Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
REVIEW
Towards a functional classification of the
freshwater phytoplankton
COLIN S. REYNOLDS1, VERA HUSZAR2, CARLA KRUK3, LUIGI NASELLI-FLORES4 AND SERGIO MELO5
1CEH ALGAL MODELLING UNIT, THE FERRY HOUSE, AMBLESIDE, CUMBRIA, LA LP, UK; 2LABORATORIA DE FICOLOGIA, MUSEU NACIONAL/UFRJ, SÃO
1975). The system works because the overlapping require- representation in conditions they had found favourable,
ments of individual species can often be satisfied simul- others will have been in decline because the same con-
taneously in particular locations, so long as the ditions were not altogether suitable for them. Our scheme
adaptations of each allow them to tolerate the conditions seeks to distinguish these behaviours, at least among the
obtaining. Most interestingly, such tolerances may require relatively more numerous species.
behavioural or physiological adaptations that are not ‘Associations’ is the word used by terrestrial plant ecol-
necessarily constrained by phylogenetic affinity: plant ogists. It has the merit of conveying the notion of a group
associations can be polyphyletic. of species responding similarly to a single set of environ-
When it comes to describing the structure of pelagic mental conditions, even when the positions in a fluid
communities however, most aquatic ecologists might be environment are more difficult to deal with. Yet this too
content to know that phytoplankton was present suffers a drawback in failing to acknowledge the fact that
(perhaps judged by its content of extractable chloro- some species may show analogous adaptations to similar
phyll). In contrast, specialists may well delight in being conditions but have yet to be found simultaneously ‘in
able to provide a full list of species, perhaps separated association’ at the same localities—thus, Cylindrospermopsis
according to criteria distinguishable only with an elec- and Anabaena minutissima show similar antennal properties
tron microscope or verifiable using polymerase chain and nitrogen-fixation capacities that suit them to turbid,
01reynolds (58J)(ds) 29/4/02 10:15 am Page 419
01reynolds (58J)(ds) 29/4/02 10:15 am Page 420
01reynolds (58J)(ds) 29/4/02 10:15 am Page 421
Table I: continued
As indicated, the groups A to C were devised originally with Merismopedia and Peridinium umbonatum (Group LO,
to apply to the vernally growing diatoms in temperate q.v.) during the filling and high-water stages (Melo and
lakes of differing trophic levels. Group A is characterized Huszar, 2000). Group B diatoms belong to more enriched
by a number of centric diatoms of the genus Cyclotella lakes, merging into Group C without precise boundaries.
(C. glomerata, C. comensis) and, especially, of Urosolenia (for- The large-celled Stephanodiscus (rotula, neoastraea) are indica-
merly Rhizosolenia) that are prominent in the plankton of tive of calcareous, often very phosphorus-rich, systems
many medium-to-large high-latitude lakes that are typi- where they may co-dominate with Asterionella and such
cally clear, dilute in solutes and deficient in phosphorus. species of Aulacoseira as A. ambigua. Asterionella and other
The algae in this group are mostly unicellular (103–104 Aulacoseira spp. (A. subarctica, A. islandica) and Cyclotella (C.
µm3 in volume), apparently have high affinity for nutri- meneghiniana, C. stelligera) co-exist in softer-water lakes.
ents, though not, apparently, for carbon. Its distinctiveness Diatoms of groups B and C form larger units (104–105
may earn the title ‘Urosolenietum’. The A association is also µm3 in volume) but shape contributes to the maintenance
represented in the clear, low-phosphorus Amazonian of high s/v and efficient light-harvesting. Population
flood-plain lake, Lago Batata, where it occurs together development is often subject to the availability of silicon
01reynolds (58J)(ds) 29/4/02 10:15 am Page 422
and dependence upon turbulence for suspension leaves genera, Spirulina, Arthrospira and Raphidiopsis that inhabit
them relatively sensitive to mixed depth and the seasonal warm, shallow and often very alkaline waters, was pro-
onset of near-surface density stratification. posed by Reynolds (Reynolds, 2000). The solitary habits of
Diatoms of Group D are mostly found in shallow, nutri- Cylindrospermopsis and Anabaena minutissima often in rela-
ent-enriched, well-ventilated waters, liable to be turbid. tively phosphorus-rich lakes and their tolerance of vertical
Small-celled (≤ 103 µm3 in volume) and fast growing, such mixing set them apart from other dinitrogen-fixing
diatoms include planktonic Nitzschia spp., Synedra acus, members of the Nostocales. They had been allocated
Stephanodiscus hantzschii, Cyclotella ocellata and, possibly, earlier to Group SN (Padisák and Reynolds, 1998).
