Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
H O L D
15 July, 2010
MindTree Ltd
Key Data (INR)
We initiate coverage on MindTree Ltd. (MTL) with “Hold” recommendation and
CMP 573
price target of INR588 per share. We are valuing IT service business at INR578 per
Target Price 588
share by assigning 12 P/E (i.e. 40% discount to Infosys’s target P/E multiple of 20)
Key Data multiple to its FY12E EPS of INR48.2 and Smart-phone business at INR10 per share
Bloomberg Code MTCL IN by assigning 5 P/E (i.e. ~40% discount to Research In Motion’s forward P/E multiple of
Reuters Code MINT.BO
8.2) multiple to its FY12E EPS of INR1.9. We expect, MTL’s IT service business will
BSE Code 532819
underperform tier I Indian IT companies (in terms of revenue growth) over the span of
NSE Code MINDTREE
next two years i.e. from FY10 to FY12E because of its relatively higher dependence on
Face Value (INR) 10
traditional service lines. Further, we expect IT service earnings CAGR to be negative
Market Cap. (INR Bn.) 22.5
over the period of FY10 to FY12E due to relatively lower reversal of mark-to-market
forex provision, increase in tax rate, decline in utilization rate and double digit wage
52 Week High (INR) 729
inflation pressure for offshore based employees. In case of smart-phone business we
52 Week Low (INR) 423
have assumed MTL will capture 1% market of android-based phones in US and India
Avg. Daily Volume (6m) 92039
and net profit margin will be around 12% (assuming 25% lower margin compared to
leading player such as ‘Research In Motion’).
Shareholding %
Promoters 32.4 Investment Rationale
Mutual Funds / Bank/ FI 15.6 ● Revenue growth will continue to lag tier I Indian IT players in FY11E and
Foreign Institutional Investors 9.6 FY12E
Bodies Corporate/Individuals/others 42.4 MTL has relatively higher exposure to traditional service lines (i.e. application
Total 100 development and maintenance-ADM) among its peer sets. Indian IT industry has
INR mn FY10 FY11E FY12E
captured nearly 1/3rd global market in these service lines and in coming years
Revenues 12,959.8 14,976.0 18,105.1
growth opportunity for Indian IT companies in ADM is expected to be almost
Operating Income 2,455.6 2,247.7 3,026.4 half of that in emerging IT service lines. On account of MTL higher dependence
Net Profit 2,148.4 1,637.1 1,981.3 on ADM space and lack of scale in emerging service lines (such as ERP, IMS
Net Profit Margins 16.6% 10.9% 10.9% and BPO), we expect its revenue growth will lag that of tier I Indian IT players
EPS (INR.) 54.4 41.4 50.1 over the span of next two years.
Book value (INR) 169.7 207.6 254.2 ● Ventured into smart-phone business
MTL has entered into smart-phone space after acquiring Kyocera Wireless (India)
Pvt. Ltd. (KWIL) in October 2009. Phone will be sold on fixed margin basis to
telecom service provider or mobile phone vendor. At present it’s working on one
model and plans to spend around USD11 million on building the product. We
expect, smart-phone business will drag overall return ratio of the company, as
this business being competitive and products have low-shelf life.
● Pressure building on operating margin
MTL has one of the highest offshore effort mix among its peer and hence it will
be the most impacted in the scenario of double-digit wage inflation for offshore-
based employees. Further, the company is currently operating at near peak
utilization rate (including trainees) and employees under training are close to the
bottom level. Whereas, employee attrition rate is expected to be around 20% (on
annualized basis) in 1Q FY11. We expect, the utilization (including trainees) to
come down to 68% in FY12 from 71% in 4Q FY10, which is more or less in with
Analyst the management expectation of around 67%-68%. Taking into account, double
Hardik Shah digit wage inflation (for offshore based employees) and dip in utilization rate,
research@acm.co.in going forward, operating margin will be under pressure.
Tel: (022) 2858 3409
Company background
MindTree Ltd. (MTL), incorporated in 1999 by ten IT professionals, provides end-to-
end IT services. The company has a team of 8300 professionals serving 258 clients
across geographies and industries.
