Sunteți pe pagina 1din 8

Peritoneal Dialysis and Hemodialysis

Kawanishi H, Takemoto Y (eds): Scientific Aspects of Dialysis Therapy: JSDT/ISBP Anniversary Edition.
Contrib Nephrol. Basel, Karger, 2017, vol 189, pp 71–78 (DOI: 10.1159/000450687)

What Is the Best Dialysis Therapy for


South Asia: HD or PD?
K.R.N. Pavan a, b · S.V. Subhramanyam a, b · A.N. Karopadi b ·
K.A. Sinoj a · K.S. Nayak a, b
a The
Deccan Institute of Nephrology and Renal Transplantation, Deccan Hospital, and b Dr. Nayak Dialysis Center,
 

Hyderabad, India

Health of Economic Systems and Chronic


Abstract
Kidney Disease Epidemics in South Asia
Background: South Asian countries have a population of
1.7 billion and are classified as low-middle to poor income
nations. Their health care systems cannot presently meet The difference between developed and develop-
the growing need for renal replacement therapy (RRT), ing nations is starkest when examining the realm
provided as haemodialysis or peritoneal dialysis (PD). of health care. Although screening for chronic
Most patients cannot afford the treatment and quickly de- diseases in the community is common in many
fault. Furthermore, most of the population is located in
developed nations, this practice is nearly non-ex-
rural areas, where there are few treatment centres; there-
istent in the countries of South Asia, i.e. India,
fore, there is a huge gap between those treated and those
in need. Summary: PD can bridge this gap and can serve Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Bhutan, Nepal,
as a first line of therapy if it becomes more affordable. Gov- Afghanistan, and the Maldives, where chronic
ernment reimbursement schemes, the Once-in-a-Lifetime kidney disease (CKD) is commonly diagnosed
Payment Scheme, and PD insurance all provide strong im- only when the disease is already at an advanced
petus to dialysis programmes. Local manufacturing of PD stage. Additionally, the exact burden of end-stage
fluid has also reduced the cost of therapy to some extent.
renal disease (ESRD) remains unknown due to
PD may be preferable for patients with cardiovascular
the lack of registry reports, poor access to health
morbidity and it also obviates the risk of transmission of
blood-borne diseases such as HIV, hepatitis B, and hepati- care, and absence of an organized chronic disease
tis C. In our own centre, automated PD is being used as management programme.
initial RRT for acute kidney injury with good results. In pro- The Screening and Early Evaluation of Kidney
spective transplant recipients, PD has been found to de- Disease (SEEK) study estimated the prevalence of
crease the risk of posttransplant graft dysfunction. Key CKD in India at 17.2% [1]. In Bangladesh, the fig-
Messages: Remote PD and home visits by PD clinical co-
ure is 16–18%, while in Nepal, the prevalence of
ordinators have brought faraway patients and their ne-
an estimated glomerular filtration rate <60 ml/
phrologists closer with the use of technology. For these
reasons, the current pressing need is to bring PD to the min/1.73 m2 was 19%. The prevalence of CKD in
forefront of RRT in resource-poor countries in South Asia Pakistan is 12.5% [2]. In Sri Lanka, a key issue is
144.82.108.120 - 12/13/2016 9:38:33 PM

to enable universal treatment of patients with renal dis- the use of agrochemicals, environmental nephro-
ease. © 2017 S. Karger AG, Basel toxins that may have adverse effects on kidney
Downloaded by:
UCL
7,000 6,567

6,000

GDP per capita (USD)


5,000

4,000
2,923
3,000
2,399
2,000
1,489 1,290
1,000
1,000 707 699

sh
a

al

an

ka

an

an
ve
di

ep

de

an
st

ut

st
In

di
ki

ni
N

Bh
iL
la

al
Pa

ga
ng

M
Sr

Af
Ba

Fig. 1. Nominal GDP spending on health care.

