Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
"#$%&(')
83
84
85
86
87
Photo (4)
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
!"#$%&(6)
101
102
6.)
103
OF7%+!%())L L O07%>.&P0"N^DB%2,$% M-48="#$%*+&!;2I<$%OF7%>E _&9-:%*0.$%01
M-"N2$%0/05.& [:%8+0:%`# P0"N^DB% 2,$%& C1:%8C:%*-.-%=4=/8>:%L ["#>"#G
*-.-%=4+.2,$% M-"N2$%0/*!&O=$%&Q"#$%+. T!*U!; 2"#$%& C15"N^<1-%0/*!&*7O=$%&0+"1@
!"2%[.&*>. 7. "2%OF$%8 [:%8*Q.$%O=$%&0+"1a/ *-.-%=4=/89->:%L
104
*A,&*-.-%!,/ T!*U/D:%&T!*U!; >2%012%O!V.D%&=5-% -
T!*U Wg@ Wd (=)@ cc (--')@
0:%>E0Q"# !#Xh"NC%27%TI&J 0/*!&!"#$%=,$%8?1$%8 7"2%M-N"-%*+,&=5B%!"#$%=,$%8-"#
0-5$%8>4#&?"#$%*7+D% 9-0%&F-%O=$%&@ P="0%&*O=.-%O=$%&@ 0*C5.%9>e.>4#&O=$%&@
C.a%*!& C.a%BEO=$%& 0O!NC#!%+!;L O!NC#!%!;- @ .&*!&-E:I!;- *[.$%Ui%@
*$,Ui%05.& =5012%+0:%L
105
*A,&*-.-%!,/ T!*U/D:%&T!*U !;>2%012%O!V.D%&=5-% -
T!*U c)(-) (=) (X)
*A,&*-.-%!,/*DG] 0/A4#01 -"#-% W(( 2,$%& 0/Q,B%O=$%&@ CH2%*2.%-#"B%7.&
C1B%*C.$%&27%TI&TI&-"# 0/*!&+D% 2#"-%2,D%&O=$%&@ P="0%&*O=.-%O=$%&@ *>,&*Q.$%O=$%&@
7,-%F-%O=$%& 7>:%05.&O!NC#!%C15$% *[.$%Ui%@*$,Ui%05.&=5012%+0:%L
106
OF7%+!% (6)L L +D%-#D%2"#$%&@ CK"$%>.B.P0"N^DB%@ CB%A,.@ 012%(c)0/A4#] D4D-%
))&((D.+I=D%G2,$% 0/*!&+D%C.*+.-%>:%8 >I`"#l%*787-%A4#01 <D%[0%&g( =D%G-"#
TI&*Q.$%C.>E05.&OF7%>:%8 9-48="#$%*+&!;2I<$% 6 TI&- 0/A4#*+1^2,$% * .%`7%f
O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I-"#>. 0/*!&+D% 0/Q,B%=/8>:%L
107
*O!.Q"#f 0/Q,B%7:%&A4#&O=$%&05.& O!NC#!%=/8>:% L ["#GO!$% *-.%0+1$% F,/G<$% TI&<$%&CK"$%01
0/Q?Z-U%O!.&C.*+.-% [#2%BE>:%8 0/Q?Z+1$%05.& .& O=*>k824Q"!% .& C-%
*[.-%O!f 0/*!&+D% *7="#$%&2"#-%2,D%&=/8>:%L
OF7%+!%()')L L +D%-#D2
% "#$%&@ >4#&=,P0"N^DB%@ 012% (W) +!%-,-% @ 0/+4# 012(% )) ]
0/A4#01b& TI&<$%&*m& ?1$%8 U#-0/A4#01b& 0>$%&>$%&* & 2"#G>:% -#C.&CE05"N& ('(()=D%G .&
S$%&2"#G-"#B%2"#$% 0/-U%O!.&*!R+1" O=*>kG24Q"!%*a&2,$% 01D%O=7%O=7%*!&-.
0/[:%8>:%8 =;01>. ["#-#C.&CE05N"&05.&-"# -"#B%2"#$%[:%8*7=/G>:%-"# NDF
!;2I01-"#B%7.&C1B%OF7%>E *0.$%+/<$%8C"K$%01 *2,^O0$%=/8>:%L Q"#!; 0>$%&
>$%&* &Q"#>E>:% 9-84="#$%F,4^PFN"&*+&!;2I<$% 27%TI&C:%&OF7%>:%L
108
OF7%+!%()6)L L +D%-#D%2"#$%&@ >4#&=,P0"N^DB%@ 0$%&+,. >$%&*-5&+,. T-nV TI&=57%C,$%
>:%0/A4# 2,$%&*=;-%24#^*=;-%O!D%>,.&C.C5-% C15"N^<1-%Q?ZO!N=D%& DI&[" <$%
*+.-%9-:%8+K-. Q?Z0/*!&>E05.& .&O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I-"#>. 0/*!&+D% :HD%9-.&=/8
>:%L
109
6.'
*A,&*-.-%!,/*DG0/*!&+.2,$% OF7%!,.&>:%8
*A,&*-.-%!,/ 0>0.0K05.&
110
0/A4#2,$% 0/Q?Z+1$%27%TI& .&Q?Z0/*!&?"#$%>:%8 7C7%O!.&>4#&*7.$%[#2%*!&P!I&
O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I .& >4#&=;O!D% 0/*!&="#$%&>:%-"# -"#B%2"#$%M-4N*2,^=/8+>:%8 C"K$%>.
B.P0"N^DB%2,$%*D["#$%>E@ 0/C.*!&>EO!:%>E05.&- *O!.>:%L
111
*A,&*-.-%!,/ T!*U/D:%&T!*U!; >2%012%O!V.D%&=5-% -
T!*U S6@ D:%&T!*U 6Y(Q)
0:%>E015-"#B%7.&*7CH2%f Q?Z0/*!&O=$%&0O!NC#!%+!;L
112
] O!:%>EGCH2%*2.% 0/7.+$%&77%*Q&>E *UR>?q.CK"$%- pJ "2% 2,$%&]
+1"*>.O!:%="#$%PF"N& 01D%O=7% 012% >.&!; 0/7.+$%&TI&["D%C$%& 0:%+1" 0/7.+$%&
7.+,-% .& 05"N&>.&CH2%*2.% 0/7.+$%&77%*Q&>E *UR*00,D%7"#& .&*!&f
*UR*00,D%7"#&01 Q?Z0/O!.& .& TI&["D%C$%&-"#B%7.& C-%012%["#& [#2%BE*D>:%-"#
>"0%&Q:%&+0">:%L
113
OF7%+!% (') L L 0C"K$%P0"N^DB%@ *+H*!R-,5D%&*-5&+,.+1" *+H*!R-,5D%&a#D%&9-I&
*-5.$%&*a&2,$% *O=7"#-%*>. 0/+4#>"#G *+H*!R-,5D%& a#D%&9-I&*-5.$%&<$%&*D
TI&>D%&[,D%&@ *UR:,D%^+II2"#G>:% ?"#<$%a. (c)+-%*DG [" 0/*!&+D%2"#-$%
C.0*!&>OF$%8 0/A4#2.<D%-5>E05.&OF7%*>. -"#<;2.&?1$%8 -"#7"D%<0%&2"#G?17%TI& .&
0/*!&+D% 2"#-$%O!.& >,.&*+.-%*2.$%&BE+. 0/*!&+D%0C"#*9-.$%& 0/[:%8P!I&
P!I OF7%*9-.$%& O!D%C:%*O!.Q"#>PF$%8 0"0"2"#G-"#B%2"#$%0/*!&C"#*9-.$%& O!$%& [D%
*O!.Q"#+. *+D4+,.>.&?17%TI&J D.0:%OF$%8 0/[:%8+0:%`# *O!.Q"#>OF$%8
["#+,.>.&?17%TI&J D.0:%?1$%8 ?"#<$%a.(g)+-%*DG2,$% 0/[:%8+.2,$%C:%&
O!D%C:%>"0%&Q:%&P!I& O=.&+,.>.&?17%TI&D.0:%?1$%8 0/*!&="#$%&>OF$%8 O!D%C:%
0/*!&=/8+*9-.$%&>"+1"+>:%L L
114
*A,&*-.-%!,/ T!*U/D:%&T!*U!; >2%012%O!V.D%&=5-% -
T!*U WY (\)@
0/C-%012%01 ! 0/!4#&[/>"#G O=.&!7o:%&27%=#=# [:%8C15$%@ [:8%+D% .&
*!&-E:IC15$% *[.$%Ui%@*$,Ui%05.&=5012%+0:%L
115
B*DG [" C-%=4*!&*Df 2" -5*O!.+D% 0OF7%?"#$%*9-.$%&*O!.>:%L
Q?Z0/7.+$%&2,$% 0!;<$%*>.%C:%& *D.-%2"#&7.&+$%&05.&-"# +!%-,-%*-.%0+1$%01
(*+,&*-.-%!,/*DG) 0/A4#!"2%=;DI& =5"D% [" O!NC#!%*!&C15-%+"1>:%L ["#0/Q?Z
+1$%05.&01. C"K$%P0"N^DB% 2,$%!$%*D["#$%*9-.$%& *[.-% [.& O!>?"#$%O=$%&0+"1L
116
*A,&*-.-%!,/ T!*U/D:%&T!*U!; >2%012%O!V.D%&=5-% -
D:%&T!*U (Sd-=-c)
CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&05.&@ *+,&*-.-%!,/-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&@ 0/A4#-"#B%7.&
C1B%05.&>:% 0/A4# 2,$%&>"#G <$%=,$%8++1"+!;0:%L
117
6.6
0/*+2,-%O=$%&?1$%8 +CU% 2:%O!NO=$%&Q"#$%+.
*+,&*-.-%!,/ 0>0.0K05.&
* .-%*F.%O!!; OF7%+!%05.&>:% '()( *A,&*-.-%!,/*DG2,$% 0/*+2,-%
+.?1$%8 +CU% 2:%O!N+. Q$%805.&2,$% OF7%!,.&=/8>:%8 0>0.0K05.& OF7%>:%L
O0D%0.?"#$%$42<D%&C4#&2,$% S$%&OF7%+!%05.&-/8>"#G C.&2E OF7%+!%*!;$%&05.&7,. OF7%!,.&
=/8>:%L
118
05.&-"# <$%*+.-%M-:%8AK=,$%80O!N=/8*9-.$%&?1$%8 ["#>#"G 9-:%8AK=,$%8 0O!N*9-.$%&
*O!.>:%-"# 0"0"2"#G01 >4>,$%&012%20%&2$%[.&*9-.$%& 2.7.: 0/A4#
-"#B%7.&C1B%01 *O!.9-.&>:%L S$%&aE&-,/M-I&A,.+1" .C.- ) 0/A4# 6@ S 2"#G2,$%
C:%& 0/*+2,-%O=$%&-"# 05.&O!:%>E<$%*+.-%9-:%8AK=,$%8 0+=/8*!L
119
*A,&*-.-%!,/ T!*U/D:%&T!*U!; >2%012%O!V.D%&=5-% -
T!*U Sd (=)@ D:%&T!*U cW@ cc (-)@ ($)@ (7)
0/A4#-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&>:% 0/*+2,-%+.2,$% !;($%9-:%8AK77%*Q&=,$%8++0:%L
0/A4#-#"B%7.&C1B%05.& .& 0/*+2,-%[.&>:%8 7.+$%&05.&-"# 2:%O!N C-%012%
*+&["#&*7+0:%L 0/C-%012%05.&[:%8>:%8 "2%05.&-"# !;<$%=5"2%!"2%=,$%8O!N+0:%L
120
*0&O0D%&+. P0N"^DB%*-.%0+1$%>"#G*+.-%01 *OF+1$%&+D% ?1$%8*O!.!"#$%=,$%80+1"*9-.$%&
=!%O!2% O!2%O!D%C:%*OF9-.&=/8f *UR=$%=5"N<$%&01 0/7.+$%&=5N!%2,$%C-%012%0["#&a/
*D=/8>:%L
[-%!;-"7o+!%05.&D1$%8 !-%>-%f NDF 01 O!:%>E^CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&
C1B%*C.$%&-"#B%2"#$% P0"N^DB% *-.%0+1$% F/,^=/,T-nm-"# 2"#$%9-.&=/8P!I& OF7%?"#$%C15$%
*-5&+,. 0/A4# F/^, 0/05.&C.!"=
G# 5"D2
% $
, % F,$%8*F.-%77%*Q&*!&+D% *2.$%&Q"=
# /8*>.%C:%&
C#!%!"#$%=,$%80+1"`# O$$%&QD%=/8>:%L ["#^*9-.$%8 S$%&CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%-
0/7.+$%&05.& 001D%-D%>OF$%8 -D%^-,-%0:%OF7%*9-.$%&@ 0/A4# ' ?1$%8 6 05.&2,$% S$%&J
C-%012%0!;>OF$%8 2:%0O!N?"#$%*9-.$%&O!D%C:%*O!.9-.&+. P0"N^DB%*-.%0+1$%
T-nm- O=.&!;2I05.&C:%& C-%012%*+&["#&[.&>:%`# *O!.9-.&=/8>:%L
>"#^*>.% O=.&!;2I01 -"#B%7.&C1B%05.&-"#C:%& 0/7.+$%&*+2,-%P!I&=5"D%2,$%
["#&="#$%&O=$%& 0`#2%a/ *-5&+,.(+.B.- )>"#^*+.-%01>. ["#&="#$%&O=$%&OF7%>:%L
121
*A,&*-.-%!,/ T!*U/D:%&T!*U!; >2%012%O!V.D%&=5-% -
D:%&T!*U g)@ Sd (\)
P0N"^DB%*-.%0+1$% F,/^=,/>:% 0/A4#!"2%=5"D% :*D*C&D.+I*D.-%!"#$%&01
*+.-%C.*>. M-N"2$%0/C-%012%05.&-"# [:%8>,$%&*+2,-%O=$%& 0O!N+L
122
OF7%+!% (S)L L 0+0%&-#D%&O0"N^DB%@ 012%(6) +!%-,-%@ .0.-('Y)@ 0/A4# 012%
c@ g >"#^ :*D S D.+I=,/*-5.%2,$% +!%-,-%T-nV TI&*-5.%*-5.%<$%&Q"#>E01 M-N"2$%
0/05.&!;<$%>:%8 -t,2%-t,2% "2% ) C4#& .&>B%*Q.$%C.P!I& [:%8>,$%& *+2,-%
*7=/8>:%L L
123
*A,&*-.-%!,/ T!*U/D:%&T!*U!; >2%012%O!V.D%&=5-% -
T!*U cW@ cc
0/*!&O=$%&P!I&C15$% 0/05.&-"# 0/A4#2,$%*+2,-%P!I&01 P0N"^DB%*-.%0+1$%>"#G 0/+CU%
7.+$%&05.&?1$%82-,!"#G*Q.$%+0:%L
124
*A,&*-.-%!,/ T!*U/D:%&T!*U!; >2%012%O!V.D%&=5-% -
D:%&T!*U cc (X) (\)
!B%0/ OF7%>2%012%?"#$%>:%80/05.&01. )L *-.%0+1$% 2:%O!N 012%
>.&0!; 'L 0/+4#01b&C-%012%0!; 6L 27%TI&[-%!"# Q?ZO!N[.& SL Q?ZO!N[.&O=$%&0+1"
WL Q?ZO!N[.&0K 0[$%+1.&@ 0*>=5. cL 2#`# 0/+4#01b&-Q4#&OF2% gL 0/*!&>E-"#
>"* .$% 012% >.&C#!%[.& dL Q#2%PF/[.&>:%8 0/C-%012%05.&OF7%>:%L
!B%0/ OF7% >2%012%?"#$%>:%8 M-N"2$%0/05.&01. )L *-.%0+1$% 2:%O!N
012% >.&0!; 'L *-.%0+1$% 24Q"!%0!; 6L [#2%*!&>E (0/+4#01b&0`#2)% +/^
C-%012%0!; SL 27%TI&[-%!"#Q?ZO!N[.& WL Q?ZO!N[.&0K0+1" cL 0*>=5.@ 0[$%+1.&
gL 2#`# 0/+4#01b& (>")#G *-.%0+1$% F,/^@ F,/^=,/ - Q4#&OF2% dL 0/*!&>E-"#>"* .$%
012% >.&O!NC#!%[.& YL Q#2%PF/[.& >:%8 M-N"2$%0/05.&OF7%>:%L
125
0/A4#01b&01 C-%0=4=/8*!L C.&2E 01D%O=7%05N"&OF$%8 NDF Q?Z0/05.&-"#0E !B%0/ OF7%
>2%012%=/8P!I& -D%^-,-%>E *0.$%+/+$%8<$%& .&0/A4#01b& TI&<$%&*V&01 TI&7"#&2$%8@
TI&C10"#&@ T"I& #D%&M-I&@ TI&<$%&O0$%8?1$%8 TI&*F* .$%2"#^ *+1^2,$% 2"#$%=5$%>:%8*D+.2,$%
2"#$%?"#$%*9-.$%&@ XA#07"#-%*9-.$%& `"D%&*`.-%*O!.Q"#=/8>:%L
126
*A,&*-.-%!,/ T!*U/D:%&T!*U!; >2%012%O!V.D%&=5-% -
D:%&T!*U cg (=)@ !4#74 ()Y)
P0N"GDB%*-.%0+1$% F,/^=,/>:% 0/Q?ZDB% 2,$%&+1" 0/A4#05.&01 !4#74 )c OF$%8
*+&>,$%&[.&>:%8 -"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& >I&>I&++1">:%8 0/ *+ 2,-% ?1$%8
!4#74 )d + C-%<B%++1"[.&>:%8 -"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& >I&>I& ++1">:%8
M-N"2$%0/ *+ 2,-%05.&-"# -"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& 7I 7T% 2"#$%& !4#74 )Y OF$%8
05.&O!:%>E *+1^*01.-%2,$% 7.+$%&O!N7#+0:%L !4#74!; =5-% C-% + C,2%*2.%
-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&05.&@ *+,&*-.-%!,/ -"#B%7.&C1B%05.&@0/Q?Z+1$%05.&J 0:%
C-%012%!;<$%+0:%L
127
7.+$%&!4#74 ()c)05.&-"#C:%& 9-:%8=,$%80*!&!;L CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&
05.&01 C-%012%*+&["#&O=$%&0O!Na/ !4#74 )c 05.& -E&BE=,$%8 *2.$%&+. =,$%80O!N=/8!;L L
128
6.S
*+,&*-.-%!,/*C8C.*7.$%89-:%8*+& *0&=,D%&!4#74D0ED.05.&
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
6.W
*+,&*-.-%!,/*C8C.*7.$%89-:%8*+&*0&=,D%&05.&O!N7#+.2,$%
-"#&-.&=/8*>.7. #!%05.&7.+$%&
3. Campaign for free and fair elections (CaFFE), “ Parliamentary Elections, Final
Election Observation Report 8th & 20th April, 2010,”26th April, 2010.
137
10. The Carter Center, “ Special Report Series,2004 Indonesia Election Report,”
June 2005.
12. UNESCO, “ The Media and the Election Process Reference Material,” Pub-
lished by UNESCO,UN, Reuters Foundation, XIX, INDEX for free expression &
insi.
13. www.2010myanmarelection.info
14. www.anfrel.org
15. www.africa-union.org
16. www.article19.org
17. www.caffe.lk
18. www.ndi.org
138
!#"$%&(S)
139
140
O!:%>EG 2,-% O!:%>E>.+"1>:%?1$%8
'()( *+,&*-.-%!,/05.&
141
[$%+1.&Q4#&-"# *O!.+0B%Q"#+$% dd *+& =$%&-"# TI&7,.*[.-%O!=5$%
!;2B%L B$%&-.C 2,$%&- O0D%0.O!:%>E05.&*2,`. 0"0"2"#G >-% "#& "0%
7:%&7"0%-"# -. -,B%*!&0B%8@ -.-,B%*!&+0B%8 2!%0*2.%+1"*D>:%82"#$%
Q"#!;2!%0*2.%-"#B%]- ?"#$%$4*+& .i.a-%-"# +!%2:%=/82/8 2,-% O!:%>E
05.&+/^ C4#P=4N*+& 2,-% +!%2:%*!&?"#$%O=$%& 0+1"=/8!;aE&L 2!%0*2.%`. .i.
>"0%&F"#G 2,-%*2.8 C4#*C.-%>:%8 2!% $% .&+1"=/8!;2B%L *D.-%Q-%2,/+CU%
*DD/G O!:%>E05.&`. 0"0"2"#G >-% "#& "0%@ 7:%&7"0%-"# 0"0"2"#Ga.>.
-.-,B%=/8+P!I& -"#B%8 .&-"#B%-"#&@ -"#B%8<0%&-"#B% *-5.$%&=/8+!;2B%L -"#B%8*O=
*[.-%*!R01. -"#B%+!%=/8+O=$%&!/ OF7%!;*2.82B%L
U#2"BOF7%+!%-*2.8 '((d=#?17%01. M-4N*2,G=/8+2/8 O!:%>2
E 7%>D
" &% *-5.%
*>Q4&# =/+
8 2/8 D.X7%0D
# 2
% $
#" &% *+&OF7%!;2B%L M-I&0.&2/8 >a.<*a& ?q+.B%
M-4N*2,^2/8 =;2"#$%&01. ?"#$%$42-.+/8 -E :I-"#+BEP!I& -E:I-B%QB%*+&D/G
O!D%C:%[E*[.$%*+& -"7o+!%*2,-"# C#!%9-+!;2B%L ?"#$%$42,$%& $% .&D/G
2"#$%&>EO!:%>.&2"#G+/8 CE0Ka<[E*[.$%*+&-"# ["["*+.-%*+.-% *Q.$%+,-%F"#G
2,-% 22%?"#$%7,0%&0+1"2/8 =;05"N&01. ?"#$%$42-.- -E :I-"#BE+2.-
>a.<!/OF7%!;2B%L +BE=/82/8 -E :I`.Q"#+$%C:%& ?"#$%$42-.74:HD%&D/G
9-:%80B%Q"#+$% *O!.!*C.-%* .$% 0+1"=/8!;aE&L +1$%&C$%&>">.2/8 -"7o-*2.8
s"#C%=5N!%01b&M-I&>D%&*+H+/8 ?"#$%$4*+& +:%01D%&=5-%05.&D/G >EG+/^ .i. *++1:%
2:%P0/C"#0KQ"#2/87"#&+"0%0K*9-.$%8 ?"#$%$42-. -E :I*2,-"# 0BE=/82/8 2,-%
*D.-%Q4#&+CU%`. O!:%>E 05.& -"#B%8<0%&-"#B%*-5.$%&@ -"#B%8 .&-"#B%-"#&P!I&
-"#B%8*O=*[.-%*!R -"#B%+!%=/8+O=$%&!/ OF7%!;2B%L =5$%&=5$%&*F&0P!I& 0"0"9-0x.@
0"0"a<O!D%C:% [E*[.$%*+&-"7o05.&-"# C#!%*Q.$%=/89-+!;2B%L
Q"#!;OF7%+!%?17%=#-"# >4#&>!%O=$%& + O!:%>E05.&>:%>. O!:%>EG
2,-% .&-"#&+.OF7%*9-.$%&@ O!yD.OF7%2"#$%& O!:%>E05.&-"#B%2"#$%>.
