Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Title:
Cowry Shells: Fertility/Fecundity Symbols in Southern Calfiornia Iconography
Journal Issue:
Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology, 23(1)
Author:
Koerper, Henry C, Cypress College
Publication Date:
2001
Publication Info:
Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology, UC Merced Library, UC Merced
Permalink:
http://escholarship.org/uc/item/1z6919vc
Keywords:
ethnography, ethnohistory, archaeology, native peoples, Great Basin
Abstract:
Ornamental employment of Chestnut Cowry (Cypraea spadicea) shell artifacts in southern
California prehistory included inlay work set into the rims of mortars and bowls. These and other
observations are marshaled to develop circumstantial evidence pointing to a linkage of cowry
shells with sex-based symbolism. More direct evidence from J. P. Harrington's notes connect the
cowry symbolically to the vulva.
Figure 1. Cvpraea spadicea (Chestnut Cowry) specimens (a) Back-punched cowry, CA-ORA-855; (b) Back-removed cowry,
CA-ORA-855; Outer lip cowry inlay, CA-ORA-855; (d) Outer lip cowry inlay, CA-ORA-855, with illustration of its position in
the shell; (e) Outer lip cowry inlay from the Medea Creek collection (courtesy UCLA Fowler Museum of Cultural History
Archaeological Collections Facility); (f) Cowry pendant (after King 1982:501).
%
^
Figure 5. Pestles: (a) Courtesy Mission San Juan Capistrano Museum collection; (b) Bonita Site (CA-ORA-107), excavated
by WPA (Courtesy Santa Ana College collection); CA-ORA-660, Newport Coast Archaeological Project.
Story that attributed "all stone mortar holes, in representations of numerous southern California
situ as well as portable, to the coyote, who pestles and in the associations of pestle-like
e m p l o y e d an a g e n c y of m a n u f a c t u r e t h a t artifacts with other objects inferred to embody
d e c e n c y d e b a r s from m e n t i o n " ( K r o e b e r sexual content. With mortar as female element,
1925:528). Many Native Californian and Great cowry decorations encircling a mortar opening
Basin peoples recognized Coyote as the maker are best explained as visual enhancements of
of bedrock mortars and/or portable mortars (e.g., vulvar imagery, a palpable argument since so
Gifford and Kroeber 1937:138; Driver 1937:68; many cultures associate the cowry shell with
Voegelin 1938:17; Steward 1941:286; Stewart r e p r o d u c t i o n or a r e l a t e d t h e m e . This
1941:381; Aginsky 1943:406). Speculatively, the perspective is expanded below.
m e t a p h o r i c product of mortar and pestle in
congress may build on conditions where modes DISCUSSION
of production and environmental settings at least
periodically bring special immediacy to issues Notwithstanding the generally phallic
of life forces, h u m a n fertility, and nature's morphology of virtually all pestles, artisans
bounty. occasionally provided these tools with priapic
Pestle as phallus is writ large in the graphic e n h a n c e m e n t s that exceeded any compelling
32
JOURNAL OF CALIFORNIA AND GREAT BASIN ANTHROPOLOGY
Figure 6. "Spikes"from CA-ORA-278, the Corona del Mar site, found in association with a steatite birdstone (dimorphic
sexual symbol) and a perforated steatite disc. (Anon. 1938a:73; and Winterbourne 1967:21).
Utilitarian necessity (Lee 1981:50; Hudson and at a village site in Pacific Palisades, numerous
B l a c k b u r n 1 9 8 3 : 1 2 2 - 1 2 7 ) (Fig.5). Equally spikes occurred with numerous birdstones (Fig.