health; it is estimated that approximately 400,000 Table 1. Prevalence of CKD in South Asian countries
individuals in the North Central Province of Sri
Country CKD prevalence, %
Lanka may be affected by CKD (table 1).
India (SEEK study) 17.2
Bangladesh 17–18
Financial and Social Challenges of Chronic Nepal 19
Kidney Disease Programmes Pakistan 12.5
Sri Lanka 7–8 (ESRD)
Universally reimbursed and equitable renal re-
placement therapy (RRT) programmes are rare
in South Asia, and most nations remain depen-
dent on expensive imported technology for RRT. tain provincial and state governments have estab-
Private health care forms the backbone of RRT in lished free maintenance haemodialysis (MHD)
South Asia and the expenditure on health care is [3], continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis
nominal (fig. 1). Haemodialysis (HD) is the most (CAPD), and transplantation through health in-
common form of RRT in South Asia, followed by surance schemes for the underprivileged (in the
renal transplantation and then peritoneal dialysis states of Tamil Nadu, Telangana, Andhra
(PD). PD is growing at a rate of 17% per year. Pradesh, Kerala, Goa, Pondicherry, and Bihar in
Although an accurate prediction of RRT prev- India, and in the cities of Lahore and Karachi in
alence in South Asian countries is unknown, es- Pakistan [4]).
timates put the figure at >95,000 patients receiv- The nephrology work force is growing slowly
ing RRT, with the incidence increasing annually in South Asia, with current levels at 1.1 nephrolo-
by approximately 232 per million population. gists per million population. Nephrology training
144.82.108.120 - 12/13/2016 9:38:33 PM

The quality of dialysis delivered to patients in programmes have been established in India,
South Asia can vary from centre to centre. Cer- Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal, and Sri Lanka.
Downloaded by:

72 Pavan · Subhramanyam · Karopadi · Sinoj · Nayak


UCL

Kawanishi H, Takemoto Y (eds): Scientific Aspects of Dialysis Therapy: JSDT/ISBP Anniversary Edition.
Contrib Nephrol. Basel, Karger, 2017, vol 189, pp 71–78 (DOI: 10.1159/000450687)
Table 2. Peritonitis rates in South Asia

Country Incidence of peritonitis

India [Nayak, 2003; Prasad et al., 2004] 1 episode/71 patient-months 0.63 episodes/patient-year Gram positive, 40%;
Gram negative, 60%
Pakistan [Hussain et al., 2006] 1 episode/22 patient-months

Bangladesh [Samad et al., 2006] 1 episode/19.46 patient-months

Nepal [Sharma et al., 2006] 0.43 episodes/patient-year

Source: Abraham et al. [4] (used with permission).

Status of Renal Replacement Therapy in tricity, on-line water purification, and home-
South Asia and the Need for Growth in based therapy independent of institutional care,
Peritoneal Dialysis which together translate to potential cost sav-
ings.
Only 3–5% of all patients with ESRD in South
Asia receive some form of RRT [4]. The cost of
MHD for a single session varies from USD 10 to Peritoneal Dialysis and Government
65. Furthermore, the hidden cost of travel to the
HD centre and loss of daily wages for the patient A look at the Indian CKD registry data shows
and any accompanying person is usually not cal- that 37.3% of patients have a monthly income of
culated when the cost of HD is considered. The USD <100, the majority are men (69.5%) (GDP:
unmet need for RRT must be addressed by PD, USD 1,050), 31.4% have diabetes, and the pa-
which is available even in remote areas. There are tients are aged between 19 and 60 years (www.
approximately 7,000 patients on chronic PD in ckdri.org). This harsh reality, with hardly any in-
India. However, although some centres have ex- surance coverage for PD patients in India, pre-
cellent results, peritonitis remains a major factor cludes the growth and expansion of PD pro-
limiting PD growth in the region (table 2) [4]. grammes. A recent development in this coverage
is of federal government employees receiving re-
imbursement for dialysis costs. The additional
Growth of Peritoneal Dialysis in South Asia, cost borne by some state governments in provid-
with a Focus on India ing access to dialysis to certain sections in the
society has also expanded the PD program in
PD for CKD was initiated in India in 1991 [3], India [3].
with other South Asian countries later following
the Indian model. Despite relatively few contra-
indications and the added advantage of being a Role of the Pharmaceutical Industry in
simple home therapy, PD has seen penetration in Innovating Cost-Effective Products
India of only 8–10%. In developing countries in
Asia, PD offers certain clear advantages over HD, Domestic production of PD fluid and accessories
including simplicity, reduced need for trained in India, China, and Southeast Asia has reduced
144.82.108.120 - 12/13/2016 9:38:33 PM

technicians and nurses, minimal technical sup- the cost of treatment. If PD manufacturing com-
port requirements, lack of dependence on elec- panies bring down the cost of their products on
Downloaded by:

