Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Editor's Comment.......................14
News & Events............................20
CE: Road Construction E-Scape.....................................228
Extreme Utility Machines In Large Earthmoving Projects
M.K. Prabhakar 144 Classifieds.................................207
144
Dr. Qiu Jianhai, BEng PhD CEng MIMMM FICorr, NACE Certified Corrosion
Specialist (#5047) WebCorr Corrosion Consulting Services CE: Road Construction
Extreme Utility Machines in Large Earthmoving Projects
M.K. Prabhakar
94 150
44 128
14 The Masterbuilder - April 2011 | www.masterbuilder.co.in
PNP Polytex Pvt.Ltd
Contents
204 Spotlight
162 Infrastructure: Highways
Paving the Way to the Future
Gmmco-Caterpillar Celebrate 25 Years of Partnership
M.K. Prabhakar
183 Awards
Design of Place Lalla Yeddouna in Fez - Competition Winners
[A part of material handling solutions division]
Announced
218 Profile: Shoring System
STAXO 40 The Lightweight, Economical, Safe and Efficient
184 Flooring
One Day Flooring
Shoring System
222
Mr. Ajay Mohta, General Manager Construction Accessories Division,
The Supreme Industries Ltd. Automated Doors
Smart Reset Self-Repairing Automatic Flexible Door
162
Advertisers Index___________________________
A Hess Concrete Machinery Rockwool (India) Ltd 173, 175
India Pvt.Ltd Back Cover
Action Construction S
Equipment Ltd 137, 139, 141 Hormann India Pvt.Ltd 199
Savcor India Private Limited 55
Ajax Fiori Engineering (I) Pvt.Ltd 81 Hyundai Construction Equipment
India Pvt.Ltd 9 Schwing Stetter (I) Pvt.Ltd 45
Amogha Road Equipment 203
J SEC-RJMT Engineering Pvt.Ltd 187
Asons Enterprise 131
JBA Concrete Solutions Pvt.Ltd 159 Seven Hills Safety Equipments
Apollo Infratech Pvt.Ltd 31,39 and Systems (P) Limited 207
B JCB India Ltd Flap
Silicone Concepts Int'l.Pvt.Ltd 101
JSW Serverfield
Bridge Seminar 121
Structures Ltd Front Cover- 2 Simpson & Co.Ltd 119
Bomanite India 147
K SKG Equipments Pvt. Ltd. 225
C
Kamaz Vectra Motors Ltd Back Inner Sleek Boards India Ltd 111
Case Construction Equipment 21
Kryton Buildmat Co.Pvt.Ltd 29 Soilmec Foundation Equipment
Cemseal System & Sales Pvt.Ltd 27
L
(Webac) 187 Speedcrafts Ltd 161
Lipi Polymers Pvt.Ltd 61
Cico Technologies Ltd 59 SSA Techno Construction Pvt. Ltd. 207
Liugong India Pvt.Ltd 85
Cipy Polyurethanes Pvt.Ltd 53
Lucky International 91 STP Ltd 107
Chetra Machinery India Pvt.Ltd 63
M T
Columbia Pakona Engineering
Machines & Engineering Company 113 Tac System Formwork
Pvt.Ltd 203
Sdn Bhd Gatefold
Cosmos Construction Machineries Maco Coporation India Pvt.Ltd 173
& Equipments Pvt.Ltd 179 Terex India Pvt.Ltd 71
MB subscription form 211
Cosmos Sales Corporation 153 TIL Ltd 73
Metecno India Pvt.Ltd Front Inner- 2
D The Supreme Industries Ltd 41
MM Castings (P) Ltd 127
Dextra India Pvt.Ltd 197 Tunnel Design & Construction
N (IQPC -Singapore) 215
Doka India Pvt.Ltd 19 Nicomac Doors Pvt. Ltd 175 Toshniwal Systems & Instruments
Don Construction Chemicals P
India Ltd 49 Pvt.Ltd 193
Partnership Contracting U
E (Hongkong) 217
E Surveying Solutions 199 Unipave Engineering Products 103
Pidilite (Dr.Fixit) 77
Ermotec International Pvt.Ltd 203,225 Universal Construction Machinery
PNP Polytex Pvt.Ltd 15
& Equipment Ltd 155
Esquire -CMAC Pvt.Ltd 123, 165,197
Putzmeister Concrete Machines
Unisteel Engineering Works 97
F Pvt.Ltd 23
Unitech Exhibitions - Roof India 221
Fayat India 10 R
G Ramtec 207
V
Gandhi Automations Pvt.Ltd 11 RD Mining Equipments Pvt.Ltd 89 Viki Industries (P) Ltd 135
Greaves Cotton Ltd 67 Reliance Industries Ltd 169 Vimtech Corporation Front Inner- 1
CONSTRUCTION EQUIPMENT
CONSTRUCTION EQUIPMENT
INFRASTRUCTURE
` 6, 000-cr Thermal
Power Project Beginning
to Take Shape
A 6,000 crore thermal power plant
project is going to come up in
Adilabad district of Andhra Pradesh. The Asian Development Bank
The project will mark the stepping (ADB) has loaned an amount of
into the power generation domain by US $ 250 million for the Bangalore
Anil Sardana, MD, Tata Teleservices, state-owned Singareni Collieries Co metro project to the Indian government.
“this project further contributes to our
clean fuel portfolio and reinforces Ltd (SCCL), which was till now
The project which is scheduled for
our sustainability agenda.” majorly in coal mining projects. completion in 2013 will consist of 42.3
Tata Power has announced that its Financial closure for the project has km of track, equipment, sleek new
consortium with SN Power, a Norway- been achieved according to media stations, and rolling stock for the two
based firm, has won the rights to build reports. The total debt component of key routes that it will cover in the
a 236 MW hydroelectric power plant Rs.4,000 crore for the proposed 2 x Indian IT capital.
in the northern part of India.Tata Bangalore Metro Rail Corporation
Power and SN Power Norway entered is the special purpose vehicle which has
into an exclusive partnership in 2009 been formed to carry out the project.
to develop hydro-power projects to Japan International Cooperation
meet the increasing demand in India Agency has also provided funds for the
and Nepal through the provision of project. Loans from commercial
clean energy. sources are also being utilized for the
project.
The company in a statement said
that the Dugar Hydroelectric project
in Himachal Pradesh would be devel- New Hurdle for
oped through a special purpose vehi- S NarsingRao, Chairman & MD,
Singareni Collieries
Hyderabad Metro Project
cle. A detailed exploration and design
study will then be taken to plan and 600 MW power project will be A new hurdle seems to be crop
finalise the project implementation. provided by the Power Finance Corpo- from seemingly nowhere for the
The pre-implementation agreement ration (PFC), according to Mr. S Hyderabad Metro Rail (HMR) project,
will be signed with the Directorate of almost every passing day. If it was shop
NarsingRao, the Chairman and
Energy, Himachal Pradesh govern- owners who didn't want the line to be
Managing Director of the company.
passing close to their buildings some
ment. It however, did not disclose the
The project is likely to be time ago, it is now the time of founda-
financial details of the project.
completed and be operational by April tion stone ceremony, which could
Tata Power's managing director, 2014. potentially delay the project.
INFRASTRUCTURE
INFRASTRUCTURE
INFRASTRUCTURE
INFRASTRUCTURE
INTERNATIOAL
Manitowoc Exhibits Top The MDT 268 is one of the recent Yet another Super
introductions in the Potain topless
of Line Cranes at MDT crane line. It offers fast erecting Heavy Lifter Tested
Intermat Trade Show and dismantling times without Sarens, a leading name in lifting
compromising capacity. NFT, an Abu solutions, has tested a new 120,000
Dhabi-based Potain dealer and one of tonne metre SGC 120 super heavy
the largest tower crane owners in the lifting ring type crane in its facility in
world, has many Potain MDT 268 Belgium recently.
cranes which it has used on some of
Saudi Arabia's most prestigious recent The 3,200 tonne capacity super
construction projects. heavy lift crane is among the largest in
the world. The lattice boom giant
This crane, along with Potain's comes with 130 metres of main boom.
larger model, the MDT 368, were The crane boasts of a capacity of 1,000
lifting leaders during the construction tonnes at 80 m radius. The crane is
(L - R) Carina El Rkaiby and David Semple of
Manitowoc Cranes, Nabil Al Zahlawi, od NFT, of the Princess Nora bint designed to meet both European and
Ahmed Talhimet of Manitowoc
and Fadi Daher of NFT.
Abdulrahman University in Riyadh, US standards for lift cranes.
the world's largest women-only
Two of the latest innovations from university. There were 150 cranes used
Manitowoc stood side-by-side on the on this $11.5 billion project, the
company's booth at Intermat Middle majority from Potain.
East. The company showed the Grove
GMK6300L all-terrain crane, that The MDT 268 has a topless design,
combines 300 t of lifting power with a with no cathead and tie-bars, which
long-reaching80 m boom, and the means contractors can place them in
Potain MDT 268, one of the most close proximity on job sites, without
recent additions to the company's needing to erect them too high. This
range of high-capacity topless tower saves both time and money and
cranes, with a capacity of either 10 t or provides an optimized working envi-
12 t. Both cranes are new to the ronment. The versatility and speed of
Middle-East market within recent erecting and dismantling the MDT
years. 268 allowed main contractor Saudi
David Semple, vice president of Oger to not only meet but exceed the
sales for Manitowoc in the Middle East extremely tight build schedules on the
and Africa, said the two cranes demon- university project. The new crane's application areas
strate the company's industry-leading One interesting feature on the include nuclear power plants, refiner-
engineering and ability to adapt to MDT 268 is its folding jib an industry ies, mining, and construction. The
changing market needs. first for topless cranes. The patented design also boasts of features that
With an Allison transmission, the folding jib helps with one of the reduce cost of transporation and oper-
GMK6300L has a powerful, reliable biggest problems in the construction ation. The crane can be shipped in 135
and cost-effective drive-train that of cooling towers dismantling the standard containers in standard boom
offers unmatched performance. Its elec- crane once construction is complete. condition.
tronic controls allow it to adapt to its Because the jib's radius is greater than
surroundings and it has self- the cooling towers, contractors are CAT's New CT Series,
diagnostics for easier maintenance. often faced with a problem when Vocational Trucks
When combined with Grove's 'climbing down' the crane. But the
Megatrak independent suspension folding jib offers an innovative solu- Caterpillar, one of the leading
system, the Allison transmission tion to this problem. Another construction equipment manufactur-
provides optimum travel both on and standout feature is the counter jib that ers, will unveil its newline of voca-
off the road. can be folded for transport. tional trucks during the forthcoming
INTERNATIONAL
The crane can lift 1.3 tonnes at the hurdles such as the potential problem
jib, with its compact dimensions that could be caused to air craft pilots
ideally suited for work in urban areas whose visibility could be disturbed due
where space is at a premium. The to the beams of light that shoot out
highly versatile climbing tower section from the turbines. There was also the
of the crane is 3.9 m long and can be concern about the turbines generating
used both inside and outside a build- solar rays that could set surrounding
ing. buildings on fire, if they are concen-
trated.
The crane is also easy for carrying
around in urban centers since its unit Shantui Launches
weigh less , the heaviest component
weighing less than 3 tonnes. Another First Product in
ConExpo show in Las Vegas. The interesting feature of the crane is that US Market
machine on display at the company's it can be operated either with or even
without a cabin. Shantui Construction Machinery
booth would be the Cat CT660.
