Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
costs simultaneously (3). In the meantime, better technologies are needed to detoxify
and isolate existing hazardous wastes from the environment. Within the technical
community, these needs are widely recognized. Literature focusing on wastewa
ter (4,5,6), hazardous waste treatment (7,8,9), land disposal technologies (10). and
the related legislative and legal issues ( Π ) continues to grow exponentially.
Our present contribution focuses on selected technologies that are currently un
der development. Since these are emerging technologies and management tech
niques, neither process safety nor economic considerations are discussed in detail.
While both factors are important, additional research and development are needed
before these aspects can be assessed with an acceptable level of confidence.
Traditional concerns with industrial water quality have focused on process use (e.g.,
pretreatment for cooling tower and boiler water) rather than wastewater treat
ment (12). This latter issue has been of more concern to municipalities rather
than to industries, but this situation is rapidly changing. With the widespread use
of chemicals and increasingly limited water supplies, reuse and waste minimization,
rather than discharge, are emerging as dominant strategies for industrial wastewater
management.
Groundwater pollution (e.g., from landfill and land disposal leachates) is now
a more frequent industrial concern, especially in light of tighter regulations and
long-term liabilities (11,13,14). It is increasingly difficult for generators to abandon
wastes, and this reality is changing perceptions and emphases. Short-term benefits
are being weighed more carefully against long-term liabilities. Less tangible con
siderations, such as public and community relations, are also galvanizing corporate
sensitivities. More commonly, the prudent decision is to minimize waste generation
and provide in-house stabilization, rather than discharge minimally treated wastes
to municipal or private waste handlers and thereby assume greater long-term liabil
ities.
Nonetheless, existing landfill, migration, and surface runoff problems persist.
The resulting polluted waters usually contain only trace levels of restricted species,
but management is still required. Moreover, traditional methods are often ineffec
tive and new treatment methods are needed to economically manage these wastes.
Chemical or biological oxidation or reduction techniques are often possibilities, al
though partially degraded species from inadequate treatment may be more noxious
than the parent compounds. Thus, these technologies must be thoroughly under
stood before deployment can be safely initiated.
A related issue concerns the ability to model species degradation and fate at
infinite dilution in water, based on limited experimental data. Regardless of the
degradation technology, the chemistry is complex because of multiple reaction paths
and solutes, species competition, and other interactions. Considerable efforts have
already been expended toward the development of predictive techniques for estimat
ing species migration from landfills, land disposal sites, etc. (e.g., Valocchi (15)).
Pacheco and Holmes (see Chapter 3) also present results on oxidation in the
presence of T1O2 and UV, but with salicylic acid as the reactive solute. Their
emphasis is on the engineering design of solar driven reactors, rather than funda
mentals, and they compare the relative efficiencies of falling-film versus glass-tube
reactors. They confirm Tseng and Huang's observations and discuss some of the
design limitations. While increased T1O2 concentrations accelerate reaction rates,
higher T1O2 concentrations also increase stream turbidity and reduce UV absorp
tion. Since both UV irradiation and the catalyst are important, competition results
and an optimal T1O2 concentration must exist for a particular waste stream. It
also helps to maintain high dissolved oxygen concentrations in the reactor and, while
poisoning effects are not discussed, they are doubtless important in many instances.
A third study of heterogeneous catalysis for water purification takes a broader
view. In Chapter 4, Bull and McManamon discuss its use to enhance oxidation rates
for several different solutes and catalyst preparations. They find that many pollu
tants can be effectively destroyed including: sulfide, thiosulfate, mercaptans and
cyanide species. Their catalysts include various transition metals on aluminosili-
cate and zeolite supports. Several catalytic systems exhibit encouraging results over
a range of pHs. Hence a wider class of streams may be effectively treated with
reduced levels of ρ H adjustment. They examine the destruction of three key inor
ganic pollutants; thiosulfate, sulfide, and cyanide. In their experiments, H2O2 and
aqueous solute were mixed and pumped upflow through jacketed beds packed with
metal-supported catalysts. Iron on mordenite and copper on synthetic zeolites were
found particularly effective. The practical operating range was ~ 4 < pH < 12,
but it depended on the pollutant. For example, cyanide with pH < 6-8 liberated
HCN which is usually unacceptable. However, pH did not appear to affect catalytic
activity and the relatively large catalytic particle sizes used permitted an efficient
packed bed design.
