z

 O>CNM;NGOFNCJF?+"-!@;=CFCNC?MB;P?MN;N?>NB;N>O?NIOH>?LMN;@@CHA +"-!

@;CFMNIJ?L@ILGNB?GIMN<;MC=IJ?L;NCIHML?KOCL?>NILOHJLCMIHM.LCMIH?L=IOHNM @IL?R;GJF? 

;L?J?L@ILG?>CH=ILL?=NFS;H>CH=IHMCMN?HNFS ;H>A;HA=IHNLIFCMJL?P;F?HN;=LIMM@;=CFCNC?M

 'HMOG +"-!@;=CFCNC?M;L?'28+'*?CH;MN;N?I@=LCMCM-P?L=LIQ>?>;H>F;=ECHA

NB?G?;HMNIMQC@NFSL?MJIH>NIG;HSG?>C=;F?G?LA?H=C?MOH>?LHILG;F=CL=OGMN;H=?M +"-!

CMCH;J;LNC=OF;LFS>C@@C=OFNJIMCNCIHNI;>>L?MMNB?AL;P?;H>CGGCH?HN=B;FF?HA?MJIM?><SNB?

!-4'" ION<L?;E

" -*&2,*6397&2)!20&;+900<*+.(.*28140*1*28&8.323+"&2&,*1*28
6383(307&8&2)

 "?@?H>;HNM B;P? @;CF?> NI N;E? L?;MIH;<F? MN?JM ;N !+!$ ;H> 1+!' NI JLIN?=N

.F;CHNC@@M;H>NBIM?QBIM?MCGCF;LFS@LIGNL;HMGCMMCIHI@!-4'" "?@?H>;HNMEHIQ;<ION;H>



 'HP?MNCA;NCIH I@ F;<;G;\M 1N;N? .LCMIHM @IL +?H W  31 "?J\N I@ (OMNC=? JL    
'<'/2'(2+':BNNJMQQQDOMNC=?AIP=LN=;M? >I=OG?HN@CF?>IQHFI;>

 (?LLS +CN=B?FF  4CIF?HN  -HAICHA &?FF +CMMCMMCJJC .LCMIHM +;S ? 5ILM? NB;H F;<;G;M 5CFF
"-( 1N?J CH  !*0'-, *#"%#0 OA     '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMQQQ=F;LCIHF?>A?L=IGMNILSH?QMGCMMCMMCJJC JLCMIHM =IH>CNCIHM QILM? NB;H
;F;<;G; >ID PCIF?H=? =LO?F OHOMO;F JOHCMBG?HN

 "++ ";CFS 'HG;N? .IJOF;NCIH W -=NI<?L   +CMM "?J\N I@ !ILLM ,IP     '<'/2'(2+ ':
BNNJMQQQG>I=GMAIP>GCH $CH;H=?"I=OG?HNMHHO;F0?JILNJ>@

!0'.*?NN?L ;N

!0'.*?NN?L ;N 



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 22 of 38

B;P?>CML?A;L>?>NB?I<PCIOMLCMEMNI.F;CHNC@@M\M;@?NS"?@?H>;HNMB;P?FCE?QCM?@;CF?>NIG;E?

L?;MIH;<F?GI>C@C=;NCIHMNINB?CLJLIAL;GM;H>M?LPC=?MNIJLIN?=NCH>CPC>O;FMQBIMO@@?L@LIG

>CM;<CFCNC?M;H>;L? ;M;L?MOFN J;LNC=OF;LFSPOFH?L;<F?NIM?LCIOMCFFH?MM;H>>?;NBL?MOFNCHA@LIG

!-4'"  CH@?=NCIH "?@?H>;HNM ;=NCIHM ;H> CH;=NCIHM  IONFCH?> <?FIQ  B;P? JON .F;CHNC@@M

MCGCF;LFSMCNO;N?>L?MC>?HNMCHJ?LCF

 !+!$ CM NB? MN;N? I@ +CMMCMMCJJC\M F;LA?MN JLCMIH  BIF>CHA ;JJLIRCG;N?FS  

QIG?H;H>G?H1+!'CMNB?M?=IH> F;LA?MNJLCMIH BIF>CHA;JJLIRCG;N?FS G?H+"-!

=OLL?HNFSB;M;JJLIRCG;N?FS G?H;H>QIG?HCH=OMNI>S

 +IMNI@NB?,;G?>.F;CHNC@@M;L?BIOM?>CHYIJ?H<;SZOHCNM;N!+!$;H>1+!' 

QBC=BA?H?L;FFSBIF>ILGIL?CH>CPC>O;FMCHLIQMI@<OHE<?>MMJ;=?>;JJLIRCG;N?FS@IOL@??N

;J;LN2B?INB?L,;G?>.F;CHNC@@M;L?BIOM?>CH=?FFM>?MCAH?>NIBIF>NQIJ?IJF?

 'NCMHINJIMMC<F?NIMN;SMCR@??N;J;LN@LIGINB?LM;N!+!$;H>1+!''HNB?IJ?H

<;SOHCNM NB?L?CMMCGJFSHIN?HIOABMJ;=?FMI NB?L?CM@IINNL;@@C=IH;HIHAICHA<;MCM<?NQ??H

<OHEM ;H>L?MC>?HNM;L?QCNBCHCH=B?MIL;=IOJF?I@@??NI@?;=BINB?L>;S;H>HCABN'H=?FF?>

OHCNM  =?FFG;N?M =;HHIN G;CHN;CH MCR @??N I@ >CMN;H=? <?NQ??H IH? ;HINB?L <?=;OM? I@ NB? =?FFM\

>CG?HMCIHM;H>>?MCAH ;H>NB?=IGGIH;L?;M;L?=IGJL?MM?>

 +IMNI@NB?MJ;=?CHIJ?H<;SBIOMCHAOHCNM;N!+!$;H>1+!'CMN;E?HOJ<S

L;=EM I@ <OHE <?>M ;H> NB? H;LLIQ MJ;=?M <?NQ??H NB?G 'N CM L?MC>?HNM\ FCPCHA MJ;=? +IMN

L?MC>?HNM?;N MF??J ;H>MI=C;FCT?@LIGNB?M?FCPCHA;L?;M0?MC>?HNM?R=B;HA?JLIJ?LNS J;J?LM 

;H>@II>IH;H><?NQ??HNB?L;=EM

 2B? =IGGIH ;L?; I@ IJ?H <;S OHCNM ;L? =IGJ;L;NCP?FS MG;FF !IGGIH ;L?;M CH

OHCNMBIF>CHAILGIL?J?IJF?A?H?L;FFS=IHMCMNI@@IOLILMCRMG;FFN;<F?MQCNB@IOL;NN;=B?>

MNIIFMJ?LN;<F?5B?L?NB?N;<F?M?H> NB?L;=EMI@<OHE<?>M<?ACH



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 23 of 38

 1IG?,;G?>.F;CHNC@@MFCP?CHOHCNMNB;N;L?BIG?NI;F;LA?JIJOF;NCIHMI@?F>?LFS

;H>=BLIHC==;L?G?>C=;FJ;NC?HNM2B?;JJLIRCG;N?FSL?MC>?HNMCHNB?M?OHCNMMJ?H>GIMNI@

NB?CLNCG?CH;H>;GIHALIQMI@<OHE<?>MMJ;=?>;JJLIRCG;N?FS@IOL@??N;J;LN

 &IOMCHA OHCNM ;N !+!$ ;H> 1+!' ;L? >?MCAH?> NI <? MOJ?LPCM?> <S GOFNCJF?