Co., a multinational based in
According to the company, the Solar-Powered Wind Shandong, China, announced today
trucks are suited to a wide variety of the launch of its SD10YE bulldozer,
work and have been designed using
Turbine for Ultimate the Company's first product to enter
customer feedback. Also on show Energy Generation the U.S. market. The SD10YE is certi-
would be the company's 64 tonne fied by TÜV SÜD America as Tier III
capacity G Series 775 rigid dump emissions compliant, and is the
truck. smallest dozer in Shantui's arsenal.
The SD10YE runs on hydrostatics,
The company will also display five
comes standard with a Cummins
new models in the K Series of mid-
engine, and has horsepower rated at
sized wheeled loader range. This new
100, or 74kW.
line features an improved cab, apart
from featuring a fuel efficient engine. Like other Shantui offerings, this
dozer packs in value for the price.
New Flat Top City Intelligent GPS service, automatic
alarm system, and auto-diagnostic
Crane Launch functions keep uptime at a maximum.
Scientists have now come out with
The SD10YE also doesn't skimp on
a new set of spinning solar blades that
operator comfort,. The fully enclosed
will enable both solar energy and wind
hexahedronstyle cabin provides for
energy to be produced together. A
low noise and vibration, and a high-
team led by Dr. Joe King has come out
capacity climate control system circu-
with the innovation solution in the
lates air and defrosts.
UK.
The SD10YE is designed for smaller
Dr. King, while speaking about projects, but has Shantui's hallmark
the project said, “While we are no toughness and durability, along with
strangers to windy weather in the UK, being environmentally friendly and
it can be intermittent in other regions. highly economical.
Solar panels may only be useful here
Liebherr, a market leader in lifting “This is our first product that
during our ten days of summer or an
solutions, is all set to launch its 85 EC meets the stringent emission stan-
occasional heat wave, but in countries
B 5 tronic flat top city crane soon. The dards of Europe and the USA. It is on
such as Morocco, Italy, and Spain they
company will be launching the crane the vanguard of a whole line of new
could make a real difference.”
during the SMOPyC exhibition that is products that we will be introducing in
going to be held in Spain this month. The team had to face several the coming years,” said Richard Li,
INTERNATIONAL
O ur global society is
simultaneously experiencing an
economic and environmental
crisis. Economically, signs of a feeble
recovery mask fundamental flaws with
and the necessary leadership too
wanting.
Those of us in the building space now
find ourselves at the front line of the
battle against these two crises. And as
the way capital and currencies are
with many in the front lines, we are both
managed worldwide. Environmentally,
in the “cross-hairs” of new regulation but
world energy demand is predicted to
luckily newly equipped with an
Emma Stewart, Ph.D. double by 2030 and water shortages are
“armament of tools” to respond.
predicted to hit every major city in the
next couple decades. The combination of Buildings are in the crosshairs for new
two such complex and seemingly regulation because, in most economies,
intractable challenges has led many to they represent the biggest guzzlers of
defeatism. The numbers are too large, the energy, outpacing even vehicles. The
causes too many, the data too expansive, reasons are simple.
For existing buildings, BIM enables greatest impact. So BIM helps to tackle analyzing and prioritizing building
the team to more quickly and easily to the issue of scalability, because it is just improvements with a surprisingly high
create a basic building model to as applicable at the level of thousands level of accuracy. Also at this stage, one
simulate the performance and cost of of buildings as it is at the level of one can begin selecting building materials
renovations. The digital model includes building. from within the BIM tool itself, perhaps
data components that represent prioritizing recycled, renewable, or
The basic steps are as follows:
building elements and locally sourced materials.
characteristicssuch as materials, 1. Get Pickin': Collect basic building
3. Get Testin': Analyze multiple
weight, thermal resistance, and other informationincluding wall, floor, roof,
attributes to improve environmental
physical propertiesthat contribute to and ceiling dimensionson each building
building performance. With BIM, one and economic performance. For
within the portfolio. This can be done
can analyze and assess the energy example, use Revit to analyze heating
the old-fashioned expensive way (i.e. a
performance of individual buildings -- and cooling load for a typical schedule
walk-through audit), but more recently
for example, what generates a better of operation. Then explore creative
software has come about that allows
economic and energy-efficient return options to shed that load through
you to stitch together the model from
for our headquarters, installing higher natural ventilation (uses weather
digital photos and satellite images from
R-value wall insulation, or modifying a data), shading (uses sun path data),
the web.
heating system? One can then scale up onsite renewable generation potential
to multiple buildings to evaluate, and 2. Get Sketchin': Create basic BIM (uses wind and sun data), and water
rank the environmental and financial m o d e l s fo r e a c h b u i l d i n g ( o r catchment potential (uses
impact of proposed renovations for “prototype” for commercial stores) in precipitation data). A water catchment
example, which buildings within the the portfolio. You can generate a system may inspire the use of non-
portfolio would benefit the most from comprehensive BIM modelincluding potable water for irrigation or even a
an HVAC upgrade? With a more floor plans, elevations, sections, and plant-based gray water filtration plant
comprehensive understanding of the 3D views from the most basic building on site, reducing wastewater service
relative performance of the property dimensions in just a few hours so don't costs. With sister civil engineering
portfolio, one can craft a strong over-do it here. Even with minimal up- tools, the building site can be evaluated
inventory modernization program, and front effort, you can generate a basic for storm-water system needs and to
focus detailed design efforts and model that represents the form and maximize the water returned clean to
construction on the projects with the geometry of the building and begin the aquifer.
T
his paper presents the nonlinear seismic
analysis, development, and implementation of to reduce the torsional irregularity of the building.
an innovative seismic retrofit strategy for a The proposed cost effective, state-of-the-art retrofit
six-story nonductile reinforced concrete 145,000-sf will improve the seismic performance of the building.
(13,470 m2) historic building. Dynamic and This paper presents the performance-based
nonlinear static analytical results verified that the evaluation and retrofit design of the Hotel Stockton.
building had a weak soft-story with inadequate post- The 145,000-sf (13,470 m2) reinforced concrete
yield capacity, and large torsional response. The building, built in 1910 in Stockton, California, is a
analysis indicated that the existing building is not torsionally irregular structure comprised of a six-story
seismically adequate to withstand anticipated lateral portion connected to a two-story portion. There was
forces generated by earthquake excitations at the site. significant concern that the building will not be able
A "collapse prevention" performance upgrade for a to withstand the level of earthquake shaking
475-year return event was desired. Nonlinear fluid expected at the site for two reasons: a weak and soft
viscous dampers were placed at the first story level to lateral force resisting system at the first floor level,
reduce the seismic demand and obtain a more and the inadequate confinement of reinforcement in
uniform response. Visco-elastic fluid viscous dampers the first story columns. To assess the performance of
the structure, a detailed mathematical model of the story is 18 ft (5.5 m) high and the remaining floors
building was prepared based on FEMA 273 have a story height of 10'-3" (3.1 m). Figure 1 below
guidelines. Dynamic and nonlinear static analytical shows a south elevation of the eastern portion of the
results verified the presence of the soft-story building.
response, inadequate post-yield capacity, and large
In the E-W direction, the building consists of 15
torsional response. The analyses indicated that the
bays at approximately 20-ft (6.1-m) spacing. In the
existing building is not seismically adequate to N-S direction, there are five bays at approximately 20
withstand anticipated lateral forces generated by ft (6.1m) per bay, see Figure 2. The structure is a
earthquake excitations at the site. The existing cast-in-place reinforced concrete building. Reinforced
structure will suffer substantial damage and possible concrete columns, beams, and shear walls comprise
collapse in the event of a major earthquake. the gravity and lateral load resisting system. The
To address the above-mentioned inadequacies, the basement columns are 18- and 20-in. (457 and 508
Owner decided to undertake a voluntary seismic mm) square for the twostory and six-story segments
upgrade of this building. The focus of the seismic of the building, respectively. At the ground floor and
rehabilitation was to address the major deficiencies of above, column sizes vary from 18-in. (457 mm)
the structure, namely the soft-story and torsional square at the first story to 14-in. (356 mm) square at
response of the building. The main objective was to the fifth story. There is a full 9-in. (229 mm) thick
provide a "collapse prevention" performance goal concrete perimeter wall between the basement and
during a 475-year return event. Nonlinear fluid the first floor, and there are numerous 6-in. (152
viscous dampers were placed at the first story level to mm) thick concrete walls between the floors above
reduce the seismic demand and obtain a more the second floor. However, there are no structural
uniform response. Visco-elastic fluid viscous dampers walls between the ground and the second floor levels.
were strategically placed at one side of the building Typical floors consist of 4-in. (102 mm) concrete slabs
to reduce the torsional irregularity of the building. with a 2-in. (51 mm) topping slab supported by EW
Finally, the first story interior columns supporting concrete beams, and N-S concrete girders.
the six-story portion of the building were wrapped
with a fiber-reinforced polymer composite (FRP). A Although the as-built plans of the structure are
new mathematical model was prepared incorporating not available, field investigations have shown that the
the seismic upgrades, and was subjected to nonlinear columns typically have four and eight longitudinal
time history analyses using three sets of reinforcing bars around the perimeter of columns at
twocomponent, independent acceleration histories the two-story and six-story segments, respectively.
derived from a site-specific acceleration spectrum. Typical minimum concrete cover for the
Evaluation of the analytical results of this model reinforcement is approximately 2 ½ to 3 in. (64 to 76
showed that the story drift for the first floor was mm). The groundto- first story columns have eight
significantly reduced, the torsional response was 1-in (25 mm) square bars. Typical transverse ties
nearly eliminated, and all structural members consist of 1/8-in (3.2 mm) thick by 1-in (25 mm)
remained elastic. wide bars at 8 in. (203 mm) spacing.
The computer program ETABS (CSI 2001) was moment of inertia (Ig) for the cracked moment of
used to prepare a mathematical model of the inertia (Icr) of the flexural members. This
building, see Figure 3 for a schematic of the model. reduction factor was applied to the beams,
Key features of the mathematical model are columns and shearwalls.
summarized below. o Material properties. A concrete
Ø Parameters for nonlinear analysis. For this softstory
compressive strength of 3 ksi was used. This value is
structure, the nonlinear behavior will be entirely
consistent for concrete strength of buildings
limited to the first story columns. As such,
constructed in the early part of the last century
nonlinear hinges were defined and placed on these
(FEMA 273), and corresponds to the values obtained
columns. To capture the complete nonlinear
from field investigations. Tensile testing of sample
response of these columns, two types of hinges
reinforcement indicated yield and tensile strengths of
were used: shear hinges placed at mid-height of
approximately 65 and 72 ksi (450 and 500 MPa),
respectively. Field studies indicated that the column
longitudinal reinforcement splice lengths varied from
26 to 28 inches (660 to 711 mm) for 1-in (25 mm)
square bars. Therefore, the yield properties of the
longitudinal bars were reduced to 42 ksi (290 MPa),
per FEMA 273. A yield value of 36 ksi (250 MPa)
was used for the column ties.
Ø Frame elements. All columns were modeled as
square sections with longitudinal bars in a circular
pattern. Girders and beams were modeled as Figure 4: Response Spectra
rectangular sections with the section depth
measured from the top of the topping slab. T- the columns, and biaxial-force (PMM) hinges near
beam action from the floor slab was neglected. All the top and bottom of the columns. The location
dimensions were specified as centerline-to- of the PMM hinges was determined by assuming
centerline - (i.e. no rigid end offsets were that the plastic hinges would form at a distance of
specified). The perimeter basement walls and wall 2b/3 (where "b" equals the width of the column)
segments between the floors were modeled as from the top and bottom of column-to-floor
shell elements. Similarly, the floor slabs at all connections. For the PMM hinges, interaction
levels were modeled as shell elements. FEMA 273 curves based on ACI 318-99 were used to
recommends using a value of 50% of the gross determine the axial forcebiaxial moment yield
surface. For the nonlinear analysis, the column
plastic hinge properties are a function of column
slenderness, transverse reinforcement (size,
spacing, and anchorage), and axial and shear
demand. For the columns under consideration,
the axial force ranges between 10-15 percent of
the nominal compressive strength, and flexure is
the controlling response. The shear force is less
than three times the nominal shear strength, and
the columns have poor confinement (transverse
reinforcement). Since the lap splices for the
longitudinal reinforcement are not fully
developed, sudden strength degradation may
occur after the onset of the nonlinear behavior.
