Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
REVIEW ARTICLE
ASHIMA ANAND
ventilation of subjects who while being hyperpnoea was not diminished by ventilating
subjected to LBNP, also breathed gas the dogs with pure oxygen (see above) or by
mixtures which either consisted of a low removing the carotid bodies. A marked
percentage of CO 2 (1.25%) or a higher one augmentation in ventilation was also seen
(2.25%) in O 2 and were compared to a breath in dogs who had pulmonary congestion and
b y b r e a t h m e a s u r e m e n t o f ( V T) a n d in whom an increase in pulmonary blood
b r e a t h i n g f r e q u e n c y ( f B) , w h e n t h e s a m e flow was produced by exercising them on a
subjects breathed either room air or almost treadmill (14). This increase in ventilation
pure oxygen (95%). An increase in was susceptible to cooling of the vagi - a
ventilation when LBNP was released was procedure whereby the afferent impulses in
evident in all cases as an increase in f B more these nerves are blocked (15).
than an increase in V T . However, the point
to note was that the presence of hypercapnia, Brown et al. (16) studied a situation
either a borderline increase over physiological in exercising subjects, which was opposite
levels or a greater one, could not account to the above and proved the same point.
for the increase in ventilation that was seen Essentially they used intravenous propanalol
with the above procedure. Ventilation was hydrochloride, a β-adrenergic blocker which
augmented to the same order as when the decreases heart rate and cardiac output but
subject breathed pure oxygen or room air. does not influence oxygen consumption or
arterial oxygen saturation. Under its
d. Pulmonary stretch receptors influence heart rate fell by about 17% and
ventilation (V E ) was reduced by about 9.6%.
The observation that the respiratory
effect of releasing the accumulated blood was
WHAT DOES AN INCREASE IN BLOOD FLOW
primarily seen during inspiration and that STIMULATE ?
it could occur mid-expiration or even at the
height of inspiration, seems to suggest ( a ) Intrapulmonary CO2 receptors
strongly that this reflex was not mediated
by the pulmonary stretch receptors (5). Accompanying the increase in cardiac
output produced by leg-raising, was a
I I . VASCULAR FACTORS
significant increase in ETCO2 Boone and
Exercise physiologists studying the Foley (4) considered the stimulation of
increase in ventilation that persists after possible carbon dioxide-sensitive sensory
exercise has ended, have also entertained receptors in the pulmonary vasculature to
the notion that this augmentation is related be responsible for the respiratory reflexes
to a concomitant increase in cardiac output. seen. This question had also been addressed
This was at first shown in dogs by to earlier, by Green and Sheldon (17). Their
increasing cardiac output by injecting results allow one to conclude that the
isoproternol intravenously (13). Ventilation presence of an increased CO 2 output, while
was enhanced almost immediately (the next ventilation was increasing linearly in
breath) with the increase in heart rate and response to an increasing pulmonary blood
persisted for as long as the haemodynamic flow, produced an additive effect on the
changes remained sustained. Furthermore, former.
22 Anand Indian J Physiol Pharmacol 2005; 49(1)
effects of lobeline injected seen within 2 sec located specifically near the alveoli and
to a stimulation of pulmonary baroreceptors. accessible only through the venous
For such short latencies, one would have to circulation. These, referred to as the
assume that the sensory endings were in juxtapulmonary capillary (J) receptors, are
direct contact with the blood in the stimulated by certain drugs and chemicals
pulmonary artery, which not being likely, (especially phenyl diguanide or PDG)
gives rise to the possibility of the origin of injected intravenously and by an increase
hyperpnoea from receptors from somewhere in interstitial volume (32, 33). A noteworthy
further downstream or from a site that is stimulation of the J receptors is also
accessible from the capillary circulation (in produced by pulmonary congestion produced
so short an interval). by phosgene gas (34). The respiratory reflex
effects that they give rise to consist of
The observations that advocate the
tachypnoea followed by an apnoea or the
possible involvement of pulmonary
two occurring in reverse sequence.