What Is Best for South Asia: HD or PD? 73


UCL

Kawanishi H, Takemoto Y (eds): Scientific Aspects of Dialysis Therapy: JSDT/ISBP Anniversary Edition.
Contrib Nephrol. Basel, Karger, 2017, vol 189, pp 71–78 (DOI: 10.1159/000450687)
par with GDP per capita income, a positive effect Telemedicine in Peritoneal Dialysis
will be seen in PD utilization. The appropriate
use of smaller exchange volumes (6 litres/day) in In our centre, we have made extensive use of the
patients with smaller body size or those with re- Internet for maintaining records and of mobile
sidual renal function can positively impact the phone technology for collecting data, including
daily cost of PD without compromising adequate general patient status by using the short mes-
dialysis. A reduction in complications of PD by sage service (SMS) feature [6–10] and image/
implementing better ‘connectology’ techniques video transfer. We have a dedicated PD team
that aim at decreasing peritonitis rates may re- consisting of trained medical and paramedical
duce associated hospitalization and treatment staff who have undergone training to acquire
costs [3]. Presently, due to initiatives for local proficiency in all the mentioned technologies as
manufacturing, Indian patients are able to afford well as in training patients to transmit medical
biocompatible, low GDP (glucose degradation information with the compliance required for
product) triple chambered bags (TriChoice; Mi- safe and easy PD therapy. A comprehensive
tra Industries, New Delhi, India). software app for the iPad is currently being used
to capture videos and images and send all ex-
changed data directly to an online database [10].
Once-in-a-Lifetime Payment Scheme for It is our opinion that this application can be an
Chronic Peritoneal Dialysis: a Novel Initiative all-in-one solution for solving the challenges of
remote monitoring, can help simplify the entire
The Once-in-a-Lifetime Payment Scheme for pa- process even further, and has the potential to
tients to pay suppliers for PD supplies has en- change the practice of PD worldwide (fig.  2).
abled the expansion of the PD programme in The technology has been reviewed in a recent
India since 2003 [3]. In a legal agreement between commentary on telemedicine by Nayak et al.
the patient and the dialysis industry, supplies [10].
such as a double-bag transfer set and mini-caps
are provided until the patient continues onto
CAPD. The lifetime scheme currently costs INR Home Visit Protocol
10,00,000 (USD 15,500) for 3 exchanges, includ-
ing all supplies delivered to the place of residence, Our system relies heavily on regular patient
either as a single upfront payment or 3 instal- home visits. The home visit schedules are pre-
ments over 3 years [3, 5]. pared by the clinical head and conducted by clin-
ical coordinators, who ensure that the proper
techniques are being followed and identify any
Peritoneal Dialysis ‘Suraksha’ Insurance for conditions that might require the attention of the
Peritonitis nephrologist. The clinical coordinators also ad-
vise the patient about nutrition status, psycho-
A novel initiative, called ‘Suraksha’, was intro- logical well-being, physical fitness, and rehabili-
duced in 2010 by a medical insurance company tation levels. After they complete their assess-
involving a payment of USD 58 per year that en- ment, they enter these details into the referral PD
sures coverage for peritonitis treatment, includ- unit records.
ing hospitalization and antibiotics, for PD pa- The theme of our home visit protocol is to nip
tients in India. All hospitalization expenses are incorrect practices in the bud before they become
insured up to a sum of USD 1,063 per year. The a serious problem. This can also be thought of as
cost of a new catheter, implantation surgery, and a kind of posttraining follow-up to ensure the
144.82.108.120 - 12/13/2016 9:38:33 PM

hospitalization is included in case a patient re- highest form of compliance [6–9].


quires catheter removal [3, 5].
Downloaded by:

74 Pavan · Subhramanyam · Karopadi · Sinoj · Nayak


UCL

Kawanishi H, Takemoto Y (eds): Scientific Aspects of Dialysis Therapy: JSDT/ISBP Anniversary Edition.
Contrib Nephrol. Basel, Karger, 2017, vol 189, pp 71–78 (DOI: 10.1159/000450687)
Fig. 2. Remote PD.

Automated Peritoneal Dialysis as an Initial


Modality in the Intensive Care Unit

Automated PD can also be used as an initial ther-


apy for CKD patients or in cases of acute kidney
injury (AKI) in the ICU. PD aids in early recovery
in AKI, and recent studies in Brazil by Ponce et
al. [11] have shown automated PD to be as effec-
tive as HD. At our centre, we use automated PD
as an initial modality in AKI and stable CKD pa-
tients (fig. 3). We use a low-cost, locally manufac-
tured automated PD machine (mCycler; Mitra
Industries), making treatment affordable. Un-
published data from our centre shows that about
60% of patients with AKI on CKD recover sig-
nificant renal function. Those in ESRD are more
likely to opt for PD as long-term RRT, thus in-
creasing PD penetrance.