Figure 3: Schematic of The Mathematical Model of The Building Therefore, hinge formation (yielding) should be
Table 1
Earthquake (MCE) (2% probability of exceedence in
50 years) is also shown. Three sets of time histories
were prepared by J. P. Singh (Singh 2002) by
matching the response spectra derived from the
horizontal components of each of the three recorded Figure 7: Mode 1 (Plan)
(S.E.) corner of the building. Using equal capacity of the columns along the right (east) side
displacement assumption, a comparison of the time of the structure. Addition of steel columns for the
history response of the existing building with that of FVD braces adjacent to all the columns along this
the nonlinear pushover analysis indicates that the gridline met this goal.
story drifts will cause significant plastic rotation in
Ø Increase ductility of all the interior first story
the hinge regions of the columns, and cause probable
columns for the 6-story segment of the building.
collapse of the building. Performance Goal. Since this
To meet this criterion, fiber-reinforced polymer
is a voluntary seismic upgrade, the focus of the
composite (FRP) was wrapped around the hinge
seismic rehabilitation is to address the major
regions (top and bottom) of the columns.
deficiencies of the structure, namely, the soft-story
and torsional response of the building. The retrofit Device No. DBE Capacity, c, k-sec/in K, k/in
will limit the response of the structure to linear kip (kN) (kNsec/ mm) (kN/mm)
elastic behavior; that is, limiting the maximum xand FVD 16 210 (934) 100 (35) 0.5 100 (35)
y-components of the second floor displacement to FVED 4 300 (1334) 125 (44) 0.5 125 (44)
0.85 in. (22 mm) and 1.44 in. (37 mm), respectively. Table 2: Damper Properties
This will give an adequate level of confidence against Structural upgrade
collapse of the structure. The main performance goal
is to provide a cost-effective "collapse prevention" FVDs have been extensively researched
performance upgrade during a 475-year return event (Constantinou and Symans, 1992) and implemented
(DBE).
Retrofit method
To meet the selected performance goals for the
upgrade of this structure, a retrofit approach
combining several state-of-the-art strategies was
utilized.
Ø Reduce the soft-weak story effects by increasing
the effective damping of the structure. This
objective was achieved by employing Fluid
Viscous Dampers (FVD) at the first floor.
Ø Reduce the torsional response of the building
without increasing acceleration demand of the
super structure. This was achieved by adding fluid
viscoelastic dampers at the east side of the
structure.
Ø Provide a more redundant story shear capacity in
the upper floor transverse direction. In the
transverse direction, the building has structural Figure 12: Damper Frame Elevation
walls at the exterior walls only. Therefore, wood
in the upgrade of many structures, including the
shear walls were added for the upper six story
seismic retrofit of the historic Hotel Woodland
portion of the building. These walls will act in a
(Miyamoto and Scholl 1996). FVDs provide an
fashion analogous to cross-walls in an
economical way of improving the structural response
unreinforced masonry (URM) bearing wall
without losing any floor space. This was the chosen
building.
seismic improvement method for this building for
Ø Provide redundancy for the gravity load-carrying two reasons: (1) it reduces the second floor
displacement by increasing viscous damping, and (2) polyurethane elastomers have been successfully used
it reduces the seismic demand of the superstructure. in the aerospace industry. The mechanical
characteristics of this elastomer are as follows:
Damper selection. FVDs were strategically placed
(Gallagher Corporation, 2002)
in the structure to optimize their effectiveness
without blocking access to the architecturally Ø Urethane Elastomers provides consistent
sensitive areas of the ground floor. A total of 20 mechanical properties through a temperature
damper bays were utilized. Initially, only linear fluid range of 0ºF to 225ºF (-18ºC to 107ºC).
viscous dampers were considered for the upgrade,
Ø Urethane exhibits compressive capacity of 80 ksi
however, this approach necessitated using relatively
(552 MPa) without molecular damage and
large devices to meet the performance criteria. In
addition, this did not address the torsional
irregularity of the building. To mitigate these
problems, two types of devices were utilized:
nonlinear fluid viscous dampers were used in 16
braced bays, and a combination of nonlinear fluid
viscous dampers in parallel with elastic elements
(herein referred to as fluid visco-elastic dampers, or
FVEDs) was utilized in four braced bays. The table
below summarizes the pertinent properties of the
devices.
Additional columns at either end of the diagonal Figure 14: Displacement History of Damped Structure
devices will prevent the transfer of the damper forces
to the existing building columns. Figure 12 shows a elasticity.
typical damper frame elevation.
Ø Aging under static stress has no effect on
Fluid Visco-Elastic Damper mechanical properties if protected from ultraviolet
light.
A combination of fluid viscous dampers and
Ø Flame resistance is sufficient to meet
Federal Aerospace Regulation 25.853B.
See Figure 13 for FVED and FVD
construction. Prototype testing per FEMA
273 will be conducted to verify response
and durability.
Response of the retrofitted structure
To assess the effectiveness of the proposed
building upgrade, nonlinear time history
analyses of the structure incorporating the
dampers were performed. The mathematical
model of the existing building was modified
by adding the sixteen FVDs and the four
FVEDs. Two time history cases were
considered. In one case, the mathematical
model was preloaded by a static load equal to
90% of the total dead load prior to being
Figure 13: FVED & FVD Devices subjected to the lateral accelerations. In the
I
n recent years, durability requirements are often means that the electrochemical potential of the steel
specified for new reinforced concrete structures locally becomes more negative and forms anodic
especially for those to be built in marine areas, while the other portions of the steel which have
environments. It is evident today that the use of high the passive layer intact will act as catchment areas for
performance concrete, good concrete cover, corrosion oxygen and will form cathodic areas.
inhibitors and protective coating is not sufficient to
In spite of the development of high performance
provide corrosion prevention for reinforced concrete
concrete from the early 1970s until today, it is
structures in severe conditions of marine
evident that the application of high performance
environments. Various corrosion prevention measures
concrete in conjunction with measures such as
such as the use of corrosion resistant reinforcement
protective coating, thick concrete cover and corrosion
and cathodic prevention have been used in the past
inhibitors is not necessarily good enough for ensuring
20 years to reduce the corrosion of reinforcement for
high durability of concrete structures in marine
new reinforced concrete structures in marine
environments. For this reason, various corrosion
environments. This paper will provide a brief review
prevention measures have been used and specified for
of these measures and highlight their applicability
new reinforced concrete structures to be built in
under various circumstances.
marine environments. This paper will provide an
Reinforced concrete is a composite material that overall review of these measures.
relies on the high compressive strength of concrete
Corrosion Prevention Measures
and the high tensile strength of steel for its
mechanical performance. Steel has poor corrosion Corrosion prevention measures in vogue include:
resistance and concrete has good anti-corrosion modifying the concrete mix design to decrease
properties. The hydration process of concrete leads to concrete permeability and provide an adequate cover
the formation of hydroxides which raises the pH level to reinforcement; coating application to limit
of the cement to around 12.5 and provides a stable
oxide layer on the steel surface, which
prevents the anodic dissolution of the
steel. Reinforced concrete failure is caused
by the corrosion of the steel reinforcing
bars as a result of the destabilisation of the
oxide layer. When the passivity of the
steel partly or completely breaks down,
either as result of carbonation or
chlorides, the corrosion will start. This Fig.1. Mechanism of chloride induced corrosion
chloride ingress into the concrete; use of corrosion- exposed to salt water, the concrete will absorb the
resistant reinforcement; addition of inhibitors to the salt water relatively fast and wetting and drying of
fresh concrete; and cathodic prevention by impressed the concrete especially in tidal zones can accelerate
current. the accumulation of high concentration of salt in the
concrete. Furthermore, similar areas of concrete with
Mix design, concrete cover and coating
similar exposure conditions will have variation in the
application
concrete deterioration process as it is very difficult to
The quality of concrete is of major importance in ensure homogeneity of concrete after being placed.
determining the durability of reinforced concrete
In certain applications where a 100 year design
structures. Although concrete is a dense material, it
life requirement is specified for structures located in
contains pores and many of these pores are
marine environments, the use of various chloride
interconnected to form a network of channels that
diffusion modelling, carbonation modelling and
allow water and oxygen, both important to steel
durability assessment of other deterioration
corrosion, to penetrate into the concrete. For this
mechanisms may lead to the theoretical development
reason, a low water/cement ratio will lead to either a
of concrete mixes and design covers that may provide
lower number of pores or smaller pores in the
theoretically a 100 year design life. Typical concrete
concrete, both of which can lead to a reduction of
used for such applications is 50MPa compressive
concrete permeability and to conductivity of the
strength concrete with, for example, a binder
concrete. In addition to selecting a lower cement
combination of 52% Shrinkage Limited (SL) cement,
ratio in the concrete, the selection of the cement type
25% fly ash, 23% blast furnace slag, 600Kg/m3
and the addition of mineral admixtures such as silica
cement content, 0.38 W/C ratio, 75 mm concrete
flume, fly ash and slag will play a significant role in
cover and 500 microstrain drying shrinkage at 56
reducing the corrosion rate of reinforcement in
days. There is no doubt, that the use of such concrete
concrete.
will lead to a substantial increase in the design life of
An adequate layer of concrete to the first layer of a structure in a harsh marine environment, however
reinforcing steel may under some circumstances, there are many other factors that could not be
delay the ingress of chloride ions. The adequate considered in the modelling process, such as concrete
depth of concrete cover is normally stated in various cracking; wetting and drying effect in accelerating
standards, subject to the exposure condition of the the rate of chloride penetration; early-age exposure
structure. The minimum depth of concrete cover to seawater before the concrete has gained sufficient
must be adjusted to allow for tolerances caused by maturity and density; high temperatures during
construction practices. concrete placement; homogeneity of the concrete;
workmanship problems especially in relation to
For dense, high quality concrete with adequate
concrete cover; and finally, the nature of the
concrete cover, carbonation induced corrosion of the
formation of the corrosion cell due to chloride ingress
embedded steel is not considered to represent a major
problem, however, for concrete structures in marine within the structure which only requires ingress of
environments, regardless of the quality of concrete chloride to the steel level at various crack locations to
and the thickness of the concrete cover, it appears start the development of unlimited numbers of
that it is only a matter of time before detrimental corrosion cells within the concrete itself.
amounts of chloride reach the embedded steel Coating the external surfaces of concrete may in
through the concrete covers or concrete cracks and some circumstances, assist in delaying the onset of
cause reinforcement corrosion and concrete spalling. reinforcement corrosion. In a marine environment,
The penetration of chloride takes place through especially in the tidal and splash areas, it is unlikely
uncracked concrete mainly by capillary absorption that such a measure will be effective in preventing
and diffusion. When a relatively dry concrete is reinforcement corrosion.
When epoxy coated rebars have been used in For marine structures, where the primary
substructures that are exposed to a severely corrosive problem is chloride-induced corrosion, the increase in
service life could be too short to justify the extra cost
environment, the epoxy coated rebars did not
required for the use of galvanised reinforcement.
perform well. Significant premature corrosion of the
Rapid corrosion will occur when galvanised and black
epoxy coated rebars was observed in many structures
steel is used in the same structure and is electrically
after 5-10 years from the date of construction.
connected in chloride-contaminated structures.