AO;L>M

 !+!$;H>1+!'>IHIN;FQ;SMB;P?AO;L>MMOJ?LPCMCHABIOMCHAOHCNM5B?HNB?S

>I  IH? AO;L> CM I@N?H MJFCN <?NQ??H NQI M?J;L;N? BIOMCHA OHCNM 1IG?NCG?M IH? AO;L> CM MJFCN

<?NQ??H @IOL BIOMCHA OHCNM ;H> NQI M?J;L;N? <OCF>CHAM 2BCM G?;HM  NI  J?IJF? ;L?

OHMOJ?LPCM?>;NIH?NCG?QB?HNB;NIH?AO;L>CMCHNL;HMCNILN?GJIL;LCFSOH;P;CF;<F?

 5B?HHIAO;L>CMJL?M?HN NB?L?CMHI;FN?LH;N?G?;HM<SQBC=B;L?MC>?HN=;H;==?MM

G?>C=;F;MM?MMG?HNILCHN?LP?HNCIH

 N <INB !+!$ ;H> 1+!'  J?IJF? B;P? <??H CH H??> I@ G?>C=;F ;NN?HNCIH ;H>

OH;<F? NI I<N;CH CN <?=;OM? MN;@@ Q;M OH;P;CF;<F? IL OHL?MJIHMCP? $IL ?R;GJF?  IH? ,;G?>

.F;CHNC@@;N!+!$B;MFC@? NBL?;N?HCHA;MNBG;;NN;=EM+?>C=;FMN;@@B;P?;>PCM?>NB;NB?>CL?=NFS

L?JILNNINB?CH@CLG;LSQB?HB?@??FM;H;NN;=E=IGCHAIH&?B;M?RJ?LC?H=?>NB?M?>?<CFCN;NCHA

;NN;=EM QB?H HI MN;@@ G?G<?L Q;M JL?M?HN NI B?FJ BCG NI PCMCN G?>C=;F MN;@@ HINB?L ,;G?>

.F;CHNC@@;N!+!$Q;MJL?M?HNQB?H;JL?AH;HNQIG;H\MQ;N?L<LIE?CHB?LOHCN;H>HIAO;L>

Q;MJL?M?HNNI;FFIQB?L;==?MMNIG?>C=;FMN;@@

 YMMIIH;M;HCH>CPC>O;F>?P?FIJMMSGJNIGMI@!-4'"  Z"?@?H>;HNMMBIOF>

?HMOL? NB;N B? IL MB? YQ?;L8M9 ; @;=? G;MEZ ;H> CM Y/33+*/':+2? JF;=?> OH>?L G?>C=;F

CMIF;NCIH89Z'GG?>C;N?CHN?LP?HNCIHI@NBCMNSJ?>?=L?;M?MNB?JIMMC<CFCNSNB;N;J?LMIHQCNBNB?

PCLOMQCFFNL;HMGCNCNNIINB?LMIHNB?JLCMIHM\=LIQ>?>OHCNM



 4:+8/3;/*'4)+54'4'-+3+4:5,5854'</8;9/9+'9+
%
/4588+):/54'2'4*
+:+4:/54 ')/2/:/+9 !NLM @IL "CM?;M? !IHNLIF  .L?P '8   !"! %OC>;H=?  '<'/2'(2+ ':


Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 24 of 38

 N1+!' HIN;FFJ?IJF?QCNBMSGJNIGMI@!-4'" B;P?<??HCMIF;N?> ;H>;N

!+!$ ;H> 1+!'  JLIFIHA?> MN;@@ ;<M?H=?M @LIG BIOMCHA OHCNM G;E?M CGG?>C;N? CHN?LP?HNCIH

CGJIMMC<F? $IL ?R;GJF?  ;N 1+!'  IH? ,;G?> .F;CHNC@@ L?JILN?> MSGJNIGM =IHMCMN?HN QCNB

!-4'" NI@;=CFCNSMN;@@;@?P?L P?LS<;>=IOAB <I>S;=B?M ;H>J?LMCMN?HNL?MJCL;NILS>CMNL?MM

&?MO<GCNN?>;MC=E=;FFMFCJNI<?M??H ;H>CNNIIE>;SMNI<?;HMQ?L?> >OLCHAQBC=BNCG?B?

MN;S?>IHBCMOHCNI@G?HFCPCHACHLIQMI@<OHE<?>M;JJLIRCG;N?FS@IOL@??N;J;LN&?Q;M

H?P?LN?MN?>@ILNB?@FOIL@IL=ILIH;PCLOM0?JILN?>FS NB?CFFH?MMB?B;>KOC=EFSMJL?;>NIINB?LM

CHBCMOHCN1SMN?GQC>? +"-!B;MN?MN?>F?MMNB;HIH?B;F@I@IH?J?L=?HNI@CNMJIJOF;NCIH@IL

!-4'" XIHFS;@?Q>IT?HI@NB?IP?L CH>CPC>O;FMCNBIF>MCH=OMNI>S

 2I GCHCG;FFS =IGJFS QCNB NB? =LCNC=;F !"! JLIPCMCIH L?KOCLCHA CGG?>C;N?

CMIF;NCIH I@ MSGJNIG;NC= CH>CPC>O;FM  "?@?H>;HNM GOMN CGJF?G?HN ; L?FC;<F? G?;HM <S QBC=B

L?MC>?HNM=;HL?JILNMSGJNIGMI@=ILIH;PCLOM;H><?M??HJLIGJNFS<?G?>C=;FMN;@@ ?P?HQB?H

HII@@C=?LM;L?IH>ONSCHNB?CLBIOMCHAOHCN

 2B? !"! %OC>;H=? JLIPC>?M NB;N =F?;HCHA L?AOF;LFS ;H> @L?KO?HNFS CM E?S NI

JL?P?HNCHA;H>G;H;ACHA!-4'" CHJLCMIHM

#P?H C@ !-4'"  =;M?M B;P? HIN S?N <??H C>?HNC@C?> CHMC>? NB? @;=CFCNS IL CH NB?
MOLLIOH>CHA =IGGOHCNS  <?ACH CGJF?G?HNCHA /4:+49/,/+* =F?;HCHA ;H> >CMCH@?=NCHA
JLI=?>OL?M;==IL>CHANINB?L?=IGG?H>;NCIHM<?FIQ"+<+8'2:/3+96+8*'?=F?;H;H>
>CMCH@?=N MOL@;=?M ;H> I<D?=NM NB;N ;L? @L?KO?HNFS NIO=B?>  ?MJ?=C;FFS CH =IGGIH ;L?;M
1O=BMOL@;=?MG;SCH=FO>?I<D?=NMMOL@;=?MHINIL>CH;LCFS=F?;H?>>;CFS?A >IILEHI<M 
FCABN MQCN=B?M  MCHE B;H>F?M  =IOHN?LNIJM  NICF?NM  NICF?N B;H>F?M  L?=L?;NCIH ?KOCJG?HN 
ECIMEM  ;H> N?F?JBIH?M     !IHMC>?L CH=L?;MCHA NB? HOG<?L I@ MN;@@ ;H>IL
CH=;L=?L;N?>>?N;CH?>J?LMIHMNL;CH?>;H>L?MJIHMC<F?@IL=F?;HCHA=IGGIH;L?;MNI?HMOL?
=IHNCHO;F=F?;HCHAI@NB?M?;L?;MNBLIOABIONNB?>;S#HMOL?;>?KO;N?MOJJFC?MNIMOJJILN
CHN?HMC@C?>=F?;HCHA;H>>CMCH@?=NCIHJL;=NC=?M



