Theory for Eclipsa, Moon, and the

Realm of Magic
Forum > General Discussion board > Theory for Eclipsa, Moon, and the Realm of Magic


1 Kudos 
Theory for Eclipsa, Moon, and the Realm of Magic
TheGiftedMongol

This is a sort of theory I have connecting The Realm of Magic to Eclipsa and Moon.

The Realm of Magic is the source of magic in the universe and the wand is an extention of that. When Toffee
corrupted the wand, he in turn corrupted the realm of magic, hence the black goo. The black goo can also be
seen in "Divide" when Star wades through it to find her mother. This black goo has to have come from an
outside source (such as Toffee or Moon when she was blasted) and this is where Eclipsa plays a larger role.

Eclipsa said that she never learned to use magic without a wand, despite Baby implying that Eclipsa was
greatly talented in her magic. Despite this, Moon and Star can turn into their Mewberty forms. The difference
between Eclipsa and Moon is that Moon "learned" to become an extention of that Realm through their use of
magic while Eclipsa couldn't because there is no universe of Dark Magic. They both have traveled into the
Realm of Magic and can manipulate Light Magic (I’ll use the term “Light Magic” to refer to the type of Magic
naturally found in the Realm) because they have control of it. The Realm of Magic is full of Light Magic and
not intended to be corrupted. Eclipsa, however, meddled heavily in the Dark Arts meaning that she does not
have the same connection to Light Magic and The Realm of Magic as Moon and Star. That could explain why
she never learned to use magic without a wand: she can't because Dark Magic does not naturally exist the
Realm of Magic.

The way I think she can create the Dark Magic in the first place is that she can modify and morph the magic to
her will using spells she created through her wand. By extending this logic, this can be used to further to
explain the deep purple marks on Moon’s and Eclipsa’s arms. Eclipsa’s interference in Dark Magic would
have likely caused this to happen to her as continuous study of it can cause corruption similar to that of the
Realm of Magic. Similarly, when Moon made a deal with Eclipsa and used the Death Spell, she meddled with
the Dark Arts (of an especially high degree to add) as well, meaning she was also corrupted by Eclipsa’s
magic. They both channel a darker side of the Realm of Magic – a realm not present but rather fabricated and
advanced by Eclipsa.
Now for something a little crazy… I have a bold prediction for Season 4. I believe that, whether intentional or
not, Eclipsa will be like Toffee and corrupt the Realm of Magic. Assuming that the Dark Magic Moon bathed
off (I guess) herself remains in the Realm, it can spread and infect it like a virus. Similar to Toffee, he started
generally small: he entered the broken wand of Ludo and slowly started to manipulate him while also infecting
the Light Magic. This could very well happen with Eclipsa, especially considering that she now owns the
wand.

This is probably crazy but I don’t think this is out the realm of possibility. What do y’all think of this?

Edited by JustTimoCraft 00:08, April 30, 2018

JustTimoCraft

I think it's a great theory and it really got me thinking. One of things I have the most
questions about is: "Can Eclipsa only use dark magic, or can she also use light magic?".
I'd say she could use both. Which means that, though her dark magic might not have a
dimension/realm of its own, her light magic certainly does, meaning that
Eclipsa should still be able to change to her Mewberty form (if she masters it) and 'dip
down'. The only two real explanations I could come up with why she can't are:

1) Glossaryck saw that Eclipsa was very powerful but was also tending to dark magic,
which is why he never taught her how to 'dip down'. Though this wouldn't make a lot of
sense as Star is taught to 'dip down' and afterwards Glossaryck has no real issue showing
Star Eclipsa's chapter, other than warning her it's dangerous and that it might 'taint' her.
All while Baby says Star is showing the same amount of power as Eclipsa.

2) 'Dipping down' wasn't invented/discovered 300 years ago. As new spells are created,
mastered and written down by every queen, that means that, at some point, possibly
between Eclipsa's reign and the present, some queen or Glossaryck himself might have
found out about 'dipping down'. 

Also, mastering the Mewberty form takes years of training, according to Moon. The
process was probably sped up for Star as she was exposed to the Realm of Magic, while
Moon might have never been there. The same story goes for this. Maybe mastering the
form was something noone had done 300 years ago and that's why Eclipsa wasn't taught
that.
 As for the theory that that little dark magic could recorrupt the entire realm, it's possible,
but I don't think so. We don't know how it happened, but the most information we have
about how the realm got cleaned of all dark magic was because of the millhorse Star
created, the 'First Born'. The realm got corrupted because the millhorse 'keeping it clean'
was killed thanks to the wispering spell. So if my thoughts are correct, as long as the
millhorse is alive, the realm can't be corrupted, making it impossible for someone to
corrupt it accidentally, as you would have to kill the millhorse. 

