Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
PROJECT REPORT
ON
FARIDABAD
1
ING VYSYA BANK
FARIDABAD , HARYANA.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
2
Finally I express my sincere gratitude to all those who directly or
indirectly helped me in the successful completion of this project.
CONTENTS
Page no.
Executive summary…………………………………………………
1. Introduction…………………………………………………….
3. Objectives ………………………………………………………
4. Scope……………………………………………………………..
5. Methodology…………………………………………………….
5.1 Sample……………………………………………………….
5.2 Research instrument……………………………………..
3
6. Data collection & interpretation……………………………
7. Conclusion …………………………………………………
8. Recommendation …………………………………………
9. Limitation …………………………………………………
References…………………………………………………
Annexure……………………………………………………
4
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
5
To study the service quality of ING VYSYA bank’s corporate
salary account.
To do a SWOT analysis of ING VYSYA bank.
For the comparison I have visited some of the banks and used the
internet for the data; while to measure the service quality I have
conducted a survey for the customers of ING Vysya and collected data
from them. And based on this I have done the SWOT analysis.
2. Due to RBI guide lines which have been some what restrictive for
foreign players, ING Vysya cannot be blamed solely for being
unpopular. It is expected that in the time to come when these
guide lines would be eased ING Vysya would be able to utilize
more resources and would be able to establish itself more
efficiently.
6
i) It offers PAP cheque books to its customers where as
other banks don’t.
ii) It offers 2 free DD/PO to its customers where as banks
like standard chartered don’t
iii) It opens the salary accounts even at lower averages
where as other banks are stringent in this respect.
iv) In this period of post recession ING VYSYA Bank had
come up with an initiative of innovative banking product
called ING FORMULA Savings Account for the Formula 1
Fans residing in metro cities of India with an additional
offering of Party vouchers of night clubs worth Rs.3000 ,
w.e.f. 1st August 2008.
7
1. INTRODUCTION
ING Vysya Bank Ltd., is an entity formed with the coming together of
erstwhile, Vysya Bank Ltd, a premier bank in the Indian Private Sector
and a global financial powerhouse, ING of Dutch origin, during Oct
2002.
The origin of the erstwhile Vysya Bank was pretty humble. It was in the
year 1930 that a team of visionaries came together to found a bank
that would extend a helping hand to those who weren't privileged
enough to enjoy banking services. It is one of the oldest private sector
banks offering banking products and services to retail and corporate
customers. Its business has been organized into Retail Banking and
Wholesale Banking.
Being new on the ground ING Vysya is making all its efforts to compete
with its competitors in the best possible way. In its retail banking I got
this opportunity to work and do the comparative analysis of Aspira
account which is the salary account of the bank and measure its
service quality, the reason I was given this project was the newness of
the bank and hence its necessity to be aware of where it stands as
compared to its competitors, how its products differ from its
competitors, and how is it perceived by its competitors. To measure
this perception I used the SERVE QUAL tool and surveyed its
competitors.
8
As suggested by the faculty guide I also covered the rest of the liability
products i.e. the savings account and the current account of the bank
and compared its features with other banks namely; ICICI, HDFC, Yes
bank, ABN Amro bank and Standard Chartered bank, to increase the
knowledge about all the products and enhance my learning.
Finally I also did an over all SWOT analysis on the basis of data that I
collected and knowledge of the present scenario that I gathered during
my summer internship about the banking sector.
9
1.1COMPANY PROFILE
ING Vysya Bank Ltd., is an entity formed with the coming together of
erstwhile, Vysya Bank Ltd, a premier bank in the Indian Private Sector
and a global financial powerhouse, ING of Dutch origin, during Oct
2002.
The origin of the erstwhile Vysya Bank was pretty humble. It was in the
year 1930 that a team of visionaries came together to found a bank
that would extend a helping hand to those who weren't privileged
enough to enjoy banking services. It is one of the oldest private sector
banks offering banking products and services to retail and corporate
customers. Its business has been organized into Retail Banking and
Wholesale Banking.
Its Retail Banking business comprises four business units namely
Consumer Banking, Small and Medium Enterprises (SME) Agriculture
and Social Banking Unit (ASBU) and Private Banking. It’s banking
products and services for retail customers include both loans and
liabilities products and services. It offers a range of credit products
including home loans, automobile loans, commercial vehicle loans, two
wheeler loans, dealer financing, personal loans, debit cards, credit
cards, loans against term deposits and loans against shares. It offers
loans and fee-based services to small and medium enterprises. It
finances agricultural activities and government-sponsored schemes. Its
deposit products include demand deposits (savings and current
accounts) and time deposits, with specific products for customers in
various segments, like salary accounts, accounts for small and medium
enterprises and non-resident Indian accounts. Our other retail products
and services include private banking, fund transfer facilities and utility
bill payment services.
10
Its Wholesale Banking is organized into three groups, Client Coverage,
Products and Services and Financial Markets. While the Client
Coverage group is responsible for managing relationships with
identified client subgroups, the Products and Services and Financial
Markets groups are responsible for product and service delivery to the
entire Wholesale Banking client base.
Savings Accounts
Out of the following one can choose the product suiting the most to
their requirements and pockets.
• Orange savings account
• Freedom account
• Formula savings account
11
Current account
Small, medium and large businesses alike will find that ING Vysya
Bank's current account offerings come with all the benefits needed to
stay ahead of competition. Whatever the size or scope, one will find a
current account option exclusively designed for him/her.
