Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
S U S TA I N I N G B R A N D R E L E VA N C E
BRAND ARCHITECTURE:
DESIGNING YOUR BRAND
PORTFOLIO FOR SUCCESS
NEED A NEW
IMAGE-
ANOTHER APPLE?
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
Copyright
© 2015
Brand
Amplitude
LLC
All Rights Reserved – May Not Be Reproduced Without Permission
QUESTIONS
WE
ANSWER
HERE
§ What is brand architecture and why is it important?
§ What
are
the
various
roles
brands
play,
how
are
they
determined
and
why
are
they
useful?
§ What
is
the
range
of
brand
architecture
soluMons,
what
are
their
implicaMons
and
what
determines
which
is
the
best
opMon?
§ How do marketers go about developing architecture soluMons for their brands?
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
1
BRAND
ARCHITECTURE
OVERVIEW
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
2
BRAND
ARCHITECTURE
DEFINED
Architecture
is
about
opMmizing
the
hierarchy,
linkages,
and
roles
of
brands
within
the
porRolio
in
support
of
the
business
strategy.
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
3
BENEFITS
OF
A
CLEAR
ARCHITECTURE
Brand
architecture
helps
organizaMons
structure
their
brands
and
products
to
drive
value
and
growth
by
enhancing:
§ Clarity:
Clarifies
what
the
organizaMon
can
do
for
customers
by
providing
a
coherent
face
to
the
offering
and
the
business
strategy.
§ Efficiency:
Increases
markeMng
efficiency
by
ensuring
brand
leverage
without
overstretching.
§ Focus:
Provides
direcMon
for
where
to
focus
innovaMon
and
markeMng
investments
by
disMnguishing
strategic
brands
from
others
in
the
porRolio.
§ Growth:
Opens
up
new
opportuniMes
for
growth
by
lending
credibility
from
exisMng,
successful
brands.
§ Equity:
Enables
equity
to
flow
through
the
porRolio
by
defining
the
relaMonships
between
porRolio
brands.
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
4
BRAND
ARCHITECTURE
TAKES
AN
OUTSIDE-‐IN
VIEW
The
opMmal
architecture
usually
does
not
line
up
neatly
with
internal
organizaMonal
structures
–
and
that’s
okay!
Masterbrand
A
Corporate
Business Business
Unit Unit
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
5
ARCHITECTURE
DEFINES
BRAND
ROLES
Sony
plays
mulMple
roles
in
its
porRolio
due
to
the
needs
of
the
business.
Some
offerings
have
stand-‐alone
brands
that
do
not
feature
the
Sony
name
at
all.
Corporate
Brand
Master
Brands
Sub-‐Brand
Ingredient
Brand
Stand-‐Alone
Brands
Master
Brand:
Allows
equity
Sub-‐Brand:
Leverages
Ingredient
Brand:
Brings
Stand-‐Alone
Brand:
to
be
shared
among
brand
the
strength
of
the
energy
and
news
to
an
Separates
offerings,
creates
assets
when
used
in
either
master
brand
while
offering.
Always
used
in
new
sources
of
equity
or
driver
or
endorser
role.
helping
to
separate
and
conjuncMon
with
another
targets
new
audiences.
organize
the
offerings.
porRolio
brand.
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
7
WHAT’S
INCLUDED
IN
ARCHITECTURE?
Only
offerings
are
included
in
the
architecture.
Trademarked
or
licensed
branded
elements
live
outside
the
architecture
and
enhance
equity
by
providing
uniqueness
and
memorability.
Branded Elements Are Not Included in Architecture
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
8
BRAND
ARCHITECTURE
SOLUTIONS
Hybrid
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
9
MOST
SOLUTIONS
ARE
A
HYBRID
Brand
architecture
soluMons
fall
on
a
spectrum.
Most
soluMons
fall
somewhere
between
branded
house
and
house
of
brands.
House
of
Brands
Hybrid
Branded
House
Builds
equity
in
strong
stand-‐ Leverages
strong
master
brand
Results
in
strong
master
alone
brands
across
a
wide
while
allowing
flexibility.
brand.
range
of
categories
Requires
significant
Requires
careful
planning
to
avoid
Can
be
difficult
to
extend
markeMng
investment
confusing
customers
or
diluMng
beyond
the
experMse
of
the
Con the
master
brand.
master
brand.
s
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
10
BRAND
ARCHITECTURE
SOLUTION
IMPLICATIONS
Architecture
decisions
have
investment
implicaMons,
and
the
opMmal
soluMon
is
determined
in
large
part
by
the
business
strategy.
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
11
EXAMPLE:
DISNEY
BRAND
ARCHITECTURE
SOLUTION
Disney uses a mix of brand architecture soluMons to build and protect its diverse businesses.
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
12
BRAND
HIERARCHY
EXAMPLE:
DISNEY
Master
Brand
A
broad
brand
that
is
the
primary
frame
of
reference
for
the
customer.
It
is
used
as
an
umbrella
across
a
wide
range
of
product
categories,
services
and
geographies
that
can
exist
without
the
support
of
another
brand.
