Dhamma darna

by Sympathy
 (A Dhamma talk given by Mr S.N. Goenka in Singapore)

Most Venerable Bhante Dhamma-Ratanaji, devotees and admirers of

Lord Buddha,

You are all assembled here this evening to understand the

universality of the teaching of the Buddha. A Buddha always teaches
Dhamma, nothing else but Dhamma. And Dhamma means truth,
nature, the law of nature, which is universal. Dhamma can never be
sectarian; it is the universal law of nature. There were many at the
time of the Buddha, contemporaries of the Buddha, and there were
many before Gotama Buddha who tried to teach the same thing, but
they were not successful.

I come from a family, from a tradition, of very staunch conservative

Hindus, and because I come from that tradition, I know the
background of Indian spirituality, I know the teachings. When I went
to my teacher for the first time to take a Vipassana course, nothing
seemed new to me. Buddha taught sila (morality), and the
conservative Hindus, and also the Jain tradition of India, give
importance to sila. Buddha taught samadhi, mastery over the mind,
and I found that this was there also. Every tradition teaches how to
control the mind, how to develop mastery over the mind. Buddha
teaches panna, wisdom; and it seemed that that also was not new to
me. In the tradition from which I come, one has to work to purify the
mind - to come out of raga, i.e. craving; to come out of dosa, i.e.
aversion; to come out of moha, i.e. ignorance. Nothing was new, and
yet everything was new. Every step that I took was wonderful.
And why? Let me explain why.

Like many teachers of different religions Buddha also taught about

sila, the five precepts, the panca sila, and like others he explains to
people, in different ways, why they should observe sila. You should
not kill.

Why should you not kill? If somebody comes and kills you, you
certainly don't like it. Therefore when you try to kill somebody, that
person won't like it. What you don't like,

others don't like. So refrain from actions which, if performed by

others towards you, you won't like. You should not do something
which will hurt or harm others. Therefore don't kill.

If somebody steals something belonging to you which is very dear to

you, you won't like it. Certainly you don't like it. Therefore don't
take something belonging to somebody else, which is dear to that
person. You don't steal it because you don't like that to be done to
you.

If someone commits rape or adultery with a member of your family,

you don't like it. So you should not do something like that. Somebody
speaks lies and deceives you. You don't like it. Therefore you should
not do a thing like this which others won't like. You may agree to
these four precepts-"Yes, I understand I should not kill. I should not
steal. I should not commit sexual misconduct. I should not speak lies
and yet when you get intoxicated you might commit all these four.
You are helpless. You are a slave of the intoxicant. You are not the
master of yourself. Therefore don't take any intoxicant. Wonderful!
Another way of explaining: if you don't break any one of the sila,
after death you will get this heaven or that heaven. Again wonderful!

Another approach: you are a human being and every human being
has to live in society. A householder has to live with the members of
his own family, members of the society. Even if someone renounces
the householder's life, yet one remains in contact with the society. As
a member of the society you should not do anything which will
disturb the peace and harmony of the society. You cannot enjoy
peace and harmony if all around you there is no peace and harmony
at all. If you want to live a life of peace and harmony, that means you
must encourage peace and harmony around you. If you are
surrounded by burning fire, don't think that you won't suffer from
that fire.

The heat of the fire will make you miserable. If you want peace, then
don't do anything at the physical level or at the vocal level which will
disturb the peace and harmony of others, which will harm and hurt
others. Wonderful! Wonderful!

People keep listening to such discourses, but they listen with this ear,
and it goes out the other ear. This happens with everyone's teaching.
We are not here to condemn the teaching of other religions but to
understand the difference. A drunkard knows very well that drinking
is not good for him. He wants to come out of it. A gambler
understands that gambling is not good for him. He would like to
come out of it; and yet when the time comes, he or she can't control
himself or herself. He or she commits the same thing. One
understands that one should not do it, and yet one is a slave of one's
own mind, because one does not have mastery over the mind.
So the next step is to develop samadhi, mastery over the mind. Again,
the teaching of samadhi was not just the monopoly of the Buddha.
The contemporary teachers at the time of the Buddha were teaching
samadhi. Before the Buddha became Buddha, he himself went to two
teachers, Alara Kiama and Uddaka Ramaputta from whom he learned
the technique of deep samadhi up to the seventh jhana (absorbed
concentration) and the eighth jhana. So samadhi was being taught.
Different types of practices of samadhi were there, and yet the
teaching of the Buddha is wonderfully different. There can be no
comparison between the samadhi that was practiced in those days,
the lokiya-jhana (mundane absorption), and what he developed and
taught others, the lokuttara-jhana (supramundane absorption).

It is the same with the teaching of panna, wisdom. This mind, this
body, which includes the entire sensorium, is impermanent, anicca,
anicca. This cannot be a source of happiness for us. This is only a
source of misery, dukkha, dukkha. This phenomenon is not "I," is not
"mine," is not "my soul." Anatta. To many people it seems that this
was the contribution of the Buddha. But this is not so. Even at the
time of the Buddha we find instances when people who were not his
disciples came to him and he questioned them, "Kim mannasi? What
do you believe about this mind-matter sensorium?

