Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
The rate of bullying among individuals with disabilities is alarming. Because ofthe social
and motor deficiencies that individuals with Asperger's syndrome (AS) often display, they
are frequently targets of buUying.The physical education setting often consists of a larger
number of students than the typical academic instructional setting. This increase in the
number of children may foster a breeding ground for bullying of students with limited
physical abilities or poor social skills. Understanding AS and bullying will enable social
workers and educators to engage in team problem solving to teach children with AS the
skills needed to address bullying issues if they encounter them.This approach is particularly
beneficial to those students with AS being educated in the general physical education
setting. The team approach is most effective when a social worker takes an active role in
the process.
I am often asked if and how I was bullied at they were bullied. There are several reasons for
school. It is difficult to answer because not this. Individuals with AS often can be naive, be
only was I bullied but often I was seen as the overly trusting, and have a strong desire to be
bully. People perceived me as a scary bully included (Blacher & Lauderdale, 2008).
because I didn't know what appropriate play
was since no one ever told or taught me. I BULLYING AND STUDENTS WITH AS
also tended to play more imaginative games As previously noted, the rate of bullying among
and less physical or strenuous games. When I students is alarming. Results of a study con-
wasn't viewed as the buUy, I was being bullied ducted in 2001 on 16,000 sixth- to lOth-graders
by other kids. Usually it was verbal comments from schools within the United States indicted
about my weight, my slow speed, or something that approximately 30 percent reported moder-
else equally cruel. I was also bullied because ate or frequent involvement in bullying (Nansel
I would stem in and out of class, and they et al., 2001).The same study showed that male
would find a big kid making funny sounds students were more likely to be either victims
and movements with his hands disturbing.The or perpetrators in the bullying experience. The
problem was, in most of my classes my teachers reality is that the "effects of bullying may linger
were either too busy or far away to deal with long into the victims' adulthood" (San Antonio
the bullying. Sometimes they even allowed it & Salzfass,2007,p.32).Most educators recognize
knowingly! It was these classes where I didn't the need to address bullying issues and have
care and would try to escape the situation, created antibullying programs to increase a safe
(personal communication with J.Williams, co- school environment. However, students with
teacher. Humble Independent School District, disabilities, particularly those with AS, are often
Humble, Texas, January 4, 2009) victims of bullying, and their special needs are
seldom addressed in such programs.
T
he rate of bullying among individu-
als with disabilities is alarming. Little Children and adolescents with Asperger's syn-
(2001) reported that over 75 percent drome often find themselves socially isolated
of children with Asperger's syndrome (AS) felt or caught in the middle of conflicts related
CCC Code: 1532-8759/10 $3.00 ©2010 National Association of Social Workers 135
to their (a) lack of understanding of the rules did. I always thought that my skill level was
of social behavior, (b) lack of awareness of the same, but once I realized this, I started to
accepted social protocol, (c) lack of common withdraw. Nobody really encouraged me to
sense, (d) propensity to misinterpret social use the skills that I had and several times, my
cues and unspoken messages, and (e) display teachers would just let me sit out and not par-
of socially unaccepted responses. (Simpson & ticipate. I think they meant well, but this only
Myles, 1998,p. 149) isolated me more, (personal communication
with J.Williams, January 4, 2009)
These specific deficits may result in social
isolation or aggressive behaviors. If aggressive Children with AS are often described as dis-
behaviors are displayed by students with AS, playing motor clumsiness and awkwardness.
they may "be easy targets for bullies and peer In addition, it has been reported that children
derision" (Simpson & Myles, 1998, p. 150). with AS have poor motor ability and social
AntibuUying program seldom address the needs deficits. As coexisting conditions, these deficits
of those students identified as having specific may contribute to difficulties in the physical
disabilities such as AS. education setting.
Students with disabilities are often targeted as The physical ability of children with AS is
victims because of their lack of social skills and often lower than that of their peer group, and
low self-confidence. "Children with disabilities motor impairments have been found to exist
are at least twice as likely to be bullied than their within the autism spectrum (Jansiewicz et al.,
non-disabled peers" (Marini, Fairbairn, & Zuber, 2006). It is uncommon for children with AS to
2001, p. 175). Supporting this notion,Wainscot, possess highly athletic skills, as these children
Naylor, SutclifFe, Tantam, and Williams (2008) rarely display general gross motor precocity
found that individuals with AS were bullied on (Silverman & Weinfield, 2007). Green et al.
