Sunteți pe pagina 1din 10

A Study of Turbulence Induced Forces Acting on a Globe

Control Valve Operating at Small Opening

A. Hassan1. and A. Sharara2

Abstract - Under certain opening conditions and partial opening of control valves, the piping
systems occasionally suffer large vibrations. To understand the valve instability that is responsible
for such vibrations, experiments and CFD simulations were performed. As a result of the study of
the turbulence flow through a single seat globe valve operating at small openings, it was found
that a complex three-dimensional flow structure (valve attached flow) sets up in the valve region
leading to high pressure variations in the valve trim region. CFD calculations showed how a jet
may impinge on the roof of the valve body and cause a large-scale recirculation region in the pipe
downstream of the valve. Moreover, it was found that the smaller valve opening, the larger the
exciting force acting on the valve stem. The harmful effect of the fluid flow forces (exciting forces)
is very much pronounced at relatively smaller valve opening. The simulation results for turbulent
flow with k   model were more accurate than the k   model. In addition, k   model was
simpler and faster in convergence than the k   model.

Keywords: Control valves – Turbulent – Simulation – Computational fluid dynamics.

I. Introduction attempt to avoid a host of valve problems, Miller [1]


proposed applying valve trim maximum K E criteria
Control valves are used to control volumetric flow including component vibration, breaking parts,
rates and keep the regulated process variable as close excessive aerodynamic noise, trim and/or valve pitting
as possible to the desired set point. One of the most
and erosion caused by liquid cavitations or flashing and
common types of control valves is the single seat globe
surface erosion by solid particulate. Based on
valve. It consists of three main components: body, trim
operational experience, Miller and Stratton [2]
(which made up of the plug and seat), and actuator.
presented an allowable trim K E limit for a given
The trim of the control valve is responsible for the
inherent valve flow characteristics. Different flow control valve application that depends on the
conditions require different shapes of the plug and seat application service conditions. The criterion involves
to achieve optimum flow control. In severe service limits on the fluid K E existing from the valve’s trim.
applications; control valves are equally crucial for They advocate a 485 kPa limit to a clean flowing
safely dissipating high process fluid energy levels to process fluid, but suggested a 275 kPa limit for
avoid valve and piping damage from acoustic noise,
cavitating and multiphase trim flows. Hardin et al [3]
vibration, cavitations and erosion. To varying degrees,
studied three different plug design cut off, concave and
all of these potentially damaging phenomena scale with
hybrid to eliminate the flow-induced instability of
flow velocities in the valve and valve trim, leading
steam turbine control valves. They used a steady state
some valve manufactures to recommended specific
CFD model and found that the hybrid plug design is
limits to fluid kinetic energy (K E) in the valve trim.
the most convenient shape for the presented case.
More recently, designers of fluid handling equipments Wojtkowiak and Oleśkowicz-Popiel [4] carried out
are using CFD simulation for product development numerical and experimental investigation on the flow
and optimization. In the present study, CFD has been characteristics of butterfly valves. Flow patterns and
combined with experimental work to analyze the flow pressure distribution in the disk vicinity were obtained.
through globe control valve with a flat-faced plug, The computational results, obtained from the standard
operating at small opening. k-ε turbulence model, agree qualitatively with the
results of the experimental study. It is likely that more
sophisticated turbulence model will yield quantitatively
II. Literature Review more accurate values. Using the FLUENT code, Kim
Despite of the importance of control valves, a little [5] investigated a three dimensional numerical
research work has been published on control valve simulation to analyze an incompressible flow through
design, especially for the globe control valves. In an the partially-opened thin-flap disk butterfly valve.
Chern and Wang [6], conducted a 3D numerical the pressure fluctuations caused by the valve. The
simulations and experiments were conducted to upstream pressure P1 and downstream pressure P2 are
observe the flow patterns and to measure performance measured from static wall tapings located 5 pipe
coefficients when V-ports with various angles were diameter upstream and 11 pipe diameter downstream
used in a piping system. Three V-ports with angles 30 of the valve. The mounting of the pressure transducers
deg, 60 deg, and 90 deg were studied. It was found that needed special attention to avoid an influence to the
