Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
The paper presents a kinematical model enabling the analysis of mandibular motion in a sagittal plane. Based on the recorded tra-
jectories of incisors, the configuration coordinates were identified. The configuration coordinates explicitly identify the position and
orientation of the mandible during motion. Such values are basic to the evaluation of alteration in muscle length and to the orientation of
forces in particular muscles. This paper also deals with the influence of the coefficients of the weight matrix on the character of the solu-
tions of the configuration coordinates applied in the model study of the kinematical chain. The results of the numerical calculations ob-
tained demonstrated that the trajectory representation was in a considerable concordance with the data recorded.
______________________________
* Corresponding author: Wiesław Chladek, Research Group for Medical Engineering, Silesian Technical University, ul. Krasiń-
skiego 8, 40-019 Katowice, Poland. E-mail: chladekw@interia.pl
Received: May 23, 2007
Accepted for publication: October 16, 2007
10 J. MARGIELEWICZ et al.
tors increases together with the experience of a re- characteristic points most frequently chosen are those
searcher [13]. The data recorded should be further proc- placed between the two bottom incisors, i.e., the inci-
essed, regardless of the diagnostic devices applied, in sion point and points located in the surrounding area
order to carry out a kinematical analysis and should be of the centre of the mandible head. An exact location
adjusted to a numerical experiment. Only the combina- of the characteristic point enables the definition of
tion of clinical trial and numerical study can provide us mandible orientation in selected time intervals. During
with comprehensive information on a functional behav- the analysis of recorded trajectories the limiting posi-
iour of mandible. Mandibular kinematics can be consid- tions, named border positions, are observed. The
ered in two ways [3], [4], [7]. The first one is by plotting characteristic feature of such positions is their repeat-
the trajectory for selected points at given configuration ability. The repeatability of limiting trajectories
coordinates (direct kinematics task). The second way proves to be one of the criteria fundamental to the
consists in the plotting of configuration coordinates application of a mathematical model in clinical diag-
based on a given trajectory (inverse kinematics task). nostics. The mandible, when dislocating within the
The configuration of the kinematical chain can be identi- maximum achieveable range of positions, follows
fied by means of several methods, i.e., analytical meth- a path defined as a limiting trajectory. The limiting
ods, numerical methods or neural networks. Each of the trajectory defines a working space within which free
above-mentioned methods has its advantages and disad- and functional motions are performed. The recorded
vantages. The major disadvantage of neural networks is trajectories of free and functional motions, in contrast
the need for the preparation of training data. An appro- with the limiting motions, are not required to be re-
priate preparation of such data is a time-consuming and peatable. Generally speaking, there are three basic
laborious process, and the efficiency of identification of motions performed in the temporomandibular joints:
the kinematical chain depends substantially on the neural • Abduction and elevation.
network ‘training’. Therefore, the application of neural • Protraction and retraction.
networks in the diagnostics of mandible kinematics is • Rotations in a horizontal plane.
considered to be inefficient. The solutions derived from
analytical method provide the most substantial benefits.
However, these methods have also some disadvantages.
The main one is the lack of the possibility of obtaining
unique explicit solutions. Despite a considerably long
time required for calculations compared with analytical
methods, this drawback does not appear to be highly
important in mandibular kinematics. Therefore, the
model study of mandibular kinematics demonstrated in
this paper applied the aforesaid numerical methods.
2. Biomechanics of
mandibular motions
performed, is not a fixed axis. The axis of rotation rotation axis crosses the central points of the heads.
intersects the mandible heads and is located in close The actual shape of the trajectory plotted by the inci-
proximity to their central points. Concurrently with sion point of the mandible differs from the shape
a gradual increase in mandibular opening, the axis demonstrated in figure 2. The trajectory represents an
dislocates in anterior direction. Additionally, the mo- ideal state of the stomatognathic system.
