Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Yuli Chen
Merchant Marine College, Shanghai Maritime University, Shanghai 201306, China
Abstract: To analyze the detection probability of shipborne AIS (automatic identification system) signal from space, a mathematical
model dependent upon three factors of message collision avoidance, power of signal received by satellite and interference ratio of
signal received is presented in the paper. The altitude and footprint area of the AIS satellite are discussed to overcome the collision of
messages transmitted in the different time slots from different SOTDMA (self organizing time division multiple access) cell areas,
but arrive at the same time slot due to the different signal path lengths. The simulated result shows that compared to the normal LEO
(low earth orbit) satellite system, on average the maximum signal coverage area and the maximum FOV (field of view) of the AIS
satellite system are reduced by 74% and 38%. The majority of power of signal transmitted from shipborne 12W-power AIS
transmitters located within the maximum signal coverage area may be received with the sufficient margin of power of signal by the
LEO satellite, but the space-based AIS system generally suffers from the insufficient CIR (carrier to co-channel interference ratio) of
signal received since around 95% pairs of message simultaneously received by satellites may not be correctly decoded. The
insufficient CIR of signal received is the bottleneck for the high message detection probability. Therefore, the measure of separating
the collision messages should be further taken by the space-based AIS system to increase the detection probability.
Key words: AIS, LEO satellite, detection probability, message collision, distance delay, signal margin, CIR.
performance of space-based AIS system is highly and simultaneously avoid the collisions between
dependent upon the determination of the satellite orbit messages transmitted by different AIS application
altitude. The footprint area, power margin of signal platforms, the communication protocol so-called
received, message detection probability, etc., vary SOTDMA (self organizing time division multiple
with the satellite orbit altitude and become unusual if access) is applied. Fig. 1 shows the principle of the
AIS technical characteristics is also considered. The SOTDMA which specifies that one-minute, also
paper based on the AIS technical characteristics referred to as one frame, is divided into 2,250 slots for
presents the mathematical model that AIS signal can each of two designated VHF channels, AIS1-87B
be correctly received and decoded from space relative (161.975 MHz) and AIS2-88B (162.025 MHz), to
to the factors of message collision avoidance, power alternatively transmit but simultaneously receive AIS
of signal received and interference ratio of signal messages. Each time slot is then equal to 26.67 ms
received. Comparison of coverage area between long for 256-bit information communication. AIS
space-based AIS satellite and normal LEO satellite as automatically and autonomously determines the slots
well as the quantity of power of signal received and unused to transmit its messages at the rate of 9.6 Kb/s
CIR of signal received that are both required within using a binary GMSK (gaussian minimum shift
the available AIS satellite footprint area are analyzed keying) modulation and meanwhile reserves other
as well at the various altitudes of satellite orbits so as slots for next message transmission. Multiple slots for
to demonstrate the appropriate orbit altitude for the transmission of the longer AIS message are also
space-based AIS system or the system performance allowed. The SOTDMA scheme that requires AIS to
properties which would be achieved as the satellite reserve their transmission slots ahead of time is able to
altitude remains constant. ensure that AIS messages are not transmitted at the
same time slots within a SOTDMA cell. Moreover, as
2. AIS Technical Characteristics
a channel approaches an overloaded state, the
Totally 27 different types of messages can be SOTDMA algorithm is capable of producing a
transmitted by using the various AIS application progressive reduction of the SOTDMA cell size in
platforms, such as Class A AIS equipment, Class B order to drop AIS reports from vessels farthest from
AIS equipment, AIS base station, SAR (search and the center of operations, while maintaining the
rescue) aircraft AIS equipment, AtoN (AIS Aids to integrity of the (more important) closer range reports.
Navigation), etc., between ship to ship, ship to shore
and ship to space [6]. Each AIS application platform
is able to transmit and receive several types of
messages. For the Class A shipborne equipment which
is mandatorily required to be fitted on the SOLAS
Convention vessels, the message’s information
exchanged is classified into four categories, i.e., static,
dynamic, voyage related and short safety related. The
details including the component and the refreshing
transmission rate for these four categories of messages
are illustrated in Ref. [7].
To enable the automatic and autonomous operation
for AIS without any organization of the base station Fig. 1 Principle of SOTDMA protocol.