The main reasons for the failure of the epoxy
Stainless steel reinforcement
coated rebars are:
The term stainless steel refers to a group of
Under-film corrosion because of the migration of
water, oxygen and chlorides through the concrete corrosion resistant steels containing a minimum of
and epoxy to the steel surface; 12% chromium. Various alloying additions (nickel,
titanium, nitrogen.etc) can be added to provide
Wet adhesion loss resulting in the separation of different mechanical and corrosion properties. The
the coating from the substrate; and use of stainless steel in concrete is related to its
Disbondment of the epoxy coating from the capacity to resist corrosion in chloride-contaminated
reinforcing steel which starts at coating defects. structures.
It is the authors' opinion that the use of epoxy Stainless steel reinforcement has been used in
coated rebars for corrosion prevention should not be various countries in structures that are located in
considered under any circumstances. In areas of low aggressive environments. Stainless steel has been
corrosion risk, the use of carbon steel with high used in construction joints or critical gaps between
columns and decks. There are no extensive related to the long-term experience with corrosion
performance data available from long-term use of inhibitors, the effect of corrosion inhibitors on
stainless steel as reinforcement in concrete. concrete properties, the acceleration of corrosion
when the corrosion inhibitors are used with
Because of the very high cost of stainless steel
inadequate dosage, and other issues related to the
reinforcement, it is not likely that the entire
leaching out and evaporation of the inhibitors from
reinforcement for a large marine structure would be
the concrete.
made from stainless steel. A more likely use of
stainless steel would be for the outer rebar layer of a In general, it appears that if inhibitors are used in
reinforced concrete element in the tidal/splash zone. suitable concentration, they may delay the initiation
Galvanic corrosion in this case between stainless steel of corrosion, however there is no established evidence
and carbon steel should be investigated. that the commercial inhibitors available at present
are able to reduce the corrosion rate after the
Corrosion inhibitors
initiation of corrosion.
Corrosion inhibitors are chemicals that can be
Cathodic prevention
added to the concrete to decrease the corrosion rate.
The inhibitors can be subdivided into three Steel embedded in alkaline-free chloride concrete
categories, anodic inhibitors, which are used to is in the passive condition. This passivity breaks
reduce the anodic reaction rate, cathodic inhibitors, down when the level of chloride content exceeds the
which are used to reduce the cathodic reaction rate, threshold and pitting corrosion can initiate.
and mixed inhibitors which are used to reduce
Cathodic prevention is an electrochemical
cathodic and anodic reaction rates.
technique that involves the application of a small
The inhibitors are used as a preventive measure electrical current using anodes that have been
for new reinforced concrete structures in aggressive embedded in the concrete during construction. This
environments with a known future risk of chloride- system can be applied to an entire structure or to
induced corrosion. Corrosion inhibitors are marketed selected elements of a structure with the aim of
separately as admixtures or they are present in the preventing reinforcement corrosion when chloride
repair product used for conventional patch repair. penetration from the environment takes place during
the service life of the structure. The basic philosophy
There are various questions in relation to the of cathodic prevention is that a much smaller
application of corrosion inhibitors as admixtures to cathodic prevention current is required to prevent
reinforced concrete. Some of these questions are pitting corrosion compared to a higher current
requirement to suppress ongoing corrosion.
The cost of the application of cathodic
prevention is substantially lower than the
cost of the application of cathodic
protection.
The conditions for pitting initiation and
propagation were pointed out by Pourbaix
who during the 1970s introduced the
concept of "imperfect passivity" and "perfect
passivity" intervals. The different domain of
potentials is shown below. As can be seen
from the graph, for cathodic prevention, a
modest lowering of the steel potential can
produce a significant increase in the critical
chloride level. The free corrosion potential of steel environment, the exposure conditions should be
ranges from -200mV to 0mV versus saturated established and the elements of the structure should
calomel electrode (SCE). Pitting corrosion can take be classified based on corrosion risk.
place if the chloride level exceeds 0.4%w/w cement.
It is the authors' opinion that for any elements of
If a cathodic prevention current is applied to steel the structure that are classified in the low corrosion
in chloride-free concrete, this will allow the steel to risk category, a combination of the use of high
remain passive even when the chloride reaches a performance concrete, good concrete cover and
considerably high content. The cathodic prevention external coating can be used to ensure long term
current produces hydroxide ions at the steel surface durability of the structure and to increase its life with
and causes the chloride ions to move toward the minimal maintenance.
anode away from the steel.
For any elements of the structure that are
When cathodic prevention is applied, the classified as high corrosion risk areas, such as the
initiation of a new pit is prevented but pitting can tidal and splash zones, the only economically viable
propagate. For this reason cathodic prevention has to option that can be considered is the use of high
be applied before corrosion initiates and must be performance concrete combined with the use of good
maintained throughout the service life of the
concrete cover and the installation of a cathodic
structure. If pitting corrosion has initiated, the
prevention system. It is important to note that any
current capacity typical for cathodic prevention will
cathodic prevention system should be maintained for
no longer be sufficient and cathodic protection
the life of the structure as an integral part of the
current would be required.
maintenance program of the structure.
Graph showing: cathodic prevention (1-2-3-);
cathodic protection restoring passivity (1-4-5-); and The use of a suitable type stainless steel
cathodic protection reducing corrosion rate (1-4-6-) reinforcement can also be considered to improve the
corrosion resistance of reinforcement. However, this
The use of cathodic prevention for prestressed should only be considered only if stainless steel is
steel will eliminate the risk of hydrogen evolution used for the entire structure and no stainless steel is
because a lower current is required to prevent the used in conjunction with carbon steel in order to
initiation of pitting corrosion. A typical operating avoid potential galvanic corrosion problems.
current for cathodic prevention ranges from 1-2mA/
m² of steel. The cathodic prevention design current References
density is normally 10mA/m² of steel surface. The Tettamanti, M., Rossini A., and Cheaitani, A., "Cathodic
design for a cathodic prevention system, system Prevention and Cathodic Protection of New and Existing
monitoring and operation is similar to cathodic Concrete Elements at the Sydney Opera House", Corrosion/97,
protection. The main difference is related to the Paper No.255, NACE, 1997.
lower current density requirement and the ease of
Cheaitani, A., "Corrosion Prevention for Marine Structures",
installation during construction. Coast and Ports Australasian Conference 2003, New Zealand.
Conclusion Cheaitani, A., Karajayli, P., and Chun-Ni, J., "Application of
Cathodic Prevention to Sea Cliff Bridge, Lawrence Hargrave
In order to improve the corrosion resistance of Drive", Corrosion & Prevention 2006, Paper 006.
reinforced concrete structures to be built in marine
Cheaitani, A., Pedeferri, P., Bazzoni, B., Karajayli, P., and Dick,
environments, it is essential to undertake durability R., "Performance of cathodic
assessment, durability design and durability planning
prevention system of Sydney Opera House underbroadwalk
as a part of the design phase and construction phase after 10 years of operation", Paper No. 06342, NACE 2006.
in order to minimise the risk of long term
deterioration of the structure. Zhou,H., and Cheaitani, A., "Corrosion prevention of new
reinforced concrete structures", Chengdu Conference, China
For any structure located in a marine 2006.
P
olymer modification of cement paste increases fibres increases its toughness (resistance to crack
the tensile and flexural strength of mortars and propagation). Polymer modification of cement paste
concrete and reduces their brittle nature. Since increases its tensile and flexural strength and reduces
the polymer-modified cement is a composite of two its brittle nature by increasing toughness of mortars
entirely different types of materials, the and concrete. In this presentation we will briefly
characteristics of the key components, cement and review the field of polymer modified concrete and
polymer, will be briefly described. Classification of mortars. Since the polymer modified cement is a
the polymers used in modification is followed by a composite of two entirely different types of materials,
description of the main characteristics of flexible the characteristics of the key components, cement
polymer-modified cement composites and their and polymer, will be briefly described. Classification
applications in concrete repair. of the polymers used in modification is followed by a
Portland cement based concrete and mortar are description of the main characteristics of polymer-
among the most widely used construction materials. modified cements and their applications in concrete
Low cost, high stiffness, high compressive strength, repair. The presentation will then describe
non-flammability and ease of fabrication are the most performance characteristic and applications of novel
obvious advantages of concrete, whilst low tensile highly flexible, polymer modified cement composites.
strength, brittleness and, to some extent, long term We will conclude by showing that future use of
durability represent its most serious limitations. polymer modified cement composites will likely be in
Reinforcing the concrete with steel provides the the area of durability and performance improvements
necessary tensile strength and the incorporation of of cement materials applied in thin sections.
are mainly interested in flexibility of polymer cement Polymer modification of cement paste changes the
composites, we need to introduce the term "glass properties of mortar and concrete. These effects
transition temperature "Tg" of a polymer. Below the depend mainly on the polymer content, expressed as
Tg temperature, polymers exhibit "glassy" behavior polymer/cement ratio, the type of polymer and also
and are relatively brittle with limited flexibility. At the design of the mortar or concrete. Typical effects
temperatures above Tg, the polymer is more flexible are summarized in Table 2.
and tough and exhibits a larger elongation in tension. Property Effect
At Tg properties such as specific volume, specific Compressive strength Decreased or increased
heat, dielectric coefficient, rates of gas/liquid Tensile strength Increased
diffusion through the polymer and conductivity Fracture Toughness Increased
change as shown in Figure 2. Adhesion Increased
Modulus of Elasticity Decreased or increased
Drying shrinkage Decreased or increased
Water vapor permeability Decreased
Hydraulic permeability Decreased
Creep Decreased of increased
CO2 permeability Decreased
Chloride penetration resistance Decreased
Chemical resistance Increased in some chemicals
cement solids), is shown in Figure 3. The Tg of the relationship of a non-reinforced and a polypropylene
acrylic polymer used in the study presented in Figure fabric reinforced, proprietary FPMC. The addition of
3, was +13 oC. short fibre reinforcement generally increases the
tensile strength but may reduce the tensile
elongation. The reinforcing fabric increases the
tensile strength properties without significantly
reducing the tensile elongation. The type of fibre or
fabric, their moduli of elasticity, fabric design and
volume fractions will affect the tensile stress/strain
behaviour of such a composite, but it is beyond the
scope of this presentation to cover this area. The
tensile stress/strain properties and other mechanical
properties of FPMC composite are affected by
temperature. With decreasing temperature the
flexibility of the FPMC composite decreases and this
Figure 3. Compressive and flexural strengths of polymer modi-fied
mortars vs polymer cement ratio (p/c). decrease becomes critical around temperatures below
Tensile Properties the Tg of the polymer used. The tensile stress/strain
behaviour is also affected by the wet or dry state of
Decreasing the Tg of polymer modifier and the composite material. A non-reinforced composite
increasing the polymer content in the mortar will exhibit lower ultimate tensile stress and ultimate
increases the tensile elongation. The ultimate tensile elongation in a wet (water saturated) state than those
elongation may vary anywhere from 5% to 100% of dry material. Tensile properties of flexible polymer
depending on the level of polymer modification, the modified cements may decrease with time but this
type of the polymer used (even for a given Tg), and decrease is also dependent on the type of exposure
the type of mortar used. The ultimate tensile stress such as continuous "wet", continuous "dry" or "wet
may vary from 1 MPa to 6-7 MPa and more, but and dry". The decrease in tensile elongation is usually
accompanied by an increase in tensile strength but it
can be to some extent controlled by the formulation
of the cement mortar.
