Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
MUSIC 518
25 March 2020
Unit Study: An American Elegy by Frank Ticheli
Unit 1: Composer
Frank Ticheli's music has been described as being “optimistic and thoughtful" (Los
Angeles Times), “lean and muscular" (New York Times), “brilliantly effective" (Miami Herald)
and “powerful, deeply felt crafted with impressive flair and an ear for striking instrumental
colors" (South Florida Sun-Sentinel). Ticheli (b. 1958) joined the faculty of the University of
From 1991 to 1998, Ticheli was Composer in Residence of the Pacific Symphony.
Frank Ticheli's orchestral works have received considerable recognition in the U.S. and
Europe. Orchestral performances have come from the Philadelphia Orchestra, Atlanta
Symphony, Detroit Symphony, Dallas Symphony, American Composers Orchestra, the radio
orchestras of Stuttgart, Frankfurt, Saarbrucken, and Austria, and the orchestras of Austin,
Long Island, Louisville, Lubbock, Memphis, Nashville, Omaha, Phoenix, Portland, Richmond,
San Antonio, San Jose, Wichita Falls, and others. His clarinet concerto was recently recorded by
the Nashville Symphony on the Naxos label with soloist James Zimmermann.
Ticheli is well known for his works for concert band, many of which have become
standards in the repertoire. In addition to composing, he has appeared as guest conductor of his
music at Carnegie Hall, at many American universities and music festivals, and in cities
throughout the world, including Schladming (Austria), Beijing and Shanghai, London and
Academy of Arts and Letters, his third award from that prestigious organization. His Symphony
No. 2 was named winner of the 2006 NBA/William D. Revelli Memorial Band Composition
Contest. Other awards include the Walter Beeler Memorial Prize and First Prize awards in the
Composition Contest, and Virginia CBDNA Symposium for New Band Music.
In 2018, Ticheli received the University of Michigan Alumni Society’s highest honor, the
Hall of Fame Award, in recognition for his career as a composer. He was also awarded national
significantly contributed to the cause of music in America," and the A. Austin Harding Award by
the American School Band Directors Association, “given to individuals who have made
exceptional contributions to the school band movement in America." At USC, he has received
the Virginia Ramo Award for excellence in teaching, and the Dean's Award for Professional
Achievement.
Frank Ticheli received his doctoral and master’s degrees in composition from The
University of Michigan. His works are published by Manhattan Beach, Southern, Hinshaw, and
Encore Music, and are recorded on the labels of Albany, Chandos, Clarion, Equilibrium, Klavier,
Unit 2: Composition
An American Elegy by Frank Ticheli is a single movement work for concert band graded
as a level four piece. Over a span of 11 minutes, Ticheli expresses the emotions of loss, sorrow,
hope, and healing dealt with after the Columbine High School Massacre of 1999. An American
Elegy (2000) was commissioned by the Columbine Commissioning Fund, a special project
sponsored by the Alpha Iota Chapter of Kappa Kappa Psi at the University of Colorado on behalf
of the Columbine High School Band. Contributors to the Fund included members, chapters,
alumni, and friends of Kappa Kappa Psi and Tau Beta Sigma National Honorary Band Fraternity
and Sorority. The work received its premiere performance by the Columbine High School Band,
William Biskup, Director, Frank Ticheli, guest conductor, on April 23, 2000. Its premiere served
as the centerpiece of a special commemorative concert given by the Columbine High School
Band in conjunction with the University of Colorado Wind Symphony, held at Macky Hall in
Boulder, Colorado.
those who lost their lives at Columbine High School on April 20, 1999, and to honor the
survivors. It is offered as a tribute to their great strength and courage in the face of a terrible
tragedy. I hope the work can also serve as one reminder of how fragile and precious life is and
Frank Ticheli stated, “I was moved and honored by this commission invitation, and
deeply inspired by the circumstances surrounding it. Rarely has a work revealed itself to me with
such powerful speed and clarity. The first eight bars of the main melody came to me fully formed
in a dream. Virtually every element of the work was discovered within the span of about two
weeks. The remainder of my time was spent refining, developing, and orchestrating.”
