Sunteți pe pagina 1din 86

Examining HCU Events

HCU events from a-z …

Allan Juul Larsen, MDT LEO9


Copenhagen 2018-12

© MAN Diesel & Turbo


Content to cover…

• Basics
• What is a “HCU event” (data stored and saved in case of fault, thus FIVA
Basic understanding
• FIVA Internal parts.
• FIVA Flow diagram.
• Examining using LDE plot
• Signals
• Which signals are stored
• Examples from service
• Selected cases from service
• Don’t waste time on bad data…
• (jitter profile, engine not running)

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 2 >
HCU Events - Basics
What is a HCU event

• Hydraulic Control Unit Event

• Tells us what is going on in the FIVA control loop


• VERY important for troubleshooting Fuel and Exhaust valve problems!
• Many names: “HCU Event” “HCU Dump” “Log Dump” “Burst Log”

• Electrical signals related to exhaust valve and fuel booster


• Continuously sampled by each CCU
• In case of an critical alarm the data is send to the MOP and stored
• Both data before and after alarm is stored
• Stores a few seconds of data sampled at 2 kHz (2000 times pr. sec.).
• FIVA Setpoint, position, Fuel plunger and exhaust valve position

• Data size: 124 kb each. (~50 kb zipped)

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 3 >
HCU Events - Basics
What is a HCU event

• HCU Event retrieved


from the MOP GUI one by one
• Select one and export to
USB

• If more dumps are needed they


may be copied using explorer:
D:\MANDiesel\MAD

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 4 >
HCU Events - Basics
When is a HCU event stored

• HCU events are store either manually or triggered by a specific alarm.


• Information about the reason is stored in the HCU event.

• Header is composed of:


• MPC type.
• Date and time for event
• Trigger reason, actual alarm or manual dump.

• Make manual dumps from all cylinders for reference.


• The specific list of alarms triggering alarms is shown later.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 5 >
HCU Events - FIVA
Internal part MDB FIVA

A T P

Main spool

P = Hydraulic high pressure supply


CFI = Fuel booster
TFI = Fuel booster to tank
CVA = Exhaust actuator
TVA = Exhaust actuator to tank
TFI CFI P CVA TVA
MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 6 >
HCU Events - FIVA
FIVA main spool

Main spool

TFI CFI P CVA TVA

P = Hydraulic high pressure supply

CFI = Fuel booster


TFI = Fuel booster to tank

CVA = Exhaust actuator


TVA = Exhaust actuator to tank

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 7 >
HCU Events - FIVA
Opening diagram

x-axis position [mm]


y-axis flow area [mm2]

-6mm 0 mm2
Pressurize port to
exhaust valve actuator

- 2

Fuel plunger drained


to tank

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 8 >
HCU Events - Basics
FIVA Set Point – For ME-C engine one engine revolution

Fuel injection

Levels found in
Flow diagram for
valve type.
“Preparation” return plunger and
close exhaust valve Red area
“dangerous” only
allowed here
near TDC!
Position Exhaust valve opening
mm.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 9 >
HCU Events - Signals

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 10 >
HCU Events - Signals
FIVA Feedback CH30 – Setpoint

Feedback follows
set point nicely.

Small time delay


seen at fast
changes.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 11 >
HCU Events - Signals
FIVA Feedback CH30 – Fuel profile

Nice step at prep.

No overshoot
Fuel profile
Prepare for Offset is a
fuel injection few ms.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 12 >
HCU Events - Signals
Flow diagram – Fuel injection

Flow towards fuel injection


start between -0.5 and 0.75 mm

Lets just say 0 mm

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 13 >
HCU Events - Signals
Plunger position CH31 – Fuel profile start

Flow to
plunger
Mechanical system Start of fuel
with some reaction time profile

Feedback passes
0.0 mm

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 14 >
HCU Events - Signals
Plunger position CH31 – Fuel profile shape

Start of fuel
profile
Profile shape determines
plunger acceleration

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 15 >
HCU Events - Signals
Plunger position CH31 – Fuel profile end

After small time delay


Flow to plunger plunger is stationary
stops
Top dead point of
fuel plunger
movement.

