Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
T
Abstract- Wire-cut electric discharge machining of mentioned applications. Moreover machine tool
Aluminum-24345 has been considered in the tables provided by the manufacturer often do not
present work. The low rigidity and high material meet the requirements in machining a particular
removal rate of aluminum alloys offers a material [4]. So, to obtain various shapes of structural
challenging task in obtaining a better surface components the wire-cut EDM process is important
ES
finish. Experimentation has been done by using
Taguchi’s L18 (21x37) orthogonal array under
different conditions of parameters. The response
of surface roughness is considered for improving
the machining efficiency. Optimal combinations of
parameters were obtained by this method. The
confirmation experiment shows, the significant
in many cases, but it requires the improved
machining efficiency. Hence, for improving the
machining efficiency it requires the models to predict
optimum parametric combinations accurately. But
wire-cut EDM consists of a number of parameters,
which makes it difficult to obtain optimal parametric
combinations for machining different materials for
improvement in surface finish (1.03µm) was various responses like surface roughness, material
obtained with this method. Multiple linear removal rate, kerf etc. Taguchi‟s robust design has
regression model have been developed relating the been used in various applications to obtain optimum
process parameters and machining performance parametric combinations [4-9] for desired responses.
and a high correlation coefficient (r2 = 0.97) In many of the manufacturing processes, the surface
A
indicates the suitability of the proposed model in roughness is one of the response performance
predicting surface roughness. The study shows measures. Several researchers were attempted
that with the minimum number of experiments previously to improve the surface roughness [10-20]
the stated problem can be solved when compared on various materials. Han et al [14] were conducted
to full factorial design. Experimental results the experiments on different materials namely
demonstrate that the machining model is suitable aluminum alloy, brass, alloy steel, cemented carbide
IJ
and the Taguchi’s method satisfies the practical at the same conditions to obtain surface roughness.
requirements. They found that the rigidity is a significant factor
affecting the surface roughness. The surface
Keywords: Wire-cut EDM; Taguchi’s method; roughness decreases accompanying an increase in
ANOVA, Orthogonal array, Regression analysis; material rigidity. Therefore high rigidity materials
will produce finer surfaces and low rigidity materials
I. INTRODUCTION like aluminum alloys produces high surface
roughness. In addition, Khan [21] presented his
The wire-cut electrical discharge machining plays an analysis on material removal rate during EDM of
important role in manufacturing sectors especially aluminum and mild steel using copper and brass
industries like aerospace, ordinance, automobile and electrodes. The highest material removal rate was
general engineering etc [1-2]. Conventional observed during machining of aluminum due to high
machining is more efficient than unconventional thermal conductivity and low melting point when
machining like wire-cut EDM process but it is compared to steel at low thermal conductivity and
difficult to obtain intricate and complex shapes of the high melting point. As a result highest material
components [3] as it is required in the above removal rates were obtained during machining of
aluminum alloy. It is well known fact that a high A. Experimental Set-Up and wire electrode:
material removal rate and a very good surface finish
All the experiments were conducted on Ultra Cut
can never be achieved simultaneously in WEDM
843/ ULTRA CUT f2 CNC Wire-cut EDM machine.
process [22-23]. Hence, wire-cut electrical discharge
In this machine, all the axes are servo controlled and
machining of Aluminum BIS-24345 alloy (alloy
can be programmed to follow a CNC code which is
equivalent Aluminum 2014) has been considered in
fed through the control panel. All three axes have an
the present set of research work with surface
accuracy of 1μm. Fig. 1 shows the experimental set-
roughness as a response variable. This material is
up of WEDM in machining Aluminum BIS-24345
rapidly growing its applications because of its high
alloy. The chemical composition of the material
strength and hardness even at higher temperatures
given by the energy-dispersive spectrometer (EDS) in
this suits most of the engineering requirements today.