ICICI BANK
12
industry. The principal objective was to create a development financial
institution for providing medium-term and long-term project financing
to Indian businesses. In the 1990s, ICICI transformed its business from
a development financial institution offering only project finance to a
diversified financial services group offering a wide variety of products
and services, both directly and through a number of subsidiaries and
affiliates like ICICI Bank. In 1999, ICICI become the first Indian
company and the first bank or financial institution from non-Japan Asia
to be listed on the NYSE.
13
in March 2002, and by the High Court of Judicature at Mumbai and the
Reserve Bank of India in April 2002. Consequent to the merger, the
ICICI group's financing and banking operations, both wholesale and
retail, have been integrated in a single entity.
Today, ICICI Bank is India's second-largest bank with total assets of Rs.
3,793.01 billion at March 31, 2009 and profit after tax of Rs. 37.58
billion for fiscal 2009. ICICI Bank is the most valuable bank in India in
terms of market capitalization and is ranked third amongst all the
companies listed on the Indian stock exchanges in terms of free float
market capitalisation*. The Bank has a network of about 1438
branches and 4,600 ATMs in India and presence in 19 countries.
ABN AMRO
14
most complicated cross-border transactions, yet we also understand
the subtleties of local markets.
HDFC BANK
15
& Development. HDFC main focus is on their employees' career
development so that their aspirations can meet company’s goals.
From the early 90s, Standard Chartered has focused on developing its
strong franchises in Asia, the Middle East and Africa using its
operations in the United Kingdom and North America to provide
customers with a bridge between these markets. Secondly, it would
focus on consumer, corporate and institutional banking, and on the
16
provision of treasury services – areas in which the Group had particular
strength and expertise.
In the new millennium we acquired Grindlays Bank from the ANZ Group
and the Chase Consumer Banking operations in Hong Kong in 2000.
17
2. REVIEW OF LITERATURE
18
the more developed economies. But many products and services in the
emerging markets compete at their expected product levels (Kotler,
2003). In some industries, the competition is at the basic product
levels or core benefits. Market differentiation can be achieved through
the way products and services are delivered; creating satisfying
customer experiences about the company, employees and the delivery
process; but this may not create the necessary competitive advantage
for growth. Even in the business environments where the competition
is at the augmented product level, it would be pertinent to know the
relative strengths of industry specific aspects of “what is offered”
versus “how it is offered”. Whether a below expectations service
outcome is considered more important by customers or if an improper
service delivery process and employee interaction is viewed more
serious. Focus only on functional quality dimensions of service quality,
therefore appears to be misplaced. Only a few studies have recently
tried to empirically explore the outcome dimension of service quality
(Kang and James 2004; Jain 2005). The present study fills the gap and
looks at the relative importance of service quality dimensions in the
Indian banking sector.
The study that was conducted had final sample
consisting of 131 usable questionnaires. The primary data was
collected by personally administering the questionnaire. Mean age,
household income and education level of the sample is 29 years, Rs
21,000.00 and some college education respectively. Government
service, private service and own business is represented by 25, 25 and
26.5 percent of the participants. The sample had 91% male
respondents. Nationalized banks represent 97% of the banks
patronized by the participants. Data was collected in the month of
February 2005.
Evidence of convergent validity was examined through simple
correlation with the independently measured overall quality score.
19
Corresponding correlations with independently measured overall value
score were used for observing discriminant validity. It was found that
the service quality dimensions had internal consistency; however
outcome quality could not establish convergent validity and
discriminant validity conclusively. The results buttress the
multidimensional structure of service quality. Though some service
quality dimensions are found to be similar to the ones posited in five
dimensional model, the model as such is not supported in banking
services. As expected, in the study, the functional quality dimensions
of responsiveness, assurance, empathy and tangibles do not have
much significance for customers. Results however do not support the
proposition that outcome quality dimension would emerge to be the
important dimension. Reliability is found to be the vital dimension in
customers’ perception of service quality.
The findings of this study have important managerial
implications. Customers regard reliability to be the most important
dimension of services in banks. Reliability dimension is the descriptor
of the functional quality and outcome quality (Brady and Cronin, 2001).
This implies that the banks should be able to perform what they
purport to perform – whether it is the functional quality aspect or the
outcome quality aspect. Ignored in widely used measurement
instruments, outcome quality features such as there should not be
queues for withdrawals, making demand drafts etc have been found to
be lagging behind the customers’ expectations and therefore warrant
improvement. A moderate sample and a non parsimonious scale are
some of the limitations of the study. The operationalisation of outcome
quality needs improvement through further exploratory work.
20
3. OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY:
4. SCOPE
21
The project is mainly concentrated on the corporate sales of the bank
i.e. on the ASPIRA account, which is the salary account of the bank, its
comparative analysis and SWOT analysis. It also include the service
quality delivered to and perceived by its customers using the serve-
qual tool and comparison of rest of the liability products with similar
products of other banks namely ICICI Bank, HDFC Bank, ABN AMRO
Bank, and YES Bank.
This would help the bank to measure its standing as compared to
its competitors and find out where it lacks and needs improvement.
The survey conducted on its customers of salary accounts provided
valuable information as, what features are liked by them and which are
not, and what are the areas where they feel ING Vysya needs
improvement. This exercise also made its customers feel that ING
Vysya wants to improve and is looking forward to their feedback so in a
way it helped in improving its relationship with its customers.
