Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Contents
1. About this guide 2. Evolution 3. What structured products can bring to a portfolio 4. Capital protection 5. Hard protection or soft protection 6. Gearing 7. Diversification 8. Tax efficiency 9. Income 10. Difficult to replicate return options 11. About Absa Capital 12. In conclusion
Pages 1 1 2 3 4 5 8 10 10 12 14 14
2. Evolution
Retail Structured Products have previously not played a predominant role in the South African (SA) investment landscape. However, with the recent increase in global market uncertainty, structured products have begun to play a significant role in investors investment portfolios. While the majority of structured products are linked to equity indices, an investment can also be structured to link to a basket of commodities or another asset class. The asset coverage offered by structured products has continued to widen, with links to international markets appearing from several providers. Innovation has continued to be a key aspect of the structured products market, as providers respond to changing market conditions and the needs of clients in a drive towards risk mitigation. The range of underlying asset classes now available through structured products underlines how far the market has moved from its early days in guaranteed stock market products.
Timing Most structured products have specific maturity dates, commonly in the three to six year range. The fixed term nature of these products has been, for some advisors, a point of contention. However much has been done to improve the accessibility to structured products during the life-cycle. It is now often possible to redeem the product early, although there may be penalties. Tax efficiency The framework of a structured product can usually be chosen to provide tax efficient returns. For example, products with the same underlying asset could deliver more tax efficient returns depending on whether the product is geared to provide normal investment returns subject to income tax or capital gains tax returns (as may be the case with a LEIPS product). These aspects of structured products are explored in greater detail throughout this guide.
4. Capital protection
The volatility seen in virtually all markets throughout 2008 has had an inevitable effect on the psychology of many investors; an element of capital protection is now likely to be more welcome than in the past. The capital protection given by structured products can provide a floor level for a portfolio. For example, if 60% of a portfolio is invested in structured products with 100% protection, it could be argued the effective maximum loss exposure is 40%. Capital protection can allow a low risk portfolio to incorporate a broader range of assets than might otherwise be the case. For instance, it is easier to expose part of a cautious investors portfolio to equities or commodities through a structured product which limits or removes completely the downside risk to capital. While capital protection is a key feature of virtually all retail structured products, the level and degree of protection varies between structured products: there is no universal standard. Thus, advisors must examine each product to ensure that they and their clients understand what protection is being provided as well as its effect on investment returns. Protection is not guaranteed. If the counterparty providing the underlying investment of a structured product defaults, then the protection may be lost. The choice of structured products for a portfolio must take into account the strength of counterparties and their ability to repay the clients money. Protection has a cost. As a general rule, the higher the level of protection, the lower the potential upside. This becomes obvious when a product provider offers two products which are identical except for the level of capital protection (e.g. 85% vs 100% of original investment). The corollary is that a portfolio should only incorporate protection to the extent it is required. Protection can be either hard or soft as explained on the next page.
Soft protection is the more cost effective option, meaning it offers potentially higher returns, but there is also a greater risk of loss to both capital and the return, particularly in extreme market conditions.
6. Gearing
Portfolios for private investors rarely incorporate any explicit form of gearing, whether in the form of borrowing to finance additional investment or the use of derivative contracts. Underlying investment funds used in portfolio construction - particularly hedge funds - may include such techniques, although there are strict limits on the borrowing possible within Collective Investment Schemes (Unit Trusts). Gearing is usually avoided in private investor portfolios because of the additional risk it creates. A return of twice that of the underlying asset return is attractive when values are rising, but losses are magnified when the prices are falling. The 2008 experience of some professional investors has underlined the risks. Structured products with capital protection allow gearing to be introduced into a portfolio with defined limits placed on the corresponding downside. However, the higher the gearing, the more likely it is that the total return will be capped. 5
Geared structured products have several useful roles in portfolio planning: If returns from an asset class are expected to be positive, but not substantially so, a structured product can be used to amplify those returns. The ultimate form of gearing is the digital structured product. A typical digital product gives a fixed return (e.g. 40% after five years) provided the relevant index at the end of the term is not below its starting level. Where the threshold is not met, normally there would be 100% capital protection. The digital plan is best suited to those situations where returns from an asset are expected to be close to flat. Gearing can free up capital for investment for other areas or provide additional liquidity. For example, if a 30% exposure to South African equities is required, then only 10% of the portfolio need be invested if the chosen structured product has 3:1 gearing to the FTSE/JSE Top40 Index. The mechanics of a geared structured product often effectively mean that income is being exchanged for faster capital growth. This can be advantageous for high tax paying investors (see Tax Efficiency).
The solution The advisor recommends that the tracker funds forming the core of the SA equity holding should be replaced by a four year Accelerator product. The benefits of this approach: The core would have a 400% geared exposure to the FTSE/JSE Top40 Index, giving a maximum potential return of 50% if the Index has risen by 12.50% or more in the next four years. If the Index falls over the next four years, there is 100% soft capital protection with a barrier level of 60%. The Accelerator is linked to the FTSE/JSE Top40 Index rather than the JSE All-Share Index. As the satellite funds are mostly at the small cap end of the market, the end result is a closer match to the overall South African market than the current structure. A modest market performance favours the Accelerator, as does an Index fall of more than the net dividend yield. The Accelerator produces no income and is likely to be taxed as capital gains due to the LEIPS wrapper, thereby producing a tax efficient return for Pieter who is a higher rate tax payer.