Peritoneal Dialysis and Renal Transplantation

PD can be a safe modality in patients awaiting a


144.82.108.120 - 12/13/2016 9:38:33 PM

deceased donor renal transplant. Although the


modality of RRT has been found to have no influ- Fig. 3. Patient on automated PD.
Downloaded by:

What Is Best for South Asia: HD or PD? 75


UCL

Kawanishi H, Takemoto Y (eds): Scientific Aspects of Dialysis Therapy: JSDT/ISBP Anniversary Edition.
Contrib Nephrol. Basel, Karger, 2017, vol 189, pp 71–78 (DOI: 10.1159/000450687)
Table 3. State of RRT in India by zone (2009)

Zone Dialysis Dialysis Dialysis Cost of dialysis per


centres, n machines, n sessions per month, n session, INR

North 229 1,106 50,560 1,250


South 306 1,453 85,440 1,100
East 108 430 27,050 1,350
West 175 1,000 90,000 1,000

ence on graft survival, long-term studies on de- Table 4. Hepatitis C infection in dialysis patients in South
layed graft function have shown better results in Asia
patients who received PD compared with those
Country Prevalence of HCV, %
who received HD [12]. Our experience has been
that patients receiving PD have lower total isch- India 30
aemia times while undergoing deceased donor Pakistan 38
renal transplant due to various inherent advan- Bangladesh 27.3
tages of the therapy itself.

Why Choose Peritoneal Dialysis Over for the vast majority of dialysis patients to un-
Haemodialysis? dergo regular MHD on a long-term basis (ta-
ble 3).
Malnutrition in PD and HD
Prevalence of malnutrition in PD patients varies Hepatitis Seroconversion during MHD
based upon the method of assessment used. For Acquiring hepatitis B and or C infection while on
unclear reasons, longitudinal studies have shown dialysis is another major problem in South Asian
that following an initial improvement upon ini- countries. Although the availability of reasonably
tiation on PD, nutritional status then gradually effective vaccination against hepatitis B has
declines. There is a clear association between helped to reduce the conversion rate, the situa-
malnutrition and poor outcome in PD patients. tion with regard to hepatitis C is much more dire
Incidence of severe malnutrition is lower in Asian because there is no vaccination for hepatitis C
populations compared to Western populations, and the spread of the virus is both blood-borne
which may be due to lower activation of systemic and nosocomial. Disease prevalence varies wide-
inflammatory reaction. Lower incidence of meta- ly, at 5–75% [14, 16] (table 4). However, the CDC
bolic acidosis in Asian patients has also been re- guidelines do not recommend isolation of hepa-
ported [12, 13]. titis C-positive individuals during dialysis pro-
vided that universal precautions are meticulously
Inaccessibility of HD Centres adhered to.
South Asian countries have poor accessibility to
dialysis due to high demand and high cost. Cardiovascular Mortality
More than 70% of the population lives in vil- Cardiovascular disease is the leading cause of
lages, whereas HD centres are present only in mortality and hospitalization in ESRD patients
cities and large towns [14, 15]. Until recent- due to accelerated atherogenesis, lipid derange-
144.82.108.120 - 12/13/2016 9:38:33 PM

ly,  several district headquarters did not have ments, endothelial dysfunction, and inflamma-
HD facilities. Hence, it is logistically difficult tion. Pre-existing cardiovascular conditions may
Downloaded by:

76 Pavan · Subhramanyam · Karopadi · Sinoj · Nayak


UCL

Kawanishi H, Takemoto Y (eds): Scientific Aspects of Dialysis Therapy: JSDT/ISBP Anniversary Edition.
Contrib Nephrol. Basel, Karger, 2017, vol 189, pp 71–78 (DOI: 10.1159/000450687)
worsen outcomes in new ESRD patients depend- Nepal. According to Mishra et al. [19], the cost of
ing on the treatment modality chosen. HD is NPR 2,500–3,500 per dialysis session.
Researchers have noted a higher mortality
rate after 6 months of therapy among CAD (cor- Economics of PD
onary artery disease) patients treated with PD India. Dialysis penetration in India is still very
than those treated with HD. Theoretically, PD low [20], mostly due to its limited reimbursement
should offer patients with cardiac conditions im- structure. PD in India has become significantly
proved blood pressure control, less haemody- more affordable since the emergence of local
namic stress, and avoidance of the uraemic peaks manufacturers. India has the seventh-largest
and troughs often seen with HD. number of PD patients (>7,000), behind Mexico,
However, PD promotes a proatherogenic envi- the USA, China, Brazil, Japan, and South Korea.
ronment [14, 17]. Ultrafiltration failure and the de- Nepal. Nepal is a prime example of a country that
velopment of high transport membrane permea- cannot achieve economies of scale and cannot sus-
bility over time may contribute to hypertension, tain local production of CAPD bags due to its small
fluid overload, and cardiomyopathy in PD-treated PD patient population [20]. The government has
patients. Additionally, PD patients are seen less fre- removed all import duties on CAPD bags. Nepal
quently than HD patients by their nephrologists. now acquires bags from Baxter India at a cost of
Residual renal function is important for the about NPR 330 per bag (a little under USD 4), mak-
removal of uraemic toxins. Preservation of resid- ing it significantly less expensive than HD.
ual renal function is better with PD than HD. In Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, and Pakistan. The PD uti-
addition, the intermittent nature of HD requires lization rate in these countries is low, mainly due
greater dietary compliance among HD patients to the significantly higher cost of PD compared
because there are potentially lethal complications with HD. PD solutions are imported and duty is
like hyperkalaemia or pulmonary oedema if the high. Most patients on HD in these countries can
diet is not followed appropriately. afford just 2 sessions a week, and several drop out
due to prohibitive dialysis costs. Only a few pa-
tients in these countries are reimbursed, and this
Cost of Therapy through private insurance companies. As of 2008,
there was a total of just 325 patients on PD in all
Economics of HD 3 countries combined [20].
India and Pakistan. MHD is not provided in gov-
ernment hospitals. Insurance covers a tiny frac-
tion of the population. Most patients pay out of Conclusion
pocket. The monthly cost of HD in most private
hospitals is about INR 12,000, not including the We can clearly see that PD is the more affordable
cost of medications [17]. modality in most South Asian countries. This
Bangladesh. There are 14 dialysis centres, with 150 conclusion is further corroborated by the fact
dialysis machines providing dialysis in 3 shifts. The that many basic cost assessments do not consider
annual cost of HD at private hospitals can vary be- hidden costs such as loss of productivity of the
tween USD 4,000 for twice-weekly treatment to patient and their family members or cost of trans-
USD 5,500 for thrice-weekly treatment [18]. portation to the centre. Although HD remains
Sri Lanka. The mean cost per patient of a single the dominant therapy at present, local manufac-
4-hour dialysis session is LKR 6,377 (USD 56). turing of PD fluids (including biocompatible low
The annual cost of HD for a patient with chronic GDP solutions), low-cost automated PD ma-
renal failure undergoing 2–3 4-hour dialysis ses- chines, and telemedicine have the potential to
144.82.108.120 - 12/13/2016 9:38:33 PM

sions per week is LKR 663,208–994,812 (USD significantly impact PD practice in the region. In
5,869–8,804). addition, PD can be recommended for patients
Downloaded by:

What Is Best for South Asia: HD or PD? 77


UCL

Kawanishi H, Takemoto Y (eds): Scientific Aspects of Dialysis Therapy: JSDT/ISBP Anniversary Edition.
Contrib Nephrol. Basel, Karger, 2017, vol 189, pp 71–78 (DOI: 10.1159/000450687)
with cardiovascular morbidity or those who are Acknowledgements
awaiting deceased donor transplants. Lastly, PD
minimizes the risk of hepatitis B and C infection We thank Dr. G. Abraham for valuable information
and reduces the incidence of delayed graft func- that helped us prepare this review.
tion after transplantation.