+$%Q"#$%*OF+1$%&=/8+*9-.$%&-"# [$%+1.&7,.*2,^O0$%?"#$%!;2B%L -5!% 2:%&
-.C01. O!:%>E27%TI&27%*B.-%O=$%&+/8 Q4#&OF2%=5-%>:%>. *+& !;Q4#&
*OF OF7%2B%Q"#2.-"# *+& =$%&D/G D.X7%0#D%2"#$%&C,D%-.C *O= *D05.&
- *FRO!*D!;>:%L 22"BOF7%+!%27%=#+1"!;*>&2B%L
142
UI!/B$%& *+& =$%&C"#G Q"#C"#-%+$% s"#C%=5N!%01b&M-I&>D%&*+H+/8 20$% -,-%
=5C#!%M-4[.&2/8 0>0.0KM-I&C"#G -,-%-,-%-,$%&-,$%& O0$%*B.$%0"9-01. OF7%!;
2B%L UIC"#7I7T% -,-%=5[.&!;C5-%D/G 0* .$%O0$%2/8C#!%M-40KC"#G >0"#$%&2,$%
*70B%8 *OF-"#[#2%*!&>E*2,-*2.8 O=.&0`#2%!;aE&L O!:%>EG Q4#&
OF2%C"#GQ"#+0B%8 2D:%& .&OF$%8 -5I+,.>.&05.&+/8 Q4#& OF2%!/ OF7%!;2B%L
*U>=4 -5I+,.>E@ +,.>.&05.&`. O!$%!- *+.-%+1"C.2/8 +D%C"#*D2/8 CE7"0%&05.&-"#
2.<D%>">"=#=4-.-,B%=/82/8 2,-% p2"#G7I7T%[.&2/8 OF7%7T%27%=#C4#&
`D%=5-%!5-% *O!.$%&C/>,.&=/+
8 !;2B%L p 77%Q$%*+&27%=# OF7% B"-
# -
, `
% .-,-%
0+1"* .$% 9-47:%O!NC#!%[.&2/8 C#!%9-40KM-I&`. O!:%>E05.&+/8 2.<D%>"2/8
Q4#&OF2%=5-%*9-.$%8 0*015.%C$%82/8 C1:%8 *O!.$%&05.& OF7%*!R=/8+O=$%&OF7%!;2B%L
*UR* .$%QD%&7#9-:%-"#B%2"#$%C:%& >-%*a&-*D C-%02$%-*C&
C,2%*O0.-%=/8+!;2B%L
O!:%>ECE[#+/^ -"#B%8 .&-"#B%-"#& Q4#&OF2%=5-%05.&`. O0D%0.CEG F,/G
7:%& 2,-% 0:%015 *+&!;2B%Q"#2/G 2"#$%& 2.-"# [-%!;OF7%+!%
UI>4#&=#- >">.[$%+1.&7,. *F.%O!*D!;>:%L O!$%&[D%7,.OF7%!,.&=/82/8 dd
*+& =$%&@ Q"#+1B%C7%7D7%P!"NC/0K?1$%8 D.X7%0#D%2"#$%& O!yD.01>:% O!:%>E05.&J
a<+1$>
% D%*+&?1$%8 O!D%C:%[E*[.$%?$
"# %*+& -"7o .&C4#&`. O!:%>GE Q4#& OF2%+/^
+CU%05.&!/ OF7%!;2B%L
U;8*9-.$%8 =# '()( *+,&*-.-%!0
/, 1.C/ aB%C!
"# / M-"N2$%O!$%Q$% -,-=
% 5
O!$%Q$%[.&>:% Q"#*7-.0E O!:%>ECE[#+/^ Q4#& OF2%-"# .&-"#&?"#$%0B%
Q"#C"#G+1"+$% *+1^-OF7%7T%*2,C"#!/ Q$%[.&2/8 -,-% 2"#$%& 0OF7%?"#$%A4#>.0-
QD%G-5$%a-% *OF-"#*2.$%01 [,-%>,.&*7?"#$%2B% Q"#2/8 $% .&D/G C.&
C.+1"*D*9-.$%&*O!.C"#!;2B%L O!:%>EGQ?Z!;<$%>:%8 Q4#& OF2% 0:%015
*+&!;2B% Q"#2.-"# .&C4#&-"# >"*7C"#!;2B%L
B=# '()( *+,&*-.-%!,/-"#C:%& 9-!% 2:%&2=# *DD/G
+$%Q"#$%+KO0$%0B%Q"#C"#G+1"+$% z *D [.&01. !;<$%9-0B%8 >I&>I&*>. ?"#$%$4*+&
!;2I*2,@ !,/>,$%&0B%8 77% 7"#&+D/G@ =$%& -5$%& + B=#!,/-"# >!"2%0*01.-%a/
<$%-7.&0B%C"#G Q4#&OF2%2/G ?"#$%$4*+& $% .&7#*2,@ 77% 7"#&+*D.-%=4O!N
143
O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I@ O!:%2,$%&O!:%! 0IUIB.05.&D/G $%2.D-%*!R01. +1"*D9-2/8
CE0K-,D%B-% >4#&O!N*D9->E .&C4#&-"# 7T%&7.&*7C"#2/8 *0&=,D%&*2,+1"!;2B%L
O0D%0.O!:%2,$%&01.+1"2/8 Q"#&=4*-.$%&=4OF7%>C"#@ *+& M-I&Q4#&?1$%8 *+&
!;Q4#&C:%&OF7%2/8 O!:%>ECE[#+/8 C"# !%=5-%@ O!:%>E05.& a.C"#=5$%>C/L p2"#G
a.*2,7T%&7.&*D9-!;>C/Q"#2.-"# *> =5.>"9-!;+/8C.& C"#G*0&7+.+1"!;
2B%L O!:%>E05.&`. *+,&*-.-%!,/-"# s,"N-%*-.-% C#!%=5$%9-!;>C.&@
U;010`#2% O!:%>E05.&`. 0/[,-%*!&=5$%*D9->C.&L *9-.$%& 05"N&05"N&*9-.$%8
O!:%>E05.& 0/[,-%*!&+0B%Q"#+$%*+. aB%C"#0/*!&+0B%Q"#2.@ aB%>EG-"#*2.8
0/*!&>$%82B%Q"#2.-"# >"* .$%C#!%[.&9-!;>C.&Q"#2/8 *0&=,D%&05.&7,.
+1"!;2B%L
O0D%0.O!:%>E05.&
O0D%0.O!:%>E05.&+/8 *D [.&-"# UI*D+.01. *[.-%O!=5$%!;2B%L
O!:%>E05.&`. 0"0"2"#G a<+1$%>D%*+&D/G 7.&<2%*D*+& Q$%*O!* .$% A#D%&-D%
*D+>:%-C,/P!I& O=.&?"#$%$405.&01.+1"2/8 O!:%>E*2,(*U>2,$%&01. C,D%=/82/8?17%
*2,- O0D%0.?"#$%$4*D.-%01. -5D%=/82/8 C. "#D/G -*0.{UI&B.&2"#GC"# ?"#$%$4*2,-
?"#$%$4>.&*2,) =47.&+2/8 CEGa<7:%&7"0%Q"#2.05"N&-"# 0++1"9-!;L U;*9-.$%8C:%&
?"#$%$4*+&-"# 7"2%<$%7.&F"#G *O= *D0+1"aE&C"#G >4#&>!%0"!;2B%L UI *D [.&01.
M-"N-%>:%OF7%*7@ 0M-"N-%>:%OF7%*7 '()( *+,&*-.-%!,/Q"#2. OF7%C.
*2.801.OF7%!;2B%L -t,D%*2.%2"#G CE$B%05.& *D?1$%8 O!:%>E05.&?1$%8 -"#B%7.&
C1B%*C.$%&05.&-"# ["*2,^*O!.Q"#9-:%82/8 =;01. 2"#$%&O!:%01.OF7%*D2/8 C-%+1"
+1"2+.&*2,-"# *2,^O0$%C.+2.*2,+1"!;2B%L C-%+1" O!:%>E05.&+/8 *D
[.&`.Q"#+$% 0"0"a<+!%2:%*+&01C,/P!I& -5D%2.7"2%0<$%7.&?"#$%>:%8 =5-%
27%=5-%?1$%8 0:%>E05.&-"# 0:%-/8>"#G 0/*!&+0:%Q"#>:%-"# 0>"2/G =5-%`.
C-%+1" *O= *D 01D%OF7%!;>:%L
U;*!0B%8C:%& O!:%>E .&C4#&`.Q"#+$% *+,&*-.-%!,/Q"#2/8 +1"2+.&
-"#C:%& 0C,/0*>, OF2%>D%&9-+01.!;L B=#C-%+1" =5"D%01. O!:%>E05.&+/8a<`.
+1$%>D%0K=-%=/2.*+.@ !,/>,$%&>E77% 7"#&+/8 ["D%&=5N!%0K*9-.$%8!; ?"#$%$4*+& *!R01.
144
CK!%+1.&0K@ 7"2%<$%7.&0K 0+1"*!0B%8 *+,&*-.-%!,/ 02#"$%=$% ' !2%*C.-% C"#01.
*2.8 7"2%<$%7.&0K 2-%C.0B%C"#G =D%G01D%&0"!;2B%L
2-B%20%&9-*2.8 *+,&*-.-%!,/D/G !-%>-%C"#G O!:%>E*2, a.*2,
>"[.&C/@ aB%C"#7T%&7.&*D>C/@ a.-"# C"# !%*D>C/@ aB%C"#>*a.[.&
*2,+1">C/@ a.-"#B4#9-:%>C/Q"#2/8 O!:%>E-"# s`"#O!N2/8 *0&=,D%&*2,-"#
?"#$%$4*+&!;2I*2,-7C"#G 0IUIB.@ *+,&*-.-%!,/*-.%0+1$% @ 2!%0*2.% 7"#&+ Q4#&
7T%&7.&*!&9-!;+/8C.&Q"#2.-"# 0=5$%80+/D/G [!%*0&=5$%!;2B%L *+,&*-.-%!,/
0<$%aE&@ 0<$%>$%8aE&Q"#2/8 $% .&7#05.& 2,-%*2.8 >I&O=.&*0&=,D%&05.&
[!%*0&!;TI&0B%L
O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I
O!:%=#"$%PF"N& *DD/G aB%C"#*9-.$%8!/ *!RC.*!RC. ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I
27%=#OF7%C.2B%L U;*!0B%8 [$% +O!:%="#$%PF"N&`. ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I2=# *DD/G
P!I&7C,B% OF7%-22%QD%&05.& C#!%*D>C.&C"#G *2,&0"!;2B%L O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I+/8
*9-:.7.20%&[/01. UI0"#-*+7I -"# 6) M-"0%2"2" [:%8*O!.[.&*!0B%8 /UI!;2I+/8
7:%&A4#&*+& *O==4>*a.2+.&05.&Q"#2/8 7. #!%[/01.*2.8 UI0"#-*+7I Q"#2/8
7-.&`. 27%=,D%&010!;!;aE&L
O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I-"# *>*>=5.=5.*C8C.9-:%80B%Q"#+$% >E2"#G=5O![.&2/8
!;2I0E<;U*2,@ !;2I+/8 * .$%?"#$%*+& s5b`.*2,`. 77%2!%27%2!%+/8 77%Q$%
*+&DB%*O001.+1"2/8 05.&O!:%>E-"# aB%C"# +$%Q"#$%["D%&=5N!%0C/ Q"#2/8 77%Q$%*+&
!4#74[/- 0[,-%!;aE&L /UI*2.8 O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I-"# *0&=5$%!;2B%L !;2I`.
01D%2-B%!/ O!:%>E-"# C#!% *-t,&O!N01.C.&L U;010`#2% .i. 2,-%
>-%Q-%F"#G 2,-%C.&Q"#2. *>=5.+1$%&C$%&* .$% *O!.F"#G>$%8!;P!IL *O!.
!"$
# =
% ,$0
%8 +"+
1 $%*>.%C:%&*-.$%&@ [#2%*F.%*O!.Q"C
# 0
G"# ++$%*>.%C:%&*-.$%& -"B
# %8
`.-"# O!D%P!I& 7T%&7.&>4#&>!%F"#G >$%8!;P!IC"#G *O!.C"#!;2B%L
Population as Enemy `# Q-%C-%>*a.[.&*D0:%Q"#C15$% O!:%>E
CE[#?1$%8 D.&C:%0K2:%*Q.-%+D%0OF7%?"#$%!;L a.9-.$%8C/Q"#*2.8 DI&-!%C.
2/8 *+,&*-.-%!,/D/G 2E *D.-%-,B%- C#"#-%!;C.0B%8 *9-.$%&2+.&
145
05.&`. =$%s5.&2"#G-"# >0"#$%&01. D.0:%!5-%7.+$%& >,$%&C"#-%?"#$%2/8 2,-%
*9-.$%8!/ OF7%!;2B%L U8; O!$% O!:%="#$%PF"N&7I&!,.&*+&OF7%2/8 (W) >"D%&2D%F#D%&*2,-"#
O0D%0.Q-%>,B%*+&C#!%$D%&- -"#B%7.&C#!%-"#$%*!&*D+2/8 -"7o05"N&`.C:%&
7"#&+*$,D/G !;2I*[.$%2B%Q"#2.05"N&-"# >-%*>[E*DO!D%!;*>&2B%L
UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#05.&
?"#$%$4*+&OF7%7T%[/01. *+& M-I&Q4#&*D+.-!;<$%2/8 $% .&7#05.&
OF7%!;2B%L UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#05.& *DD/G $% .&D:%&2.@ a-%74#-*D
0=40+!%?"#$%*C.-%* .$%F" .&*!& 2"#-%="#-%=4*D+2.`. 01D%!;2B%L U;*!0B%8
O!:%>ECE[#2+!%C4#&+/8 *015.%C$%8=5-%*+.$%O=:%OF7%C"#G 2.<D%aB%*C.-%
M-I&2B%Q"#2.-"# >2"O!N0"9-!;+/8C.&L 0"0"2"#G`. *+&M-I&2/8 =D%&-u
01.*+.-%*D2.-"#*+. >"9-!;+/8C.&C"#G *0&C"#!;2B%L
07T%&7.&[.&*>&C/ 7T%&7.&9-F"#G 2"#-%2,D%&C"#!;2B%L >0"#$%&2,$%0B%8
C#!%*Q.$%=5-%05.&OF7%C.0:%Q"#>:% -"#C:%& 7T%?1C4#&>,$%&[.&*7C"#!;2B%L
27%=5"N^*>. UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#05.&`. s"#C%=5N!%01b&M-I& M-"N-% UI0"#-*+7I
$% .&7# =5$%&=5$%& ?"1!%-,!%2.05"N&-"# O!NC#!%*D!;*>&2B%L
0IUIB.05.&
*+&M-I&2/8 *D.-%-u- 0IUIB.05.&OF7%!;2B%L O!:%2,$%&01.
?"#$%$4*+&>2$%&05.&-"# 0OF7%0*D [:%8>,$%&P!I& *F.%O!*!&*D2/8 !2%7T%[#2%
X5.DB%*7.$%*+ ?17%QB%DI&!;&+1"!;2B%L O!:%2,$%&0IUIB.05.&`. -D%G >2%05.&
9-.&@ 2.&QI&=5-%*2, 9-.&-*D ++$%+>*C.-% *D++.<$%BE?"#$%>C"#
7T%27"#-%C/ 2,D%&2"#-%*D2/8 2,-% >" 012%O!N+01.OF7%!;2B%L
?"#$%$4!#$
" %0IUIB.05.&Q"#+$%C:%& 2-B%*72D.01D%2B%Q"#+$% 2F-%-
*=2%0+1"*2.82/8 72.C$%*=2%!4#74 <;UOFD%G2/8C#!%$D%&-"#C:%&C#!%!;L ["#-%2D%
2/8 +CU%*2.8+01.!;L U;*!0B%8 2F-%-C:%& O!:%>E05.&-"# aB%C"#
0/*!&>$%82B%Q"#2.05"N&@ 0/a.*9-.$%8 *!&>$%82B%Q"#2/8 !:.*!&C#!%$D%&05"N&
-"#C:%& ["["0"0"C#!%C"#G+!;2B%L ?"#$%$4+/8 >0"#$%&01. 2.<D%*-52B%Q"#2.05"N&OF7%F"#G
146
=5"D%01I!;*>&2B%L
O!:%! >4CH$%8V.D05.&+/8 O0D%0.a.>.D/G [#2%CH$%82/8 7I 7T%
05.&D/G O!:%!*+.-% O0D%0.05.& C#!%*Q.$%*D2/8 ,D%C"#$%&0IUIB.*2, .&C4#&
-"# *C8C.9-:%80B%Q"#+$% O0D%0.8?"#$%$4*+&?1$%8 !2%>-%P!I&*2.8 *+,&*-.-%
!,/-"# P!"N$%!,/27%=#C"#G 9-:%8AKQ4#&OF2%@ AKO0$%>4#&>!%*D9-2.-"#*2,^+
!;2B%L >E2"#G01.0E<;U*+&+. +:%0D
1 %&=5-%0+1">C"#@ 0`.s5b`.-5-5
TI&2:%=5-%C:%&+1"9-!4# 0*!R!;aE&L p2"#G>:% O0D%0.?"#$%$4UI0"#-*+7I++1"*+&-"#
27%>-%C4#&["#$%* .%C.9->:%82"#$% O0D%0.?"#$%$42,$%&+1" 0:%>:%8 UI0"#-*+7I
$% .&7#05.&-"#0Q"# *[.-%=4*!&>:%8@ 7T%&7.&*!&>:%8 0E<;U05"N&+!%2:%
=5-%05"N&0+1"!;L
O!:%!0IUIB.05.&`. *+,&*-.-%!,/-"# CE27%*B.-%*+D7%*D!4#
Q$%8Q$%83.2%!4#A"#-%-&E *D2/8 3.2%!4#Q+.C"#-5$%89-42B%L Game Schema
-/8>#"G >*a.[.&O!N0E2B%L a.C"#GC:%&Q"#*2.8 *+,&*-.-%!,/D/G NLD
?17%a-% .&P!"N$%!,/01. *2.%C1D%*+&>0.&05.&!I!I NLD a-%- +!%C"#-%9-C"#G!/
OF7%!;2B%L
O!:%!+"10IUIB.05.& *DD/G 05"N&>.&UI0"#-*+7I!;2I F,/G=5N!% NLD
*!R01.C:%& >4*B.eT%+1"?"#$%@ *[.-%=4?"#$%!;2B%L >"#G*>.% $;D/G02E $;8+D%>E
>*a.05"N&[.&-. +!%2:%>:%8 *O= *D05"N&01. O0D%0.?"#$%$4UI0"#-*+7I++1"
*+& 2,-%@ +CU%*-.$%&++D% 2,-% *[.-% -EOF7%0:%0[$%!;L p2"#G+/8
*Q.$%+,-%=5-%`. UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#05.& *!R01. M-"N2$%7I+$%=5-%=5>C"#
OF7%*D!;2B%L O!:%>E*2,- >E2"#G-"#aB%C"# >*a.[.&>C/ Q"#2.-"#
07E&70%&!/ 7I+$%=5-%=5>C"#05"N& *Q.$%+,-%O=$%&`. O!:%>ECE[# *!R *72D.[.&
>:%8 *Q.$%+,-%=5-%05"N&`# 0*O!.?"#$%!;L
OF7%>$%8>:%01. O!:%>E05.&J 01D%2-B%C"#C.&=5-%-"# *0&O0D%&+D%
C"# !%P!I& C"# !%=5-%05.&-"# 01D%2-B% OF:%8Q:%*!&?"#$%+D% 2,-% O!:%>E
05.&a-%- +!%2:%*!&+D%C"# !%!;2B%L U;01 O!:%>E*2,- UI0IUIB.*2,+/8
7,0%&D/G Informed Decisions *2, C#!%?"#$%01. OF7%!;2B%L 0/[:%80B%8O!:%>E-"#
aB%>"#G 0/[:%8?"#$%2B%Q"#2. *O!.>$%8!;2B%L
147
O0D%0.O!:%>ED/G O0D%0.8CEG F,/G 7:%&`. *0,&F,.&=5"D%-*D *>Q4#&=5"D% ["
2*C15.-%C4#&01. aB%>EG -E :I010!;a/ -"#B%8-"#-"#B%>. .&-"#&=/89-2.!;L
2>-%C4#& aB%8>EG -E :I01 0+=/8aE& Q"#2.05"N&+/8 3"- *9-.$%&`.
77% .i.+1$%7D7%+/8 F"?1"!%0K*9-.$%8OF7%!;2B%L /UI*2.8 O!:%! 0IUIB.05.& *DD/G
3"- *9-.$%&OF7%2/8 77% .i.+1$%7D7% *!5.-%-,B%>,.&*+&Q"#2/8 -"7o-"#
*[.-% -EOF7%* .$% C#!%0*!&?"#$%aE&Q#"+$% >E2"#G[#2%CH$%8*O!.Q"#*D2.