5. METHODOLOGY
22
I visited the banks to meet bank personnel who could guide
me about the various features offered by them as part of their liability
products.
3. With the help of data so collected a SWOT analysis was done after
visiting various banks, talking to various people through personal
interviews.
5.1 SAMPLE
The sampling frame was provided by the bank from its data base out of
which 30 companies were surveyed consisting of approximately 10
employees each. The study was conducted with the cooperation of the
management and ING Vysya’s customers who took the valuable time
out of their schedules to fill my questionnaire and give their feedback
about ING Vysya’s services.
The questionnaire used in this study followed the five basic dimensions
of SERVEQUAL instrument developed by Parasuram. The instrument
includes 7 items on special instruction from my industry guide because
he wanted the questionnaire to be as short as possible so that the
23
customers are not bothered much and they don’t feel irritated while
answering them. The customers and management were asked to mark
their levels of perception and expectation respectively on a five-pointer
scale. The gap hence found between the perception and expectation
was administered consistently to find out the meaningful results.
The questionnaire is given in the annexure.
For the first part which is the comparative analysis of liability products,
data was collected by visiting the banks and finding on their respective
websites.
For the second part i.e. SERVE QUAL, primary data from 300
respondents was collected in 30 companies to measure the service
quality gap. The number of respondents from the management side
was 12, which were the part of corporate salary team. Personal
interviews with some employees were also conducted to know the
problems they encountered in detail. The response rate both at the
companies I visited and at the bank was 100%.Reliability was tested
using one way ANOVA to test whether any significant difference exist
in the perceptions and expectations of customers and management
respectively for all the parameters of SERVE QUAL model and are
shown separately.
And finally on the basis of the findings of the study a SWOT analysis
was conducted.
The names of the companies from which the data was collected are
given in appendix.
24
1. Given below are the features of different liability products offered by
ING Vysya bank and after ward their comparison with similar products
of other banks namely ICICI Bank, HDFC Bank, ABN AMRO Bank, and
YES Bank.
There are two types of salary account offered by ING Vysya Bank.
25
i) Advantage salary account. (Avg salary less than 25,000)
26
• AAA cash deposits are restricted to two transactions with a value
not exceeding RS. 50,000/- per month. Service charge of RS
100/- for every month that the account is overdrawn.
27
• Free Unlimited ATM transactions in over 25,000 (Cirrus) ATM’s in
India.
• Shopping convenience at over 200,000 merchant locations, with
the ING Vysya International Debit card.
28
• Free four ATM transactions per month in over 25,000 other Bank
ATM's in India.
• Shopping convenience at over 200,000 merchant locations, with
the ING Vysya International Debit card.
• Free issue of personalized chequebooks.
• Free Electronic Bill Payment service -at select centers.
• Free Transfer of funds across all networked branches.
• Free Statement of Account through E-mail at no charge.
• Mi-b@nk - Internet banking facility
• Customer Service Line facility
• Conversion from other type of accounts to the Freedom Savings
Account is not allowed.
• Annual Maintenance Charge of Rs.1000/- + taxes to be collected
in advance, upfront from the Customer every year.
29
• Enhanced ATM cash withdrawal limit of Rs. 50,000/- per day in
own ATMs / other bank ATMs.
• Free issue of DDs up to Rs. 50,000/- per month without
commission/charges.
• Free Internet Banking facility (special looks & feel for ING
Formula MiBank customers , Value added benefits like games /
quiz/Formula 1 trivia etc.
• Free SMS alerts to customers on transaction value > Rs.1500/-
• Free bill pay facility through internet banking.
From personalized cheques that get treated at par with local ones in
any city where we have a branch, to Free collection (if instruments are
lodged directly) of outstation cheques (payable at branch locations), to
free inter-city funds transfers of up to 200 lakhs per month, the bank’s
priority services have become the benchmark for banking industry.
There are three products under ING Vysya’s current account, they are:
• General current account
• Advantage current account
• Orange current account
30
Features of ING Vysya’s current account are:
i) General account
• Free remittance limit (DD/ PO/ PAP/ RTGS/ EFT/ NEFT) of Rs. 50
lakhs p.m.; power packed features with potential to save upto
Rs.1.20 lakhs p.a.
31
• Free collection of outstation cheques at all branches of the Bank
on local collection basis. #
• Free unlimited transfer of funds within the Bank
• Easy anywhere cash deposit and withdrawal (up to specified limit
for self only)
• Personalized cheque books and personalized payable at par
cheques
• Free SMS alerts *
• Free standing instructions facility * for regular payments
• Free ATM cum debit card with access to any ATM, of any bank ^
• Avail safe deposit locker facility (where available) on a
preferential basis
• Free 24 hours Customer Service Line (toll free)
• Multiple channels to access your account and many more
32
• Free remittance limit (DD /PO /PAP /RTGS /EFT / NEFT) of Rs.2
crores per month; power packed feature with potential to save
upto Rs.4.8 lakhs per annum.
• Free collection of outstation cheques at all branches of the Bank
on local collection basis .
• Free mi-b@nk Internet Banking facility.
• Free unlimited transfer of funds within the bank.
• Easy anywhere cash deposit and withdrawal (upto specified limit
for self only.
• Free personalized cheque book (including PAP cheques).
• Avail safe deposit locker facility (where available) on a
preferential basis.