Detection Probability Analysis of Space-Based AIS Signal by Using Geometrical Model 163
The detailed technical characteristics for the Class path lengths. Regarding this case, many AIS messages
A AIS equipment are summarized in Table 1 [8]. transmitted from different AIS-equipped ships located
in the different SOTDMA cell areas are received by a
3. Two Scenarios for Space-Based AIS
LEO satellite at the same time slot as both their
Message Collision
transmission time slots and distance from each ship to
As previously stated, AIS message time slots satellite are exactly same. Fig. 2 shows two messages
conflict is able to effectively be avoided during the collide in this case. Ship A and ship B are located in
communication between ships as the SOTDMA different SOTDMA cell areas due to the sufficient
scheme which is designed for the coordination of the space between them but both cell areas are within the
time slot usage in a given area (a circular area with the coverage of AIS satellite footprint. As the
radius of approximate 40 nm) is applied. However, corresponding distance between satellite to ship A and
this is not the case for the space-based AIS system. As ship B is exactly same. If each transmits a message at
the footprint area from the AIS sensor installed on a the same time slot and these two messages will
LEO satellite covers a number of SOTDMA cell areas, undoubtedly also arrive at the satellite at the same
there is no coordination between these cell areas in time slot, which will cause the message collide.
general. Therefore, time slots conflicts may occur for Scenario two is that AIS messages are transmitted
many AIS messages received by a LEO satellite at the in the different time slots from different SOTDMA
same time. The first issue to be considered for cell areas, but arrive at the same time slot due to the
designing the space-based AIS system is then that AIS different signal path lengths. The only difference of
messages from different SOTDMA cell areas may this case with the previous case is that even the
simultaneously arrive at the satellite so that AIS massage transmitted by ship A and ship B,
messages collision arises, which will lose the content respectively, at different time slots, but will also suffer
of AIS message. from the collision when received by satellite because
In theory, two scenarios of space-based AIS the difference of transmission time slot is
message collision exist. Scenario one is that AIS compensated by the difference of distance of each ship
messages are transmitted at the same time slots from to satellite, see Fig. 3, which only shows two
different SOTDMA cell areas with the same signal messages collide.
hmax SA SG (3)
h SA SS1 (2)
Table 2 Comparison of coverage area between AIS satellite and normal LEO satellite.
h (km) ymax (nm) xmax (nm) r (%) PSQmax (°) BSAmax (°) d (%)
400 1,188.36 347.45 70.76 140.4 95.1 32.30
500 1,320.46 373.16 71.74 136.0 90.4 33.54
600 1,437.72 396.53 72.41 132.1 86.2 34.77
700 1,543.62 418.01 72.92 128.6 83.4 35.94
800 1,640.44 437.88 73.30 125.4 78.9 37.05
900 1,729.78 456.38 73.62 122.4 75.8 38.08
1,000 1,812.82 473.68 73.87 119.6 72.9 39.04
1,100 1,890.46 489.94 74.08 117.0 70.3 39.94
1,200 1,963.39 505.28 74.27 114.6 67.9 40.78
1,300 2,932.17 519.78 74.42 112.3 65.6 41.56
1,400 2,097.27 533.53 74.56 110.1 63.6 42.29
1,500 2,159.06 546.60 74.68 108.1 61.6 42.98
Average 74.40 Average 38.20
Detection Probability Analysis of Space-Based AIS Signal by Using Geometrical Model 167
Fig. 8 Coverage area and message power received at orbits for 12 W power.
Fig. 9 Coverage area and message power received at orbits for 2 W power.
Detection Probability Analysis of Space-Based AIS Signal by Using Geometrical Model 169
Therefore, AIS message power of signal received located within xmax area are working on the power
by the satellite reduces as the orbit altitude rises. For a of 12 W, the majority of power of signal received by
constant orbit, except that it is null around the satellites orbiting from the altitudes of 400 km to 1500
sub-satellite point due to the halfwave dipole km is more than AIS receiver sensitivity. All
properties, the graphical relation between the signal messages transmitted from the ground will be received
power received by satellites and the radius of the with the sufficient margin of signal power by the
satellite coverage area on the earth is like a satellites orbiting at 400-700 km altitudes. Even for
left-skewed curve, i.e., the power received will the 1,500 km—altitude satellites there is about 87% of
quickly reach the peak before the gradual reduction as messages with the sufficient margin of signal power
the radius of the satellite coverage area on the earth can be received. By comparison, most power of signal
increases. For example, if the satellite is orbiting at the received by LEO satellites is rather weaker than the
altitude of 700 km, the maximum message power to AIS receiver sensitivity when shipborne AIS
be received for the AIS transmitter working on 12 W transmitters located within xmax area are working on
will be around 94 dBm transmitting from the position the power of 2 W, especially none of power of signal
of about 280 nm from the sub-satellite point. received by the satellites running at the altitudes of
As the radius of AIS satellite footprint area should 900 km or above are sufficient.