Is it nicca or anicca, permanent or impermanent?" And the listener

answered, "Anicca." "Is this sukha or dukkha?" and he said, "Dukkha".
"Is this I, me, mine, myself, or no I, no me, no myself?" "It is no I, no
me, no myself - anatta". He was Bahiya (an outsider), not a follower
of Buddha, and yet he gave these answers. Then what was the
wonderful contribution of Buddha?
First he questioned this person, "Kim mannasi? What do you believe?
Is it anicca? Is it dukkha? Is it anatta?" And this person replied, "Yes,
this is anicca. It is dukkha. It is anatta." And then the Buddha said,
"Evam passa (by observing it so, one becomes liberated from misery).
Mere believing won't help you. Passa: you observe the reality; and
with your own observation, jana: direct experience, then you
understand this is anicca, this is dukkha, this is anatta." Herein lies
the beauty of the Buddha's teaching.

It is very easy to give sermons and easier still to listen to sermons.

"Let's talk about Dhamma and listen to words of Dhamma. Oh
wonderful! Buddha's teaching is wonderful." With this approach, one
becomes an admirer of the Buddha, one becomes a good devotee of
the Buddha, but one does not become a follower of Buddha. To
follow the Buddha, passa-yana: by Vipassana you experience for
yourself the truth, the law of nature. And then you understand. Then
it is your wisdom. Otherwise it is the wisdom of the Buddha, a
borrowed wisdom, not your wisdom.

Each individual has to develop his or her own wisdom. Each

individual has to develop his or her own enlightenment. The wisdom
developed by Siddhatta Gotama could only help one person, and that
person was Siddhatta Gotama, none else. This person became fully
enlightened because he developed the wisdom himself. Others can
get inspiration; others can get guidance: "Oh, this is how the Buddha
practised, and this is how he became Buddha." But each individual
has to take every step on the path to reach the final goal. If I don't
take any step on the path and just keep on praying, "Buddha-Oh
wonderful Buddha," I keep on admiring Buddha-"Oh wonderful
Buddha-and wonderful Dhamma". It doesn't help.
For my whole life I may keep on praying to the Buddha. For my
whole life I may keep on admiring the Buddha and Dhamma.

But if I don't practise Dhamma, I don't get the fruits of Dhamma.

This was the basic difference between the Buddha's teaching and the
teaching of all other teachers.

Because I come from a particular tradition, everything that I learned

from my teacher at the theoretical level was nothing new to me. But
at the practical level my tradition had nothing new to offer. Later on
I found that no tradition had anything to offer. It was all just talking,
talking, talking. There was no way out. One should practice
Vipassanas the Buddha wanted you to practise. "Passa-yana: you
observe the reality within yourself. And then you will understand
why I am teaching like this, why I want you to observe sila." All the
other reasons that are given are so superficial or so gross.

The teaching of the Buddha takes you from the gross, olarika, to
sukhuma, the subtle: subtle mind and matter. A constant interaction
of mind and matter is going on throughout one's life. From the time
one takes birth to the time when one passes away, there is a constant
interaction. The mind, the matter are influencing each other - are
getting influenced by each other. Mind arises because of matter, the
matter arises because of mind-currents, cross currents, under-
currents, and all of this is happening within the framework of the
body.

As you practise Vipassana you will find that there are sensations
throughout your body; but don't take them merely as physical
sensations. The body alone cannot feel; the mind is involved - mind is
feeling. A particular sensation has come - mind feels it and a part of
the mind reacts to it. If it is pleasant, it reacts with craving.
If it is unpleasant, it reacts with aversion. When the mind is reacting
with aversion, the unpleasant sensation becomes more unpleasant.
This interaction is going on, every moment and one does not know
what is happening.

As you start experiencing these sensations, you will notice that as and
when you kill you generate a tremendous amount of anger or hatred
or ill will or animosity. This dosa must arise in your mind - only then
will you kill someone. If you are a good Vipassana meditator, you will
find that as soon as you generate any negativity in your mind - anger,
hatred, ill will, animosity-you are getting agitated, you are becoming
miserable.

You can't enjoy peace when you generate anger. As soon as you
generate anger you are the first victim of your anger. This is
Dhamma, the law of nature. When anyone arouses anger it makes no
difference if he or she is a Hindu, a Muslim, a Christian or a Jain; a
Singaporean, an Indian, an American or Russian, a black, a white or a
brown. Anyone who generates anger, or any negativity, gets
punishment here and now. You have broken the law of nature. When
you break the law of the state, the state punishes you. You might
escape that punishment, but when you break the law of nature, you
can't escape it. If you break the law of the state, the punishment may
come after a few years, after going to this court or that court, but
with the law of nature there is no wait.