Feedback passes
0.0 mm

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 16 >
HCU Events - Signals
Plunger position CH31 – Fuel plunger return

Final
position
Fuel plunger
Flow from plunger to Increases return movement.
tank will allow tank flow and
plunger to return. plunger return
speed

Main spool in More negative


negative position position.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 17 >
HCU Events - Signals
Plunger position CH31 – Different loads

Engine running
10% load

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 18 >
HCU Events - Signals
Plunger position CH31 – Different loads

Engine running
25% load

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 19 >
HCU Events - Signals
Plunger position CH31 – Different loads

Engine running
40% load

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 20 >
HCU Events - Signals
Plunger position CH31 – Different loads

Engine running
50% load

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 21 >
HCU Events - Signals
Plunger position CH31 – Different loads

Engine running
75% load

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 22 >
HCU Events - Signals
Plunger position CH31 – Different loads

Engine running
90% load

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 23 >
HCU Events - Signals
Plunger position CH31 – Different loads

Engine running
100% load

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 24 >
HCU Events - Signals

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 25 >
HCU Events - Signals
Flow diagram – Exhaust valve opening

Flow towards exhaust valve


opening start
between -4 and -6 mm

Lets just say -5 mm

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 26 >
HCU Events - Signals
Exhaust valve Position CH34 – Exhaust valve opening

Flow to Exhaust
valve actuator

Feedback passes
-5.0 mm

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 27 >
HCU Events - Signals
Exhaust valve Position CH34 – Exhaust valve

Opening speed determined


by constant flow rate.

Constant main spool position

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 28 >
HCU Events - Signals
Exhaust valve Position CH34 – Exhaust valve close

Exh.v. closing will start.

Speed determined by
flow rate to tank

Feedback passes
-5.0 mm

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 29 >
HCU Events - Signals
Exhaust valve Position CH34 – Exhaust valve damp

Final close speed is


controlled by exh.v. damper
step one and step two.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 30 >
HCU Events - Signals
Exhaust valve Position CH34 – High force Exhaust valve

Good ability to
Dampened
stay open
opening

Highforce
Step 1 damper
exhaust valve
Step 2 damper Different opening
profile with
overshoot

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 31 >
HCU Events - Signals
Exhaust valve Position CH34 – High force Exhaust valve

Slow open and close slopes

Highforce
exhaust valve
Different opening
profile with
overshoot

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 32 >
HCU Events - Signals
Exhaust valve Position CH34 – Low force Exhaust valve

Fast open and close slopes

Lowforce
exhaust valve
Different opening
profile with
overshoot

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 33 >
HCU Events - Signals
Exhaust valve Position CH34 – Low force Exhaust valve

Overshoot at Slowly closes


open stroke due to leakage

Lowforce
exhaust valve
Different opening
profile with
overshoot

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 34 >
HCU Events - FIVA
Opening diagram

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 35 >
HCU Events - FIVA
Opening diagram

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 36 >
HCU Events - FIVA
Opening diagram

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 37 >
HCU Events - Signals

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 38 >
HCU Events - Signals
ME-V feedback. 1 – Digital “position” signal

The up wards flank is Return flank is


“preparing” the ME-V critical.
Timing is not critical. Time is adusted
to get accurate
timing of exh.v. Activation is not
close time critical, and
will change with
load.

Return stroke
timing is
important. Will
control
Pcomp/Pscav
ratio

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 39 >
HCU Events - Basics
How are axis scaled

• X-axis shows time in ms.


• Resolution is in 500µs (½ms)
• Resolution locked to MPC CPU clock of 2 kHz.

• Y-axis is scaled according to the signals being displayed:


• The resolution is 1 and the span is ±32767 (16 bit values).
• FIVA Set Point / Feedback are shown in mm * 1000
• Electrical current is shown in A/D Counts
• Electrical voltage is shown in A/D Counts
• Exhaust valve position in mm but must be scaled according to parameter
• Tacho angle is shown in deg.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 40 >
HCU Events - Basics
Amount of data stored

• Time stored dependents on the number of signals.