BNNJMQQQ=>=AIP=ILIH;PCLOM H=IP=IGGOHCNS=ILL?=NCIH >?N?HNCIHAOC>;H=? =ILL?=NCIH;F
>?N?HNCIHBNGF=ILL?=NCIH;F @;=CFCNC?M J?GJB;MCM;>>?> 

*':?GJB;MCM;>>?> 




Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 25 of 38

 N !+!$  BIQ?P?L  =F?;HCHA I@ =IGGIH ;L?;M CM B;JB;T;L> ;H> I==OLM

;JJLIRCG;N?FSIH=?;>;SCHMN?;>I@M?P?L;FNCG?MJ?L>;S!F?;HCHAMOJJFC?M@IL=IGGIH;L?;M

;L?FCGCN?> ;H>NB?SMIG?NCG?MLOHION,I=F?;HCHAMOJJFC?M;L?;P;CF;<F?NI=F?;HNB?FCPCHA

;L?;MQB?L?J?IJF?MF??J;H>MJ?H>NB?GIMNNCG?2B?HOG<?LI@MN;@@;H>CH=;L=?L;N?>J?LMIHM

NL;CH?>;H>L?MJIHMC<F?@IL=F?;HCHAB;MHIN<??HCH=L?;M?>

 N1+!' =F?;HCHAI@NB?=IGGIH;L?;MCMB;JB;T;L>;H>>I?MHINB;JJ?HM?P?L;F

NCG?MJ?L>;S'HMIG?MCNO;NCIHM NB?L?;L?HIN?HIOABMOJJFC?MNI=F?;HNB?=IGGIH;L?;M2B?L?

;L?HIMOJJFC?M;P;CF;<F?NI=F?;HNB?FCPCHA;L?;MQB?L?J?IJF?MF??J;H>MJ?H>GIMNI@NB?CLNCG?

2B?HOG<?LI@MN;@@;H>CH=;L=?L;N?>J?LMIHMNL;CH?>;H>L?MJIHMC<F?@IL=F?;HCHAB;MHIN<??H

CH=L?;M?>

 2B? !"! %OC>;H=? =;FFM @IL YCHN?HMC@C?> =F?;HCHAZ Y8?9P?H C@ !-4'"  =;M?M

B;P?HINS?N<??HC>?HNC@C?>CHMC>?NB?@;=CFCNSZ!"!%OC>;H=? J5B?L?;=;M?CMMOMJ?=N?>

ILB;M<??HC>?HNC@C?> NB?H??>CM?P?HAL?;N?L7?N;N!+!$ ;F;LA?TIH?Q;ML?=?HNFSJF;=?>IH

KO;L;HNCH? ;H>HIN?P?H<;M?FCH?=F?;HCHAJLINI=IFMQ?L??R?=ON?>

 2B? !"! %OC>;H=? JLIPC>?M NB;N JLCMIHM MBIOF>  Y'GJF?G?HN >;CFS N?GJ?L;NOL?

=B?=EMCHBIOMCHAOHCNMQB?L?!-4'" =;M?MB;P?<??HC>?HNC@C?>Z!"!%OC>;H=? J

?GJB;MCM ;>>?>  7?N ;N !+!$  QB?H ; TIH? Q;M L?=?HNFS JF;=?> IH KO;L;HNCH?  N?GJ?L;NOL?

=B?=EMQ?L?IHFS>IH?IH;JJLIRCG;N?FSNBL??I@NB?@IOLN??HKO;L;HNCH?>;SM

 2B? !"! %OC>;H=? JLIPC>?M NB;N JLCMIH ;ONBILCNC?M MBIOF> Y8J9LIPC>? ; HI =IMN

MOJJFSI@MI;JNICH=;L=?L;N?>>?N;CH?>J?LMIHM MO@@C=C?HNNI;FFIQ@L?KO?HNB;H>Q;MBCHAZ;H>

;>>MMO=BMI;JMBIOF><?YFCKOC>MI;JQB?L?JIMMC<F? Z;H>NB;N Y8C9@<;LMI;JGOMN<?OM?> ?HMOL?

NB;NCN>I?MHINCLLCN;N?NB?MECH;H>NB?L?<S>CM=IOL;A?@L?KO?HNB;H>Q;MBCHAZ*;N 



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 26 of 38

 &IQ?P?L ;N!+!$;H>1+!' L?MC>?HNM>IHINB;P??HIOABMI;J@ILL?AOF;LB;H>

Q;MBCHA GO=BF?MM@L?KO?HNB;H>Q;MBCHA-HFS<;LMI;JCMJLIPC>?> NB?L?CMHIN?HIOABI@CN 

;H>CNA?H?L;FFSCLLCN;N?MNB?MECHI@NBIM?QBIOM?CN-HNQII==;MCIHML?=?HNFS ;<ION;GIHNB

;J;LN MIG?JLCMIH?LMQ?L?JLIPC>?>QCNB;MCHAF?<;LI@"C;FMI;J <ONNB;NA?H?L;FFSL;HIONQCNBCH

NQIQ??EM

 2B? !"! %OC>;H=? JLIPC>?M NB;N JLCMIH ;ONBILCNC?M MBIOF> Y8.LIPC>?9 8L9OHHCHA

Q;N?L ;H>B;H>>LSCHAG;=BCH?MIL>CMJIM;<F?J;J?LNIQ?FM@ILB;H>Q;MBCHA8.LIPC>?98N9CMMO?M

;H>HI NIO=BNL;MBL?=?JN;=F?M@IL>CMJIM;FZ*;N&IQ?P?L ;N!+!$;H>1+!' NB?L?;L?

HIJ;J?LNIQ?FMILB;H>>LSCHAG;=BCH?M2B?L?;L?HI@;=C;FNCMMO?M#;=BJ?LMIHB;M;LIFFI@

NICF?NJ;J?L <ONC@;HSI@CNNB;NCMOM?>@IL@;=C;FJOLJIM?M>CGCHCMB?MNB?J?LMIH\MNICF?NJ;J?L

MOJJFS;H>L?MC>?HNMMIG?NCG?MLOHION

 2B? !"! %OC>;H=? =;FFM @IL MI=C;F >CMN;H=CHA  Y'GJF?G?HN MI=C;F >CMN;H=CHA

MNL;N?AC?M NI CH=L?;M? NB? JBSMC=;F MJ;=? <?NQ??H CH=;L=?L;N?>>?N;CH?> J?LMIHM C>?;FFS  @??N

<?NQ??H;FFCH>CPC>O;FM L?A;L>F?MMI@NB?JL?M?H=?I@MSGJNIGM Z*;N+?;MOL?M@IL>ICHA

NBCMCH=FO>?NB?@IFFIQCHAY#H@IL=?CH=L?;M?>MJ;=?<?NQ??HCH>CPC>O;FMCHBIF>CHA=?FFM ;MQ?FF

;MCHFCH?M;H>Q;CNCHA;L?;MZ*YLL;HA?<OHEMMINB;NCH>CPC>O;FMMF??JB?;>NI@IINNI

CH=L?;M?NB?>CMN;H=?<?NQ??HNB?GZ*

 &IQ?P?L ;N!+!$;H>1+!' NB?L?;L?CH;>?KO;N??@@ILNMNI?H@IL=?IL?H=IOL;A?

