Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Unit 4
CONTENTS
Section Page
1 Principles of Warehouse Design and Layout 5
• Why have warehouses? 5
• Warehouse design 5
• Location 6
• The building 8
• Warehouse operating functions 10
• Important concepts 12
• Marshalling, goods receiving and dispatch 16
3 Order Picking 35
• Objectives and principles of picking 35
• Item picking 37
• Case-picking 41
• Pallet picking 43
• Other considerations 44
4 Inventory Issues 49
• Why hold stock? 49
• Stockholding costs 49
• Inventory accuracy 50
• Stock checks 53
6 Waste Management 69
• Packaging and legislation 69
• Minimising waste 70
8 Case Study 81
Section Objectives
Warehouse design
The warehouse is, in most organizations, the last area in which significant
improvements can be made. If properly designed, built, planned,
organized and managed, it can improve customer service levels whilst
reducing money tied up in stock and in processes that do not add value.
This has the effect of improving an organization’s profitability.
♦ Order picking.
♦ Receiving/dispatch.
Location and building type may well be areas in which the warehouse
designer has no input as the facility is already in existence, and the design
will need to be based around existing buildings.
All of these factors are inter-related in that choices made in one area will
impact on those in another. No one area can be considered in isolation.
Most companies already have facilities that they have to work with, and
warehouse managers have to make do with buildings, equipment and
locations that are not ideal. A company will often find that what may have
been designed according to the requirements of the company several
years ago is no longer suited to the business as the size of the operation
has changed and there have been changes in the mix of customers and
suppliers.
This section, however, will enable you to look at all the elements that need
to be considered when designing and building a new warehouse. Many of
these can be revisited in a warehouse that has been in existence for many
years.
Location
There are two main factors in deciding where a warehouse should be built:
The actual site chosen will often be a compromise between the two. If the
warehouse is sited close to the market, then distribution costs will be low,
but purchasing and transport costs may be high due to the distances over
which goods need to be shipped. The reverse will apply if the warehouse is
sited close to the manufacturing location. If a number of markets and
suppliers are considered, then the process can start to become quite
complex.
the cost of holding inventory – particularly if all the product range has to
be held at each location. It is therefore a financial exercise to determine
not only where warehouses get built, but how many.
Over the last decade, there has been a movement towards a smaller
number of better managed, better organized and more automated
facilities. Overall, this has resulted in lower costs and better service levels.
Total costs
Costs
Warehouse costs
Transport costs
Total costs
Costs
Distribution costs
Trunking costs
Near to manufacturer
Near to market
Optimum location / supplier
The Building
Ideally, the storage and handling systems that will be used in a particular
operation should be considered before a warehouse is built. In practice
though, as a designer of a warehouse operation, you may have to make
use of an existing building, and compromises will have to be made. The
principles that are used in the design of a new building, however, can
often be used within an existing facility.
Building Height
As the cubic cost of the warehouse reduces as the height increases, there
is a strong argument to build as high as is practicable. Not only do build
costs reduce as the building height increases, but as rent and rates are
dependant on the footprint (square footage) of a building, then this adds
further justification.
If a building that currently exists is too low, then raising the roof height
could be an option, although it would be difficult to implement because of
the disrupting effect it would have on operations.
An office should be sited between the receiving and dispatch areas, ideally
on the ground floor. Other offices that do not need to be on the ground
floor can be built above these offices to minimize the amount of space
taken up.
Docks in a warehouse
photo G Wheaton
Floor Design
The warehouse floor needs to be capable of withstanding unusually high
loads. Storage equipment such as racking or mezzanine flooring results in
high point loads on the floor as the weight of both the racking and their
loads is focused on the narrow legs. The base below the floor slab and the
slab itself therefore need to be designed and built so that the racking can
be positioned as required. Besides this static loading, the floor also has to
be capable of withstanding dynamic loads – applied by the movement of
fork lift trucks, particularly when they are carrying loads. The joints
between the flooring slabs need to be capable of withstanding these loads
or the floor will break up when vehicles begin to move. In your planning
and design, the floor surface also needs to be considered, as there will be
high levels of wear in the operating aisles. Concrete surfaces should be
treated with a floor hardener.
Floors need to be very flat, and the higher the racking that is to be used
within the warehouse the flatter the floor surface needs to be. A difference
in the floor level of just 4mm over a 1500mm wide aisle translates to a
32mm deflection with equipment lifting to a height of 12m. This could be
dangerous. Furthermore, the racking itself needs to be flat to permit
access to pallets stored.
Data relating to all the above activities needs to be sourced and analysed
before a warehouse design can be prepared accurately, and should include
the following:
♦ Physical characteristics of the product stored, for example fragility, size
and perishability.
♦ Stock holding volumes (cartons, pallets).
♦ Throughput (number of orders, lines per order, items per line, receipts,
etc).
♦ Equipment available for storage and handling.
♦ Cost data (buildings, equipment, labour).
♦ Existing equipment and buildings constraints.
♦ Statutory requirements.
♦ Market trends – what is likely to happen in the future.
♦ Synthetics – the analysis, modelling and simulation required to
establish optimum equipment.
♦ Labour availability and quality.
♦ Service level requirements – what customers expect.
♦ Safety and security.
♦ Capital and time available.
♦ The relationship with other parts of the system – both internal with
other departments within the same organization and external with
customers and suppliers.
The basic warehouse structure should include areas for goods receiving,
bulk reserve storage, order picking, goods inwards and associated offices.
Additional space should be given to marshalling.
Very simply, the flow of product and processes within a warehouse would
be as shown below
There are many different ways to lay out and operate a warehouse, and
designers often go through the process of evaluating a number of
alternatives before a decision is made. Although the optimum least-cost
warehouse system may appear attractive, it needs to be considered along
with other aspects of the business to ensure it does not lead to
diseconomies elsewhere.