a regular basis and were buUied much more than (2002) found that children with AS had motor
their peers. During breaks and lunch time, these impairments, consistent with various studies
students were often alone. "There are common indicating that children with AS have a high
reports of peers who have bullied and provoked prevalence of clumsiness. In this research, all
individuals with Asperger's syndrome to engage participants with AS were diagnosed as having
in inappropriate behaviors" (Simpson & Myles, motor impairments. Freitag, Kleser, Schneider,
1998, p. 150).The acts of bullying that children and von Gontard (2007) added that individuals
with AS often experience can lead to a poor with high-functioning autism and AS had im-
self-image and clinical levels of depression or pairments in dynamic balance and diadochoki-
anxiety (Blacher & Lauderdale, 2008). Aalsma nesis. In addition, many children with AS often
and Brown (2008) related the victimization to have a coexisting condition of developmental
significant psychosocial effects throughout ado- coordination disorder (Elder et al., 2006).
lescence and into young adulthood. These acts Along with the deficits in motor skills that
may lead to the individual that is being bullied children with AS may display, by definition,
wishing not to attend school (Myklebust, 2002). children with AS possess social deficits. These
This, along with coexisting physical deficits that social deficits, paired with physical deficits, can
children with AS may have, leads one to assume create even more challenges for students with
that these same children wiU not want to par- AS when they participate in the physical edu-
ticipate in physical education or extracurricular cation setting. Physical performance and social
sports activities. interaction often work together as children
experience opportunities to play and com-
PHYSICAL DEFICITS AND AS municate with peers through various games
I remember when I was in junior high school that require or use physical activity. Myles
and I realized that I was not able to perform and Simpson (2002) explained that the social
the same skills as other students in my class deficits inherent in students with AS include
GARCIA BIGGS, SIMPSON, AND GAUS / Usinga Team Approach to Address Bullying of Students with Asperger's Syndrome 137
to ensure the student's safety and make him or
If I could tell physical education teachers her feel welcomed by teachers and peers. It will
one thing, it would be to understand that bring about the most effective intervention to
we may not be interested in team sports or rely on the accountability of those designing the
approach. The intervention must also address
certain kinds of activities, but that doesn't
the student's levels of cognitive understanding,
mean we don't want to do anything. around which the intervention will be designed
and implemented. The type of intervention
designed for the student must be presented to,
adults, (personal communication with J.Wil- and developed with, that student.
liams,January 4, 2009) The physical education teacher can work
with the student in designing a fitness program
In the school setting, the social worker's that will improve skills and enhance the physi-
"specialty in social work is oriented toward cal education experience.The special education
helping students make satisfactory adjustments teacher and adapted physical education teacher
and coordinating and influencing the efforts have the expertise in adapting or modifying in-
of the school, the family, and the community struction. Using a strengths-based approach, the
to achieve this goal" (NASW, 2002). Using a social worker can help the student to recognize
multidisciplinary approach, a social worker can his or her skills and act as an advocate for the
arrange a team meeting to include the student, student regarding difficult decisions on his or
physical education teacher, special education her level of commitment to the established plan
teacher, general education teachers, physical (Garcia Biggs, Simpson, & Gaus, 2009).
therapist, occupational therapist, campus admin- The teachers can be involved in a range of
istrator, parents, school counselor, and any other topics related to the intervention, such as the
community member or individual the student or monitoring of peer relationships. Administra-
parent would like to invite. The facilitated team tors can provide support in areas such as policy
meeting would be designed to develop interven- development, enforcement, and the level of
tion plans for the student. Each discipline would support and commitment needed to ensure
identify their role with the student, describe the success of the intervention. Specifically, this
strengths of the student, and present a theo- support can include the "implementation of a
retical framework of their discipline. When all zero tolerance policy for bullying within school
members understand and accept the theoretical limits and support through classroom visits and
frameworks and perceptions of other individuals private meetings as needed" (Garcia Biggs et al.,
on the team, common ground is more easily 2009, p. 41). Parental involvement can assist in
established. The various thought processes help creating a more positive commitment to helping
to shape the most appropriate approaches, with students with AS succeed. A commitment from
direction from the student. all those involved in the child's instruction can
create a new level of communication, opening
If I could tell physical education teachers one the door for students and families to feel less
thing, it would be to understand that we may ahenated in the intervention process.
not be interested in team sports or certain kinds
of activities, but that doesn't mean we don't DISCUSSION
want to do anything. For me, I had to fmd the Most practitioners, educators, and parents agree
activities I enjoy; they weren't the same as what that there is a tremendous need to address bul-
others wanted for me. (personal communica- lying behavior. There is a general impression
tion with J. Williams, January 4, 2009) that bullying in schools is being addressed by
school systems, but for students with disabili-
Valuing the skills and knowledge of a variety ties, those interventions are often limited. In
of individuals to design an intervention helps particular, students with AS may find bullying
GARCIA BIGGS, SIMPSON, AND GAUS / Using a Team Approach to Address Builying ofStudents with Asperger's Syndrome 139
Table 1: Bullying Interventions
1. Provide staff development to school personnel so that they can be aware ofthe specific needs of children with Asperger's syn-
drome (AS) in relation to bullying. The staff development should focus on not only the characteristics of bullies and victims, but
also the prevalence and types of bullying that occur. A strong emphasis should be placed on how individuals with social deficits
are at a greater tisk of bullying. Involve community leaders in staff development when addressing the specific needs of students
with disabilities in relation to extracurricular and community activities. Teachers can be a student with AS's strongest advocate
when addressing on-campus bullying.