The work begins at the bottom of the ensemble's register and ascends gradually to a
heartfelt cry of hope. The main theme that follows, stated by the horns, reveals a more lyrical,
serene side of the piece. A second theme, based on a simple repeated harmonic pattern, suggests
yet another, more poignant mood. These three moods - hope, serenity, and sadness - become
intertwined throughout the work, defining its complex expressive character. A four-part canon
builds to a climactic quotation of the Columbine Alma Mater. The music recedes, and an offstage
trumpeter is heard, suggesting a celestial voice - a heavenly message. The full ensemble returns
Unfortunately, our culture is not unfamiliar with the tragedies of school shootings. One of
these incidents was an “inspiration” to over 74 copycats around the nation for the most recent
shootings such as Sandy Hook, Parkland, and Virginia Tech (Guy, 2015). At Columbine High
School in Littleton, Colorado, two teens went on a shooting spree on April 20, 1999, killing 13
people and wounding more than 20 others before turning their guns on themselves and
committing suicide. The Columbine shooting was, at the time, the worst high school shooting in
U.S. history and prompted a national debate on gun control and school safety, as well as a major
investigation to determine what motivated the gunmen, Eric Harris, 18, and Dylan Klebold, 17
(History.com, 2009).
The Columbine effects have impacted the United States for the past 20 years. There have
been at least 143 people killed in school shootings and 11 mass school shootings since the
incident at Columbine High School. School security, police emergency procedures, weapon
laws, students with mental illness, and PTSD counseling services have all changed in regard to
the events that occurred on that day in 1999 (Shapiro, 2019). Some students from that day such
as Laura Farber have not been open to communicate about the massacre until this year. Now,
Farber and many others are pushing the national agenda toward gun restrictions and other related
the Columbine Commissioning Fund to compose a piece that commemorated the victims and
survivors. Travis Johnson explains the meaning of this commission in his dissertation:
The American Heritage Dictionary (Costello, 1997) defines elegy is “a poem or song
composed especially as a lament for a deceased person (p. 443).” As the title suggests An
American Elegy is a somber work that portrays the grief associated with the terrible
tragedy of the Columbine massacre. Despite the dark tone of the work, Ticheli (2000)
states that this work is “above all, an expression of hope.” (Johnson, 2010).
More background information and program notes of An American Elegy can be found in
An American Elegy demands high musical maturity of the ensemble. From intonation,
tone quality, balance, to dynamic control, Ticheli’s piece challenges the musicality and pureness
of tone in each individual. The musicians participating are stretched to play as they would as
soloists within the ensemble. This piece also requires excellent soloists in the trumpet, oboe,
horn, and alto saxophone sections. In addition, a strong horn and clarinet section is essential to
the introduction of the main theme from the horns and support of the melody and harmony
This work is fairly simple in its melodies, ranges, keys, and rhythmic structures.
However, if not executed with outstanding tone production, the effect and legacy of this piece
will not be as strong. It is important for the conductor to express and teach proper breathing,
phrasing, and listening. A solid foundation must be built delicately from the lower parts of the
ensemble to the upper woodwinds. Brass players should pay special attention to their balance in
regard to low woodwind voices in the clarinet and saxophone sections. Listening to one’s section
sound will be important in obtaining a unified sound throughout. Musicians will be familiar with
the conductor’s use of rubato adding elegance to the ends of phrases. This may be a challenge at
first, but clear communication from the podium and musical understanding from the musicians
An American Elegy features both sudden and gradual dynamic shifts. This piece will
challenge performers to gain control of their musical playing by changing phrase lengths and
timbre of each section. The entire piece builds up to a climax point in measures 111-113, which
quotes the Columbine High School Alma Mater, also written by Ticheli after this tragedy.
Afterwards, there are hopeful and triumphant sounding sections with great dynamic contrast. In
these final sections, an offstage trumpet soloist symbolizes the ethereal voices of the victims and
Notes from Frank Ticheli express that, “An American Elegy is not a reflection of anger
towards the Columbine incident; instead it represents the healing process after significant
tragedy. Three different moods are presented during the piece. Hope, serenity, and sadness are at
the heart of the work, and all three provide the ensemble, conductor, and audience with the
opportunity to explore the relationship between music and our emotions” (Johnson, 2010). The
most important stylistic consideration for this piece is the amount of emotional value every
measure should hold. This is essential for the conductor to analyze and express, as well as the
Throughout the work, there are groupings of four eighth or sixteenth notes within the
melody and harmony parts. Every beginning of these should have substantial weight and feeling.