Important Concepts
As a warehouse designer, you will need to consider 5 important principles
in the process of warehouse design.
1. Unit Loads
Most warehouses operate with unit loads – “the assembly of individual
packages, usually of a like kind, to permit convenient composite
movement” 1
1
Source: Handbook of Physical Distribution Management, John Gattorna, Gower, 1981
Picture – G Wheaton
A photograph of a 40 by 48 inch (1 by 1.2 metre) pallet – a standard size
agreed by the International Standards Organisation (ISO). The pallet is 4
way entry (meaning forks can enter on any pallet face) with a perimeter
base to increase sturdiness.
At its most basic level, the pallet can be manoeuvred using a hand pallet
truck.
Picture – G Wheaton
The forks of the truck are pushed underneath the pallet and the handle
pumped to lift the pallet which can then be pulled or pushed.
If long journeys, heavy loads or lifting to any height are required, then a
fork lift truck is necessary.
3. Minimising Movement
Any movement of product within a warehouse adds cost in additional time
and resource, plus the risk of damage, and therefore excessive movement
needs to be avoided, or speeded up where this is not possible. There are a
number of techniques available for reducing movement.
♦ Separating stock for picking from other stocks, thereby keeping the
picking face as small and tight as possible.
♦ Determining which items are most popular – most frequently picked –
and locating these close to the dispatch area.
♦ By storing bulk stock (reserve) close to the picking face for those items
so that when the picking face needs to be replenished it can be done
quickly and with minimal movement.
♦ Batching orders and picking a number of them together – this can mean
picking staff going to a location once for a particular product for a
number of orders rather than a number of different trips.
♦ Adopting systems that move product to the picker (e.g. a carousel)
rather than the picker having to travel to pick the stock.
♦ Implementing zoning, which restricts picking staff to particular zones of
the warehouse, and consolidates stock picked by different staff into
customer orders at a later stage?
♦ Eliminating paperwork which has to be taken to particular stations for
processing.
4. Controlling Flow
The flow of goods, vehicles and people within the warehouse needs to be
as smooth as possible (to ensure optimum productivity), and attempts
must be made to minimize the number of cross-over points and areas of
high density traffic flows. There are two main methods for enabling this to
happen. The first is by establishing a “U” flow system within the
warehouse, where both movements into and out of the warehouse take
place on a single face of the building, although separated. The second is
“through flow”, where the input and output are at opposite ends of the
building.
The marshalling area is used for incoming stock, where the products are
taken from delivery vehicles, checked against delivery documentation and
broken down into the unit loads that will be used whilst product is stored
in the warehouse.
If deliveries are in bulk from the supplier, it may have been possible to
arrange with the supplier to deliver the stock in the configurations
required. If this has not been possible, then more space will be required to
enable the stock to be sorted and reconfigured.
Typically, goods receiving and dispatch areas are considered less than
other areas of warehouse layout.???? What is meant by this SENTENCE?
This is because the warehouse operator has less control than in other
areas so more flexibility is required and this normally results in more
space being left than is actually required to cover for emergencies.
Activity 1
With reference to your own warehouse or one you know about, carry out the following
tasks.
2. Do you think your warehouse would be better located elsewhere? Explain your
answer.
4. Look at the operation and explain how it works in relation to the 5 key principles
of warehouse design.
2. What are the main factors to be considered when looking at a warehouse build?
5. What can happen if columns supporting the roof and racking layouts are not
considered together?
6. What are the four main activities that take place within a warehouse?
9. What factors need to be considered before a warehouse design can be drawn up?
10. What measures should be taken to ensure warehouse cube is used effectively?
15. What factors need to be considered when determining the size of a marshalling
area?
Location
Building type
Warehouse operations
Materials handling
Storage
Order picking
Receiving/dispatch
2. What are the main factors to be considered when looking at a warehouse build?
Building height
Docks and offices
Floor design
Building column spacing
They have to withstand very high point loads from the heavy weight of the racking and
its contents acting through the very small area of the base of the legs. They also have
to be very flat to minimise the angular deflection when lifting to a height and to allow
access to pallets.
5. What can happen if columns supporting the roof and racking layouts are not
considered together?
6. What are the four main activities that take place within a warehouse?
Receiving
Storage
Order picking
Dispatch
Unit loads
Using warehouse cube
Minimising movement
Controlling flow
Safety and security
9. What factors need to be considered before a warehouse design can be drawn up?
10. What measures should be taken to ensure warehouse cube is used effectively?
Stock should be stacked as high as possible and as densely as possible with the
minimum aisle width between stacks.
The health and safety of employees, the potential for litigation, risk to product.
15. What factors need to be considered when determining the size of a marshalling
area?
The type, size and number of vehicles making deliveries/collections.
The means of access on to the site.
Traffic flow around the site.
Manoeuvring for all vehicles used on the site
Space requirements for marshalling, checking and quality control.
Product characteristics and throughput.
Unit load characteristics and throughput.
The environment.
The number of loading and unloading bays required
Control and administration.
Security and safety of personnel.
The first two concern most warehouse operations, and the latter
operations such as carpet warehouses.
Block stacking is cheap, uses only simple equipment and can make good
use of cube. The disadvantages are that there is the possibility of damage,
control can be difficult, utilization can be poor if the product cannot be
stacked high enough and there is no means available to adopt a first in –
first out (FIFO) policy.
Racking Types
There are many different types of racking to suit different products and
methods of operating.
The figure below shows the most common configuration of selective pallet
racking where single pallet depth racking is placed back to back. This
configuration can be used with wide aisles using a standard forklift, in
narrow aisles using a reach truck, and very narrow aisles using order
selectors, turret trucks, and swing mast trucks.
Push-Back Racking
This is a racking system that incorporates a carriage or other sliding device
that makes it possible to feed multiple pallets into the same location,
“pushing back” the previous pallet. This can be used in wide aisle and
narrow aisle applications.