• Free ATM cum debit card with free access to any ATM of any
bank.
• Free 24 hours Customer Service Line (toll free).
• Multiple channels to access your account.
• Free standing instructions facility for regular payments and many
more
33
* Saving of Rs.4.8 lakhs per annum is calculated at 20 ps. percent and
is subject to usage of full limit of free remittance package of Rs.200
lakhs
Per month On the Cirrus network.
34
High AUM per customer and low High AUM per customer & good
revenue per customer. revenue generation per customer
Faridabad
Low AUM per customer and low Low AUM per customer but good
revenue per customer revenue generation per customer
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
35
6.1.1 Comparative analysis of ING VYSYA Bank’s
salary account features with other banks.
36
Min balance to be Zero Zero
maintained
ATM card Free of cost to every Free of cost to every
account holder account holder
Internet banking Available Available
*Reimbursement account:
37
If you opt to disburse/reimburse the travel, food etc. expenses via
reimbursement accounts, a reimbursement account can be opened
simultaneously along with the Salary Account savings bank account,
which would be linked together with the debit card already held by
your employee.
Though features of both the banks are almost similar but the repute
enjoyed by ICICI is commendable. The reason for this could be the time
span by which ICICI came earlier and cashed on the opportunity of
establishing it self in all the spheres. Other reasons could be:
1. Wide network of its branches and ATMs all over India, which
makes it reliable.
2. Strong brand recognition in the minds of people.
3. Its facility of letting the customer transfer its fund online
instantaneously where as in case of ING Vysya it takes one whole
day to make it effective, though both the banks provide this
facility of net banking.
4. A positive point with ING Vysya is that it offers free PAP cheque
books to all of its orange salary account holders where as it is
chargeable in case of other banks.
5. While talking to some customers of ICICI they complained about
some hidden charges, which they said they never mentioned in
the beginning (though they refused to disclose what these
charges were.)
II) ING VYSYA V/S HDFC
38
products in case of salary accounts, classic and regular. Under classic,
employees having monthly income Rs.7500 to Rs.14999 open their
accounts while in regular; employees having their monthly income
above Rs.15000 have their accounts. Its comparison can be done on
following grounds:
Issue of international Free for every body Only for regular salary
debit card account holders
Safe deposit lockers Not Available Subject to availability
39
Available, at 18% for no. Available at 1.5%+ 12%
OD facility of days overdrawn (service charge) for no.
of days overdrawn
HDFC again is one of the most renowned and respected banks in our
country and has the advantage of coming in to existence earlier, over
ING Vysya. The brand value that it enjoys is commendable and it
seems that it is one of the reasons why people prefer HDFC over ING
Vysya. Apart from this other reasons contributing to it could be:
1. Wide network of its branches and ATMs all over India, which
makes it reliable.
2. Strong brand recognition through advertisements and other
sources.
3. RBI guide lines doesn’t allow ING VYSYA which is an MNC bank to
open their ATMs in company premises which is not the case with
banks like HDFC and ICICI hence companies which are already
with these banks and enjoy this facility cant switch over even if
they want to.
40
Reimbursement
savings account for Not available Available
expense-
reimbursement
PAP cheque books Free for orange salary Not available
account holders and Rs.2
per leaf for advantage
salary acc
Cash delivery Not available Available
YES bank like ING Vysya is new on the ground and is similarly striving
for existence. Though within a short span, it has gained a strong
foothold but still it has a long way to go.
41
separate product, which is advantage salary account, ING Vysya
entertains even those.
• On the other hand YES Bank gives unlimited ATM transactions
with its associated banks to its customers as it knows that it
doesn’t have sufficient number of ATM outlets, where as ING
allows only 6 ATM transactions to be free of cost.
42
month you required it
extra.
ii. ING Vysya bank gives the OD facility where as Standard Chartered
doesn’t.
43
V) ING VYSYA V/S ABN AMRO BANK
44
Issue of free Available Available, Rs.20 for
Personalized cheque issue of next cheque
books book
Free phone banking Available Available
As we can see that features of ING Vysya and ABN Amro bank are
almost same but both the banks are new and have a long way to go.
iii. ING Vysya offers 2 D.D’s/P.O.’s free of cost where as ABN Amro
doesn’t.
45
i) ING VYSYA V/S STANDARD CHARTERED BANK.
46
Balance enquiry Free Rs.20
47
amt greater than 50,000 account.
48
Regular debit card Free for first year then Rs.180
Rs.150 per annum.
D.D. Rs.50 for amt up to Rs.50 on own branches
Rs.10,000;Rs.2.50 per 1000 0.25% on other’s
for amt up to 50,000;Rs 2 branches.
per 1000 for amt greater
than 50,000
Pay order (P.O.) Same as above.
49
statement per month.
50
NO. OF PRODUCTS Two: orange savings Three products: regular,
account and freedom savings plus & savings
account max; each of which are
further divided into
option 1 and 2.(I have
taken comparative
product that is option 1
of regular savings acc.)
Average quarterly Rs.5,000 on orange, and Rs.5000
account balance nil for freedom
Fee for non maintenance Rs.600 per quarter Rs.750 per qtr.
of quarterly average
balance
Statement of account Quarterly free and Monthly statements to be
monthly e-statement free Collected from branch.