This was the enlightenment of the Buddha. As soon as you perform

any action at the physical level or at the vocal level, you defile your
mind, you generate negativity in your mind. As soon as you generate
negativity in your mind, misery starts.
At the surface of the mind you do not know because you have not
gone deep inside. But deep inside you have started suffering.

It is the same with stealing. You can't steal unless you generate greed
in your mind. You can't commit sexual misconduct unless you
generate passion in your mind. You can't lie and deceive others unless
you generate ego or craving or some impurity or the other in your
mind. The law of nature is such that as soon as you generate any
negativity in your mind, you start suffering. And it is not that the
result of this action will come after death. It will come after death
also but nature doesn't wait for that - it starts punishing you here and
now and it keeps punishing you.

Idha tappati, pecca tappati, papakari ubhayattha tappati.

He suffers now, he suffers after death, in both cases the wrongdoer

suffers.

If you perform any action, sinful action, unwholesome action, at the

physical or vocal level - you start suffering, suffering, suffering. This
was the Buddha's teaching which is universal. Anybody who
performs any action, physical or vocal, which harms, hurts or disturbs
the peace and harmony of others, starts suffering immediately.

Manasa ce padutthena bhasati va karoti va.

When you perform any action, physical or vocal, with a defiled mind,
then what happens?

Tato nam dukkhamanveti cakkam'va vahato padam.

Then misery will keep following you - following you, like the wheel
of the cart follows the bullock, that is yoked to the cart.
Wherever it runs, because it is yoked to the cart, the wheel is there,
the wheel is there. Because you perform an action, physical or vocal,
with the base of a defiled mind, you have multiplied your habit
pattern of reacting with the defiled mind. And this habit pattern
keeps multiplying, keeps generating misery for you. One understands
this by practicing Vipassana. Every moment that I react with
aversion, I become miserable. The sensation that I experience while
generating aversion is a very unpleasant sensation. It makes me feel
so unhappy, and I realize, "Look nature is punishing me, nature is
punishing me now, here and now and will continue to punish me
unless I come out this habit pattern."

This is the law of nature. The Buddha did not create it. Buddha is not
the creator of Dhamma. Dhamma is there. The Buddha discovered it.
He went to such a depth that he discovered the law of nature at the
experiential level, which made him an enlightened person.

Everyone can practise the technique that he discovered and they will
get the same result. Everyone can explore the truth within the
framework of the body and can understand the interaction: "Look
what is happening. As soon as I defile my mind the punishment is
there." When you become more and more established in this truth at
the experiential level your sila becomes perfect. If I place my hand on
the fire - knowingly or unknowingly - it burns. The next time I will
be very careful: "Oh, I should not place my hand on the fire - it burns
- look, it burns and I don't like this burning. I want to keep my hand
away."

As the fire outside burns you as soon as you touch it, so also, your
impurities burn you as you start generating them, and you start
experiencing this burning. You won't want to generate more misery
for yourself when you start experiencing the truth inside.

This is what the Buddha called passa-yana: "With Vipassana you

observe directly; experience this truth and understand the reality.
Then you understand my teaching properly." Otherwise, for your
whole life you may say "Everything is anicca, everything is dukkha,
everything is anatta-. We are the believers in anicca, we are the
believers in dukkha, we are the believers in anatta." What do you
gain? Tell me,what do you gain? It is a big delusion. I didn't gain
anything until I practised. Buddha is not in favor of any devotional or
emotional entertainment. Buddha is teaching the actual practice of
Dhamma. He taught sila and people reached the stage, whereby,
experiencing the truth inside, they naturally abstained from breaking
sila.

He taught samadhi, which before him was just the eight jhanas. As
you go deeper in the technique, you will understand the difference
between the eight jhanas of those days, which are lokiya jhanas, and
how Buddha gave a twist, a tum towards liberation making them
lokuttara. Sampajanna in its true sense: constant thorough
understanding of impermanence, was not included in the eight jhanas
of those days. Buddha started the practice with sati-sampayana. By
the time one attains the third jhana, the third jhana samapatti
(attainment), the sampajanna is perfect. Sampajanna is perfect only if
you are aware of these sensations - arising, passing; arising, passing;
continuously aware day and night.

One who practises Vipassana properly will start understanding the

importance of the words of the Buddha when he says sampajannam
narincati, sampajannam na rincati:
You can't afford to miss even one moment of sampajanna. Every
moment-sampajanna, sampajanna, arising; passing, arising; passing,
then it is not just a theory, then it is not just a philosophy, it is a
practice. When you are with this arising, passing; arising, passing;
anicca, anicca, anicca, you can't generate a new impurity. And when
you are with this anicca the old impurities keep coming on the
surface.

They come on the surface and get eradicated, layers after layers of
impurities, come and pass away. Then you become the master of your
mind, and the samadhi is not mere samadhi, panna is included with
it.