Cyclotella pseudostelligera. At the other extreme of warm-water systems are the
Groups N and P also involve diatoms but both are clear, low-biomass oligotrophic and ultra-oligotrophic
associated either with lower latitudes or with the summer water columns in which relatively the largest biomass
period in temperate lakes. The dependence upon physical resides in the picophytoplankton. Group Z was an ad hoc
mixing is strongly apparent, requiring a continuous or creation to accommodate the organisms and what, at first,
semi-continuous mixed layer of 2–3 m in thickness. Both seemed to be their habitats. The significance of
associations can be represented in shallow lakes where the autotrophic picoplankton [photoautotrophs in the size
mean depth is of this order or greater, as well as in the range 0.2–2 µm: (Sieburth et al., 1979)] to the carbon flow
01reynolds (58J)(ds) 29/4/02 10:15 am Page 423
members of the nanoplankton. For the present, we retain Close to J is another group of (mostly) shallow-water
the Z category to refer to the picocyanobacteria that small-celled colonial Cyanoprokaryotes of the genera
dominate in the photic layers of oligotrophic lakes, either Aphanocapsa, Aphanothece and other non-vacuolate types.
in the upper mixed layers or forming deep chlorophyll We are uncertain of the precise significance of abundant
maxima in the upper hypolimnion, as they do in the populations of these Group-K species, save that they seem
Stechlinsee (Padisák et al., 1997). Elsewhere, Olrik’s (Olrik, to survive high pH particularly well and may thus repre-
1997) discrimination among the smaller nanoplankters sent an association in transition towards LM or M.
(mostly unicells, < 103 µm3 in volume) is sufficient to justify The Group H is another of long standing, having been
the ascription of oligotrophic (X3), meso-eutrophic (X2) created originally for dinitrogen-fixing Cyanobacteria of
and eutrophic-hypertrophic (X1) associations. the bloom-forming Order Nostocales. However, the
The Y association was set aside for larger nanoplanktic group has been subject to recent reviews: the solitary
flagellates (103–104 µm3 in volume), although it has been forms were recognized to be more Oscillatoria-like than the
used more or less synonymously with the larger Crypto- buoyancy-regulating types in their ecology (Padisák and
monad species. Well-adapted to live in a wide-range of Reynolds, 1998; Huszar et al., 2000) and were distin-
habitats, their dynamics are, nevertheless, vulnerable to guished as SN (for nitrogen-fixing S types). Now, we feel
the feeding activities of a wide range of crustacean zoo- moved to separate the classical eutrophic, low nitrogen
01reynolds (58J)(ds) 29/4/02 10:15 am Page 424
such as Microcystis aeruginosa, with many of its overlapping mostly at high latitudes, usually having a low calcium
subspecies and ecotypes, Microcystis wesenbergii and Sphaero- content and a pH on the acid side of neutrality [see
cavum brasiliensis. Each may be well over 106 µm3 in volume especially (Korneva, 2001)].
and its buoyancy control copes not just with segregation
per se but accommodates quite striking diel fluctuations in T H E A P P L I C AT I O N O F
stratification and mixing in low-latitude lakes.