V-ports with angles 30 deg and 60 deg make the flow flow field [11]. The bonnet of the tested valve was
rate proportional to the valve opening. However, V- modified from a standard type (Fig.2-a) to an extended
ports increase the pressure loss between the inlet and type (Fig.2-b) which included an S-type load cell to
the exit of a ball valve. Davis and Stewart [7] studied measure the flow net force acting on the valve and to
the performance of a single seated globe valve by transmit it to the valve body. The sensing elements of
applying Fluent CFD code. They showed that the the load cell, those subjected to bending moments.
valve characteristics could be accurately predicted Bending elements offer high strain level at relatively
using axisymetric flow models over most of the plug low force, which makes them ideal for low capacity
travel. Hong et al [8] performed a numerical simulation load cells. In the proposed design of the load cell, there
for the cavitating flow in hydraulic conical valves. The are two surfaces subjected to equal strains of opposite
structure of the valve was simplified as two sign. This offers convenient means for implementing a
dimensional axisymmetric model. They found that the full bridge circuit, while temperature compensation is
cone shape have a considerable effect on the intensity relatively easy. Bending as a measuring principle offers
of the cavitation. Amirant et al [9] studied theoretically excellent linearity of the S-type load cell, which was
flow forces on an open center directional control valve. used in the experiments to measure the flow net force.
The results showed that the flow force increases with Using CIO-EXP-GP signal conditioning board, the
increasing the flow rate. Oza et al [10] presented a time history signals have been collected and
CFD model for a globe valve in oxygen applications. transformed to DAS08-AO data acquisition card via a
They used both k   and k   models of turbulence 37 pin connector cable.
through the numerical computations. The simplified
axisymmetric model was used to predict the inherent III.1. Test Conditions
valve characteristic. Their results showed that the
k   turbulent model is more suitable for boundary The hydraulic test and measurements have been
level flow. made at room temperature with flow rate up to
40 m3 / hr and a valve opening up to 40%. The
In the present study, the fluid flow around a single opening of the control valve was set using a dial gauge
seat globe valve will be treated as a three-dimensional indicator, which has a resolution of 0.01 mm. The
flow to focus on the details of the flow variations in the valve’s opening was 5, 10, 20, 30, and 40 %;
valve region. An experimental study and CFD respectively, and the maximum valve travel was 23
simulation are conducted to understand the cause of the mm. The maximum pump outlet pressure was 5.7 bar,
fluctuations. The fluid flow force acting on the valve while the minimum back pressure of the valve was 0.3
stem is measured and compared with the obtained bar.
values from the numerical study to verify the numerical
model.
III.2. Valve Characteristics
III. Experimental Facility There are two important control valve parameters,
the overall flow coefficient Cv and the relative valve
An experimental test rig was designed on the basis
of closed loop flow system. The test setup in Fig.1 is capacity Cd . The flow coefficient Cv is a measure of
driven by a 7.5 hp centrifugal pump and is capable of valve capacity. It is given by the ISA standard S75.01
providing 48 m 3 hr of water flow. The test rig [12] for incompressible, fully turbulent, noncavitating
and nonflashing flow as
generates 400 kPa (4 bar) across the test valve at flow
rates up to 30 m³/hr. the rotational speed of the pump Gf
C v  11.6 Q (1)
may be adjusted via a frequency inverter to obtain a P
desired value of the water flow rate. The test section is where G f is the specific gravity of the fluid. In the SI
situated at the fully developed flow area and the back system of units, the units of Cv are
pressure can be controlled using a butterfly valve
downstream of the test section. A calibrated orifice ((m3 / hr ) /(kPa )0.5 ) . Equation (1) is applicable to fully
flow meter is used to measure the flow rate during the turbulent flow field for which valve parameters
experiments. Pressure transducers, which can becomes independent of the Reynolds number. The
distinguish millisecond fluctuations, are mounted relative valve capacity factor Cd is a measure of the
upstream and downstream the globe valve to measure
Tested Butterfly
Globe Valve
Valve
Entrance Pipe

Upstream Downstream Flexible


Pressure Pressure
Transducer Transducer
Joint

Water
Tank

Isolation Ball Valve


Flexible
Joint

Long
Radius Pump Filter Isolation Ball Valve
Orifice
Bend
Meter
(a) Outline of experimental apparatus

(b) Overhead view of the test loop

Fig. 1. The experimental test rig.

