Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
3, JULY 2005
Abstract—This paper presents the design of a harmonic source the difficulty in determining the proper architecture. In [9]
detection system with a cascade correlation network (CCN). Cur- and [10], a partial connecting network was proposed to detect
rent-injection-based harmonic power flow was used to calculate harmonics in the active filter; however, the training process is
bus voltages and total harmonic distortion (THD). THD of volt-
ages is used as indices for meter placement in the power network. still very slow. Architectural design and the time-consuming
At metering buses, it shows that the harmonic components of volt- process have become the weaknesses in ANN applications.
ages under various loads would form particular patterns in the fre- The cascade correlation network (CCN) was proposed in
quency domain, and can be used to create training examples for this paper for harmonic source detection. With the independent
CCN. Good meter planning is helpful to reduce the number of me- training process and the predetermined number of hidden units,
ters and training examples. With an IEEE 14-bus power system,
computer simulations were conducted to show the effectiveness of the size of ANN can be effectively controlled. CCN [12], [13]
the proposed system. functions by dynamically adding hidden units to the ANN
architecture. Event-independent hidden units were added one
Index Terms—Cascade correlation network (CCN), harmonic
source detection, total harmonic distortion (THD). by one to maximize the correlation. Only a minimum number of
hidden units are necessary to build the network. The algorithm
learns quickly and is capable of constructing a near-optimum
I. INTRODUCTION network with high generalization capability.
Utility companies have the responsibility of maintaining low-
M ODERN technology promotes power electronics which
has become more and more popular in recent years.
These nonlinear loads could create a lot of harmonic currents
voltage distortion. If sufficient harmonic measurements exist,
the utility may estimate better the location of the distorted loads.
to downgrade the power quality. Harmonic distortions cause However, the cost of measurements is an issue, and choosing
problems, such as equipment overheating, motor failures, proper measurement points is an important research topic [2],
misoperation of protective equipment, inaccurate metering, and [3]. The proposed CCN will have the advantages of minimum
sometimes interference with communication circuits. Harmonic metering with a limited number of training examples created at
currents also endanger the sensitive high-tech customers such measurement points only. It is also flexible to structural changes.
as those in the science park of Xin-Zhu and Tai-Nan in Taiwan, In addition, the type of harmonic generating device could be
R.O.C. Recently, the massive rapid transit system (MRT) and further identified by the proposed algorithm. A sample power
high-speed railway (HSR) have been rapidly developed [8]. system will be studied for example. Computer simulations will
With extensive applications of semiconductor technologies in also be shown with test results provided.
the large-scale auto-traction systems, the harmonic distortion
problems could grow worse. To ensure the power quality now II. PROBLEM DESCRIPTION
and in a future deregulated industry, harmonic source detection Harmonics could create distorted waves and degrade the
is important. It is also important to further detect the location voltage quality to impair the operation of electrical apparatus.
and equipment types. In a future deregulated power industry, distribution companies
Applications of artificial neural networks (ANNs) have or major customers might connect to the transmission network
been presented in dealing with the problem [6]–[11]. Many re- through self-owned substations. Facing a fragmented power
searchers have applied ANN to locate harmonic sources [6]–[8], system, the access for measurements will become difficult
and detect harmonics in the active filter [9]–[11]. Applications due to various ownerships. In [4], it shows that system-wide
of multilayer back-propagation network (BPN) [6]–[8], [11] harmonic levels can only be estimated from a given set of
are widely accepted in the power system. However, training harmonic measurements. Locations and the number of mea-
BPN is time consuming and very slow without guaranteed surements need to be chosen in such a way to ensure the system
global minimum. Another problem of multilayer networks is observability. It is obvious that obtaining harmonic measure-
ments will be limited by the cost and the various ownerships
Manuscript received October 21, 2003; revised July 27, 2004. Paper no. in the future. Full observability of the network may not be
TPWRD-00369-2003. easily attainable. Reference [5] provided a study for partially
W.-M. Lin and C.-H. Wu are with the Department of Electrical Engineering,
National Sun Yat-Sen University, Kaohsiung 80424, Taiwan, R.O.C. (e-mail: observable measurements for part of the networks.