00:07, April 30, 2018

TheGiftedMongol

Well, wasn't the millhorse corrupted at one point? When Glossaryck examined the wand
in "My New Wand" the horse was obviously corrupted by the Dark Magic caused by
Toffee (it was all demonic and had green eyes). Maybe the horse is like some sort of
gatekeeper that watches what goes in and out. When it died, Toffee was able to go in but
only because the original millhorse had died. It was only a matter of time before the Dark
Magic spread and took over the wand and, eventually, the horse. Regardless, thanks for
reminding me about the horse, I totally forgot about that. 

Arguably, Eclipsa can "dip down" to some extent. When Moon was about to kill Meteora,
Eclipsa interfered by jumping in the way. Her eyes and cheeks were glowing a bright

pink/purple  (see the picture). This is similar to when Star

did it in "My New Wand" to stop Marco from finding out "her secret" (her thoughts on
Marco and likely her crush on him). Star used it in a moment of desperation and it was
seemingly out-of-nowhere. Maybe "dipping down" is a sort of reflex that can happen in
moments of high stress among high-magic wielders and can be honed in through magical
training. Eclipsa looks to be in an early stage of "dipping down" likely because she is
incredibly magical.
Edited by ImperfectXIII 21:44, May 12, 2018
o

AmansCraft

That millhorse from Season 2, was Vincenzo, who entered the new wand in the Season 1
finale. He was killed after Star destroyed Ludo’s handwand.

16:02, May 27, 2019

Anonymius

Er, no, I'm pretty sure he was still alive in star's wand until the final episode

16:15, May 27, 2019

AmansCraft

If he was alive, Firstborn would not exist right now.

22:03, May 31, 2019

Anonymius
reply to #6

AmansCraft wrote: If he was alive, Firstborn would not exist right now.
 If he was dead, then who was powering stars wand from the end of season 1 until the final
episode (and whose ghost we saw at the end)? The existence of the firstborn had nothing
to do with who was powering star's wand.

08:13, June 1, 2019

AmansCraft

Then who died in the Season 3 premiere? Yeah, no answer.

22:30, June 6, 2019

Anonymius

Yeah that didn't make much sense to me, considering that there was no millhorse in ludo's
wand and Eduardo was in star's not ludo's 

05:44, June 7, 2019

ShadowBeast
reply to #9
Anonymius wrote:
Yeah that didn't make much sense to me, considering that there was no millhorse in ludo's
wand and Eduardo was in star's not ludo's 

The wands were linked as they had half of the same crystal.. So the millhorse was in both
wands like how Glossaryck was able to be in two places at one time in "Swim Suit".

Who's Eduardo? The millhorse that powered the wands was named Vincenzo.
 11:51, June 8, 2019

Anonymius

If that's true and star killed the millhorse in both wands then why didn't her wand die?
Also again, if the millhorse was dead then who was powering star's wand from that point
on to the end of the series?

12:36, June 8, 2019

ShadowBeast
reply to #11
Anonymius wrote:
If that's true and star killed the millhorse in both wands then why didn't her wand die?
Also again, if the millhorse was dead then who was powering star's wand from that point
on to the end of the series?

Her wand didn't work after killing the millhorse as proven when Moon tried using
Eclipsa's spell on Toffee again and nothing happened(it didn't even transform when Moon
was holduing it).

As for who was powering the wand after Star revived the magic, the Firstborn was
obviously powering it when Star defeated Toffee, after that, who knows. The writing in
this show hasn't been consistent and really hurt the show in the end. 

13:05, June 8, 2019

Anonymius
reply to #12
 ShadowBeast wrote:
Anonymius wrote:
If that's true and star killed the millhorse in both wands then why didn't her wand die?
Also again, if the millhorse was dead then who was powering star's wand from that point
on to the end of the series?

Her wand didn't work after killing the millhorse as proven when Moon tried using
Eclipsa's spell on Toffee again and nothing happened(it didn't even transform when Moon
was holduing it).

As for who was powering the wand after Star revived the magic, the Firstborn was
obviously powering it when Star defeated Toffee, after that, who knows. The writing in
this show hasn't been consistent and really hurt the show in the end. 