baroreceptors, cannot, however, preclude
the role of vagal receptors in the pulmonary But most importantly, in cats the
bed, which must also experience the rise in activity of J receptors increases significantly
pressure and an increase in flow. This was (from a near zero resting value to 0.75
never more obvious in Bevan’s study (27) impulses/sec) when pulmonary blood flow is
and is discussed further in a later section. increased by 133%, i.e. twice cardiac output
(35). This level of increase in their activity
c. Receptors near pulmonary capillaries is normally seen accompanying an injection
of phenyl diguanide that causes a 40–140%
From the latency of response to the increase in ventilation (36). In addition to
stimulus of releasing the occluded blood, reflex respiratory acceleration, stimulation
Mills concluded that the site of origin of of J receptors in human subjects by injecting
the hyperpnoea was located somewhere in an alkaloid, lobeline intravenously, gives
the pulmonary capillaries. The following had rise to certain sensations that are typically
been concluded from earlier experimentations: confined to the upper respiratory (chest)
receptors in the pulmonary vascular bed areas (37). The foregoing conclusion was
gave rise to the marked tachypnoea that inevitable as the respiratory reflexes and
arose reflexely, as a result of multiple sensations occur within a few seconds of
pulmonary embolism and also that it required each other. Furthermore, they demonstrated
intact vagi. This was supported by two key quite clearly that the other predominant
clinical observations that (i) pulmonary group of lung receptors-the pulmonary
congestion was always accompanied by stretch receptors had no role to play in
dyspnoea (29), and (ii) in cases of primary the perception of the lobeline-induced
sclerosis of the pulmonary arteries there is respiratory sensations.
no evidence of dyspnoea, suggesting that
receptors proximal to the pulmonary Respiratory reflexes and sensations after
arteries are not involved in the reflexes (30). pulmonary denervation
In 1955, Paintal (31) identified receptors The above observations and conclusions
near the pulmonary vasculature that were have also been reaffirmed in patients who
24 Anand Indian J Physiol Pharmacol 2005; 49(1)
had recent bi lateral lung transplants (28). in the ventilatory response. They observed
In them, lobeline injected intravenously does that in response to exercise, an increase in
not give rise, either to respiratory reflexes ventilation after HLT was much reduced
o r t o r e s p i r a t o r y s e n s a t i o n s i n t h e same compared to that obtained before surgery
manner (qualitatively or q u a n t i t a t i v e l y ) a s and in addition it was not too different from
it does in normal subjects. Thus it is quite that of the normals. On the other hand, the
apparent that an intact pulmonary vagal increase in ventilation in response to
innervation is vital for above mentioned exercise in HT patients was comparable to
respiratory reflexes to occur and the the values obtained before their surgery.
accompanying sensations to be felt. The Two obvious conclusions can be drawn from
presence of lobeline-induced sensations in these finding: (i) cardiac receptors including
heart transplant subjects, who were also pulmonary baroreceptors are not the site of
studied similarly in this investigation provides origin of the augmented ventilation seen
further proof that they do not arise from during exercise, and (ii) pulmonary sensory
any receptors in the region of the heart or receptors are more likely to have been
from any major blood vessels arising from it. stimulated by a rise in pulmonary blood
flow, although they had been deafferented
It is crucial that we review the hypothesis in this situation. The important point to
put forward by Moore et al. (26) in the light note was that the haemodynamic changes
of the above findings on lung and heart related to pulmonary hypertension were also
transplant patients. These investigators no longer present.
have assigned a central role to the pulmonary
artery baroreceptors in influencing ventilation In Theodore et al’s (38) view since both
when stimulated by a rise in pulmonary pulmonary hypertension and pulmonary
artery pressure that is produced by the afferent innervation are absent in HLT and
increased cardiac output during exercise. no augmentation of ventilation is recorded
in response to exercise, this issue can only
Exercise studies after pulmonary denervation be resolved by conducting neurophysiological
studies. One such study was the one
It is fairly well established that the undertaken by Butler et al. (28). In the
ventilatory response to exercise is foregoing account, it has been elaborated
exaggerated still further in patients with upon that in subjects with deafferented
pulmonary hypertension (38, 39). Theodore lungs (especially recent ones) – neither
et al (38) conducted an exercise study on respiratory sensations nor respiratory
patients with pulmonary hypertension, reflexes are evoked by injecting lobeline i.v.
before and after they underwent heart- These findings thus attribute this function
bilateral lung transplantation (HLT) and to pulmonary sensory receptors albeit with
compared the data obtained from them with intact innervation. The above conclusion is
that from normals and those patients who also supported by the observations of
had undergone only heart transplantation Pfeiffer et al. (40) on respiratory sensations
(HT). The criterion of the slope of minute evoked by loaded breathing in lung
ventilation over carbon dioxide production transplant subjects. The intensity of
i.e. (VE/VO 2 ) was used to express a change sensations (Borg scale score) in relation to
Indian J Physiol Pharmacol 2005; 49(1) Pulmonary Blood Flow Increment and Augmentation 25
the stimulus provided in the form of increased CO 2 flow, are likely to mediate the
increasing peak inspiratory mouth pressure - increase in ventilation seen during exercise.
expressed as a correlation coefficient, was
reduced in subjects after they had The foregoing discussion inevitably
undergone lung transplantation. This was strengthens Mills’ observations made sixty
also accompanied by, as expected, reduced years ago, that when pulmonary blood flow
ventilatory response to loaded breathing. increases due to an increase in cardiac
output (with exercise), it stimulates sensory
From the various studies discussed, it is receptors lying near the pulmonary
obvious that neither pulmonary baroreceptors vasculature, that reflexely augment
which may be stimulated significantly by ventilation. Further evidence in support
the increased blood flow nor pulmonary CO2 may be provided by studies that include
receptors (?) that may be stimulated by the subjective data of responses.