Business model
MTL has presence across service lines i.e. traditional service lines as well as emerging
service lines. Within emerging service lines it offers consulting, ERP implementation,
testing and infrastructure management services (IMS). The company has recently
forayed into knowledge process outsourcing (KPO), however so far it has been unable
to make any significant headway in this space.
Revenue by service-line wise in FY10
18% 4%
4%
3%
71%
80% 18%
17.4%
72%
70% 17%
65%
60% 16%
20% 12%
HCL Tech Wipro Infosys TCS Hexaware Patni Mindtree Mindtree (excl. TES-PV, Aztecsoft & Kyocera) Indian IT industry (excl. Hardware)
II. Adopted inorganic route for diversifying into emerging service lines
The company has adopted ‘string of pearls’ acquisition strategy to diversify from
traditional service lines to emerging areas.
Service line Company acquired Year of Purchase consideration
acquisition (in INR mn)
ERP ASAP Solutions Pvt. Ltd. FY05 32
Linc Software Services Pvt. Ltd. FY06 306
Product engineering TES-Purple Vision FY08 259
Testing Aztec soft Ltd. FY09 3194
Smart-phone business Kyocera Wireless India Pvt. Ltd. FY10 436
Infrastructure Management 7Strata FY11 72
Services (IMS)
Source- Company and ACMIIL Research.
15%
10%
6%
5%
5% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 3% 3%
4%
3% 3% 3%
2%
0%
Consulting & IP Licensing ERP Testing IMS
FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10
Source: Company and ACMIIL Research
30.0
5%
50 20.0
-2% 0% 13.2
12.7 12.9 10.0
0 -5% -
Mindtree Wipro
Without Aztecsoft acquisition Including Aztecsoft acquisition
In 4Q FY10 In 4Q FY09 YoY growth
We are assuming, MTL will be able to garner around 1% market share of total
market for android based phone within one year of launch i.e. FY12E and net
margin will be around 12% (assuming 25% lower margin compared to leading
player such as ‘Research In Motion’). Taking same into account net profit from
smart-phone business will be INR76 mn in FY12E. Assuming investment of
around $11 mn and net profit of INR76 mn the return ratio will be around 16%
for the smart-phone business as compared to return ratio of around 20% for IT
service business.
Impact of change in market share and net margins on net profit from smart-phone business in FY12E
Market share
Net Profit (in INR mn) 0.50% 0.75% 1.00% 1.25% 1.50%
10.0% 31.7 47.5 63.4 79.2 95.1
Net margins 11.0% 34.9 52.3 69.7 87.1 104.6
12.0% 38.0 57.0 76.0 95.1 114.1
13.0% 41.2 61.8 82.4 103.0 123.6
14.0% 44.4 66.5 88.7 110.9 133.1
Source- ACMIIL Research.
Concern
● Possibility of significant decline in business from Kyocera Group
MTL acquired Kyocera Wireless (India) Pvt. Ltd. (KWIL) from Kyocera Wireless
Corporation (KWC) for around USD6 million. KWIL was captive division of
KWC and had revenue of around USD18 million p.a. and net margin of around
15%. We believe KWIL was acquired at throwaway valuation of around 2.2x
P/E (assuming revenue of USD18 million p.a. and net margin of 15%). However,
lower valuation is justified to an extent because there is no revenue commitment
from KWC (normally in case of captive acquisition parent company gives revenue
commitment- case in point is CGSL acquisition by TCS from Citi along with
ten years revenue commitment by Citi). Lower valuation and lack of revenue
commitment point towards possibility of scaling down of business by KWC.
This is further corroborated by 3.4% (QoQ) decline in revenue from KWC in 4Q
FY10 and MTL has shifted around 200 employees of KWIL for the development
of smart phone.
● Aggressive accounting policy
MTL follows the practice of setting off the goodwill arising on amalgamation
against the securities premium account. However, prudent accounting treatment
requires amortization of goodwill through profit and loss account over the span
of five years. In comparison to standard accounting practice of amortization
of goodwill, the accounting policy followed by the company has inflated both
earnings and return ratios of the company.