Barrier
Payoff
Index
Cap
Underlying
7. Diversification
Diversification is one of the key principles of portfolio construction. The fact that diversification can be used to improve the risk/reward ratio is one of the main conclusions of modern portfolio theory, which underpins the basis for much proprietary asset allocation software. In practice: There is diversification between different asset classes. This was historically limited to three or four asset classes - domestic/international equities, fixed interest and cash. There is no commonly agreed number. Commercial property and commodities would now appear on most asset allocators lists, while other classes, such as infrastructure and hedge funds, are becoming norms for institutional investors to consider. Within each asset class diversification is also required. Often the starting point for this is an appropriate index. For example, US equity asset allocation is commonly benchmarked against the S&P 500 Index. For private investors, diversification within the traditional asset classes is usually achieved by the use of Collective Investment Schemes (CIS). Collective Investment Schemes can also provide access to some of the new asset classes, although the choice of funds and track records tend to be limited. Structured products play a variety of roles in providing a means of diversification for a portfolio. Most structured products have an index as the underlying asset, which means that diversification within the asset class is automatic. A structured products index-linking is not subject to any tracking error, although it must be borne in mind that many structured products use averaging when setting final values. The range of underlying assets for structured products includes areas which are not easily accessed via Collective Investment Schemes e.g. certain foreign markets or commodity-linked products. In addition, underlying asset classes like inflation and hedge funds suddenly become accessible in packages which reduce risk or gear up returns. Although diversification is generally recognised as a risk-reducer, it does not eliminate all risk. In extreme market conditions - such as those seen worldwide in the second half of 2008 - the benefits of diversification can largely disappear in the flight to safety. Under such circumstances, the capital protection offered by structured products can play a valuable supporting role alongside diversification. 8
Payoff
Commodity Basket
100%
Cap
* As at 30 April 2010 9
8. Tax efficiency
Generally it is tax efficient for investment returns to be in the form of capital gains: For the 2009/10 tax-year there is an individual annual exclusion for the first R17, 500 of capital gains. There is a 25% inclusion rate on capital gains earned above the annual exclusion mentioned above which at a maximum individual tax rate of tax of 40% would result in a maximum tax charge being levied of 10% (25% x 40%).
There is also the benefit of being able to defer capital gains to the disposal date of the asset, whereas a liability to income tax on normal investment income may result in taxation being payable at a much earlier date as and when the investment income is received or accrued. Structured products are often able to provide investment returns in the form of capital gains, even in those rare cases where an underlying asset incorporates re-invested income (e.g. accumulation units in Collective Investment Schemes). Through Absa Capitals LEIPS structure, it is possible to earn investment returns in the form of capital gains which are more tax efficient.
9. Income
Just as structured products can be used to convert income into prospective growth, so they can also switch from potential growth into immediate income. Thus a structured product can offer an income yield well above that of the underlying asset with a capital protected return of the original investment. For example, it would be possible to have a product linked to the FTSE/JSE Top40 Index that could offer 10% annual income over four years against a yield on the index of 2.08% p.a*.
*As at November 2010
The ability of a structured product to boost an assets underlying income has three main benefits in planning income portfolios: It provides a fixed amount of income for the structured products term; It allows part of a portfolio to be invested in an area which might otherwise be considered inappropriate because of its low yield and; It avoids the need to make regular capital withdrawals to supplement dividend or other income.
10
The exchange for the additional income is that the investor will not receive any growth in their capital and could suffer a loss. Income plans normally have soft protection with a barrier level such as 50% to 60% of the strike price. Thus at maturity there would be a capital loss if the barrier has been breached and the index has not fully recovered.
11
Payoff
Index
Digital plans can produce relatively highly geared returns in dull markets, providing the asset value at maturity is not below the strike level. Best of structured products provide a return based on the best performing component of an asset basket, e.g. the highest performing of the FTSE/JSE Top40, FTSE/JSE SA Listed Property and the FTSE/JSE Industrial 25 Index. There are also worst of versions. Kick-out or knock-out structured products are fixed term products which automatically mature early if a certain level of asset performance is achieved by a given date (usually a plan anniversary). Where an advisor has a particular view about a market, these types of structured product can be used to reinforce the potential returns from that judgement.
-40%
40%
Underlying
12
13
12. Conclusion
In the world of Treating Customers Fairly, portfolio construction can no longer be a black art which magically produces a mix of funds for a client. The portfolios construction must reflect the clients goals and its contents must be understood by the client. It is equally the case that a portfolio cannot be a fixed structure. It must be regularly reviewed to take account of changes in the clients circumstances, investment conditions and new investment opportunities. Structured products have a major role to play in achieving these goals in the initial construction and subsequent maintenance of a portfolio. Structured products can: Address some of the typically conflicting client wishes for capital protection and equity-type growth. Offer exposure to asset classes which are otherwise difficult to access. Provide tax efficient solutions for both income and growth. Produce geared, reverse and other types of return for different asset classes. Form a core index-tracking holding in a core/satellite structure. Reduce administrative burdens by avoiding the issue of income reinvestment.
Yes
110% - early redemption of the product 120% - early redemption of the product 130% - early redemption of the product 140% - early redemption of the product 100% of the initial investment Par - fall investment
Year 2
Yes
Year 3
Yes
Year 4
Yes
No
Yes
Structured products are at the leading edge of retail investment design. Many of the most innovative products to be launched in recent years have been structured products or had structured product components included. This is not an area anyone involved in developing client portfolios can afford to ignore.
Tel: +27 (0)11 895 5528 :: 15 Alice Lane, Sandton, 2196, South Africa :: http://www.rsp.absacapital.com/