Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
DECISION
PANGANIBAN,
:
R
*
The Facts
* #
#
R
!
#
c
#
#
&$
#
*
$
#
&
%
*
#
c
R
&
%
*
+'
#
c
R
$
*
*
#
( #
c
R
)$R
R
(
%
)
&
R
c,
*
*
*
R
#
#
c,&
#
!
c,
R
#
)
*
($
#
R c#c#c
c%#
#
c
R
&
*
R
R
&
*
&
R
#
!
$
&
&(
)
)
!
)
&*
)
&'
( +
(
The Issues
)
!
+$
!
&
c R.
R
R
R
$
R
c R c cRR #cc R Rc
R#%c#/R c#cRRc cR c
cRR %%c R 0cR %c#
R #R #R
& R c #% R c R !#ccc R
R R #cc c,c R#%c c c
#Rc c+ & #Rc,
R c c RRR
R c #% !#ccc R
R c,c R #cR#R # # R c
c,c#c c!R%c c# /
!#c
* #% / # #
Rc#c#c R R c c,c#c
c#/R #R #!R !#c
c%c c
R c ##c cR cc Rc R c
R !#ccc R R c,c c R
# % c# ! R R R R
c R c R Rc#
c#R c R c
c#R ! Rc R
c#%c
$
R
*$
'(
$
R
R
+
&
,
R
,
&R
R
$
a) In the area of investment measures related to trade in
goods (TRIMS, for brevity):
&
National Treatment
0
#
!RR
*
*
R
#
% &( #
&&&
R
c,
TRIMS that are inconsistent with the obligation of
national treatment provided for in paragraph 4 of Article
III of GATT 1994 include those which are mandatory or
enforceable under domestic law or under administrative
rulings, or compliance with which is necessary to obtain
an advantage, and which require
*
*
R
shall be accorded
treatment no less favorable than that accorded to like
products of national origin
!RR
*(
,,%!RR *
*' )&R'&'*
!
R
R
* %
#
((
b) In the area of trade related aspects of intellectual
property rights (TRIPS, for brevity)
National Treatment
treatment no less favourable than it
accords to its own like services and service suppliers.
,%
!
R
% &'
#
&&)+
R
&$
')
&
# /
,
&
c
%
,%
'(
R
R
i
&)$
R
%
-
!
c
-
-
-
+
&
,
R
!
&
&($
&
&'$
&
$
+$
!
" #
#
$
+
,
'(
R
+
,
#
R
&$
R
R
R
#
Specific WTO Provisos Protect Developing Countries
c
$
%
&
' (
'
)
R
'(R
R
'$
R
*$
**$
*$
R
*)$R
&
"
R
R
R
*($
c
(
&
+
%
+
R
R
!
&*
)
#
R
R
R!RR
R
R
*'$
*
*
c &
*
&$
R
#
(
R
R
R
,,%!RR
)$
R
&(
($
R
'$
# & *i
*
!RR
*
!
R
R
+
*(
R
c
!RR
*(
&
*
$
#
)+$
#
##
R.
#
#
R
#
c R2
#
R
(
c
!
R
Epilogue
WHEREFORE
###c
SO ORDERED.
+
ã )
!
,
$
'
)
&
)
R
#
*)
!RR
*(The birth of GATT.+
*(
!
R
R
!RR
&
!R
R &
c
*)
R
RR R
#
*(
&
&+
!RRR
#
* +++
4+
!RR
R
)
R
*'R
R
!RR
*'Entry into force
*' !RR
R &
3
#
"
R
R
R
!RR
/
!R
!
*
Second Round at Annecy
#
+++
+Third Round At Torquay
+
' (++
c
&
*'
!RR
R
R
)Fourth Round at GenevaR
#
4&
!RR
'The Haberler Report. !RR
R
R
"
#
!
!RRR
!RR
R
R
c c
,,%)
!
)+The Dillon Round.R
#
cc
c
R
#
)&
* *++
4*
)The Short-Term Arrangement
!RR
R
)&
R
(*
)*The Kennedy Round.
R
"
#
)(
#
+
(
#
R
+
4*+
)A New ChapterR
)+
!
%
R
R
!RR
R
!RR
!RR
R
R
)'
R
!RR
R
R
(The Tokyo Round.R
#
#
(
4++
(+
*(
R
#
(*
(*
#
R
Multifibre
Arrangement
)R
R
('
'&
')
*
R
!RR
*(
R
&$
R
&
#
#
#
R "
#
#
#
#
#
#
"
# # c
c
c
#
# !
# !
#
! ! # !
!
# !
# !
"
#
" "
"
"
!
#
#
#
# #
#
#
"
#
#
"
3
#
# "
#
#
0
# #
#
"
%
!
#
"
#
# "
"
# R
"
R
R
# #
R
R R
R
c
"
!
c
#
% # 3 # 3
# 3
)& % #
R
$
*
R
R
c
!
#
R
#
*
R #
R
R
R
!RR
*
R
R
c
!
#
R
#
*
c
R
#
#
R
c
R
&
%
R
R #
R
R
R
!RR
*
c!# !#
&) &
%
+'
## ! R c #RR R c !#ccc R
cR !R c#R#c#! 3R
R
%
!c%#
)$
& +'
#
(
!
R
R
!
&'
(
($
R
R
&)
)
&
#
#
#
# c
c
c
c
! ! !
! !
!
! !
!
" " "
"
c
3
!
0
# #
"
%
5
!
#
R R
R R
R R
R
c
"
% 3
3
'$
) &)
$
&
)
)
R
+$
#
&)'
$
"
&*)#*+
(
%
%
R
! &*#*( )
"
! &
#') ** &
*
&$
c
# '
)
(
(*
&+ # (
& (
&)
$
!
!
&
# &) (
*$
R
+ +
$
% &
)$
(
R
R
($
#
*)
'$
'+#*
) &
'
$
*) &+*&+)
&+$
*
,% R
#
R
% *)
&$
R
(
'(
&&$
)&c
)
&$
& +
& &
- . +
%
'' c
&
! !# &&)
(
'
'(
&*$
&*) # *+ )* (
R
!# *
&
&$
(#& )' *
&)$
&&*#(
& '( +
&($
+
,
&'$
&
,
&
$
+$
,
$
!# &&)
( *
&$
,
$
*$
R
( %
$
)$
#
&&
($
,
'$
& /
c
0
# /
(&
$
*
,%
R
*) %
*+$
&
&
*$
&*
%
*&$
& &'
%
*$
&
**$
& /
c
*$
/ +
*)$
&'(
*($
0
*c
('
*(
#
# +#
)'
( &(
)
*'$
R
R #
R
*
)
*
$
#
R
%
&**
+$
%
$
#
R
%
&**
&$
$
*$
/ &'
&
+
$
R
Final Act Embodying the Results of the
Uruguay Round of Multilateral Trade Negotiations
#
R
c
R
c
R
R
&
R
R
R
#
R
*
c
*R
R
,%
R
R
*
R
R
R
!
R
R
!
!
R
)R
R
!
R#R !
#Rc
!
R
R
c
c
)$
)
($
)
'$
#
R
%
('
$
)+$
R)' #
)$
3
!#
+)
(
)
)&$
( # '
**
&
# *+
&
&) # *
) &(
&
)$
& # '*
*
*
+
)*$
&
)$
0
)
&'