With sampajanna included, Buddha's practice takes one to the first

phala samapatti; as one becomes sotapanna one experiences the first
jhana. Proceeding on the path one gets the second phala
samapatti:sakadagami, which may come with the first jhana or higher
jhanas. As one attains the third phala samapatti: anagami, and the
fourth: Arahant, the third and fourth jhanas are useful. It is not
absolutely necessary to practise the fifth, sixth, seventh and eighth
jhanas to attain the phalas, though one can easily do so after these
stages if one wants. But in these first four jhanas, he included
sampajanna, sati-sampajana, which at the time was not available
anywhere.

Of course, there had been other Buddhas, but since the passing of the
teaching of the previous Buddha nobody prior to the Gotama the
Buddha or at the time of Gotama the Buddha or other teachers that
came after Gotama the Buddha could understand the proper meaning
of sampajanna. This word had percolated down from the time of
previous Buddhas but the real meaning was lost.
In the teaching of the lokiya jhanas it had the meaning of, "knowing
intentionally, or deeper, precise awareness." But the wisdom of anicca
was absent so the actual teaching and practice of sati-sampajana was
far away. This wisdom was the contribution of the Buddha, the
wonderful contribution of the Buddha.

And then, with this experiential understanding inside, it becomes so

clear that there is no sectarian teaching at all. This is just the law of
nature. It is not necessary that I must call myself a Buddhist to
practise the teaching of Buddha. I may keep calling myself by any
name, because it doesn't make any difference. Even if I call myself a
Buddhist, if I generate raga/lobha, I generate dosa, and I generate
moha - is there any Buddha above the clouds who will come and save
me? I will have to suffer; calling myself a Buddhist won't help. If I
really want to come out of suffering I must come out of lobha, I must
come out of dosa, I must come out of moha.

The beauty of Buddha's teaching is that he discovered this law in

depth, made use of it for his own enlightenment and then distributed
it to others. "Look; I got enlightenment by this, I got liberated by this.
You can also get liberated, everyone of you. You just try - you just
work with the practice.

And it is the beauty of Buddha's teaching that he says, "I am not

teaching to have you as my pupils." In the Udumbara Sutta he says, "I
am not interested to make you my pupil, I am not interested in
breaking you from your old teacher - I am not interested. I am not
interested even to change your goal, because everyone wants to come
out of suffering. Just give me seven days of your life." Buddha says,
"Just give me seven days of your life and try it. Try something that I
have discovered and then judge for yourselves whether it is good or
not good for you. If it is good for you, then accept it. Otherwise, don't
accept it." This is Buddha's way of teaching. He is not interested in
snaring pupils. Nor is he interested in establishing a sect, a particular
sect. How will the world benefit if everyone in the world calls
himself or herself a Buddhist but no one practises Dhamma? Rather
these people will be helped and the world will be helped when
people practise sila, samadhi, and panna. This starts to benefit oneself
and others. The whole atmosphere becomes purified. It becomes
charged with Dhamma - with the vibration of purity with the
vibration of metta, because one starts practising. The Buddha wants
us to practise, not to play intellectual games. These games will not
help; they are a big delusion.

Take as an example the taste of a piece of cake. The cake is very

sweet. You accept that it is sweet because the Buddha said so. And
you have great devotion in Buddha, so you accept it. This is mere
acceptance. "Kim mannasi - what do you believe? I believe Buddha's
teaching is wonderful." This is merely your belief. Or suppose you
take one step further and you try to intellectualize: "Oh, Buddha says
this is so. Others say something different. Buddha's words are so
rational, so scientific - ah, wonderful! Buddha's teaching is so
wonderful. "Again, what do you gain? The cake is very sweet because
it contains sugar. So naturally it is sweet. It must be sweet.

But is the cake really sweet or not? Only when you put it on your
own tongue and you taste it can you say, "Yes, it is sweet." It is sweet
on your tongue . If you do not practise Buddha' s teaching - you just
keep admiring his teaching - then you are a wonderful admirer of
Buddha. You are also a wonderful devotee of Buddha but you are not
a follower of Buddha. And one does not get anything unless one
follows what Buddha taught.
Devotion is wonderful. Saddha- (devotion) is the first step on the
path of Dhamma. I say saddha is like preparing a field for cultivation.
You plough the field, you remove all the pebbles and stones, you
cultivate it well-and then you sit near this field and keep praying.
"Now I have prepared the field. Oh field, give me a wonderful crop;
please give me a fruitful crop." Similarly, "Oh Buddha, please do
something to give me a wonderful crop." But nothing comes up. You
have to plant the seeds in the field; you have to irrigate it; you have
to fertilize properly. Only then will you find that healthy crops have
grown. Devotion is like preparing the ground but don't stop there. It
is a very important step, no doubt. But then, you have to take the
next steps and those you have to take yourself, nobody else can do
that for you. A Buddha cannot do that for you. Your guru cannot do
that for you. Your teacher cannot do that for you. You have to work
yourself.