wmlin@ee.nsysu.edu.tw). Measurements of current and voltage harmonics are essen-
C.-H. Lin is with the Department of Electrical Engineering, Kao- tial for the reliable distribution of electric energy. Reference [1]
Yuan Institute of Technology, Kaohsiung 821, Taiwan, R.O.C. (e-mail:
eechl53@mail.educities.edu.tw). highlights a few guidelines for measurements. It suggests the
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPWRD.2004.843462 folowing:
0885-8977/$20.00 © 2005 IEEE
LIN et al.: MULTIPLE HARMONIC SOURCE DETECTION AND EQUIPMENT IDENTIFICATION WITH CCN 2167
reached, where is a preset tol- Step 3) Trace the key buses and determine
erance. meter placement according to the
Step 4) If acceptable error limits have bus geometry.
been reached, the candidate unit 1) Point: If the bus is an iso-
becomes a hidden unit. Generate a lated island, place a meter.
new candidate unit 2) Line: If two or more buses
and freeze the weights. Go to connect to become a line, place
Step 1 until all hidden units are a meter on the line.
trained. 3) Polygon: If a few buses con-
nect to become a loop, place a
meter in the loop.
B. Meter Placement
In a power system, harmonic sources could affect the branch
currents and node voltages. Harmonic measuring should be per- C. CCN Training Process
formed from time to time at selected points with existing har-
monic distortion as background noises before locating harmonic
With harmonic power flow [15, Appendix], we can calculate
sources. THD is used to define the total harmonic voltage dis-
harmonic voltage components at key buses. For example, the
tortion. It is commonly used in low-, medium-, and high-voltage
harmonic voltage components of a rectifier are ,
power systems. THD is defined by
where is the harmonic order, is any positive integer
, and is the pulse number of the rectifier circuit
.
Let each meter monitor harmonic sources, there will be
(8) training stages. Training processes for CCN were stated in
(2)–(7). For stage 1, the first hidden unit will be added to the
where network with adjusted weights according to training examples.
total harmonic voltage distortion; Other hidden units are added, one unit per stage, with the same
harmonic component of voltage; process until the maximum number is reached. CCN acquires
fundamental component of voltage; harmonic components of voltages from supervisory control and
bus number; data acquisition (SCADA) and the architecture of CCN are de-
harmonic order . termined with 1) the number of input units being equal to the
Harmonic source also causes voltage distortion for neigh- number of harmonic orders; 2) the number of hidden and output
boring buses. As the cost of the harmonic measurement is units being equal to the number of monitored harmonic sources;
expensive, proper measurement is an important research topic and 3) the number of biases being equal to the number of mon-
[2], [3]. Meter placement adopted by the state estimation (SE) itored harmonic sources.
can provide guidelines in this arena [5], [7], where algorithms Although the limit to the number of units in each layer is not
are available to optimize the meter number and locations. Al- a constraint, the performance of CCN is directly related to its
though the measurement of optimization is not a major concern physical size. A careful evaluation is important for CCN to min-
in this paper, a systematic method is still proposed to reduce imize the parameters for training. With the independent training
the number of meters. The method is designed by making process, for example, and the predetermined number of hidden
use of the network geometry, means to be easy rule-of-thumb units, the size of CCN can be effectively controlled to avoid the
without needing profound theories as SE, and proves to be overfitting problem from free parameters and random weights.
straightforward and effective by considering only the geometric If the monitored power network becomes too large, a proper
distribution of harmonic sources. An in-depth study and opti- partition should be plotted to ensure the CCN performance. Be-
mization work can be further carried out in future research. sides, proper meter placement with a partially observable, lim-
ited number of training data can be preplanned including various
load combinations to reduce the data requirement for CCNs.
Step 1) With harmonic power flow for var- In real-world applications, training data could be periodically
ious load conditions, calculate collected by portable recording instruments placed at measure-
bus voltages and . ment points. With possible noise and other uncontrollable ef-
Step 2) Sort and find buses with fects, CCNs must learn the varying spectral patterns of the envi-
(IEEE Std. 519-1992 ronment and harmonic sources. The patterns could be extracted
recommended). Select the key from either the system operating data or real-world monitors at
buses as buses with harmonic in- measurement points. Constant or other background noises could
jection (i.e., containing har- be regarded as training data for detection. Effects of the unpre-
monic devices), where harmonic dictable noise will be tested in a later section to show the ro-
measurement data can be avail- bustness of the proposed method. Extra training examples can
able. be collected for a data update and added to the active database.