MI=C;F>CMN;H=CHA'HNB?IJ?H<;S;L?;M <?>M;L?;<IONNBL??@??N;J;LN2B?L?CMHIMF??JCHAB?;>

NI@IIN;H>HIIH?B;MIL>?L?>CN1CGCF;LFS L?MC>?HNM>IHINMN;SMCR@??N;J;LNCHNB?=IGGIH

;L?;M <;NBLIIGM ?;NCHA;L?;M ILCHFCH?@ILJCFF=;FF'NCM>C@@C=OFN;H>I@N?HCGJIMMC<F?NI>IMICH

NB?IP?L=LIQ>?>MJ;=?MCHNB?JLCMIH ;H>HIIH?B;MCHMNLO=N?>IL?H=IOL;A?>NB?GNINLS



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 27 of 38

 2B?!"!%OC>;H=??GJB;MCT?MNB?CGJILN;H=?I@=IGGOHC=;NCIHY!IGGOHC=;N?

)2+'82?'4*,8+7;+4:2?QCNBCH=;L=?L;N?>>?N;CH?>J?LMIHM;<ION=B;HA?MNINB?CL>;CFSM=B?>OF?

;H>BIQNB?S=;H=IHNLC<ON?NILCMEL?>O=NCIH.LIPC>?OJ NI >;N?CH@ILG;NCIH;<ION!-4'"

 NI CH=;L=?L;N?>>?N;CH?> J?LMIHM IH ; L?AOF;L <;MCM      !IHMC>?L B;PCHA .+'2:.)'8+ 9:',,

6+8,58385;4*954'8+-;2'8('9/9NI;HMQ?LKO?MNCIHM;<ION!-4'" Z!"!%OC>;H=? J

?GJB;MCM;>>?> 

 0?MC>?HNM;L?HINL?=?CPCHANBCM=LCNC=;FCH@ILG;NCIH@LIGJLCMIHM$IL?R;GJF? IH

;NF?;MNIH?TIH?;N!+!$ CN;JJ?;LMNB;NL?MC>?HNM Q?L?HINC@C?>NB?SQ?L?IHKO;L;HNCH?@IL

JIN?HNC;F ?RJIMOL? QB?H ; AO;L> ?HN?L?> NB? TIH?  ;HHIOH=?> NB? KO;L;HNCH?  ;H> F?@N QCNBION

@OLNB?L?RJF;H;NCIH

 2B?!"!%OC>;H=?;FMI=;FFM@IL;ONBILCNC?MNIY8J9IMNMCAH;A?NBLIOABNB?@;=CFCNS

=IGGOHC=;NCHAMSGJNIGMI@!-4'" ;H>B;H>BSAC?H?CHMNLO=NCIHMZ;H>=IGGOHC=;NCHA

NB;N CH=;L=?L;N?> J?IJF? MBIOF> YL?JILN MSGJNIGM NI MN;@@Z  * ;N  Y#HMOL? NB;N MCAH;A? CM

OH>?LMN;H>;<F?@ILHIH #HAFCMBMJ?;ECHAJ?LMIHM;H>NBIM?QCNBFIQFCN?L;=SZ*1??;FMI

/*;NMN;NCHANB;N;ONBILCNC?MMBIOF>Y8J9IMNMCAH;A?NBLIOABIONNB?@;=CFCNS;H>=IGGOHC=;N?

NBCMCH@ILG;NCIHP?L<;FFSIH;L?AOF;L<;MCM Z

 N !+!$ ;H> 1+!'  BIQ?P?L  #HAFCMB IHFS @FS?LM Q?L? JIMN?> IH MIG? OHCN

<OFF?NCH<I;L>M<ONNB?S>CM;JJ?;L?>KOC=EFS;H>Q?L?H?P?LL?JF;=?>2B?L?B;M<??HFCNNF?P?L<;F

=IGGOHC=;NCIH L?A;L>CHA MSGJNIGM ;H> BSAC?H?  ;H> J?IJF? B;P? HI Q;S I@ CH@ILGCHA

NB?GM?FP?M;<IONBIQNI<?MNJLIN?=NNB?GM?FP?M2B?L?;L?HIH #HAFCMB MJ?;ECHAJ?IJF?;N!+!$

;H> 1+!' QBI B;P? HIN B;> NB? IJJILNOHCNS NI L?;> ?P?H NB? @FS?L IL @FS?LM NB;N Q?L? <LC?@FS

JIMN?>



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 28 of 38

 2B? !"! %OC>;H=? =;FFM @IL ;ONBILCNC?M NI Y=IHMC>?L MOMJ?H>CHA =I J;SM @IL

CH=;L=?L;N?>>?N;CH?>J?LMIHM;MECHAG?>C=;F?P;FO;NCIH@ILL?MJCL;NILSMSGJNIGMZ'>;N

 N<INB!+!$;H>1+!' CN;JJ?;LMNB;NG;HSL?MC>?HNMB;P?HIN<??HCH@ILG?>

I@ ;HS Q;CP?L I@ NB? MCR >IFF;L MC=E =;FF @?? @IL NBIM? M??ECHA G?>C=;F =;L? @IL !-4'" 

MSGJNIGM'HJL;=NC=? NBCM>CM=IOL;A?MJ?IJF?@LIGM??ECHA=;L?;H>=;HJLIFIHANB?NCG?NB;N

J?IJF?QCNB!-4'" L?G;CHMSGJNIG;NC=CH=LIQ>?>BIOMCHAOHCNM

 2B?!"!%OC>;H=?MN;N?MNB;NY8;9MMIIH;M;HCH>CPC>O;F>?P?FIJMMSGJNIGMI@

!-4'"  NB?SMBIOF>Q?;L;@;=?G;ME;H>MBIOF><?CGG?>C;N?FSJF;=?>OH>?LG?>C=;F

CMIF;NCIHZ'>;N?GJB;MCM;>>?> 'GG?>C;N?;=NCIH>?=L?;M?MNB?JIMMC<CFCNSNB;N;J?LMIH

QCNBNB?PCLOMQCFFNL;HMGCNCNNIINB?LMCHNB?OHCN$ILCGG?>C;N?;=NCIHNII==OL ;G?;HMGOMN

?RCMN@ILL?MC>?HNMNICH@ILGMN;@@QBIQCFFN;E?JLIGJN;=NCIH

 N<INB!+!$;H>1+!' NB?MC=E=;FFJLI=?MMOMO;FFSN;E?MGOFNCJF?>;SM;H>

G;HSL?MC>?HNMB;P?HIN<??HCH@ILG?>I@;HS?RJ?>CN?>JLI=?>OL?@IL!-4'" MSGJNIGM

MBILN;A?I@MN;@@G;E?MCN>C@@C=OFNNII<N;CHKOC=E;=NCIHC@MSGJNIGM>I;LCM?

 

 .OLMO;HNNI0OF?M; ;H><  I@NB?$?>?L;F0OF?MI@!CPCF.LI=?>OL? NB?