percentage of mass are as follows, Si=0.74,
Apart from this, this is one of the strongest heat
Fe=0.195, Cu=4.70, Mn=0.61, Mg=0.452, Zn=0.030,
treatable alloys for screw machine applications. So
Ni=0.003, Cr=0.009, Pb=0.005, Sn=0.005, Ti=0.025,
far very limited work has been reported on aluminum
Li<0.001, Al=93.230. The composition confirms that
alloys in wire electric discharge machining. The main
the material tested on EDS is Aluminum BIS-24345
objective of this paper is to study the effect of
T
alloy. The size of the work piece considered for
different parameters of WEDM using Taguchi‟s
experimentation on the wire-cut EDM is 25 mm x 20
design methodology. To prepare the models for
mm x 10 mm. Among the eight WEDM parameters
machining of Aluminum BIS-24345 alloy using
two levels for one control factor (Pulse on time) and
standard matrix experiments L18 (21X37) orthogonal
three levels for remaining seven control factors, are
array. In several references it is found that very few
considered for optimality analysis during machining
researches considered parameters like servo gap
ES of Aluminum BIS-24345 alloy. Tables 1-2 shows
voltage and servo feed rate setting which also have an
WEDM parameters and their levels and material
impact on surface roughness. The results obtained are
properties of Aluminum BIS 24355 alloy.
analyzed for the selection of an optimal combination
of WEDM parameters for proper machining of B. Data collection
Aluminum BIS-24345 alloy to achieve better surface
finish. Different analyses were made on the data Surface roughness measurement has been done
obtained from the experiments. Analysis of variance using a stylus-type profilometer of Talysurf 10 as
(ANOVA) is carried out to determine significant shown in Fig. 2. The Talysurf 10 (Surtronic 3+) is
factors and signal-to-noise (S/N) ratio is conducted to a self-contained instrument for the measurement of
find the optimal settings and factor levels. To surface texture. Surface roughness measurements
establish a relationship between factors and response are taken on the work pieces in the transverse
A
variable multiple regression models was used. direction; and this procedure have been repeated
Finally, experimental confirmations were carried out five times to obtain the average values of surface
to identify the effectiveness of this proposed method. roughness. In all the measurements of surface
roughness cut-off length is taken as 0.8 mm.
II. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
IJ
T
Density 2.8g/cc Thermal Conductivity 154 W/m-K
Hardness, knoop & Vickers 170 & 155 Melting Point 507 - 638 °C
Tensile yield strength 414 Mpa Poission‟s ratio 0.33
Modulus of elasticity 72.4 Gpa Shear modulus 28 GPa
(In tension)
experiments in L18 (21X37) orthogonal array and the conducted at this optimal combination and an
optimal surface roughness was obtained at 105 µs improved surface roughness value of 1.03µm was
pulse on time (level 1), 62 µs pulse off time (level 3), obtained. This is 2.70 times the initial surface
10 ampere for peak current (level 1), 7Kg/cm2 roughness value (2.79 µm) obtained at
flushing pressure of dielectric fluid (level 3), 10 A2B2C2D2E2F2G2H2 . The S/N ratio is also improved
m/min wire feed rate setting (level 2), 10Kg-f wire by 8.6552 dB. This is an indication of improvement
tension setting (level 3), 8Volts spark gap voltage in the machining performances i.e. surface roughness
Setting (level 1) and 500mm/min servo feed Setting Fig. 3 shows the effect of control factors on surface
(level 1). From the signal to noise ratio, optimal roughness diagrammatically. Figs. 4-5 show the
combination of parameters was obtained for SR as surface roughness at initial and optimal combination
A1B3C1D3E2F3G1H1. A separate experiment was of parameters.
