Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Indian Standard
GEOLOGICAL EXPLORATION BY GEOPHYSICAL
METHOD (SEISMIC REFRACTION) —
CODE OF PRACTICE
ICS 93.020
(3 BIS 2006
FOREWORD
This Indian Standard was adopted by the Bureau of Indian Standards, after the draft finalized by the Geological
Investigations and Subsurface Exploration Sectional Committee had been approved by the Water Resources Division
Council.
Seismic refraction technique is mainly concerned about evaluation of the project site and its stability to man-made
structures. The technique plays a crucial role in the design of engineering projects. Seismic refraction surveys,
being rapid and economical, are conducted to help select a site amongst a number of alternatives at the
reconnaissance stage. It also forms a part of detailed site investigations at the chosen location. It plays a major
role in locating fault and shear zones and in determining engineering parameters (for example, Poisson’s ratio,
dynamic Young’s and shear moduli of elasticity).
It is a reliable tool for determining depth to various subsurface layers, particularly in conjunction with a few
exploratory drillings. The accuracy of depth determination has been improved substantially with the availability
of multichannel digital enhancement seismographs and new interpretation techniques, using digital computers.
This standard deals with various aspects of seismic reflection technique and its applications to shallow subsurface
exploration of engineering sites. The primary purpose of the standard is to provide working knowledge of the
method, with relevant references, and with a basis to weigh the applicability of the method to various engineering
geological problems. In particular, it seeks to provide an understanding of the proper planning of surveys, so as to
obtain adequate and relevant coverage and highlight the most important area of interpretation of seismic data.
It has been assumed in the formulation of this standard that the execution of its provisions is entrusted to
appropriately qualified and experienced people, for whose guidance it has been prepared.
IS 15681:2006
Indian Standard +
2.17 Seismic Waves — Seismic waves are elastic 2.27 Velocity — A vector quantity which indicates time
waves. Energy may be transmitted through the body of rate of change of displacement, usually refers to the
an elastic solid by P-waves or S-waves or along propagation rate of a seismic wave without implying
boundaries between media of different elastic properties any direction.
by surface waves.
3 MEASURED PARAMETER AND
2.18 Seismograph — A recording system for seismic REPRESENTATIVE VALUES
waves.
The seismic refraction method gives the velocity of
2.19 Shear Modulus — The stress-strain ratio for compressional (P-) waves in subsurface materials.
simple shear. Although the P-wave velocity can be a good indicator
2.20 Shear Wave (S-wave) — A body wave in which of the type of soil or rock, it is not a unique indicator.
the particle motion is perpendicular to the direction of Table 1 shows that each type of sediment or rock has a
propagation. Also called S-wave. wide range of seismic velocities, and many of these
ranges overlap. While the seismic refraction technique
2.21 Shot/Hammer — To make an impact on ground, measures the seismic velocity of seismic waves in earth
or tire an explosive to generate a seismic wave. materials, it is the interpreter who, based on knowledge
2.22 Snell’s Law — When a wave crosses a boundary of the local conditions or other data, or both, must
between two isotropic medi%the wave changes direction interpret the seismic refraction data and arrive at a
so that the sine of the angle of incidence (angle between geologically reasonable solution.
the wavefront and a tangent to the boundary) divided by P-wave velocities are generally greater for:
the velocity in the first medium equals the sine of the
angle of reii-action divided by the velocity in the second a) Denser rocks than lighter rocks;
medium. Snell’s law applies to both P-and S-waves. b) Older rocks than younger rocks;
2.23 Surface Wave — Energy which travels along or c) Igneous rocks than sedimentary rocks;
near the surface. d) Solid rocks than rocks with cracks or tlactures;
e) Unweathered rocks than weathered rocks;
2.24 Time-Distance Curve — A plot of the arrival
lime against the shotpoint-to-geophone distance. Also f) Consolidated sediments than unconsolidated
called a r-x curve,used in interpreting refracted waves. sediments;
The slopes of segments of the curve give the reciprocals g) Water-saturated unconsolidated sediments
of the apparent velocities for various refractor beds. than dry unconsolidated sediments; and
h) Wet soils than dry soils.