Drive-in/Drive-through Racking
This racking system has been designed to allow a fork lift truck to drive
into the bay creating very high density storage for non-stackable loads. It
is useful for operations with limited stock keeping units (SKUs) and high
quantities of pallets per SKU. FIFO is difficult to maintain in drive-in
racking systems however.
Cantilever Racking
This is a racking system where the shelving supports are connected to
vertical supports at the rear of the rack. There are no vertical supports on
the face of the rack allowing for storage of very long pieces of material
such as piping, timber or carpets.
Wire Decking
Wire decking can be used with adjustable pallet racking and cantilever
racking, and is usually used when a product is placed into racking without
pallets. Wire decking increases safety, productivity, and reduces product
damage. There are other types of decking available including solid
decking, but fire inspectors generally do not like solid decking since it
reduces the effectiveness of sprinkler systems.
The primary constraints to aisle width are the type of lift trucks used and
the characteristics of the loads being handled.
♦ Wide aisle.
♦ Narrow aisle.
♦ Very narrow aisle.
Fork lift trucks used for handling unit loads in racked storage are classified
by the aisle widths they are designed to work in. Wide aisle (WA) trucks
are the most common type of fork lift trucks – also known as a
counterbalance. Wide aisle trucks generally operate in aisles greater than
4 metres, handling 48” deep pallet loads (the ISO standard pallet size –
1.2 metres). They are also used in yards, marshalling areas or for vehicle
loading. They are available in a number of different configurations – fuel
type, tyre type, lift height and attachments. Many small operations will
only have a need for this type of fork lift.
The reach truck is a narrow aisle truck designed specifically for racked
pallet storage, lifting up to 12 metres. It consists of outriggers in front and
telescoping forks that permit pallets to be picked up and retracted over or
between the outriggers. This reduces the overall truck and load length,
permitting turning in a narrower aisle. Double-deep reach trucks use an
extended reach mechanism which allows storage 2 pallets deep in specially
designed double-deep rack. Reach trucks are designed for working in
racked areas only and a counterbalance is required in addition to load
vehicles.
Very Narrow Aisle (VNA) trucks generally operate in aisles of less than 2
metres and work in conjunction with guidance systems (wire, rail, optical)
to travel safely within the aisles. VNA trucks can be either man-down
(where the operator remains at ground level) for moving full pallets, man-
up order pickers used to handle less-than-pallet-load quantities manually
or man-up turret trucks used to handle full pallets. There is also a swing
mast truck, where the mast can swing 90 degrees to allow access to
pallets, and the increasingly popular `bendi` truck that looks (and can be
used) like a standard counterbalance, but the mast is mounted onto the
steering axle
The most significant difference between VNA trucks and all others is that
VNA trucks turn only the load while wide aisle and narrow aisle trucks
must turn the entire vehicle in the aisle.
Moving to narrow aisles and a reach or double deep reach provides greater
storage density with only marginal additional equipment investment.
Reach trucks are also capable of greater storage heights in excess of 10
metres compared to the 7 metres or less of wide aisle trucks.
Fuel Types
There are a number of fuel types that can be used with fork lift trucks.
Electric vehicles are designed for indoor use only. Their big advantages
are the absence of fumes and their quiet operation, along with the fact
that there is no requirement to keep an eye on fuel stock. Where shifts are
worked in a warehouse, additional batteries and charging/transfer stations
are needed. In single shift operations, or, if the truck is not used 100% of
the time, it can be charged out of work hours.
Petrol or Diesel fork trucks should be for outdoor use only. They are
extensively used in construction and scrap yards, for example.
Tyre Type
Consideration also needs to be given to which tyre type is to be used with
a fork truck.
Cushion tyres are solid tyres generally with no tread pattern (though
tread patterns are available) designed for use indoors on smooth solid
surfaces.
Pneumatic tyres require air and are designed for use outdoors on uneven
and loose surfaces. Pneumatic tyre trucks will also have higher ground
clearance which raises the centre of gravity thus reducing its rated lift
capacity.
Mast Options
Single, double, triple and quad are the types of masts available, denoting
the number of stages in the mast. The greater the number of stages, the
shorter the mast in the lowered position, which means that overhead
clearances can be reduced, making it useful if the truck needs to go on the
back of a vehicle, for example.
Attachment Options
There are a number of attachments and options available for lift trucks.
While most attachments are designed for use on standard lift trucks, some
of them are also used on reach trucks and VNA trucks.
Sideshift devices allow the fork carriage to slide left and right to allow
more accurate placement of the load. Sideshifts will increase productivity
and safety as well as reduce product damage by allowing the operator
more flexibility in load placement.
Fork positioners allow the operator to adjust the distance between the
forks without getting off of the truck. Used primarily in high volume
operations where there is a great variety of pallet and crate sizes handled.
Fork pivots allow the forks and carriage to pivot (rotate). Used for
transporting and dumping specially designed hoppers.
Paper roll clamps are designed specifically for the handling of large
paper rolls, the paper roll clamp ensures that it clamps around the roll and
also allows for a full 360 degree rotation.
Carton clamps operate like the paper roll clamp except the clamping
surface is flat rather than circular.
Prongs are specialized rod type attachments used for picking up rolls of
materials such as carpet rolls, wire and cable spools, and rolled steel, by
inserting the prong into the centre of the spool.
Fork extensions slide over the existing forks on the truck to allow longer
loads to be picked up.
Activity 2
What aisle types do you operate with in your own organisation and why?
What type of fork lift trucks do you operate with? Do they have any attachments, and
if so, why?
♦ Minimise movement.
♦ Simple administration.
♦ Eliminate ineffective time.
♦ Lowest error rate.
♦ Fastest order turnround.
The correct balance of these will provide you with an appropriate level of
customer service at maximum productivity and minimal cost.