tion of mandible heads in temporomandibular joints is Theoretically, a purely rotary motion can occur in
considerably influenced by the joint geometry as well any position of the mandible heads. A necessary condi-
as by the susceptibility of intra-articular discs. The tion for such a motion is a stable constant position of
model of mandibular head position in a socket during axis about which the mandible rotates. The first stage of
abduction and adduction is demonstrated in figure 1. limiting motion during posterior opening is performed
During mandible abduction the intra-articular discs until the dislocation angle of the mandible attains the
slide in a socket in anterior direction. Concurrently, value of ca. 10°. Further abduction is connected with the
the mandible heads are dislocated towards the inferior second stage (figure 2, curve 2). At this stage of motion
surface of the articular tubercle. Such a motion is de- the rotary axis is dislocated in an anterio-inferior direc-
fined in specialist literature as rotary sliding. The tion. The abduction of the mandible during the second
range of dislocations of mandible heads is limited by stage of motion is performed until the widest opening is
the anatomy of joints, ligaments and joint capsules. reached. The limiting motion during anterior opening
The element responsible for mandible abduction is represented by curve 3 (figure 2) is clearly determined
a suprahyoid muscle which, when the hyoid bone is by two terminal positions representing maximum pro-
immobilized, causes its abduction. Abduction is en- traction and opening. Theoretically, when the mandible
hanced by gravitational force. For the elevation and heads are not subjected to linear dislocations and are
occlusion of dental arches the temporomandibular stable during the occlusion of dental arches, the transpo-
muscles are of primary importance. Essential charac- sition from the maximum opening to the position of
teristics of mandible heads and the mandible itself are maximum protraction of the mandible would be per-
obtained as a result of applying dental diagnostic de- formed as a purely rotary motion. However, the maxi-
vices. Such devices allow the mandibular motions to mum protraction of the mandible is affected to some
be recorded in three planes. The recording of mandi- extent by the stylomandibular ligaments which, during
ble trajectory in the sagittal plane is performed in or- occlusion of the dental arches, retract the mandible
der to identify the following basic stages of motion: heads. Accordingly, the limiting motion during anterior
• Limiting motion during posterior opening. opening fails to be performed as purely rotary motion.
• Limiting motion during anterior opening. Thus, it may be inferred that the mandible heads attain
• Limiting motion during mandible protraction the most anterior position during maximum opening, but
with occlusal contacts. not during its maximum protraction. The limiting motion
due to mandible protraction with occlusal contacts (fig-
ure 2, curve 4) is determined by the following factors
[13]:
• Range of the difference between the posterior
occlusal position and the maximum protraction of the
mandible (maximum mandible intercuspation).
• Geometry of the cusps of posterior molar teeth.
• Occlusion of the incisors of the mandible and
maxilla in the sagittal and horizontal planes.
• Geometry of the palatal surface of the anterior
maxillary teeth.
• State of dentition within dental arches.
The protraction of the mandible in the sagittal
Fig. 2. Mandibular trajectory in the sagittal plane plane is a result of the contraction of the lateral ptery-
goid muscles. During the anterior protraction of the
Limiting motion during posterior opening is per- mandible a slight drop in the recorded trajectory is
formed in two stages. In the first stage, the mandible observed. The drop results from the alignment of the
heads are in fovea articularis. In such a case, the ab- mandibular incisors with respect to the maxillary inci-
duction of the mandible can be sufficiently precisely sors (figure 3). The posterior filaments of the temporal
described by rotary motion (figure 2, curve 1), and the muscles assist in the retraction of mandible.
12 J. MARGIELEWICZ et al.
preted in two ways. In the first interpretation, the problems lying in the choice of an optimal configura-
model represents the actual position of mandibular tion. The number of configuration solutions depend on
incisors in the sagittal plane (the point B in figure 4). the number of kinematical pairs in the mechanism
Then, the point A, representing the motion of mandi- which models a given motion and, additionally, is the
ble head, is the result of the projection onto the plane function of geometric parameters. Theoretically, there
on which the motion is analysed. In the second inter- are three situations to be considered which may occur
pretation, the situation is inverse, i.e., the point A rep- during the solution of an inverse kinematical task [4]:
resents the actual motion of the mandible head, • The dimension of a one-column matrix of con-
whereas the point B is the result of projection. The figuration coordinates is smaller than the magnitude
fact that the numerical models represent the ideal me- of the location vector. The number of the degrees of
chanical states of the mandible should, however, be freedom in such a system are not sufficient. An in-
taken into consideration. A conscious idealization of verse kinematical task can only be solved in specific
motion in temporomandibular joints incorporated in cases.
such a way is based on the assumption that the ge- • The dimension of a one-column matrix of con-
ometry of both joints is the same. The application of figuration coordinates is equal to the magnitude of the
matrix notation in the analysis of mandibular kine- location vector. In such a case, the number of the de-
matics allows the definition of the location of any of grees of freedom correspond with a neighbourhood
its points, with an explicit definition of its orientation vector. The solution of an inverse task is explicitly
with respect to a static reference system. By means of possible.
the superposition of elementary relocations of the • The dimension of a one-column matrix of con-
local reference systems, the following dependence is figuration coordinates is greater than the magnitude of
derived: the location vector. The kinematical chain has a higher
number of the degrees of freedom than necessary to
c12 − s12 0 c1q + c12l
s realize a given task. The solution of an inverse kine-
0 12 c12 0 s1q + s12l matical task is an infinite set of configurations.