Compression properties
The compressive strength of polymer-modified
mortar is also affected by polymer modification. permeance, a thin 2 mm layer may act as a very
Figure 5 shows the ultimate compressive strength efficient vapour retarder with permeance around 50-
values of mortars modified with polymers of varying 60 ng/Pa.s.m2 (or approximately 1 perm). On the
Tg temperature. other hand, flexible polymer modified cements can be
formulated at the same thickness of 2 mm to exhibit
Modulus of elasticity in tension
permeances, in excess of 500-600 ng/Pa.s.m2, (or 10
The tensile modulus of elasticity of flexible Perms), thus providing a highly "breathable"
polymer cement will vary considerably depending on waterproofing and protective layer.
the polymer content, Tg of the polymer and the
composition of the cement matrix. Thus the moduli Carbon dioxide and chloride penetration
of elasticity may reach values as low as 300-500 MPa resistance
for highly flexible composites. Data available from technical information on
Crack Spanning commercial products show that polymer modified
cements, including flexible cements, exhibit excellent
One of the reasons for using FPMC is their resistance to carbon dioxide penetration and are very
flexibility, allowing waterproofing of concrete effective protection for reinforced concrete structures
structures with "moving cracks". The crack bridging against carbonation and consequent corrosion of the
capacity of a non-reinforced and fabric reinforced reinforcing steel. Similarly the resistance to chloride
proprietary product in a thickness of 2.5 mm at
penetration of these materials is also very good
different levels of polymer modification is shown in
(Coppola et al. 1997).
Figure 6.
Abrasion resistance
Properly formulated FPMCs exhibit very good
abrasion resistance mainly because of their toughness.
Figure 7 shows "wet" abrasion resistance of several
materials: conventional sand cement/mortar, high Tg
polymer modified mortar, a "dry" polymer modified
proprietary repair mortar, a proprietary FPMC and a
polyurethane membrane - the type used in protection
of balconies. The Taber Abrader was used to
determine the abrasion rate and the results show that
the polymer-modified cement with low Tg is superior
Figure 6. Crack-bridging capability of reinforced and non-reinforced to conventional and polymer modified mortars and
proprietary FPMC as a function of polymer content.
has similar abrasion resistance to that of polyurethane
Hydraulic Permeability membrane. The testing was carried out under both
FPMC exhibit very good hydraulic dry and wet conditions. Under wet (water saturated)
impermeability. A relatively thin layer, 1.6-2.00 mm conditions the abrasion is higher for all the materials
thick, applied to concrete will resist water head tested in very similar proportions.
pressure in excess of 30-40 meters on both negative Salt Scaling Resistance
and positive sides.
The salt scaling resistance of FPMC is generally
Water vapor transmission very good, most likely due to the flexibility of the
Depending on the polymer/cement ratio, type of materials.
polymer and formulation of the modified mortar, the Chemical Resistance
FPMC will exhibit a wide range of water vapour
transmission. When expressed in terms of Due to their high polymer content, FPMC exhibit
T
echnology always advances faster than the rebar/concrete interface cannot maintain the passive
development of codes, specifications, and state of reinforcing steel, active corrosion in either
standards. Recent innovations in materials, uniform or localized form (pitting) will occur.
processes and corrosion control technologies have Because of the widespread use of reinforced concrete,
enabled designers and architects to meet today corrosion of reinforcing steel is rapidly
performance-based specifications at lower life cycle becoming a major problem throughout the world.
cost. This paper focuses on the recent developments Bridges, marine structures, buildings and other
and applications of state-of-the-art emerging concrete structures are being severely damaged by
technologies for repair and rehabilitation of corrosion.
reinforced concrete structures. These technologies
Carbonation
include: press-on zinc hydrogel anode CP system,
snap-on zinc mesh anode CP system, pre-packaged Carbonation refers to the interaction of carbon
zinc sacrificial anode system, conductive concrete, dioxide in atmosphere with the hydroxides in the
electrochemical chloride extraction (CE) or concrete. Carbonation is detrimental to the corrosion
electrochemical chloride removal (ECR), resistance of reinforcing steel as it destroys the
electrochemical realkalisation (ER), duplex/stainless passive film.
steels and alloys reinforcements. Most of these Ca(OH)2+CO2=CaCO3+H2O
emerging technologies are also increasingly used for
corrosion prevention in new concrete structures. CaCO3+CO2+H2O=Ca(HCO3)2
Some application examples are also cited to soluble bicarbonate
demonstrate the potentials of these promising
technologies in the new millennium. Leaching of Ca(OH)2 due to carbonation causes
the pH of the concrete to fall below 9 and this leads
Primer on Concrete Corrosion to the depassivation of the reinforcing steel surface.
General
Chlorides
Reinforced concrete is the most versatile and
potentially one of the most durable materials that a Chlorides are well known for their ability to
designer can choose to build almost any type of penetrate and destroy passive films on steels and
structures. Under normal conditions, the reinforcing alloys.
steel is in a passive state - it is protected from Fe => Fe2+ + 2e-
corrosion by a rather inert oxide film (passive film) on
its surface. The formation and the subsequent FeCl2+2H2O=2HCl + Fe(OH)
breakdown of such an oxide film are mainly Chlorides may come from an external source such
determined by the pH and the chloride content of as seawater or exist as mixed-in. The local
the concrete. When the local environment at the acidification due to the hydrolysis of metal chloride
creates an auto-catalyzing situation for the corrosion more attracting and promising today.
of steel. Chlorides either alone or combined with
carbonation are the primary cause of concrete Pressure-sensitive Zinc-Hydrogel Anode
corrosion. For conventional CP systems (SA or ICCP) to
function properly, it requires the presence of a
Corrosion Products
continuous conductive electrolyte between the anode
As corrosion continues, corrosion products build and the cathode. This is to form a closed circuit such
up around the reinforcing steel. Corrosion products that the reinforcing steel is indeed made the cathode.
commonly observed when concrete cores containing In areas of electrical discontinuity, reinforcing steel
corroding rebar were broken open were ferrous would not be cathodically protected. One of the
hydroxide (Fe(OH)2), hydrated ferrous chloride recent innovations is the self-adhesive and conductive
(FeC12H2O), and black ferrous oxide (Fe3O4).The zinc-hydrogel anode that provides a continuous
exact product formed depends on the availability of electrolyte contact between the anode and the
oxygen, water, and chloride ion, but the result is reinforcing steel embedded in the concrete structure.
essentially the same. These corrosion products occupy The pressure-sensitive zinc-hydrogel anode is
from 2 to 14 times the volume of the original steel, essentially a sheet of zinc foil coated with an ionically
creating an expansive force that is sufficient to cause conductive hydrogel pressure-sensitive adhesive
the concrete to crack. Propagation of the cracks leads (Figure 1), which serves as the electrolyte between
to staining, spalling and delamination of concrete. the anode (zinc foil) and the cathode (reinforcing steel
in concrete). The hydrogel is covered with a liner to
Innovative Cathodic Protection Systems for help protect it from contamination. At time of
Concrete Repair and Rehabilitation installation, the protective liner is removed from the
hydrogel by hand, and the zinc-hydrogel anode is
Introduction adhered to the clean, bare concrete surface.
Zinc, as a sacrificial anode, has been used to This zinc foil anode coated with hydrogel is
catholically protect ship's hulls for more than a provided in roll form for coverage of the concrete
century now. It has become a common practice to use surface to be protected. The ionically conductive
cathodic protection either alone or in combination hydrogel performs two functions: (1) to enable the
with coatings for buried pipelines, storage tanks and anode to be securely adhered to the exterior surface
offshore structures. It has been well established both of the concrete structure, and (2) to serve as a
in theory and in practice that the process achieves an continuous conductive electrolyte between the anode
immediate reduction in corrosion rate by making the and the concrete structure.
reinforcing steel the cathode, inhibiting its tendency
to oxidize. In addition, the cathodic reactions at the How It Work
steel/concrete interface increase the alkalinity (raise As illustrated in Fig. 2, the zinc foil is applied to
the pH) by hydroxyl ion (OH-) generation and drive the surface of structurally sound concrete structure.
chloride ions (Cl-) away from the steel as a result of The pressure sensitive adhensive (conductive
the negative charge on the ions being repelled by the hydrogel) bridges the gap between the zinc anode
negative polarity of the reinforcement and attracted (foil in this case) and the concrete surface - making
to the positive polarity of an installed anode. Thus possible the electrolyte continuity across the anode
Cathodic Protection of steel in concrete has always and cathode (rebars).
incorporated some degree of Realkalisation (increase
in pH) and Chloride Extraction (redistribution of The zinc foil must be electrically connected to the
chlorides). Both these processes reduce the risk of rebar network by wires so that electrons can flow
corrosion of steel in the concrete and also achieve through the wire from zinc (anode) to rebars
further protection. Recent innovations in materials (cathode). Conventionally, current flows in the
and design have made CP, - the old remedy, ever opposite direction of electrons, i.e., from cathode to
output) at which zinc "sacrifices" itself (in order to Major Attractions and Applications
protect the cathode):
Compared with conventional CP system, the
snap-on zinc mesh anode jacket has the following
attractions:
Manufacturer's data sheet suggests that the zinc All-in-one, self-contained sacrificial anode CP
mesh embedded in the snap-on fibreglass jacket has a system
projected life of 46 years. Snap-on type quick, easy installation
Low cost effective repairs
Maintenance-free
No need for external power
Long life protection
Jackets are available in a wide range of sizes and
can accommodate both square and round pilings
(Fig.10)
Major applications include splash and tidal zones
of steel reinforced concrete structures. Optional Cast
bulk zinc anode can be used on fully submerged
structures.
Fig.6 Snap-on Zinc Mesh Anode CP System (Galvashield LJ) (Photo Electrochemical Treatment
copyrighted by FOSROC International and Alltrista Zinc products
Company) Principles
In all electrochemical restoration techniques a
direct current is applied between the reinforcement
(cathode) and an external anode in electrolytic
contact with the concrete. Cathodic protection (CP) is
a permanent installation with design currents below
10 mA/m2, electrochemical chloride extraction (or
removal, - EC or ECR) and electrochemical
realkalisation (ER) are applied only on a temporary
basis and use currents up to 1 A/m2. In all three
Fig 7 & 8 The two-piece fiberglass jackets snap together (Photo cases the electrochemical reactions at the cathode (the
copyrighted by FOSROC International and Alltrista Zinc rebars) produce hydroxyl ions leading to an increase
products Company)
of the pH near the rebar. This facilitates passivation
of the steel. Reaction (1b) is possible at very high
current densities and produces hydrogen and
especially high tensile steels under load could suffer
hydrogen embrittlement.
2 H2O + O2 + 4e ==> 4OH- (1a) (at low
current density)
2 H2O + 2e- ==> 2OH- + H2 (1b) (at high
current density)
Fig.9 Zinc Mesh Anode Installed on Bridge Pilings (Photo copyrighted
by FOSROC International and Alltrista Zinc products Company) At the anode the possible oxidation reactions are
2 H2O ==>O2 + 4H+ + 4e- (2a) (if tap Electrochemical chloride removal and
water is used) electrochemical realkalization lead to an increase in
pH at the rebars and to repassivation of corroding
4OH- ==> O2 + 2H2O + 4e- (2a') (if steel. The durability of ECR has been proven on
alkaline solution is used) different site jobs with a track record between five
2 Cl- ==>C12 + 2e- (2b) and eight years if further chloride ingress is avoided
by applying a coating on the concrete surface. Several
H2O + C12 ==>HCl + HClO (2b') reinforced concrete structures treated with ER
These reactions lead to an acidification of the showed good performance over several years without
electrolyte around the anode (OH- ions are converted applying a coating. To avoid adverse side effects the
into O2; H2O is converted into H+). The decrease in current density during the treatments must be
pH value in the electrolyte around the anode depends limited to < 2 A/m2 steel surface. Methods and
on the current density applied. quantitative criteria to assess the efficiency and
durability of the electrochemical repair methods
Anode and Electrolyte Selection should be improved and defined in an international
standard.