Of all warehouse processes, order picking tends to get the most attention;
there are generally more outbound transactions than inbound transactions,
and the labour associated with the outbound transactions is normally a big
part of the total warehouse labour budget. Another reason for the high
level of importance placed on order picking operations is its direct
relationship with customer service levels. Turning round customer orders
quickly and accurately has become an essential part of doing business.
The methods for order picking vary greatly and the level of difficulty in
choosing the best method for an operation will depend on the type of
operation itself. The characteristics of the product being handled, total
number of transactions, total number of orders, picks per order, quantity
per pick, picks per SKU (stock keeping unit), total number of SKUs and
value-added processing such as private labelling for some customers will
all need to be considered; as will whether the operation includes individual
item/piece-pick, case-pick, or full pallet-loads. In many situations a
combination of picking methods is needed to handle diverse product and
order characteristics.
♦ The order picker ends up fairly close to the original starting point.
♦ The picking document should have the picks sorted in the same
sequence as the picking flow.
♦ Fast-moving product should be stored close to the point of dispatch and
the main cross aisle and additional cross aisles put in to allow short
cuts.
♦ Larger bulkier items would be stored towards the beginning of the pick
flow to ensure that product is not damaged.
Picking Productivity
Productivity in order picking is measured by the pick rate – the number of
items, lines or pallets picked over a given period of time, usually an hour.
Since the actual amount of time it takes to remove the product physically
from the location tends to be fixed regardless of the picking method used,
productivity gains are usually made by reducing the travel time by using
mechanisation, for example by using goods to man systems.
Cycle Time
Cycle time is the amount of time it takes to get an order from order entry
to the point of dispatch – the shipping dock. Customers’ increasing
expectations in terms of how quickly they want to receive orders has
increased the emphasis on reducing cycle times from days to hours or
minutes. Immediate release of orders to the warehouse for picking include
methods that provide concurrent picking of items within large orders thus
reducing cycle times An example being splitting an order into different
parts and giving one part each to a number of picking staff.
Accuracy
Regardless of the type of operation, accuracy is a key objective. Virtually
every decision made in setting up a warehouse will have some impact on
accuracy, from the product numbering scheme, to the design of product
labels, product packaging, the design of picking documents, location
numbering scheme, storage equipment, lighting conditions, and picking
method used. Technologies that assist in picking accuracy include pick-to-
light systems, counting scales, and bar-code scanners. Beyond the design
aspects of an order picking operation, employee training, accuracy
tracking, and accountability are essential to achieving high levels of
accuracy.
Item Picking
This is also known as piece picking or broken-case picking and is where
individual items are picked. Piece-pick operations usually have a large SKU
base in the thousands or tens of thousands of items, small quantities per
pick, and short cycle times. Mail-order catalogue companies and repair
parts distributors are good examples of piece-pick operations.
Batch Picking
In batch picking, a number of orders are grouped together in batches. An
order picker will pick all orders within the batch in one run using a
consolidated pick list. Usually the picker will use a multi-tiered picking
trolley with a separate tote or carton on the trolley for each order. Batch
sizes usually run from 4 to 12 orders per batch depending on the average
picks per order in that specific operation. Batch picking systems may use
extensive logic programmed to consolidate orders with the same items. In
operations with low picks per order, batch picking can greatly reduce
travel time by allowing the picker to make additional picks while in the
same area. As multiple orders are being picked at the same time, systems
and procedures are required to prevent orders being mixed. In very busy
operations, best practice is batch picking is often used in conjunction with
zone picking and automated material handling equipment.
Zone Picking
In zone picking, the picking area is broken up into individual pick zones.
Order pickers are assigned a specific zone, and only pick items within that
zone. Orders are moved from one zone to the next as the picking from the
previous zone is completed in assembly line style (also known as "pick-
and-pass"). Usually, conveyor systems are used to move orders from zone
to zone. In zone picking it is important to balance the number of picks
from zone to zone to maintain a consistent flow to maintain productivity.
Zones are usually sized to accommodate enough picks for one or two order
pickers. Creating fast pick areas close to the conveyor is essential in
achieving high productivity in zone picking. Zone picking is most effective
in large operations with high total numbers of SKUs, high total numbers of
orders and low to moderate picks per order, such as mail-order
operations. Separate zones also provide for specialization of picking
techniques such as having automated material handling systems in one
zone and manual handling in the next.
Wave Picking
A variation on zone picking and batch picking where rather than orders
moving from one zone to the next for picking, all zones are picked at the
same time and the items are later sorted and consolidated into individual
orders/shipments. This is the quickest method for picking, but sorting and
order consolidation can prove to be difficult.
Static Shelving
The most common equipment for storage in item-pick operations, static
shelving is designed with depths from 12” to 24”. Product is either placed
directly on the shelving or in cardboard, plastic, or steel parts bins. Static
shelving is economical and is the best method where there are few picks
per SKU or where parts are very small.
Carousels
Horizontal carousels work on the same principle as those used at baggage
reclaim at airports, although on a smaller scale. Generally an operator will
run 2 to 4 carousels at a time avoiding the need for the operator to wait
while one unit is turning. Picking is usually performed in batches with
orders downloaded from the host system to the carousel software.
Horizontal carousels are most common in picking operations with very high
number of orders, low to moderate picks per order, and low to moderate
picks per SKU. Horizontal carousels provide very high pick rates as well as
high storage density. Pick-to-light systems are often integrated into
carousels. Vertical Carousels (similar to a small scale Ferris wheel) are
frequently used in laboratories and specialty manufacturing operations and
are rarely used in regular order picking operations.