2.25 Time Break — The mark on a seismic record
which indicates the shot instant or the time at which 4 PURPOSE OF SEISMIC REFRACITON SURVEY
the seismic wave was generated.
The seismic refraction survey has application in a
2.26 Travel Time — The time between time break and variety of geological exploration problems, where
the recording of a seismic event. information on the depth and strength of subsurface
2
IS 15681:2006
materials is required. These surveys provide subsurface vibrations into an electrical signal. This electrical signal
information over large areas at relatively low cost, is recorded and processed by the seismograph. The
locate critical areas for more detailed testing by drilling travel time of the seismic wave (from the source to
and can readily eliminate less favorable alternative geophone) is determined from the seismic wave form.
sites. Seismic surveys can also reduce the number of 5.2 The seismic energy source generates elastic waves
boreholes required to test a particular site and improve which travel through the soil or rock or both. When the
correlation between boreholes. The following are the seismic wave reaches the interface between two
areas, where this method can be used to obtain materials of different seismic velocities, the waves are
information: refracted according to Snell’s law. When the velocity
a) Problems of engineering geology Vzis greater than Vi the ray will bend away from the
normal to the inter~ace on refraction, as shown in
1) Depth to bedrock (thickness of overburden Fig. 1A. In such a case for a particular angle of
andfor weathered rock). incidence, known u the critical angle iC,the angle of
2) Strength of the bedrock (looking for refraction will be 90°. This gives rise to a critically
weak zones like fractures, shears and reffacted ray that will then be traveling within the lower
weathering and for faults etc) for foundation niedium at the velocity Vz,at grazing incidence along
studies. the interface. It should be,noted that critical refraction
3) Rippability/excavability studies for can only occur, where there is an increase in velocity
quarries and dynamic elasticity at deeper refracting layer.
determination. 5.3 In Fig. lB, the position of a wavefront in the lower
4) Location of sink holes and other man medium is shown, together with the associated
made objects. wave front being directed back into the overlying layer.
5) Correlation of geological units between The latter is known as a head wave. The ray paths are
boreholes, also shown. The head wave is attached to the faster
6) Monitoring of land slides. traveling wavefiont in the deeper, higher velocity
medium of the refractor. The position of the wavefiont
b) Problems in alluvial prospecting
of the head wave may also be constructed as the envelope
1) Indirect search for alluvial deposits. of the secondary wavelets, by the application of
2) Location of ancient stream channels. Huygen’s principle. Since the angle of critically reflacted
3) Location of thick gravel beds. ray in the lower medium is 90° for rays, which are either
entering or leaving the Vzrefracting layer, the head wave
c) Problems in hydrogeology
also re-enters the overlying VIlayer at the critical angle.
1) Thickness of aquifer overlying Since the critically refracted waves are returned to the
impermeable bedrock. surface in this manner, they are recorded.
2) Detection of water table, mainly in 5.4 A number of elastic waves are produced by a
alluvial aquifers. seismic energy source. As the compressional (P) wave
3) Location of leakage zones. has the highest seismic velocity, it is the first wave to
d) Complimenta~ method as a constraint on the arrive at each geophone.
ambiguities inherent in other geophysical The P-wave velocity VPis dependent upon the bulk
methods. modulus and the density and is given by
5 METHODOLOGY ..(1)
5.1 Measurement of subsurface conditions by the where
seismic refraction method requires a seismic energy
source, trigger cable, geophones, geophone cable, and VP= compressional wave velocity,
a seismograph. K = bulk modulus,
p = shear modulus, and
The geophones and the seismic source must be placed
in firm contact with the soil or rock. The geophones r = density.