REFERENCES
1. Krogh A, Lindhard J. The regulation of respiration 10. Innes JA, Solarte I, Huszczuk A, Yeh E, Whipp
and circulation during the initial stages of BJ, Wasserman K. Respiration during recovery
muscular work. Journal of Physiology 1913; 47: from exercise: effects of trapping and release of
112–136. femoral blood flow. Journal of Applied Physiology
2. McCloskey DI, Mitchell JH. Reflex cardiovascular 1989; 67: 2608–2613.
and respiratory responses originating in exercising 11. Lawler JM, Cline CC, O’Kroy JA. Coast JR. Effects
muscle. Journal of Physiology 1972; 224: 173–186.
of inspired 02 and CO2 on ventilatory responses to
3. Åstrand P-O, Cuddy TE Saltin B, Stenberg J. 1964. LBNP-release and acute head-down tilt. Aviation
Cardiac output during submaximal and maximal work. Space & Environment Medicine 1995; 66: 751–756.
Journal of Applied Physiology 1964; 10: 268–274.
12. R o b b G P , W e i s s S . 1 9 3 3 . A m e t h o d f o r t h e
4. Boone T, Foley M. Effect of venous return on measurement of the velocity of the pulmonary and
respiratory response. Journal of Sports Medicine peripheral venous blood flow in man. American
and Physical Fitness . 1991; 31: 249–256. Heart Journal 1933; 8: 650–670.
5. Mills JN. Hyperpnoea produced in man by sudden 13. W a s s e r m a n K, Whipp BJ, Castagna J.
release of occluded blood. Journal of Physiology Cardiodynamic hyperpnoea: secondary to cardiac
1944; 103: 244–252. output increase. Journal of Applied physiology
1974; 36: 457–464.
6. Habak PA, Mark AL, Kioschos M, McRaven MD,
Abboud FM. Effectiveness of congesting cuffs 14. Phillipson EA, Murphy E, Kozar LF, Schultze RK.
(“rotating tourniquets”) in patients with left heart Role of vagal stimuli in exercise ventilation in dogs
failure. Circulation 1974; 50: 366–371. with experimental pneumonitis. Journal of Applied
Physiology 1975; 39: 76–85.
7. Klein HO, Brodsky E, Ninio R, Kaplinsky E & Di
Segni E. The effect of venous occlusion with 15. Phillipson EA, Hickey RF, Bainton CR, Nadel JA.
tourniquets on peripheral blood pooling and Effect of vagal blockade on regulation of breathing
ventricular function. Chest 1993; 103: 521–527. in conscious dogs. Journal of Applied Physiology
1970; 27: 475–479.
8. Danzer CS. The pathogenesis and treatment of
dyspnoea in the light of recent experiments. Annals 16. Brown HV, Wasserman K, Whipp BJ. Effect of beta-
of Internal Medicine 1928; 2: 239–247. adrenergic blockade during exercise on ventilation
and gas exchange. Journal of Physiology 1976; 41:
9. Kountz WB, Smith JR, Wright ST. Observations 886–892.
on the effect of tourniquets on acute cardiac crises,
normal subjects and chronic heart failure. 17. G r e e n J F , S h e l d o n M I . V e n t i l a t o r y c h a n g e s
American Heart Journal. 1932; 23: 624–636. associated with changes in pulmonary blood flow
26 Anand Indian J Physiol Pharmacol 2005; 49(1)
in dogs. Journal of Applied Physiology 1983; 54: 29. Weiss S, Robb GP. Cardiac Asthma (paroxymal
997–1002. cardiac dypnoea). Journal of American Medical
Association 1933; 100: 1841–1846.
18. Bianconi R, Green JH. Pulmonary baroreceptors
in the cat. Archives Italia Biologica 1959; 97: 305– 30. E a s t T . P u l m o n a r y h y p e r t e n s i o n . B r i t i s h H e a r t
315. Journal 1940; 2: 189–200.