Electrochemical Realkalisation:
Anode material: Steel mesh Conductive Concrete
materials such as carbon fiber, graphite and 'coke control and electric or thermal heating for deicing
breeze' - a cheap by-product of steel production - to have been attempted and met limited success. Based
make a continuous network of conducting pathway. on the results of a transient heat transfer analysis, a
The design formulation is based on the 'electrical thin conductive concrete overlay on a bridge deck has
percolation' principle by which the composite the potential to become a cost effective deicing
conductivity increases dramatically by several orders method. When connected to a power source, heat is
of magnitude when the content of the conductive generated due to the electrical resistance in the
phase reaches a critical 'threshold' value. Further cement admixture with metallic particles and steel
increases in the conductive phase content boost fibers. Small-scale slab heating experiments have
composite conductivity only slightly. The design shown that an average power of about 520 W/m2
specifies an amount just over the threshold content, (48 W/ft2) was generated by the conductive concrete
assuring high conductivity and mechanical strength to raise the slab temperature from -1.1oC (30oF) to
as well as good mixing conditions. 15.6oC (60oF) in 30 minutes. This power level is
Concrete bridge decks are prone to ice consistent with the successful deicing applications
accumulation. The use of road salts and chemicals for using electrical heating cited in the literature.
deicing is cost effective but causes damage to Applications of Conductive Concrete
concrete and corrosion of reinforcing steel in concrete
bridge decks. This problem is a major concern to The conductive concrete can be used as a
transportation officials and public works due to rapid structural material and bonds well with normal
degradation of existing concrete pavements and concrete. The conventional mixing type is
bridge decks. The use of insulation materials for ice lightweight, with only 70 per cent of normal
concrete weight. Thermal stability is comparable to
normal concrete, production employs conventional
mixing and casting equipment, and application of the
conductive concrete is similar to that of conventional
concrete. The conductive concrete could be used
along with specially configured electrodes and an
electric power supply to provide de-icing on roads,
sidewalks, bridges and runways. Placed as an overlay,
conductive concrete with very low resistivity can be
used as a secondary anode in existing cathodic
protection systems, providing uniform current
distribution over its large surface area and reduced
anodic current density. At the same time, it provides
excellent mechanical stability due to its load-bearing
capacity and its bond strength as an overlay. And
because conductive concrete attenuates
electromagnetic and radio waves, it can be used to
shield computer equipment from eavesdropping
efforts and protect electrical installations and
electronic equipment from interference.
The Benefits
Sydney Opera House Conductive concrete has excellent mechanical and
Type 316 stainless steel rebar and mesh replacing carbon steel electrical conductivity properties.
reinforced concrete which failed after about 25 years of service
(Photo copyrighte dby NiDI) It is much lighter in weight than conventional
Institute, 3M Company (S) Pte Ltd, Fosroc Ø J. Parker, Concrete, September 1997
International. Ø P. Whiteway, Nickel, Vol.14, September 1998
References Ø R. J. Kessler, "Zinc Mesh Anode Cast into Concrete Pile
Jackets", Materials Performance, December 1996
Ø Peter Pullar-Strecker, Corrosion Damaged Concrete,
Butterworths 1987 Ø G. Sergi and C. L. Page, Sacrificial Anodes for Cathodic
Protection of Reinforcing Steel Around Patch Repair Applied to
Ø Corrosion of Steel in Concrete, Eds P. Schiessl, Chapman and Chloride-Contaminated Concrete", EuroCorr' 99
Hall, 1988
Ø J. Flis et al, Corrosion, Vol.49, 1993
Ø Corrosion of Reinforecment in Concrete Construction, Eds Alan
P. Crane, Ellis Horwood, 1983 Ø "Concrete Conductor", Construction Materials, Chemistry &
Industry News, 17 March 1997
Ø Corrosion Rate of Steel in Concrete, ASTM, STP 1065, 1988
Ø P. Xie, P. Gu and J. Beaudoin, Electrical Percolation Phenomena
Ø Cathodic Protection of Reinforcement Steel in Concrete, Eds K.
G. C. Berkeley, Butterworths, 1990 in Cement Composites Containing Conductive Fibres", Journal
of Materials Science, Vol. 31, 1996
Ø Controlling Concrete Degradation, Proc of the International
Seminar, University of Dundee, Scotland, 1999 Ø Renderoc Galvashield XP - Sacrificial Anodes for Sustaining
Localised Concrete Repairs, system guide of FOSROC limited.
Ø Corrosion of Reinforcement in Concrete, Eds C. L. Page, K. W.
J. Treadaway and P. B. Bamforth, 1990 Ø Galvashield LJ for Marine Structures, Product Guide of
FOSROC limited.
Ø Corrosion of Reinforcing Steel in Concrete and Its Prevention by
Cathodic Protection, J. Bennett, 1986 Ø Rob W. Lambe and Nigel Davison, Enhancing the Durability of
Concrete Repair Systems, Concrete' 99, 6th International
Ø Corrosion of Reinforcement in Concrete Construction, Eds C. L. Conference on Concrete Engineering and Technology, 29 June -
Page, P. B. Bamforth and J. W. Figg, 1996 1 July 1999, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Ø C. J. Abbott, Concrete, May 1997 Ø Zinc-Hydrogel Anode 4727, Product Guide, 3M.
Ø A. Lewis, Concrete, September 1997
Ø R. B. Hartman and J. E. Wehling, "A Galvanic Zinc-Hydrogel
Ø B. Elsener, M. Monila and H. Bohni, Corrosion Science, Vol.35, System for Cathodic Protection of Reinforced Concrete
p1563 (1993) Structures", 3M Company
T he importance of construction
chemicals can never be
overemphasized, especially in a
developing country like India where
awareness levels about them is
comparatively lower. The 2nd
International Conference on
Construction Chemicals “ Construction
Chemicals Conclave -2011 , organized
by FICCI and the Dept. of Chemicals &
Petrochemicals, Govt. of India, was
therefore an important event, with
several industry luminaries
highlighting the advantages of
construction chemicals and the way
forward for the country in the field. The
conference was held at Hotel Le
Meridian, Bengaluru, from March 17-18.
construction chemicals in the last two in India to say the least. To put things
The conclave featured high profile decades. Surging construction activity, into perspective, one just needs to look
speakers from both and abroad talk on spurred on by the continued impetus at the market in comparison with that
the entire spectrum of topics to infrastructure development of a development nation like the
connected to the construction activities and the booming real estate United States where the market is
chemicals industry. Going into the market are giving fillip to the valued at US $ 7.7 billion.
current status of the industry, construction chemicals market in the
While the overall market is fairly
Mr.R .K.Bhatia, Head-Chemicals country today. Talking about the
consolidated, there is considerable
Division, FICCI, observed “Construction challenges ahead Mr.R.Mukundan,
fragmentation when it comes to
chemicals is estimated to be an Rs.1, Managing Director, Tata Chemicals Ltd, application areas. While admixtures
800 crore industry in the country. in his welcome address said “The form the largest selling products at 35
About 85 percent of contractors aren't construction chemicals market is right percent, flooring chemicals follow
aware of the advantages of now small but we can expect rapid second with a 15 percent market share.
construction chemicals,” a fact that growth rate of 25-35 %. This is not Another interesting fact is that the top
was agreed to by almost all the going to be sufficient. Why can't we five players account for about 50
speakers. think of making it a ` 10,000 crore percent of the market, while the rest of
However, there is no denying the industry? This conference has been it is taken care of by the smaller,
fact that awareness levels about organized to address such challenges. unorganized players.
construction chemicals is on the rise in For instance, how can we improve
Speaking further about the
the country. The rapid advancements quality standards, etc.”
challenges faced by the industry, guest
in building technology owe a lot to the The growth potential for the speaker, Dr.Paul J.Tikalsky, Chairman &
d eve l o p m e nt s i n t h e f i e l d o f construction chemicals industry is huge P ro fe s s o r, D e p t . o f C i v i l a n d
Environmental (Nuclear) Engineering, address by Mr.S.C.Gupta, Joint address was the emphasis on
The University of Utah, USA, remarked Secretary, Dept. of Chemicals and sustainability and how construction
in his address, “Development of Petrochemicals, GoI, who during his chemicals can contribute towards a
infrastructure in a sustainable way is speech observed that the construction green tomorrow.
the challenge for the construction chemicals industry is potentially a US $
Under the topic of “Role of
industry. We must therefore find 1 billion industry by 2020.” According
Construction Chemicals in making
inorganic and organic chemicals for a to estimates, construction chemicals
S u s t a i n a b l e S t r u c t u r e s ”,
sustainable environment.” cost less than 2 % of the total
Dr.S.K.Manjrekar, Chairman and
construction cost, but offer immense
Dwelling on the way forward for the Managing Director, Sunanda Specialty
benefits,” Mr.Gupta quipped, speaking
industry, Mr.Sanjay Bahadur, CEO, Coatings Pvt Ltd, highlighted the crucial
about the advantages of construction
Pidilite Industries, said in his keynote role of construction chemicals in
chemicals and the lack of awareness
address that diminishing natural today's world, where sustainable
about them in the country. He also
resources, demands of mass housing, structures are the norm. Giving an
pointed out that things are changing
high-rise construction, high speed architect's perspective on the issue,
for the better and it is only a matter of
construction, etc, are all challenges for Ms.Meghana Dutta, Principal
time before the country catches up
the construction chemicals industry. Architect, Studio Decode, observed
with the rest of the world in the field.
“Propagation of the multiple benefits that, “Every building presents an
of construction chemicals is the need of The session on “Overview of opportunity for sustainability.” The
the hour,” added Mr.Bahadur, Construction Chemicals” was chaired session on “Green Chemistry of
emphasizing the role that major brands by Dr.Y.P.Kapoor, a doyen in the Construction Chemicals for
have to play in this industry, which is construction chemicals industry and Sustainability” also saw speakers
still at a nascent stage in India. Director, Editorial, Construction including, Mr.K.Padmakar, Head-
As part of the vision statement, Chemicals, The Masterbuilder. The P ro d u c t M a n a ge m e nt , P i d i l i te
M r. D . S i t a r a m i a h , E x p e r t a n d eight sessions saw over 30 eminent Industries, and Mr.Ravindra Babu,
Consultant, spoke about history of speakers from the industry speak on an Marketing Manager, Fosroc India speak
construction chemicals in India, its entire gamut of topics pertaining to the on the relationship between
current status and where it is headed. construction chemicals industry. A key sustainability and construction
This was followed by the inaugural undertone in almost every speaker's chemicals.