valve capacity relative to its nominal pipe size D p , it is relative to its maximum stroke length. The flow
given by coefficient Cv is experimentally determined for
Cv different valve openings or positions. For a constant
Cd  (2) valve opening, ten test runs were made for turbulent
(0.0394 D p ) 2 flows at high Reynolds numbers such that the flow
and has units of (m 3 / hr ) /(kPa ) 0.5 /(mm 2 ) . Values of coefficient should remain constant, R e  1  10 5 . Runs
Cd do not normally exceed 11, see [7]. The inherent were made at levels of heavy cavitation were avoided
valve characteristic is a plot of Cv versus percent because of the effect of cavitation on Cv . The flow
opening of the valve, which represents an indication coefficient was then calculated from the average of the
for how the flow rate will change with a change in test runs at a constant valve opening, after excluding
percent opening of the valve. The percent opening of the largest and smallest values. Valve position is
the valve is a measure of how far the plug is stroked expressed in terms of percentage of full opening
1- Valve Body
2- Seat
3- Plug
4- Stem
5- Bonnet
6- Side Rod
7- Load Cell
8- Lower Square Plate
9- Rigid Spacer
10- Nut
11- Side Guide
12- Upper Square Plate
13- Handle
14- Dial Gauge

(a) Standard (b) Modified

Fig. 2. Bonnet design of tested valve

(23 mm) . For the purpose of test repeatability, valve valve to a given position. The experimental results
opening was always set and measured by opening the illustrated in Fig.3 show the inherent valve
characteristic for the valve under investigation.
Accordingly, the test-valve was found to be of quick- Formula (4) was established with the least-square-error
opening type. technique of fit using the experimental data, and
automated curve fitting software.

Fig. 3. Inherent valve characteristics

IV. Dimensional Analysis


The flow force acting on the valve stem 'F' depends Fig. 4. The variation of the dimensionless exciting
upon the volume flow rate 'Q', the valve opening or force with the dimensionless volume flow rate
position 'l' , the valve diameter 'D', the upstream
pressure' P1 ', the pressure drop across the valve ' P ', V. Experimental Uncertainty
the viscosity of the fluid '  ', and mass density '  '. By Experimental uncertainty in the present work has
applying the Buckingham’s  -theorem, a several sources. The most obvious and easiest to
dimensionless expression for the flow force acting on quantify is the error associated with the
the valve stem may be obtained as follows, instrumentation. This includes the pressure transducers,
  the orifice flow meter, and load cell. The uncertainty
F Q
2
 f  3 

(3) for pressure measurements was  0.1 percent. The
P1 D  D P /(  D )  flow meter had an error of one percent of the reading.
F The load cell had an error of 0.5 percent. Other
where is defined as the dimensionless exciting
P1 D 2 sources of error in the study included the plug percent
opening and the errors caused by plug centering. The
Q plug percent opening error was investigated
force Fd and is defined as the
D P /(  D )
3
experimentally using repeated measurements and
dimensionless volume flow rate Qd . The experimental applying statistical arguments. The measurements were
results shown in Fig.4 show the variation of the taken using a dial indicator that gave an error of one
dimensionless exciting force with the dimensionless percent of the valve percent opening. The uncertainty
volume flow rate. The test runs were made at high associated with plug percent opening error was
Reynolds numbers and turbulent flow at different flow negligibly small. Centering the plug with equally
spaced was investigated. This was verified
rates and pressure drops. The dimensionless force ' Fd '
experimentally by rotating the valve stem after the
and the dimensionless volume flow rates were setting of the valve opening, while taking
calculated as the average of the test runs at a constant measurements in the load cell. The results showed that
valve position. The results show that the dimensionless the flow force acting on the plug (valve stem) could
exciting force decreases as the valve opening increases, vary by a maximum of 4 percent depending on the
see Fig.5. For small valve opening values, a little valve opening percentage and the plug's rotation. The
change in the plug position yields to a significant experimental uncertainty changed with valve opening.
variation in the value of the exciting force which When calculated as a percent of the measured Cv , the
means that the effectiveness of valve position becomes
very much pronounced for small values of valve experimental uncertainty ranged from a minimum
opening. Based on the experimental results an value of 1.66 percent error to a maximum value of 7.21
approximating equation may be obtained as follows, percent error.