are usually located in a line, sometimes referred to as a The energy from the seismic source at each geophone
geophone spread. The seismic source maybe a sledge is recorded by the seismograph. From the positions of
hammer, a mechanical device that strikes the ground, the pick-up points, the travel times are measured for
or some other type of impulse source. Explosives are the first arrivals of seismic waves. The travel times are
used for deeper refractors or special conditions that then plotted at appropriate geophone distances on graph
require greater energy. Geophones convert the ground called a travel-time curve, or a time-distance curve, or
3
IS 15681: 2006
Source ~eophone
il
I
z
r 4
B REFRACTED c v~7 VI
i?AY
/
often abbreviated as t-x curve (see Fig. 2). Alignments refraction at the second interface is shown in Fig. 3.
of points on a t-x curve indicates the velocities of The seismic velocities of the three layers are Vj>V2>V1.
seismic waves through different layers and provides The ray corresponding to the least travel time makes
the information needed to calculate layer thicknesses. -1
vI
an angle ‘i3 = sin ~ with the vertical in the uppermost
3
5.5 Two Layers Analysis
_, ~
Two layers with plane parallel boundaries are illustrated layer and angle ’23 = ‘in ~ with the vertical in the
3
in Fig. 2. The first few arrival times are those of direct second layer, iz~being the critical angle for the lower
arrivals through the first layer and the slope of the time interface.
distance curve through those points, At/Ax, is simply
the reciprocal of the velocity of that layer; that is I/V’l, The thickness of 22 can be computed by:
The energy that arrives at the detectors beyond the
crossover distance will plot along a line with slope of
l/V2,The one through these refracted arrivals will pass
through a projection on time axis to intersect it at a
time called the intercept time ‘ti’.
‘2=4’i2-2z’~lf
‘-(3)
The depth to the lower interface is sum of Zzand 21
Thickness of the layer at shotpoint from the intercept where 21 is computed by the two-media formula
time analysis is given by: (Equation 2) using the slopes of the first two segments
of the time-distance curve and the intercept of the
second segment.
.(2)
5.7 Multilayer Analysis
True depth to the second layer is determined simply by If a structure has n horizontal layers with the thickness
adding half the shot depth to the value of 21computed z,, Z2, Z3, . . .... Zn and wave velocities V,, Vz, Vq,.....
by equation (2). Vnresting on deeper material in which the wave velocity
is Vn+la travel time with n+ 1 straight line segments is
5.6 Three Layers Analysis
expec~ed. The intercept time determined from wave
The geometry of ray path in the case of critical reaching the deepest reflactor is given by:
4
IS 15681:2006
-------- ---
811,1
;, ,1,,
/
-.&-
X2 X4 X6 X8 Xlo X12
SOURCE- RECEIVER DISTANCE (X)
V2
FIG. 2 TIME-DISTANCE
CURVEANDIUY PATHSFORA Two LAYERCASE
ti2
tit
5
9
IS 15681:2006
t
“ Zk From the forward direction:
TO= 2~Fcos ik[.+l) ...(4)
k-l k
. ..(6)
and the thickness of the deepest layer by
=+-~~cOsik(n+l)
And, from the reverse direction
Zn
[ 1cost.+,)
.
...(5) k’2”= ~
sin (12- e) . ..(7)
tt m
tj
FIG. 4 TIME-DISTANCE
CURVEANDGEOMETRYOFRAY PATHFORCRITICAL
REFRACTION
FORTwo LAYERDIPPINGCASE
6
1S 15681:2006
7
IS 15681:2006
a) Depth of investigation : uptol Om too close to a geophone station will delay waves arriving
Geophone interval : 5m at the geophone for all subsequent recording, which will
Number of channels : 12 not allow separation of this delay in arrival time from
the increase in arrival time coming from deeper layers.