• Number of signals depend on engine type:
• ME-C 6 signals = 5.250 sec.
• ME-B DOT3 5 signals = 6.300 sec.
• ME-B 4 signals = 7.875 sec.
• ME-B (2 cyl. pr. MPC) 7 signals = 4.500 sec.

• In total 31500 samples are stored.

• Marker line indicated the time where the HCU event was triggered.
• ECS Parameters determine the time before and after Marker line.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 41 >
HCU Events - Basics
Examining using LDE plot

• Windows application to examine HCU Events at office.


• Intuitive user interface and proper screen resolution.
• Sort multiple events based on:
• Dump cause.
• CCU number.
• Data / Time.
• Change colors and line width.
• Export and print to improve documentation.

• Show short DEMO

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 42 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust valve stroke low.

HCU Events from service

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 43 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust valve stroke low.

Exhaust valve
stroke is reduced
for each
revolution.
At the marker the
fuel is stopped.
Exhaust valve
activation
continues.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 44 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust valve stroke low.

Reason:

SW related?
Exh.v. Mech?
Hydraulic?
Sensor?

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 45 >
HCU events from service
Manual dump - Feed back not following well.

Manual dump
troubleshoot.

Fuel plunger OK

Exh.v. OK

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 46 >
HCU events from service
Feed back not following well.

Closer look at
feedback.
Unable to follow
set point.
Large Control
signal amplitude.

Reason:
Worn out FIVA.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 47 >
HCU events from service
Illegal FIVA Position

Exhaust valve open to avoid


Cover lifting. Feedback cross
zero when prep.
Is made!
Control signal is
set to safe.
Note that set
point keeps
“going” only
intern signal.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 48 >
HCU events from service
Illegal FIVA Position – zommed

A bit closer

FIVA is reacting
and following
control signal
safe position

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 49 >
HCU events from service
Illegal FIVA Position – zoomed more..

Even closer!

At first sample
crossing zero
control signal is
set to safe.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 50 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust valve closed position changed

Large control
signal tells that
FIVA is not
reacting!

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 51 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust valve closed position changed – compare revolutions

Note the “short”


fuel injection
FIVA Pilot spool
is stuck at exh.v.
open position.

Unable to control
FIVA.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 52 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust valve closed position changed- The good

After fuel
injection control
signal settles as
FIVA stopes at
desired position.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 53 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust valve closed position changed – and the bad

Control signal
keeps going
positive to stop
FIVA movement.
FIVA is NOT
following control
signal.
May be caused
by particle in oil.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 54 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust valve closed position changed

Why is control
signal still
running???
Should be
compression
pressure limiter!!
And safe position
on control signal?

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 55 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust valve closed position changed

• WHY did the control signal NOT go to safe position?

ECS SW 1304-1 ECS SW 1008-6


Load reduction introduced in this ECS
MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 56 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust valve stroke low– OR what is going on?

Something is
very wrong here.
But what?

electrical signal
error
CH30?
CH70?

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 57 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust valve stroke low– OR what is going on?

Electrical fault!
Fault on
Which signal?
MPC output: CH70 or
FIVA input
Is Feedback
correct CH30?

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 58 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust close position change – OR what is going on?

Look like
previous
situation.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 59 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust close position change – OR what is going on?

Dependent on
other alarms and
conditions the
controller might
be active and try
to control the
error.
Could also be
CH70 error.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 60 >
HCU events from service
Exhaust close position change – OR what is going on?

But why is the


control signal
active NOW?

= 20 RPM
= ? Load
= ? Pscav
Below 0.9 bar!!

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 61 >
Update for self-controlling FIVA ME-C
A safe safe-position

• IMPORTANT update for Bosch-Rexroth FIVA

• Self controlling type


• Feedback CH30 used by valve itself.
• In case a FIVA fault is detected the ECS orders FIVA to safe position
• Safe position must be OPEN Exhaust valve to avoid compression cover lift
• Safe position is a constant output on CH70
• Default is -30 %

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 62 >
Update for self-controlling FIVA
A safe safe-position

• Explained on flow diagram

• Controlled (regular) FIVA


• -30% pilot valve position
• -30% sets return speed
• Return to end stop

• Self-Controlling FIVA
• -30% main spool position
• Not opening exh. valve!