It wasn't the firstborn.  That's not how Star's wand works, and if it had really become
inactive because there was no more millhorse then the star would have gone black like it
did in storm the castle.  What should be obvious is that star's wand retained the same
millhorse it had when it entered back in the season 1 finale until it was killed in the final
episode.  perhaps the real inconsistency is that there was a ghostly millhorse coming out of
ludo's wand.

08:41, June 9, 2019

ShadowBeast
reply to #13
Anonymius wrote:
ShadowBeast wrote:
Anonymius wrote:
If that's true and star killed the millhorse in both wands then why didn't her wand die?
Also again, if the millhorse was dead then who was powering star's wand from that point
on to the end of the series?

Her wand didn't work after killing the millhorse as proven when Moon tried using
Eclipsa's spell on Toffee again and nothing happened(it didn't even transform when Moon
was holduing it).
 As for who was powering the wand after Star revived the magic, the Firstborn was
obviously powering it when Star defeated Toffee, after that, who knows. The writing in
this show hasn't been consistent and really hurt the show in the end. 

It wasn't the firstborn.  That's not how Star's wand works, and if it had really become
inactive because there was no more millhorse then the star would have gone black like it
did in storm the castle.  What should be obvious is that star's wand retained the same
millhorse it had when it entered back in the season 1 finale until it was killed in the final
episode.  perhaps the real inconsistency is that there was a ghostly millhorse coming out
of ludo's wand.

Of course it was the Firstborn, there were no more millhorses until Star found the last bit
of magic and created her with it.

And the wand only turns black when the whispering spell is used on it. as proven in Storm
the Castle and Toffee when Star used the spell on her and ludo's wands and they turned
black.  And again, the millhorse that entered Star's wand in Storm the Castle was also
powering ludo's wand and so died in Toffee.

12:49, June 9, 2019

Anonymius

Yes there was, there was the millhorse left in star's wand, and according to you when Star
used the whispering spell on ludo's wand it also killed the millhorse in star's wand, so why
wouldn't it turn black?  Also I didn't think that star's millhorse was also powering ludo's
wand but because they were connected it corrupted star's millhorse.

22:27, June 12, 2019

ShadowBeast
reply to #15
 Anonymius wrote:
Yes there was, there  was the millhorse left in star's wand, and according to you when Star
used the whispering spell on ludo's wand it also killed the millhorse in star's wand, so why
wouldn't it turn black?  Also I didn't think that star's millhorse was also powering ludo's
wand but because they were connected it corrupted star's millhorse.

Because Star used the whispering spell on the crystal half in Ludo's wand and not on the
crystal half in her wand.  That's why it didn't turn black. Vincenzo, the millhorse that was
powering Star's wand was also powering Ludo's as well since the wands are linked and
were effected by the other.  If there was a millhorse still alive in Star's wand, then Moon
would've been able to use magic against Toffee after he was revived.

02:34, June 13, 2019

Anonymius
reply to #16
ShadowBeast wrote:
Anonymius wrote:
Yes there was, there  was the millhorse left in star's wand, and according to you when Star
used the whispering spell on ludo's wand it also killed the millhorse in star's wand, so why
wouldn't it turn black?  Also I didn't think that star's millhorse was also powering ludo's
wand but because they were connected it corrupted star's millhorse.

Because Star used the whispering spell on the crystal half in Ludo's wand and not on the
crystal half in her wand.  That's why it didn't turn black.  Vincenzo, the millhorse that was
powering Star's wand was also powering Ludo's as well since the wands are linked and
were effected by the other.  If there was a millhorse still alive in Star's wand, then Moon
would've been able to use magic against Toffee after he was revived.

There are other reasons for why the spell didn't work, like because magic was basically
dead, or the nature of the spell she was using.  also I don't believe that just because the
wands were linked it meant vincenzo was powering both, and from what we saw of the
episode Toffee it showed ludo's 'wand' (which to be fair, was really just half of the crystal
embedded in toffee's skeletal arm) doesn't even need a millhorse to functin.

20:56, June 16, 2019

o

ShadowBeast
reply to #17
Anonymius wrote:
ShadowBeast wrote:
Anonymius wrote:
Yes there was, there  was the millhorse left in star's wand, and according to you when Star
used the whispering spell on ludo's wand it also killed the millhorse in star's wand, so why
wouldn't it turn black?  Also I didn't think that star's millhorse was also powering ludo's
wand but because they were connected it corrupted star's millhorse.