Pick-to-light
Pick-to-light systems consist of lights and LED displays for each pick
location. The system uses software to light the next pick and display the
quantity to pick. Pick-to-light systems have the advantage of not only
Bar-code Scanners
Though very useful in increasing accuracy levels, bar-code scanners in a
fast-paced piece-pick operation tend to become cumbersome and can
significantly reduce pick rates. With proper training, tracking, and
accountability, very high accuracy rates can be achieved in order picking
without scanners. These are generally better suited to case-pick, pallet-
load, putaway and order checking operations.
Voice-directed Picking
Voice technology has come of age in recent years and is now a very viable
solution, although it is not widespread. Directions are given to staff via
head sets.
Case Picking
Case picking operations (where numbers of the same item in carton
quantities are picked) tend to have less diversity in product characteristics
than piece picking operations, with fewer SKUs and higher picks per SKU.
The methods that can be used are similar to those outlined above for item
picking.
The basic case picking method relies on product being stored in pallet
racking rather than shelving, and cases being picked from floor locations
directly onto a pallet on a hand pallet truck.
Carousels
Although you can incorporate unit-load carousels into a case-pick
operation, it tends to be an unlikely match-up. If doing batch picking
where you have many picks per SKU and few pieces per pick you can pick
from an ASRS unit onto a unit-load carousel.
Pick-to-light
Pick-to-light can be used in case-pick operations, however, its application
is significantly less than in piece-pick operations.
Bar-code Scanners
Bar-code scanners are frequently used in case-pick operations. Since the
time to physically pick the product is higher in case-pick operations, the
time spent scanning tends to have little impact on productivity and
therefore the accuracy benefits will usually outweigh any reduction in
productivity.
Voice-directed picking
Voice directed picking is equally suited to case picking operations.
Lift Trucks
Motorized pallet trucks, man-up order selectors, and man-up turret trucks
are the vehicles of choice for case-pick operations.
The basic motorized pallet truck is designed for the operator to walk along
with the truck to move loads and there is a stand-on version, which the
operator rides on. Stand-on machines in particular are good for moving
loads over long distances, and are fast, manoeuvrable and require little
operator training.
Pallet Picking
Pallet picking involves picking of the complete pallet at once, rather than
selecting individual cases or items from it.
Task Interleaving
Task interleaving is a method of combining picking and putaway, where
every time an operator puts a pallet away into storage, the in-house
warehouse management system will ask for one to be picked – taken out –
to minimise the amount of empty running.
ASRS
Unit-load ASRS units when combined with unit-load conveyors and
sortation systems can provide fully automatic pallet picking operations,
with excellent storage density.
Bar-code Scanners
Bar-code scanners are very commonly used in pallet-pick operations.
Voice-directed Picking
Again, voice-directed picking is suitable for pallet picking.
Lift Trucks
The lift trucks used for pallet picking will inevitably depend on the chosen
storage configuration. Standard counterbalance lift trucks are used in bulk
floor storage and wide-aisle pallet rack storage in singe-depth, push-back,
drive-in/drive-thru, and flow rack. Reach trucks are used in narrow-aisle
storage in single-depth, double-deep, push-back, drive-in/drive-thru, and
flow rack. Swing mast and turret trucks are used in very narrow aisle
storage in single depth pallet rack.
Other Considerations
Fixed locations are a method commonly employed in picking operations
with each SKU always being stored in the same location. In any system
the fastest moving products should be located as near to the marshalling
area as possible (to minimise movement) and at the heights that are
easiest to pick from.
Prior to actual order dispatch, you also need a checking process to be put
in place to ensure that what is required is actually being dispatched. This
can vary from a simple look at the order to see if it looks right to more
complex check-weighing or scanning.
Once stock has been picked and consolidated into the customer’s order, it
may be packed in a carton if the quantity is small, and shipped via a parcel
carrier. Larger consignments can be placed on pallets and stretch wrapped
to hold the order together before transporting. This will increase security,
especially if sealed with security tape.
Activity 3
What type of picking do you use in your operation, and why?
Rather than orders moving from one zone to the next for picking, all zones are picked
at the same time and the items are later sorted and consolidated into individual
orders/shipments.
13. What is pick to light?
Lights and LED displays at each pick location display the next pick and quantity
to pick.
14. What is task interleaving?
A method of combining picking and putaway.
Stockholding Costs
The cost of holding stock varies from industry to industry, and from
business to business. Martin Christopher states that “It is estimated that in
total it (inventory) costs a minimum of 25 percent per annum of the book
value of inventory just to hold it” 2 The cost of holding stock is made up of
two main elements – the investment in the inventory and the storage
costs.
2
Logistics and Supply Chain Management, Martin Christopher, Pitman Publishing 1998. p81
Inventory Accuracy
If an organisation is having problems with inventory accuracy, it is often
assumed that the introduction of new technology such as bar-coding, or
pick-to-light will solve the problems. It is possible for technology to reduce
errors, but not eliminate them altogether. As a manager, your
organisation’s focus should be on the basics first.
Attitude
Maintaining inventory accuracy must be an integral part of your attitude
and of your organisation. Like quality, customer service, and plant safety,
accuracy must be promoted throughout the organization as everyone's
responsibility. Processes are often shortcut if they impact on short term
productivity and profitability. In the long term, this will reduce an
Procedure Documentation
The processes and procedures within them should be written down, once
identified, and staff advised that they must follow them. The
documentation should be as clear and comprehensive as possible and it
should be written for a specific task within a specific job responsibility, it
should include everything the employee needs to know to complete the
task. Good practice requires that procedures should also include the
correct method for filling out and processing paperwork, the sequence and
timing of entering data, and any checks that are required to be performed.
If there are any exceptions to a procedure they should be specified in the
document, allowing undocumented exceptions to a procedure will decrease
its effectiveness. Once the documentation is complete, it should be
passed initially to a few key employees and monitored to see if anything is
missing or incorrect. Once this is done, it can be passed to all staff.
Employee Training
Again as a manager it is important that you set time aside to go through
the processes with staff to ensure they have a thorough understanding of
what needs to be done for each documented task. Revisions to procedures
should take place periodically, but not too often as this can cause
confusion.
