Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
“Life Success”
to Students
with LD:
Lessons Learned
From a 20-Year Study
M A R S H A L L H. R A S K I N D ,
R O B E RTA J. G O L D B E R G ,
E L E A N O R L. H I G G I N S ,
AND
K E N N E T H L. H E R M A N
Children with learning disabilities (LD) grow up, and although some find the
road to successful, satisfying, and rewarding lives, others continue to struggle
and “fail” into and through adulthood. Research has indicated that successful
individuals with LD possess a set of “success attributes” (personal character-
istics, behaviors, attitudes, and conditions) that lead them to positive life out-
comes. This article presents a conceptual framework for fostering success
attributes in students with LD and provides suggestions for classroom activities.
I will always think of myself as a child with a learning man, 1999; Reiff, Gerber, & Ginsberg, 1997). Some chil-
disability. I don’t think it has ever really changed . . . it dren with LD follow a life path that leads them to “suc-
is a part of my life forever. cess,” while others find little more than continued
—33-year-old adult “failure.” Now take a moment and think about the stu-
dents with LD in your classroom. Think about their in-
C
hildren with learning disabilities (LD) do grow dividual strengths, weaknesses, interests, experiences,
up, but many of the difficulties they faced and living environments. Try to picture them 20 years
during childhood persist into and through from now. Are you able to imagine how they will turn
adulthood (Johnson & Blalock, 1987; Kavale, out? Will they have good jobs, go to college, be happy, or
1988; Raskind, Goldberg, Higgins, & Her- have positive relationships with family and friends? Are
I NTERVENTION IN S CHOOL AND C LINIC VOL . 37, N O. 4, M ARCH 2002 ( PP. 201–208) 201
you able to predict who will become “successful” and who Similarly, there were unsuccessful participants who
might not? Although you may be able to make some good showed some of the success attributes, again to lesser or
guesses about the outcome of a number of your students, greater degrees. Still, successful individuals displayed
the accuracy of these predictions is questionable, at best. these attributes to a greater extent (at a statistically sig-
Of course, we never really know how someone will turn nificant level) than the unsuccessful participants.
out in life. However, wouldn’t it be helpful in developing
your teaching strategies and curriculum to have a more Self-Awareness
reliable way to predict how your students might end up
or, more important, to know what you could do with The successful individuals often referred to themselves as
your students that would help to promote positive life “learning disabled.” They were very open about their dif-
outcomes for them? ficulties and described life events in terms of their LD.
At the Frostig Center in Pasadena, California, we be- One individual stated,
lieved that making such determinations or “predictions”
As I said, I have dyslexia. I have never not had dyslexia.
would be of tremendous value in helping students with
So it has always, and always will, affect my life. I don’t
LD reach their full potential and lead satisfying and re-
know what it’s like not to have dyslexia. I don’t know that
warding lives. We needed to understand, despite similar
I want to do life over again without it. It’s part of me. It
backgrounds and learning difficulties, why some of our
will hinder me, as it has, and it will push me into places
students ended up as happy, satisfied, and productive mem-
where I never would have gone.
bers of society, whereas others were barely able to keep
their heads above water emotionally, socially, and finan- Successful individuals were not, however, overly defined
cially. We wanted to know why one former student was by their difficulties. These individuals were able to com-
currently president of a software company, while his partmentalize their disabilities—seeing their difficulties
former classmate was living out his days in a state peni- as only one aspect of themselves. They also accepted their
tentiary. In an effort to gain such an understanding, we LD and utilized appropriate services to overcome diffi-
initiated a 20-year follow-up study designed to identify culties whenever possible. Many of the “successfuls” had
various factors in the lives of our students that led some a clear picture of their individual strengths and weak-
to “success” and others to “failure.” (Please see Raskind nesses, recognizing and accepting their talents along with
et al., 1999, for a complete description of the study.) Re- their limitations. These ideas were expressed by one partic-
sults of the study revealed that a set of personal charac- ipant who stressed, “At this point I just accept it, that this
teristics, attitudes, and behaviors were predictive of is the way it is, and it isn’t going to get any better. . . . We
success. These “success attributes” included all learn differently, we all have strengths and weak-
nesses.” Similarly another informant shared,
• self-awareness,
I think I’ve pretty much gotten over it. It’s still there, and
• proactivity,
I compensate . . . I think the problems that I had were no
• perseverance,
different than anybody else who is conscious of their weak-
• goal-setting,
nesses, and then some of their strengths. Some people are
• the presence and use of effective support systems, and
not conscious at all.
• emotional stability.
Still another adult stated,
These characteristics were more powerful predictors
You know, everybody comes with a package. And yeah,
of success than numerous other variables, including IQ,
there are things that I am good at and things that I am
academic achievement, life stressors, age, gender, socioe-
not so good at. Some of my limitations are reading and
conomic status, and ethnicity.
writing. But boy, when it comes to putting things together
and understanding how things go together, reading plans,
I’m really good at reading plans. I’m really good at chas-
Understanding ing down problems. I’m a good diagnoser . . . so those are
the Success Attributes some talents, some skills that I was born with. . . . I carved
a different path, and my whole life has been that way.
What exactly were these success attributes, and how did
they manifest themselves in successful individuals? We
answer this question below for each attribute. Dialogue Proactivity
from successful study participants are used to elucidate
each attribute and to provide a first-hand account of how Successful individuals with LD were actively engaged in
these attributes were expressed. However, not every suc- the world around them. They tended to socialize, partic-
cessful individual displayed every success attribute, and ipate in community activities, and take an active role in
some attributes were evident to greater or lesser degrees. their families, neighborhoods, and friendship groups. They