Tumhe hi kiccam atappam, akkhataro Tathagata.

You yourself must earnestly practise, the enlightened ones only

proclaim the path.

A Tathagata, will only show the path; he won't carry you on his
shoulders to the final goal. Nobody can carry you on his shoulders to
the final goal. Tumhe hi kiccam atappam: you have to work out your
own salvation - you have to work out your own emancipation.
Someone can guide you because he has walked over the path, step by
step. As the Buddha explained, "I walked over this path. I benefitted.
If you want to come along, then you also walk. Start taking steps." As
many steps as you take, you will get that much benefit. If you take all
the steps on the path, then you will reach the final goal.
The path is universal. One comes to a course of ten days or longer to
practise what the Buddha taught. And the first requisite is: when you
come you have to observe five precepts during your stay. It doesn't
matter whether you have been observing them in the past or not.
While you are in a retreat, when you are trying to practise what he
wanted you to practise, at least for these ten days, you must observe
these five precepts very scrupulously. Hindu or Muslim,
Christian,Buddhist or Jain, all will take five precepts. They don't
disagree; they accept this discipline-because the precepts are
universal. Which religion will say, "Yes, you can kill; it doesn't
matter. Go ahead, you can steal; it doesn't matter. You can commit
adultery; doesn't matter. You can speak lies." No religion will teach
that, because moral conduct is the greatest common denominator of
all the religions.

So the first step is to practise moral physical and vocal actions. Next
you are asked to sit down comfortably. You are not required to sit in
a lotus or half-lotus posture. You choose whichever way you can sit
comfortably, keeping your back straight. You close your eyes, close
your mouth and your guide will say, "Observe your breath." This is
what Buddha taught: "Observe your breath, natural breath - as it
comes in - as it goes out."

Suppose along with the awareness of the breath, one is instructed to

mentally recite a word. This is what happens in various kinds of
meditation. I passed through such practices, so I know what happens.
You are asked to breathe in while mentally reciting one word;
breathing out, you mentally repeat another word. For example, if I
am a Hindu, I breathe in: "Rama, Rama"; if I am Sikh: "Sata-nama,
Sata-nama."Like this, some word is used, whatever it might be. One
who calls himself a Buddhist will say, "Buddha, Buddha, Buddha."
This is not Buddha's teaching. It is sectarian, because whenever one is
given any word to recite, that word is almost always a sectarian word.
How can a non-Buddhist say "Buddha, Buddha, Buddha"? Certainly,
mentally repeating "Buddha, Buddha," the mind will get
concentrated.

In the same way if you recite, "Rama, Rama, Rama,"your mind will
get concentrated. You can say, "Christ, Christ, Christ," your mind will
get concentrated. If you say, "Allah, Allah," it will get concentrated.
But these are sectarian words and Buddha's path must remain
universal. Even if you use an ordinary word, like, "clock, clock,clock,
clock," the mind will get concentrated. If you repeat any word
continuously, your mind will get concentrated. This is a law of
nature. But the Buddha never gave his followers any word to
concentrate on.

Buddha's instruction is to observe the breath just breath, natural

breath. The breath cannot be Hindu, breath cannot be Muslim,
cannot be Christian. You can't give it a title. This fellow who is
breathing: can we say his breath is a Muslim breath, is it a Hindu
breath? No. Breath is breath, natural breath. Buddha's object of
meditation is so universal.

In my teaching, everywhere around the world, I find people coming

from different sects, different communities, different beliefs. I ask
them to observe breath. It doesn't go against their religion and they
accept it, "Yes, observing breath is not against my religion." If, along
with the breath, I were to instruct them, "You must say, 'Namo tassa
bhagvato...'," many would react, "Oh no, no, no, I can't say this." But
if I tell them, "Observe only breath," then yes, they accept it.
Another way of concentration was very common at the time of
Buddha, and it still continues today. Along with the breath a
meditator imagines some image - a shape, a form of this god or that
god, of this saintly person or that saintly person, founder of this
religion or that religion. Again, as soon as one imagines this shape or
form, it becomes sectarian, because one shape or form belongs to this
particular sect, another shape or form belongs to that particular sect.
Nothing doing! Buddha says no shape, no form, no verbalization, no
visualization, no imagination. Yathabhuta nana dassanam (realization
of the truth as it is). This is Buddha's teaching. Yathabhuta: as it
happens, as it is happening at this moment. The breath has come in.
That's all. The breath has gone out. That's all. If it is deep you are just
aware that it is deep.

If it is shallow, you are just aware that it is shallow. You don't

interfere with the natural flow of the nature. If it passes through the
left nostril, you are just aware: it is passing through the left nostril. If
it passes through the right nostril, you are just aware that it is passing
through the right nostril. If it is passing through both the nostrils,
you are just aware. Your job is to develop the faculty of awareness.