.&C4#&`. O!:%>E 2,-% *[.-% -EOF7%?"#$%C.& 0OF7%?"#$%aE&C.&Q"#2.-
*0&=,D%&M-I& OF7%*D!;2B%L O!:%!0IUIB.05.&`. O!:%>ECE[#+/8 >*a.[.&-"#C/
0*7.*9-.aE&@ NLD +/^>*a.[.&-"# O!:%>ECE[#>*a.[.& OF7%!4#*F.%2B%L
-"#B%8a-%- 0`#2%aE&Q"#+$% 9-.&[/-*!RC.2/8>E*2,-"# >4>B -5"N&
=47.&=,$%80*!&aE&Q"#2/8 O0$%05"N& +1"*D2.-"# *2,^*D+!;2B%L /U;-"# *O!.$%&?"#$%!;
*>&>C.&L =5"D0
% 1I*>&>C.&L -#7+.*Q& +1"*>&>C.& Q"2
# . O!:%!- 0IUB
I .
05.& 2,-% *0&=,D%&OF7%!;2B%L B$%&2"#G`. O!:%>E 2,-% >4#&2:%82/8
>2$%& =5-% C-% 01D%-"# *!&?"#$%+/8C.&Q"#2.-"# -"#B%8-"#-"#B%O!D%*0&F"#G
>$%82B%L *+.-%2B%Q"#C/ 27%05"N&*!;8L U;*!0B%8 -t,?#%!%2"#G`. O!:%>E [/-
O!:%>EOF7%2/8 2,-% 0"0"*O=*[.-%*!R 0"0"+!%2:%F"#G 2,-% 2:%82:%80["
*>&aE&Q"#2.-"# >"*7=5$%!;2B%L
Online*!R01.+"12/8O0D%0.05.&
$%2.D-%-"# >4#&O!NP!I& ,D%C"#$%&*!R01. +1"*D9-2/8 O!:%!*+.-%
O!:%>E05.& *D?1$%8C:%& O!:%!01.*+.-%*D9-C"#G 0"0"2"#G01. 2.<D%0+1"aE&
Q"#2/8 *2,& O0$%05"N&[-% O0D%0.?"#$%$4Q"#$%+. >2$%&74#-"# 2.& QI&
-$%&-$%&+BE?"#$%2/8 *D [.&01. 0"0"D/G Q-% 7!%+1"2/8 0">.&7#*2,
0"2%*Q, *!;$%& >$%&*2,-"# =,$%8 C0%&27%=# *DD/G >E2"#GC"# !%0B%8 =5-%
C-%05"N&-"# 7#7:%&*!&?"#$%0B%@ !"#G*!&?"#$%0B%Q"#+$% 01D%-D%2/8 Q4#&OF2%=5-%=5F"#G
*[.-% -EOF7%?"#$%0B%Q"#2.-"# >2"O!N0"9-*7=5$%!;2B%L ,D%C"#$%&*!R01.
148
+"12/8 O!:%!*+.-%O0D%0.05.&`. -t,D%*2.%2"#G O!:%>ECE[#+/8 =-% =/-"#
-"#B%=5$%&7.0*!&?"#$%aE&C"#G =47.&+2B%L >E2"#G *O!.*D2. .&C4#&`. 0$%&2"#G
=i*C&Q-%*2.$%8[.&C"#-%TI&C"#G *O!.*D>C#"a/L -t,D%*2.%2"#G-"# a.
*OF010*!&?"#$%aE&L UI0"#-*+7I++"1*+&- 27%O!.&>.&01 0*C15.G?"#$%aE&C"#G 2$%&0.
C,D%&2.-"# Facebook *2, *!R01.C:%&*2,G*D+!;2B%L
O0D%0.8?"#$%$4*+&*=;$%&*Q.$%05.&
O0D%0.?"$
# $
% +
4 /8*=;$%&*Q.$%05.&-u`. !,$!
%8 ,$C
%8 $%&C$%&*O!.++$% .&+7+.
0+1"!;aE&L C,2%C!%*+& +BE*!&=/82/8 s"#C%=5N!%* .$%QD%& -C,/C"#G *D.-%!"#$%&
*=;$%&*Q.$%05.&OF7%2/8 TI&?#@ TI&*D<$%&@ TI&>D%&*+H [" O!:%>E05.& .&0-"#&=/8+aE&@
.&-"#&?"#$%*C.-%* .$%C/ >4#&0-5=/89-aE&L >E2"#G+/8 +1.&!;&C12/8 *-.$%&-,-%
*2,-"# FB%P!I&*O!.++$% O0D%0.8>0"#$%&01.+1"=/82/8 [-%!;*=;$%&*Q.$%05.&`.
aB%C"#*O!.*O!. O!:%>E*2,+/8a<-"# O0|$%82$%*!&2/8 C#!%$D%&OF7%2/8 2#"$%&O!:%7I&!,.&
F,4GPF"N&2"#&2-%* .$% aB%>E01 C#!%0*!&?"#$%=/89-!;aE&L U;*9-.$%8*D.$%*!RC.0B%8
*=;$%&*Q.$%05.&-"# M-"NP!I& *0&=,D%&[#2% [.&=5$%2.- ?"#$%$4*+& .i. +BEF"#G
7T%&7.&*D9-2B%Q"#+$% O!:%>E*2,+/8a<-"# 01D%2-B% O0|$%82$%*!&?"#$%F"#G
Q"#2/8 *+&-"# 0"0"2"#G .i.+BEA4# >-%>-%[-% *-5.%P!I& 7T%&7.&[.&!;+/8C.&
Q"#2.!;!/=$%s5.L +!%>.& UI0"#-*+7I*=;$%&*Q.$%05.&-C:%& UI0"#-*+7I
++$% .&C4#&*-.$%&>,.&01.!; Q"#2.[-% a.*9-.$%8aB%C"#Q"#2. aB%>E01
0*O!.?"#$%9-aE&L
*D.-%Q4#& *DD/G D"X4#&>*a.*O!.C"#2.-*2.8 [-%-*F.%O!=/82/8
F,/G 7:%& >I&>I&!#X"hNC% >I&>I&`. >.0D%O!:%>ECE[# >"=5$%9-2/8 =#
*0&=,D%&05.&D/G !2%>-%P!I& aB%C"#7T%&7.&[.&9-!;>C/L aB%C"#7T%&7.&9-01.
!;C/L 0/20%&=4a-%-+1"=/82/8 O!:%>ECE[#-*2.8 =#-"7o01.C:%&=!%2:%
2:%!;!/L 2"2%-.C-OF7%+!%05.&- >$%=D%&7.*-.$%&*-.$%&+BE[.&9-
P!I& OF7%2/8 O!:%>0
E 5.&`. -"B
# %8 .&-"-
# "#&P!I& -"B
# 9% -0x. -"B
# F
% D%2I&F"G# Q$%>$%!
8 ;!/L
149
-t,D%*2.%2G"# CE$B%05.& *DD/G *O!.C"2
# .- aB%>E*2, a.!/C!
# C
% !
# @% aB%-7
" !
o /
*-.$% [:%*F.%*F.% 0"0"2"#G -"#B%-5"N&7I&!,.&[-% O!:%>ECE[#s`"#O!N*>.
7T%&7.&*2,&*=R0K05.&?1$%8 UI '()( *+,&*-.-%!,/D/G !2%>-%>:%05.&-"# 7T%&7.&
C#!%*Q.$%*!&9-!;C"#G *02q.+!%=4C"#-%+!;2B%L L
O0D%0.CE$B%-,D+
% -%
Myanmar lunge Network (26-9-2010) [#2%O!D%=5-%
150
-,0%&P=4-#D%&?1$%8 *+,&*-.-%!,/+CU%
151
[-%!;*-5&+,.2,$% "0%*O= d(( <D%&-5$% ["+1"*9-.$%& *02q.
*-5&+,.01 *D["#$%>E27%TI&- Q"#>:%L -,0%&P=4-#D%&P0"N^DB%J *-5&+,.05.&2,$%
!; <$%OF7%>:%8 *>.-%-#D%*-5&+,.2,$% 0/*!&>:%8 *O= *D01. O!:%=#"$%PF"N&
!;2I27%=#01C,/f -5D%>:%8 0:%>:%8!;2I01 0/[:%8=,$%80+1"*9-.$%& 0"0" -"#B%!"#$%
C,2%C!%=,$%8OF$%8 0/*!&=,$%80+1"a/ O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I01 >-%Q"#$%>E05.&- *7.$%89-:%8*D
>:%8 *D [.&05"N& OF7%>:%8 2,-% B=$%- 0/*!&=5$%*>.%C:%& 0/A4#*+1^>"#G
*+.-%01 0/*!&=5$%7"2%0+1"*2.8!/ C1:%8O!D%C.=/8*9-.$%&@ O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I01 -"#B%7.&
C1B%*C.$%& -E01C,/f -5D%>:%8!;2I05.&J -"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& -E0+1"
*9-.$%&@ 0"0"2"#G*-5&+,.2,$% "0%*O= W(( +1"P!I& 0/*!&?"#$%>:%8CETI&*+01. 27%*[.$%
*-5.%+1"*9-.$%& *>.-%-#D%*-5&+,.01 [-%!; 2"#$%& M-4N*2,^+!4#?1$%8 !2%>-%
f Q"#!; *-5&+,.2,$%*D["#$%>E27%TI&01 !;2I74#UI0"#-*+7I *[,*[,*+,&*-.-%!,/
-5$%&!*D7T% =5"D%*DGC:% 'D.+I=D%G2,$% Q-%>,B%*O!.9-.&>:%L
!;2I74#UI0"#-*+7I *[,*[,*+,&*-.-%!,/-5$%&!*D=5"D%OF7%>:%8 ?"#($%a.
g+-%*DG2,$% *-5&C-%*D O!:%>E 05.&7#01. 0/*!&D:%&7D7%@ -"#B%!"#$% =,$%8 *+&
7>:%2"#G-"# *>=5.D.&C:% >*a.*!;-%+D% =/BT%&*D*>&P!I& *+,&*-.-%!,/-"#
0/*!&+.2,$% *2.$%&Q"#P="0%&*O=.-%0K 05"N&74#M-4N*2,^ +>:%8 *D [.&05"N& OF7%>:%8
*C5.-% C,2%C!%7,. 0/*!&=,$%80+>:%8 >*a.!$%OF7%>:%L
-,0%&P=4-#D%&P0"N^DB%!"#$% *2.%=+0%&M-I&*-5&+,. CB%!"#$%&2,$% 0/A4# )01S
["+1"P!I& 0/A4#)?1$%8S01. 0/A4# !"2%>"0%&f 0/*+2,-%=5"D% :*D SD.+I2,$% 0/*+2,-%0K-"#
0/A4#01b&?1$%8 M-4^="#$%*+&?1$%8F,4^PF"N&*+&!;2I01 -"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& -E TI&C,D%&>I
?1$%8 -5D%+,.>.&05.&*+1^2,$% *+2,-%*>.%C:%& 0/A4# '-6 2,$% :*D W D.+I
["0/*+2,-%O=$%&0+1"*9-.$%&@ 0/*+2,-%+D% =5"D%*-5.%*DP!IOF7%>:%8 2,-%
0/*+2,-%+D% *2.$%&Q"#+.2,$% 0/A4#-"#!"2%f 0:%>:%8 *C8C.*7.$%89-:%8>E01
0!;a/ 0/*+2,-%=/8*9-.$%& Q"#!; *-5&+,.2,$% 0/>,.&*!&=/8>:%8 >E27%TI&01
*O!.9-.&>:%L
0/Q,B%7:%&A4#&=,$%8-"# O!:%8 <0++1"*9-.$%&@ >4=5/^7-%?1$%8 0/Q,B%=,$%8
0+1"*9-.$%& M-4^="#$%*+&?1$%8F,4^PF"N&*+&!;2I01 *<$1>:%8C-%-0%&7.*7.$%01 !
152
0:%>:%8 C-%-0%&7.*7.$%-"#01 0/Q,B%7:%&A4#&>:%8 *-5&+,.27%*C15.-%2,$%
0BE<48>E-05.&*9-.$%& -,0%&P=4-#D%&P0"N^DB%2,$% <$%*+.-%B1T%P!"N$%>:%8 27:!;2I
01 2"#$%&*U>M-I& ' CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& TI&>-%C"K$%- Q"#>:%L
*+,&*-.-%!,/ -5$%&!P!I&7I&>:%8 ?"#<$%a. g +-%*DG 0/A4#!"2%>"0%&P!I& SD.+I
9-.2,$% 27:!;2I01 O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&O!N <$%*+.-%B1T%P!"N$%>:%8
TI&0$%&?"#$%01 TI&*Q.$%f -,0%&P=4-#D%&P0"N^DB% *+,&*-.-%!,/-5$%&!*+& *-.%0+1$%A4#&
2,$% -D%G-,-%7.2$%=/8P!I& NDF !;2I01 O!:%>EGCH2%*2.% -"#B%7.&O!N <$%*+.-%
B1T%P!"N$%>:%8 TI&2$%C$%&01 ?K2%OF$%8 0:%>:%8+CU%-"#01 C-%012%["#&>,.&0:%
0`#2%*9-.$%& *O!.9-.&=/8>:%L “-t,D%*2.% Boycott C#!%2B%” `# 27:!;2I01
TI&0$%&?"#$%- Q"#>:%L
-,0%&P=4-#D%&P0"N^DB%?1$%8 g 0"#$%-,.*(&>:%8 >O!N70%&*-5&+,.2,$% 0/*!&
?"#$%>:%8 CETI&*+ g(( <D%&-5$%=D%G ["+1"P!I& 0/A4# (6)+1">:%L 0/A4#())2,$% !:.*+&
V.D01 Q+.005.&+1"P!I& M-4^="#$%*+&!;2I01 -"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& -E@ 27:!;2I01
-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& -E?1$%8 Q"#!;*-5&+,.2,$% <$%*+.-%B1T%P!"N$%O=$%&0O!N>:%8
*=2%>7%O!:%>EG!;2I01 -"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& -E2"#G+1"*DP!I& *-5&+,.CEM-I&05.&@
M-4^="#$%*+&!;2I01 7:%&A4#&*+&01b&05.&@ !;2I<$%05.& 0/A4#!+(#i% 2,$%&+1"*DP!I& 0/
C.*+.-%[:%8>E05.&-"# !:.*+&V.D01 Q+.005.&- -"#B%2"#$% M-4^="#$%*+&!;2I
a-%01 <$%*+.-% 01D%O=7%*!& C5-%+1">:%-"# *2,^+>:%L
“aB%C"# 0/*!&+0B%Q"#2.0>"9-C"#G -E*!&2.!;”`# Q"#!; 0/A4#01
2.<D%-5Q+.0 *UR0E0E>D%&- Q"#>:%L “M-84="#$%*+&!;2I-CE*2, 0/A4#*2.$%
0F,$%8*>&aE& [/01.*+.-%*DP!I -t,D%*2.%C.01 O!$%[,-% ="#$%&+2B%” `#
-,0%&P=4-#D%&P0"N^DB% NDF !;2I01 <$%*+.-%B1T%P!"N$%>:%8 O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%
-"#B%7.&C1B% *C.$%& TI&2$%C$%&-Q"#>:%L
0/A4#!+<#i%D1$%8 0/A4# 2,$%&-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& -E01C,/f -5D%>:%8
!;2I<$%05.&0+1"*>.%C:%& >O!N70%&*-5&+,.2,$% M-4^="#$%*+&!;2I24Q"!%!; -5}05.&
<2%Q$%[.&>:%8 !;2I<$%05.&-"#C:%& *2,^+>:%L
“2O=.&>E*2,Q"# M-"N2$%0/BE2B%L 2"#G- =*0.-%-"# [:8%01.0"#GC"#G C.
0BEaE&” `# -,0&% P=4-#D%&P0"N^DB%*2.$%!"#$%& e0~b>I+"C0%&*D >-% d6?17% +,B%+1"
153
*UR2$%C1- 0/[:%8+D% *?1&B.T%OF$%8 C.*+.-%7T% *O!.9-.&>:%L
-,0%&P=4-#D%&P0"N^DB%2,$% 0/A4#*!;$%& )gd A4#?1$%8 0/*!&?"#$%>:%8CETI&*+01.
g))SY TI& ["+1"*9-.$%& P0"N^DB%*-.%0+1$%01 2+.&<$% >2$%&[#2%O!D%=5-% +
>"+>:%L -,0%&P=4-#D%&P0"N^DB% 0D%&>C"!%*-5&+,.2,$% 0/A4#01 2.(D%-5Q+.001
($%*+.-% 01D%O=7% >:%8 2,-% Q"#!;*-5&+,.01 *-.%0+1$%T-nV- P0"N^DB%
*-.%0+1$%A4#&>"#G 7.2$%2"#$%9-.&=/8*9-.$%& Q"#!; *-5&+,.01 0/[:%8=/8>:%8
*O= *D?1$%8!2%>-%f *=2%>7%O!:%>EG!;2I01 !;2I<$%27%TI&-Q"#>:%L
-,0%&P=4-#D%&P0"N^DB%2,$% !; <$%OF7%>:%8 0B%+0%&*-5&+,.2,$% M-4^="#$%*+&
!;2I 05"N&>.&CH2%*2.%01 <$%*+.-%B1T%P!"N$%>:%8 TI&=$%*+H01 0-5$%&!01I
27%+-% C"#01 72$%f "0%*O= W(( 2,-% 27% "0%*[.$%C15$% QD%27% "2%
?KD%&*<$1=/8P!I& >B%BE7+"2% *DOF$%8 27% "2%C15$% W(( -5!% *!&*Q.$% +*9-.$%&
>"+ >:%L
[-%!;*-5&+,.2,$% 0/*+2,-%P!I& *D.-%Q4#&+CU%-"# 27:!;2I01
O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%-#"B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& -E C-%012%["#&f 2:%O!NO=$%&0+1"
*>.%C:%& Q"#!;7.+$%&05.&-"# P0"N^DB%*-.%0+1$%>"#G !"#G*Q.$%=/8*9-.$%& >"+>:%L
“-,0%&P=4-#D%&01. 27:D/G NDF (=*0.-%) D/G- !E&*!;$%&*D+2/8>*a.!/” `#
27:!;2I01 2"#$%&*U>M-I&CH2%*2.%(') -"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& TI&>-%C"K$% -
[!%04*O!.9-.&>:%L
“>0I&2"#G-*2.8 TV [/-C"#!/* .-%*08C”"#G `# e0~b>I+"C0%&*D >-%
'6 ?17% +,B%+1" "0%*[.$%+1$% 05"N&>0I&27%TI&- 0/0*!&01I-.C A#!%O0$%>49-.&
2,$% O!>[.&!4#?1$%8 O!$%a-%2,$% 2-B%C-%*2,^ 0/*!&+>:%8 *O= *D
-,.O=.&=5-%?1$%8!2%>-%f *O!.9-.&>:%L
2Is,I[/2,$%*F.%O![.&>:%8 0/*!&!4#01. 7D7%-5D*>.%C:%& !4#?1$%80/A4#2,$%&
O!-,-%05.&01. 02E:I*9-.$%&@ 0/A4#2,$%& 0:%>E0Q"# <$%*+.-%*D?"#$%>:%8 *D
[.&05"N&OF7%P!I& 0/!4#&?1$%8 0/A4# 2,$%& O!$%2,$% C,2%C!%7,. >,.&C.C5-% +1"*D
*9-.$%& B$%&M-4N*2,^+!4#?1$%8 !2%>-%f Q-%C-%*O!.9-.&>:%L
“ +$%-0/*!&=5$%2/87"2%+1"2B%L -"#B%*!&=5$%2. 0*!&+2/8 2,-% 0/
0*!&!/ O!D%C.2B%” `# *:.$%-#D%&*-5&+,.01 +,.>.&27%TI&- 2B%CIF#D%& 01
154
0? *C&?1
q $%8 *+,&*-.-%!/,
155
OF7%>:%L .[.-('() `E*>. Q"#$%&a#2%* .-%<B% * .$%*O0>.74 ' @
O!:%M-I&+D%C4# 0/A4#(')`E*>. 7"0%&*D.-%=4 OFb7.C4#&9-I&- =D%G:.&*D>:%L
0/A4#*+1^2,$% +-%-,-% -5"N&*Q.$% F/,^<$%05.&@ C4#P=4N*+&+/*a.%05.&@ 0I&>2%05.&?1$%8
*-5.$%&[/2,$%*2.8 0/A4#01b&?1$%8 0/A4#<D%[0%& Q+.005.&- 0/!4#&05.&-"# 72$%f F,$%8O!
C"#-%>:%L !;2I05.&01-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&!$% 74#* .$% 0*+.-%*>&L
["#7T%01.!$% 0/*!&0:%8>E ?17%*B.-% *+.-%C.>:%L 0/A4# 2,$%& <$%>,.&
9->:%L 0/A4#<D%[0%&05.&- 012%!4#2$%D4!;2%?1$%8 0:%7.+$%& 2"#-%Q"#$%77%*Q&
-. 0/[:%8=,$%8O!NC"#-%>:%L ["#G*D.-% 0/*!&P!I&O!D%[,-%C.*>. ![0Q4#&
0/Q?Z+1$%-"# >E $%2.s5b& C#!%*2.8>:%L
‘’ Q$%*O!!;2B%L a.010*O!.9-aE&@ -"#B%M-"N-%2.[:%8@ [:%8=5$%2.[:%8C"#G
+2B%L” `# 0/Q?Z+1$%- +H$%CD%&7,. *OF>:%L
“*`8*-.$%a.C.AK!%2.C/@ 0*2,^2.9-.P!I” +/BEDI*F.$%&?1$%8 +/*a.%
27%*B.-% C.*0&f C-%[/2,$% <1-%-"#$%C.*>. `D%&Q-%01 >4F0%&[.&
O=$%&-"# !"2%C"#-%>:%L *>=5.9-:%8C"#-%01 *-5.$%&2#D%&- Q"#&*F.%*2F-%
*0.$%*-5.%?"#$%7"#&!;C.&L
“a.010AK!%!;aE&Q+.+B%@ Q+.-*+. UI01.2.<D%-52.C.&`$%” >E
*D.-%C"#-%>:%L
“* &`#2%2B%-,@ C.-,. C-%F-%+:% *>.-%+* .$%L UID.&-
0*-.$%&aE&-,” +/*a.%*-5.%?"#$%7"#&- C-%F-%+:%Q"#$%a-% TI&2:% C"#-%>:%L
>2$%&*2.8+*!TI&*2.80:%L
“UIC"#!;!/-,.L $;C/ *<&>$%P!I&2:%&- +/[/<$%C"#-%2.@ 0$%&*+.
a.C#!%*DC/” 7>:%OF$%8 7=5I-. *+.-%22%+.+.*O!.9->:%L
“$;2"#G-"# 7=D%&- 01.[.&2B%-,.@ 0/A4#*+1^-"# 0C"# !%!/0>,.&F"#G@ *2.%9-.