be limited within xmax at various orbit altitudes to
9. Analysis on CIR of Signal Received by
avoid the collision of messages transmitted in the
Satellites
different time slots from the different SOTDMA cell
areas according to Table 2, the percentages that the Even though scenario two of message collision can
power of signal received within xmax area received be avoided by using distance delay, scenario one may
by satellites is more than the AIS receiver sensitivity still occur. The signal interference simultaneously
required at various orbit altitudes for the different received by satellites should be avoided in order to
shipborne AIS transmitter power are shown in Fig. 10. correctly decode the messages. The minimum CIRT
As a result, when shipborne AIS transmitters (carrier to co-channel interference ratio threshold) for
Fig. 10 Percent of power of signal received by satellites with sufficient margin varying from orbits.
170 Detection Probability Analysis of Space-Based AIS Signal by Using Geometrical Model
Fig. 11 Percent of CIR of signal received by satellites more than CIRT varying from orbits.
should be around 600-700 km with the maximum receiver, Acta Astronautica 58 (2006) 537-549.
[3] M.A. Cervera, A. Ginesi, On the performance analysis of
signal coverage of 800 800 nm area and the
a satellite-based AIS system, in: Proceedings of 10th
maximum FOV of 80.0°as the majority of power of International Workshop on Signal Processing for Space
signal transmitted from shipborne 12 W-power AIS Communications, Rhodes Island, Greece, October 6-8,
transmitters located within the maximum signal 2008, pp. 1-8.
[4] G.K.J. Høye, T. Eriksen, B.J. Meland, G. Narheim,
coverage area can be received with the sufficient
Space-based AIS for global maritime traffic monitoring,
margin of signal power by the LEO satellite. But due Acta Astronautica 62 (2008) 240-245.
to the insufficient CIR of signal received, for the [5] K. Reiten, R. Schlanbusch, R. Kristiansen, F. Vedal, P.J.
space-based AIS system, the measure of separating the Nicklasson, P.C. Berntsen, Link and Doppler analysis for
the space-based AIS reception, in: Proceedings of 3rd
collision messages should be further taken to correctly
International Conference on Recent Advances in Space
detect and decode the messages and increase the Technologies, Istanbul, Turkey, June 14-16, 2007, pp.
probability and the reliability of AIS signal reception 556-561.
from space. [6] Guidelines on the Universal Automatic Identification
System (AIS), IALA (International Association of Marine
Acknowledgement Aids to Navigation and Lighthouse Authorities),Volume
1-2, Paris, 2002.
The research is sponsored by Science and [7] Recommendation on Performance Standards for an
Technology Commission of Shanghai Municipality Universal Shipborne Automatic Identification System
(AIS) (Resolution MSC.74 (69)), IMO, London, 1998.
(Project No.: 13510501600).
[8] Technical Characteristics for a Universal Shipborne
Automatic Identification System using Time Division
References
Multiple Access in the VHF Maritime Mobile Band
[1] T. Wahl, G.K. Høye, New possible roles of small (ITU-R M.1371-4), ITU (International
satellites in maritime surveillance, in: Proceedings of the Telecommunication Union), Geneva, 2010.
4th IAA Symposium on Small Satellites for Earth [9] Y.L. Chen, H.J. Geng, Analyzing the possibility of signal
Observation, Berlin, Germany, April 7-11, 2003, pp. reception for space-based AIS system, in: Proceedings of
343-346. the 10th International Conference of Chinese
[2] T. Eriksen, G.K. Høye, G. Narheim, B.J. Meland, Transportation Professionals, Beijing, China, August 4-8,
Maritime traffic monitoring using a space-based AIS 2010, pp. 2317-2327.