Castrantas and Gibilisco (see Chapter 6) present results where UV and H2O2 are
used without a heterogeneous catalyst or other additives to promote the destruction
of phenol and substituted phenols. They point out that this approach is somewhat
simpler than methods using soluble additives (e.g., Fenton's reagent), and it is more
effective under a wider pH range. Another advantage is that H2O2, being unstable,
does not require subsequent removal as would be the case with iron soluble salts, for
example. Compared to UV alone, the UV and H2O2 system gives almost a factor
of 20 increase in reaction rates.
Homogeneous phase reaction with UV catalyzed oxidation is a classical method
which has been studied for many years. Most investigators, however, have ex-
amined reactivities in mixtures that initially contained only one oxidizable solute.
With respect to wastewaters, this situation seldom exists and Sundstrom et al.
present results in Chapter 5 which suggest that solute interactions can inhibit ox-
idation. In particular, they find that mixtures of two priority pollutants, benzene
and trichloroethylene, oxidize more slowly than the individual species. While this
result is partly due to competition for the oxidant and mass action, benzene and its
derivatives apparently inhibit trichloroethylene oxidation. Consequently, a reactor's
volume requirements may be seriously underestimated if its design is based on pure
component oxidation rates.
Downloaded by 111.68.103.227 on March 9, 2011 | http://pubs.acs.org
Publication Date: March 8, 1990 | doi: 10.1021/bk-1990-0422.ch001
Coincidentally, Sundstrom, Weir, and Redig's work has implications for Desai
et al.'s study of chemical structure and biodegradability relationships in Chapter 9.
In both cases, most available data describe solute destruction rates in relatively
simple systems. Although the reactive pathways are quite different, unfavorable
interactions are plausible in each. The complexity of most wastewater streams, and
the need to design for a wide range of applications, suggest that solute interactions
and mixture reaction rates will require much more study before reliable design and
scale-up procedures can be defined a priori.
The use of catalysts, H2O2, etc., to promote oxidation are advanced technologies
compared to current practice. Such systems generate radical species in sufficient
quantities that they become the primary detoxifying agents. Although many of
these technologies have been available for several decades, their complex chemistry
is still only partially understood. Consequently, modeling has been difficult and
the results of limited value. Nonetheless, modeling is needed and in Chapter 7,
Peyton presents results from his efforts to describe advanced oxidation systems
involving methanol, formaldehyde, and formic acid as pollutants. He concludes that
lower oxidant dose rates are more efficient for the destruction of dilute contaminants
and that, in the absence of promoters, H2O2 and UV radiation may be the most
appropriate combination in many situations.
Solute species may also be destroyed using anaerobic reduction rather than ox-
idation chemistry. One possibility for inducing such chemistry lies in freshwater
lake sediments. In Chapter 8, Wiegel et al. discuss aspects of using isolates of
methanogenic sediments to degrade 2,4-dichlorophenol. They conclude that each of
the probable sequential degradation steps is catalyzed by a different microorganism.
Dechlorination is apparently rate limiting. Nonetheless, they were able to obtain a
fast growing, dehalogenating, and stable enrichment culture.
A wastewater stream typically contains many species that must be controlled.
Currently, experimental measurements are essential to characterize degradation be-
havior (e.g., using a biological process), and such studies are often time-consuming
and expensive. On the other hand, a generalized, theoretical procedure for estimat-
ing degradation rates may be achievable. Desai et al. present one possible technique
for characterization using respirometry data and molecular structure in Chapter 9.
They present Monod kinetic parameters for the substituted phenols.
The historical practice of solid waste disposal in near-surface facilities (e.g., landfills,
land disposal sites, low-level radwaste burial grounds, etc.) becomes more expensive
and difficult as available land and high-quality groundwater resources continue to
diminish. Extensive site characterization (ΓΓ) and monitoring (18,19) efforts are
now required, but they do little to mitigate the public controversy surrounding any
new site selection process. Increasingly, generators arefindingit more beneficial to
minimize waste quantities while maximizing recycle and reuse.