Fd  0.109049 log Q d  1.41356 (4)


VI. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) turbulence dissipation rate,  (m 2 s3 ) . The k  
Using FLUENT 6.3, a three dimensional model of turbulence model is similar to the low Reynolds
the valve body and connecting pipes shown in Fig.6 is number k   model, with  replacing  , which
created to investigate the flow. The valve was modeled represents the specific dissipation rate (s 1 ) .
with the plug positioned at different percent openings. Researchers have developed many turbulence models
The converged flow field was used with Equation (1) provided results with major differences and
to calculate the valve Cv . Also, the converged pressure contradictions in some cases. The model used in this
was used to calculate the flow net force acting on the study was the two-equation k   model. The Standard,
valve stem. RNG, and Realizable k   models are investigated.
Other turbulence models (Standard and Shear Stress
Geometry: The fully dimensioned valve was modeled Transport, SST k   ) were used in an attempt to
and the plug and seat region was well represented. obtain the best convenient model for the present study.
Upstream of the seat, the inlet pipe length divided by All turbulence models were used with the standard
L parameters.
the valve diameter   was 5, and downstream of the
 D Numerical accuracy: All conservation equations are
seat, the outlet pipe length divided by the valve discretized in FLUENT using a finite volume
diameter was 11. formulation with second order spatial accuracy. The
Grid: The grid used in the numerical study was made continuity is satisfied using a SIMPLE (semi-implicit
up of tetrahedral cells, the nodes of grid were clustered pressure linked equations) algorithm. Normalized
in the plug and a seat region since this was the area of residuals were used for the convergence criteria, which
largest flow gradients. In addition, an effort was made was set at three orders of magnitude.
to reduce the grid distortion. Fig 5-a shows an extended
view of the grid and Fig.5-b shows the expanded view The numerically tested valve was geometrically
of the grid. similar to that applied in the experimental
Boundary conditions: All solid boundaries were investigations. It was assumed that the flow is three-
represented as walls with no slip velocity conditions dimensional, steady, isothermal, turbulent, Newtonian
and log well turbulence conditions. Inlet conditions and incompressible. However, body forces have been
were represented by a uniform total pressure. The neglected. Water, at the room temperature, was applied
treatment of pressure inlet boundary condition can be as the fluid passing through the valve. The flow was
described as a loss-free transition from stagnation governed by the system of mass and momentum
conditions to the inlet conditions. For incompressible conservation equations. In turbulent flow region the
flows, this is accomplished by application of the system of equations RANS (Reynolds Averaged
Bernoulli equation at the inlet boundary. The outlet Navier-Stokes equations) was closed by the
boundary conditions were set as a uniform static introduction of the turbulence model.
pressure. The boundary conditions at inlet and outlet
sections of the domain of solution were obtained from (a) Extended view
the laboratory experiments. Turbulence intensity and
turbulence length scale at the entrance cross section
were set as I  0.16 R e 1 8 and L  0.0175 d h [13],
where dh is the hydraulic diameter. Test cases were
run with 10 and 20 percent turbulence intensity, no (b) Close up view of grid
significant change in the predictions was observed.
Selection of turbulence model: The choice of
turbulent model depends on consideration such as the
physics encompassed in the flow, the established
practice for a specific class of problem, the level of
accuracy required, the available computational
resources, and the time available for the simulation.
Two equation turbulence models have become the
most popular, since they are relatively simple to
program and place much lower requirements on
computer resources than other more complex models
(Algebraic and Reynolds stress models). The k  
model relates the turbulence viscosity,  t (Pa s) , the
Fig. 5. Generated mesh for investigated geometry
turbulence kinetic energy, k (m 2 s 2 ) , and the
VII. Results and Discussions
The flow field was examined through the
interpretation of the post process data resulting from
the model solution. The results of the numerical study
are shown in Fig.6 through 11, and Fig.13 shows the
comparison of numerical and experimental results of
the inherent valve characteristics.
Flow field: The numerically obtained path line patterns
in a partially opened valve on the longitudinal mid
plane for 5, 10, 20, 30 and 40 percent openings are
illustrated in Fig.6. On the upstream surface of the plug
disk a stagnation region forms and outside of this
region, the flow direction is towards the edge of the
disk. In each case, the flow initially accelerates through
the plug and seat region and then flows downstream in
the form of a wall jet at the side of the valve body, and
at the open valve side. For valve opening up to
approximately 30%, flow separation from the plug with
a second recirculation zone occurs between the wall jet
and the plug surface. At valve opening greater than
30%, the results show that the flow remaining attached
to the plug surface, Fig.6-e. In addition, a large
recirculation region develops on the downstream side
of the plug at the closed valve body. As the valve
opening increases, flow separation from the valve body
with a recirculation zone between the jet and valve
body at outlet path of the flow occurs. A vena contracta
phenomenon and a hydrodynamic minimum flow area
down stream of the plug are observed. The jet flows
interact and mix downstream of the trim area and
sufficiently far from it the flow again occupies the
available flow area and approaches a fully developed
pipe flow.
Pressure contours: Fig.7 displays the numerically
modeled contours of the static pressure in a plane
placed close to the upstream surface of the plug. At
small opening value, the results show that the pressure
contours are radial relative to valve centerline, which
implies that the pressure field is primarily one
dimensional with the axial (stem) direction. As the
valve percent opening increases, the static pressure
contours become two dimensional and the gradients are
less confined to the gap between the plug and seat. In
each case, the pressure decreases in the downstream
direction with the largest pressure gradients occurring
in the plug and seat region. No significant pressure
changes are observed upstream of the seat and only
minor changes are observed downstream of the seat.
Fig.8 shows the variation of the static pressure along a
line in a longitudinal mid-plane placed close to
upstream surface of the plug. The pressure has a
maximum value corresponding to zero total velocity at
stagnant point, see Fig.9. At the plug edge the static
pressure has a minimum value while the velocity of the
fluid has a maximum value.
Fig. 6. Numerically obtained path line patterns
in a partially open valve.
(a) (a)