Spread Length Shots
7.4 When explosives are used as sources, charge
O-55 m –50 m, 2.5 m, 27.5 m,
weights adequate to produce sharp and well defined
52.5 m, 77.5 m, 102.5 m
first arrivals on the seismic records are needed. Charge
50-105 m 2.5 m, 27.5 m, 52.5 m,
weight is dependent on:
77.5 m, 102.5 m, 127.5 m,
152.5 m ‘ a) geology,
100-155.5 m 52.5 m, 77.5 m, 102.5 m, b) length of the seismic profile,
127.5 m, 152.5 m, 177.5 m, c) shot depth, and
202.5 m
d) amount ofbackground noise at the site of work.
150-205 m 102.5 m, 127.5 m, 152.5 m,
177.5 m, 202.5 m, 255 m From field experience at various sites in India, the
following charges are found to be sticient for providing
b) Depth of investigation up to : 20m
clear first arrivals and are recommended for obtaining
Geophone interval : 5m
good records. Generally, when top layer is not very loose,
Number of channels : 12
half a stick (130 glstick) of gelatine for central shot (that
Spread Length Shots is, shot in the middle of the profile) and one stick for the
shotpoints at the end of spreads is adequate. For 50 m
O-55m –100 m, 2.5 m, 27.5 m,
and 100 m offset shots, two and four sticks respectively
52.5 m, 77.5 m, 102.5 m,
are enough to produce clear first arrivals. Shot hole
127.5 m, 152.5 m
depths may vtuy from 1m to 3 m depending on the nature
50-105 m –50 m, 2.5 m, 27.5 m,
of top layer and difficulty of drilling the holes, the holes
52.5 m, 77.5 m 102.5 m,
being deeper in case of loose top surface layer. Coupling
127.5 m, 152.5 m, 177.5 m,
of explosive energy with the ground should be improved
202.5 m
by burying charges deeper and saturating the shot hole
100-155m 2.5 m, 27.5 m, 52.5 m,
with water, This will help in transmitting most of the
77.5 m, 102.5 m, 127.5 m,
seismic energy into the ground.
152.5 m, 177.5 m, 202.5 m,
227.5 m, 252.5 m 7.4.1 Special blasting caps (instantaneous blasting or
zero delay type) should be used for seismic survey. The
c) Depth of investigation up to : 10m
geophones should be held vertically and firmly coupled
Geophone interval : 5m
to the ground, to avoid any delay in the recording of
Number of channels : 24
seismic wave arrivals.
Spread Length Shots
7.4.2 It is desirable to maintain a constant shot depth
O-l15m –100 m, 2.5 m, 27.5 m, for the survey at a particular site. If it is not feasible to
57.5 m, 87.5 m, 112.5 m, maintain the same depth, a shot depth correction should
215 m be added to all arrival times to effectively yield a travel
time, which would have been recorded had the shot
d) Depth of investigation up to : 20m
been at the surface of the ground,
Geophone interval : 10m
Number of channels : 24 7.5 Seismic cables are manufactured with fixed
spacing, that is, the take-out or polarized connector for
Spread Length Shots
each detector is moulded into the cable and the spacing
0-230 m –200m,5m,55m, l15m, between these take-outs is fixed. It is desirable to have
175 m, 225 m, 430 m at least two cables with spacings 15 m and 30 m. For a
majority of the engineering surveys, where the sampling
7.3 The advantage of locating the shotpoints between
interval is less than 15 m and the depth of exploration
two geophones is that the reciprocal times between
is seldom more than 100 m, a 15 m spacing cable
different shotpoints can be read directly instead of
should be employed. H’owever, for investigations
extrapolating beyond the end geophone, which can
where marker of interest (refractor) is deeper, seismic
introduce errors in measurement of reciprocal time, in
cable with 30 m spacing should be used.