I
ndia has an ambitious target of power production company and registered under Companies Act, 1956
by Nuclear Power Reactors to meet future energy on 22nd October 2003 under the administrative
needs of the country. Two Indian companies, control of Department of Atomic Energy is presently
Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited (NPCIL) involved in construction and commissioning of 500
and Bharatiya Nabhikiya Vidyut Nigam Limited MWe Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor (PFBR) at
(BHAVINI) are responsible organization to construct Kalpakkam. Kalpakkam is an important nuclear
thermal reactors and fast breeder reactors respectively establishment of Department of Atomic Energy of
in the country. NPCIL is currently operating India and this coastal site is situated 70Km south of
seventeen nuclear reactors and constructing five Chennai. The PFBR is the forerunner for the future
reactors. Many more reactors are at anvil. Bharatiya Fast Breeder Reactors to be constructed in various
Nabhikiya Vidyut Nigam Limited formed as a parts of our country including two more reactors at
Kalpakkam to meet the future energy needs of India. Fig 2(a) Integrated layout of shore protection &PFBR Intake &Outfall
BHAVINI is constructing Mega Project PFBR and designed to draw sea water from off-shore location
the reactor is now in advanced stage of construction. above sea bed, where depth of water is approximately
10 metres. Central Water and Power Research
Preface: Station (CWPRS) has developed the scheme of
drawing condenser cooling water, the length of
PFBR is situated on the south of existing twin
intake submarine tunnel, position of intake shaft, the
units of Madras Atomic Power Station (MAPS). The
depth at which the water should enter the intake
centre lines of MAPS unit 2 and PFBR are only 500 shaft, and has finalized the hydraulic parameters of
meter apart. PFBR and MAPS locations on the beach intake. CWPRS finalised these parameters based on
of Bay of Bengal, is shown in Figure-1. extensive study of several factors including the height
Submarine Tunnel
The submarine tunnel has a length of 556m and a
diameter of 3.6m
Fig 6c: Inner view of the tunnel
Approach Jetty for the Offshore intake shaft
Intake Submarine Tunnel
Approach jetty has the length of 567m width is
3.52m and diameter 7.1m Exploratory bore holes were drilled along the
centre line alignment of the proposed submarine
Geotechnical Investigation along the length of tunnel well before the tunnel construction was taken
depth of 65m below the sea bed for fixing the tunnel
Invert level for safe tunneling. Further, tests were
also carried out for finalizing the design of tunnel
supports, lining thickness etc. These 13 numbers of
bore holes were drilled from fore bay location to
offshore intake location (600m length). Out of 13
core samples collected along the length of the tunnel,
five boreholes namely TBH-1 to TBH-5 were on
shore boreholes and eight boreholes namely TBH-6
to TBH-13 are off shore boreholes. The intake well is
located at the bore hole No.13. The bore holes drilled
at 50m intervals indicate that the hard rock levels
closely follow the sea bed profile (expect bore hole
Fig 7a: Construction of approach jetty No.7).
Apart from these, 13 bore holes for geotechnical
evaluation, two numbers of receiver boreholes were
also drilled which are on shore bore holes, for cross
hole tests.
All the fifteen boreholes including on shore and
offshore were plugged using grout material
consisting of cement and bentonite in 1:1 proportion.
Fig 8: Original layout sea water intake structure, approach jetty, seal pit
& outfall structure
the centre line of the tunnel and this is true even at property etc., were planned to be conducted.
TBH-7 where the hard rock was found at much
deeper depth. Weathered Rock
M/S Design Group Project Consultants (P) This zone is encountered immediately below the
Limited, Bangalore have provided the entire design clay horizon. This zone consists of broken core of
and construction detailing for the submarine tunnel garnetiferous charnockite and chloritised charnockite
after analyzing the geotechnical investigation data. / migmatite. Thickness of the weathered zone ranges
They have also analysed the rocks, produced from 0m to 15.6 m (approx.).
geological mapping, decided on rock anchoring, Hard Basement Rock
taken decision on geological issues encountered
during construction and have produced detailed This zone occurs immediately below the
reports of the incidents. weathered rock zone without any transition to fresh
rock. The hard basement rock has been encountered
Geological Characterisation of the Lithological in all the Bore holes between 10.5 m to 18 m depths
Units: from ground level except for Borehole 7 (TBH-7),
All boreholes reveal similar stratification. Four where hard rock is encountered at a depth of 29 m
distinct layers were noted in all the bore holes, these below ground level. Depth persistence and lateral
are Sandy soil, Clay layer, Weathered rock and Hard prevalence of the hard rock has been established as
rock. Geological characteristics of the lithological seen from the correlation of the sub surface
units encountered was analysed by experts and the lithological data.
detailed description of the lithological units are given Hard basement rock encountered in this strata
below: belongs to the Archean Charnockite group of rocks
Upper Brown Granular Zone and Migmatite complex comprising igneous intrusive
rocks and metamorphic rock. The charnockite group
This is upper most zone which comprises of fine of rocks is made up of quartz, pyroxene, feldspar, and
to medium to coarse grain brown sand, with angular garnet. The charnockite group of rocks is also
/ assorted grains of transparent and opaque quartz, migmatised to varying degrees resulting in
minor specks of mica flakes (biotite) and mafics retrogression and conversion into migmatite complex
(hornblende, etc). There is a strand line close to the comprising different types. (Reference Geological
shaft. This indicates that it is an area of regression. Survey of India (GSl) map,1998). The migmatite
The grain size variation is not uniform. Thickness of complex comprises of different types of gneiss, such
this lithological unit ranges between 5.5 - 10.5 m. as garnetiferous, biotite gneiss, hornblende gneiss,
Argillaceous Horizon augen gneiss and garnetiferous quartzo-felspathic
gneiss. The magmatite are generally grey coloured.
This lithological unit has a thickness of 2 to 9.7 m
(approx.) and its color is greyish / greenish. This clay In addition to this the mineralogical composition
is highly sticky and plastic, with rare shell fragments. and its assemblage manifested in the form of micro
This horizon can be taken as a marker horizon. It can joints, slips, shears, slickensides, rock alteration,
also be considered as an aquiclude and groundwater fracture filling, confined only to zones of thin
below this unit is likely to occur under semiconfined partings, foliation and joints at different depths.
and confined conditions. This clay occurs like a plug Excepting for these thin weak zones, the host rock /
and its origin is not confirmed as there is no zone of country rock appears to be homogeneous, medium to
transition above and below in its spatial distribution. coarse grained, migmatitic at places; as such there is
This shows a break in sedimentation and deposition no major zones showing any effect of intense
environment. Because of its pale green color, shearing. A deeply weathered zone encountered in
chemical composition study, plasticity, engineering TBH-7 is an exception.
Seepage was noticed at the contact of overburden not have been closely maintained to submarine
and excavated rock surface. However, necessary tunnel axis. This conclusion governed decision
precautions were taken which included channelizing making process for further commencement of tunnel
the seepage water and monitoring of seepage in the boring.
shaft.
TBH-4 was encountered during blasting on
The outlet shaft construction was incidence free previous day of the incidence i.e on 12.01.2009.
and was completed without major difficulty with all Small quantity sand had fallen down into the tunnel
the temporary supports. from the hole when the zone of TBH-4 was blasted.
On 13-1-2009 at 4am further blast of 3m length was
Submarine Tunnel: taken up. De-mucking operation of excavated rock
The horizontal horse shoe shaped excavation in was completed around 11am. At 11.15am subsidence
rock for submarine tunnel of size varying from 3.6m of sandy soil occurred at grade level (GL) exactly
to 4.2m is 560 meter long with Chainage 0.00 above the bore hole No.TBH-4. People working on
starting from centerline of vertical outlet shaft. the grade level noted that sinking of ground over
Conventional blasting using controlled charge was TBH-4 location and formation of a funnel shaped
deployed for the tunnel boring. chimney at the grade level, and people working in
the tunnel informed that certain slush along with
sand is falling through TBH-4 hole. On further
inspection of the tunnel it was observed that 76mm
dia TBH-4 bore has got unplugged of grouted
material (cement and bentonite in 1:1 proportion).
The slurry of grouted material along with about
12meter cube of sand has fallen down from the hole
on to the invert level of tunnel. Slight water too was
found dripping through the hole. A rod of 25mm dia
and about 4m length could be easily penetrated into
the unplugged hole of TBH-4 from inside the tunnel
bore.
Fig 9: Photos of Submarine tunnel
Two incidences were encountered during the Immediate action taken by BHAVINI after the
submarine tunnel construction. incidence-1:
Incidence-1: Ø As a safety precaution the tunnel rock excavation
work was stopped forthwith.
Observation:
Ø The matter was also referred to the experts who
On completion of CH11500 on 13th Jan 2009 it arrived at site for assessment within hours of the
was noted that the grout in TBH-4 collapsed and incident.
crumbled into the excavated tunnel. It also was noted
Decision making process following the incidence:
that while carrying out the rock excavation for tunnel
only 3 boreholes TBH-1, TBH-2 and TBH-4 have Ø The tunnel site was inspected by various experts.
been encountered within the alignment of tunnel but Several rounds of reviews and discussions were
not in centerline of the tunnel; rather they were away held. Experts expressed apprehension that minor
from central axis to varying extent; from 0.5 m to water seepage from TBH-1 and unplugged of
1.5m. TBH-3 could not be traced inside the tunnel. grouted material from TBH-4 does not provide
This lead site to reach a conclusion that the boring enough confidence that such incidence (seepage
tool might not have taken exact gravity line while from grout or unplugging of the grout borehole)
drilling and/or the position of the drilling rig might will not happened
Ø The tunnel has to be deviated to south-east and total pressure drop computed for the original layout
after certain distance made parallel to existing which is 1.9mwc. Hence, the additional drop in
alignment as jetty on north of tunnel prevents pressure because of two bends and increase in length
deviation of alignment to north. of the tunnel by two meters does not change the
pumping head requirement of the cooling water
Ø The rock profile in deviated contour should be
pumps. The pressure drop calculations were based on
predictable from already completed geo-technical
IS 2951 (Part-II). Since, the pressure drop due to the
studies. deviation in tunnel alignment is insignificant,
Ø The water pressure drop should have only increase in head loss does not result in lowering of
marginal increase even after addition of two bends water level in the forebay sump. Therefore, the water
in the tunnel. The existing sea water pump level in the forebay would not fall below the designed
supplying cooling sea water to the condenser minimum water level. Hence, the submergence
should be checked for its capability to cope up required for the pumps is not altered. This was also
with the increase flow path resistance. confirmed by DCPL who had carried out initial
design of the tunnel.
Ø The bio-fouling concern should not enhance due
to the deviation in the flow path of the tunnel. M/s IGCAR assessed and confirmed that there is
no impact on biofouling due to the proposed change
It was decided to divert the tunnel towards south- in the tunnel alignment by deviation.
east from the location of borehole No.TBH4 which is
at a distance of 115m towards east from the fore bay M/s CWPRS, Pune has confirmed that for the
shaft which is located on land. The straight line shifted location of the intake structure, sea conditions
such as littoral drift, current etc. considered for the
lengths of the tunnel upstream and downstream of
study for the original design will remain unaltered.
the bends were checked for compliance to Bureau of
Indian Standard, IS 2951. Based on the requirement With the above deviated alignment of the tunnel,
of straight length between the bends as per standard the new axis of the tunnel with perfect drilled TBH-5
IS 2951, it was decided to deviate the alignment of would be about 10.5 meter. Even after considering
the tunnel keeping the angle of deviation as 11º from TBH-5 alignment shift by 5.5 meters towards south,
TBH-4 and incline length to be maintained to 110m. the northern boundary of the deviated tunnel will be
The tunnel bore will be again diverted by 11º at the 2.5 meter from TBH-5. Therefore any opening of
end of 110m diversion to make it parallel to the TBH-5 in the deviated tunnel path and consequent
original alignment. The southward grouting of TBH-5 was not envisaged.