Companies amalgamated with MTL Amount adjusted against securities Financial Year
premium a/c (in INR mn)
Linc Software Services Pvt. Ltd. 251.7 FY07
TES-Purple Vision 214.3 FY09
Aztec soft Ltd. 1407.2 FY10
Source- Company and ACMIIL Research
90% 88.6%
80%
77.4%
73.8% 74.8%
72.2%
70% 68.2%
60%
Hexaware HCL Tech Wipro Patni Infosys Mindtree
● High attrition rate will create pressure on current peak utilization rate
MTL is currently operating at near peak utilization rate (including trainees).
Further, employees under training are close to the bottom level. Whereas, employee
attrition rate is expected to be around 20% (on annualized basis) in 1Q FY11.
We believe the company will increase number of people under training to take
benefit of improvement in environment and to reduce pressure on bench strength
caused by the high attrition rate. We expect, utilization (including trainees) to come
down to 68% in FY12 from 71% in 4Q FY10, which is more or less in with the
management expectation of around 67%-68%.
75% 8% 9%
70% 71% 71%
7% 70%
70%
65% 66% 65%
63% 65% 6%
65%
62% 61%
60%
4%
60%
3% 3%
2% 2% 2%
55% 1% 1%
0% 1%
0%
50% 0%
1QFY09
2QFY09
3QFY09
4QFY09
1QFY08
2QFY08
3QFY08
4QFY08
1QFY10
2QFY10
3QFY10
4QFY10
Utilization rate (incl. Trainees) % of employees under training
Financials
● Breakup of revenue by geography and vertical wise
MTL derives 63% of its revenue from US geography, however around 80% of its
revenue is billed in US Dollar. Whereas, Europe revenue share is 19% but only
7% of its revenue is billed in Euro and British Pound. At the end of 4Q FY10 its
outstanding hedge position was around US$158 million at a weighted average
rate of 45.8 for FY11 and US$70 million for FY12 and FY13.
Revenue by geography in 4Q FY10
12%
6% Rest of World
India
19%
Europe 63%
US
MTL lacks significant scale (i.e. US$50 mn plus per annum) in any of its verticals,
except software product engineering that has further sub-segments. We believe
the small size in each vertical will hamper company’s ability to bid for large
projects having bare minimum scale requirement. Going forward, these will
adversely impact the company’s ability to outperform Tier I Indian IT players
inspite of its smaller size.
Revenue by vertical in FY10
80 28% 30%
60
17% 20%
14% 14%
40 13% 77.0
10%
10%
20 46.7 39.3 3%
34.5 37.9
27.5
9.3
0 0%
Mfg. BFSI Travel R&D SPE NIW Others
In USD mn As % of sales
Source: Company and ACMIIL Research, Note-SPE stands for Software Product
Engineering and NIW stands for Next In Wireless
0% 35
1Q FY09 2Q FY09 3Q FY09 4Q FY09 1Q FY10 2Q FY10 3Q FY10 4Q FY10
57 27
55 25
2QFY09 3QFY09 4QFY09 1QFY10 2QFY10 3QFY10 4QFY10 2Q FY09 3Q FY09 4Q FY09 1Q FY10 2Q FY10 *3Q FY10 *4Q FY10
Clients contributing more than USD1 mn Revenue from top 10 clients (in USD mn)
Source: Company and ACMIIL Research, Note –*We have excluded impact of Kyocera acquisition
Decline in number of one million plus clients in 4Q FY10 (YoY) and lower
revenue flow from the top 10 clients (in USD mn) in 4Q FY10 (compared to peak
level in 2Q FY09) indicates that the company is not able to mine clients, despite
significant improvement in environment in FY10 over FY09. We believe that
company’s lack of scale in non-ADM space is hampering its ability to increase
wallet share in clients’ IT budget and the same is reflected from MTL relatively
lower revenue per active client compared to peers.