Employee Testing
Employees should be tested to ensure they understand what is required of
them. Those you have identified as not having understood properly must
be retrained.
Monitoring
Any actions observed which do not comply with the written procedures
must be addressed immediately with the employees involved.
Standards
Setting standards requires tracking of the accuracy and productivity of the
tasks being performed which makes it more viable when there are a
number of people performing the same tasks. Standards need to be
enforced, but should be set at reasonable levels, after researching what
these should be. They can always be raised later.
Tracking Accuracy
There is a need to track accuracy both organizationally (as a total) and
individually by person. Accuracy tracking should always be measured as a
percentage of total transactions, and should be communicated to staff as a
way of improving the operation, not trying to find fault.
Accountability
People must be held accountable for following documented procedures. If
someone is not following the procedures you as a manager must deal with
this using appropriate disciplinary action. People will always make
mistakes, but they should at least be following procedures.
Count
Inventory will need to be counted to determine accuracy, although reports
from customers relating to short shipments should quickly help to identify
problem areas. Year-end stock checks are tools used by accountants, but
do little for inventory accuracy. Stock needs to be counted more regularly
to be useful, and this can be achieved with cycle counting. This is where
the SKUs are split by popularity, and more popular SKUs are counted, say,
10 times a year. Medium SKUs could be counted 5 times, and the slow
movers twice a year. A number of SKUs could be counted each day as part
of normal warehouse procedures.
Re-evaluation
You should ensure that processes and procedures are regularly re-
evaluated.
Stock Checks
Good practice in most organizations is to carry out a stock check at least
once a year. This is a process where all the stock held by the company is
counted and compared to what stock records say should be held.
Variances can be investigated and corrections made if necessary.
The process should be a simple one, but all too often takes companies far
too long because of inadequate preparation and training of staff involved.
If too much time is taken, then customer service levels will be affected as
no stock can be moved over this period.
It is necessary to identify the best time to carry out a stock check. This will
almost inevitably be at year end (at least), and could probably be also held
after the first half of the year. Care should be taken to conduct the stock
check at a time that causes minimum disturbance to the business and any
adverse impact on customer service levels. Many companies in the UK
count stock between Christmas and New Year, a time when the peak
period is over. Mid-term counts are often conducted at weekends.
You must ensure that sufficient staff is available to count the stock in a
given period, and to enter data on to the computer system.
All receipts should have been entered into the computer system before the
count takes place, and preferably put away into locations in the
warehouse. Any damages must be written off. Staff (and customers and
suppliers) should be made aware of the fact that no product will be
received nor any stock picked or shipped during the period of the stock
check.
3
Inventory Accuracy: People, Processes and Technology, Dave Piasecki.. Ops publishing 2003
A map or list of all locations should be drawn up, and staff nominated to
count particular areas. The count itself needs to be drawn-up to suit the
operation. Some organisations physically count stock in picking locations
and take information from flagged pallets that have not been touched
since receipt to reduce the time taken. Some count everything irrespective
of location. Counting at height requires safety cages to be used if specialist
high-level order pickers are not available, or the stock is not to be brought
to floor level to be counted.
A two-part stock count ticket is a simple yet efficient way to conduct the
count itself. This ticket has a unique identification number printed on it, as
well as blank spaces for item number, warehouse location and quantity to
be filled in by the counting staff. This is known as a blind count. Tickets
can be produced listing what is supposed to be in particular locations, but
human nature is such that the easy route is often taken, and the ticket
figures taken as being accurate if there is any ambiguity. When the count
is actually underway, one part of the ticket should be affixed to the
product in the location being counted, and the other handed in to staff to
be keyed. This gives a visual indication that stock has been counted.
A note should be made of the ticket numbers given to particular counters
in a particular area, and all tickets handed back in once completed, even if
the tickets have been spoilt. This will enable checks to be properly
conducted at a later stage. It is possible to produce just one ticket per
location and check these off once returned to ensure that nothing is
missed.
Once the physical count has been completed, all tickets handed in and
checks made to establish no tickets/locations have been missed, the count
needs to be keyed onto the computer system being used. This can often
take place concurrently with the physical count to minimize the time
taken. Once this has been completed, a variance report should be
produced comparing what the stock records in the inventory file on the
computer system say should be available against the actual count.
Differences in the physical count and the stock file can be down to any
number of reasons, and include:
♦ Inaccurate counting.
♦ Inaccurate keying of stock counts.
♦ Stock incorrectly receipted.
♦ Stock incorrectly shipped.
♦ Shrinkage.
This is a process that can be used to avoid the company having to suspend
operations whilst stock is counted. Cycle counting is the regularly
scheduled count of products, normally daily, based on some predefined
parameters. Inventory can be broken down by ABC classification, and each
classification of product assigned a count frequency. The more important
class A items may need to be counted 10 times a year, B items 5 times,
and C twice for example. A number of SKUs will be counted as part of daily
routines by fully trained staff, and any variances investigated. It should be
remembered that this system is useful if the inventory is accurate at the
outset, but is a system that is checking stock records that exist on the
stock file and so is unlikely to turn up anything that has been overlooked,
for instance stock that has not been booked on.
Activity 4
How does your organisation count stock?
Service Quality
In an increasingly-competitive business environment, service levels have
been continuously improving over time. The level of service provided is
normally reflected in the cost of the operation. The better the service
provision the higher the costs.
This steep curve is accounted for largely as a result of the large stocks
that would need to be held to ensure there were no stock-outs if demand
became unexpectedly high. It is possible to see that costs increase
disproportionately the closer service levels approach 100%. Decisions
♦ Order cycle time – the time from receiving an order to delivering it.
♦ Consistency and reliability of delivery.
♦ Available stock.
♦ Order size constraints, such as minimum order quantities.
