Sunteți pe pagina 1din 10

WORKSHEET FOR PRIMARY VS.

SECONDARY SOURCES ON THE TEJEROS CONVENTION (1897)

Name:
Primary Source: Santiago Alvarez’ Secondary Source: Teodoro
Memoirs of a General Agoncillo’s Revolt of the Masses

Author’s Background Santiago Alvarez was a revolutionary Teodoro Agoncillo, a renowned


general. Son of another Filipino Filipino historian and national
famous general, Mariano Alvarez. scientist. Born on November 9, 1912
Born July 25, 1872 in Imus, Cavite in Lemery, Batangas and died on
and died October 30, 1930 in San January 14, 1985. Agoncillo is one of
Pablo, Laguna. Member of the the most prominent Filipino Historians
Katipunan secret society during the 20th century. He started
(Magdiwang), at the outbreak of the writing history frome the so-called
revolution of the independence. He Filipino point of view along with the
was branded as the “hero of other historians.
Dalahican” after preventing the
Spanish reinforcements to reconquer
the province of Cavite.

When was the account written? The context was set on the time of the The account was written in the
(Context) assembly of the two factions. It was author’s present at that time (1947). It
written years after the Assembly of views the various perspective of
Tejeros by one of the personalities happenings in the Assembly of
that experienced the happenings on Tejeros and the election, it was set to
the said assembly which is Santiago relive the past into the present based
Alvarez. It was set to retell the story of on what did the author searched or
an event in a factual state. known about the event.

Mention of Date/s March 25, 1897 – Assembly was January 1897 – San Francisco de
convened at Tejeros Malabon Town Fiesta
March 26, 1897 – Another meeting January 2, 1897 – Bonifacio wrote a
initiated by Magdalo President letter to his uncle-in-law, Mariano
Baldomero Aguinaldo, but only Alvarez
Magdiwang leaders have attended
March 22, 1897 – Aguinaldo’s
March 27, 1897 – Eyewitness Birthday, Assembly convened at
revealed that a meeting had taken Tejeros
place at the Tanza parish house
April 1897 – Spaniards captured the
town of Malabon

Mention of Place/s Friar estate house in Tejeros – Talisay, Batangas – where Magdalo
venue of the meetings leaders reside

Santa Cruz de Malabon (Parish


House of the Catholic Church) Nasugbu, Tuwi, Look – where
Magdiwang leaders reside
Parish House in Tanza – where it is
rumored that the oath-taking Imus, Cavite – where Magdalo and
ceremony was held here Magdiwang decided to have an
assembly
San Francisco de Malabon

Noveleta – town where Andres


Bonifacio stayed and later conquered
by Spanish forces
Estate House of Tejeros – where the
assembly was held

Cavite – where the Katipunan comes


at 2 factions; Magdalo and
Magdiwang

San Francisco de Malabon

Santa Cruz de Malabon/Town of


Tanza

Mountains of Montalban and


Mariquina

Zapote – where Emilio Aguinaldo,


Candido Tirona, and Edilberto
Evangelista will meet Andres
Bonifacio

Key Personalities Magdiwang  General Blanco


 Andres Bonifacio – Supreme
 Secretary Jacinto
Head of Katipunan
Lumbreras of the Magdiwang
 Jacinto Lumbreras – acting
Council
president of the Magdiwang
 Supremo Andres Bonifacio
 Mariano Alvarez – President
Messrs.
of the Magdiwang council
 Mariano Alvarez
 Pascual Alvarez – Executive
 Pascual Alvarez
 Ariston Villanueva – secretary of Magdiwang
Secretary of War of  Emilio Riego de Dios –
Magdiwang Minister of the Interior of
 Mariano Trias Magdiwang
 Diego Mojica  Mariano Trias – Minister of
 Emiliano de Dios Grace and Justice of
 Santiago Alvarez (General Magdiwang
Apoy)  Ariston Villanueva – Minister
 Artemio Ricarte (General of War of Magdiwang
Vibora)  Santiago Alvarez –
 Santos Nocon Commander-in-Chief of
 Luciano San Miguel Magdiwang
 Pablo Mojica  Diego Moxica – Minister of
 Severino de las Alas Finance of Magdiwang
 Santiago Rillo  Artemio Ricarte & Mariano
Riego de Dios – Military
Magdalo Commanders of Magdiwang
 Baldomero Aguinaldo –  Severino de las Alas -
President of the Magdalo  Baldomero Aguinaldo –
council President of the Magdalo
 Emilio Aguinaldo council
 Daniel Tirona  Candido Tirona – Minister of
War of Magdalo
 Antonio Montenegro
 Cayetano Topacio – Minister
----------------------------
of Finance of Magdalo
 Fr. Cenon Villafranca
 Emilio Aguinaldo –
Commander-in-Chief of
Magdalo
 Edilberto Evangelista –
Lieutenant General of Magdalo
 Vito Belarmino & Crispulo
Aguinaldo – Military
Commanders of Magdalo
 Antonio Montenegro
 Ciriaco Bonifacio – older
brother of Andres Bonifacio
 Procopio Bonifacio – younger
brother of Andres Bonifacio
 Vicente Fernandez
 Polavieja
 Captain Mariano San Gabriel
 Arsenio Salvador – Occupant
of the former estate house
 Emilio Jacinto – a Filipino
General, Andres Bonifacio’s
friend