Because Star used the whispering spell on the crystal half in Ludo's wand and not on the
crystal half in her wand.  That's why it didn't turn black.  Vincenzo, the millhorse that was
powering Star's wand was also powering Ludo's as well since the wands are linked and
were effected by the other.  If there was a millhorse still alive in Star's wand, then Moon
would've been able to use magic against Toffee after he was revived.

There are other reasons for why the spell didn't work, like because magic was basically
dead, or the nature of the spell she was using.  also I don't believe that just because the
wands were linked it meant vincenzo was powering both, and from what we saw of the
episode Toffee it showed ludo's 'wand' (which to be fair, was really just half of the crystal
embedded in toffee's skeletal arm) doesn't even need a millhorse to functin.

If the magic is basically dead, then so are all of the millhorses before the FirstBorn.
Vincenzo was affected by Ludo's wand so he was in fact linked to Ludo's wand as well.
And thus was powering it too.  We saw a millhorse literally come out of Ludo's wand in
Toffee. So any claims of Ludo's wand not be powered by a milhorse is complete nonsense.

21:44, June 16, 2019

Anonymius
reply to #18
ShadowBeast wrote:
Anonymius wrote:
ShadowBeast wrote:
 Anonymius wrote:
Yes there was, there  was the millhorse left in star's wand, and according to you when Star
used the whispering spell on ludo's wand it also killed the millhorse in star's wand, so why
wouldn't it turn black?  Also I didn't think that star's millhorse was also powering ludo's
wand but because they were connected it corrupted star's millhorse.

Because Star used the whispering spell on the crystal half in Ludo's wand and not on the
crystal half in her wand.  That's why it didn't turn black.  Vincenzo, the millhorse that was
powering Star's wand was also powering Ludo's as well since the wands are linked and
were effected by the other.  If there was a millhorse still alive in Star's wand, then Moon
would've been able to use magic against Toffee after he was revived.

There are other reasons for why the spell didn't work, like because magic was basically
dead, or the nature of the spell she was using.  also I don't believe that just because the
wands were linked it meant vincenzo was powering both, and from what we saw of the
episode Toffee it showed ludo's 'wand' (which to be fair, was really just half of the crystal
embedded in toffee's skeletal arm) doesn't even need a millhorse to functin.

If the magic is basically dead, then so are all of the millhorses before the FirstBorn.
Vincenzo was affected by Ludo's wand so he was in fact linked to Ludo's wand as well.
And thus was powering it too.  We saw a millhorse literally come out of Ludo's wand in
Toffee. So any claims of Ludo's wand not be powered by a milhorse is complete nonsense.

You mean despite the fact that we saw toffee/Ludo levitating AND restoring his finger
after Star used the whispering spell?  Also what proof is there that when all magic dies
(even though there was still that one drop of magic left) that instantly kills the millhorses
as well?  The millhorses in the finale only died when the corrupted magic reached them.

21:16, June 18, 2019

ShadowBeast
reply to #19
Anonymius wrote:
ShadowBeast wrote:
Anonymius wrote:
ShadowBeast wrote:
 Anonymius wrote:
Yes there was, there  was the millhorse left in star's wand, and according to you when Star
used the whispering spell on ludo's wand it also killed the millhorse in star's wand, so why
wouldn't it turn black?  Also I didn't think that star's millhorse was also powering ludo's
wand but because they were connected it corrupted star's millhorse.

Because Star used the whispering spell on the crystal half in Ludo's wand and not on the
crystal half in her wand.  That's why it didn't turn black.  Vincenzo, the millhorse that was
powering Star's wand was also powering Ludo's as well since the wands are linked and
were effected by the other.  If there was a millhorse still alive in Star's wand, then Moon
would've been able to use magic against Toffee after he was revived.

There are other reasons for why the spell didn't work, like because magic was basically
dead, or the nature of the spell she was using.  also I don't believe that just because the
wands were linked it meant vincenzo was powering both, and from what we saw of the
episode Toffee it showed ludo's 'wand' (which to be fair, was really just half of the crystal
embedded in toffee's skeletal arm) doesn't even need a millhorse to functin.

If the magic is basically dead, then so are all of the millhorses before the FirstBorn.
Vincenzo was affected by Ludo's wand so he was in fact linked to Ludo's wand as well.
And thus was powering it too.  We saw a millhorse literally come out of Ludo's wand in
Toffee. So any claims of Ludo's wand not be powered by a milhorse is complete nonsense.