This is a common theme with all accented parts in this piece. Weight represents the sadness and
love for each of the victims in this incident and must be represented properly. With this weight
comes the connection in between phrases. There is hardly a moment of silence until the end of
this piece, which means that each section must plan to sustain all legato phrases to their full
values.
To understand the emotion and style needed to play this piece to its fullest, the conductor
should communicate to the ensemble the history and meaning behind this piece frequently. An
ensemble will not fully be able to grasp the appropriate emotion associated with this music
without this understanding. Ticheli’s score notes on the emotional content of each section can be
1. Melody
The melody is passed among all of the wind sections in the band throughout. It is
introduced in the low register of the horn section in the opening measures and closed with
a solo from a horn in its middle range. Most frequently, the melody is played by the
horns, clarinets, saxophones, and flutes. The trumpets are added into the melodic voices
at the climactic and hopeful sections of the piece. The melody in the upper winds is
delicately balanced by low drones from the low brass. This melody hints at the
Columbine High School Alma Mater, specifically at the lyrics of “We are Columbine.”
Occasionally, the melody seems similar to Ticheli’s Shenandoah and Amazing Grace.
The melody is reminiscent of a chorale and has themes of hope, serenity, and sadness.
2. Harmony
Most of the harmony parts are maintained by the low brass, low woodwinds,
timpani, string bass, and vibraphone. These voices heavily support the phrasing and
cadences of the melody. According to Johnson, “Strong cadences are avoided throughout
the work, and small pieces of connecting material bring the different sections together. In
his own interpretation of the work, Ticheli states that staying away from the tonic in
many instances allows him to propel the piece forward and build a sense of anticipation
tension, pain, and the sense of healing to the music” (Johnson, 2010).
3. Rhythm
The rhythmic structure and motifs of An American Elegy are fairly simple. This
simplicity adds to the layers of delicateness in the melodic lines. As mentioned in Unit 5:
Stylistic Considerations, there are groupings of four eighth or sixteenth notes that provide
weight and emotion to the melodic parts. Other than these groupings, there is one other
moment in the piece that explores outside of half, whole, and quarter notes. At the climax
section in measurers 111-113, the Columbine Alma Mater is directly quoted. There is a
triplet feel on beats three and four of measure 112, despite being written as sixteenth
notes. Several instances of rubato are used to elongate the ends of phrases and stretch as
4. Timbre
expressively as soloists during exposed parts. The piece gradually builds from the low
ranges of all instruments to the middle and upper ranges toward the climax and final main
theme statement. The low woodwinds, clarinets, and saxophones play almost
continuously throughout the work. These instruments have the capability to easily blend
into the background or shine in the foreground, which makes them an excellent option for
Ticheli’s main focus. Whenever the high brass voices are brought in, the overall emotion
of that section changes to hope, healing, and triumph. Rarely is the entire ensemble
playing simultaneously. These moments are reserved for the climax points and phrases
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ieNYOAmi65o
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5jobe6a8uq0
“An American Elegy for Concert Band.” An American Elegy by Frank Ticheli, Manhattan Beach
Music,
www.manhattanbeachmusiconline.com/frank_ticheli/html/an_american_elegy.html.
Cullen, Dave. “At Last We Know Why the Columbine Killers Did It.” Slate Magazine, Slate, 20
columbine-killers-did-it.html.
Farber, Laura. “It Took Me 20 Years to Finally Talk about Surviving the Columbine High
www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/voices/2019/04/18/columbine-shooting-anniversary-
school-massacre-column/3473084002/.
California, www.music.usc.edu/frank-ticheli/.
“Frank Ticheli's ‘American Elegy’ Continues to Have Impact.” USC Thornton School of Music,
american-elegy-continues-to-have-impact/.
Guy, Fiona. “The Columbine Effect and Mass School Shootings.” Crime Traveller, Crime
effect/.
2009, www.history.com/topics/1990s/columbine-high-school-shootings.
Johnson, Travis. An Examination of the Works of Flourish for Wind Band by Ralph Vaughan
Williams, Air for Band by Frank Erickson, An American Elegy by Frank Ticheli, Rough
state.edu/dspace/bitstream/handle/2097/4586/travisjohnson2010.pdf?sequence=1.
Shapiro, Emily. “20 Years after Columbine, What's Changed -- and What Hasn't -- for School
www.abcnews.go.com/US/20-years-columbine-changed-school-shootings-america/story?
id=62248885.
www.manhattanbeachmusiconline.com/frank_ticheli/biography.html.