Historical practices, either deliberate or accidental, have left numerous site lega
cies that must be managed. While much of the public concern rightly focuses on
species migration and groundwater contamination, more effective remediation and
control may result from soil management and on-site treatment practices. In some
instances, modified site operations, as well as chemical and biological treatment
technologies, will have useful roles in solids management.
tor ash. Left untreated, many incinerator ashes are hazardous wastes because of
their toxic metal content. In particular, ash residues from coal and municipal solid
waste incineration must often be controlled. These authors point out, however, that
such ashes may be fabricated into concrete blocks which are then used to form reef
barriers. They report leachability and stability test results suggesting that this op-
tion is environmentally acceptable. Their studies further indicate that reef blocks
fabricated from such incinerator ashes have maintained their physical and chemical
integrity in the ocean environment without adversely affecting marine life.
In Chapter 20, Bostick et al. describe treatment and disposal options for " T c .
This radioisotope exhibits relatively high bioaccumulation factors when released to
the environment. Although it is a synthetic isotope resulting from the operation of
light-water nuclear power reactors, its behavior shares a common feature with more
common toxic species such as Pb and Hg. Namely, it is immobilized by reducing
Downloaded by 111.68.103.227 on March 9, 2011 | http://pubs.acs.org
Publication Date: March 8, 1990 | doi: 10.1021/bk-1990-0422.ch001
conditions. In this case, iron filing are useful in removing both Hg and " T c from
a dilute aqueous solution. Iron filings also reduce species leaching rates from grout
waste forms.
The last two contributions are concerned with recycle. Campbell et al. discuss
the use of fluorine peroxide to separate Pu from ash residues in Chapter 21. They
describe a low-temperature volatility process that offers improved capabilities for
decontaminating transuranic wastes, particularly incinerator ash. It also has poten-
tial applications at sites producing UO2 light water reactor fuels from UFe where
uranium-contaminated ash and CaF2 are generated.
Solvent wastes are also a significant hazard. Too often, used solvents are illegally
disposed as orphan wastes in landfills or unmarked burial grounds. In Chapter 22,
Joao et al. describe a simple, but effective, method for recycling toxic solvent wastes
that are generated in peptide synthesis. Their contribution emphasizes the impor-
tance of recycle to minimize waste production and disposal costs, as well as solvent
costs. The best waste management techniques are not always the most obvious or
the simplest approaches. However, the best methods always reduce both costs and
waste quantities.
Summary
While the contributors to this volume address different problems, there are common
threads. Anaerobic bacteria, for example, apparently have an important role to play
in decreasing toxicity in soil systems through species degradation. These bacteria
may also retard the migration of many organic and inorganic species through their
maintenance of a chemically reducing environment. Microorganisms may also play
important roles in water purification through their immobilization and the exploita-
tion of their naturally occurring bioaccumulative properties.
Our a priori ability to predict species degradation rates in wastewaters may be
limited in the foreseeable future. The chemistry of dilute wastewaters is usually
complex and, while we can predict general trends, meaningful quantitative analysis
without experimentation is more elusive. Group contribution theory is probably
one useful key, but considerably more work is needed and unexpected interactions
between solutes, affecting their degradation rates in mixtures, are likely.
Waste stabilization and degradation are both important, especially for existing
wastes. Recycle, however, will doubtless become increasingly important, especially
in the chemical industries and for the management of future wastes. Increased efforts
are needed in all of these areas and in the development of integrated strategies for
modifying management approaches in the waste producing industries. In many
instances, acceptable methods must be found for either reducing or eliminating
hazardous waste production altogether. In cases where waste production cannot be
eliminated, intraprocess recycle may prove essential to the economical production
of environmentally acceptable waste forms.
Literature Cited
Downloaded by 111.68.103.227 on March 9, 2011 | http://pubs.acs.org
Publication Date: March 8, 1990 | doi: 10.1021/bk-1990-0422.ch001