You mean despite the fact that we saw toffee/Ludo levitating AND restoring  his finger
after Star used the whispering spell?  Also what proof is there that when all magic dies
(even though there was still that one drop of magic left) that instantly kills the millhorses
as well?  The millhorses in the finale only died when the corrupted magic reached them.

But Ludo/Toffee wasn't using the wand to levitate and there was still bits of magic
floating around before Toffee left. Toffee didn't need magic to restore himself with his
finger as that was just his regenerating taking effect as well as Toffee leaving the wand's
crystal. The millhorses live in the magic dimension, so destroying the magic dimension
kills everything that lives in that dimension.

21:56, June 18, 2019

Anonymius
 I'm pretty sure Toffee/Ludo was using the power of the wand in order to levitate.  And it
wasn't just his regenerating taking effect when given back the finger (as we see a small
burst of green magic when it reattached).  And yes, most millhorses do live in the magic
dimension and be destroyed along with it, but I can't see why a millhorse who lived
outside the magic dimension (ie. vincenzo) couldn't still live even with the magic in the
magic dimension gone (although given that millhorses feed on magic it probably wouldn't
live that long.  UNLESS someone found alternative fuel for the horse.  ahem, sorry, just
thinking about the millhorse that janna took).

Edited by Anonymius 21:32, June 19, 2019

ShadowBeast
reply to #21
Anonymius wrote:
I'm pretty sure Toffee/Ludo was using the power of the wand in order to levitate.  And it
wasn't just his regenerating taking effect when given back the finger (as we see a small
burst of green magic when it reattached).  And yes, most millhorses do live in the magic
dimension and be destroyed along with it, but I can't see why a millhorse who lived
outside the magic dimension (ie. vincenzo) couldn't still live even with the magic in the
magic dimension gone (although given that millhorses feed on magic it probably wouldn't
live that long.  UNLESS someone found alternative fuel for the horse.  ahem, sorry, just
thinking about the millhorse that janna took).

He didn't. Otherwise his hand would've been glowing. 

The green bit of magic was most likely from the effects of Eclipsa's spell being undone. It
could've also been the fragments of magic being used up as there was a lot of magic
fragments around until Toffee left.

And how do you know that vincenzo didn't come from the magic realm?  Glossaryck said
that once the magic realm everyone who were in the realms that they didn't come from,
would return to their realms, and since millhorses come from the magic realm, any that
weren't in the magic realm would be sent back to their realm(and to their doom), but
there's also the matter of millhorses being magical creatures and thus would die anyway
since all magical creatures were destroyed along with the realm.
 02:49, June 20, 2019

Anonymius
reply to #22
ShadowBeast wrote:
Anonymius wrote:
I'm pretty sure Toffee/Ludo was using the power of the wand in order to levitate.  And it
wasn't just his regenerating taking effect when given back the finger (as we see a small
burst of green magic when it reattached).  And yes, most millhorses do live in the magic
dimension and be destroyed along with it, but I can't see why a millhorse who lived
outside the magic dimension (ie. vincenzo) couldn't still live even with the magic in the
magic dimension gone (although given that millhorses feed on magic it probably wouldn't
live that long.  UNLESS someone found alternative fuel for the horse.  ahem, sorry, just
thinking about the millhorse that janna took).

He didn't. Otherwise his hand would've been glowing. 

The green bit of magic was most likely from the effects of Eclipsa's spell being undone. It
could've also been the fragments of magic being used up as there was a lot of magic
fragments around until Toffee left.

And how do you know that vincenzo didn't come from the magic realm?  Glossaryck said
that once the magic realm everyone who were in the realms that they didn't come from,
would return to their realms, and since millhorses come from the magic realm, any that
weren't in the magic realm would be sent back to their realm(and to their doom), but
there's also the matter of millhorses being magical creatures and thus would die anyway
since all magical creatures were destroyed along with the realm.

Well how else do you explain Toffee being capable of magic if not using the power of the
wand?  Also I never said that Vincenzo didn't come from the magic dimension, I said he
wasn't in the magic dimension when Toffee corrupted it, and even when he corrupted it
that didn't send characters back to where they belonged.