CH>CPC>O;F,;G?>.F;CHNC@@M<LCHANBCM;=NCIHIH<?B;F@I@NB?GM?FP?M;H>;=F;MM=IHMCMNCHAI@

J?IJF? QBI ;L? =OLL?HNFS CH=;L=?L;N?>  IL QCFF <? CH NB? @ONOL?  CH ; !+!$ IL 1+!' >?N?HNCIH

@;=CFCNS >OLCHA NB? >OL;NCIH I@ NB? !-4'"  J;H>?GC= .F;CHNC@@M ;FMI JLIJIM? NB? @IFFIQCHA

1O<=F;MM

; /9'(/2/:?";()2'99.?IJF?CH=OMNI>SQBIMO@@?L@LIG;>CM;<CFCNSNB;N

MO<MN;HNC;FFSFCGCNMIH?ILGIL?I@NB?CLG;DILFC@?;=NCPCNC?M;H>QBI;L?;NCH=L?;M?>LCME



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 29 of 38

I@=IHNL;=NCHA <?=IGCHAM?P?L?FSCFF@LIG ;H>IL>SCHA@LIG!-4'" >O?NINB?CL

>CM;<CFCNSIL;HSG?>C=;FNL?;NG?HNH?=?MM;LSNINL?;NNB?CL>CM;<CFCNS

  =F;MM ;=NCIH CM NB? IHFS JL;=NC=;<F? G?;HM <S QBC=B NB? CH>CPC>O;F ,;G?>

.F;CHNC@@M ;H> NB? JON;NCP? =F;MM G?G<?LM G;S =B;FF?HA? "?@?H>;HNM\ OH=IHMNCNONCIH;F ;=NCIHM

+;HSG?G<?LMI@NB?!F;MM;L?QCNBIONNB?G?;HMNIL?N;CH;H;NNILH?SNIL?JL?M?HNNB?GCH;=CPCF

LCABNMF;QMOCN

 2B?!F;MM;H>1O<=F;MM;L?MIHOG?LIOMNB;NDICH>?LI@;FFG?G<?LMCMCGJL;=NC=;F

2B? HOG<?L I@ J?IJF? CH =OMNI>S CM ;JJLIRCG;N?FS   CH !+!$ ;H> 1+!' =IG<CH?>

"CMJIMCNCIHI@NBCMG;NN?L;M;=F;MM;=NCIHQCFFJLIPC>?MO<MN;HNC;F<?H?@CNM;H>?@@C=C?H=C?MNINB?

J;LNC?M;H>NB?!IOLN

 2B?L? ;L? KO?MNCIHM I@ F;Q ;H> @;=N =IGGIH NI ;FF =F;MM G?G<?LM ;H> NI NB?

MO<=F;MMG?G<?LM CH=FO>CHA; >I?M!-4'" JL?M?HN;MO<MN;HNC;FLCMEI@B;LGNIJ?IJF?CH

!+!$ IL 1+!' =OMNI>S <  B;P? "?@?H>;HNM @;CF?> NI ;>?KO;N?FS JLIN?=N NB? !F;MM @LIG NB?

CGG?>C;N? NBL?;N I@ !-4'"  =  QB;N JL;=NC=?M ;L? "?@?H>;HNM ;=NO;FFS CGJF?G?HNCHA QCNB

L?MJ?=N NI !-4'"  >  QB?NB?L "?@?H>;HNM\ ;=NCIHM ;H>IL CH;=NCIHM =IHMNCNON? >?FC<?L;N?

CH>C@@?L?H=?NINB?LCABNMI@JON;NCP?=F;MMG?G<?LM? QB?NB?LNB?LCABNMI@NB?1O<=F;MMOH>?L

NB?G?LC=;HMQCNB"CM;<CFCNC?M=NY"Z ;H>NB?0?B;<CFCN;NCIH=N;L?<?CHAPCIF;N?><S

"?@?H>;HNM\;=NCIHM;H>NB?=IH>CNCIHM;N!+!$;H>1+!';H>@ QB?NB?L"?@?H>;HNMCFF?A;FFS

>CM=LCGCH;N?>;A;CHMNNB?1O<=F;MM<S>?HSCHAL?;MIH;<F?;==IGGI>;NCIHM

 2B?=F;CGMI@NB?,;G?>.F;CHNC@@M;L?NSJC=;FI@NBIM?I@NB?!F;MM;H>1O<=F;MM

2BCMNSJC=;FCNSMN?GM@LIG.F;CHNC@@M\=F;CGMNB;N"?@?H>;HNMB;P?JF;=?>NB?G;NMCAHC@C=;HNLCME

I@B;LG<S@;CFCHANIN;E?;JJLIJLC;N?MN?JMNI;>>L?MMNB?LCMEI@!-4'" CH!+!$;H>1+!'

2B?=F;CGMI@.F;CHNC@@M NB?!F;MM ;H>NB?1O<=F;MM;LCM?@LIGNB?M;G?=IH>O=N<S"?@?H>;HNM



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 30 of 38

;H>;L?<;M?>IHC>?HNC=;FF?A;FNB?ILC?M;H>M??EC>?HNC=;FL?FC?@FFG?G<?LMI@NB?!F;MM;H>

1O<=F;MM;L?MCGCF;LFSCHDOL?><S"?@?H>;HNM\QLIHA@OF=IH>O=N ;H>NB?B;LGM.F;CHNC@@MMO@@?L

;L?NSJC=;FI@NB?B;LGMMO@@?L?><SNB?!F;MM;H>1O<=F;MM

  =F;MM ;=NCIH CM MOJ?LCIL NI INB?L ;P;CF;<F? G?NBI>M @IL @;CLFS ;H> ?@@C=C?HNFS

;>DO>C=;NCHA NBCM =IHNLIP?LMS  ?MJ?=C;FFS MCH=? DICH>?L I@ ;FF !F;MM ;H> 1O<=F;MM G?G<?LM CM

CGJL;=NC=;F

 #;=B =F;MM G?G<?L CM CLL?J;L;<FS B;LG?> ;M ; L?MOFN I@ "?@?H>;HNM\ QLIHA@OF

=IH>O=N*CNCA;NCHANBCM=;M?;M;=F;MM;=NCIHQCFFL?>O=?NB?LCMEI@L?J?NCNCIOMFCNCA;NCIHL?F;NCHA

NINB?"?@?H>;HNM\=IH>O=N

 2B?CH>CPC>O;F,;G?>.F;CHNC@@MQCFF@;CLFS;H>;>?KO;N?FSL?JL?M?HNNB?CHN?L?MNI@

NB?!F;MM;H>1O<=F;MM2B?,;G?>.F;CHNC@@MB;P?HI=IH@FC=NMQCNBNB?OHH;G?>G?G<?LMI@NB?

JLIJIM?>!F;MM;H>1O<=F;MM'H;>>CNCIH NB?CLF;QS?LM;L??RJ?LC?H=?>CH=IGJF?R=CPCFLCABNM

=;M?M;A;CHMNAIP?LHG?HN;F?HNCNC?M

 "?@?H>;HNMB;P??HA;A?>CHOHF;Q@OF;=NCIHM;H>CH;=NCIHMCH;G;HH?LNB;N;JJFC?M

A?H?L;FFS NI NB? !F;MM ;H> 1O<=F;MM  L?H>?LCHA =F;MM QC>? CHDOH=NCP? ;H> >?=F;L;NILS L?FC?@

;JJLIJLC;N?

! 

! 
".30&8.323+8-*.,-8-1*2)1*28
 !=

222'/4:/,,9

 .F;CHNC@@M CH=ILJIL;N? <S L?@?L?H=? ;FF ;FF?A;NCIHM =IHN;CH?> CH NB? JL?=?>CHA

J;L;AL;JBM;MC@M?N@ILNB@OFFSB?L?CH

 2B?#CABNBG?H>G?HNNINB?!IHMNCNONCIHI@NB?3HCN?>1N;N?M ;MCH=ILJIL;N?>

NBLIOABNB?$IOLN??HNBG?H>G?HN JLIPC>?MNB;NCH>CPC>O;FMQBI;L?CH=;L=?L;N?>@IFFIQCHA;



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 31 of 38

=IHPC=NCIHB;P?NB?LCABNNI<?@L??@LIG=LO?F;H>OHOMO;FJOHCMBG?HN2B;NLCABN?HN;CFM ;GIHA

INB?LNBCHAM NB?1N;N?\MI<FCA;NCIHNIJLIN?=NCH=;L=?L;N?>CH>CPC>O;FM@LIG;MO<MN;HNC;FLCMEI@

M?LCIOMB;LGNINB?CLB?;FNB;H>M;@?NS1??A?H?L;FFS$;LG?LP L?HH;H 31 

 2B?1N;N?\M@;CFOL?NIJLIPC>?;>?KO;N?JLIN?=NCIH;H> C@H?=?MM;LS G?>C=;F=;L?