You are asked to keep the attention at the entrance of the nostrils.
For three days you keep working continuously because nothing else is
allowed in a Vipassana course. From 4:00-4:30 in the morning until
9:00-9:30 at night, you are permitted no reading, no discussions, no
arguments, no newspapers, no TV, no radio; nothing else. You are
just observing yourself. What will reading the newspaper do? It will
make you more extroverted. If you are extroverted you can't observe
yourself as Buddha wants you to observe yourself. So no distractions
are permitted, no disturbances from outside. You simply observe your
breath.
You observe your breath and you are asked to be aware of this area -
the entrance of the nostrils where the breath comes in, where it goes
out.

One day, two days, three days pass, then you begin to notice that
besides this breath going in and coming out, something else is
happening. What is happening? Some biochemical reaction or the
other. Every moment there is some biochemical reaction throughout
your body, but at the conscious level you are unaware of this. At a
deeper level your mind keeps feeling these biochemical flows and
keeps reacting to them. There is some sensation happening
everywhere in the body. It may be heat or perspiration; it may be
throbbing, pulsing,itching, tickling something or the other keeps
happening. But you are instructed to keep your attention on the area
of the nostrils.

On the third day you start feeling something happening here. Again,
your teacher will say, "Just observe. Do nothing. If it is itching, just
observe. Don't scratch it. Don't rub it. Just observe the itching. See
how long it lasts." You observe, observe, observe. . . and it passes
away. No itching is eternal; it doesn't stay forever. It increases and
decreases, and sooner or later it goes. "Oh, anicca. Oh, anicca.

After all,it passes away; sooner or later it passes away." You

understand anicca. Like this, everything that arises, arises to pass
away; it arises to pass away.

Initially you are concentrating on the area at the entrance of the

nostrils. By the time you reach the fourth or fifth day, you will
explore the entire physical structure and you will find that
everywhere there is some sensation or the other. There is no particle,
not the tiniest particle in the body, where there is no sensation.
Wherever there is life, there is sensation. Again, you just observe:
yathabhuta. You are observing objectively: yathabhuta nana
dassanam. You are not identifying yourself with this sensation. It is
not necessary that you start naming this sensation. Instead of naming
the sensation, you understand its nature. Whatever sensation has
come up, you are trained to observe: "Let me see how long it lasts. Let
me see how long it lasts." And you find that sooner or later, it passes
away: anicca, anicca. Buddha wanted you to understand this anicca at
the experiential level. If you simply understand at the intellectual
level - "Well, everything in this world is anicca. Look, see how people
take birth and die. Buildings get erected and later they get
demolished. Oh, everything is anicca" - this is merely intellectual
understanding; it is not the passa-jana that Buddha wants you to
have. With Vipassana you must understand, "Look how very
impermanent, how very ephemeral! Arising, passing; arising, passing;
constantly arising, passing; arising, passing.Everywhere throughout
the physical structure arising, passing; arising, passing; arising,
passing."

Again this is universal. This is not something Buddha created for you,
me or for anybody else. This is true for everybody but people don't
have the eye of wisdom. They don't have this technique of Vipassana,
to feel this process of mind and matter interaction - arising, passing;
arising, passing; arising, passing. And this is the specialty of Buddha's
teaching. As I say, in the tradition from which I came, that teaching
was there: "You must be free from craving-ra-ga"; in that teaching
vita raga is the highest goal. "You must come out of aversion"; vita
dosa is the highest goal. "You must come out of ignorance"; vita moha
is the highest goal. I used to recite all that in the Gita. I used to recite
these in different Upanishads of Vedanta.
But how to come out of raga? How to come out of dosa? How to come
out of moha? These are nothing but sermons:

"Oh, you people of the world,you must come out of greed; this is very
dangerous for you. Oh, you people of the world, you must come out
of aversion; this is very dangerous for you. People of the world, you
must come out ignorance; it is very dangerous for you."

If Buddha had also said only this, then there would have been no
difference between Buddha and other teachers. Buddha tells us how
to come out of our suffering: "Look, here is a technique. Where the
greed starts, you go to the depth where it is generated. Where the
aversion starts, you go to the depth and you see how it starts." By
practising Vipassana you will start to understand. Initially you will
experience very unpleasant sensations, gross, solidified sensations like
heaviness or pressure or heat. But as you keep observing, observing,
observing, you will find that they get disintegrated, they get
dissolved. And then you come to very subtle vibrations throughout
the body. There is nothing but a flow of subtle vibrations which is
very pleasant. One feels like having more and more. Students come to
me in the middle of the course and they say, "Oh, wonderful! Oh,
Goenkaji, today's meditation was so wonderful. I had a free flow, so
much piti (joyful delight). So wonderful! So wonderful!"