In many of the deep, clear alpine lakes, the metalimnia
F U N C T I O N A L G RO U P S
are sufficiently stable to become populated by plate-like In this section, we seek to show some of the uses of the
developments of photoautotrophs that remain centred functional-group model. These include the aid to under-
within narrow depth ranges for weeks to months on end, standing why certain species of phytoplankton should be
moving upwards or downwards in response to small more favoured than others in the assembly of communi-
changes in the light field or in the availability of other ties and why planktic species composition should vary in
essential resources. The behaviour is typified by that of the space and time. Conversely, the similarity in plankton
Cyanoprokaryote, Planktothrix (formerly Oscillatoria) assemblages in similar lakes and at similar times becomes
rubescens [(Zimmermann, 1969); see also (Bright and easier to explain, as do the differences in assemblage struc-
Walsby, 2000)] which is recognized in the group R. ture represented in lakes of different types. Such under-
01reynolds (58J)(ds) 29/4/02 10:15 am Page 425
predicted on the basis of standing inocula furnished by in a particular functional group because it is in a particu-
past spring blooms, while the alternative dominants will lar kind of lake, or it is in a particular kind of lake because
come from a robustly predictable group of species. These of its functional affinity. A much more pragmatic view is
groups correspond to the functional associations: there is that most species have a cosmopolitan or even ubiquitous
merit in being able to describe in these terms the sequence distribution but they may be more sensitive to certain
of phytoplankton dominance across temporal and spatial properties and environmental circumstances that weaken
sequences of water bodies. One of the most comprehen- their dynamic performances in comparison with those
sive of such comparisons was that of the phytoplankton of that are less sensitive or positively tolerant of the same
deep alpine lakes made by Sommer (Sommer, 1986): he properties or circumstances. The longer the conditions
demonstrated a similarity of year-to-year behaviours in obtain, the poorer is the survival of the first and the rela-
individual lakes, sequential stages (spring bloom, summer tively better is the survival of the second. In this way the
stratification, the summer–autumn phase of mixed-layer standing stock becomes biased towards the survivorship of
deepening) common to all of them, and of different kinds the tolerant species. In less exacting environments, more
of dominant association reflecting trophic status and species will, potentially operate successfully, but as the
limiting nutrient availability. However, the patterns are limiting conditions become more severe and the opera-
reported in terms of a few key dominants and of the tional criteria discount against less tolerant species, the
Table II: Sommer’s summary of the seasonality of dominant algae in nine central European lakes re-
rendered in terms of functional-group representation (Sommer, 1986)
Köningsee A N/Y A
Attersee N Y B
Walensee N N/Y
V’wldst’see B/Y N N H R
L.Maggiore C/R P L/R H L/R
Ammersee C/R Y R/P/Y P L H R/P
Zürichsee D/Y Y Y/H P/Y R/P
Lac Léman D/Y Y Y/G P L H T/P
Bodensee D/Y Y Y/G P L /H/ E T/P
01reynolds (58J)(ds) 29/4/02 10:15 am Page 426
Table III: Responses to habitat properties of functional groups of phytoplankton [updated from
(Reynolds, 2000)]
Variablea
hm I* [P] [N] [Si] [CO2] f
Codon <3 < 1.5 <8 < 10–7 < 10–6 < 10–5 < 10–5 > 0.4
A – ? + + + + – –
B – + + + – – – –
C – + + – – – ? –
D + + + – – – + –
N – – – + – +/– – ?
P – – – – – +/– + +
T – ? – +/– – + ? +
S1 + + + – – + + +
S2 + + – – – + + +
Entries in Table are to denote tolerance (+) or no positive benefit (–) of the environmental condition set.; ‘+/–’ is used to denote that some species in
the association are tolerant; ‘?’ denotes that tolerance is suspected but not proven.
a Variables signified are: depth of surface mixed layer (h , in m from surface); mean daily irradiance levels experienced (I*, in mol photons m–2 day–1);
m
water temperature (, in °C); the concentration of soluble reactive phosphorus ([P], in mol l–1); the concentration of dissolved inorganic nitrogen ([N], in
mol l–1); the concentration of soluble reactive silicon ([Si], in mol l–1); the concentration of dissolved carbon dioxide ([CO2], in mol l–1); and the proportion
of the water processed each day by rotiferan and crustacean zooplankton (f ).