(if asked for). Quarterly statements
sent by post
ATM usage 4 free for freedom First 4 withdrawals free
account, unlimited free of cost from any cirrus
on cirrus for orange network ATM
account holders ;un
limited from ING Vysya
Regular debit card Free for first year then Rs.100 plus taxes
Rs.150 per annum.
D.D. Rs.50 for amt up to Rs.50 for amt up to
Rs.10,000;Rs.2.50 per 10000, Rs.75 for amt
1000 for amt up to greater than 10000 and
50,000;Rs 2 per 1000 for up to up 50000, Rs. 2.50
amt greater than 50,000 per 1000 or part thereof
(Min Rs.150) for amt
greater than 50000
Pay order (P.O.) Same as above. Same as above.
Branch transaction Free for both Free 3 free in the qtr &
Rs. 60 per additional
transaction on non-
51
maintenance of Min
balance (cash
deposit/withdrawal)
Personalized cheque Free Free, Rs.5 per leaf on non
books maintenance of Min
balance
Balance enquiry Free Free
6.1.3. The comparison of ING Vysya’s current account
with similar product of other banks is given below:
52
ATM usage Free usage of ING Vysya, Free usage of HDFC bank
Rs.45 on withdrawal from ATMs.
other banks
Issue of international Free for 1st year, Rs.150 Free for first year
debit card there after
Transfer from one Free for all Free for all
account to other
(intercity)
D.D/P.O. Free as per schedule for Free up to 50 DDs per
GCA, free up to 50 lkhs month. Above 50
per month then charges transactions, charges @
as per schedule for rest, Rs. 25/- per DD for plus,
in case of ACA and for Free up to 30 DDs per
OCA free up to 200 lkhs month. Above 30
then charges as per transactions, charges @
schedule on the greater Rs. 25/- per DD for trade;
amount. DD Amount Up to Rs.
50,000 charges Rs. 40/-
per DD, Above Rs. 50,000
and up to Rs. 100,000-
Rs. 25/-, Above Rs.
100,000- Free for
premium and DD Amount
Up to Rs.50,000 charges
Rs.40/- per DD, Above
Rs.50,000 and up to
Rs.100,000- Rs.25/-,
Above Rs.100,000- Free
for regular.
Charges for PAP cheque Rs.0.50/1000 with a min Free in the manner as
payments of Rs.5 per payment in stated above.
case of GCA, free up to
cumulative value of 50
lkhs pm then same is
followed as in GCA, for
53
OCA free up to a
cumulative value of 200
lkhs pm then same is
followed as in GCA.
Balance enquiry Rs.15 for all Rs.25 for all
54
Statement of account Free once in a Free once in a month.
month(physical or e-mail)
Issue of cheque book Rs.2.5 per cheque leaf Only payable at par
for GCA and free for cheque books( charges
others given below)
ATM usage Free usage of ING Vysya, Free usage at ABN AMRO
Rs.45 on withdrawal from and Rs.5 at UTI banks
other banks and Rs.20 at cirrus
network.
Issue of international Free for 1st year, Rs.150 Not available
debit card there after
Transfer from one Free for all Free, unlimited
account to other (with in
own bank, intercity)
D.D/P.O. Free as per schedule for Rs.200000 pm at 0.20%
GCA, free up to 50 lkhs with min of Rs.50 for
per month then charges value+silver40;
as per schedule for rest, Rs.2000000 pm at 0.15%
in case of ACA and for with min of Rs.50 for
OCA free up to 200 lkhs value + gold 100;
then charges as per Rs.4000000 pm at 0.15%
schedule on the greater with min of Rs.50.
amount.
Charges for PAP cheque Rs.0.50/1000 with a min Rs.225 for 25 leaved
payments of Rs.5 per payment in cheque book for value+
case of GCA, free up to silver 40, same cheque
cumulative value of 50 book free for the rest.
lkhs pm then same is
followed as in GCA, for
OCA free up to a
cumulative value of 200
lkhs pm then same is
followed as in GCA.
Balance enquiry Rs.15 for all Rs.5 at UTI and Rs.20 at
cirrus network.
55
III) ING VYSYA V/S STANDARD CHARTERED BANK
56
(intercity)
57
Average quarterly Rs.10000 for general CA, Rs.25000, Rs.75000,
balance Rs.50000 for advantage Rs.200000 and
CA, & Rs.100000 for Rs.500000 respectively
orange CA for the above products.
Fee for non maintenance Rs.750 pq for GCA, Rs.1000, Rs.1500,
of AQB Rs.1500 pq for ACA, & Rs.2000, and Rs.4000
Rs.4000 pq for OCA. respectively for the
above products
Statement of account Free once in a Free once in a month.
month(physical or e-mail)
Issue of cheque book Rs.2.5 per cheque leaf Rs.2 per leaf for CA 25
for GCA and free for and unlimited free for the
others rest.
ATM usage Free usage of ING Vysya, Information not available.
Rs.45 on withdrawal from
other banks
Issue of international Free for 1st year, Rs.150 Information not available.
debit card there after
Transfer from one Free for all Rs.25 lakhs per month
account to other subsequent 0.50 per
(intercity) Rs.1000 for CA 25, Rs.50
lakhs per month
subsequent 0.50 per
Rs.1000 for CA 75, and
unlimited for the rest.