At this point we must remember Buddha's words: - adinava

(dangerous), bhaya (fearful). This is dangerous for you. When you
start experiencing pleasant sensation, if there is assada (relishing), a
very big danger has come. You will start to generate craving for it.
You will start generating attachment to it; and then, as soon as you
miss this pleasant flow of sensation, you will come running to me.
"Oh, my meditation has gone very bad. Please do something,
Goenkaji. I'm not getting that wonderful flow. "Oh, this is dangerous.
So when you get a very pleasant sensation-flow throughout the body
the teacher will remind you, "Anicca. Look, this is also anicca."

Samudaya dhammanupassi va kayasmim viharati. vaya

dhammanupassi va kayasmim viharati. samudaya-vaya
dhammanupassi va kayasmim viharati.

The meditator dwells observing the phenomenon of arising in the

body. He dwells observing the phenomenon of passing away in the
body. He dwells observing the phenomenon of simultaneous arising
and passing away in the body.

When you experienced gross sensation, there was arising - samudaya

dhammanupassi viharati. After some time, vaya dhammanupassi
viharati - look, it has arisen, and after some time, it has passed away.
But it comes to a stage when it turns into very subtle vibration. Then
the change occurs with such high velocity - samudayavaya
dhammanupassi viharati. There is no gap between samudaya and
vaya, arising and passing away. But it is all anicca. Whether it passes
away after some time or it passes away instantly, it does pass away. It
is not permanent. Experiencing this one starts changing the habit
pattern of the mind.

Unless you go to the depth of the mind, you can't change its habit
pattern at the deepest level. This is what the Buddha found by
practising all eight jhanas - the anusaya kilesa (sleeping impurities)
remain. These impurities are the behavior pattern of the mind from
so many lives and they will continue in future lives unless you strike
at the root, unless you cut that root. Otherwise there is no possibility
of getting liberated. Practising these lokiya jhanas, you may enjoy
wonderful ecstasy which does bring purity of mind at the surface
level. With this layer of mental purity, after death you may attain this
loka (plane of existence) or that loka; but still you are rolling. You are
rotating in the loka. You cannot go beyond that. Only when you cut
the root - the root of all the anusaya kilesa, where the impurities arise
- only then will you get liberated.

Understand that there is a big barrier, a very big barrier between the
so-called "conscious mind" and what is called the half-conscious or
unconscious mind by Western psychologists. Buddha never used
these words because no part of the mind is unconscious. What is
called "conscious mind" he called paritta citta, a very tiny part of the
mind.

But still, if you understand the Western psychological terminology,

then call them conscious, half-conscious, unconscious.

Day and night the so- called unconscious mind is aware of these
sensations in the body-day and night, every moment. And it is not
only aware of them; it is reacting to them - every moment, it is
reacting. That means it is multiplying the behavior pattern of craving,
of aversion; of craving, of aversion. Either the sensations are pleasant
or unpleasant, and this part of the mind keeps reacting, over and
over. The conscious mind doesn't know what is happening at all. This
tiny mind at the surface doesn't know at all.

An example - it is night time and you have gone to bed. You are in
deep sleep. Who is in deep sleep? The conscious mind is in deep
sleep. But the so-called unconscious mind never sleeps. It is
constantly in contact with these body sensations. You are in deep
sleep. A mosquito has come and bitten you. The unconscious mind
immediately feels - there is an unpleasant sensation - and it reacts. It
will drive the mosquito away or kill the mosquito.
Still, this unpleasant sensation is going on. Now it will scratch and
the conscious mind doesn't know at all. In the morning if somebody
asks you, "During the night, how many mosquitoes bit you?" You
don't know. You will know nothing about it, and yet the whole night
you were reacting to these mosquito bites.

And it does not happen only at night. This barrier remains all the
time, twenty-four hours a day. For example now, at this moment, I
am sitting. If I am not a good Vipassana meditator, what happens?
While I am talking, my conscious mind is working: "Look, I have said
so much. Now I must conclude in this way. Time is getting short. I
must finish the talk now. And whatever I am saying - are people
listening to it? Are they understanding or are they getting bored?
They have started yawning. They are looking at their watches. I must
stop talking." My conscious mind is doing this job. The unconscious
mind has nothing at all to do with it. The unconscious mind is busy
feeling sensations. Sitting for one hour in one position with this
heavy weight, a pressure starts somewhere in my body. When a
pressure starts this unconscious mind says, "I don't like it. You better
move." So I move a little. After some time another pressure appears.
Again I move a little. Some itching might start up and automatically I
scratch it. My conscious mind doesn't know what I am doing. Try
observing someone.

Keep watching him or her for 15 minutes. Do nothing: just observe

the person. You will notice how frequently he or she is shifting like
this and fidgeting here and there. What is he doing? Even the person
himself or herself does not know what he or she is doing. This is
because there is such a big barrier between the conscious and the
unconscious part of the mind.
The conscious mind is occupied with so many things. The
unconscious mind is busy only feeling sensations and reacting, feeling
sensations and reacting.