Category
Brand
Broad
groupings
of
product
and
service
offerings
that
reflect
mulMple
customer
segments
that
use
similar
technologies.
Sub-‐Category
Groups
of
products
and
services
within
a
Category
that
help
Disney
Princess
CollecMon
Brand
customer
find
relevant
offerings.
They
can
be
organized
around
products,
applicaMons
or
customer
segments.
Product
/
Service
A
collecMon
of
like
offerings
that
helps
simplify
the
buying
Line
Brand
process
for
the
customer
by
signaling
a
unique
value
proposiMon
relaMve
to
compeMMve
offerings.
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
13
BRAND
RELATIONSHIPS
EXAMPLE:
DISNEY
Shared
Core
values
of
the
brand
are
quite
consistent
with
the
master
brand,
but
augmentaMon
is
needed
Endorsed
Master
brand
equity
limits
the
brand’s
image
and
thus
necessitates
some
independence;
endorsement
adds
credibility
or
meaning
Invisible
Brand
is
inconsistent
with
core
values
of
master
brand;
risks
diluMng/eroding
parent
brand
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
14
HOW
TO
DECIDE
WHICH
SOLUTION
IS
RIGHT?
Three
guiding
principles
help
to
ensure
the
brand
architecture
has
the
opMmal
business
impact:
Clear
SeparaIon
Make
it
easy
for
customers
to
find
the
soluMon
they
seek
by
ensuring
“daylight”
between
brand
offerings.
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
15
ARCHITCTURE
DIRECTS
STRATEGIC
PRIORITIES
Not
all
brands
are
equally
important.
Architecture
guides
decisions
about
innovaMon
and
investment
as
porRolio
brands
compete
for
resources.
Example
Strategic
Brand
Significant
contributor
to
company’s
future
sales,
percepMons
or
market
posiMon.
Cash
Cow
Money
making
brand
that
does
not
represent
future
significant
growth.
Corporate
Brand
May
have
low
visibility
to
customers,
but
important
to
regulatory
bodies,
investors,
employees,
trade
groups,
partners.
Fighter/Flanker
Addresses
compeMMve
threat.
Protects
share
of
other
Brand
brands
in
the
porRolio.
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
16
EXAMPLE:
AMAZON
Amazon
keeps
its
strategic
businesses
separate
through
stand-‐alone
brands,
and
uses
an
endorsed
approach
for
its
other
brands.
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
17
EXAMPLE:
STARBUCKS
Starbucks
is
thoughRully
expanding
its
porRolio
to
separate
its
high
growth
and
premium
businesses
from
its
mainline
coffeehouses
and
Starbucks
Express
stores.
http://news.starbucks.com/news/starbucks-accelerates-growth-of-store-formats
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
18
WHEN
TO
REVISIT
ARCHITECTURE?
It’s
Mme
to
revisit
brand
architecture
when
an
organizaMon
changes
strategic
direcMon
or
adds
important
new
capabiliMes.
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
19
EXAMPLE:
KELLOGG’S
BRAND
PORTFOLIO
RE-‐EVALUATION
In
2012,
Kellogg’s
restructured
its
brand
porRolio
to
beper
leverage
its
master
brand,
acquired
stand-‐alone
brands
and
Olympics
sponsorship.
Stated
Reasons For
Revisiting Architecture
§ Acquired
new
brands
“We
had
to
start
separa7ng
out
the
Kellogg’s
brand
from
the
Kellogg
company
…Kellogg’s
is
a
truly
iconic
brand
…
§ Needed
to
elevate
Kellogg’s
We
felt
that
having
a
stronger
brand,
driving
a
stronger
corporate
brand
above
its
cereal
point
of
view,
a
more
powerful
iden7ty
and
have
at
the
master
brand
center
an
umbrella
to
talk
about
our
por@olio
more
§ Needed
to
strengthen
the
meaning
holis7cally,
to
talk
about
the
power
of
breakfast,
to
talk
of
the
Kellogg’s
brand
beyond
about
the
value
of
cereal.”
cereal
to
breakfast
§ Wanted
to
leverage
investment
in
2012
Olympics
to
benefit
all
Kellogg’s
sub-‐brands
http://www.forbes.com/sites/jenniferrooney/2012/05/10/kelloggs-embarks-on-major-brand-overhaul/
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
20
EVALUATING
ARCHITECTURE
OPTIONS
In
general,
we
evaluate
brand
architecture
from
a
handful
of
perspecMves.
For
example,
having
more
answers
to
the
lea
in
the
assessment
tool
suggests
leaning
toward
a
House
of
Brands
approach
is
best.