(b)
(b)

(c) (c)

Fig. 7. Pressure contours at upstream plug surface. Fig. 8. Pressure distributions at upstream plug surface
(a) 5% opening (a) 5% opening
(b) 20% opening (b) 20% opening
(c) 40% opening (c) 40% opening
(a) (a)

(b)
(b)

(c) (c)
Fig. 9. Velocity distributions at upstream plug Fig. 10. Turbulent Kinetic Energy contours.
surface. ( K-ω Turbulence Model.)
(a) 5% opening , (b) 20% opening (a) 5% opening, (b) 20 % opening
(c) 40% opening (c) 40% opening

Fig. 11. Comparison of flow forces for different Fig. 12. Comparison between experimental and
turbulent models. theoretical (CFD) values of flow force.
Turbulent kinetic energy: The constant contours for [4] Wojtkowiak J., and Oleśkowicz-Popiel C,.2006,"Investigations
turbulence energy are shown in Fig.10. The separated of Butterlfly Control Valve Characteristics", Foundations of
Civil and Environmental Engineering, V.7, ISSN 1642-9303
regions of the flow where shear layers exist have the [5] Kim R. H., and Huang C., 1993, "3-D Analysis Butterfly
highest magnitudes of the turbulence kinetic energy 'k'. Valve Fluid Flow", Proceeding of the Korean Fluent User's
The magnitude of the turbulence kinetic energy in the Group Meeting, Seoul, pp 43-57.
plug and seat region of the valve is high, this is due to [6] Chern M., and Wang C., 2004, " Control of Volumetric Flow-
Rate of Ball Valve Using V-Port", Trans ASME J. of Fluids
creation of large shear layer as the flow is squeezed Engineering, Vol. 126, pp: 471-481.
through this region. [7] Davis J., and Stewart M., 2002," Predicting Control Valve
Exciting force: The fluid flow forces acting on the Performance-Part I: CFD Modeling", Trans ASME J. of Fluids
valve stem were obtained using different turbulent Engineering, Vol. 124, pp: 772-777.
[8] Hong G., Xin F., and Huayong Y., 2000, "Numerical
models, as shown in Fig.11. It was noticed that no odd Simulation Of Cavitating Flow In Hydraulic Conical Valve" ,
discrepancy neither in the pattern nor the values of the A project supported by SRF for ROCS, SEM and National
flow forces, for all investigated openings. Moreover, Natural Science Foundation of China (59835160).
[9] Amirante R., Del Vescovo G., and Lippolis A., 2006,"
the flow forces, computed by the k   (SST) model Evaluation of the Flow Forces on an open Center Directional
for different valve's openings (5-40 %), have the less Control Valve by means of a Computational Fluid Dynamic
percent of deviation with experimental results, Analysis", Journal of Energy Conservation & Management,
compared with other turbulent models. Fig.12 shows Vol. 47,pp:1748-1760.
[10] Oza, A., Ghosh, S., and Chowdhury, K.,2007," CFD Modeling
the comparison between the experimental results and of Globe Valves for Oxygen Application", Proceeding of the
the numerical results. The maximum percentage of 16th Australasian Fluid Mechanics Conference.
deviation was 12.81% at 40% valve opening. [11] Au-Yang MK, Jordan KB, Nucl Eng Dec.1980,"Dynamic
pressure inside a PWR-a study based on laboratory and field
test data", Vol. 58, pp:113-125.
VII. Conclusions [12] Research Triangle Park, North Carolina: Instrument Society of
America., ISA-S75.01-1997, "Control Valve Sizing
Under completion of the study, the following Equations",
conclusions are withdrawn, [13] Fluent 6.3 User's Guide, Fluent Inc. 2005.