revealing are certain pestle-like artifacts (Fig.6 7) (Wallace 1987). Not all miniature pestle-like
a n d 7), often l a b e l e d " s p i k e s , " w h i c h are artifacts exhibit the k n o b b e d stylistic
c h a r a c t e r i s t i c a l l y k n o b b e d at one end and convention, including one of the two specimens
t a p e r e d at t h e i r o p p o s i t e e n d ( s e e Van from Corona del Mar At CA-ORA-365, several
Valkenburgh 1931; Anon. 1938a; Winterbourne m i n i a t u r e p e s t l e s w i t h o u t k n o b s , a knob
1967:20-21; Butler 1974:65, 67; Wallace 1987; fragment, a small pestle remarkable for its phallic
Koerper and Cramer 1988:101; Koerper et al. naturalism, and a small bird stone had all been
1 9 9 6 : 5 ) . Georgia Lee ( 1 9 8 1 : 5 0 ) c o r r e c t l y c a c h e d w i t h i n a ball of clay (N. Whitney-
recognized that such spike-shaped artifacts are Desautels, personal communication 1997).
phallic representations. When phallic imagery develops from pestles,
Not surprisingly, spikes have been found in m o r t a r s evoke, ipso facto, vulvar imagery.
direct association with those dimorphic sexual Further abetting the symbolic intent are those
symbols known variously as "bird s t o n e s , " cowry inlays that are set into the rims of mortars.
"pelican stones," and "hook stones" (see Koerper The artifacts' decorative purpose is a feminizing
and Labbe 1987, 1989; Koerper et al. 1995). Two one. Fernando Librado, in recalling a large
s p i k e s were found c a c h e d t o g e t h e r with a mortar bearing "half cowry" inlays, informed J.
"birdstone" (Fig. 6) at the Corona del Mar site P Harrington that "the teeth of the cowries were
(Anon. 1938a; Winterbourne 1967:20-21), and fixed inside the mortar" (Hudson and Blackburn
COWRY SHELLS: FERTILITY/FECUNDITY SYMBOLS IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA ICONOGRAPHY 33
1982:16-17; Begole 1984:22-23, 26-27) as well 1938b Report of the San Joaquin Home
as d i m o r p h i c s e x u a l s y m b o l s k n o w n as Ranch Excavation, March 28- July 25,
" b i r d s t o n e s , " " p e l i c a n s t o n e s , " and " h o o k 1938, WPA Anthropological Project
stones" (Koerper and Labbe 1987, 1989). The #7680. MS on file at UGl Library,
employment of cowry insets on mortar and bowl Special Collections.
r i m s is c o n s i s t e n t w i t h t h e c r o s s - c u l t u r a l 1938c Daily Notes for the Banning Site,
association of the shell with fertility/fecundity. December 2 1 , 1937-February 10,
It is axiomatic in archaeology that past mindset 1938, WPA Anthropological Project
reconstruction yields more grudgingly to analysis #7680. MS on file at UCI Library,
than, say, diet reconstruction. Yet this discussion Special Collections.
demonstrates that through judicious handling of 1939 R e p o r t of Morro C a n y o n No. 2
circumstantial evidence within a cross-cultural Excavation, Oct. 27, 1938-Dec. 1,
perspective, insights into past mental constructs 1938, WPA Anthropological Project
might be productively explored. #7680. MS on file at UCI Library,
Special Collections.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Bascom, William
I am p a r t i c u l a r l y a p p r e c i a t i v e of Lisa 1980 Sixteen Cowries: Yoruba Divination
W o o d w a r d , w h o s e d i l i g e n c e in m i n i n g from Africa to t h e New World.
Harrington's legacy u n c o v e r e d reference to B l o o m i n g t o n , I n d i a n a : Indiana
cowry shells as symbols for the human vulva. University Press.
Ms. Woodward had previously attended my SCA
presentation (Koerper 2000) of this study and Begole, Robert S.
consequently was familiar with the author's quest 1984 Fertility Symbols in the Anza-Borrego
for relevant information. Eric De Vries offered Desert. Pacific Coast Archaeological
valuable linguistic assistance. Wendy Teeter of Society Quarterly 20(4): 13-28.
the UCLA Fowler Museum of Cultural History
Archaeological Collections Facility was most Burgess, C M .
generous with her assistance. I am grateful for 1985 Cowries of the World. Capetown,
the artistry of Joe Cramer who illustrated all S o u t h Africa: G o r d o n Verhoef
artifacts for this report, and I t h a n k Carey Seacomber Publications.
