Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
A Note on Terminology vi
Introduction 1
Two Forms of Martyrdom 4
1 Islam 11
Jihad: Holy War 13
Martyrdom in Islam 20
The Difficult Secularisation of Religion 25
Reinterpretations of Martyrdom and Jihad 28
The Paradoxical Individualisation of Religious Discourse 52
Martyropathy 58
Death and Fear of Dying 62
Conclusion 225
1
2 Suicide Bombers
Defensive martyrdom
‘Martyr’ derives from the Greek word martur, which becomes marturos
and martures. Its essential meaning is ‘witness’. The expression was
used in Greek courts. Until the second century AD, it did not mean
dying for a cause. With the appearance of that new meaning, the old
sense of ‘bearing witness’ in a court gradually became blurred and
gave way to the new meaning. This does not mean that the wish
to die as a martyr did not exist amongst Christians until the second
century. There are many examples, including Ignatius of Antioch
at the beginning of the second century. Having fallen in love with
death, he looked forward with joy to the tortures that awaited him.4
The ‘martyr affect’ did exist, even though there was no word to
capture its semantic specificity.
Christian martyrdom came into being in the Roman Empire and
was, from the outset, closely linked to that historical and cultural
situation.5 Its appearance provoked stupefaction and incomprehension
on the part of the Romans. How, wondered the Stoic Emperor Marcus
Aureleus, could a rational being commit ‘irrational suicide’, especially
when he caused the fatal blow to be struck by others?
Pagans saw the voluntary martyrdom sought by Christian as a sign
of dementia. They were astonished to see people rushing headlong
into death by intentionally provoking the wrath of the Governor or
Emperor. They could understand their wish not to make sacrifices
to them. But acting ostentatiously and imitating those who had
refused to make sacrifices in order to be put to death was simply
irrational.6
According to Eusebius of Caesarea, who was writing at the time
of Diocletian, the first martyr was Procopus, who refused to make
a sacrifice to the gods in the presence of the Emperor.7 He said that
he recognised only one God and was ready to sacrifice himself to
Him. His head was then cut off. Martyrs were sometimes so rash as
to physically prevent governors from making sacrifices. The young
Introduction 7
involves the self who must perish, the third party who must put him
to death and the God who must accept the sacrifice.
In the Roman Empire, the burning desire to die as a martyr became
so widespread during the third century and at the beginning of the
fourth that the theologians had to step in. Whilst the desire to preserve
the faith and to fight those who wanted to impose a false religion was
considered legitimate, the conscious wish to die and thirsting after
a holy death was deemed to be blasphemous. Augustine denounces
this type of death and extends the commandment ‘Thou shalt not
kill’ to all human life, including that of the martyr. Henceforth,
putting oneself to death was murder, ‘for to kill oneself is to kill a
human being’.10
Following the logic of taking things to the limit, the martyr takes
the legitimate defence of the faith to mean self-sacrifice, and then
a quest for a death that is quite independent of any circumstances
that might make it legitimate. This dialectic is still of contemporary
relevance. Tragic circumstances can set the mechanisms of martyrdom
in motion. There comes a moment when the fascination with death
is often divorced from the religious logic that previously reined in the
passion of dying, and it becomes divorced from the religious goal.
In such cases, we have a passionate love for death and a desire for
self-annihilation, and they replace the desire to ensure the legitimacy
of a sacred cause by risking death.
Offensive martyrdom
The offensive martyr is inspired by a desire to destroy the enemy by
resorting to a legitimate violence that is sanctioned by religion. The
struggle implies killing the infidel and oppressive adversary. This
idea, which is the inspiration behind Muslim martyrdom and that
found in other religions, can also inspire nationalism, as with the
Tamil Tigers in Sri Lanka, the patriotism of the First World War, or
the revolutionary phenomena of 1789.
In the Sikh religion, martyrdom has undeniable similarities with
Islamic martyrdom.11 The martyrdom of the fifth guru, Guru Arjan,
led to the militarisation of the Sikh religion in 1606. That of his
grandson Guru Tegh Bahadur, who was the ninth Sikh master, led
to the creation of the militant Khalsa elite, which was founded in
1699 by Gobind Singh, the tenth and last Guru. The term used to
designate Sikh martyrdom is the same as the Arabic expression, which
is also used in Persian: shahid (plural: shuhada). Its two overlapping
meanings are also found in Islam.
10 Suicide Bombers
255
256 Suicide Bombers