1- The flow field was examined and the results show [14] Launder B. E. and Spalding D. B., 1972,"Mathematical
that the valve geometry has a significant impact on Models of Turbulence", London, Academic Press.
[15] Bernard, S., Muntean, S., Susan-Resiga, R. and Anton, L.,
the turbulent flow passing through the valve. The 2005, " Vorticity in Hydraulic Power Equipment", Proceedings
results are in good agreement with those obtained of the Workshop on Vortex Dominated Flows, Achievements
by many researchers as pointed in [7] and [15]. and Open Problems, Timisora-Romania.
2- Under the partial opening (greater than 5 %)
condition, a complex three-dimensional (3D) flow
structure set up in the valve region leading to high Acknowledgements
The authors want to express their great thanks and sincere gratitude
pressure variations in the valve trim region. for both Prof. Zakria Ghoneim (Mechanical Engineering Department,
3- The fluid flow forces that acting on the plug and Faculty of Engineering, Ain Shams University) and Prof. El-Sayed
stem depends on the valve opening percentage. It Saber (Mechanical Engineering Department, College of Engineering,
was found that the smaller valve opening, the larger AASTMT) for their continuous guidance and help during the
execution of the present research work.
the exciting force acting on the valve stem. The
harmful effect of the fluid flow forces (exciting Authors’ information
forces) is very much pronounced at relatively 1
Amr Hassan was birthed on 21-07-1966. A
smaller valve opening. master degree in mechanical engineering was
4- The simulation results for turbulent flow with obtained in 1994 from faculty of engineering,
Alexandria University – Egypt. A PhD was
k   model were more accurate than the k   obtained in 2002 from School of Mechanical,
model. Moreover, k   model was simpler and Materials, Manufacturing Engineering and
faster in convergence than the k   model. These Management, University of Nottingham,
Nottingham, UK.
results are in agreement with those obtained by [10]. He conducted previous research studies in the fields of windshield
defrosting and demisting in automotive. He is now interested in the
References using computational fluid dynamics in flow simulation.
Dr. Amr is member of Society of Automotive Engineers, SAE and
[1] Miller,H.,1998, "Control Valve Applications", Chapter12, IMarEST (The Institute of Marine Engineering, Science and
Control Valves: Practical Guides for Measurement and control. Technology)
G.Bordon, Editor, ISA Press, Research Triangle, North 2
Carolina Ashraf Sharara was birthed on 05-01-1970.
[2] Miller H., and Stratton L., 1997, " Fluid Kinetic Enrgy as a A master degree in mechanical engineering
Selection Criteria for Control Valves", ASME Fluids was obtained in 1997 from faculty of
Engineering Division Summer Meeting. engineering, Alexandria University – Egypt.
[3] Hardin J., Kushner F. and Koester F., 2003, "Elimination of Currently , a PhD student at faculty of
Flow-Induced Instability From Steam Turbine Control engineering, Ain Shams University – Egypt.
Valves", Proceeding of the Thirty-Two Turbomachinery
He conducted previous research studies in the fields of applied
Symposium.
mechanics. He is now interested in studying the phenomenon of flow
induced vibration in fluid valves.

S-ar putea să vă placă și