Cramer for producing the map of Figure 2. Karen
Koerper typed many drafts. The reviewers Butler, William B.
comments are appreciated. 1974 The San Pedro Harbor Site: A Primary
Subsistence Village on the Southern
REFERENCES California Coast. Pacific Coast
Aginsky, B. W. Archaeological Society Quarterly
1943 Culture Element Distributions: 10(3&4):l-98.
XXIV Central Sierra. University of
California Anthropological Records Cabrera, Lydia
8(4). 1974 Yemaya y Ochun. Madrid: Forma
Grafica.
Anonymous
1938a R e p o r t of E x c a v a t i o n s of T h r e e Driver, Harold E.
Coastal Rancherias, WPA Anthropo- 1937 Culture Element Distriburions: VI
logical Project #7680. MS on file at Southern Sierra Nevada. University
University of California Irvine Li- of California Anthropological Records
brary, UCI Special Collections. 1(2).
COWRY SHELLS: FERTILITY/FECUNDITY SYMBOLS IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA ICONOGRAPHY 35
Gobert, E. G. Kenyon, A. S.
1951 Le Pudendum Magique et le Probleme 1941 The Cowrie Shell in P r i m i t i v e
des Gauris. Revue Africaine 95:5-62. Currency. The Numismatist, May
issue: 341-342.
Gravel, Pierre
1995 The Malevolent Eye: An Essay on the King, Chester DeWitt
Evil Eye, Fertility and the Concept of 1981 The Evolution of Chumash Society:
Mana. San Francisco: Peter Lang. A Comparative Study of Artifacts
Used in Social System Maintenance
Harrington, J. P. in the Santa Barbara Channel Region
1986 John R Harrington Papers, Vol.3: South- Before A.D. 1804. Ph.D. dissertation.
em California/Basin. Washington, D.G.: University of California, Davis.
Smithsonian Institution, National An-
thropological Archives. [Microfilm edi- King, Linda Barbey
tion. Millwood, N.Y.:Kraus International 1982 Medea Greek Cemetery: Late Inland
Pubhcations]. C h u m a s h P a t t e r n s of Social
Organization, Exchange and Warfare.
Hogendorn, Jan, and Marion Johnson Ph.D. dissertation. University of
1986 The Shell Money of the Slave Trade. California, Los Angeles.
New York: Cambridge University
Press. Koerper, Henry C.
2000 Cowry Shells: Fertility/Fecundity
Hudson, Travis Symbols in S o u t h e r n California
1977 Chumash Wooden Bowls, Trays, and Iconography. Paper presented at the
Boxes. San Diego: San Diego Museum Society for California Archaeology
Papers 13. annual meetings, Riverside.
36 JOURNAL OF CALIFORNIA AND GREAT BASIN ANTHROPOLOGY
Voegelin, Erminie W.
1938 Tiibatulabal Ethnography. University
of California Anthropological Records
2(1).
Wallace, William J.
1987 A Remarkable Group of Carved Stone
O b j e c t s from Pacific P a l i s a d e s .
Pacific Coast Archaeological Society
Quarterly 23(l):47-58.
Wiedmann, Hope
n.d. The Subsistence and Material Culture
of the Chumash as Taken from the
Ethnographic and Linguistic Notes of
John P. Harrington. UnpubUshed MS
prepared under Dr Michael Glassow,
D e p a r t m e n t of Anthropology,
U n i v e r s i t y of California, S a n t a
Barbara.
Winterbourne, J. W.
1967 R e p o r t of t h e Goff's Island Site
Excavation, May 1, 1939 to January
22, 1940 (WPA). Pacific Coast
Archaeological Society Quarterly 3(2
&3).
38 JOURNAL OF CALIFORNIA AND GREAT BASIN ANTHROPOLOGY