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 63 >
HCU events from service
Update for self-controlling FIVA

• Observation in service
• Missing Exh. valve close may lead to cover lifting !

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 64 >
HCU events from service
MPC failure

MPC failure but


which channel?

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 65 >
HCU events from service
MPC failure

CH30 matches
exhaust valve
and plunger.
Fault is on CH70
CH30 is not
changing abrupt
(one sample to
the next)

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 66 >
HCU events from service
MPC failure

Same ship
different MPC.

Which signal?

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 67 >
HCU events from service
MPC failure

CH30 changes
~14mm in ONE
sample.
This is not
possible.
Electrical fault on
CH30 signal

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 68 >
HCU events from service
MPC failure

SAME SHIP!!
MPC replaced
and fault
removed!
Which signal?

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 69 >
HCU events from service
MPC failure

Fault seen on 3
signals AT ONCE
• exh.v. pos
• Fuel plng. Pos
• FIVA feedback
Almost same
value.
Common
electrical fault on
MPC affecting all
analogue inputs.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 70 >
HCU events from service
MPC failure

Affected MPC have Serial Numbers starting with OT


And date code before 1515:

OT1515….

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 71 >
HCU events from service
ELFI Fluctuation G95

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 72 >
HCU events from service
ELFI Fluctuation G95

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 73 >
HCU events from service
ELFI Fluctuation G95

• G95 ELFI Drain kit


• Including long plug

• Check HCU events or send to


LEO9

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 74 >
HCU events from service
Things not to look at….

• Use your time on the real problems


• Many HCU events are triggered by unimportant events.
• Start / stop
• Remove / apply connections
• Electrical noise
• Follow alarms to other alarms

• Some examples.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 75 >
HCU events from service
Dither function – Zoomed to show feedback

One sine
One square

Avoid that FIVA is


sticking

May give a idea


about the FIVA
condition.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 76 >
HCU events from service
Dither function – Situation 1

All OK

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 77 >
HCU events from service
Dither function – Situation 2

Feedback is
“dead”

Control signal is
running

Missing hydraulic
pressure.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 78 >
HCU events from service
Dither function – Situation 3

Set point is
“running”
No control
signal?
No feedback?

FIVA in safe
position, Control
signal forced to
exh.v. open

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 79 >
HCU events from service
Know what is NOT important look at

This HCU event


should not give
raise to much
concern?

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 80 >
HCU events from service
Know what is NOT important look at

Zooming in on
Tacho signal.
Engine is not
running.
May be
interesting but
not related to
engine running.

Connector on/off

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 81 >
HCU events from service
Know what is NOT important look at

Burst and Prep


Sync missed!!

Tacho?

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 82 >
HCU events from service
Know what is NOT important look at

After TDC it will jump to 0 deg.


normal

Tacho is jumping
Indicates that the
engine direction
have just
changed!
Tacho angle is
always counting
positive.
New angle
Migth setup exh.v. open and then this is “missed”
due to the tacho suddenly jumping to a new position. = 360-old

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 83 >
HCU events from service
Know what is NOT important look at

What is wrong?

Electrical noise is
on channel not in
HCU event.
No information in
this event.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 84 >
HCU events from service
Know what is NOT important look at

HPS pressure
drops.
Connector
removed.
Engine not
running.

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 85 >
HCU events from service
SOMETHING CLEVER

• I hope this lecture have given you a :


• Practical ways to look at HCU Events.
• Better understanding of the signals presented in HCU Events
• Understanding that not all HCU Event contain important information
• Gained some idea of the complexity of looking at HCU Events

• If you have funny looking HCU Events or get some. Let me know and I will
comment on them.

• Question…..

MAN Diesel & Turbo Allan Juul Larsen LOE9 Examining HCU events 2018-12 < 86 >

S-ar putea să vă placă și