CHL?MJIHM?NINB?L;JC>MJL?;>I@;>?;>FSPCLOM=IHMNCNON?M>?FC<?L;N?CH>C@@?L?H=?NINB?M?LCIOM

G?>C=;FH??>MI@CH=;L=?L;N?>CH>CPC>O;FMCHPCIF;NCIHI@NB?#CABNBG?H>G?HN

 .F;CHNC@@M ;H>NB?=F;MMNB?SL?JL?M?HN MO@@?L;MO<MN;HNC;FLCMEI@M?LCIOMB;LGNI

NB?CLB?;FNB;H>M;@?NS>O?NINB?MJL?;>I@!-4'" CH!+!$;H>1+!'@;=CFCNC?M

 "?@?H>;HNMB;P?;=N?>QCNB>?FC<?L;N?CH>C@@?L?H=?NINB?LCMEMJIM?><S!-4'"

NI.F;CHNC@@M

 "?@?H>;HNMEH?Q ;H>EHIQ I@NB?I<PCIOM;H>Q?FF ?MN;<FCMB?>LCMEMNI.F;CHNC@@M

=;OM?><S!-4'" 

 "?@?H>;HNMB;P?@;CF?>NI;=NQCNBL?;MIH;<F?=;L?NIGCNCA;N?NB?LCMEJIM?><S

!-4'" 

 M;L?MOFNI@"?@?H>;HNM\;=NCIHM .F;CHNC@@M;H>G?G<?LMI@NB?JLIJIM?>!F;MM

;L?MO@@?LCHACLL?J;L;<F?CHDOLS

 N;FFNCG?M "?@?H>;HNM;=N?>OH>?L=IFILI@MN;N?F;Q

!  #
".30&8.323+8-*1*6.(&27;.8-.7&'.0.8.*7(8
 != *87*5
/9'(/2/:?";()2'99

 .F;CHNC@@ML?J?;N;H>L? ;FF?A?NB?JL?=?>CHAJ;L;AL;JBM;MC@M?N@ILNBB?L?CH

 "?@?H>;HNMB;P?@;CF?>NIL?;MIH;<FSGI>C@SCNMJLIAL;GM;H>M?LPC=?MNI;>>L?MM

NB? MO<MN;HNC;F ;H> CH=L?;M?> LCME NB;N .F;CHNC@@ G?G<?LM I@ NB? "CM;<CFCNS 1O<=F;MM B;P? I@



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 32 of 38

=IHNL;=NCHA <?=IGCHAM?P?L?FSCFF@LIG ;H>IL>SCHA@LIG!-4'" >O?NINB?CL>CM;<CFCNSIL

;HSG?>C=;FNL?;NG?HNH?=?MM;LSNINL?;NNB?CL>CM;<CFCNS

 "?@?H>;HNMB;P?CHN?HNCIH;FFS>CM=LCGCH;N?>;A;CHMNNB?"CM;<CFCNS.F;CHNC@@M;H>NB?

G?G<?LM I@ NB? "CM;<CFCNS 1O<=F;MM <S >?HSCHA NB?G L?;MIH;<F? ;==IGGI>;NCIHM  CH=FO>CHA

;==IGGI>;NCIHM NB;N B;P? <??H L?=IGG?H>?> <S NB? !"!  NB;N ;L?H?=?MM;LS NI JLIN?=N NB?G

@LIG!-4'" ;H>NB;NB;P?<??H>?M=LC<?>CHNBCM=IGJF;CHN

 2B? @;CFOL? NI JLIPC>? NB?M? JLIAL;G GI>C@C=;NCIHM ;H> ;==IGGI>;NCIHM

=IHMNCNON?M CFF?A;F >CM=LCGCH;NCIH OH>?L NB? " ;H> ?HNCNF?M .F;CHNC@@M NI CHDOH=NCP? ;H>

>?=F;L;NILSL?FC?@

 3H>?L 2CNF? '' I@ NB? "  YHI KO;FC@C?> CH>CPC>O;F QCNB ; >CM;<CFCNS MB;FF  <S

L?;MIHI@MO=B>CM;<CFCNS <??R=FO>?>@LIGJ;LNC=CJ;NCIHCHIL<?>?HC?>NB?<?H?@CNMI@NB?M?LPC=?M 

JLIAL;GM  IL ;=NCPCNC?M I@ ; JO<FC= ?HNCNS  IL <? MO<D?=N?> NI>CM=LCGCH;NCIH <S MO=B ?HNCNSZ 

31!U

 +"-!!+!$ ;H>1+!';L?JO<FC=?HNCNC?M=IP?L?><S2CNF?''I@NB?"

31!U

 $ILJOLJIM?MI@NB?" G?>C=;FNL?;NG?HN;H>M;@?=IH>CNCIHMI@=IH@CH?G?HN

;L?JLIAL;GMILM?LPC=?MNB;N+"-!@;=CFCNC?MJLIPC>?NI.F;CHNC@@M

 ,;G?> .F;CHNC@@M ;H> INB?L G?G<?LM I@ NB? "CM;<CFCNS 1O<=F;MM B;P? ; JBSMC=;F

CGJ;CLG?HNNB;NMO<MN;HNC;FFSFCGCNMIH?ILGIL?I@NB?CLG;DILFC@?;=NCPCNC?M

 ,;G?> .F;CHNC@@M ;H> INB?L G?G<?LM I@ NB? "CM;<CFCNS 1O<=F;MM ;L? KO;FC@C?>

CH>CPC>O;FMQCNB;>CM;<CFCNSOH>?LNB?G?;HCHAI@NB?"

 "?@?H>;HNM EHIQ NB;N ,;G?> .F;CHNC@@M ;H> INB?L G?G<?LM I@ NB? "CM;<CFCNS

1O<=F;MM ;L? KO;FC@C?> CH>CPC>O;FM QCNB ; >CM;<CFCNS "?@?H>;HNM EHIQ NB;N CH>CPC>O;FM QCNB



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 33 of 38

>CM;<CFCNC?M;L?CH?MJ?=C;FFS;=ON?H??>I@;==?MMNIL?;MIH;<F?GI>C@C=;NCIHMJLCMIHJLIAL;GM;H>

JIFC=C?M>OLCHANB?!-4'" J;H>?GC= S?NCNB;M>?HC?>NB?M?;==IGGI>;NCIHMNINB?"CM;<CFCNS

.F;CHNC@@M;H>INB?LG?G<?LMI@NB?"CM;<CFCNS1O<=F;MM

!  
".30&8.323+8-**-&'.0.8&8.32(8
 !=  *87*5
/9'(/2/:?";()2'99

 .F;CHNC@@ML?J?;N;H>L? ;FF?A?NB?JL?=?>CHAJ;L;AL;JBM;MC@M?N@ILNBB?L?CH

 "?@?H>;HNMB;P?@;CF?>NIL?;MIH;<FSGI>C@SCNMJLIAL;GM;H>M?LPC=?MNI;>>L?MM

NB? MO<MN;HNC;F ;H> CH=L?;M?> LCME NB;N .F;CHNC@@ G?G<?LM I@ NB? "CM;<CFCNS 1O<=F;MM B;P? I@

=IHNL;=NCHA <?=IGCHAM?P?L?FSCFF@LIG ;H>IL>SCHA@LIG!-4'" >O?NINB?CL>CM;<CFCNSIL

;HSG?>C=;FNL?;NG?HNH?=?MM;LSNINL?;NNB?CL>CM;<CFCNS

 "?@?H>;HNM B;P? CHN?HNCIH;FFS >CM=LCGCH;N?> ;A;CHMN NB? "CM;<CFCNS 1O<=F;MM

.F;CHNC@@M ;H> NB? G?G<?LM I@ NB? "CM;<CFCNS 1O<=F;MM <S >?HSCHA NB?G L?;MIH;<F?