CE*2,- BEDI*F.$%&O0$%+$% CD%GF5!%P!I& -"#B%9-"N-%2.-"# 0*!&+/a/ *D9-01.
7"#&C"#G*C” +/*a.%>E$B%=5$%&7-.&*9-.$%8 *=;$%&!$%*[.$%>,.&>:%L
C,2%C!%f2+.&0152*>. *+,&*-.-%!/,@ ?"#$%$4*2.%- 01D%2-B%!$%
*72D.?1$%8 *O!.$%&C/C"#-%O=$%&*!C.&L
>E$B%=5$%&-"#?K2%Q-%P!I& P0"N^[/+1" 0/A4#05.&-"# C1:%^!2%9-:%8+D% 7"2%-E&
156
C"#-%>:%L 0/A4#2"#$%&01. CE*2, O!:%8!;C.&L 7- *+,&*-.-%!/,-"# 0:%>E015
7"2%0<$%7.&9-@ 0?q*C&>:% ?"#$%$4*+&?1$%8!-%>-%C15$% [*?1&>:%`# *<FD%=/8
*>. D.0:%*-5.% O!:%2,$%&X5.DB%27%*7.$%*2.8 a.*O!.TI&0:%0>"*!L
0"#&C$%&2:%&- 27%*B.-%- 7 C15"N C15"NOF$%8 0/C.*!&9-+. g( +.="#$%?KD%&
* .-% 0*C5.G `# 02%*C.$%&27%TI&- [$%O0$%=5-%*!&>:%L
‘’ F,.&2"#G-*2.8=*0.-%!/*!&2.@ Y( 2#D%&-C:%& =*0.-%-"#!/ *!&=/8
2.L =#C/=*0.-%!/@” a,.& "# 27%TI&- >EG7"2%M-"N-% 0/*!&=/8+!4#-"# O!D%*O!.
*D>:%L
P0"N^[/+1"0/A4#27%A4#01 0/*!&P!I&O!D%C.>E27%TI&- “M-"N-%2.*!&C"#G +!;2B%
s5.L aB%>EG-"#[:%8!;C"#GC/0*O!.aE&@ a.01C/0C#!%9-!;aE&@ .&C4#& * &* &
*Q&*Q&!;!/@ CE*2,- 7,2%+,2%P!I&*O!.=5$%+.*O!.9-2.” `# *O!.>,.&>:%01.
*+,&*-.-%!/, *!RB4#9-:%=5-% O!:%8?1$%8L
*DG=$%&01.*2.8 O!>D.*C& D:%&$B%-"# 7*2,G+>:%L !#C/*$,*+.$%
0/A4# ' 2,$% 2.<D%-5 Q+.027%TI&- 0/C.*!&>E05.&[/2,$% *B.$%C:%C:%
OF7%*D>E >4#&*C&TI&=D%G-"# Q?ZO!N>:%8!4#&D.&[" -!%f9-:%8P!I& `"#`.O=7% UI`.
O=7%`# *O!.*D2. >E-"#B%2"#$%O0$%C"#-%+>:%L =5-%=5$%&!$% 0/A4#01b&-"# *=RP!I&
-D%G-,-%>:%L 0/A4#01b&- 0/!4#&01.&[:8%0:% 7"#&*>.*9-.$%8`# *9-.$%&O!>:%L
2.<D%-5 Q+.0*O!.*D2. -"#B%2"#$%O0$%*9-.$%&@ >4#&*C&TI&=D%G+1"*Df 0/A4#01b&-"#
*=RO!O=$%&OF7%*9-.$%&@ 0"0"-"#B%2"#$% 0IUIB.>0.&27%TI& OF7%*9-.$%& *O!.*2.801
["#Q+.0-"# *=RBE>2"*!&!;0:%`# 0/A4#01b&- Q"#>:%L
0/A4#01 [,-% *D.-%- QEQE:4:4 >49-.&f C1:%8 9-:%8
05"N&>0I&27%TI&- >E02"#G "0%*[.$%7# 27%=#C4#& 7.+$%&2,$% +1.0*2,^`#Q"#>:%L
0/A4#2.<D%+1">E 27%TI&-C:%& 0/*!&!"#$%=,$%8+1">E7.+$%&05.&-"# *+,&*-.-%!/,*DG
02"#$%0I +-% *2.%9-.-!$% 0/A4#05.&] -!%[.&P!I& OF7%*9-.$%&?1$%8 7.+$%&2,$% 0"0"
0:% 0!;<$%!;- +!%-,-%*-.%0+1$%-"# *9-.$%&9-.&?"#$*
% 9-.$%& >2$%&7.05.&
2,$%C:%& *9-O$.[.&P!I&OF7%*9-.$%&@ B=# =5"D%01 0"0"2"#GC:%& 0:%>"#G015 022%
?"#$%*9-.$%&@ -B%f 0/*!&C"#!;- +!%-,-%*[.-%=47.BE=/8!;`# O!D%C:%
*O!.Q"#*D>4 9-.&C"#-%>:%L
157
“+!;2B%L 0*!&+C/ *D!;*7*2.8L a.010OF7%aE&@ C#!%AK!%0=4=5$%*2.8
aE&” 05"N&>0I&- *O!.*O!.Q"#Q"# Q"#$%-B% *0.$%&[,-%>,.&>:%L 09-.!;
=5.2"2% 27%*B.-%*B.-%C.P!I& [-%!; 2"#$%& O!D%C:%OF7%!,.&>:%L
["#=5.2"2% C/O!D%>,.&>:%L
“ /U;=-%2.!/s5.@ CE*2,- 7"2%<$%27.&0+1"9-aE&@ >E05.&*!&C"#G
C"#-%*!&9-2.L UI01.0/7.+$%& 0!;2/8>E*2, 05.&9-I&!/L -,D%!5b2. A"#-%2/8>E
*2,C/ 05-%7"01.&?"#$%2.*!;8@ 7.+,-% *C&$;&*O=.-%+,-%*C.-%-C/ *!5.-%>,.&
*>&2B%L *7.*7.2:%&- *9-.$%&9-.&+$%P!I&2.!/@ =#01*2.8L -,5D%*2.%8
0"2%*Q,C/ 27%0">.&7#C4#& +17%*B.-%*C.-%+1"0B% D.0:%0!;C"#G0*!&+aE&*C”
0/A4#<D%[0%&- >EG-"#+1$%&O!*D>:%L
UIC"#Q"#+$% UI0/A4#01. 0/0*!& C"#-%+2/8>E*2, 05.&M-I&!;C.&@ 0/*!&=,$%8
0+f O!D%>,.&9-2.!/*2,G>:%L aB%>E01 0/*!&C"#G+* .$% +!%-,-%T-nVQI >,.&
>:% `#09-.&+L O=.&+!%-,-%0/A4#*2,01.*+.L
O=.&+!%-,-%@ O=.&0/A4#*2,01.C/ ["#-/8>#"G!$%OF7%>:%L D.0:%7.+$%&
0!;f 0/0*!&C"#-%+>E*2, 05.&M-I&@ ["# "0%*[.$%7#*2, .&C4#&>:% *9-.-%
22%>E05.&@ D.0:%7.+$%&0!;f 0/*!&=,$%8+* .$% Q-%C-%C#!%*Q.$%0:%8
>E05.&0`#2%9-L 0QI0Q"#$% 0.0I&*=;-%Q/,*9-.%O$.-"# >2"+C"#-%>:%L
“ 9-4 7:%27%=#=#*2.8+1"+0B%” `E>22%L
["# 9-4 7:%>:% 01D%2-B%+1"*9-.$%& :!"#$%&-501 C-%*2,^ >"+
*2.8>:%L :*D*C&D.+I01. 0/A4#*2, !"2%>:%L ["#7T%2:%&- 0/A4#-"# 0:%>E015
<$%=,$%80+*2.8@ !;2I-#"B%7.&C1B% =5"N^!$% <$%=,$%80+f *O= 2$%OF7%9->:%L
*D.-%*2.8 <$%=,$%8+>,.&9->:%L
0/A4#05.&2,$% *+2,-%=5-% + 05"N&>.&UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#!;2I01 O!2%
>2% ?"#$%+*D>:%L O!:%! >4CH$%8V.D05.&01C:%& 05"N&>.&UI0"#-*+7I
$% .&7#!;2I01 TI&2$%* .$%* .$%@ *U;-%2.C17"#&:,D%G@ TI&*-5.%* .$%@
TI&=$%*0.$%>-%2"#G 0/A4#05.&2,$% O!2% >2% ?"#$%+*D>:%`# *9-O$.
>,.&>:%L
P0"N^DB%*-.%0+1$%2,$% 0/A4#05.&01 0/7.+$%&05.&@ 0/[#!%05.& *+.-%C.9-
158
>:%L *+2,-%+$%&?1$%8!$% :QB%827%D.+I["0P!I&?"#$%*!L * .$%*O0>.74 27%P0"N^
DB%[/2,$%!$% 0/A4#*!;$%& gg A4# +1"+. :QB%827%D.+I[" '' +4#>. *+2,-%?"#$%*>&
>:%`#Q"#>:%L *-.%0+1$%A4#&=D%&[/2,$% 02%*C.$%&05.& M-"N2$%0/ *+2,-%
*D>:%-"# 9-:%8AK*D9->:%L
“-"#B%-*2.8A4K&*D2B%@ CE*2,- 24Q"!%-"#9-"N-%*2.8 =*0.-%01
=*0.-%!/@ -"#B%2"#GT-nV TI&>#*<-*2.8 +1D%!"D%!#C$%&*2.$%<B%[.&P!I@
* .$%!/, =4F"#G@ *UR>D%&>D%&?#2"#GC/ A4K&9-2B%@” UI0"#-+-%27%!;2I01 *U;-%2.
2$%*0.$%[,D%& J *O!.7-.&L
05"N&>.&UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#+4#&=5#N!%2,$% TI&2$%* .$%* .$%@ *U;-%2.
C17"#&:,D%GD1$%8 s`"#*-.%02I<$% *+1^*D TI&O0$%8>,$% 2"#G-"# *2,^+>:%L 05"N&>.&
UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#01 -#D%C4#& ?"#$%+*D*9-.$%& *O!.>:%L ["#7T%01.!$%
*-.%0+1$%A4#&01 O!D%C.9-*>. 05"N&>.&UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#!;2I01 CE$B%05.&-
0/A4#05.&01 *-.%0+1$%A4#&>"#G *+.-%+1"C.*>. 7.+$%&05.&-"# TI&O0$%8>,$%-"# *!&C"#-%
>:%L 0/A4# *2.%05.&05.& -5D%*D*>&*>.%C:%& BEC.>015 0/A4# 7.+$%&2"#$%&2,$%
05"N&>.&UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#01!$% ?"#$%+*D*>&>:%L
“M-"N2$%0/*2,C/!;2B% D%-B%+@ M-"N2$%0/ )'d 0/01. -,5D%*2.%2"#G-
6 0/@ 2.7.: -' 0/ D/G UI0"#-+-%27%!;2I(O0D%0.)- ' 0/2/8s5@” CE$B%-
TI&O0$%8>,$%-"# 7.+$%&*!&C"#-%>:%L ["#>"#G!$% M-"N2$%0/7.+$%& *+.-%C.2"#$%&
O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I01 O!2% >2% ?"#$%+*D0K*9-.$%8 0/ '((( *-5.%?"#$%*D*>.
TI&2$%* .$%* .$%01. c(( *-5.%>. >.+?"#$%*2.8>:%L
“*2.%*>&2B% M-"N2$%0/- 27%+.*-5.%*C&*2,0"#G @ >4#&*C&+.>.Q"#
-5N!%2"#G*2.8 0C,B%aE&” TI&2$%* .$%* .$%- TI&O0$%8>,$%-"# *O!.C"#-%>:%L
“ $%&@ -5D%&0.*+&<D%9-I&D/GP!"N$%+2/8 TI&=$%*0.$%>-%*2.$% O!2%
>2% ?"#$%*D2B%s5@ *O=*D- *-.$%&!;2B%” TI&O0$%8>,$%- O!D%*O!.
C"#-%>:%L
: ' D.+I[" 0/*+2,-%C"#G0P!I&*>&@ O=.&P0"N^DB%05.&2,$%C:%& ["#>"#G
!$%OF7%>:%L UIC"#Q"#C15$% 0?q*C&01. 05"N&>.&UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#!;2I- O!2%
>2% ?"#$%++1"*DP!I`# 2,-%?"#$%P!IC.&L
159
0D-% "!%B.[01 2"#$%&*-.%0+1$%A4#&=/,>"#G >,.&*2.80:%`# *2,&-. "!%
C"#-%*2.8>:%L 0D-%*7.*7.[-. 2"#$%&*-.%0+1$%A4#&>"#G >,.&>:%L 0:%>EG-"#01
<$%=,$%8 0*!&*>&!;L 0/05.&*+2,-%Q/`# *7.$%8+/*a.%05.&- *OF>:%L
=+"#$%*-.%0+1$%A4#&*+1^2,$% -5D%&0.*+&<D%M-I&D1$%8 P!"N$%=/8*>. TI&=$%*0.$%>-%J
-"#B%7.&C1B%-"# *2,^>:%L
“?"#$2
% .*2.8?"#$%*DP!I-,@ : ' D.+I*C.-%[" 0/)c((*-5.%?"#$%[.&2B%L
=# >"+1"*9-.$%& C-%012%C.["#&2. `# S$%&-Q"#>:%L
09-.!;@ ["#-"#B%7.&C1B% 05-%?1.[.&2$%&2$%&?1$%8 O!D%Q$%&C.>:%L
a.OF7%2.C/*0&*2.8 “A4K&2B%-,@ :- M-"N2$%0/ '((( *-5.% *+.-%C.
2B%2/8L *-.%0+1$%A4#&01.2#D%&- $;2"#G*+1^01.*+2. M-"N2$%0/ 6Yd 0/!/+1"2.L $;2"#G
O!D% >,.&01 aB%-aB%C"#*+.-%C.2B%0>"aE&” *U;>>4?1$%8 O!D%*OF>:%L U;Q"#
c(( *-5.%>. ?"#$%+[.&*>. TI&2$%* .$%* .$% 2"#G*+. 0:%>"#G +1"0:%D:%&L
0+!E+DB%2,$% 0P!"N$%=$%2:%&- ?"#$%0:%`# >2$%&*O!&=/8*>.
*U;-%2.>D%&O0$%8 C:%&A4K&>:%L *U;-%2.>D%&O0$%801. 7oC.0%a.>.<$%OF7%P!I&@
0+!E+ DB%27%*9-.2,$% 0,2%7C$%a.>.($%TI&*+ 05.& O!.&+1"+. *>=5.
*!;-% ?"#$%0:%`# [$%*9-&*!&=4[.&+.01 0,2%7C$%+!%-,-%2"#$%&2,$%A4K&P!I& O=.&
+!%-,-% =5"N^2,$% ?"#$%>:%L
9>X#2%C=D%G-A"#-%0KOF$%8 F0%&=4[.&+*>. 0,2%7C$% *O=.-%TI&-"#
O!D%CH2% *!&0:%L 0,2%7C$%0% .&C4#& 0/A4#*+1^ 0C.+`# O!:%="#$%PF"N&- :""|?"K$%&
[.&>:%`# Q"#>:%L ["#GO!$% 0+!E+P0"N^DB%+1" 0/A4# .&C4#&2,$% O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I01
-"#B%7.&C1B%05.& >.0- S$%&2"#G-"# C.*+.-% C-%F-%+:%!"#G@ -,0%&B.!"#G>E05.&
2.& QI&0+1" <$%[,-% >,.&C.*D9-P!I& 0/A4#01b&05.&-C:%& 2.&QI&O=$%& 0+1" `#
*U;-%2.>D%&O0$%8J -"#B%7.&C1B%05.&[401>"+>:%L
0/A4#2"#$%&2,$% O!:%="#$%PF"N&01 -"#B%7.&C1B%05.&C-%[/2,$% 0/7.+$%&
OF:%8>,$%&>:%8 !4#74 )Y *=R 7.+,-%*C&05.&!; C.9-P!I&@ 0/A4#!"2%>:%?1$%8 O!:%="#$%PF"N&
A4#&=5N!%>"#G *9-.$%&9-.&@ ["#012Q$%8 C"# !%>:%8 M-"N2$%0/-"# Q$%>$%8O!$%@
<D%9-I& 27%TI&TI&J 0"D%GOF$%8 *-.%0+1$%-C-%=4*!&C"#-%+P!I& *-.%0+1$%01.
*D+$%&["#$%+$%& 2+.&=4OF7%>,.&>:%`# TI&=$%*0.$%>-%J -"#B%7.&C1B%-
160
[$%O0$%=5-%*!&>:%L
*D.-%27%+-% [" 0/*+2,-%=/8+*>. 0?q*C&J *+,&*-.-%!/,>:%
05-%C1:%8QD%QD%!$% P!I&Q4#&>,.&=/8P!IOF7%>:%L C,2%C!%f 2+.&0152*>.
*+,&*-.-%!/, !4#74OF$%8 !/,[,-%=/8P!I& A#!%Q"#& -5:%&2D%7,. !/,>"0%&=/8>:%L
0:%7.+$%&-5D%=/8f 0/*!&=,$%80+=/8*>.0/05.&>:% M-"N2$%0/OF7%>,.&
P!IC.&@ CE[#>:% *+,&*-.-%!/,-"# B4# 9-:%+1"!;0:%C.&@ *D.-%$;&?17%9-.
*+,&*-.-%!/,*+.-%C15$% 0/*!&9-TI&01.C.&@ *>=5.2.-*2.8 *D.-%[!%$;&?17%
*7.$%89-:8%+*2.80:% OF7%>:%L L
161
*-5&eE&+1$% 7!;&?14?1$%8 *$,O=*>k82"#G .&P!"N$% O=*>k8?"#$%
?"#<$%a.(c)+-%
162
?"#<$%a.(g)+-%
?"#<$%a. (g)+-%>"#G*+.-%C.!;P!IL D4D-%*C&D.+I=,/P!IOF7%f T-nmM-I&01
C.?K"&>OF$%8 -t,D%*2.%2"#G "!%B.[9->:%L 05-%?1.>7%@ *+ "0%>,.&@
*-5.$%&<2%74#05.& <2%Q$%9-P!I& 2"#-%!4#-"#B%7I [!%04Q$%O0D%&-. D4D-%7.
(breakfast) >4#&*Q.$%9->:%L
P!I&C15$% C4#P=4N*+& +/*a.% !; <$%2.<D%A1">E05.&?1$%8 Q+.@ Q+.005.&
>:% >7%C,$%C1! >D%GO!D%G*D>:%8 OFb@ 7"0%&05.& -"#B%7I?1$%8 0/A#4A1"+. *-5.$%&
*Q.$%QI>"#G =5I2-%=/89->:%01. -5-%>*+A1"*D!;*2.8>:%L
()) +:% *>,&*-.$%&@ +:% =5$%&O!:%8< T7o.!7o:%&9-,B%<*>.
a.>.>.>D. [,D%&*O!.$%C1>:%8 0"O0D%0.O!:%M-I&>:% *-5&C-%P0"N^A,.