2. Educators should enforce a no tolerance for bullying policy for all students and enforce the policy to the full extent.
3. Establish a buddy system to assist the child with AS. This will allow for another individual with higher social Functioning to
identify "life-threatening" bullying instances. This individual should be selected by an adult, with input from the student with
AS.
4. Teach children with AS specific areas where they are most vulnerable to being bullied, identifying these locations will help the
student with AS to avoid instances in which limited visibility by adults exists. Once these specific areas are indentified, the child
with AS can be instructed about ways to avoid these areas and be provided with alternative sites where he or she is less likely to
encounter bullying acts.
5. Role play bullying situations in which the student with AS is specifically taught to respond to bullying. Prevention of bullying
is a primary goal, but it cannot be relied on in every instance. Children with a limited ability to understand social cues may
misinterpret acts of teasing and bullying as attempts by peers to establish friendships. Reading social cues can pose difficulty for
children with AS and should be practiced on a regular basis.
6. Teach children with AS that safety exists in numbers. Students should be encouraged to play in areas near peers ot where large
numbers of students are present. Children with AS should be encouraged to participate in supervised activities. Supervised activi-
ties not only provide a safe house from bullying, but also create opportunity for social interactions.
7. ff acts of bullying take place, they must be investigated. Simply asking the child to ignore verbal taunts is not addressing the
issue at hand. Students who are perpetrators in bullying acts (toward students with or without disabilities) must receive conse-
quences as outlined by the student code of conduct.
8. When developing games and activities for use in instructional and physical education settings, avoid activities that are exclu-
sionary in nature. For example, a physical educator can select teams instead of having students select teams. Some children with
AS are the last picked for activities that involve sports/athletic skills due to poor gait, balance, and motor coordination. Activities
should be designed to include all children.
9. Educators should avoid elimination games—for example, games such as knock out, in which skill level determines the last
student remaining in the game. This type of game may signal a child out for being seen as being "weaker" than his or her peers.
Students perceived in this manner are often targets of bullying acts.
10. If bullymg acts occur, teachers can use the opportunity to talk with the child or children performing the act of bullying to
educate them not only about the ill effects it has on the child being bullied, but also about how that behavior can be detrimental
to the child performing the act if used in society.
11. Educators should talk with children about individual differences and how these differences are not to be exploited. Teaching
all children that everyone deserves to be treated with respect may help in reducing the number of incidents.
12. All children should be encouraged to report acts of bullying. Reminding students ofthe benefits that a safe environment
has on their own well-being could help them commit to reporting bullying events. It is important not only for the child who is
bullied to report it, but for the children who see it occurring toward other individuals, especially a child with AS who may be
reluctant or fearful to speak up, to report it as well.
includes children with specific disabilities. assistance of a team approach to design effec-
Schools cannot afford to ignore the tolerated tive interventions, repeated acts of bullying can
injustices against students with AS. Educators, be eliminated.
with the guidance of a school social worker, The incorporation of a social worker in
must incorporate the role of supervision— multidisciplinary planning adds an additional
particularly in physical education classes and level to programming that addresses the unique
at recess and lunch periods. "By combining needs of adolescents with AS. Many school
education about bullying and establishing personnel do not possess the specific training
consequences for continued bullying, schools to address AS in relationship to physical educa-
not only will neutralize bullying; they also tion. Social workers can play an integral role in
might prevent it" (Scarpaci, 2006, p. 174) .When the development of an effective intervention
bullying issues are addressed in the school program targeting bullying in children who
setting, student needs may vary, but, with the have disabilities, specifically AS, by providing
GARCIA BIGGS, SIMPSON, AND GAUS / Usinga Team Approach to Address Bullying of Students with Asperger's Syndrome 141
Silverman, S. M., & Weinfeld, R. (2007). School success
for kids with Asperger's syndrome. Waco,TX: Prufrock
Press. Customize the Power of Your
Simpson, R., & Myles, B. (1998). Aggression among
children and youth who have Asperger's syndrome: NASW Membership
A different population requiring different strategies.
Preventing School Failure, 42(4), 149-153.
Wainscot,J.J., Naylor, P., Sutcliffe, P,Tantam, D., &
Williams, J.V (2008). Relationship with peers
and use ofthe school environment of mainstream
secondary school pupils with Asperger syndrome
(high-functioning autism):A case-control study. ¿lialtv Prac^^Kection
International Journal of Psychology and Psychological
Vierapy, 8{\), 25-38.
#NASW.
National Association of Social Workers
Specially Praclice Sections
www.socialworkers.org/sections
202.408.8600 ext. 476