T = , (1)
B
0 0 1 0 The solutions obtained from numerical methods are
based on the Jacobian matrix [3], [4]. This matrix (2) is
0 0 1 1
achieved by the differentiation of the location vector
where: with respect to configuration coordinates. A Jacobian,
q – the length of the segment OA, also named the Jacobian matrix, is one of the most
l – the length of the segment AB, important quantities applied in the analysis and steer-
c12 = c1c2 – s1s2, s12 = c1s2 + c2s1. ing of the mechanisms with an open-structure kine-
In dependence (1), the first three rows and col- matical chain. It is applied, among other things, to the
umns represent an orientation matrix, and the fourth design and realization of smooth trajectories as well as
column is interpreted as a location vector. A mathe- to the identification of singular configurations.
matical model of mandible motion in the sagittal plane
formulated in such a way is a ground for research on ∂x ∂x ∂x
...
∂ϕ1 ∂ϕ 2 ∂ϕ i
inverse kinematics. Generalized coordinates deter-
mining the configuration of the mandibular model for ∂y ∂y ∂y
J= ... . (2)
quasi-static positions result from kinematical task ∂ϕ1 ∂ϕ 2 ∂ϕ i
formulated in such a way. One should not overlook ∂z ∂z ∂z
the fact that solving an inverse task they have only the ...
∂ϕ1 ∂ϕ 2 ∂ϕ i
data for the structure of the model, geometrical pa-
rameters and trajectory coordinates. From the mathe- The configuration coordinates of an open kine-
matical point of view the solution of an inverse kine- matical chain (figure 4) realizing a given trajectory are
matical task entails specific difficulties which make determined based on the following iterative equation:
the explicit configuration of a kinematical chain im-
possible. Such ambiguities always occur in the case of q i +1 = q i + J −P1 (q i ) ⋅ (Pi +1 − Pi ) , (3)
redundant systems, i.e., systems with more degrees of
freedom than necessary to attain a required position. where:
Practically, this means that the system can realize qi – the configuration coordinates,
a given trajectory for numerous configurations. The Pi – the trajectory coordinates,
possibility of numerous solutions can also pose the J −P1 – the pseudoinverse Jacobian matrix.
14 J. MARGIELEWICZ et al.
The pseudoinverse Jacobian matrix is deter- of the recorded trajectory into a numerical form. Al-
mined when the model of the system studied is redun- though such an operation does not provide any new
dant, i.e., when the Jacobian matrix is not a square information about the trajectory, it may, however,
matrix: result in the loss or deformation of information. The
processing of a trajectory into a numerical form is
J −P1 = J T ⋅ (J ⋅ J T ) −1 . (4) usually defined as discretization. Trajectory discreti-
zation consists in the selection of the discrete posi-
Dependence (4) is a specific case of the following
tions in which the trajectory projections onto par-
equation, assuming that the weight matrix W attains
ticular axes of a global reference system are specified.
the form of an identity matrix:
A discrete series of trajectory values should fulfill
J −P1 = W −1 ⋅ J T (J ⋅ W −1 ⋅ J T ) −1 . (5) a basic criterion of conformity. Such a criterion con-
cerns the possibility of reproducing its actual shape
The weight matrix W in (5) is a diagonal matrix based on discreted samples. If the interval between the
interpreted as the limits imposed on the motion in discreted samples is incorrectly established, then a pre-
particular kinematical pairs. With an increase in cise reproduction of the trajectory is impossible. Such
weight coefficient the motion in a kinematical pair inaccuracies most frequently appear as attenuated
is subject to limitations. A graphic interpretation of oscillations after applying an evolution to the trigo-
the influence of the weight matrix on the type of nometric series. The oscillations mostly occur near the
motion of the kinematical chain is demonstrated in limiting positions of the mandible. When the period of
figure 5. trajectory sampling is too long, a phenomenon defined
Equation (3) is a general recurrent algorithm ena- in the theory of signals as frequency masking or
bling the numerical solution of an inverse kinematical aliasing may occur [2], [10]. It should be noted here
task. In simulated calculations of this type of task, one that although the aliasing does not have to occur, such
should use stable numerical methods, or adequately a phenomenon should always be taken into considera-
low frequencies of trajectory sampling, because the tion.
