Grade 12 STEM A

Debate Grouping

Round 1

This house allows priests to become biological parents.

Opening Government Opening Opposition
Prime Minister: Leader of the Opposition:
Destacamento Pogoy
 Parameters  Challenge: priest is an assigned
 Priests do not come from the member of the church who orderly
Catholic religion follows whatever the religion is
 Can be identified for pastors  Rebuttal
 Definition  It is not limited to Catholics
 Priests are clergy men who are (parameter)
messengers of God  She sounded as though she
 Biological parents- parents whose challenged the parameter
children are from their own genes  1:20
 Arguments  She did not accept the point from
 Priests have other names based on the PM
other religions
 Priests of these religion have wives
and children
 She has talked to a certain about
this matter (in relation to a previous
argument)
 1:53
 Did not receive the point from the
LO
Deputy Prime Minister: Deputy Leader of the Opposition:
Ribay Biloy
 Not all priests do not have families  As we are baptized as Catholics, the
 With some religious non-catholics, covenant is given in the Bible, that
there are priests who have children the priest should not be allowed.
 Rebuttal The sanctity of the responsibility
 Not all priests do not have families;  The priest should be aware
some commit into love and form  Rebuttal
their families  The man only serves one master; if
 1:21 you serve your family and the
church, who will be greater served?
 2:05
 Did not receive a point from the PM
Closing Government Closing Opposition
Member: Member:
Deloso Fornolles
 Priests have the right to be a father  Arguments
and have a son.  Man has already offered himself to
 If it be allowed by the Vatican, then God, and he is complete by then
why not?  A priest is loyal and faithful to the
 For them to focus on serving the one he serves
people of God (words from one  He should be a model and a good
priest) example to everyone
 Priests are humans too  If the man really wants to give his
 Love has a strong feeling of life wholeheartedly, then it is really
 affection, and he cannot stop it,
then he should be given a chance to
build his family. He should be
given the chance to be a father to
his family, to the community, and
to be a member of the Church.
 1:39
 Did not accept points
Whip:
Zoilo
 Strong approach
 Summary
 The advice coming from priests will
make children better, or that the
advice will make the world better
(given by the DPM)
 The priest from Tubigon was
mentioned
 1:12
okay for them not to have a family
because they have God.
 A true priest only wants God.
 If the government allows this to
happen, what would happen to the
child who wants the attention and
love of a father?
 Rebuttal
 Quick but kind of unclear
 1:50
Whip:
Aladad
 The voice is not that clear and
audible. There are times when the
words sound as though being
swallowed.
 Rebuttals
 Not strong; they have not
weakened the arguments of the
government. All that he did was to
mention them
 Summary
 I did not detect the summary
 1:38