b Some representative genera or species only are listed.
the algal assemblage or the kind of lake determines the sensitivities of the various functional groups of
floristic group that may be favoured. Indeed, the supposed Cyanoprokaryota to the depth, stability and nutrient-
circularity of the argument becomes a positive strength content of water columns, shown in a small number of
when algae from the same functional association are studies (Padisák and Reynolds, 1998; Beyruth, 2000;
found under analogous conditions in different lakes of Huszar et al., 2000). Thus, it should be possible to decide
similar types, as in Table II. Other examples include the the best way of managing a lake or reservoir to make it less
01reynolds (58J)(ds) 29/4/02 10:15 am Page 427
C O N TAC T A D D R E S S E S
DEVELOPMENT OF THE
Colin S. Reynolds: csr@cah.ac.uk
F U N C T I O N A L C L A S S I F I C AT I O N
Vera L. de M. Huszar: vhuszar@gbl.com.br
The remaining objective of this presentation is to advo- Carla Kruk: ckruk@fcien.edu.uy
cate its wider adoption and to secure a wider constituency Luigi Naselli-Flores: luigi.naselli@unipa.it
for its development. We are certain that not all valid Sergio Melo: melo@biologia.ufrj.br
groupings have been described, while the functional
significance of many algal species has not been accorded
to functional groups and it is not clear that it will be simple REFERENCES
01reynolds (58J)(ds) 29/4/02 10:15 am Page 428
the analysis of species temporal replacement. J. Plankton Res., submit- Reynolds, C. S. and Maberly, S. C. (2002) A simple method for approx-
ted for publication. imating the supportive capacities and metabolic constraints in lakes
Lavorel, S., McIntyre, S., Landsberg, J. and Forbes, T. D. A. (1997) Plant and reservoirs. Freshwater Biol., in press.
functional classifications: from general groups to specific groupsbase Romanovsky, Yu. E. (1985) Food limitation and life-history strategies in
on response to disturbance. Trends Ecol. Evol., 12, 474–478. cladoceran crustaceans. Ergebn. Limnol., 21, 363–372.
Margalef, R. (1978) Life forms of phytoplankton as survival alternatives Salmaso, N. (2000) Factors affecting the seasonality and distribution of
in an unstable environment. Oceanologica Acta, 1, 493–509. Cyanobacteria and chlorophyta: a case study from the large lakes
Melo, S. de and Huszar, V. L. M. (2000) Phytoplankton in an Amazon- south of the Alps with special reference to Lake Garda. Hydrobiologia,
ian flood-plain lake (Lago Batata, Brasil): diel variation and species 438, 43–63.
strategies. J. Plankton Res., 22, 63–76. Scheffer, M. (1998) Ecology of Shallow Lakes. Chapman & Hall, London.
Olrik, K. (1997) Danmarks planteplankton. Gads Forlag, København. Seip, K. L. and Reynolds, C. S. (1995) Phytoplankton functional attrib-
Padisák, J. and Reynolds, C. S. (1998) Selection of phytoplankton associ- utes along trophic gradient and season. Limnol. Oceanogr., 40, 589–597.
ations in Lake Balaton, Hungary, in response to eutrophication and Shimwell, D. W. (1971) Description and Classification of Vegetation. Sidgwick
restoration measures, with special reference to the cyanoprokaryotes. and Jackson, London.
Hydrobiologia, 384, 41–53. Sieburth, J. McN., Smetacek, V .and Lenz, J. (1978) Pelagic ecosystem
Padisák, J., Krienitz, L., Koschel, R. and Nedoma, J. (1997) Deep layer structure: heterotrophic compartments of the plankton and their
picoplankton maximum in the oligotrophic lake Stechlin, Germany: relationship to plankton size fractions. Limnol. Oceanogr., 23,
origin, activity, development and erosion. Europ. J. Phycol., 32, 1256–1263.