0-5D% OF$%8 !5.&!D%&=2%015 *+&M-I&7,.OF$%8 D-%D-%D/D/ XA#7"#-% *Q.$%A,-%
*D9-=5"D%OF7%>:%L
0"O0D%0.O!:%M-I& .& ?#"$%$4>7%CE>7% 7"2%>7%OF7%*7+D% *O!.$%&C/7
O!N*DO=$%&OF7%>:%L CE2"#$%&CE2"#$%& *+&!;f CE2#"$%&CE2"#$%& P!4N&*<Q.7,.OF$%8
.&OF:%8*D9->:%L
O!:%>EO!:%>.&05.&01 >,$%*O!.$%&-.C-"# Q$%?H/*D9-=5"D%2,$%
*Q.$%&r-+I a#+$%0M-I&>:%C:%& ?1$%&!#<;-"# O!:%8O!:%8<< CH0%&P=4NC5-% ?"#<$%a.
g+-% D4D-%=$%&2,$% O!:%>E05.& .& 012%012%++ OF7%*7f -"#B%[$%O! *O!.Q"#
*D>*B.$%*B.$% .&OF:%8-E:I*D>C"#C"# *Q.$%&r-+I a#+$%0M-I&-"#C/
>" 012%O!N*7=5$%>:%8 C.& ?1$%&05.&*<OF.7,. -5Q$%&*D*!*2.8>:%L
D4D-% cD.+I2,$%0/A#47F,$%8>:%?1$%8 Q?Z0/*!&9-0:%8 O!:%>EO!:%>.&05.&
2F,/F,/*+.-%A1"C.9->-/8>#"G 0/7.+$%&9-:%8>E 0/C-%012%[#2%*!&>E05.&C/
XA#27"#-%OF$%8 01.&0A1"+D% *C&*C&7.&7.& *Q.$%A,-%*D9->:%L Q?Z0/*!&0:%8
7.+$%& + $;&+.DI&DI&A1">:%L
0/A#4M-I&9-!%>E05.& 0/A#4 -E05.&01C/ “UIa-%-#"!;O!!;L M-"N-%+.27%TI&TI&-"#
01D%O=7%O=7%!;L UI0/!4#&01. C.[:%8!;” 7>:%OF$%8 -E:I*Q.$%A,-%*D9->:%L
0/*!&>E05.&01 =5"N^01. *2.$%>ECB%>0.&A"#&>.&>E05.& OF7%f D.&0C:%9-!;L
“UI0/!4#&a-%C.!; 4#&” `EfC:%&*=R9-+>:%L UIC"#C/ “C-%012%["#&!; 4#&@
163
UI01.C/["#&!; 4#&” OF$%8 0D.&20%&*O!.9-+>:%L 2=5"N^TI&M-I&05.& -
0/C-%012%-"#F2%9-:%8P!I& “UI01.*2.8@ `"#a-%2#D%&-C"# TI&*0.$%*C&C/
0!;*2.8aE&” `#*O!.9->:%L UI0/!4#&- UICE UICE*2,Q"#2.-"# 0/A#4& -E05.&-
*O!.O!9-+O!D%>:%L
`"#a-%- 0/!4#&-"#C/ >,.&+ 4#&0B%C"#G 2"#$%&*U>M-I&a-% CH2%C"#-%+
O!D%>:%L C-%012%["#&="#$%&O!D%*2.8 “` C-%012%-C/ ["#&C"#-%+2.!;C.&L
0XkC.*Q.$%2#D%&-*2.$% UI*C.-%C-%012%0["#&+aE&” `# *O!.f .&C4#& P!4N&
9-+>:%L
=5"N^01. [#2%*!&C"#-%>:%8 0/C-%012%*C&-"#$%P!I& *2,*<7,.OF$%8
*0&C/0*0&+//D/G 0/!4#&[/[:%8+D% C#!%*Df “ `#"& `"#& `"# =D%&[/01. M-"N-%2/8>E-"#
>,.&O=7%C"#-%!; 4#&” `# *O!.9-+>:%L
=5"N^- *D.-%*O!.$%7,.OF$%8 “27%*B.-%[/O=7%*D.%L ?17%*B.-%O=7%C"#G
0+aE&L $;&+4^?17%*-.$%0F0%&D/GQ"#2. 9-.&FE&2B%0#"GC.&” `# =5$%&=5$%&*O!.>405.&
*9-.$%8 C#!%0 .&>:%89-.&01 P!4N&+ +B%+?1$%8 !$%!D%&>:%0[$%+*!L
=5"N^01. =5$%&=5$%& 2I&2"#&*O!.*D9-*>&>:%L “7!;&?14-"# *-5&eE&
0-D%& D/G*D.%@ /U;D$%2"#G >-%>=$% `# *O!.*D9-*>&f” P!4N&0"!;>:%L
A"#&>.&C1>:%8 *2.>E*2.$%>.&05.&>:% O!7%0O0$%22%>-/8>"#G
O0$%+.[$%+.-"#*O!.9- O!NC#!%9-*!>:%L
=5"N^- *O!.9-*>&>:%L “`/8 O=*>k8Q"#2. *$,!/`@ O=*>k8+1"+$%
a.0Q"#C#!%C"#G+2B%” *O!.9- *>&>:%L
z>"#GOF$%8 P!4N&7+. +B%7+.05.&?1$%8 *DG=$%& )(&6( D.+I>"#G*+.-%C.P!IL
0/*!&>E05.&C/ [-%<-%DI&!;& P!I&>,.&P!IL A,.[/A1"CE05.& -#D%>*C.-%OF7%f
*2.>,.& 4#>,.&05.&-5D%*2.8>:%L
CEA1$%&=5"D%2,$% *-5&A,.T-nmM-I&01 M-I&9-!%f 05"N&>0I&05.& F,/^01
[0$%&O!$%!,/05.&-"# e,D%&2!%P!I& 27%TI&27%!D%&-D%7IC"#-%*<f 0"0"*D+.2,$%2$%
["#$%C5-%?1$%8 O!$%!,/[0$%&!D%&-D%05.&-"# Q.Q.?1$%8 7.&C"#-%+. 2-%2-%>.
*O!.$%!;*2.8>:%L
C#!%C#!%-"#$%*D+$%& 7.& *>.-%7.&+O=$%&2"#G>:% 20E[E&O=.&f
164
0:%>:%8 C#!%*D+. 0:%>:%8 7.&*>.-%Q"#$%05.&?1$%8 01502Ea/ 7"2%*+.-"#B%!;
+.+. 02E*O!.$%&C/a"#G #2%O07%=5*D>:%8 C.& [E&O=.&>:%8 +>.-"#
=47.&*D0"!;*2.8>:%L !$%!D%&0K C4#&<0A1">-/8>#"G 2.<D%BE *Q.$%A,-%*D+>:%
-"#!$% *-5D!%*D0" *2.8>:%L
-t,D%*2.%2"#G [0$%&7.&P!I& *O=*:.$%&C-%QD%G DI& D.&>,.&>E>,.&
D.&>ED.&?1$%8A1"*D7T% ))D.+I=D%G2,$% =A#"$%*-.%0A1$% T-nmM-I&05.&?1$%8 F,/
*+.-%A1"C.9->:%L 0/A#4 *O= *D?1$%8 Q?Z0/*!&P!I&>E -5D%A1">E *+ 2,-%
05.& *0&O0D%&P!I& C"# !%2.05.&-"# :HD%9-.&f O!D%C:%[,-%=,.>,.&9->:%L
))&6(=D%G =5"D%01 7f 2OF:%&OF:%&C.*+.-% Q?Z0/*!&9-O!D%+. *C&TI&
27%7# $;&TI&27%7#?1$%8 Q?Z0/ *!&9-0:%8>E >4#&!4#27%!4#=D%G>. -5D%A1" !;*2.8>:%L
*DG=$%& 'D.+I=D%G2,$% P0"N^DB%*-.%0A1$%A#4&01 2.<D%A1">E27%TI& [!%04
*+.-%A1"C.P!I& *O= *D-"# *0&O0D%&f >4#&!4#?17%!4#=D%G C.*!&9-P!I& 27%!4#>.
-5D%*2.8*9-.$%& >">,.&>OF$%8 2.<D%A1">E05.& *DOF$%8 *-5D!%<0%&>.
0"*9-.$%& *O!.>,.&>:%L
*2.O!D% 7.&P!I&*>.-%P!I& -5D%A1">E05.&C.*+.-%Q?ZO!N9-O!D%+. >4#&
D.+I 2"2"2,$% .&C4#&DI&DI& P!I&>,.&!;P!IL =+I&C,D%>E D:%&$B%>.-5D%A1">:%L
=+I&C,D%05.& O!D%C:%*+.-%C.=/8*>.%Q"#P!I& *7.$%8Q"#$%&*D9-+$%&
*C&D.+I2"2"2,$% 0/A#4!"2%P!IOF7%*9-.$%& >4=5/^7-%OF$%8 +!%-,-%*-5&A,.
T-nmM-I& 01 *9-O$.C"#-%!;*2.8>:%L
*C&D.+I2"2"2,$% F,/^<$%05.& C#!%-"# +!%Q"#$%&f >-%Q"#$%+.
0/A#401b&@ U#0/A#401b&?1$%8 -"#B%7.&C1B%05.& >">-%*>05.& .&C4#&*A1^2,$% O!:%>EG
CH2%*2.%0/!4#&-"# 0/A#401b&01 F,$%8P!I& C-%=4!4#&[/>,D%C#"-%>:%L
Q?Z0/*!&[.&>:%8 7.+$%&?1$%8 0/C-%012%-"#-%:I0K A1"0A1" 72$%
*+2,-%9-:8%>:%L -"#-%:I0KA1"f [!%04 02%*C.$%&>4#&TI&J C-%=4!4#& 27%=#7I
>#"G =,/O=.&[:%8C"#-%>:%L !B%0/!4#&2,$% ()g)0/+A1"f O=*>k8 'Y)@ 7!;&?14 )WS
+A1">,.&>:%L WD.+I2,$% P!I&7I&>,.&>:%L
WD.+I2,$% 05"N&>.&CH2%*2.%!4#&-"# 2.<D%A1">E05.&*A1^2,$% >,D%=5P!I&
0/7.+$%&?1$%8 -"#-%:I0KA1"0A1" *+2,-%C"#-%+. -"#-%:I!;>OF$%8 !B%0/ !; <$% [!%
165
0/=,/[#2%9-O!D%+. 05"N&>.&CH2%*2.%2,$% O=*>k(8 'd))@ 7!;&?1(4 )cY)@ !B%0/
)'0/OF$%8 O=*>k801 TI&*Q.$%+A1"O!D%>:%L
WD.+I SW2,$% 2"#$%&*U>M-I& !4#& .&F,$%8*F.-% 77%*Q& =,/[#2%O!NC#!%
9-+.2,$% O=*>8k 'd(@ 7!;&?14 )cY@ !B%0/ ()6)OF$%8 * .$%O0$%7,. P!I&7I&>,.&>:%L
0/A#401b&01 * .$%O0$%*7@ >I=5$%&OF$%8 * .$%7:% * .$%*0.$%&2I&>4F,$%8*7P!I&
* .$%O0$%7,. P!I&7I&>,.&>:%L D.+I-"# 9-:%8C"#-%+. :*D cD.+I["#& *D!;P!IL
-t,D%*2.%2"#G F,/^ 0"0"J*D+!% P0"N^*2.%>"#GO!D%+D% T-nmM-I&01 Q"#$%-B% W7I&
7I7T%[.&P!IOF7%f Q"#$%-B%-"#B%7IOF$%8 A,.01 CE$B%05.&- 2$%*Q.$%P!I& C"#-%!"#Gf
O!D%=/89->:%L
*01.$%7O!N*DP!IOF7%f C0%&-"# XA#7"#-%*0.$%&+D%*O!.9-.&+$%& C#!%-"#
* .$%O0$%7,. *Q.$%A,-%P!I&7I& >,.&>-/8>#"G 2.<D%-5*>. 0"?#"$%$4J >.&*-.$%&
!I!I>>OF$%8 .&+*-5D!%O=$%&05.&@ *2,^ M-4N>7%05.&@ * &=50%&O=$%& !I2"05.&OF$%8
0"0"*D "0%>"#G*+.-%A1"!;P!IL
0">.&7# .& *2,^ M-4N05.& *F.-%>:%=5P!I& )(D.+I["#&*DP!IOF7%f
7"2%=5C-%=5 D.&BEC"#-%+. * &=50%&7,.OF$%8 "!%*!5.%>,.&!;*2.8>:%L L
166
0#U4#P0"N^- *+,&*-.-%!,/ *O= *D
167
UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#!;2I01 TI&2$%Q"#$%2"#G <$%*+.-% B1T%P!"N$%9->:%L
05N"&>.&CH2%*2.% 0/Q?ZDB% 012% W 2,$% O!:%*[.$%7#M-48="#$%*+&?1$%8
F,4^PF"N&*+&!;2I01 TI&>D%&[,D%&@ 2#"$%&+$%&>.&7:%&C4#&:I:,2%*+&!;2I01 0,D%O!:%DB%
T-nV TI&2$%[,D%&?1$%8 0,D%*U>C4#&Q"#$%+.UI0"#-*+7I!;2I01 TI&?"#$%[,D%& 4#2"#G
<$%*+.-% B1T%P!"N$%9->:%L
O!:%DB%CH2%*2.% 2,-% 27%P0"N^DB%C15$% CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%
?17%TI& *+,&=5B%0:% OF7%>OF$%8 0/Q?ZDB% 012% ) 2,$% O!:%*[.$%7#M-48="#$%*+&?1$%8
F,4^PF"N&*+&!;2I01 TI& #D%&O0$%8 (>2qN2,$%&<D%M-I&V.D@ <D%M-I& s"#C%=5N!% #D%&O0$%)8 @ 2#"$%&+
$%&>.&7:%&C4#&:I:,2%*+&!;2I01 TI&7"#&<$%&?1$%8 0,D%*U>C4#&Q"#$%+. UI0"#-*+7I !;2I01
TI&*0.$%>"#-%2"#G <$%*+.-%B1T%P!"N$%9->:%L O!:%DB%CH2%*2.% 0/Q?ZDB% 012%
' 2,$% O!:%*[.$%7#M-48="#$%*+&?1$%8F,4^PF"N&*+&!;2I01 TI&9-:%[,D%&@ 2"#$%&+$%&>.&7
:%&C4#&:I:,2%*+&!;2I01 TI&*>.$%&$B%?1$%8 0,D%*U>C4#&Q"#$%+. UI0"#-*+7I!;2I01
(TI&[,D%&+I) *U;-%2. 0$%&?,B%7"#&2"#G <$%*+.-% B1T%P!"N$%9->:%L
0#U4#P0"N^DB%2,$% 0/Q?ZDB% >I&>I&2,$% 3"-B1T%P!"N$%=/8>:%01. 0,D%*U>
C4#&Q"#$%+.UI0"#-*+7I!;2I?1$%8 O!:%*[.$%7# M-48="#$%*+&?1$%8 F,4^PF"N&*+&!;2I2"#G OF7%>:%L
*+,&*-.-%!,/M-"N-.C >">.*>. -D%G>2%2.&O07%=5-%27%=#01. +D%-#D%@
0?*C&?1$%8 -=5$%O!:%DB%2"#G !; <$% O=.&O!:%DB%?1$%8 2"#$%& =5N"^2,$%
*0.%*2.%B.T%@ >4=5/^7-%2"#GOF$%8 C1:%8C:% 7:%&A4#&=,$%8O!N=/8*>.%C:%&
0#U4#P0"N^DB% 2,$% B$%&-"# O!:%DB%*-.%0+1$%01 =,$%8O!N=/8O=$%& 0+1"*!L *0.%*2.%B.T%OF$%8
C1:%8C:%=,$%8 0+1"=/8*>.%C:%& Q"#-%-.&OF$%8 C1:%8C:%7:%&A4#&=,$%8 ++1"=/8>:%L
0#U4#2,$% B1T%P!"N$%>:%8 27: !; <$% 2"#-% =4!;2I05.&-"# >4=5/^7-%OF$%8
7:%&A4#&=,$%80O!Na/ =,$%8O!N=5-% M-"0%M-"0%*C15.-%[.&01 27%M-"0%27%*C>.
++1"=/8>:%L M-48F,4^!;2I-0E *DG7T%!$% “UI*O0`. $;2"#G*O0 O0D%0.!"#$% a"#&a,.&2"#G*O0
----- 7I&!,.&*+& !"2%Q"#G2. 2"#G00K!;” 7>:%8 7.>.&2"#G !;<$%>:%8 *-.%UIB4
#D%&*-5.% >IQ"#*>.>I=5$%& (B=# *+,&*-.-%!,/2,$% 7:%&A4#&*+&>I=5$%& OF7%
>4#&O!N*>. >I=5$%&) -"# M-"0%M-"0%@ FD%FD%@ [!%[!% F,$%8C17%*D=/8*9-.$%&
0#U4#P0"N^=405.&?1$%8 0#U4# *O=7"#-% 2"#-% =4!;2I05.&01 74#70%& >"+1"+>:%L
0#U4#P0"N^DB%2,$% 0/7.+$%&01.&O=$%&*9-.$%8 0/*!&=,$%8C-%C,2%+>:%8
168
OF7% 0*2,^+1"=/8+!;L >"#G*>.% 7"#&+01 [#2%O!D%>:%8 Q?Z0/*!&=,$%8+1">E7.+$%&?1$%8
O!:%DB% *-.%0+1$%01 M-"N2$%++1"[.&*>. Q?Z0/*!&=,$%8+1">ETI&*+01. -,.O=.&=5-%
+1"*D>:%L 0,D%O!:%DB%+1" P0"N^DB%2"#$%&C"#C"#2,$% -,.O=.&=5-%+1"*DO=$%& OF7%>:%L
0/*!&=,$%8+1">E !0.i01. O!:%DB%7.+$%&2,$% 05.&*DP!I& 7"#&+01 [#2%O!D%*>.
7.+$%&2,$% D:%&*D>:%L -,.O=.&=5-%01. ?17%*>.$%&<D%&-5$%OF7%P!I& B$%&!0.i01.
)W +.="#$%?KD%&<D%&-5$% +1">:%L
*-.8=!4#*-5&+,. 0EC2D%&*-5.$%&*+1^2,$% +/2!%F,/^<2%74#OF$%8 CE>4#&TI&
+!%*D>:%L C-%-"#$%2#2%?1$%8 C-%["!%2"#G-"# =;&2,$% =5"2%[.&>:%01 !
0:%>:%8C-%D-%01 -"#$%*Q.$%[.&O=$%& 0+1"*!L >E2"#G*a&2,$% M-48F,4^!;2I<$%05.&@
*-5&+,. +B-05.&-"# *2,^+>:%L *-5.$%&<$%& 2,$%&<$%>,.&>:%?1$%8 TI&7,.
*2,^+>:%01. *-5&+,.+B-05.&OF7%P!I&@ p2"#G*a&2,$% OFb 7"0%&<2% M-48F,4^
!;2I<$%05.&-"#!; *2,^+>:%L 0/A4# OF7% O!NC#!%[.&>:%8 7.>$%=D%&*+1^2,$%
0I&>2%<2%74# <2%Q$%[.&>E27%TI&-"#C:%& *2,^+>:%L
B$%&>"#G 0/A4#C4#P=4N*+& 2.<D%BE[.&>E05.&2,$% +/@ 0I&>2%@ 9--%*O=DI@
+!%-,-% 2.<D%+1">E05.& !;<$%>:%L +/05.&01 ! p2"#G .&C4#& M-48F,4^!;2I<$%05.&
OF7%9->:%L
0/A4#O!NC#!%[.&*>. 7.>$%=D%&J -5B%01. )W *!@ *! '( <D%&-5$%=D%G
+1">:%L D4D-% )( D.+I <D%&-5$% OF7%>OF$%8 D4+4-"# *-5.0I[.&*>. 0/*!&=D%&05.&
2,$% 0/*!&*D>E =5N"^?1$%8 p2"#G*D.-%D.&2,$% M-48F,4^!;2I2Q
4 "!%?1$%8 !;2I<2%74#
QD%QD% 727% -5} OFb?1$%8 !#Q"#& 7"0%&<2%Q$%[.&>E =5N"^-"# *2,^O0$%+>:%L
O!:%DB%*+,&*-.-%!,/*-.%0+1$%>:% 0,D%*U>C4#&Q"#$%+. UI0"#-*+7I!;2I@
-+$%O!:%>EG!;2I?1$%8 -+$%CE05N"&05.&OF$%8 7#F,/^[.&>:%8 FC4#Q*<RUI0"#-+-%
27%!;2I 2"#G 2,-% +!%2:%=5-% 0:I015>:%8 >2%012%=5-% 27%+!% OF7%
p2"#G!;2I<$%05.& 0/A#>
4 "#G C.*+.-%0/*!&!;- 2#"$%&+$%&>.&<2%74#0<2%+D%
-D%G>2%=/8>:%L !;2I<$%0,D%CE05N"&05.& *DOF$%8 p2"#G 27%>-%C4#& <2%Q$%
C.*>. 0,D%!#Q"#&-"# B$%&*DG2,$% <2%Q$%=,$%80+>OF$%8 M-I& -5B% *U;>
[,-%*D>:%-"# *2,^+>:%L B$%&>"#G 2"#$%&+$%&>.&!;2I05.&-"# 2#"$%&+$%&>.&
<2%74# <2%Q$%+D% -D%G>2%=/8*>.%C:%& M-48F,4^!;2I<$%05.&-0E p2"#GJ !;2I
169
<2%74#?1$%8 !;2I24Q"!%05.& <2%Q$%f 0/A4#05.&2,$% TU`"# <$%[,-%>,.&C.*D>:%-"#
*2,^+>:%L
“0/*!&+2. *-5.0C4#aE&” `# 0/*!&>E27%TI&- Q"#>:%L
0/A4#2#"$%&2,$% 0/*!&=D%&05.& [.&+1">:%87D7%01. 0/*!&>E05.& 2,-%
>">.*>. P="0%&*O=.-% `D%G2.&0K27%=# OF7%*D>:%L C15"N^<1-%0/*!&7D7%`#
Q"#>:%82"#$% 0"0" aB%!;2I-"# 0/*!&>:%-"# C"#+1">E- =5"D%0*+,& *7.$%89-:8%
?"#$%>:%8!4#74 OF7%*D>:%L
0/*!&=D%&05.& O!2$%&*!;-%05.&?1$%8 DI&-!%7,. 2:%+1"O=$%&@ 0/*!&=D%&05.&2,$%
0/*!&*D0K-"# -"#B%7.&C1B% >"#G0`#2% 0/A4#<D%[0%&05.&- C,B%2-E 9-:8%
?"#$%O=$%&@ 0/*!&=D%&05.&-"# >I&>D%G=D%&!4#74 C#!%[.&O=$%& 0+1">:%8 O!$% 0/*!&>E>:%
0/A4#<D%[0%&05.&-"# 05-%?1.0E[.&O=$%& 0`#2%a/ *-5.*!&[.&+O=$%&@ 0/*!&O=$%&-"#
0O0$%*7+D% O!NC#!%[.&>:%8 -. +405.&>:% D4+4a-%2,$%>.+1"O=$%&@
7.>$%=D%&05.&-"# 0/A4#>2%012%[.&O=$%& OF7%+. 0/A4#05.& -5T%&*O0.$%&>OF$%8 0/A4#
<D%[0%&05.& *DOF$%8 [#"$%+.0[!$% 0/*!&0K-"# 2"#$%&>.& O0$%*2,^*D+O=$%&@
0/A4#-5B%C,D%&*>. 0#U4# [- ) -/8>"#G *-5.$%&05N"&2,$%0E 7D7%2-5 0+1"a/
C1b "0%-/8>"#G 0/*!&>E*+.@ 0*!&>E!; !5.&!D%&=2%@ *B.-%B-%=2%?"#$%C,D%&P!I&@
0/*!&=D%& 27%=#2,$% CE>4#&*B.-%=D%G- P!4N=/*7.$%8Q"#$%&*D+O=$%&2"#G- 0/*!&>E
27%TI&=5$%&7IJ C,2%C!%7,. 0/*!&!"#$%=,$%8-"# C"# *C5.-% =5N"&*F.-%>-/8>"#G
OF7%*%D>:%L
“UI*DG 27%O=.&!;2I*2,-"# 0/[:8%2/8>E*2,-"# >E+/*-.$%&C"#G *O!.C"#G
+2B%L 0/A4#- A"#&A"#&9-:8%+$% 0[E&aE&L 2-B%20%&-5 P="0%&*O=.-%[.&2.@
0/A4#0`#2%aE&L M-48F,4^A4#&OF7%*D2B%” `# 0#U4#P0"N^DB%@ O!:%>EGCH2%*2.% 0/Q?ZDB%
2,$% <$%*+.-% B1T%P!"N$%>:%8 05N"&>.&UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#!;2I01 TI&2$%Q"#$%-
*O!.>:%L
0#U4#P0"N^DB% [- ) 2,$% 0/A4#<D%[0%& d( =D%G+1"P!I&@ *-.8=!4#2,$%
0/A4#<D%[0%& c' TI&=D%G+1">:%L 0/A4#2"#$%&2,$% C4#P=4N*+& =5[.&>E05.& !; <$%
0/A4#<D%[0%&TI&*+ c( [-%+1"*DP!I&@ =5N"^0/A4#05.&2,$% 27%+. [-%!$% +1"*D
>:%L B$%&>"#G 0/A4#<D%[0%& 05.& O!.&[.&+1"O=$%&J >">.*>. +:%+,B%=5-%
170
27%+!%01. Q"#!; 0/A4#<D%[0%&05.&-"# M-"N2$%0/ *DOF$%8 *-.-%=4[.&P!I& C"# !%
>C"# [:%8>,$%& >4#&O!N?"#$%+D% OF7%>:%`# ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.&- >4#&>!%>:%L
0/A4#<D%[0%&*+,&=5B%0K!4#74 + 0/A4#01b&05.& !; <$% 0/7.+$%&77%>E@
[#2%*!&>E05.&01. Q+.@ Q+.005.&@ !:.*+&<D%[0%&05.& OF7%>:%L !:.*+&
<D%[0%&05.&>:% <D%M-I&V.DF,/^7:%&!4#?1$%8 HD%9-.&=5-% + M-48F,4^ >$%&2,$%
0OF7%0*D !;<$%[.&+>E05.& OF7%>:%L !;2I $% .&O!7.+$%&05.& +C:%& p2"#G
!;<$%>:%-"# 2,-%=5-%>"+1"?"#$%>:%`# p2"#G- Q"#>:%L
0/A4# -E<D%[0%&05.&01. M-48F,4^!;2I<$%05.&`# 0:%0=4[.&>:%82"#$% B=$%
M-48F,4^ >$%&J C#!%$D%&05.&2,$% 2-%2-%-,-, !;<$%*Q.$%+,-%*C8+1">E05.&
-"#>. *+,&=5B%[.&O=$%& OF7%>:%L
P="0%&*O=.-%>:%8!4#7405N"&-"# >4#&O!N0K0+1"a/ 2#"-%2,D%& .&*!&>:%8 !4#7405N"&@
-E:I*Q.$%+,-%(O=*>k8A#!%2,$% 01D%O=7%+D% 2,-%>.) *!&>:%8 !4#7405N"&-"#>.