Architecture
Assessment
House
of
Brands
Branded
House
OrganizaIon
Product/service
brand
equity
Strong
equity
Low/no
equity
MarkeMng
spend
Supports
mulMple
brands
Supports
few
brands
Corporate
brand
equity
Low/negaMve
equity
Strong
equity
CompeIIon
CompeMMve
set
Fragmented
Consolidated
Stakeholders
Number
Many
Fewer
Customer
needs
Diverse
Singular
Cross-‐selling
opportuniMes
Low
High
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
21
BRAND
ARCHITECTURE
DEVELOPMENT
How
closely
aligned
How
aligned
are
external
What
are
the
various
Which
alterna7ve
best
are
the
brand
and
and
internal
percep7ons
ways
the
por@olio
fits
the
short
and
long-‐
business
strategies?
of
brands
and
their
could
be
configured
term
business
roles?
going
forward?
objec7ves?
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
22
REAL
WORLD
EXAMPLE:
McDONALD’S
CASE
STUDY
Using
the
arches,
color
palepe
and
“Mc”
to
idenMfy
and
link
most
of
its
offerings
to
the
master
brand,
it
is
a
prime
example
of
a
Branded
House
architecture.
http://mrktspnkr.wordpress.com/2012/06/29/brands-as-
identifiers-functional-and-symbolic-images/
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
23
McDONALD’S
CASE
STUDY:
TIMELINE
There
were
signs
of
trouble
starMng
in
the
late
1990’s,
as
business
lagged
and
new
products
failed.
The
low-‐fat
McLean
Record
number
of
Spun
off
Chipotle
in
U.S.
comp
store
Deluxe
and
Arch
franchisees
lea
2006
to
refocus
on
sales
slipped
1.7%
Deluxe
burgers,
the
system
in
core
hamburger
in
Q1
and
1.5%
in
meant
to
appeal
to
2002
business
Q2
of
2014
adults,
bombed
Sales
stagnated
In
an
effort
to
In
2004,
“Supersize
Salads
represent
only
2-‐3%
while
costs
regain
relevance,
Me”
brought
of
McDonald’s
sales
in
the
increased
as
the
McDonald’s
apenMon
to
what
United
States.
CEO
Don
product
offering
acquired
Chipotle
too
much
Thompson
admiped
“I
don’t
expanded/ Mexican
Grill
and
McDonald's
does
to
see
salads
as
being
a
major
became
more
Boston
Market
in
your
body
and
how
it
growth
driver
in
the
near
complex
1999
makes
you
feel.
future.”
(5/13)
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
24
McDONALD’S
CASE
STUDY:
STEP
1
How
closely
aligned
How
aligned
are
external
What
are
the
various
Which
architecture
are
the
brand
and
and
internal
percep7ons
ways
the
por@olio
alterna7ve
best
fits
business
strategies?
of
brands
and
their
could
be
configured
the
short
and
long-‐
roles?
going
forward?
term
business
objec7ves?
Focused
on
health-‐centric
global
ini7a7ves,
puQng
food
quality
first.
Marke7ng
now
organized
by
consumer
groups
such
as
millennials,
families
and
adults
rather
than
by
product.
Stepping
up
digital,
including
e-‐commerce,
fast-‐tracking
tes7ng
of
mobile
payments
and
ordering.
In
June
it
set
up
a
"learning
lab"
at
a
restaurant
in
Laguna
Niguel,
Calif.,
to
beZer
understand
what
people
want
and
to
experiment
with
customizable
burgers
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
25
McDONALD’S
CASE
STUDY:
STEP
2
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
26
McDONALD’S
CASE
STUDY:
STEP
3
How
closely
aligned
How
aligned
are
external
What
are
the
various
Which
architecture
are
the
brand
and
and
internal
percep7ons
ways
the
por@olio
alterna7ve
best
fits
business
strategies?
of
brands
and
their
could
be
configured
the
short
and
long-‐
roles?
going
forward?
term
business
and
brand
objec7ves?
Branded
House
approach
makes
it
difficult
to
change
percep7ons.
Consider
reserving
McDonalds
as
c
orporate
brand
and
build
equity
in
new
stand-‐alone
brands
and
sub-‐brands.
• Sub-‐brands
or
stand-‐alone
brands
for
Kids
or
Millennials
or
other
priority
McDonald’s
applied
for
a
new
targets
may
help
separate
new
ini7a7ves
from
current
offerings.
trademark
for
a
McBrunch
brand
in
September
2014
• New
digital
ini7a7ves
provide
a
pla@orm
for
a
new,
more
relevant
brand.
hpp://adage.com/arMcle/news/
mcdonald-‐s-‐files-‐trademark-‐mcbrunch/
294911/?
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
27
McDONALD’S
CASE
STUDY:
STEP
4
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
28
KEY
TAKEAWAYS
§ Architecture
aligns
business
and
brand
goals
by
defining
clear
roles,
relaMonships
and
investment
prioriMes
among
porRolio
brands.
§ A
coherent
brand
architecture
makes
markeMng
more
efficient
and
effecMve
by
ensuring
customers
and
other
stakeholders
understand
what
the
business
can
do
for
them.
§ House
of
Brands
and
Branded
House
are
just
two
of
many
possible
architecture
soluMons.
Most
companies
used
a
hybrid
approach.
A U G U S T
2 0 1 5
B R A N D
A M P L I T U D E ,
L L C
1.29
29
HOW
WE
CAN
HELP