;==IGGI>;NCIHM CH=FO>CHA;==IGGI>;NCIHMNB;NB;P?<??HL?=IGG?H>?><SNB?!"! NB;N;L?

H?=?MM;LSNIJLIN?=NNB?G@LIG!-4'" ;H>NB;NB;P?<??H>?M=LC<?>CHNBCM=IGJF;CHN

 2B? @;CFOL? NI JLIPC>? NB?M? ;==IGGI>;NCIHM =IHMNCNON?M CFF?A;F >CM=LCGCH;NCIH

OH>?L NB? 0?B;<CFCN;NCIH =N  JL?P?HNM .F;CHNC@@M @LIG I<N;CHCHA ?KO;F ;==?MM NI ;=NCPCNC?M 

JLIAL;GM ;H>M?LPC=?MNIQBC=BNB?S;L?INB?LQCM??HNCNF?> ;H>?HNCNF?M.F;CHNC@@MNICHDOH=NCP?

;H>>?=F;L;NILSL?FC?@

 N;FFNCG?ML?F?P;HNNINBCM;=NCIH +"-! !+!$ ;H>1+!'B;P?L?=?CP?>@?>?L;F

@OH>CHANB;NL?KOCL?MNB?GNI=IGJFSQCNBNB?0?B;<CFCN;NCIH=N

 2B?"CM;<CFCNS1O<=F;MM.F;CHNC@@M;H>INB?LG?G<?LMI@NB?"CM;<CFCNS1O<=F;MM;L?

KO;FC@C?>CH>CPC>O;FMQCNB;>CM;<CFCNSOH>?LNB?G?;HCHAI@NB?0?B;<CFCN;NCIH=N



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 34 of 38

 $ILJOLJIM?MI@NB?0?B;<CFCN;NCIH=N G?>C=;FNL?;NG?HN;H>M;@?=IH>CNCIHMI@

=IH@CH?G?HN;L?;=NCPCNC?M JLIAL;GMILM?LPC=?MNB;N+"-!@;=CFCNC?MJLIPC>?NI.F;CHNC@@M

 2B? "CM;<CFCNS 1O<=F;MM .F;CHNC@@M ;H> INB?L G?G<?LM I@ NB? "CM;<CFCNS 1O<=F;MM

B;P?;JBSMC=;FCGJ;CLG?HNNB;NMO<MN;HNC;FFSFCGCNMIH?ILGIL?I@NB?CLG;DILFC@?;=NCPCNC?M

 "?@?H>;HNMEHIQNB;NNB?"CM;<CFCNS.F;CHNC@@M;H>INB?LG?G<?LMI@NB?"CM;<CFCNS

1O<=F;MM ;L? KO;FC@C?> CH>CPC>O;FM QCNB ; >CM;<CFCNS "?@?H>;HNM EHIQ NB;N CH>CPC>O;FM QCNB

>CM;<CFCNC?M ;L? CH ?MJ?=C;FFS ;=ON? H??> I@ ;==?MM NI ;==IGGI>;NCIHM >OLCHA NB? !-4'" 

J;H>?GC=S?NCNB;M>?HC?>NB?M?L?;MIH;<F?;==IGGI>;NCIHMNINB?"CM;<CFCNS.F;CHNC@@M;H>INB?L

G?G<?LMI@NB?"CM;<CFCNS1O<=F;MM

 ==IL>CHAFS "?@?H>;HNMB;P?PCIF;N?>LCABNMM?=OL?>OH>?LNB?0?B;<CFCN;NCIH=N

NINB?"CM;<CFCNS.F;CHNC@@M;H>G?G<?LMI@NB?"CM;<CFCNS1O<=F;MM

$

5&#0#$-0# .F;CHNC@@M.?NCNCIH?LM;H>JLIJIM?>=F;MMG?G<?LML?MJ?=N@OFFSL?KO?MNNB;N

NBCM!IOLN

; !?LNC@SNB?JLIJIM?>!F;MM;H>1O<=F;MM

< #HN?L;HIL>?L>?=F;LCHANB;N"?@?H>;HNM\;=NCIHM;H>CH;=NCIHML?A;L>CHA

!-4'" PCIF;N?NB?#CABNBG?H>G?HNNINB?3HCN?>1N;N?M!IHMNCNONCIH

= #HN?L;HIL>?L>?=F;LCHANB;NNB?"?@?H>;HNMB;P?PCIF;N?>NB?";H>NB?

0?B;<CFCN;NCIH=N<S@;CFCHANIG;E?L?;MIH;<F?GI>C@C=;NCIHMNICNM!-4'" L?MJIHM?

> #HN?L;N?GJIL;LSL?MNL;CHCHAIL>?L JL?FCGCH;LSCHDOH=NCIH ;H>J?LG;H?HN

CHDOH=NCIHL?KOCLCHANB;N"?@?H>;HNMN;E?;FFL?;MIH;<F?;H>H?=?MM;LSMN?JMNI=IGJFSQCNB

NB? #CABNB G?H>G?HN  NB? "  ;H> NB? 0?B;<CFCN;NCIH =N ;H> NI JL?P?HN NB?

NL;HMGCMMCIHI@!-4'" ;H>NIJLIJ?LFSNL?;NNBIM?QBI=IHNL;=NCN CH=FO>CHA<ONHIN



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 35 of 38

FCGCN?>NINB?@IFFIQCHA

C 'GJF?G?HN;@;=CFCNS QC>?JLINI=IF ;H>?@@?=NCP?FSNL;CHL?MC>?HNM

;H>MN;@@NIOM?CN QB?L?<S;L?MC>?HNQCNB=ILIH;PCLOMMSGJNIGM=;HL?JILNNB?CL

MSGJNIGM;H><??P;FO;N?><SG?>C=;FMN;@@JLIGJNFSNBCMG?NBI>GOMNQILE?P?H

C@NB?L?CMHIM?=OLCNSMN;@@JL?M?HNIH;TIH?ILCHNB?NIQ?L

CC !IH>O=NCGG?>C;N?N?MNCHA@IL;HSIH?>CMJF;SCHAEHIQHMSGJNIGM

I@!-4'" 

CCC 'H@ILG;FFCH=;L=?L;N?>J?IJF?I@NB?Q;CP?LI@;FFG?>C=;F=I J;SM

@ILCH>CPC>O;FM?RJ?LC?H=CHAJIMMC<F?!-4'" MSGJNIGM

CP 'GJF?G?HN >;CFS N?GJ?L;NOL? =B?=EM CH BIOMCHA OHCNM QB?L?

!-4'" =;M?MB;P?<??HC>?HNC@C?>

P 'GJF?G?HNCHN?HMC@C?>=F?;HCHA;H>>CMCH@?=NCHAJLI=?>OL?M;H>?HMOL?