D.D/P.O. Free as per schedule for DD:2 Free Per Month
GCA, free up to 50 lkhs Min-Rs.100 Max-Rs.5000
per month then charges for CA 25, 5 Free Per
as per schedule for rest, Month
in case of ACA and for subsequent Rs.1.75 per
OCA free up to 200 lkhs rs.1000 or part there of
then charges as per Min- Rs.100 Max-Rs.5000
schedule on the greater for CA 75, 5 Free Per
amount. Month subsequent
Rs.1.50 per rs.1000 or
58
part there of
Min- Rs.100 Max-Rs.5000
for CA 200 and free for
CA 500.
PO: 2 Free Per Month
Subsequent 0.75 per
Rs.1000. Min- Rs.75 Max-
Rs.5000 for CA 25, 5 Free
Per Month. Subsequent
0.75 per Rs.1000. Min-
Rs.75 Max- Rs.5000 for
CA 75 and free for the
rest.
Charges for PAP cheque Rs.0.50/1000 with a min Free unlimited
payments of Rs.5 per payment in
case of GCA, free up to
cumulative value of 50
lkhs pm then same is
followed as in GCA, for
OCA free up to a
cumulative value of 200
lkhs pm then same is
followed as in GCA.
Balance enquiry Rs.15 for all Information not available.
SERVEQUAL ANALYSIS
59
6.2.1 The results of the study include analysis of the perception and
the expectation gap of between the customers and the management
respectively. Here,
• Table # 3 shows the overall gap between the perception and the
expectation.
TABLE # 1
Tangibles
60
Assurance
Extent to which you are well informed and aware about all 6.50
products and facilities, which are provided by bank’s
literature and staff.
Responsiveness
7.90
Extent to which you are satisfied with the staff of the bank
and their act of helping you in solving your diverse
problems and giving you prompt solution.
Reliability
The bank’s services are as per the norms and reliable in 8.92
all respects
Empathy
61
Extent to which you feel bank’s services are made for you 8.77
TABLE # 2
Tangibles
Assurance
Responsiveness
62
The staff of the bank helps customers in solving their
diverse problems and giving them prompt solution.
6.91
Reliability
9.25
Empathy
7.16
Bank’s services are made as per the customer needs and
staff also try to help them in all situations
6.91
63
Table # 3: aggregated dimensional scores
To study the service quality of ING Vysya bank, all those companies
which were surveyed were categorized in to three categories/groups
on the basis of their average salary uploaded and type of current
account, they have in the bank.
64
• Group 2 had those companies whose average salary was either
above Rs.10, 000 or was below Rs.10, 000 but had normal
current account also.
ANOVA: Single
Factor (TANGIBLES)
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
(P-E)GROUP1 10 -7.8 -0.78 0.494136
-
(P-E)GROUP2 10 6.68462 -0.66846 0.104142
(P-E)GROUP3 10 -3.7 -0.37 0.273778
65
ANOVA
Source of
Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups 0.898734 2 0.449367 1.545888 0.231401 3.354131
Within Groups 7.8485 27 0.290685
Total 8.747234 29
Here we can see that ‘F’ value is less than the ‘F crit’ hence we accept
the null hypothesis that there is no difference between the groups as
far as tangibles are concerned.
a) The bank is new, though it is trying to give best of its services but
still facilities can be provided in a better manner when there is a strong
network of branches. In NOIDA there is just one branch of ING Vysya
bank which is not sufficient to serve the customers in a better manner.
So in this case even the bank knows that it lacks and needs
improvement and has fewer expectations which match the perception
so there is no much difference between the groups.
b) Same is the case with no. of ATMs which even the bank knows so it
has rated itself lower in tangibles.
66
2. Ho: There is no significant difference among the groups of
companies with regards to ‘assurance factor’ offered by the bank.
ANOVA: Single
Factor (ASSURANCE)
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
0.03001
(P-E)GROUP1 10 -1.58333 -0.15833 5
3.80769 0.04444
(P-E)GROUP2 10 2 0.380769 4
0.23288
(P-E)GROUP3 10 8.7 0.87 9
ANOVA
Source of
Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
5.29149 25.8248 3.35413
Between Groups 3 2 2.645746 6 5.39E-07 1
2.76613
Within Groups 9 27 0.10245
8.05763
Total 1 29
67
Here it can be seen that ‘F’ value is greater than ‘F critical’ hence we
reject the null hypothesis and so there exist some difference between
the groups regarding assurance of the bank.
Under reliability it was asked to people if they are
informed about various products and schemes that are launched by
the bank through any means and to this we received different answers
and it proved to be a weak area for the bank in terms this difference.
According to me reasons for this could be:
68
3. Ho: There is no significant difference among the groups of
companies with regards to ‘responsiveness factor’ offered by the bank.
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
0.10925
(P-E)GROUP1 10 7.3 0.73 9
0.05101
(P-E)GROUP2 10 10.64615 1.064615 9
0.23333
(P-E)GROUP3 10 13.8 1.38 3
ANOVA
Source of
Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between 2.11311 1.05655 3.35413
Groups 6 2 8 8.052796 0.001808 1
3.54250 0.13120
Within Groups 5 27 4
5.65562
Total 1 29
Here we can see that ‘F’ value is greater than the ‘F critical’ hence we
reject the null hypothesis and there exists difference between the
groups.
Under responsiveness the question was regarding the employees that
if they listen to their problems and give them prompt solutions.