References

1 Abraham G: The challenges of renal 7 Nayak KS: Asia, a melting pot for 13 Nayak A, Nayak A, Prabhu M, Nayak
replacement therapy in Asia. Nat Clin peritoneal dialysis practices: redefin- KS: Nutritional Considerations in
Pract Nephrol 2008;4:643. ing and expanding peritoneal dialysis Indian Patients on PD; in Krediet R
2 Jessani S, Bux R, Jafar TH: Prevalence, horizons in Asia. Perit Dial Int 2004; (ed): Progress in Peritoneal Dialysis.
determinants, and management of 24:422–423. InTech, DOI: 10.5772/22032. http://
chronic kidney disease in Karachi, 8 Nayak KS, Sinoj KA, Subhramanyam www.intechopen.com/books/
Pakistan – a community based cross- SV, Mary B, Rao NV: Our experience progress-in-peritoneal-dialysis/
sectional study. BMC Nephrol 2014; of home visits in city and rural areas. nutritional-considerations-in-indian-
15:90. Perit Dial Int 2007;27(suppl 2):S27– patients-on-pd.
3 Reddy YN, Abraham G, Mathew M, S31. 14 Bhowmik D, Tiwari SC: Challenges of
Ravichandran R, Reddy YN: An 9 Aditi NK, Akash K, Subramanyam SV, hemodialysis in India. JIMSA 2012;25:
Indian model for cost-effective CAPD Nayak KS: Use of a peritoneal dialysis 99–100.
with minimal man power and eco- remote monitoring system in India. 15 Khanna U: The economics of dialysis
nomic resources. Nephrol Dial Trans- Perit Dial Int 2012;32:200–221. in India. Indian J Nephrol 2009;19:
plant 2011;26:3089–3091. 10 Nayak KS, Ronco C, Karopadi AN, 1–4.
4 Abraham G, Pratap B, Sankarasubbai- Rosner MH: Telemedicine and remote 16 Jaiswal SP, Chitnis DS, Salgia P, Sepa-
yan, Govindan P, Nayak KS, Sheriff R, monitoring: supporting the patient on ha A, Pandit CS: Prevalence of hepati-
Naqvi SA: Chronic peritoneal dialysis peritoneal dialysis. Perit Dial Int 2016; tis viruses among chronic renal failure
in South Asia: challenges and future. 36:362–366. patients on hemodialysis in central
Perit Dial Int 2008;28:13–19. 11 Ponce D, Berbel MN, Regina de Goes India. Dial Transplant 2002;31:234–
5 Abraham G, Kumar V, Nayak KS, C, Almeida CT, Balbi AL: High-vol- 238.
Ravichandran R, Srinivasan G, Krish- ume peritoneal dialysis in acute kid- 17 Van Biesen W, Verbeke F, Vanholder
namurthy M, Prasath AK, Kumar S, ney injury: indications and limita- R: Cardiovascular disease in haemodi-
Thiagarajan T, Mathew M, Lesley N: tions. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 2012;7: alysis and peritoneal dialysis: argu-
Predictors of long-term survival on 887–894. ments pro peritoneal dialysis. Nephrol
peritoneal dialysis in South India: a 12 Sezer S, Karakan S, Özdemir Acar FN, Dial Transplant 2007;22:53–58.
multicenter study. Perit Dial Int 2010; Haberal M: Dialysis as a bridge thera- 18 Rashid HU: Health delivery system for
30:29–34. py to renal transplantation: compari- renal disease care in Bangladesh. Sau-
6 Nayak KS, Prabhu MV, Sinoj KA, Sub- son of graft outcomes according to di J Kidney Dis Transpl 2004;15:185–
hramanyam SV, Sridhar G: Peritoneal mode of dialysis treatment. Trans- 189.
dialysis in developing countries; in plant Proc 2011;43:485–487. 19 Mishra D, Koirala P: Status of chronic
Ronco C, Crepaldi C, Cruz DN (eds): kidney disease patients registered in
Peritoneal Dialysis – From Basic Con- National Kidney Center, Banasthali,
cepts to Clinical Excellence. Contrib Kathmandu. JMMIHS 2015;1:19–23.
Nephrol. Basel, Karger, 2009, vol 163, 20 Karopadi AN, Mason G, Rettore E,
pp 270–277. Ronco C: Cost of peritoneal dialysis
and haemodialysis across the world.
Nephrol Dial Transplant 2013;28:
2553–2569.

Dr. K.R.N. Pavan


144.82.108.120 - 12/13/2016 9:38:33 PM

The Deccan Institute of Nephrology and Renal Transplantation, Deccan Hospital


Hyderabad 82 (India)
E-Mail pavannavva@gmail.com
Downloaded by:

78 Pavan · Subhramanyam · Karopadi · Sinoj · Nayak


UCL

Kawanishi H, Takemoto Y (eds): Scientific Aspects of Dialysis Therapy: JSDT/ISBP Anniversary Edition.
Contrib Nephrol. Basel, Karger, 2017, vol 189, pp 71–78 (DOI: 10.1159/000450687)

S-ar putea să vă placă și