shift in the tunnel alignment thus works out to The geologists confirmed that the hard rock
21m. With the deviation of tunnel from the location profile at PFBR site generally follows the natural
of borehole No.4, involving horizontally shifting the ground profile. The slope is only form west to east
tunnel by 21m southwards at the end of an inclined and the rock profile follows the ground profile as
length of 110m, the increase in total tunnel length proved by the TBH bore holes. With the decision of
will be around 2m in addition to introduction of two shifting the tunnel by 21 meter towards south
bends. For deviated alignment of submarine tunnel - beyond TBH-5, no change is expected in the hard
plan (general arrangement please refer Annexure - 1). rock strata or the profile compared to initial
prediction based on geotechnical investigation. It
CWPRS that estimated the head loss due to may be noted that for the original geotechnical
shifting of the tunnel by 21m and two angular investigation itself the bore holes were taken at
deviations of 11º and at two end of an inclined length distance of 50m; each borehole representing the
of 110m as 0.023mwc (meter of water column). Thus strata over a radial distance of 25m. The new
the head loss due to change in the layout of the alignment is adjudged to be safe and the deviated
submarine tunnel is insignificant compared to the alignment of tunnel will also have adequate hard
rock cover. The available rock cover for the tunnel From 13.4 m to 25.05 m the rock is highly
from the crown is expected to be 4D on south of weathered. Further from 25.05 m to 30.0 m the rock
TBH-7 as at this location, the hard rock level is is highly weathered to moderately weathered
comparatively at a lower level than the other bore Charnockite with poor core recovery and nil RQD
holes. Whereas at the other borehole locations had been obtained. From 30 m to the end of the hole
indicate rock cover of more than 6D. (65 m) slightly weathered Charnockite with good
core recovery and fair to good RQD had been
Internal pressure due to water at submarine recorded.
tunnel level is about 5kg/sq.cm. (50m water
column), where as external pressure due to weight of The occurrence of deep weathering in a single
rock and over burden soil is about 11.4kg/sq.cm. As lithologically similar hole is intruguing. In view of
per IS standard 4880 Part-IV, maximum rock cover the completely weathered to highly weathered rock
required is H i.e. 5Kg/Sq.cm. With this 21m shift of with very poor core recovery, shattered rock and zero
the off-shore Intake structure towards south from the RQD in TBH-7 alone, it was inferred that the reason
original location, the jetty length has also to be for this may not be lithological but structural
increased by another 21m towards south. The infirmity. With only scanty subsurface data available,
grouting of already exposed boreholes i.e. TBH-2 & the experts took recourse to the regional geology and
4 located on land was also undertaken and effected also the geotechnical investigation done for Madras
successfully. Atomic Power Station (MAPS) tunnel bore holes
which is existing 500meter north of PFBR submarine
Depth (in m) Lithological Details tunnel and was constructed around forty year back.
0.0 – 7.0 Medium grained yellowish brown sand The absence of dolerite in any of the PFBR boreholes
7.0 – 13.40 Very stiff to hard brown sandy clay and the occurrence of dolerite in the MAPS tunnel
13.40 – 25.05 Yellowish grey completely weathered rock bore holes was had suggested to the possibility of an
25.05 – 26.0 Highly weathered Charnockite. Poor recovery. RQD east-west fault between the two tunnels before actual
Nil.
tunneling work started. Since, the dolerite rock is
26.0 – 29.0 Highly weathered grey fractured Charnockite. Poor
now encountered after the shear zone this possibility
Recovery. RQD Nil.
is now ruled out.
29.0 – 30.0 Moderately weathered Charnockite. Poor Recovery.
RQD 20% Possibility-1
30.0 – 60.0 Slightly weathered Charnockite. Recovery good,
RQD Fair to good. Regionally the foliation trend in the gneissic rock
is N25º to 50º ES25º to 50º W with a dip of 60 to
Incidence-2 (Shear Zone Encountered between 80 degree in easterly direction. N30º E - S30º W
Ch243 and Ch264) joints (Foliation joints) are dominant. Hence,
probably the shear zone encountered in TBH-7 could
(Rock condition at TBH-7) be a foliation shear.
From the analysis of borehole log details of 13
Possibility-2
numbers of boreholes it was evident that low rock
will be encountered while tunneling at TBH7 and Dolerite with sheared contact is reported in the
site will have to take cautious approach during tunnel off shore bore holes drilled at MAPS. The dip of the
excavation between TBH-6 and TBH-8. Rest other dyke is estimated to be 70º close to Kalpakkam, at
bore log predicted trouble free construction while Punjeri a N.W.-S.E. dyke is traceable for about 1 km.
advancing blasting for creation of submarine tunnel In the area around Anaikattu about 15 km south
bore. The following are the lithological, core recovery west of Kalpakkam several WNW-ESE dykes are
percentages and RQD details of TBH-7 core samples reported. In MAPS Reactor I pit a N60º W - S60º E
as prepared by M/S Geotechnics & Constructions dyke was reported. It could be seen that the dykes in
Pvt. Ltd. the area trend WNW-ESE to NW-SE direction with
a dip of 65º to 75º towards S30º W. The contacts of dolerite Dyke although hard and fresh was found to
many dykes are sheared; the shear zone trend is also be blocky and seamy. To the left of the crown damp
in the same trend. If the structural infirmity in TBH- surface and dripping conditions prevailed.
7 could also have the same trend and dipping
The absence of dolerite in any of the bore holes (as
towards SW. Strike trend and apparent dip were
per data provided) and the occurrence of dolerite in
projected on to the new alignment. Thus it was
the MAPS tunnel bore holes was referred to and the
predicted that rock in the shear zone and adjacent
possibility of an east-west fault between the two
area will be closely jointed and could render the
tunnels was predicted earlier, even before start of
crown of the tunnel weak where it intercepts.
tunnel excavation boring. Since, the dolerite rock is
A horizontal diamond drill hole was planned to be now encountered after the shear zone this possibility
drilled with double tube core barrel as tunnel is now ruled out.
advanced. It was planned in advance that if drilling
In the MAPS tunnel boreholes, the dolerite is
data confirms the prognosis, tunneling in this
found to be at least 54 m wide. As per bore hole
hazardous zone has to proceed cautiously. The zone
details, dolerite was not encountered even in TBH-7,
may be under a hydrostatic head. A similar zone in
the logs of TBH-8 also indicate only charnockite and
Naptha Jhakri HEP in Himachal Pradesh (Himalaya
not dolerite. Hence, it is probable that the dolerite
range) was tackled through DRESS Methodology i.e
now encountered is less than 50 m wide.
Drainage, Reinforcement, Excavation and Support.
Remedial measures taken in PFBR tunnel in the
The method consists of drainage beyond the
shear zone.
heading by drilling holes with simultaneous insertion
of partly perforated steel pipes, improving the Ø The entire excavation was geologically mapped
heading by grouting and shotcreting. Before starting Ø From Ch. 243m to Ch 264m (in the shear zone
the work supports (as dictated by design and blocky and seamy dolerite portions), 75 mm
considerations) was planned to be kept ready and thk. shotcrete of M35 grade with wire mesh was
placed as soon as possible taking care to provide applied.
laggings between the supports and crown. The above
Ø Wherever dolerite was found blocky, it was
details were brought to the notice of the field staff
stitched by 10mm thick plate anchored 3m deep
and they were kept in readiness to face the situation.
into the rock using 25mm diameter rebar.
To conform this and take precautionary measures, Ø ISMB 600 @ 600 c/c with steel lagging was
a horizontal diamond drill hole was drilled with provided in this stretch of submarine tunnel. The
double tube core barrel as tunnel advanced. Great
entire inner surface (top, sides and bottom
precaution and cautious approach was taken from
surfaces) of this dolerite region was supported
Ch.250 to Ch.290.
with the above referred structural members.
Observation during sub marine tunneling Ø After the 3D geological logging of the submarine
operation: tunnel, consolidation grouting was carried out
As predicted earlier, during the excavation of between Ch.15m to 30m, Ch.75m to Ch.85m and
tunnel the shear zone was encountered at Ch.245 Ch 240m to Ch 270m.
continued up to Ch.257.5. The material in the shear Ø Before any blasting for the tunnel, probe holes,
zone consists of highly crushed leucocratic 6m deep were drilled from the blasted face to
Charnockite. Although most of it is granular and determine the rock strata ahead of tunnel face.
non-cohesive, in places it is completely clayey. No This was done either by diamond drilling or jack
water seepage was notice in the shear zone portion. hammer drilling.
From Ch: 257.5 onwards and up to the face of the The work of tunnel excavation is under progress
excavation at Ch.270 Dolerite was encountered. The and as of 15th September, 2009, 515 meter out of
560 meter of tunnel was already excavated. investigation data. They have also analysed the
rocks, produced geological mapping, decided on
Concluding Remarks: rock anchoring, taken decision on geological
The PFBR intake structure is a design and issues encountered during construction and have
construction marvel. True to the type of activity, the produced detailed reports of the incidents
construction has met several surprises which were Ø M/S DBM Geotechnics and Constructions Pvt
quickly addressed with the help of experts within Ltd., Bombay who carried out Bore Hole drilling
India. The job has progressed well as per schedule and Geotechnical Investigations
despite the above mentioned difficulties.
Ø M/S Anna University, Chennai who gave expert
Acknowledgement: analysis on geotechnical analysis.
This detailed technical paper is prepared after Ø M/S NGRI who carried out cross hole tests
drawing technical contents from various reports Ø M/S Indian Institute of Technology, Chennai
prepared by experts and organizations engaged by
BHAVINI for intake structure design, construction, Ø M/S National Institute of Ocean Technology,
trouble shooting and remedial actions. This report NIOT, IIT, Chennai who have done HWL and
has also major inputs from the agencies who have LWL studies
carried out geo-technical investigation, construction Ø Dr. D.N. Seshagiri, an experienced Engineering
and inspection activities. The authors thankfully Geologist and Dr. S.R. Gandhi, a Senior Geologist
acknowledge them. and Professor at IIT Chennai, who have
contributed significantly in preparation of this
The credit of this report goes to:
paper. Few names of organisations and experts
Ø Dr. S.K. Jain, Chairman and Managing Director, have been brought out above. The contribution of
M/s Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited those whose names do not appear is also not less
& M/s Bharatiya Nabhikiya Vidyut Nigam and is thankfully acknowledged.
Limited
References:
Ø Dr. Baldev Raj, Distinguished Scientist and
Director, Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Ø Geotechnical Investigation Report for Sea Water Intake
Structure at Kalpakkam in Tamilnadu State for FBR-Project,
Research, Kalpakkam
BHAVINI-DBM Geotechnics and Construction Pvt.Ltd.
Ø Shri S.C. Chetal, Director, REG, Indira Gandhi
Ø Report from Design Group, Bangalore Titled Paper on
Centre for Atomic Research, Kalpakkam Geotechnical Problems faced during execution of Submarine
Ø M/S IGCAR who have conceptualised and Tunnel and Remedial measures carried out.
conceived entire scheme. Carried out bathymetric Ø Physical Thermal Model Studies for Locating Intake/ Outfall of
studies, analysed the results produced by various 500MWe Fast Breeder Reactor Project (PFBR)-CWPRS
experts Ø Mathematical Model Studies for Location of Intake/ Outfall of
Ø The entire civil team of M/S BHAVINI Ltd 500MWe Fast Breeder Reactor Project (PFBR)-CWPRS
Ø M/S CWPRS, Pune have designed and done Ø Flow Model Studies for Intake Structure of Fast Breeder
Reactor Project (PFBR)- CWPRS
model studies of Intake Structures and finalised
blasting charge Ø "Supplementary Mathematical Model Studies for Littoral Drift
and Thermal Recirculation for Sea Water Intake/ Outfall of
Ø M/S Gammon India Limited who have finalized 500MWe Fast Breeder Reactor Project (PFBR)-CWPRS"
construction and inspection schemes and done
Ø Physical Wave Model Studies for Sea Water Intake/ Outfall of
field construction of Intake Structures 500MWe Fast Breeder Reactor Project (PFBR)-CWPRS
Ø M/S DGPCL, Bangalore who have provided the Ø Field Data Collection and Analysis for Condenser Cooling Sea
entire design and construction detailing for the water System (CCWS) of 500MWe Fast Breeder Reactor
submarine tunnel after analyzing the geotechnical Project (PFBR)-CWPRS
ACCIDENT
generated). 6 Serious Accident