LIN et al.: MULTIPLE HARMONIC SOURCE DETECTION AND EQUIPMENT IDENTIFICATION WITH CCN 2169
For the sample system, there are three chosen paths for
measurements (i.e., Bus 4 Bus 7 Bus 9, Bus 10 Bus 11,
and Bus 6 Bus 12 Bus 13) in Fig. 3. Note that the plan does
not require the entire power system to be observable. The
paths were chosen according to the geometric distribution of
harmonic sources as straightforward point, line, or polygon.
Measurement points can be used to assess harmonic levels and
identify harmonic sources. Fig. 4 shows the various harmonic
load combinations with a measurement point at Bus 12. It has
to be noted that the adjacent Bus 11 is also included since Bus
11 has a harmonic source. The harmonic sources at the nearest
next neighboring buses will be considered in our tests, while the
second next neighboring buses are electrically far enough to be
ignored in our example. It can be seen that a 14 set of training
examples could be collected at Bus 12 by running harmonic
power flow, which yielded 14 input–output training pairs. The
process can also consider various load combinations and work
duration such as intermittence load (dc motor). Input patterns
Fig. 2. Architecture of the HDS.
are harmonic voltages in frequency spectrum, and all harmonic
voltages are normalized according to the largest voltage level
before training. The HDS was designed on a Pentium III PC
D. Architecture of the HDS with 128-MB random-access memory (RAM) and Matlab
Architecture of the proposed HDS based on CCN is shown in software. To show the effectiveness of the proposed HDS, a
Fig. 2. For a 3-m example, HDS includes the SCADA interface, few case studies are chosen for demonstration.
three structured CCNs (CCN1–CCN3), and display generation.
HDS can be used to detect harmonics with data acquired from A. Effectiveness Test
digital harmonic measuring equipment. When the waveform is
recorded with suitable bandwidth, analog or digital techniques The number and location of meters, architectures of CCNs,
can be used to perform the spectral analysis. In Fig. 2, the output the number of training examples, and the executing time for
values of are evaluated by CCNs with values between 0 and training CCNs are shown in Table III. For example, at M1-Bus
1. For ample harmonic injections, will be close to “1;” oth- 4 and M2-Bus 10, we have a 28 set of training data for Bus 4
erwise, close to “0.” A fair value 0.5 is used as a threshold in and Bus 10. At M3-Bus 12, with a dc motor as the bus load,
this paper to separate the existence of harmonics from nonex- a 35 set of training data were created with 14 set for full rated
istence. A value greater than 0.5 or less than 0.5 can also be and full rated plus 5% load, 14 set for half-rated and half rated
used as a threshold according to various environments and ex- plus 5% load, and another 7 set for bus combinations without
periences. Display generation will provide a man-machine in- harmonic sources (i.e., the dc motor stops running). With mul-
terface (MMI) to show the results. In display generation, the se- tiple harmonic sources at Bus 4, Bus 6, Bus 7, Bus 10, Bus
lection sort is used to find the maximum value in output [16]. 12, and Bus 13, harmonic power flow calculates harmonic volt-
Following the identification of the harmonic source, HDS will ages to perform the spectral analysis. Fig. 5 shows harmonic
further identify the type of nonlinear devices from checking the voltages at M1-Bus 4, M2-Bus 10, and M3-Bus 12 After HDS
database. training, three harmonic detectors identify the harmonic sources
and equipment as shown in Table A.