♦ Ordering convenience – how easy it is for the customer to place an
order.
♦ Delivery times and flexibility such as speed and booking deliveries.
♦ Invoicing procedures (such as payment terms – 30 days, 60 days etc)
and accuracy.
♦ Claims procedure – if stock is missing from a delivery, how the
organisation deals with it.
♦ Condition of goods.
♦ Visits by sales people – more visits are better.
♦ Order status information.
It can be seen that although not all of the above is affected by warehouse
operations, a significant section is, highlighting the importance of the part
that the warehouse has to play.
If improving customer service costs more than the actual sales generated
as a result of the improved policy, then there should be questions asked
about whether it is worthwhile pursuing.
Pareto can form the basis for developing a service strategy – giving better
service to better customers.
Administrative Processes
The main administrative processes within a warehouse are concerned with
incoming stock, movements of stock and shipments of stock out of the
warehouse.
The number of picking notes produced each day need to be sorted by the
warehouse management team to ensure that not only are orders
processed according to the customer’s delivery expectations, (and also
internal standards), but that the workflow is smoothed as much as
possible to minimize the resource required. Any additional processing
required, such as ticketing for customer orders, needs to be considered at
this stage.
Whilst the order is being picked, the picker should annotate the picking
note to show that the items have been picked in the right quantities, and
on completion, it should be signed by the picker and filed in case any
query should be raised about it at a later date. Any checking of the order
should be conducted at this stage. This can be through using scanning
technology or manually checking against the order.
for shipment. This will vary according to the method selected for dispatch
and the size of the order. Smaller orders may well be boxed and sent out
via a parcel carrier such as Parcelforce or TNT, whereas larger orders may
be palletised and sent out using a parcel carrier, haulier or in-house
transport operation.
At the same time that stock is being shipped out, your warehouse is also
dealing with stock coming in from suppliers or your own manufacturing
facility. Orders will have been placed according to company inventory
policy and will be received dependant on lead time – the time it takes for
a supplier from receipt of an order, to manufacture and deliver stock to
the customer.
Where there are a number of orders outstanding with suppliers at any one
time, it is important that attempts are made to smooth the flow of stock
into the warehouse to minimise resource requirements (for unloading and
put away), but without compromising company targets on order fulfilment.
A booking-in system is invaluable to ensure an even work flow.
The stock received should then be keyed onto the main inventory system
to update stock records. This is normally done against a goods received
note (GRN) that can then provide an audit trail. This will match-up receipts
against purchase orders that have been raised for the stock. Any
discrepancies from the delivery documentation should be notified to the
supplier, normally via the generation of a debit note that will reflect the
difference between the delivery note (invoiced quantity) and actual
receipts. It is important to contact the supplier quickly, as companies often
have set time limits within their terms and conditions of business after
which claims will not be entertained.
After being flagged, product can then be put away into pallet or shelf
locations within the warehouse. This should be reflected on the WMS, with
records made of what is put where. Again, this can be either on a manual
or computerised basis.
Any movements from location to location within the warehouse should also
be recorded to ensure stock records are accurate.
♦ Stock checking.
♦ Quarantine/QC – if product is inspected within the warehouse then it
needs to be quarantined (made unavailable), and only put into stock
once tests have been passed.
♦ Returns – product coming back needs to be evaluated to determine.
why. It may be a quality problem, in which case it will need to pass
through the QC process or it could even be stock incorrectly delivered
which can be returned to stock.
♦ Damaged/broken stock – damages within the warehouse need to be
written off.
♦ Stock transfers – this could be moving stock from one warehouse to
another, for example.
♦ Frozen stock – stock can be reserved for certain customers by being
frozen, and therefore unavailable to others.
♦ Kitting – this is where a number of items are put together to form a
set.
♦ Ticketing – processes need to be in place to ensure sufficient tickets
are available for customer orders.
It is important not only that the KPIs used within a particular area have
relevance for all staff working within that area, but that the data can be
Service Levels
Both operational and inventory service levels need to be set in conjunction
with customer service requirements, normally in relation to a time period.
An example of this would be that all customer orders should be turned
round within 5 days from receipt, and the stock should be dispatched
using a guaranteed 48-hour delivery service.
Operating Costs
Expense budgets are drawn up by companies at the beginning of a given
period, and these should then be broken down into cost centres which
should then become the responsibility of the relevant departmental
manager. These should include all the elements within that department,
such as labour, overheads, and maintenance.
Unit costing can then be “pulled-out” from the budget and used for control
purposes, making comparisons and assessing alternative methods. The
budget can be compared with actual costs and unit costs calculated, for
example, a budget of x would allow for a certain number of pallets being
stored. If the actual costs show more than x, then this may well be
because more pallets are being stored than budgeted for.
Unit costing could relate to the number of pallets stored, the number of
trucks received and unloaded, the number of truckloads dispatched, the
number of orders processed, or units picked for example. Whatever
measure is used, it must be understood by those working within the group
and be shown to be accurate.
Productivity Measurement
This is similar to unit costing, but is considered at two levels, the macro
and the micro. The so called “helicopter view” of the macro level would
generate information such as:
At the lower micro level, the information would be more detailed, and
could include:
The results would need to be compared with the standard, and any
variations analysed.
Benchmarking
This is the process of comparing one operation with another in order to
establish whether the organization is performing well or not in a number of
areas. Operations being compared (partners) should be carefully chosen,
as no two organizations are completely alike, and this could lead to some
confusing analysis. One method sometimes used is to compare an
organisations processes and performance with industry best-practice to
see whether improvements could be made.
Activity 5
Identify where customer service improvements could be made in your organization
without disproportionately increasing costs.
What is the 80:20 rule, and how do you think it could be used to improve customer
service?
Can you think of any potential partners for benchmarking with your own operation,
and why would they be suitable?