case of uneven refractor topography. Secondly, it does
not disturb the ground under adjacent geophone stations. The cable shouId be laid along the ground in a straight
Any disturbance of the ground caused by placing a shot line. If the terrain along the seismic line has any relief,
8
ground level survey should be carried out so that the In the presence of a low velocity layer, the interpretation
subsurface layer thicknesses can be plotted in true of travel-time curves leads to an overestimation of the
elevation of the site. depth to underlying interfaces. Low velocity layers are
a hazard in all types of refraction seismology. On a
7.6 In water, the picking up of the arrivals of
small scale, a peat layer in muds and sands above
compressional waves is done by hydrophores. The
bedrock may escape detection, leading to a false
hydrophore cable is towed beyond the ship and at some
estimation of foundation conditions and rock depths
places the cable is tied with the buoy rope so that the
beneath a construction site.
cable will float on the water surface. The hydrophore
cable is connected to a multichannel seismograph 9 INTERPRETATION
(see Fig. 5). Shots are fired on the bottom with fixed
intervals. 9.1 In some limited cases, quantitative interpretation
of the data may not be required and a simple qualitative
8 LIMITATION OF SEISMIC REFRACTION interpretation may be sufficient. Examples of qualitative
TECHNIQUE and semi-quantitative interpretation may include the
lateral location of a buried channel without a concern
A hidden layer, or blind layer, is one that is undetectable
for its depth or minimum depth to rock calculations. In
by refraction surveying. In practice, there are two
most cases, however, a quantitative interpretation will
different types of hidden layer problem.
be necessary.
A layer may simply not give rise to first arrivals, that
9.2 The level of effort involved in the interpretation
is, rays traveling to deeper levels may arrive before
will depend upon the objectives of the survey and the
those critically refi-actedat the top of the layer in question
detail desired that, in turn, will determine the method
(see Fig. 6A). This may result ffom the thickness of of interpretation. A number of manual methods and
the layer, or from the closeness of its velocity to that
computer programmed are available for interpretation.
of the overlying layer. In such a case, a method of
While the solution for these methods can be carried
survey involving recognition of only first arrivals wili
out manually, the process can be Iabour intensive for
fail to detect the layer. The problem maybe overcome
the more sophisticated methods.
by firing a shot in a deep hole so that arrivals from the
intermediate layer are recorded at the surface. 9.3 A problem inherent in all geophysical studies is
the non-unique correlation between possible geologic
A more insidious type of hidden layer problem is
models and a single set of field data. This ambiguity
associated with a low velocity layer, as illustrated in
can be resolved only through the use of sufficient
Fig. 6B. Rays cannot be critically refracted at the top of
geologic data and by an experienced interpreter.
such a layer and the layer will, therefore, not give rise
to head waves. Hence, a low velocity layer cannot be 9.4 The first step in the interpretation process is to
detected by refraction surveying although the top of the determine the time interval from the impact of the
low velocity layer gives rise to wide angle reflections seismic source to the first arrival of energy at each
that may be detected during a refraction survey. geophone. When the first arrivals are sharp and there
Seismograph
inside the boat Hydrophore
/ Cable Bouv
FIG. 5 LAYOUTOFHYDROPHORES
FORUNDERWATER
SEISMICREFRACTIONSURVEY
9
IS 15681:2006
v,> VI
\ /
A
v, * VI
is no ambient noise, this procedure is straightforward. geometric factors are then made. The two main types
In many cases, noise in the data will make picking the of corrections are elevation corrections and weathering
first arrival times difficult. To minimize errors, a corrections. Both are used to adjust field-derived travel
consistent approach to the picking of the arrival times times to some selected datum, so that straight-line
should be used. Care should be taken to ensure that segments on the time distance plot can be associated
each trace is picked at the same point, that is, at the with subsurface refractor. These corrections can be
first point of movement or the point of maximum applied manually or by computer.
curvature. This procedure will make the interpretation
a more uniform process, as the data will be consistent With the corrected travel-time data, a time-distance plot
from one trace to the next. In some cases, a first arrival of arrival times versus shotpoint-to-geophone distance
pick from one or more geophones may be uncertain. can be constructed. Lines are then fitted to these points
If this occurs, these picks should be noted. If a to complete a time-distance plot. These time-distance
computer programme is used to make first arrival plots are the foundation of seismic refraction
picks, these picks should be checked by the individual interpretation.
doing the processing and interpretation.