O!NC#!%9->:%L 0/A4#<D%[0%&05.& .&C4#&C"#C#" O=*>k8-"# 0/[:%8+D% 2"#-%2,D%&
.&*!&0K O!NC#!%9->:%-"# 05-%O0$%>-%*>05.&@ -"#B%*2,^M-4N+>E05.&
*O0.-% O0.& +1"*D>:%L
-0.<-%*-5&+,.+1"@ -0.<-% [-%2D%&*-5.$%&J 0/A4# *O= *D01.
0/A4# 0:%*O!.$%&C/>,.&>:% 01 ! *-.8=!4# *-5&+,.?1$%8 [!%2E!$%OF7%>:%L
M-48F,4^!;2I<$%05.&@ -"#B%7.&C1B%05.&>:% 0/A4#M-"NQ"#*+& 2.<D%=405.& *D+.-"#
*72D.8<D%[0%& [0%&*Q.$%*D9->:%L
M-48F,4^!;2I-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&>:% 0/A4# 2,$%& >2%012%*D+.2,$% 0+1"a/
0/*!&=D%&05.& DI& >,.&*+.-%f 0/*!&0K-"# 7,-%F-% F" .&*!&O=$%&05.&-"#C:%&
[- ) 0#U4#@ *-.8=!4#0EC2D%&*-5.$%&@ -0.<-% [-%2D%&*-5.$%&2"#G2,$%
>.0- 0/A4#2"#$%&C"#C"#2,$% *2,^+>:%L
+B- T-nV@ +!%-,-% *-.%0+1$%?1$%8 M-48F,4^+!%-,-% 7:%&A4#&*+&01b&2"#G01.
27%*B.-%2:%& OF7%*D>:%-"#C:%& *2,^=/8+>:%L p2"#G>:% *-.%0+1$%
2.<D% +`#Q"#-. 0/A4#>"#GC.*+.-%P!I& O=*>k8-"# 01D%O=7%+D% CK4*Q.%0K@
2"#-%2,D%&0K@ P="0%&*O=.-%0K05.& +1"*D=/8>:%L
["#GO!$% M-48F,4^05.&>:% M-"N2$%0/[:%8+D% "0%2"#$%+.*+.-% C"#-%C4*=RBE
171
9-+.] “0/0[:%8- 0"0"2.<D%” `#Q#"-. 0/Q?Z+1$% 05.&-"# *=RBE7#*Q.$%& *D9-
>:%-"# *2,^+1"+>:%L B$%& >4#& ?KD%&-"# *=RBE=4+>:%8 O!:%>E05.&- >*a.
*!;-%9->:%01. 0/0[:%8- F0%&=4+?"#$%>:%`#>.OF7%P!I& B$%& 3"!j.B%05N"&
*!;-%*+.-%*7+D%C:%& M-48F,4^05.&- >,B%<"#-% .i.O! *O!.Q"#=/89->:%L
*DG=$%&!"#$%&-2:%&-!$% 0/*!&>E05.& 0+1"*2.8P!IOF7%>:%8 2,-%
0#U4# [- ) *-5.$%&<$%& 2,$%& 0D-%!"#$%& O0$%-,$%&?1$%8 -,.O=.&7,.!$% CE>E
+1$%&*D>:%L
“*>.8=2%C"#-%@ *>.8=2%C"#-%*2.8” `# C10%&* .%>4-"# 9-.&C#"-%>4
?1$%8 2E +B- 27%TI&- *78[.&*>. >4!D%&24=;& X5-%-"# C10%&!"2%P!I& *>.8=2%
C"#-%>:%8 O0$%-,$%&-"# O0$%*2,^+>:%L 0/*+2,-%0:%8 *D+.2,$% 0/A4#<D%[0%&05.&@
0,D%!;2I@ 27:!;2I@ 05N"&>.&UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#!;2I -"#B%7.&C1B% ?17%TI&7I-"#
*2,^+>:%L M-48F,4^!;2I<$%`# BEQ+>E05.&01. 0:%015+1"0:%!$% *+2,-%+D%
=-%=/C1>:%L
0/*+2,-%0K-"# 0/Q?Z+1$%05.& *+1^*01.-%2,$% *+2,-%0:%@ 0/Q?Z+1$%05.&
C,2C
% !%7,. *C8C. 9-:%8AK=,$%8+1">:% Q"#*>.%C:%& 2-B%20%&2,$%
9-:8%AK=,$%80+*=5L 0/A4#!"2%=5"D%2,$% 0/A4#!+<#i%-"# P!I&!"2%C#"-%>:%L C4#P=4N*+&-"#
!"#0"#=5[.&=/8>:%L 9-:%8AK=,$%8 *2.$%&>E05.&-"# *OF+1$%&=5-%*2.$%&>:%L
0/*+=5"D%2,$% 9-:%8AK=,$%8+>E05.&01. !;2I-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&@ +B-05.&@
7 F@ 0/A4#<D%[0%&05.&@ *-.%0+1$%05.&>. OF7%>:%L
0/*+2,-%7T% =5"D%2,$% !B%0/>2%012%=5-%-"# 0/A4#01b& 27%TI&2:%&Q?ZOF$%8
Q4#&OF2%>:%01 ! -5D%0/="#&0K 27%74#27%+. 0O!N=/8`# BEQ+>:%L
!B%0/>2%012%=5-%05.&?1$%8 !2%>-%f >2%012%=5-%+1"*>.%C:%&
!;2I05.& >"[.&*>. >2%012%=5-%?1$%8 0/A4#01b&05.& >"[.&*>.@ 0/77%*Q&*>.
>E05.& >"[.&*>. -,.O=.&=5-%05.& +1"*D>:%-"# *2,^+>:%L 0/A4#27%=#?1$%8
27%=#!$% !B%0/ Q4#&OF2%=5-% -,.O=.&*D>:%L B$%& =5-%-!$% 0/A4#01b&05.&J
a-%C"#-%0K >0.>02%0-50K-"# *2,^O0$%*D+>:%L
!B%0/05.&2,$% 20$%2-.!$% O!NC#!%>,.&*>. !B%0/@ >2%012%=5-%?1$%8
-5N4&0<$%>OF$%8 !B%0/OF7%>,.&>:%8 0/`# 9-0%&F5$%& ?17%!"#$%&=,/?"#$%>:%L
172
>2%012%=5-%?1$%8 -5N4&0<$%*>. !B%0/05.&2,$% 01D%O=7%-"# !I!I>>0O=7%O=$%&05.&
3"- OF7%>:%L !4#74*C&05N"&-"# 05.&Q4#& *2,^+>:%L 01D%O=7%P!I&-.01
0[$%+1.&>OF$%8 [!%O=7%=5"D%2,$% ?17%[!%>F,B%OF7%>,.&O=$%&@ C.&2E
!"#0"#[$%+1.&+D% [!%O=7%C#"-%=5"D%2,$% 7,D%&05.& 9--%*O==2%>u.D% OF7%>,.&O=$%&@
01D%O=7%*=;$%& 0!;>OF$%8 05T%&*9-.$%&>-%>-%OF7%*DO=$%&@ 01D%O=7%*O!.$%&O!D%@
*e.-%["#&OF7%*DO=$%&2"#GOF7%>:%L >"#G+.2,$% !;2I*!R 0E2:%f a-%C"#-%O=$%&-"#
*2,^+1"+>:%L !B%0/05.&J 27%+.="#$%?KD%&=D%G>. M-48F,4^!;2I ++1">:%`# *C8C.
*7.$%89-:8%>E2"#G- >4#&>!%>:%L
+!%-,-% 2,$%& M-"N2$%0/05.& C4#& +$%&C"#-%C4*-.-%=40K-"# !;2I
>I&>I&- -D%G-,-%=/8>OF$%8 M-"N2$%0/*-.-%=40K-"# ["#-% *C5.-%
2.&O07%0K05.& O!NC#!%=/8>:%L >"#G*>.% 2.&O07%A4#>.+1"=/8P!I& T!*U@ >2%012%=5-%05.&
?1$%8 :I *-.-%=4=/8O=$%& 0+1">:%8 M-"N2$%0/05.&-"# !B%F5-%O=$%& 0O!N=/8*!L
["#G*9-.$%8 0/A4# >I&>I&2,$% M-48F,4^- >.+=/8>:%L
M-"N2$%0/05.&?1$%8 !2%>-%>:%8 [E&O=.&=5-%01. M-48F,4^- ?1.27%F5.&>.A4#
*D [.&OF$%8>. 0/A4# >I&>I&2,$% <$%C.O=$%&OF7%P!I& *-.%0+1$%01 +CU%
[#2%O!D%=5"D%2,$%0E ?17%Q -,.O=.&*DO=$%& OF7%>:%L
T!0. 0,D%!;2I?1$%8 M-48F,4^>:% 0/A4#05.&J +CU% (0/A4#>"#G*+.-%>:%8
M-"N2$%0/05.& !; <$%) + +.XiD%&>. -,.O=.&*>.%C:%& O!:%DB%
*-.%0+1$%@ O!:%*[.$%7#*-.%0+1$%2"#GJ [#2%O!D%=5-% +0E ?17%Q (*>.$%&XiD%&)
-,.O=.&*D>:%L
O!:%DB% 012% ) 2,$% <$%*+.-%B1T%P!"N$%>:%8 s"#C%=5N!% #D%&O0$%8>:%
O!:%DB% ' 2,$% <$%*+.-% B1T%P!"N$%>:%8 0,D%!;2I01 *U;-%2.0$%&?,B%7"#&-"#
0/*!&+D% 2,-% p2"#GJ 0.=4 M-48F,4^!;2I<$%05.&-"# *$, W((( -5!%?1$%8 -5}@
!#Q"#&27%74#7I*!&f 0/<B%*!&=/8>:%L O!:%DB% ' 2,$% *U;-%2.0$%&?,B%7"#&
?"#$%++1"O=$%&?1$%8 !2%>-%f 0,D%!;2I-"#B%2"#$%- M-48F,4^!;2IJ *C5.%-,-%27%=#
OF7%*9-.$%& +"!%0"=/8>:%L
*U;-%2.0$%&?,B%7"#&J O!:%DB% ' 01 ! -5D%CH2%*2.%*D+. >4#&=#C4#&-"#
M-48F,4^!;2I- +BE=/8>:%L L
173
*+,&*-.-%!,/0152*>.%C:%& * .$%!,/0=4?"#$%=/8>:%8
*O0C2%- O0$%&P=4P0"N^
174
-C/ 27%+-%>.&!/ *9-.%O$.*C&C.*<P!I& O!D%>,.&2.L 9-:8%+2. !;2I*2,
-"#- *9-.-%!4#+2B%-,L $;2"#G- >E2"#GC.7:%&A4#&2.@ a.*2,*O!.0C/ >"=5$%
2.L a.01C/ `#2%2"!2%2" 7:%&A4#&*+&0C#!%9-aE&L” `# NLD CE$B%*`.$%&
27%TI&- Q"#>:%L
O=.& NLD CE$B%*`.$%&27%TI&-C/ “$;2"#G-*2.8-,.@ -"#B%8=*0.-%
-"#B% *!&=5$%2.*!;8L 7:%&A4#&*+&C.0C#!%C/*!&+01.!/L $;2"#G*!&+05. 05N"&>.&
CH2%*2.%D/G O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%!/ ' *D+.!/*!&+01.@ -5D%2.*2.8 *!&0*DaE&L
72:%&- =*0.-%!/L *[.$%[/C/<$%=/82.!/L a.!/OF7%OF7% =*0.-%!/” `#
<$%*O!.>:%L
“*=2% Q-%Q-%-"#C/ OF2%>D%&=/8P!I&>.&!;L -t,D%*2.%- !$%C4#e.2"@
O0$%&P=401.*D2.@ 0#D%G`$%&=;&Q"#$% F,$%8[.&2B%L Q"#$%D.0:%-"#*2.$% !$%C4#C"#G
*!&[.&2.@ e.2"0"#G*!&2.0`#2%aE&L 2-B%8-"# 2#"$%&+$%&>.& 7:%&C4#&:I:,2%
=/82/8 *D+.0"#GC"#G *!&[.&2.L =#C/ 2-B%8-"# 2#"$%&O!:%-"# -5N"&O!N0B%C"#G
B4#9-:%+2/8 !;2I-"# *!&01.!;” `# ?"#$%$4*+&-"# 7"2%<$%27.& *C8C.=/8>E27%TI&-
Q"#>:%L
["#CED:%&7#?1$%8 QD%G-5$%7,.!$% O=.&>E2"#G01. *+,&*-.-%!,/-"#C:%&
0>"9-@ Q?Z0/*!&D:%&-"#C:%& 0>"9-@ ?"#<$%a. g +-%*DG>:%!$% a.01D%&0>"@
0/*!&0:%C.&*0&*2.8L
“0/*2.8>,.&*!&0B%L aB%>EG-"#*!&+0B%Q"#2.*2.8 0>"aE&L 0*!&+$%
F0%&0C.&0>"aE&L O!yD.*2.8 02-%=5$%aE& *!&*2.8*!&0B%” 05N"&>0I&M-I&
27%TI&- Q"#>:%L
“M-"N-%+$% 01D%O=7%@ 0M-"N-%+$% 01.&O=7%!/0`#2%C.&L /C"#*!&+01.
0`#2%C.&L”
“`.aB%->. *UR-C/ 0/- >4#&0/*!&+01.s5L 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%
+B%@ O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%+B%@ 2"#$%&*U>M-I&CH2%*2.%+B%@ -"#B%M-"N-%2/8>E+/^
*a&-,-%[/01. 01D%O=7%27%=#!/ O=7%+01.s5L 27%=#[-%!"#+$% !B%=4+C"0%80B%L”
“`#2%C.&@ `/8C.9-70%&@ *-.$%0*C&*2,0/- >4#&0/*!&+01.2/8@ D$%O!D%
+1$%&O!C"#-%” !4#?1"!%2"#-% 27%2"#-%01 Q"#$%+1$%OF7%>E P$"0%&7.&*-5.$%&Q+.0
175
27%TI&?1$%8 2EOF7%>E2"#G =5I =5 *O!.Q"#*D9-O=$%& OF7%>:%L
["#>"#G!$% 0/*!&D:%&-"# 0>"+1"9->E01. 05.&7#OF7%>:%L
05N"&>.&UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#!;2I 2,-% 7:%&A4#&*+&Q$%&+D% C.>E
CE$B% 27%TI&- >EG *2,^ M-4N-"# *O!.O!+.2,$-%
pJ*Q,05N"& 05.&7#+1"+. O0$%&P=4>"#G 05N"&>.&UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#!;2I
01 O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%2,$% <$%*+.-% B1T%P!"N$%0:%8 -"#[-%?"#$% 2,-% 7:%&A4#&*+&
Q$%&+D% C.=/8*9-.$%&@ 05N"&05.&?1$%8 +$%&?I1&*>. 0"2%*Q,05.& .&C4#&- ?"#$%$4*+&
-"# 7"2%0<$%7.&9->:%8 O!$%@ ?"#$%$4*+&C#!%>:%8 2,-% 2.&9-*9-.$%&@
CEM-I&05.&-C:%& O!7%2$%*9-.$%&@ =5"D%2D%C15$% C-%+1" 7"#&+>. ?"#$%+
>,.&0:%OF7%*9-.$%&@ =D%G0>$%8C15$% F0%&=4+?"#$%f ?"#$%$4*+&0C#!%!;?1$%8`#>.
05.&Q4#&9-.&=/8+>:%`# Q"#>:%L
“U;Q"#+$% *+,&*-.-%!,/P!I&>,.&+$% .&C4#&*-.$%&>,.&0B%@ UI0"#-*+7I++$%
$;2"#G-*+. *-.$%&*-.$%& *D+01.C.&@ ?"#$%$4-*-.$%&>,.&01.C.&L” ["#CE$B%J
7%0<0%&-,/27%*B.-%- <$%*0&C#"-%>:%L
“ /U;=$%s5.&2"#GD/G!/Q"#$%2B%L =$%s5.&2"#G 2,-% *-.$%&2.C#!%*!&0B%8
!;2I-"# =$%s5.&2"#G!/ *+,&=5B%+01.” `# ["#CE$B%- O!D%*OFC"#-%>:%L
“ 7-*2.80>"aE&L =#DI&C.*2.8 *O!.9-Q"#9-D/G 0/*!&>$%82B%
Q"#2.*2.8 >"!;P!IL 0/*2.8 >,.&*!&0B%” `# *U>=4 05N"&>0I& 27%TI&- Q"#>:%L
“-t,D%02"#G 012%!4#2$% =#["C#!%C"#G 0C#!%aE&L -t,D%02"#GC:%& 2"#$%&+$%&>.&!/@
7"#&+<D%[0%&!/L =#[" -t,D%02"#G[/- CE$B%*2, 012%!4#2$% C#!%+$%
+0%&=-%=/2B%@ *D.-%2-%C.0B%8 7"#&+-C/ U;*2,-"# *OF+1$%&*!&
?"#$%C"0%80B%C"#G 0B4#aE&@ -t,D%0C/ 0/A4#<D%[0%&[/01. !;2B%L a.HD%9-.&=5-%01
*2.8 0+1"aE&L *!&C/0[.&aE&L U;*!0B%8 -t,D%0[$%2B% U4#+$%&- U4#+$%&!/*C”
*-5.$%&Q+.0 27%TI&- Q"#>:%L
“`#"*DG-*2.8 M-48="#$%*+&-*-.$%*2, C.2B%L 7:%&A4#&*+&Q$%&2.L
01D%O=7%22%* .$% UID.&*C&01. O=7%!;C.&C"#G *a.C%!$%D/G 7.+,-%D/G [#2%*!&
2B%L +2B% 0C"#aE&L -5N!%D.&C:%2B%L =$%s5.&2"#G "0%[/0<$%D/GC"#G * .%CH2%
C"#-%2B%” `# NLD CE$B%*`.$%&- Q"#>:%L
176
“ 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%01. P!"N$%0B%8 TI&* .$%*$,- >.7:%>.&@ U;*!0B%8
>EC/ =#[" 7:%&A4#&*+& Q$%&2. 0O0$%+*>&aE&” `# p- Q-%C-% *O!.9-.&
>:%L
“-t,D%*2.%2"#G- +="#$%0,2%7C$%0%*2,L aE&>I&*2.$%- -t,D%*2.%2"#G
05N"&*2, UI-"#C.C"#G0+aE&L 0*2,^2. ?17% '( *-5.%*DP!IL >E2"#GD/GC/ *2,^=5$%
2B%L /U;D/G M-48="#$%*+&!;2I+/^ 0/A4#-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& C#!%F"#G *C15.-%C"#-%
2B%L +="#$%-"# =+I&>,.&F"#G >,.&+$%C/ M-48="#$%*+& 2,-% 7:%&A4#&*+&Q$%&=/8!;80B%C"#G
*O!.O!C#"-%2. =+I&>,.&=,$%8+2B%L 05N"&*2,D/GC/ *2,^+2B%L O!D%C.*2.8
!#Q"#& 27%[:%C-%*Q.$% *!&2B%L .&C4#&- >*a.C/*-.$%&9-!;2B%L
-t,D%*2.% M-48="#$%*+&!;2I+/^ 0/A4#-"#B%7.&C1B%C#!%0B%L "0%-CE*2,C/ M-48="#$%*+&
-"#!/ 0/*!&9-01.!;L O!D% C1D% -5N"&O!N+2.!;!/L” +="#$%0,2%7C$% a"#& "#
27%TI&- +1:%C5.&7,. +1$%&O!>:%L
>EJC#!%+!%-"#C/ X#i%BE*D!4#+>:%L O0$%&P=4P0"N^DB%2,$% !2%=5.C:%]
+,.05.&<D%&+4C5-%+1"P!I&@ 05.&7#01. O!:%="#$%PF"N&+,.05.& OF7%9->:%L O0$%&P=4C0%&
2*C15.-% +,.05.&2,$% O!:%="#$%PF"N&+,.`E*>. *-5.-%2"#$%05.&?1$%8 O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I01
-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&J *9-.%O$.Q"#$%&a#2%M-I&05.& 7"#-%[E[.&>:%-"# *2,^+>:%L
Q"#$%&a#2%M-I&05.&01. O0$%&P=4P0"N^01 ?,.&["#&M-I&P0"N^DB%@ O07%>.&P0"N^DB%05.& ["OF7%P!I&
O=.&!;2I05.&J *9-.%O$.Q"#$%&a#2%05.&-"# C4#&<0*2,^=/8+*!L
["#*-5&+,.05.&01 *U>=405.&J *O!.9-.&=5-% + +,.05.&>"#G 7:%&A4#&*+&
C.*+.-% Q$%&>:%01.C:%& O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I>.+1"P!I&@ ["#!;2I01!$% *+2,$%&05.&
2E&*!&O=$%&@ C0%&05.&*F.-%C#!%*!&O=$%&05.& O!NC#!%*!&*9-.$%&@ O!:%=#"$%PF"N&-"#>.