Revenue per active client in 4Q FY10 (in USD 000's)
2,500
2,254
2,000 1,839
1,696
1,500 1,380
1,000
663
500
312 289
-
Infosys TCS HCL Tech Wipro Patni Hexaware Mindtree
Ratios
Particulars FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 E FY12 E
Profitability Ratios
Operating profit margin 16.9% 26.7% 18.9% 15.0% 16.7%
PAT Margin 14.0% 4.2% 16.6% 10.9% 10.9%
RONW 19.4% 9.5% 32.0% 20.0% 19.7%
ROCE 18.8% 10.6% 38.2% 24.0% 24.3%
Per Share
Earnings (INR) 27.2 13.8 54.4 41.4 50.1
Book Value (INR) 140.6 145.1 169.7 207.6 254.2
Growth Ratios
Revenue 25.3% 67.1% 4.8% 15.6% 20.9%
Operating profit 14.4% 163.5% -25.7% -8.5% 34.6%
Net profit 14.7% -49.4% 311.2% -23.8% 21.0%
Source: ACMIIL Research.
Industry Outlook
● Spurt in global IT spends in CY10
The global IT spending, which has a positive correlation with GDP of developed
economies, is expected to grow in 2010 (by 2.4%) and 2011 (by 4.2%) along with
expected momentum in developed economies’ GDP over the next two after years
after declining in 2009 (Source-NASSCOM).
Real GDP in local currency (% chg YoY)
3%
2%
2% 2% 2%
1%
1% 1% 1% 1% 1%
0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
0%
-1% -1% -1%
-1%
-2%
-3% -2% -3% -3%
-4% -4%
-5% -4%
-5% -5%
-6% -5%
Germany UK* France Italy Spain Japan* Canada* US*
2008 2009† 2010†
Source: IMF and ACMIIL Research
In USD Bn
10%
150 175
8%
100 125 6%
4%
50
2%
0 0%
Low demand Domestic factors constrain India retains Innovation drives
constrains growth growth (Likely scenario) competitiveness growth
US$ billion (LHS) CAGR % FY09-FY20 (RHS)
Source: NASSCOM-Mckinsey
Growth is expected to come from new geographies (BRIC countries), customer segments
(SME), and verticals in developed countries (public sector, utilities and healthcare) as
well as the core market (Fortune 1000 companies based in developed economies).
Domestic IT market in FY2020-different scenarios
70 17% 18%
17%
65 17%
60 16%
16%
55 15%
14% 65 15%
50 14%
45 50 14%
13%
40 13%
Constrained growth (Likely scenario) High growth
US$ billion (LHS) CAGR % FY09-FY20 (RHS)
Source: NASSCOM-Mckinsey
The domestic IT market is expected to expand ~5x by FY20, mainly driven by economic
growth rather than changes in customer behavior (e.g., adoption of IT). Priority segments
are likely to mirror the global sourcing market. In IT services, BFSI and public services
will account for a 40% share. In IT-enabled services, call centers, BFSI non-voice
services, and finance and accounting will comprise 55% of the addressable market.
Total market size in FY20
Notes:
Institutional Sales:
Ravindra Nath, Tel: +91 22 2858 3400
Kirti Bagri, Tel: +91 22 2858 3731
Himanshu Varia, Tel: +91 22 2858 3732
Email: instsales@acm.co.in
Institutional Dealing:
Email: instdealing@acm.co.in
Disclaimer:
This report is based on information that we consider reliable, but we do not represent that it is accurate or complete and it should not be relied upon such. ACMIIL or
any of its affiliates or employees shall not be in any way responsible for any loss or damage that may arise to any person from any inadvertent error in the information
contained in the report. ACMIIL and/or its affiliates and/or employees may have interests/positions, financial or otherwise in the securities mentioned in this report.
To enhance transparency we have incorporated a Disclosure of Interest Statement in this document. This should however not be treated as endorsement of the views
expressed in the report
This document has been prepared by the Research Desk of Asit C Mehta Investment Interrmediates Ltd. and is meant for use of the recipient only and is not for
circulation. This document is not to be reported or copied or made available to others. It should not be considered as an offer to sell or a solicitation to buy any security.
The information contained herein is from sources believed reliable. We do not represent that it is accurate or complete and it should not be relied upon as such. We
may from time to time have positions in and buy and sell securities referred to herein.
SEBI Regn No: BSE INB 010607233 (Cash); INF 010607233 (F&O), NSE INB 230607239 (Cash); INF 230607239 (F&O)