The methods given in 9.4.1 to 9.4.3 are generally used
Corrections to travel-time for elevation or other for seismic refraction interpretation.
10
IS 15681:2006
tG= l/2(tAo + tBG– tm) ...(14) Like the conventional reciprocal method, the GRM uses
both forward and reverse arrival times, and is relatively
where t*G,rB~and tA~are the travel times of the critical insensitive to dip angles up to about 20°. As a result,
rays from A to G, Bto G, and A to B respectively. depth calculations to an undulating refractor are
particularly convenient, even when the overlying strata
Substituting travel times in terms of their segment travel
have velocity gradients.
times as distance times velocity
The conventional reciprocal method smoothens
t~ = l/2(GX/Vl + GY/V1 –XY/V2) . ..(15)
refractor irregularities because it assumes a plane
If the refractor is assumed to be plane bemeen the refractor between the points of emergence of the
points X and Y,then from the symmetry, forward and reverse rays. The GRM employs the
principle of migration. Arrival times at two geophones,
tG= (GX/V1 – PX/ VJ . ..(16)
separated by what is termed the XY-distance, are used
which is the expression for the time-depth. “ in refractor velocity analysis and time-depth
calculations. A range of XY spacings is used, and the
The depth to the important refi-actor at a geophone
optimum value is selected using various tests associated
station G, Z~, is calculated tlom the equation,
with the method. At the optimum XY spacing, the
ZG= tG~ . ..(17) forward and reverse rays emerge from near the same
point on the refractor, so the refractor need only be
where tG is the time-depth to the important refractor plane over a very small interval.
11
IS 15681:2006
The two major steps involved in using GRM are as in units of time it is related to the thicknesses ZjGof the
follows: layers by:
a) Velocity analysis function: n-l
A DATUM x 6 Y B
‘Bfl
\ I
n
L tAY
I -. //
II
VI \ Lz,ta/
\\
v~
12
lS 15681 :2006
70 70
60 “60
50 “so
.
~ 40 “ 40
m
x
-30
“20
10 .10
0 0
OtSTANCE (m)
5 s
0 o
-?
z
o
G
3 -s ‘.. s
w
-1
Id
‘-lo
[ I I I t 1 I I n 1 I I 1 I
1
-J I I i
I I I [
-15
o so 100 150 200 220
DISTANCE (m)
FIG. 9 TYPICALTRAVEL-TIMECURVESANDCORRESPONDING
DEPTH SECTION
FORTwo LAYER CASE
13
Bureau of Indian Standards
BIS is a statutory institution established under the Bureau of Indian Standards Act, 1986 to promote
harmonious development of the activities of standardization, marking and quality certification of goods and
attending to connected matters in the country.
Copyright
BIS has the copyright of all its publications. No part of these publications may be reproduced in any form
without the prior permission in writing of BIS. This does not preclude the tiee use, in the course of implementing
the standard, of necessary details, such as symbols and sizes, type or grade designations. Enquiries relating to
copyright be addressed to the Director (Publications), BIS.
Amendments are issued to standards as the need arises on the basis of comments. Standards are also reviewed
periodically; a standard along with amendments is reaffmed when such review indicates that no changes are
needed; if the review indicates that changes are needed, it is taken up for revision. Users of Indian Standards
should ascertain that they are in possession of the latest amendments or edition by referring to the latest issue of
‘BIS Catalogue’ and ‘Standards: Monthly Additions’.
This Indian Standard has been developed from Dot: No. WRD 5 (439).