0/*!&0:%OF7%*9-.$%& *O!.9-.&9->:%L 05.&7#01. *+,&*-.-%!,/Q"#>:%-"#
D.&0C:%9-a/ p2"#G-"# -E :I*!&*D>:%8 O!:%="#$%PF"N&-"# *-5D!%7,.
0/*!&9-0:%8 >*a.!$% OF7%>:%L
O0$%&P=4P0"N^01 0"#$% D:%&$B%>. -,.*<&*>. *2.$%>.P0"N^DB%2,$%
C-%+1"7-%0K<D%M-I& TI&* .$%*>.$%&>:% O!:%=#"$%PF"N&!;2I-"# -"#B%7.&O!Nf
<$%*+.-%B1T%P!"N$%0:% OF7%>:%L <D%M-I&OF7%*>.%C:%& *U>=405.&?1$%8
-t,0%&<$%O=$%&@ *U>F,4^PF"N&*+&05.&-"# *+,&*-.-%!,/ 02"#$%=$% <D%M-I&a<-!$%
177
C#!%*Q.$%=/8O=$%&*9-.$%8 p-"# *[.-%=40:%8>E 05.&O!.&>:%-"# *2,^+>:%L
05.&7#01. *2.>E*2.$%>.&05.&OF7%P!I&@ =5N"^01. 7.*!022%*O0.-%
9-*!L TI&*>.$%&J -"#B%7.&C1B%05.&- * .-%Q4#&- !4#-"# 01D%O=7%=/8+D%
01.9-.& [.&f .&C4#&* .-%Q4#&- -,-%2,$% 01D%O=7%=/8>:%`# Q"#9->:%L
Q?Z0/ C-%012%05.&2,$% O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I-"# * .-%Q4#&2,$% A"#-%?1"!%[.&>:%-"#
*2,^+>:%L
P0"N^*!R+1" ?"#$%$4*+&-"# 7"2%<$%7.&9-*>. CE D:%& -5T%&01 ! O=.&>E
05.&01. 0"0"2"#GJ 7I&!,.&*+& -"7o2,$%>. .+4#7"#-%9-O=$%&@ ?"#$%$4*+& *!R2,$%
*9-.-%+,4^7"2% +1"9-O=$%&@ 0/*!&D:%&-"#!$% 0>"9-O=$%&@ O!:%=#"$%PF"N&!;2I01 ! O=.&
!;2I05.&01.C/ $% .&D:%&!;&>:%8 O!$% 7:%&A4#&*+&C#!%+D% +D%!4#*$, $% .&
0*2.$%82$%&O=$%&2"#G*9-.$%8 O0$%&P=4P0"N^J *+,&*-.-%!,/01. O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2IJ !,/>.
OF7%C"0%80:%`# *7.7I&7,. *OF[#2%f +*DP!I OF7%>:%L
-,D%O0bD7%2"#G M-I&7"#&+.*U>@ “*D<$%&@ 7"D%C,$%@ >2%!7% >2%!7%”
`# ?"#$%$4*+& *-,&*9-.%>4 :4=/8*>. O0$%&P=4P0"N^>:% C,D%=/8*>. ?17%*!;$%&
?17%QB%*-5.%=D%G ?1$%8B1T%C15$% 05.&7,.-,/O!.&>,.&=/8P!I OF7%>:%L *+,&*-.-%!,/
2,$%C:%& 2,-%Q[.&>:%8 2"#$%& O!:%=#"$%PF"N&!;2I-!$% ?"#$%++1"=/8>:%L
O0$%&P=4P0"N^J *+,&*-.-%!,/-"# >4#&>!%+C15$% 2+.&01520K+1"=/8>:%`# Q"#?"#$%
>:%L O0$%&P=4P0"N^2,$% O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I * .$%!,/=4?"#$%=/8O=$%&01.@ M-"N2$%O!$%Q$%0K
.&*-.$%&O=$%&@ 7:%&A4#&*+&-"# $%2"#-% .&2"#-% C#!%*Q.$%?"#$%=/8O=$%&@ CE[#-
?"#$%$4*+&-"# 0>"D.&0C:%O=$%&?1$%8 O=.&P!"N$%a-%!;2I05.&01. $% .&D:%&f
7:%&A4#&*+& 0C#!%?"#$%=/8O=$%&*9-.$%8 OF7%>:%L L
178
=47.&=5-%05N"&74# *!&=/8>:%8 +10%&O!:%DB%01 *+,&*-.-%!,/
179
-#D%C4#&-"# O=*>k8!/ *!&+0B%C"#G =B- T-nV- 0"D%G*!&[.&2B%2/8L
<D%[0%&*2, ( [E&>OF$%8 *-5.$%&Q+.0*2,) - 0/A4#*7.$%8+01.Q"#*2.8 M-"N2$%0/
*2, [:%8+!;2B%L M-"N2$%0/01. 27%F-%- D4!;2%!;!;2B%L U;8*9-.$%8 M-"N2$%0/
01. aB%>E- aB%!;2I-"# 0/[:%8>C/Q"#2. >"+!;2B%L O=*>k8-"# 0/[:8%+$%
C7. (6(((() 2"#&*!&0B%C"#GC/ *O!.*D9-!;2B%L U;*!0B%8 +!%-,-%[/-
CE*2,-*2.8 -5.&OFb-"#!/ 0/*!&9-!;2B%L
-t,D%0 0/[:%8+0B%8 0/A4#- -t,D%0 >E$B%2D%&-*D 2-n>"#C%<$%2D%&["
*-5.$%&2-%=/82/8 [-(') *-5.-%0/01.!;L -t,D%0 *a& "0%- :I0<0%&-,/*C&
-"# *=RP!I&@ 0/>,.&[:%89-!;2B%L 0/A4# <$%01. `D%&F#D%&!;+$% [.&=/8F"#G
*O!.!;2B%L CE-"# 77%2.*2.8 0+1"!;aE&L 0[.&=/8=5$%+$%*2.8 0!;aE&C"#G *OF+$%
+0B%[$%!;2B%L -t,D%0-*2.8 O!yD.0OF7%=5$%2.D/G -t,D%0`D%&F#D%&-"# *!&
C"#-%!;2B%L 0/[:%8F"#G 2,-% "0%2"#$%+.*+.-% -U%O!.&*C&*2, C"#-%*<[.&
2. +1"!;2B%L D4!;2%*C&*2,!;!;2B%L *-5.-%0/P0"N^01.*2.8 -t,D%0>">*C.-%
>2%012%7:%&-0%&D/G:I+/^>.&D/G 0/[:%8=,$%80+2/8>E 0+1"!;aE&L -#D%C4#& -U%O!.&
(24#-$%C"#`.) +9-!;2B%L
0/A4# O!$%01. 0/[:%8F"#G *7.$%8+$%&D/G (O!:%="#$%PF"N&-C"#G [$%+2/)8 2#"-%!4#<2%
TI&*C&M-I&27%*B.-%-"# :*D 0/C-%012%*2, *+2,-%2/8 =5"D%-5+$%
C.9-:%8 C"#G+C.&C"#G *0&*2.8 0+aE&C"#G O!D%*O!.!;2B%L >-%Q"#$%+.!;2I-
-"#B%7.&C1B%*2, [.&P!I&>.&OF7%2/8 2,-% 0/*+2,-%2/8 =5"D%01. O!$%CE
<$%C"#G 0+aE&C"#G -t,D%0-"# *O!.!;2B%L -t,D%0 C1:%8*+.-%C"#G 0/<$%*!&2/8 =;01.
24#-$%-U% *2.$%&!;2B%L 012%!4#2$%D/G*2.8 02"#-%!;aE&L U;*!0B%8 0/C-%012%
[#2%*!&2/8 Q+.0- -t,D%0-"# 7.>$%FE&2/8 Q+.0OF7%2/8 2,-% -t,D%0-"#
>"!;2B%L 0/C-%012%[#2%*!&+$%&D/G Q$%*O!C.& a.:. -t,D%0-"#*2.$%
7-.&*O!.!;2B%L
-t,D%0 0/C-%012%*2,[#2%P!I& C15N"^<1-%Q?Z0/*!&2/8 *D+.01. Q?Z0/*!&P!I&
0/!4#&[/-"# >,.&[:%8!;2B%L aB%>E-01 -t,D%0-"# 0*?1.$%8B1-%!;aE&L -t,D%0
C,2%C,2%C!%C!%!/ 0/!4#& 6 !4#&C4#&-"# 0/[:%8=/8P!I& O!D%[,-%C.!;2B%L C.&2E!/
-t,D%0:I0-"#C/ *?1.$%8 B1-% 0*!&9-!;aE&L -t,D%0 *0 >,.&[:8%*2.8C/
180
/UIC"#!;!/L
-t,D%0 /UI*DG27%*DGC4#& P$"0%P$"0%>-%>-%-"# ["#$%C"#G-"#0+!;aE&L -t,D%0
*OF*2,-"# +0%&>"=5$% *D!;2B%L :*D *C&D.+I*-5.%2.D/G -t,D%0 0/A4#*2,
D.&-"# 0*B.$%0C:% >,.&*D!;2B%L -5.&OFbA4#&-"#C:%& F#D%&*2, =i=i
Q-%*0&0"2B%L *O= *D*-.$%&2B% Q"#2/8 >4*2, Q-%2"#-%9-.&+*2.8
-t,D%0*C *!5.%C"#-%2.Q"#2.L /UI =5"D%[" +D%-#D%a-%- >2$%&*2,
-C:%& =*0.-%?"#$%2B%Q"#2. [,-%*D*2.8 -t,D%0 +0%&*!5.%2.!/L 0/A4#*2,01.
-5.&OFb- (6(() *C.-%+2/8 =5"D%01. O=*>k8- ()g)0/ *C.-%!/+!;2B%L
-t,D%02"#G 0/[,-%*!&+-5N"& D!%>,.&!;2B%L -5.&OFb!;2I- *-5.-%0/P0"N^01. 0/
O!2% >2%D/G ?"#$%>,.&!;P!IL : ()()D.+I*C.-%01. *OF-"# O!2%O!2%>.&>.&
>"C#"-%+!;2B%L
>I*!;P0"N^01.Q"#+$%C:%& *+,&*-.-%!,/*-.%0+1$%- +0%&-"# 2+.&01520K
+1"!;2B%L M-"N2$%0/-"# g +-%*DG 0D-%(d)D.+I01. !;2I-"#B%7.&C1B%*2, *+1^01.
*+2,-%!;2B%L :*D *C&D.+I*-5.%01 *+.-%C.2/8 M-"N2$%0/-"# !B%!;2B%L
>I*!;P0"N^01.C:%& -5.&OFb O!2% >2% ?"#$%!;2B%L
C.&AK"&>2$%&-"# 9-.&+2/8 =5"D%01.*2.8 -t,D%0 <0%&D:%&!-%C-%
=47.&C"#-%+!;2B%L (g)+-%*DG : [" -5.&OFb?"#$%*DP!I&*2.8 *D.-%27%+-%
0D-%-5*2.8 M-"N2$%0/C-%012% (Y((()*-5.% [!%*+.-%C.P!I& O=*>k8-
?"#$%>,.&!;2B%L
a.!/*O!.*O!. -t,D%02"#G+/^ *+,&*-.-%!,/M-I&-*2.8 P!I&>,.&!;P!IL
05.&7#- O=*>k8 ?"#$%++1" >,.&!;P!IL -t,D%0-*2.8 0/[,-%*!&C"#-%2/8 2,-%
*D.$%20+!;aE&L -t,D%0 2.<D%*-5!;2B%L a.*9-.$%8C/Q"#*2.8 O=*>k8-"#
M-"N2$%0/*!&2/8 7.+$%&[/01. -t,D%0D.0:% aB%C"#01 0!;?"#$%C"#G!;L 0"#&27%*!;-% [/-
a.010OF7%*!0B%8 0"#&7-%*C&*2, 05.&M-I& 7#C"#-%2/8 =5"D%01.*2.8 O07%@ *=5.$%&@
$%&@ "#$%@ !$%CB% [" OF7%>,.&01.!;L UI27%=; *+,&*-.-%!,/-*2.8 -t,D%0-"#
+$%=#D%7+.@ *!5.%+H$%7+.@ *U;>[,-%7+. =47.&=5-% 05N"&05N"&-"# *!&>,.&=/8!;P!IL L
181
M-"N2$%0/- C.*+.-%Q?ZO!N>E[-%
!"#05.&=/8>:%8 S P0"N^DB%
(+0:%&>$%&@ *!5.%a,B%@ 0"2vIC.@ *DO!:%*2.%)
+0:%&>$%&
27%[!% #2%:|!% 0EC2D%&*-5.$%& 27%*-5.$%&2,$%OF7%>:%L !"#0"#2"-5
7,. *O!.+C15$% 0?*C&2"#$%&@ +0:%&>$%&=A"#$%@ +0:%&>$%&P0"N^DB%@ 9-:%*2.%-#D%&
+!%-,-%A1" 0EC2D%&*-5.$%&$B% 27%*-5.$%&[/2,$% OF7%>:%L
?"#<$%a. (g)+-% 0D-%2,$% '()( *A,&*-.-%!,/ Q?Z0/*!&+. 0/A#427%A#4
OF7%>"#G B.BI >,$% -E&*O!.$%&>,.&*>. Q"#!; 0EC2D%&*-5.$%&$B%[/>"#G
9-:%*2.%-#D%&+!%-,-%*D 0/Q?ZA1$% O!:%>E05.& TI&2:%>,.&C.*D9->:%L
0/Q?Z+1$%05.& Q?Z0/ C15"N^<1-%*!&?#"$%+D% 7I7T%[.&*>. *D+.01. !5T%=5!%
>4#&=5!%-"# CE27%-"#B%<$%7.C1!%f -.+4[.&*>. *D+. 27%*D+.OF7%>:%L
Q"#!; *D+.?1$%8 *C&*!=D%G -,.2,$% Q?Z0/!4#&05.&A1"*D>:%L Q?Z0/!4#&05.&?1$%8
*C&*!=D%G -,.2,$% 0/A#401b&?1$%8 0/A#4-"#B%7.&C1B% =5"N^A1"*D>:%L Q?Z0/C-%012%
[#2%*!& >E05.&-"# <$%*!;-%2,$% 7.&!,/A1:% 27%C4#&OF$%8 *2,^+>:%L
0/A#4 2,$%&01 [,-%C.*>. 0/Q?ZA1$% 05.&7#*!&=/8*>. 0/05.&01.
0:%>:%8 !;2I 2,-% OF7%>:%-"#0E -.B-4A1$% 0/Q?ZA1$%-"#B%2"#$%-
>"Q4#&OF7%0:%L 0/A#4!"2%=5"D% :*D*C&D.+I0172$%f Q?Z0/05.& *+2,-%=5"D%2,$%0E
0/Q?ZA1$%05.&- M-"N2$% *!&[.&9->:%`# Q"#*>. M-"N2$%Q?Z0/ C-%012%05.&
-"#!; 0/A#401b&- O0D%0.O!:% 2D42C5.& 0/A#4 05.&7#2,$% O!NC#!%>:%8 2"#$%&
[:%8>,$%&*+2,$%=/8>:%`# 0/*+2,-%+.2,$% *7.$%89-:%8*D=/8>:%8 +!%0"+!%F05.&
?1$%8 ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.&J 0/A#4-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&- Q"#>:%L
“?17%+.....?17%+.827%@ ?17%+.8?17.% ...-/>4#&+.$;&QB% *-5.%2B%... .&C4#&
O0$%!/*D.%” `#Q"#-. M-84="#$%*+&!;2I-"# 01D%O=7% Q?ZO!N[.&*>. M-"N2$%0/05.&
-"# 7#7#*!;$%& 0/7.+$%&2,$% [:%8>,$%&C"#-%>:%L
182
7#7#*!;$%&0/A#4 *+ 2,-%D1$%8 0/C.*!&>ETI&*+
+0:%&>$%&P0"N^DB%2,$% P0"N^*!R+!%-,-%M-I& ()()+!%-,-% !; <$%
*-5&A,. #!%7# (cd) #!%7# A1"!;>:%L 0/*!&?"#$%>ETI&*+ ?17%>"D%&=,/*-5.%A1"P!I& 0/A#4*!;$%&
'6g A#4F,$%8C17%=/8>:%-"# P0"N^DB%*A,&*-.-%!,/*-.%0A1$%- 27%Q$%8 >"A1"+>:%L
+0:%&>$%& *A1^O=0%& *-5&A,. S(@ *D.-%O=0%&*-5&A,. '6 ?1$%8 P0"N^*!R(W)
#!%7# 7#7#*!;$%&J 0/Q?ZO!N0K 7.+$%&01. ?17%>"D%&?1$%8 ?17%*>.$%&*-5.% OF7%>:%L
B$%&2"#G D-% M-"N2$%0/7.+$%&01. P0"N^*!R+!%-,-%M-I& ()()+!%-,-%?1$%8 *-5&A,.M-I&
(6()2,$% *-.-%BE+A1"*>. 7.+$%& + =#?17%*>.$%& $;&*[.$%*-5.% (gW((()
*-5.%A1">:%-"# *2,^+*>.*9-.$%8 0/A#4>"#GC.*+.-% Q?ZO!N>E TI&*+[-%
*-5.%C,D%*D>:%-"#*2,^+>:%L
+0:%&>$%&P0"N^*!R2,$% 9-:%*2.%-#D%&@ *-5.%e$%@ #D%&!$%@ *AH-E@
A10%&<"#$%&@ <;2"#&*75&-#D%&@ * .$%0XkC.@ *AHO!:%>.@ !D%&2"0%@ 7IsIC"#$%+!%`E*>.
+!%-,-%M-I& ()()=#A1">:%L
Q"#!;+!%-,-% ()()+!%-,-%J M-"N2$%0/7.+$%&01. *C&*>.$%&
$;&*[.$%*-5.% (SW(((*-5.%)A1"P!I& M-"N2$%0/ Q?ZO!N+.2,$% C,2%C!%01520K
A1"0A1"?1$%8 -.B-4A1$%J Q?Z 01D%2"#$%& `#2%0`#2%@ F" .&274#2+.*9-.$%8 Q?Z
O!N=/8O=$%& A1"0A1" QD%&77%0K05.& 0O!N?#"$%=$%01.!$% B$%&M-"N2$%0/05.&>:% ?"#<$%a. g+-%
:TI&!"#$%&2,$% 2:% OF7%>,.&=/8>:%L
M-"N2$%Q?Z0/*!&=/8+*>.>E 05.&7#01. C15"N^<1-%0/*!&7D7% >"#G0`#2%
"2%!"2%7D7%OF$%8 0`#2%a/ -"#B%0:%>:%8 !;2I-"# 01D%O=7%Q?ZO!N>:%-"#
+!%2D%G*7.$%89-:%8*D>E05.& (+!%-,-%CEM-I&05.&) *A1^*01.-%2,$% 7"2% 0C,2%
0C!%OF$%8 Q?ZO!N=/8+>:%`# M-"N2$%0/*!&>E g(% *-5.%-*O!.Q"#9->:%L
+0:%&>$%&P0"N^DB% O!:%>E05.&J Q?Z0/05.&-"# M-"N2$%Q?Z0/05.&OF$%8
*+.*?1. *+2,-%P!I&*>. =; 05"N&>.&CH2%*2.% 2,-% M-84="#$%*+&!;2I-
O=.&!;2I05.&[-% gc% >.OF$%8 05.&Q4#&@ O!:%>EGCH2%*2.% 2,-% g(%
>.OF$%8 05.&Q4#&@ 2"#$%&*U>M-I&CH2%*2.% 2,-% gc%OF$%8 05.&Q4#& +A1"-.