T
Parameters D.F SS V F %p
TON 1 2.053689 2.053689 130.485 28.85295
TOFF 2 0.029478 0.014739 0.936463 0.414143
IP 2 3.503611 1.751806 111.3043 49.22338
WP 2 0.355211 0.177606 11.2845 4.990478
WF 2 0.068578 0.034289 2.178609 0.963472
WT
SV
SF
Error
Total
2
2
2
2
17
ES 0.650544
0.377678
0.047511
0.031478
7.117778
0.325272
0.188839
0.023756
0.015739
20.66678
11.99824
1.509354
9.139713
5.306119
0.667499
0.442242
100
Table 5 MEAN S/N RATIOS FOR SR AT EACH LEVEL FOR ALL THE PARAMETERS
TON TOFF IP WP
-5
Mean η (dB)
-5 -5
-5
for SR
-7 -7 -7.5 -7
-9 -9 -10 -9
1 2 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3
T
WF WT SV SF
Mean η (dB)
-5 -5 -5 -5
for SR
-7 -7 -7 -7
-9 -9 -9 -9
1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3
ES
Figure. 3 Effect of control factors on surface roughness
A
Ra =2.79µm, Rz = 16.79µm cut-off length 0.8
T
η η ∑ η η during the machining of Aluminum BIS-24345 alloy.
So, the suggested mathematical model is as given in
Here, ηopt is the predicted optimal S/N ratio, ηm is the (3)
total mean of the S/N ratios, ηj is the mean S/N ratio
at the optimal levels and k is the Number of main
design parameters that affect the quality
S. Experimental Mathematical
No model model
SR S/N ratio SR S/N ratio
1 Initial
2.79 -8.9120 2.87 -9.1576
conditions
2 Optimum
1.03 -0.2567 1.08 -0.6684
conditions
3 Improvement 2.70 8.6552 2.65 8.4891
times dB times dB
V. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION be beneficial for the people working on low rigid,
high thermal conductivity and low melting point
The effect of the wire-cut EDM parameters on materials of aluminum alloys. The proposed
surface roughness in machining Aluminum BIS- regression model (with high correlation co-efficient)
24345 alloy is studied. From the ANOVA and S/N successfully predicted the parametric values in the
ratio calculations, it is found that, the parameters IP machining of aluminum BIS-24345 alloy.
and TON have the most significant effect on surface
roughness due to the fact that the energy content of a REFERENCES
single spark discharge can be expressed as a product
of TON x IP known as discharge energy. So, [1] J.A. Sanchez et al, “On the influence of cutting
increasing the discharge energy generally increases speed limitation on the accuracy of wire-EDM
surface irregularities due to much more melting and corner-cutting”, J Mater Process Technol, 2007,
re-solidification of materials. Because of this, large Vol. 182, pp. 574-579.
T
debris is formed which cannot easily pass through a [2] R. Ramakrishnan and L. Karunamoorthy, “Multi
narrow gap, so it stays between the wire and response optimization of wire EDM operations
workpiece reducing the surface quality. Hence, it is using robust design of experiments”, 2006, Vol.
found that SR tends to decrease significantly with 29, pp. 105-112.
decrease in IP and TON. Here, the minimum SR is
obtained at low IP (10 A) and low TON (105 µsec). [3] K.K. Choi, W.J. Nam and Y.S. Lee, “Effects of
heat treatment on the surface of a die steel STD
ES
The parameters wire tension and spark gap voltage
are observed as significant parameters in obtaining
better surface finish. This is due to increase of wire
tension reduces its vibration and improves the surface
quality of the machined part. The increase of voltage
means that the electric field becomes stronger and the
11 machined by W-EDM”, J Mater Process
Technol, 2008, Vol. 201, pp. 580-584.
[4] A. Manna and B. Bhattacharya, “Taghuchi and
guass elimination method: a dual response
approach for parametric optimization of CNC
wire cut EDM PRAISiCMMC, Int J Adv Manuf
Technol, 2006, Vol. 28, pp. 67-75.
spark discharge takes place more easily under the
same gap and a coarse surface is always obtained. [5] P.G. Benardos, G.C Vosniakos, “Predicting of
The minimum SR is obtained at high wire tension (10 surface roughness in CNC face milling using
kg-f) and low spark gap voltage (8 V). neural networks and Taguchi‟s design of
experiments”, Robotics and computer integrated
A
The proposed mathematical model predicted values manufacturing, 2002, Vol 18, pp. 343-354.
at optimum and initial conditions with an error of [6] J.A. Ghani, I.A. Choudhury, and H.H
2.7% and 4.6-% for SR when compared with the .Hassan,“Application of Taguchi method in the
experimental values. A good agreement of results optimization of end milling parameters”, J Mater
was obtained with mathematical model when Process Technol, 2004, Vol 145, pp. 84-92.
compared to the experimental work.