This barrier needs to be broken. You may have the intellectual

understanding: "Oh everything is anicca, everything is anicca, there
should be no lobha, no dosa." And yet there is lobha, there is dosa.
This mind, this unconscious mind does not understand that this is
anicca. When there is pain, it doesn't like it: "Oh, this is unpleasant. I
don't like it." It keeps on reacting. Now, with Vipassana, you go to the
depth where the mind feels the body sensations. It is at the level of
the bodily sensations that the unconscious mind is reacting; and it is
at this level that you can stop this unconscious mind from reacting.
Whatever may have been understood at the intellectual level, now
this mad mind, the blind mind, also starts understanding: "Look-
anicca, Look, these sensations are anicca." Then the behavior pattern
at the depth of the mind starts changing.

This was Buddha's enlightenment: this paticca samuppada (dependent

origination). He said whether there is a Buddha present or not, the
law of paticca samuppada is always there. Other teachers will say,
"Oh, you must not react with craving to anything pleasant that you
see, or to anything pleasant that you hear, or to any pleasant thing
you smell, taste, touch or think. You must not react with craving. Or,
whatever unpleasant experience there may be, something that you
see, you hear, you smell, you taste, you touch, or you think - do not
have aversion." This teaching was there. Even today many are giving
this teaching. Buddha found out that there is a gap between the
outside object coming in contact with the six sense doors and the
reaction of craving or aversion. He discovered a missing link, and that
missing link is vedana, the sensation on the body.
Salyatana paccaya phasso; phassa paccaya vedana; vedana paccaya
tanha.

With the base of the six senses, contact arises; with the base of
contact, sensation arises; with the base of sensation, craving and
aversion arise.

I may think that I am free from craving or aversion when I hear

something pleasant or unpleasant, but deep inside where the
sensations have started, my mind keeps reacting. At the depth it
keeps reacting. If I do not work with this link which is deeper than
my superficial, intellectual understanding, I cannot come out of my
misery because I cannot change the habit pattern of my mind. This is
what the Buddha found out: salayatana paccaya phasso - at the six
sense doors, there is contact. Phassa paccaya vedana: at every contact,
there is sensation. When there is a contact at the ear sense door, or
eye sense door, or nose sense door, or tongue sense door, or body
sense door, or mind sense door - there is bound to be sensation on the
body: vedana. Then vedana paccaya tanha: only after vedana will this
craving and aversion arise. If you miss vedana, how will you know
where the tanha has started? You won't even know that tanha has
started. You may try to keep the impurities away at the surface level
of the mind, but at the depth, long before the reaction becomes
strong enough to emerge at the conscious level, it has already tied so
many knots, so many knots! The behavior pattern becomes stronger
and stronger. You can't come out of it by working only at the
intellectual level.

The beauty of Buddha's teaching is that he gave this wonderful

technique, which is universal. Anybody who goes to the depth and
takes out all the impurity becomes a liberated person, and can keep
calling himself by any name. It makes no difference. But someone
who cannot penetrate to this depth keeps on rotating in misery. This
law is universal, applicable to one and all. Buddha rediscovered this
law, made use of it for himself, became liberated and then started
distributing it to others with so much love, so much compassion. As
people started practising it, they benefitted from it.

People of this wonderful island, I am glad you have so much devotion

to Buddha. You admire Buddha. You admire Buddha's teaching.
Therefore the base is wonderful. You all have the seed of Dhamma in
you.

Otherwise you would not have come to a talk like this. By now,
perhaps, you would have been in some theatre or some cinema or
some dance hall or somewhere else. You are here. That shows that
you have got the seed of Dhamma in you. But if for the whole life the
seed remains only a seed, you won't get anything. The seed must
grow and give wonderful fruits. And certainly the seed can give
wonderful fruits. I invite all of you. As Buddha says, "Give me seven
days of your life. Just give a trial." I am not a Buddha. I say, "Give me
ten days of your life and try. Just try." Accept it only after you have
passed through these ten days. You will find that Buddha's way is
really beneficial - that it gives results, akaliko, here and now. You
won't have to wait until after death. You will benefit here and now,
and keep on benefitting.

Idha nandati pecca nandati katapunno ubhayattha nandat.

Here and now he rejoices, after death he rejoices, in both cases the
well doer rejoices.
The moment you start practising Dhamma, you will see that you are
benefiting. In the beginning, it is beneficial; in the middle, it is
beneficial; at the end, it is beneficial. But it is beneficial only when
you practice.

I hope all of you, sooner or later, will find the time to begin the
practice of Buddha's teaching. You have done a lot of intellectual
entertainment already. Today also you have listened for one hour,
which was only intellectual entertainment. But now take this hour
and turn it into the strong determination that whenever you find
time, you will pass through a practice of ten days.

May all of you pass through a practice of ten days.

May all of you get the best benefit of Buddha's teaching,
the best fruits of Buddha's teaching.
May all of you enjoy real peace, real harmony, real happiness.
S.N.GOENKA