1. What is the limit to the level of customer service that a company should provide?
2. What are the factors that affect customer service as viewed by the customer?
3. How is the perfect order defined?
4. How can customers place orders?
5. What system should be implemented for smoothing inbound deliveries?
6. What should the process be on receiving goods?
7. What tools are available to measure performance?
8. Why should performance be measured?
9. Give some examples of : a – KPIs
b – Unit costs
c – Productivity
The Environment Agency has been given powers that enable them to audit
an organisations compliance, which needs to be fully documented.
Companies that do not comply can be prosecuted.
Some products are now banned from landfill sites, and everything except
inert waste will need to be treated in some way before it can be sent to
landfill. This may be a physical, thermal, chemical or biological treatment
to reduce not only the volume of material, but also reduce the hazardous
nature of the waste. This will apply to all hazardous waste from July 2004
and all other waste from July 2009. These tighter controls should have the
effect of motivating companies to reduce their waste production.
Minimising Waste
Companies need to embrace methods for minimising waste in order to
control costs. Companies should evaluate all work processes and activities
to identify types and volumes of waste being created. Types of waste can
be anything from used lubricants to waste paper. Most typical warehouse
4
Source: Storage, handling and distribution magazine, July 2003 page 22
operations will find that the bulk of waste will be in the form of cardboard
boxes, stretch wrap polythene, polythene tape, plastic strapping, plastic
bags and polystyrene or paper-based void fill material.
Waste cardboard and stretch wrap material can be baled (to reduce the
space it takes up), and passed to specialist recycling operators. In this
situation, documentation will be provided by the collector that can then be
used to offset some recycling obligations.
Activity 6
What laws apply in your own country with regard to waste?
How does a company that you know of dispose of waste materials and what does it
recycle?
Fork Trucks
Modern materials handling equipment (MHE) is manufactured to safety
standards laid down by European Directives covering design and function.
Ultimately, however, safety is down to the individual using the equipment.
Training is of critical importance.
Your company should have a strong self interest in safety as the economic
impacts of accidents can be considerable, such as:
♦ Damage to equipment.
♦ Damage to stock.
♦ Damage to premises.
♦ Delays in productivity.
♦ Heavy fines.
♦ Adverse publicity.
5
“Looking Forward to a Safer Future” Fork Lift Truck Association Safety Conference 2003 SHD supplement
♦ Expensive litigation.
♦ Personal injury to staff
Health and Safety training reduces incidents involving injury and damage
and associated costs. The result is improvement in efficiency and
productivity. Suitable Health and Safety training is required under section
2 of the Health and Safety at Work Act and should be conducted on
recruitment, when individuals change jobs, when systems of work change
or when new equipment or technology is introduced.
Training staff in the use of fork lift trucks should be related to specific
vehicle types. A member of your staff who is fully trained in the use of a
counterbalance truck would not be able to drive a man-up turret truck
without the necessary training. Training should also relate to the
environment in which the trucks will be used. Special attention should be
paid to fork trucks working near the loading docks, as this is a particularly
dangerous area. Operators working in a VNA environment should be
trained in that environment.
Once staff has passed a competency test, they can be certificated and
should then be authorised to drive that particular piece of MHE in that
environment. This authorisation should be displayed on the safety notice
board.
A regime should be set up where users check trucks before they use them
– completing a vehicle check sheet. The vehicles themselves should be
properly maintained, and records kept of each service or remedial work
carried out.
Racking
The racking used within the warehouse also needs to be examined
regularly – at least once a year – to ensure that the structure is sound.
Racking can support huge weights, but if it is damaged, for instance by a
fork truck, and the structure is weakened then a collapse could be
catastrophic. Reports from inspections should be kept. Any accidents
should be reported and investigated internally straight away.
Racking is designed to cope with specific loads – heavy duty racking being
required for heavy loads. It is important that fork truck operators know
what the load-carrying capabilities of the racking are, and load
accordingly. Maximum load indicators should be prominently displayed.
Pallet scales are useful to establish weights of pallets that are to be stored.
Other Regulations
There are many other regulations covering health and safety provisions by
employers. The main items are summarised here.
First Aiders
Dependant on size, your company should ensure that a number of staff
are qualified as First Aiders, i.e. to give immediate simple healthcare and
who should then be re-assessed every three years to keep abreast of
developments in first aid care. The names and work locations of these
individuals should be displayed on notice boards.
COSHH Regulations
COSHH (Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations UK, 1999
stipulate that a register should be kept of all hazardous materials used or
kept on site. This could include substances such as bleach, cleaning
materials, even Tippex. Safety data sheets for the products should be
sourced from the manufacturers and a note made of the harmful
properties of the substances, and what action should be taken in the event
of a spillage or inhalation. It may be necessary to provide eye wash
stations at strategic locations around the premises.
Manual Handling
The Manual Handling Operations Regulations UK, 1992 – require
employers to avoid manual handling activities that could injure employees.
Where this is not possible, an assessment of these activities should be
carried out with a view to reducing the risk of injury.
This statement should list the person with overall responsibility for health
and Safety – normally the managing director. It will then list those
responsible as deputies, the appointed health and safety representative
Other employees must have training needs identified, and training plans
drawn up to tackle skills shortfalls. This can be for employees remaining in
a particular activity who are not performing properly, or for any staff
moved to different activities.
Activity 7
What are the principles of risk assessment?
Useful books
Key Text Book: Hand Book of Logistics and Distribution Management,
Alan Rushton, John Oxley, and Phil Croucher, 2006, Kogan Page
Others
www.ciltuk.org.uk
www.linde-mh.co.uk
www.imhx2004.co.uk/page.cfm/action=Exhib/ExhibID=00145
www.tclmagazine.com/
www.packagingmagazine.co.uk
www.hse.gov.uk/
www.elogistics101.com/Mag-Articles/Magazine-Articles.htm