[7] H.T Lee and J.P .Yur, “Characteristic analysis on
IJ
Process Technol, 2007, Vol 192-193, pp. 459- [19] I Puertas, C.J .Luis and L .Alvarez, “Analysis of
464. the influence of EDM parameters on surface
[11] Aminollah Mohammadi, Alireza Fadaei Tehrani, quality, MRR and EW of WC-Co”, J Mater
Ehsan Emanian, Davoud Karimi, 2008. A new Process Technol, 2004, Vol. 153/154, pp.1026-
approach to surface roughness and roundness 1032.
improvement in wire electrical discharge turning [20] R .Ramakrishnan, L .Karunamoorthy, “Surface
based on statistical analysis, Int J Adv Manuf roughness model for CNC wire electro discharge
Technol, Vol. 39, pp. 64–73. machining”, J Manuf Technol Today, 2004, Vol.
[12] P.G .Benardos, G.C .Vosniakos, “Predicting 3(5), pp. 8-11.
surface roughness in Machining: A Review”, Int [21] A.A. Khan, “Electrode wear and material removal
J Mach Tools Manuf, 2003, Vol 43, pp. 833-844. rate during during EDM of aluminum and mild
[13] U .Esme, A .Sagbas and F .Kahramam, steel using copper and brass electrodes”, Int J
“Prediction of surface roughness in wire Adv Manuf Technol, 2008, Vol. 39 (5-6), pp.
electrical discharge machining using design of 482-487.
experiments and neural networls”, Iranian [22] A.B. Puri and B.Bhattacharyya, “An analysis and
T
journal of Science & Technology, Transaction B, optimization of the geometrical inaccuracy due
Engineering, 2009, Vol. 33(B3), pp.231-240. to wire lag phenomenon in WEDM”, Int. J.
[14] Fuzhu Han, Jun Jiang, Yu .Dingwen, “Influence Machine Tools & Manufacture, 2003, Vol. 43,
of machining parameters on surface roughness in pp. 151-159.
finish cut of WEDM”, Int J Adv Manuf Technol, [23] K. P. Rajurkar and W.M Wang, “Thermal
2007, Vol 34, pp. 538-546. ES modeling and on-line monitoring of wire-EDM”,
[15] MI .Gokler, AM .Ozanozgu, “Experimental J Mater Process Technol, 1993, Vol 38(1-2), pp.
investigation of effects of cutting parameters on 417-430.
surface roughness in the WEDM process”, Int J [24] R.Karthikkeyan, P.R. Lakshminarayanan, R.S.
Mach Tools Manuf, 2000, Vol 40, pp. 1831- Naagarajan, 1999. Mathematical modeling for
1848. electric discharge machining of aluminum- silico
[16] M .Kiyak and O .Cakir, “Examination of carbide particulate composites, J Mater Process
machining parameters on surface roughness in Technol, 87: pp. 59-63.
EDM of tool steel”, J Mater Process Technol, [25] YS.Liao, JT. Huang , HC.Su, “ A study on the
2007, Vol. 191(1-3), pp. 141-144. machining parameters optimization of wire
[17] H.T .Lee, et al., “Influence of EDM process electrical discharge machining”, J Mater Process
Technol, Vol 71, pp. 487-493.
A
parameters on surface defects and roughness”,
Chin. J. Mater. Sci. 1996, Vol 28(4), pp. 270-
278.
[18] YS .Liao, JT .Huang, YH .Chen, “A study to
achieve fine surface finish in wire EDM”, J
Mater Process Technol, 2004, Vol 149, pp. 165-
171.
IJ