According to me for the whole span of two months during which I
69
worked for the bank I saw that each employee be it of any hierarchy
use to listen to problems of those who came to bank, very sincerely so
there is no doubt that they don’t listen. But reasons for the difference
in service quality could be due to following:
b) For all those who came to the branch with their problems there is
not a single case when the problem wasn’t solved. The main
problem here again lies with the network of branches and ING
Vysya seriously needs more number of branches in NCR.
70
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
(P-E)GROUP1 10 7.183333 0.718333 0.025386
(P-E)GROUP2 10 5.1 0.51 0.026561
(P-E)GROUP3 10 5.9 0.59 0.090667
ANOVA
Source of
Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups 0.220907 2 0.110454 2.323483 0.1172 3.354131
Within Groups 1.283525 27 0.047538
Total 1.504433 29
Here, ‘F’ value is less than the ‘F critical’ value hence the null
hypothesis is accepted and there is no difference between the groups
regarding reliability of the bank.
Under reliability we asked the customers if they feel
secure about their possessions and if they feel that bank’s services are
as per the norms of the RBI to which almost all of them rated between
8 and 10 which shows that the bank is credible in the eyes of its
customers and all the customers are treated in the same manner by
the bank.
71
ANOVA: Single Factor (EMPATHY)
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
0.05563
(P-E)GROUP1 10 17.35 1.735 3
16.8307 1.68307 0.03839
(P-E)GROUP2 10 7 7 6
(P-E)GROUP3 10 18.6 1.86 0.02
ANOVA
Source of
Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between 0.16540 0.08270 2.17589
Groups 9 2 5 4 0.133006 3.354131
1.02625
Within Groups 7 27 0.03801
1.19166
Total 6 29
For empathy also the value of ‘F’ is less than the ‘F critical’ hence the
null hypothesis is accepted that there is no difference between the
groups regarding empathy shown by the bank.
Under empathy it was asked to customers if they feel that bank
understands the customer needs and provide the solutions as per the
needs and if they feel that bank’s services are made as per their
requirements to which most of them replied in
72
Following is the graphical representation of average perception scores
given by the 30 companies for various parameters of SERVE QUAL
model. Where
1. Tangibles:
20 19
15
10 Series1
7
5 4
0
0
2.0-4.0 4.1-6.0 6.1-8.0 8.1-10.0
73
Extent to which customers are well informed and aware about all
products and facilities, which are provided by bank’s literature and
staff.
25
21
20
15
Series1
10 8
5
1
0
0
2.0-4.0 4.1-6.0 6.1-8.0 8.1-10.0
3. Responsiveness
The staff of the bank helps customers in solving their diverse problems
and giving them prompt solution.
74
RANGE OF SCORES GIVEN BY COMPANIES FOR
RESPONSIVENESS
14 13
12
10
10
8
6 Series1
6
4
2 1
0
0
5.0-6.0 6.1-7.0 7.1-8.0 8.1-9.0 9.1-10.0
4. Reliability:
It represents the average range of scores for the following two
questions-
The bank’s services are as per the norms and reliable in all respects
75
RANGE OF SCORES GIVEN BY COMPANIES FOR
RELIABILITY
20 17
15
11
10 Series1
5 2
0
7.1-8.0 8.1-9.0 9.1-10.0
Bank’s services are made as per the customer needs and staff also try
to help them in all situations
76
RANGE OF SCORES GIVEN BY COMPANIES FOR
EMPATHY
24
25
20
15
Series1
10 6
5
0
0
7.1-8.0 8.1-9.0 9.1-10.0
6. Besides the research, part of my job was also the corporate sales i.e.
I was suppose to sell the salary account of the bank. So for that I use to
first make a cold call in the companies, find out which bank are they
with for salary account purpose and how would they like to switch to
ING Vysya. Some companies open such accounts in 2-3 banks also so I
used to convince them to make ING Vysya at least their second choice.
While making the sales call for pursuing companies to open the salary
accounts of their employees in ING Vysya bank, there emerged a
picture of how popular different banks are. Given below is a graph
based on that picture of approximate market share hold by the banks.
77
On an average out of 100 calls made 26 said they are with ICICI and
doesn’t want to change, 23 said they are with HDFC and are satisfied,
5 said they are with ABN Amro and want to continue, 10 said they are
with standard chartered bank and are satisfied with their services, 3
were with YES bank and have tied up recently so cant change.
SWOT ANALYSIS
SWOT Analysis of ING Vysya Bank Ltd.:
Strengths Weaknesses
78
Opportunities Threats
79
Pie-Chart # 1: share of banks found, when sales call was made
market share
ICICI
HDFC
ABN AMRO
STANDARD
CHARTERED
YES BANK
OTHERS
80
6.3 SWOT ANALYSIS
STRENGTHS:
The bank has got the biggest asset in the form of its association with
the ING Group of Netherlands, which is a well-known
financial house world over. The brand is considered to be a high quality
service provider.
2. Marketing strategy.
The bank has very well targeted the market and is focusing on high net
worth clientele. It gives a lot of stress in strategy making to take an
edge over other bank.
Though the bank is new on the ground but still it has endeavored to
make its mark in the minds of people through various sales promotion
techniques like calling celebrities like Amrita Arora for inaugurating an
ATM outlet and Ricky Ponting to give a speech on team work.
81
WEAKNESS:
Though the bank has a tie up with no. of banks which let its customers
withdraw money from there at least 6 times a month but still to make
its presence feel having a strong ATM network is very much necessary.