22:23, June 20, 2019

o
ShadowBeast
reply to #23
Anonymius wrote:
ShadowBeast wrote:
Anonymius wrote:
I'm pretty sure Toffee/Ludo was using the power of the wand in order to levitate.  And it
wasn't just his regenerating taking effect when given back the finger (as we see a small
burst of green magic when it reattached).  And yes, most millhorses do live in the magic
dimension and be destroyed along with it, but I can't see why a millhorse who lived
outside the magic dimension (ie. vincenzo) couldn't still live even with the magic in the
magic dimension gone (although given that millhorses feed on magic it probably wouldn't
live that long.  UNLESS someone found alternative fuel for the horse.  ahem, sorry, just
thinking about the millhorse that janna took).

He didn't. Otherwise his hand would've been glowing. 

The green bit of magic was most likely from the effects of Eclipsa's spell being undone. It
could've also been the fragments of magic being used up as there was a lot of magic
fragments around until Toffee left.

And how do you know that vincenzo didn't come from the magic realm?  Glossaryck said
that once the magic realm everyone who were in the realms that they didn't come from,
would return to their realms, and since millhorses come from the magic realm, any that
weren't in the magic realm would be sent back to their realm(and to their doom), but
there's also the matter of millhorses being magical creatures and thus would die anyway
since all magical creatures were destroyed along with the realm.

Well how else do you explain Toffee being capable of magic if not using the power of the
wand?  Also I never said that Vincenzo didn't come from the magic dimension, I said he
wasn't in the magic dimension when Toffee corrupted it, and even when he corrupted it
that didn't send characters back to where they belonged.

Toffee used the magic of the wand's crystal when he possessed Ludo, he did not use magic
when regenerating himself as he had destroyed most of the magic.

Then why are you making claims about millhorses like vincenzo living outside the magic
dimension?  Glossaryck said that if the magic realm is destroyed, everyone who is away
from their dimensions would be returned to it, I don't see why millhorses would be an
exception.  And we don't even know how exactly does the millhorses in the wands work.
 The wand's crystal could be directly connected to the magic realm, which would explain
how Toffee was destroying it from within Ludo's wand.

Toffee didn't destroy all the magic though. He destroyede most of it and Star revitalized it.

23:33, June 20, 2019

Anonymius

The wand's crystal focuses magic, it's not a source of magical power itself.  Also Toffee's
green 'magic' was fueled by the corrupted green magic from the magic dimension (as we
saw when Star used her corrupted wand to blow a hole in the sanctuary in puddle defender
and the corrupted magic glowed as she used her spell).

Because Vincenzo didn't live in the magic dimension, he lived inside Star's wand, and as I
said before characters were not sent back to their dimension when Toffee corrupted the
magic dimension, so why would all millhorses? (or maybe you're also talking about that
millhorse I mentioned under Janna's hat and when Star destroyed magic it would've sent
that millhorse back to the magic dimension).  

20:29, June 24, 2019

ShadowBeast
reply to #25
Anonymius wrote:
The wand's crystal focuses magic, it's not a source of magical power itself.  Also Toffee's
green 'magic' was fueled by the corrupted green magic from the magic dimension (as we
saw when Star used her corrupted wand to blow a hole in the sanctuary in puddle
defender and the corrupted magic glowed as she used her spell).

Because Vincenzo didn't live in the magic dimension, he lived inside Star's wand, and as I
said before characters were not sent  back to their dimension when Toffee corrupted the
magic dimension, so why would all millhorses? (or maybe you're also talking about that
 millhorse I mentioned under Janna's hat and when Star destroyed magic it would've sent
that millhorse back to the magic dimension).  

Where exactly was it said that the wand's crystal only focuses the magic?  The green glow
was from Toffee leaving the wand. 

Vincenzo technically lived in both Star and Ludo's wands since the wands are linked. But
Vincenzo died when Star used the whispering spell on Ludo's wand. But then he could be
living in the magic realm at the same time like how Glossaryck was able to be at two
places at the same time. 

Again! No one was sent back to their dimensions when Toffee corrupted the magic
BECAUSE there were still fragments of good magic still left over. Not all of the magic
was destroyed yet. There was still good magic in the magic realm. What part of that do
you not understand?

Kelly and Jorby were sent back in Cleaved, Marco and Janna were sent back to Earth as
well. So why wouldn't the Millhorses not be sent back?

23:20, June 24, 2019

AmansCraft

Holy shit guys. Gone for five days and you wrote a full discussion about millhorses.

11:46, June 30, 2019

Quote More 

Gemnist 2.0
reply to #27

AmansCraft wrote: Holy shit guys. Gone for five days and you wrote a full discussion
about millhorses.
Yeah man, this wiki's discussion sections have gone to absolute hell since the show
ended...