TABLE I
TEST CASES FOR SAMPLE POWER SYSTEM
TABLE II
PLANS OF METER PLACEMENT
TABLE A
RESULTS OF CASE STUDY A
TABLE B
RESULTS OF CASE STUDY B
TABLE V
METER LOCATIONS AND ARCHITECTURES OF CCNS FOR CASE STUDY D
and work duration. Old training examples must be modified by E. Performance Comparison
the effect of new harmonic sources, and CCN needs to be re- Table VI shows the comparison chart of BPN and CCN.
trained with new training examples. Case study D shows the Training BPN is very slow. The training time is approximately
2172 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 20, NO. 3, JULY 2005
TABLE C
RESULTS OF CASE STUDY D
TABLE VI
COMPARISON BETWEEN BPN AND CCN
[5] S. S. Matair, N. R. Watson, K. P. Wong, V. L. Pham, and J. Arrillaga, Chia-Hung Lin was born in 1974. He received the
“Harmonic state estimation: A method for remote harmonic assessment B.S. degree in electrical engineering from the Tatung
in a deregulated utility network,” in Proc. Int. Conf. Electric Utility Institute of Technology, Taipei, Taiwan, R.O.C., in
Deregulation Restructuring Power Technologies, London, U.K., Apr. 1998, the M.S. degree in electrical engineering from
4–7, 2000, pp. 41–46. the National Sun Yat-Sen University, Kaohsiung,
[6] R. K. Hartana and G. G. Richards, “Harmonic source monitoring and Taiwan, R.O.C., in 2000, and the Ph.D. degree in
identification using neural networks,” IEEE Trans. Power Syst., vol. 5, electrical engineering from National Sun Yat-Sen
no. 4, pp. 1098–1104, Nov. 1990. University in 2004.
[7] Y.-Y. Hong and Y.-C. Chen, “Application of algorithms and artificial -in- Currently, he is with the Department of Electrical
telligence approach for identifying locations of harmonic sources in dis- Engineering, Kao-Yuan Institute of Technology,
tribution systems,” in Proc. 19th Symp. Electrical Power Engineering, Kaohsiung, where he has been since 2004. His
Taiwan, R.O.C., Nov. 1998, pp. 884–888. research interests include fault diagnosis in power system, neural-network
[8] C.-H. Wu and C.-R. Chen, “Apply artificial neural network to power computing, and harmonic analysis.
system in detecting the positions of the harmonic sources,” in Proc. 21st
Symp. Electrical Power Engineering, Taiwan, R.O.C., Nov. 2000, pp.
329–333.
[9] N. Pecharanin, H. Mitsui, and M. Sone, “An application of neural net-
work for harmonic detection in active filter,” in Proc. IEEE World Congr.
Computational Intelligence, Int. Conf. Neural Network, vol. 6, 1994, pp.
3756–3760.
[10] , “Harmonic detection by using neural network,” in Proc. IEEE Int.
Conf. Neural Network, vol. 2, 1995, pp. 923–926.
[11] A. A. M. Zin, M. Rukonuzzaman, H. Shaibon, and K. L. Lo, “Neural
network approach of harmonic detection,” in Proc. Int. Conf. Energy
Management Power Delivery, vol. 2, 1998, pp. 467–472.
[12] M. Hamamoto, J. Kamruzzaman, and Y. Kumagai, “Network synthesis Keng-Pang Tu was born in 1968. He received
and generalization properties of artificial neural net using Fahlman and the B.S. degree in electrical engineering from the
Lebier’s learning algorithm,” in Proc. 35th Midwest Symp. Circuits Syst., Oriental Institute of Technology, Taipei, Taiwan,
1992, pp. 695–698. R.O.C., in 1989, and the M.S. degree in electrical en-
[13] E. Littman and H. Ritter, “Cascade network architectures,” in Proc. Int. gineering from the National Sun Yat-Sen University,
Joint Conf. Neural Networks, vol. II, Baltimore, MD, 1992, pp. 398–404. Kaohsiung, Taiwan, R.O.C., in 2003.
[14] D. W. Patterson, Artificial Neural Networks: Theory and Applica- His research interests include harmonic analysis in
tions. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1996. power system and neural-network computing.
[15] Y. H. Yan, C. S. Chen, C. S. Moo, and C. T. Hsu, “Harmonic analysis for
industrial customer,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 30, no. 2, pp. 462–468,
Mar./Apr. 1994.
[16] S. Lipschutz, Theory and Problems of Data Structures. New York: Mc-
Graw-Hill, 1986.