OPPORTUNITY
82
1. Indian multinational
2. Globalization
THREATS:
This is one of the biggest threats that it has in front of itself. The
banking sector is witnessing and is expected to witness more players
in future. Many of the FIs are thinking of converting into banks
corporate houses are planning to launch their banks.
Bargaining power of the buyers will be high, as they will be having lot
of service providers to choose from. This will force bank to improve
their service and emphasize upon the customer relationship
management for their survival.
83
7. CONCLUSION
2. Due to RBI guide lines which have been some what restrictive for
foreign players, ING Vysya cannot be blamed solely for being
unpopular. It is expected that in the time to come when these
guide lines would be relaxed ING Vysya would be able to utilize
more resources and would be able to establish itself more
efficiently.
84
a. YES bank gives unlimited ATM transactions with its partner
banks to all of its customers where as it offers only to
orange customers
b. ICICI facilitates immediate transfer of funds which is not
the case with ING
c. Customers also complain about its late salary transfer.
8. RECOMMENDATIONS
1. The bank should first of all try to increase its network by opening
more and more branches and ATM outlets because in order to be
there in the minds of the people it should be seen every where
like ICICI and HDFC.
85
c. Delay in transfer of online funds.
d. Problems with the statement of accounts that many of
them haven’t received it.
e. These are some problems which are related to operations
and management needs to device some technique to
speed up the whole process.
86
87
9. LIMITATIONS
88
REFERENCES:
http://www.ingvysyabank.com/scripts/retailbankin
g.aspx
http://www.ingvysyabank.com/scripts/About_overv
iew.aspx
http://www.icfaiuniversitypress.org/
http://www.icfaiuniversitypress.org/507/pb.asp
www.icicibank.com
www.hdfcbank.com
www.standardchartered.co.in
www.abnamro.co.in
www.yesbank.in
http://www.iimk.ac.in/GCabstract/Ashwini
%20Awasthi.pdf
89
APPENDIX
Questionnaire
Age Designation:
Annual Salary:
up to Rs.1,00,000 Rs.1,00,000 to
90
2. Extent to which you are well informed and aware about all
products and facilities, which are provided by bank’s literature
and staff.
3. Extent to which you are satisfied with the staff of the bank and
their act of helping you in solving your diverse problems and
giving you prompt solution.
5. The bank’s services are as per the norms reliable in all respects
91
6. Extent to which you feel that your bank understands your needs
and gives solutions as per your needs.
7. Extent to which you feel bank’s services are made for you and
staff also try to help you in all situations
92
Names of the companies who are customers of ING Vysya Bank and
from which data for SERVE-QUAL was collected.
F-26,BASEMENT
WINGS SALESLAJPAT NAGAR-III,91-11-
4 PROMOTIONS NEW DELHI-110024 41720582/83
A-85-86 SECTOR-63,91-120- MR. RAJU RANJAN
5 SONAL GARMENTS NOIDA 4321634-36 AZAD
C-161, PHASE-II,
PROGRESSIVE EXTENSION-NOIDA- 91-120- MR. ARVIND
6 INFOTECH (P) LTD. 201305 4393939 KUMAR AGARWAL
93
A-18 & 21, SECTOR-
SAWHNEY 6, NOIDA COMLEX,
8 BROTHERS GHAZIABAD 91-120- MR. G D PANDE
B-48, HOSIERY
IL JIN ELECTRONICSCOMPLEX, PHASE-II,91-120- MR. KULDEEP
9 (I) PVT. LTD. NOIDA,201305 4323981/83 RASTOGI
PACETEL
COMMUNICATIONS B-14, SECTOR-58,91-120- MR. NEERAJ
10 PVT. LTD. NOIDA-201301 2587224/5 SRIVASTAVA
91-120-
SUNLORD APPARELSD-12, SECROT-3,2524582/25296
11 MFG. CO. LTD. NOIDA-201301 55/2527296 MR. A K AGARWAL
C-1/2, SECTOR-31,91-120-
17 FINAL DIAGNOSIS NOIDA-201301 2451452 MR. PRADEEP MEGI
94
B-37, SECTOR-91-120-
SUPERHOUSE 59,PHASE-III, NOIDA-2584819/25858 MR. RAJEEV
19 LEATHERS LIMITED 201301 19/2584877 BHATNAGAR
RENESAN
SOFTWARE INDIABSN-4 LOGIX PARK,91-120- MR. PRAVEEN
23 PVT. LTD. SECTOR-16, NOIDA 6417162 GULATI
ABSOTHERM
SERVICES C-8, SECTOR-4,1
24 PVT. LTD. NOIDA 0120-4243771 MR. NEGI
PLOT-22, UDYOG
VIHAR, GREATER MR. RAVINDRA
25 TAREX NOIDA 0120-2560830 SINGH
C-14, SECTOR-2,
26 ROTOPQWER NOIDA 9899416133 MR. PAVITRA
UDYOG VIHAR,
27 YAMA MOTORS GREATER NOIDA 9810367705 MR. PRADEEP
MR. SANJAI
28 KOUSTOCOM 0120-3053814 SRIVASTAVA
95
A-5, SECTOR 64, MR.SANJEEV
29 B.L. INTERNATIONAL NOIDA 9968400550 CHOWDHARY
3©WORLD TRADE
TOWER NEW
ASCENT CREDITBARAKHAMBA LANE,
30 SERVICES PVT. LTD. NEW DELHI-110001 9891966220 MR. MUKESH
96