NB;N M?P?L;FNCG?MJ?L>;S =F?;HCHA;H>>CMCH@?=NCHAI==OLMI@MOL@;=?M;H>I<D?=NMNB;N

;L?@L?KO?HNFSNIO=B?> ?MJ?=C;FFSCH=IGGIH;L?;M

PC #HMOL? NB;N ?;=B CH=;L=?L;N?> CH>CPC>O;F L?=?CP?M ; @L?? ;H>

;>?KO;N?J?LMIH;FMOJJFSI@B;H>MI;JNB;N>I?MHIN=;OM?MECHCLLCN;NCIH;H>QBC=B

CMMO@@C=C?HNNIJ?LGCN@L?KO?HNB;H>Q;MBCHA J;J?LNIQ?FM @;=C;FNCMMO?M =F?;HCHA

CGJF?G?HNMMO=B;MMJIHA?MIL<LOMB?M ;H>>CMCH@?=N;HNJLI>O=NMNB;N;L??@@?=NCP?

;A;CHMN!-4'" ;FMIJLIPC>?;HI NIO=BNL;MBL?=?JN;=F?M@IL>CMJIM;FI@J;J?L

JLI>O=NM

PCC 'GJF?G?HN;@;=CFCNS QC>?JLINI=IF ;H>?@@?=NCP?FSNL;CHL?MC>?HNM

;H> MN;@@ NI OM? CN  QB?L?<S ; L?MC>?HN QBI LOHM ION I@ MI;J =;H I<N;CH GIL?

JLIGJNFS

PCCC .LIPC>? CH=;L=?L;N?> CH>CPC>O;FM QCNB MO@@C=C?HN ;H> ?@@?=NCP?



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 36 of 38

=F?;HCHAMOJJFC?M@L??I@=B;LA?MINB;NNB?SG;S=F?;H@L?KO?HNFSNIO=B?>CN?GM 

MO=B;MJBIH?M <?@IL?OM?

CR #HMOL?NB;N;FFCH>CPC>O;FMB;P?;==?MMNIB;H>M;HCNCT?L=IHN;CHCHA

;NF?;MN;F=IBIF

R 0?KOCL?NB;N;FF!+!$;H>1+!'MN;@@Q?;L..#=IHMCMN?HNQCNB

NB?!"!%OC>;H=? CH=FO>CHAG;MEM;H>AFIP?M QB?HCHN?L;=NCHAQCNBPCMCNILM;H>

CH=;L=?L;N?>CH>CPC>O;FMILQB?HNIO=BCHAMOL@;=?MCH=IGGIH;L?;M

RC #HMOL? CH=;L=?L;N?> J?IJF? ;L? JLIPC>?> AOC>;H=? IH BIQ NI JLIN?=N

NB?GM?FP?M@LIG!-4'" ;H>L?>O=?!-4'" NL;HMGCMMCIH

RCC .LIPC>? @L?KO?HN =IGGOHC=;NCIH NI ;FF CH=;L=?L;N?> CH>CPC>O;FM

L?A;L>CHA!-4'"  G?;MOL?MN;E?HNIL?>O=?NB?LCMEI@CH@?=NCIH <?MNJL;=NC=?M

@ILCH=;L=?L;N?>J?IJF?NI;PIC>CH@?=NCIH ;H>;HS=B;HA?MCHJIFC=C?MILJL;=NC=?M

RCCC .LIPC>? ;H ;HIHSGIOM G?=B;HCMG @IL CH=;L=?L;N?> CH>CPC>O;FM NI

L?JILNMN;@@QBIPCIF;N?NB?M?AOC>?FCH?MMINB;N;JJLIJLC;N?=ILL?=NCP?;=NCIHG;S

<?N;E?H

RCP 'H@ILG CH=;L=?L;N?> J?IJF? ;L? NIF> NB;N NB?S QCFF HIN <? L?N;FC;N?>

;A;CHMN@ILL?JILNCHA!-4'" MSGJNIGMIL@ILL?JILNCHAF;=EI@=IGJFC;H=?QCNB

!-4'" GCNCA;NCIHG?;MOL?M

RP #HMOL? NB;N CH=;L=?L;N?> CH>CPC>O;FM =;H L?G;CH MCR @??N ;J;LN NI

JL;=NC=?MI=C;F>CMN;H=CHACH=IGJFC;H=?QCNB!"!%OC>;H=?

RPC JJICHN ;H CH>?J?H>?HN GIHCNIL QCNB G?>C=;F ?RJ?LNCM? NI ?HMOL?

=IGJFC;H=?QCNBNB?M?=IH>CNCIHM ;H>JLIPC>?NB?GIHCNILQCNBOH@?NN?L?>;==?MMNI

G?>C=;F OHCNM  =IH@C>?HNC;F =IGGOHC=;NCIH QCNB >?N;CH?> CH>CPC>O;FM CH ;H> ION I@

KO;L;HNCH? ;H>MOLP?CFF;H=?PC>?II@JO<FC=;L?;MI@NB?@;=CFCNC?M;H>



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 37 of 38

? 0?N;CHDOLCM>C=NCIHIP?LNBCM=;M?OHNCF"?@?H>;HNMB;P?@OFFS=IGJFC?>QCNB

NB? IL>?LM I@ NBCM !IOLN  ;H> NB?L? CM ; L?;MIH;<F? ;MMOL;H=? NB;N NB?S QCFF =IHNCHO? NI

=IGJFSCHNB?@ONOL? ;<M?HN=IHNCHOCHADOLCM>C=NCIH

@ 'MMO?;HIL>?LAL;HNCHAL?;MIH;<F?;NNILH?SM\@??M;H>=IMNMJOLMO;HNNI

31!UU;H>;H>

A %L;HN;HS@OLNB?LL?FC?@NB;NNBCM!IOLN>??GMH?=?MM;LS




 



Case 3:20-cv-00340-TSL-RHW Document 1 Filed 05/14/20 Page 38 of 38

";N?>+;S  

 
 M.;FIG;5O    
(IH;NB;H*<L;G685.')</)+@ILNB=IGCHA  .;FIG;5O+CMM ;L,I 
(IBH.&;GCFNIH685.')</)+@ILNB=IGCHA  0I<?LN +="O@@+CMM ;L,I 
&-%,*-4#**131**. +'11'11'..'!#,2#0$-0(312'!#
!IFOG<C;1KO;L? 2BCLN??HNB1NL??N ,5 -F>0CP?L.F 1N?
5;MBCHANIH "CMNLC=NI@!IFOG<C;  (;=EMIH +1
     
DIH;NB;H;<L;GBIA;HFIP?FFM=IG JQOGM=?HN?L@ILDOMNC=?ILA
DIBHB;GCFNIHBIA;HFIP?FFM=IG LG=>O@@GM=?HN?L@ILDOMNC=?ILA
 
+;>?F?CH?0 ?=B685.')</)+@ILNB=IGCHA  +;LE5BCN<OLH685.')</)+@ILNB=IGCHA 
&-%,*-4#**131**. 5&'2 30,.#41,#0 .**!
#G<;L=;>?LI!?HN?L 1OCN? #*;G;L FP> 1OCN?
1;H$L;H=CM=I !;FC@ILHC; LFCHANIH 26
     
G;>?F?CH?<?=BBIA;HFIP?FFM=IG GQBCN<OLHQBCN<OLHJ?PMH?L=IG
 
1S>H?S!0OJ?685.')</)+@ILNB=IGCHA  (IMBO;2IG+CMM ;L,I 
&-%,*-4#**131**. !*3-$+'11'11'..'
+;CH1NL??N 1OCN? #;MN!;JCNIF1NL??N
&IOMNIH 26 (;=EMIH +1
     
MS>H?SLOJ?BIA;HFIP?FFM=IG DNIG;=FO GMILA


::584+?9,582'/4:/,,9
 




S-ar putea să vă placă și