Sequencing of Events  Meeting at the Long  Factions of Katipunan,


Presidential Table in Magdalo and Magdiwang set
Assembly of Tejeros to unite for an election of
supreme council.
 Discussion on the kind of
government to implement
 Attempt was made by both
factions to wear the same
 Exchange of arguments uniform. However, both
factions don’t have the
between General Apoy and means to buy the uniform.
Mr. Montenegro about the
establishment of  Silent conflict led to a contest
government of better faction that is fitted
to rule their territory.
 Convention resumed but
 A delegate was sent out to
Supremo Andres Bonifacio
invite and inform Andres
presides the meeting
Bonifacio in the mountains of
instead of Sec. Jacinto
Montalban and Mariquina for
Lumbreras
the purpose of mediating the
two factions.
 Election began for
President, Vice-President,
 Andres Bonafacio was
Minister for finance, welfare,
brought by the rebel leaders
justice, as well as captain-
at Imus. He orders to be
general.
obeyed by all. At this time, he
wrote a letter to his uncle-in-
 Emilio Aguinaldo proclaimed
law about what happened in
as the President after the
the Magdalo area.
elections. Mariano Trias as
Vice-President, General
 Andres Bonifacio was invited
Vibora as Captain General,
to the demonstration of the
Emiliano de Dios as
Magdiwang rebels in
Secretary of War, Supremo
Noveleta and a parade took
Andres Bonifacio as
place.
Secretary of the Interior.
 Polavieja’s counter-offensive
 Mr. Daniel Tirona’s
led to the fall of several
questioned and contested
towns that was previously
the election of Andres
held by the rebels, due to
Bonifacio as Secretary of
this, both fractions believe
the Interior. In result,
Bonifacio got insulted and that they should come
demanded an apology which together.
Mr. Tirona did not agree.
 The assembly was opened
 Supremo Andres Bonifacio with Andres Bonifacio seating
declared that the meeting at the head of the table,
and election was null and assuming presidency.
void then he left quickly. Insisting that there was no
need for a new government
 The Magdalo President, Mr. and objecting the elections
Baldomero Aguinaldo did which the Magdalo leaders
not leave to convince the would refuse.
Magdiwang leaders to
reconvene the disrupted  Town fiesta was held on on
meeting on the next day in the town of Noveleta, where
the same friar estate house the rebels was disturbed by a
in Tejeros. series of rifle shots.

 Only the Magdiwang leaders  On March 22, 1897,


along with Supremo Andres Magdiwang held a
Bonifacio had attended the convention at the estate
meeting. There was no house of Tejeros for both
Magdalo leaders that factions but not all of
attended even Magdalo Magdalo leaders were able to
president that initiated the attend due to battles raging
meeting. the locality.

 Eyewitnesses revealed that  Jacinto Lumbreras opened


the rumor about the the convention and took the
Magdalo leaders holding a chair. Firstly, tackling the kind
different meeting at the of the government to set up
Tanza parish house was for the country. Where Mr. de
sought to be true. las Alas and Andres
Bonifacio had an argument
 Even though the election about the “K” in the
was declared to be null and Katipunan flag in relation to
void, they held a secret the government they will
oath-taking ceremony at the have.
Tanza parish without inviting
Supremo Andres Bonifacio  Emotions ran high as the
that was elected to office. meeting was going nowhere.
Santiago Alvarez was pricked
to anger as Mr. Montenegro
supported the suggestions of
Mr. de las Alas regarding on
the “K” on the Katipunan flag

 Moreover, the election was


continued. Emilio Aguinaldo
won in absentia over Andres
Bonifacio. Then, Severino de
las Alas suggested the
election of Andres Bonifacio
for the Vice President since
he got the second largest
vote, which no one approved
or disapproved it.

 Andres Bonifacio eventually


decided to resume the
election. The results of
election came and the
election of Bonifacio nearly
ended in a bloody way with
Daniel Tirona insisting that
Bonifacio should not be
elected because of his
educational attainment.

 As Andres Bonifacio is
insulted on what happened,
he declares the elections null
and void.

 Andres Bonifacio then wrote


letter to Mariano Alvarez,
Emilio Jacinto, giving the
background of what
happened in the convention.

DIFFERENCES between the two  It was said that the Tejeros  Contrary to the primary source,
accounts Convention happened on March it was said that the Tejeros
25, 1897. Convention occurred on March
 The story revolves more on the 22, 1897, which was
election that was made in the Aguinaldo’s Birthday.
Tejeros convention and the  The source of Teodoro
aftermath of the Magdalo- Agoncillo tells about the
Magdiwang factions. purpose of why they had a
 Trining (Trinidad Rizal, sister of convention.
Jose Rizal) and Josephine  Alvarez’s bodyguards stayed
Bracken was present. near the stairs.
 Alvarez’s bodyguards are  Did not mention Trinidad Rizal
outside the estate house. and Josephine Bracken.
 Narrated straightforwardly by  Widely narrated by a historian
Alvarez, who is present at the with evidences of the
same story. convention.
YOUR OWN ANALYSIS of the The primary source was more of a It has the same story as the primary
differences between the two accounts focus on the election and explained source but the secondary source was
what was happened in the convention more of a backstory of the election.
of Tejeros. Two accounts have the Dealing on why was the election
same tone although some parts have needed to happen. There was even a
a difference from the secondary sketch of the estate house which
source which is the evidence. Even supports the events that happened
though it lacks evidences, Santiago there. Providing evidences are more
Alvarez, the author alone can be a convincing for the readers to believe
solid proof that the events in the the story.
estate house of Tejeros are
believable.

S-ar putea să vă placă și