CH2%*2.%(6)+!%7C4#& 2,-% M-48="#$%*+&!;2I27%=#2:%&- * .$%!,/=4>,.&>:%`#
P0"N^DB%*A,&*-.-%!,/*-.%0A1$%- Q"#>:%L
183
05"N&>.&UI0"#-*+7I $% .&7#!;2I- ))%@ 2.7.:!;2I- )6% +A1" >:%`#
Q-%C-%*O!.Q"#>:%L
“A,.C4#&-t,2% =*0.-%-"#0/*!&2.*2,A1"2B%L A,.*2,01.C:%& '(
*C.-%?#"$%2B%L M-"N2$%0/*!;$%&-.01 AK4&*2.82.!;!/”`# 05"N&>.&UI0"#-*+7I
$% .&7# (+0:%&>$%&) * .$%?#"$%*+&A#4&- 02%*C.$%&27%TI&- Q"#>:%L
*!5.%a,B%
+0:%&>$%&=A"#$% *!5.%a,B%P0"N^DB%2,$% P0"N^*!R+!%-,-%M-I&(g)
+!%-,-%?1$%8 *-5&A,.*!;$%& )W(*-5.% 2,-% 0/A#47#7#*!;$%& ()cd)A#4F,$%8C17%=/8>:%L
0/*!&?#"$%>ETI&*+ 27%>"D%&A17%*>.$%& ()d(((()*-5.%A1"P!I& 0/Q?ZO!N=/8>ETI&*+
27%>"D%&=,/ ()W(((()*-5.%A1">:%L M-"N2$%0/*!&>E7.+$%&01. (g(((()*-5.%
+1">:%L M-"N2$%Q?ZO!N>E05.& M-"N2$%Q?Z0/ *!&=/8>:%8+-%01. W+-%*DG`# P0"N^DB%
*A,&*-.-%!,/*-.%0A1$%- Q"#>:%L W+-% c+-% '+-%2. 2,$%& M-"N2$%Q?Z0/
*!&>E .&C4#&01. M-84="#$%*+& !;2I-"#>. 01D%O=7%=/8O=$%&01. 489>7+.OF7%>:%`#
?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.&- Q"#>:%L
0/7.+$%& =5N!%C"#-%*>. =; 05"N&>.&CH2%*2.% 2,-% d(%OF$%8
M-48="#$%*+&!;2I- 05.&Q4#&@ O!:%>EGCH2%*2.% 2,-% gc% OF$%8 M-48="#$%*+&!;2I-
05.&Q4#&@ 2"#$%&*U>M-I& CH2%*2.% 2,-% gd% OF$%8 M-48="#$%*+& !;2I-
05.&Q4#&OF$%8 CH2%*2.% (6)+!%7C4#&2,$% C.&2E* .$%!,/=4>,.&>:%-"#
*2,^+>:%L
0"2vIC.
0"2vIC.P0"N^DB% P0"N^*!R+!%-,-%M-I& (d)+!%-,-%?1$%8 *-5&A,. #!%7#*!;$%&
d(*-5.% 2,-% 0/A#4 66( *-5.% F,$%8C17%=/8>:%L
Q?Z0/*!&?#"$%>E ?17%>"D%&=,/*-5.% D-% Q?ZO!N>E ?17%>"D%&>4#&*>.$%&
('6(((()*-5.%A1"P!I& M-"N2$%0/ *+ 2,-%01. Y*>.$%&*-5.% (YSW(()OF7%>:%L
0/+CU%05.& 2+.&<$%*9-:.+O=$%&0A1"*>&*>.%C:%& M-48="#$%*+&!;2I -!$%
CH2%*2.%(6)+!%7C4#&2,$% TI&*Q.$%?#"$%F,B% A1"*D>:%L
184
*DO!:%*2.%2!%-#D%&
*DO!:%*2.%2!%-#D%&2,$% P0"N^*!R+!%-,-%M-I& (W)+!%-,-%?1$%8 *-5&A,.
*!;$%& W(*-5.% 2,-% 0/A#4 '((*-5.% F,$%8C17%=/8>:%L 0/*!&?#"$%>E ?17%>"D%&*-5.%
2,$% Q?Z0/*!&>E 27%>"D%&A17%*>.$%&*-5.%A1">:%L M-"N2$%0/ *+ 2,-%01.
-"#&*>.$%&*-5.%(YW(cg) !/OF7%>:%`# ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.&?1$%8 *A,&*-.-%!,/
7"2%<$%7.&>E05.&J *-.%BE[.&*>. 7.+$%&05.& + >"+>:%L
*DO!:%*2.%2!%-#D%& O!:%>EGCH2%*2.% 2,-% M-48="#$%*+&!;2I- Po-
litical Post 2,$% 2.<D%[0%&*Q.$%*D*>. O!:%[/*+&<D%M-I& s"#C%=5N!%*0.$%TI&-
7#7#*!;$%&0/ d'% +.="#$%?KD%&OF$%8 ?"#$%+A1">,.&>:%L
*A,&*-.-%!,/*DG01. aB%C"#0/*!&=/8+>:%
[-%!;P0"N^ (S)P0"N^2,$% *A,&*-.-%!,/*DG Q?Z0/-"# 0:%>"#G 0:%!4# *!&=/8+
>:%-"# C-%C10%&0I>015 *0&O0D%&+. “-t,D%*2.%2"#G 0/>,.&*!&2/8 0/A#401. 7.&!,/
=4#A1:%M-I& *!R01. *!5.%!,/AH$%!,/C#!%>C"# .&C4#&- -"#B%*!&2/80/-"# O0$%>.[$%>.
A1"A1"!/ *!&=/89-+2B%” `# 0"2vIC. * .$%*eB5.DB%*O0(d)A1" >-% SW
?17% A,B% C-%F-%+:%Q#"$%A1$% 05"N&>.& 27%TI&- Q"#>:%L
+0:%&>$%&P0"N^*!R+!%-,-%27%=#A1" M-"N2$%Q?ZO!N>E27%TI&- “-t,D%*2.%
- M-"N2$%0/*!&*2.8 +!%-,-% CEM-I&*2,- 0/7.A,-%[#2%*!&2B%@ >E2"#G*A1^
01.!/ -t,D%*2.%Q?Z0/ 01D%O=7%*!&+2B%@ "2%*2, a.*2, !"2%0*!&+ !;aE&@
0/!4#&*2,C:%& >E2"#G!;0C.aE&” `# pJ *2,^ M-4N-"# *O!.9-.&>:%L
*DO!:%*2.% 2!%-#D%&2,$% M-"N2$%Q?ZO!N>E 05.&7#-C:%& C.&2E !$%
*OFQ"#9->:%L
*A,&*-.-%!,/*DG2,$% 0/A#4 Xk;+!%?1$%8 O!:%874#*>. 0/A#405.&A1">-/8>"#G@ 0/A#4
Xk;+!% 0O!:%874#*>. 0/A#405.&01.C:%& 0/A#47#7#*!;$%&J c( +.="#$%?KD%&=D%GA1"*9-.$%&
P0"N^DB% (S)P0"N^DB%A1" '()( *A,&*-.-%!,/-"# 0/A#4-"#B%2"#$%-"#B%-5 0/>,.&*!&+$%&
OF2%>D%&=/8>E05.&- >4#&>!%>:%L
0:%>"#G!$%OF7%*7 CB%!"#$%&*U> *C&P0"N^DB%J D.X2% 2,-%
M-84="#$%*+&!;2I -27%!;2I2:%& +.?KD%&O!:%8 +D% D:%&$B%>.C"#*>. Q?Z0/@
185
M-"N2$%Q?Z0/05.&OF$%8 CH2%*2.% (6)+!%7C4#&2,$% ?"#$%+A1">,.&=/8P!I OF7%>:%L
*C&P0"N^DB% D"X4#&=5N!%
P0"N^DB%*C&=#7C4#&2,$% M-"N2$%0/*!&>E *+ 2,-%>:% C.*+.-%
Q?ZO!N>E *+ 2,-%[-% !"#05.&!;>:%L M-"N2$%0/Q?Z .&C4#&>:% O=.&
?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.& 2,-% 0!;<$%>*C.-%OF7%P!I& M-48="#$%*+&!;2I-"#>. 05.&Q4#&
Q?ZO!N9-O=$%&OF7%*9-.$%& *C8C.>"+1"+>:%L M-"N2$%Q?Z0/05.&J C,2%C!%
01520K ?1$%8 01D%-D%0K 2,-% .0=4=5-% 274#2+.*!&*+&-"# >-%Q"#$%+. P0"N^DB%
>I&>I&J *+,&*-.-%!,/ *-.%0+1$%05.&- ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.& .& +1$%&C$%&*O!.Q"#0K
0+1"=/8*9-.$%&>"+>:%L L
186
-"#&-.&7.+$%&
)L www.2010myanmarelection.info
gL ('()() 2"#$%&*U>M-I&CH2%*2.%(>"#G0`#2)%
O!:%DB%CH2%*2.%*+,&*-.-%!,/T!*U
dL ('()() 2"#$%&*U>M-I&CH2%*2.%(>"#G0`#2%)
O!:%DB%CH2%*2.%*+,&*-.-%!,/ D:%&T!*U
187
188
!"#$%&(W)
189
190
W.)
>2$%& =5-% C-%05.&7#*Q.$%&O=$%&?1$%8
>#*2>DO!N+.2,$% >4#&O!N=/8*>.D:%&C0%&05.&
191
)L B=#*+,&*-.-%!,/2,$% !;<$%=/8*>. C4#*C.-%>:%8 0/Q?Z+1$% *+ 2,-%-#"
*0&=,D%&!4#74OF$%8 77%20%&*-.-%BE*0&O0D%&O=$%&L
'L !;2I >I&>I&01 2.<D%+1">E05.&-"# 2"#-%+"#-%*0&O0D%&O=$%&L
6L O!:%="#$%PF"N&!;2I !; <$% ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I )6=#01 <$%*+.-%B1T%P!"N$%=/89-*>.
-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&05.&[401 $%2.s5b&!4#74OF$%8 >2$%& =5-% C-%05.&-#"
*0&O0D%& 7#*Q.$%&O=$%&L
SL *+&M-I&>2$%& =5-% C-%05.&-"# >-%Q"#$%+.>"#G 2"#-%A"#-%*0&O0D%&f
7#*Q.$%&O=$%&7>:%8 D:%&C0%&05.&-"# >4#&O!N=/8!;>:%L
>#*2>DO!N C#!%$D%&27%=#C4#& 2,-% >2$%& =5-% C-%05.&-"#
[-%!;D:%&C0%&05.&OF$%8 7D7%2-5 7#*Q.$%&=/8A4#0150- >2$%& =5-% C-%
05.& 74#C$%*7+D%C:%& >-%Q"#$%+. 7# F,G/05.&OF7%>:%8 0/Q?Z+1$%O!:%>E05.&@
0/[,-%0*!&9->E05.&@ !;<$%B1T%P!"N$%=/8*>. -"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&05.&@ B$%&2"#GJ
*+,&*-.-%!,/* .$%?"#$%*+& F,/G<$%05.&@ *72D.8 <D%[0%& F,/G<$%05.&@ O!:%="#$%PF"N&
!; <$% !;<$%B1T%P!"N$%=/8*>. ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.&?1$%8 0IUIB.05.&7>:%2"#G[401
>2$%&05.&-"# +?"#$%>015 7#*Q.$%&[:%8>,$%&[.&!;>:%L ["#GO!$% O!:%DB%?1$%8
192
ANNEXES 5.2
ANNEX 5.2.1
193
ANNEX 5.2.2
O!:%*[.$%7#O0D%0.?"#$%$4*2.%
O!:%*[.$%7#*+,&*-.-%!,/*-.%0+1$%
*DO!:%*2.%
*9-:.=5-% 012% ()S6/'()()
)6g'=#?17%@ D2%*2.%CQD%& ) +-%
('()(O!:%8?17%@ UIe$%a.C g+-%)
194
cc) DB%2,$%C:%&*-.$%&@ '()( O!:%8?17%@ ?"#<$%a. g +-%*DG2,$%
O!:%*[.$%7#27%<D%&C4#&] 27%P!"N$%2:%&-5$%&!=/8P!I& CH2%*2.% C"#-% 0/Q?ZDB%
>I&>I&2,$% *+,&*-.-%2$%*O0|.-%=4+>:%8 CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&J
0:%05.& .&C4#&-"# [#2%O!D% *9-:.=/8P!I& OF7%>:%L
()) O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%
(--) *+,&*-.-%!,/-5$%&!+D% >2%012%[.&>:%8 0/Q?ZDB% 66( DB%
(= =) *+,&*-.-%!,/-5$%&!=/8>:%8 0/Q?ZDB% 6'W DB%
(X X) *+,&*-.-%!,/-5$%&!?"#$%>:%8 +.="#$%?KD%& Yd.Sd%
(') 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%
(--) *+,&*-.-%!,/-5$%&!+D% >2%012%[.&>:%80/Q?ZDB% )cd DB%
(= =) *+,&*-.-%!,/-5$%&!=/8>:%8 0/Q?ZDB% )cd DB%
(X X) *+,&*-.-%!,/-5$%&!?"#$%>:%8 +.="#$%?KD%& )((%
195
(6) 2"#$%&*U>M-I&CH2%*2.% >"#G0`#2% O!:%DB%CH2%*2.%
(2#"$%&+$%&>.& CE05N"& !; <$%)
(--) *+,&*-.-%!,/-5$%&!+D% >2%012%[.&>:%80/Q?ZDB% cg6 DB%
(= =) *+,&*-.-%!,/-5$%&!=/8>:%8 0/Q?ZDB% cc) DB%
(X X) *+,&*-.-%!,/-5$%&!?"#$%>:%8 +.=#"$%?KD%& Yd.' %
()) O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%
(--) Q?Z0/*!&!"#$%=,$%8+1">ETI&*+ 'Y(')c(d TI&
(= =) Q?Z0/*!&>ETI&*+ ''S'))'6 TI&
(X X) Q?Z0/*!&0K +.="#$%?KD%& gg.'c %
(') 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%
(--) Q?Z0/*!&!"#$%=,$%8+1">ETI&*+ 'Y(')c(d TI&
(= =) Q?Z0/*!&>ETI&*+ '''d6ScW TI&
(X X) Q?Z0/*!&0K +.="#$%?KD%& gc.gd %
()) O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%
(--) Q?Z0/*!&>ETI&*+ ''S'))'6 TI&
196
(= =) ++1">:%8=#"$%C4#*>. Q?Z0/ *+ 2,-% '(dcW)c) 0/
(X X) ="#$%C4#*>.Q?Z0/++1"0K +.="#$%?KD%& Y6.(c %
(') 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%
(--) Q?Z0/*!&>ETI&*+ '''d6ScW TI&
(= =) ++1">:%8=#"$%C4#*>. Q?Z0/ *+ 2,-% '(dW)(gd 0/
(X X) ="#$%C4#*>.Q?Z0/++1"0K +.="#$%?KD%& Y6.Wg %
()) O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%
(--) Q?Z0/*!&>ETI&*+ ''S'))'6 TI&
(= =) ++1">:%8=#"$%C4#*>. Q?Z0/ *+ 2,-% '(dcW)c) 0/
(X X) !B%0/@ *!5.-%0/ *+ 2,-% )WWWYc' 0/
(\\) Q?Z0/++1"0K D-% !B%0/@ *!5.-%0/ +.="#$%?KD%& c.YS %
(') 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%
(--) Q?Z0/*!&>ETI&*+ '''d6ScW TI&
(= =) ++1">:%8=#"$%C4#*>. Q?Z0/ *+ 2,-% '(dW)(gd 0/
(X X) !B%0/@ *!5.-%0/ *+ 2,-% )S6'6dg 0/
(\\) Q?Z0/++1"0K D-% !B%0/@ *!5.-%0/ +.="#$%?KD%& c.S6 %
197
(6) 2"#$%&*U>M-I&CH2%*2.% >"#G0`#2% O!:%DB%CH2%*2.%
(2"#$%&+$%&>.& CE05N"& !; <$%)
(--) Q?Z0/*!&>ETI&*+ ')dc6)'6 TI&
(= =) ++1">:%8=#"$%C4#*>. Q?Z0/ *+ 2,-% '('SW)Wg 0/
(X X) !B%0/@ *!5.-%0/ *+ 2,-% )c)gYcc 0/
(\\) Q?Z0/++1"0K D-% !B%0/@ *!5.-%0/ +.="#$%?KD%& g.S( %
()) O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%
(--) B1T%P!"N$%>:%8CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&TI&*+ YdY TI&
(= =) ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.&-"#B%7.&O!NB1T%P!"N$%>:%8 CH2%*2.% YSY TI&
-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&TI&*+
(X X) 27%>I&!#XhC CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&TI&*+ S( TI&
(\\) ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.&-"#B%7.&O!NB1T%P!"N$%>:%8CH2%*2.% YW.Yc %
-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& +.=#"$%?KD%&
($ $)27%>I&!#XhC CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& +.=#"$%?KD%& S.(S %
(') 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%
(--) B1T%P!"N$%>:%8CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&TI&*+ SgY TI&
(= =) ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.&-"#B%7.&O!NB1T%P!"N$%>:%8 CH2%*2.% Sg' TI&
-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&TI&*+
(X X) 27%>I&!#XhC CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&TI&*+ g TI&
(\\) ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.&-"#B%7.&O!NB1T%P!"N$%>:%8CH2%*2.% Yd.WS %
198
-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& +.=#"$%?KD%&
($ $)27%>I&!#XhC CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& +.=#"$%?KD%& ).Sc %
-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&TI&*+
(X X) 27%>I&!#XhC CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&TI&*+ 6W TI&
(\\) ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.&-"#B%7.&O!NB1T%P!"N$%>:%8CH2%*2.% Yg.d) %
-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& +.=#"$%?KD%&
($ $) 27%>I&!#XhC CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%& +.=#"$%?KD%& '.)Y%
(7) CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&05.&J
*+,&*-.-%=4+0K *O= *D
()) O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%
(--) ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.&-"#B%7.&O!NB1T%P!"N$%>:%8 YSY TI&
CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&05.&TI&*+
(= =) *+,&*-.-%2$%*O0|.-%=4+*>. ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.& 6'S TI&
-"#B%7.&O!NB1T%P!"N$%>:%8 CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&TI&*+
(X X) *+,&*-.-%2$%*O0|.-%=4+0K+.="#$%?KD%& 6S.)S %
199
(') 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%
(--) ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.&-"#B%7.&O!NB1T%P!"N$%>:%8 Sg' TI&
CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&05.&TI&*+
(= =) *+,&*-.-%2$%*O0|.-%=4+*>. ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.& )cg TI&
-"#B%7.&O!NB1T%P!"N$%>:%8 CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&TI&*+
(X X) *+,&*-.-%2$%*O0|.-%=4+0K+.="#$%?KD%& 6W.6d %
CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&05.&TI&*+
(= =) *+,&*-.-%2$%*O0|.-%=4+*>. ?"#$%$4*+&!;2I05.& cWg TI&
-"#B%7.&O!NB1T%P!"N$%>:%8 CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&TI&*+
(X X) *+,&*-.-%2$%*O0|.-%=4+0K+.="#$%?KD%& S).YW %
(Q) 27%>I&!#XhCCH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&05.&J
*+,&*-.-%=4+0K *O= *D
())O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%
(--) !;<$%B1T%P!"N$%>:%8 27%>I&!#XhCCH2%*2.%
-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&05.&TI&*+ S( TI&
(= =) *+,&*-.-%2$%*O0|.-%=4+*>. ) TI&
200
27%>I&!#XhCCH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&TI&*+
(X X) *+,&*-.-%2$%*O0|.-%=4+0K+.="#$%?KD%& )S.'Y %
CH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%*C.$%&05.&TI&*+
(= =) *+,&*-.-%2$%*O0|.-%=4+*>. S TI&
27%>I&!#XhCCH2%*2.%-"#B%7.&C1B%05.&TI&*+
(X X) *+,&*-.-%2$%*O01.-%=4+0K +.="#$%?KD%& )).S6 %
(!4)# >"D%&7"#&
T-nm
O!:%*[.$%7#*+,&*-.-%!,/*-.%0+1$%
201
ANNEX 5.2.3
O!:%*[.$%7#>0x2O0D%0.?#"$%$4*2.%
2#"$%&*U>M-I&?1$%8 O!:%DB%05.&+1"0/Q?ZDB%O!*O0!4#05.&
202
-=5$%O!:%DB%+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& )d P0"N^DB%
203
-B.&O!:%DB%+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& g P0"N^DB%
204
-+$%O!:%DB%+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& g P0"N^DB%
205
=5$%&O!:%DB%+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& Y P0"N^DB%
206
77%-"#$%&2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& 6g P0"N^DB%
207
2D>k.+I2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
208
!/=E&2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
209
0*-,&2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
210
0?q*C&2"#$%&*U>M-I&+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& 6c P0"N^DB%
211
0,D%O!:%DB%+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
212
+=#"$%O!:%DB%+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& )g P0"N^DB%
213
+D%-#D%2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& SW P0"N^DB%
214
+10%&O!:%DB%+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& WW P0"N^DB%
215
r+.<2I2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1"O!:%>EGCH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
216
-=5$%O!:%DB%+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& )d P0"N^DB%
217
-B.&O!:%DB%+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& g P0"N^DB%
218
-+$%O!:%DB%+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& g P0"N^DB%
219
=5$%&O!:%DB%+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& Y P0"N^DB%
220
77%-#"$%&2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& 6g P0"N^DB%
221
2D>k.+I2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
222
!/=E&2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
223
0*-,&2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
224
0?q*C&2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& 6c P0"N^DB%
225
0,D%O!:%DB%+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& )( P0"N^DB%
226
+=#"$%O!:%DB%+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& )g P0"N^DB%
227
+D%-#D%2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& SW P0"N^DB%
228
+10%&O!:%DB%+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
P0"N^DB%7#7#*!;$%& WW P0"N^DB%
229
r+.<2I2#"$%&*U>M-I&+1" 05N"&>.&CH2%*2.%0/Q?ZDB%05.&O!*O0!4#
230
*-5&eE&2$%CH.
D.&C:%=,$%8CH2%0:%`# A"#&>.&7,.B4#9-:%0"!;>:%L
231