errors occurring during its processing have the fea- When there is no digital record of a trajectory, the
tures of systematic errors which, as a consequence, trajectory has to be discreted manually which is a time-
lead to an imprecise representation of a given trajec- consuming process. However, the time required for
tory by the kinematical chain. the discretization of the trajectory can be reduced by
interpolation (figure 6a). Interpolation consists in the
generation of a full line [9], [14] which crosses the
4. Numerical experiment discreted values defined as the interpolation nodes.
Interpolation allows the prediction of the values be-
tween the interpolation nodes. One of the interpolation
The basic action allowing one to carry out a nu- methods is the application of the Lagrange interpola-
merical study in inverse kinematics is the processing tion polynomial:
Kinematical analysis of mandibular motion in a sagittal plane 15
n where:
∏ (x − x )
j =0
j ai, bi, ci, di, ei, fi – the Euler–Fourier coefficients,
n
n – the number of measurement points,
L ( x) = ∑ j ≠i
n
⋅ yi . (6)
t – the time or number of a sample.
i =0
∏ (x − x )
j =0
i j Figures 7 and 8 demonstrate the influence of the
j ≠i quantity of data for discreted trajectory on the quality
of approximation.
The curve generated in this way is subjected to fur- The availability of the continuous functions of tra-
ther numerical discretization at a new and higher sam- jectory coordinates allows for the possibility of defin-
pling frequency. This allows a trajectory with a higher ing the values for the configuration of a mandibular
number of discrete values to be obtained (figure 6b). model (figure 4). The configuration coordinates are
a) b)
Fig. 6. Discretization of a mandibular trajectory: a) before the interpolation of the trajectory, b) after interpolation
Furthermore, the values of new trajectory are equally derived from equation (3), where a pseudoinverse Ja-
distant from each other. Another way enabling us to cobian matrix has been determined from dependence
obtain an increased number of trajectory coordinates is (5). The same results are obtained by the application of
the application of approximation methods. For that pur- dependence (4), assuming that the weight matrix is an
pose, the individual components of a trajectory are ap- identity matrix. It should be emphasized that the itera-
proximated by straight lines or parabolas. Owing to the tion algorithm applied in kinematical modelling is effi-
fact that characteristic points of mandible move on cient, which is proved by the precise representation of
closed paths, the best method for trajectory approxima- a given trajectory (figure 9). A representation error for
tion is by evolving it into a trigonometric series (7). In the trajectory is demonstrated in figure 10.
order to apply efficiently the numerical set of values of The influence of the weight matrix coefficients on
trajectory coordinates, this set is processed in a way the type of the solution of the kinematical chain is
aimed at obtaining modified trajectory components in shown in figures 11–13.
the form of an explicit function. The use of explicit The basic criterion that should be assumed in the
functions in numerical calculations is more convenient evaluation of the results obtained is the periodicity of the
than calculations carried out on a discreted measurement solution. This criterion must be fulfilled, because each
series: position of the mandible that performs a limiting trajec-
tory is repeatable. The selection of weight matrix coef-
a1 n
∑
x(t ) = + [ai +1 cos(i ⋅ t ) + bi +1 sin(i ⋅ t )] ,
2 i =1
ficients is crucial for this type of trajectory of the man-
dibular head, and the determined configuration coordi-
c1 n nates are essential for its identification (figure 14).
y ( t ) = ∑
+ [ci +1 cos(i ⋅ t ) + d i +1 sin(i ⋅ t )] ,
2 i =1
(7) The results obtained from numerical calculations
of inverse kinematics will be incorporated in future
e1 n
z (t ) = ∑
+ [ei +1 cos(i ⋅ t ) + f i +1 sin(i ⋅ t )] ,
2 i =1
computer simulations as the steering values in a dynamic
mandibular model.
16 J. MARGIELEWICZ et al.
Fig. 14. Results of numerical calculations; trajectories of the central point of the mandibular head