Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
High quality
Adding value and
engineers to lead
eliminating waste
change
Demonstration
Innovation and Management and
of employee
technology transfer leadership
competence
Culture change
at all levels
Quality and
availability of Transferable skills and
metallurgists and retraining
engineers
Contents Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
Contents
1. Introduction 3
7. Action plan 25 - 33
2
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
Introduction Introduction
1 Introduction
Welcome to the Metals Industry Skills and Performance Strategy 2005. This updates similar strategies which have been in place for
the metals sector for the past five years and provides:
Case studies from some of the 500 companies which have benefited from industry solutions are included at Appendix 5.
The Strategy has been produced following extensive consultation with employers, from large and small companies and in different
parts of the sector, over the period October 2004-April 2005. Our Metals Forum trade association partners1 were instrumental in
convening these groups, and also provided invaluable state of trade information. Metals Forum has already adopted the main
findings in the Metals Forum Annual Report 2005 and continues to provide a significant ‘route to market’ for industry solutions and
collaborative projects which are developed in response to priority needs.
In 2005 Metals Industry Skills and Performance will become part of SEMTA, the Sector Skills Council for Science, Engineering and
Manufacturing Technologies, and this Strategy will form the first two stages of a Metals Sector Skills Agreement. In that new form it
will, we hope, both open up new partnerships and resources and engage yet more employers, and thus further the overall aim - to
achieve measurable improvement in the business performance of the UK metals sector.
Lindsay Millington
Chief Executive
Metals Industry Skills and Performance
July 2005
With thanks to Dawn Vinall for collating and editing the results.
1 See page 47 for a description of the Metals Forum and its member associations.
3
Facts & Figures
Facts and Figures Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
2.1 Footprint
The UK metals sector (comprising those companies which make, process, distribute and recycle metals, or fabricate metals
for construction or other products) supplies vital raw materials, precision products and complete building structures to the
manufacturing, public and service sectors. Every year, the metals sector:
The metals market covers a diverse range of industries, including aerospace, automotive, engineering, retail, leisure and public
buildings and bridges, oil and gas extraction, power generation, telecommunications, defence, orthopaedic medicine, rail, domestic
appliances, furniture and packaging. The metals sector footprint is depicted in the diagram on the next page.
The metals sector contributes £38 billion per annum to UK GDP and creates close to £15 billion of gross value added (GVA) for the
economy. This is:
The UK metals sector has also invested £14.17 billion in the UK over the last ten years (excluding acquisitions). In addition, direct
exports are also worth some £13 billion per year (£3.5 billion in scrap metal).
4
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Facts
Facts and & continued
Figures Figures
tele-
communications
power
generation aerospace
process
automotive
plant
orthopaedic
domestic
medicine
appliances
metal metal
forming packaging
Iron
Aluminium Steel
constructional
casting
steelwork
marine
agriculture
furniture chemicals
freight
transport & construction
rail
defence
This is the footprint previously covered by Metals Industry Skills & Performance (MetSkill) and SEMTA’s Engineered Metal Products
Sector Strategy Group.
5
Facts & Figures Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
2.3 Workforce
Total Employment
The UK metals sector comprises some 30,000 companies employing 471,000 people across the UK (1 out of every 8 jobs in UK
manufacturing). The metals sector directly employs nearly twice as many people as the chemicals industry and twice as many as
the automotive sector, as shown in the table below.
Indirectly, it is estimated that the metals sector supports a further 1 million people working in sub-contract businesses, such as site
services, catering and general engineering. Twenty years ago, many of these services would have formed part of metals companies’
direct employment. This restructuring accounts for a significant part of the ‘decline’ perceived by the public.
Employment: 2002
Metals compared to other sectors
Metals 471
Electricals 417
Machinery 328
Chemicals 253
Automotive 222
Plastics 198
Note: Metals SIC codes 27 & 28 only for purposes of comparison with other sectors.
Age profile
The metals age profile is toward the higher end of the spectrum, with 48% aged 45 and over. The all-industry average is just 35%.
6
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Facts & Figures
Gender
The metals sector is heavily male-dominated. Whilst the figure has fallen slightly since 1995, over 84% of the workforce is male,
compared with the all industry average of 55%.
Ethnicity
The metals sector’s ethnic workforce composition has a white/non-white split of 96% and 4% This is broadly inline with UK industry
as a whole, with a white/non-white split of 94% and 6% respectively.
Sub-sectors
Employment by metals sub-sector is shown below. There are strong supply chain links between these industries, although each has
its own specific processes and trade associations.
7
Facts & Figures Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
Although the industry includes one of the largest UK companies, Corus Group, and a number of other large enterprises, approximately
88% of the workforce is employed in companies with less than 250 people.
2.5 Location
Employment in the metals industry is UK-wide, however, 62% of businesses and employees are located in five English regions: West
Midlands; Yorkshire and Humberside; North West; North East and South East. The metals industry is also a very important part of
the economy in Scotland and Wales.
Businesses Employees
7% 2% 4% 1%
7% 8%
6% East Midlands
4%
5% East of England
9%
3% London
12% 14%
North East
2%
6%
2% North West
South East
South West
12% 10%
West Midlands
25%
19% Yorkshire & Humber
Wales
Scotland
13%
15% Northern Ireland
9% 5%
8
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Drivers for productivity and competitiveness
3.1 Overview
Market trends
From mid-2003, strong demand for metals, particularly in the ferrous sector, put pressure on available supplies, and a near-decade-
long trend of falling metals prices was reversed during 2004 with some metals recording historic highs.
As a result, metals producers have seen a marked turn-round in their business. But with mineral ores and energy prices surging, UK
metals companies continue to look for production and supply chain efficiencies so that they can deliver the competitively priced
materials that their customers need to succeed in their markets: selling completed goods like cars, planes and medical equipment,
the components for them, or the capital goods needed to produce them.
Sustainability
Metals are highly recyclable, so the sector is central to the UK’s success in achieving environmental sustainability. 10 million tonnes
of metal is recycled each year, including 2 million vehicles, 3.5 million white goods and 2 billion steel cans. The industry also has
strong local community roots and creates high added value using capital-intensive plant. Ultimately, it depends on a combination
of advanced academic and technician level skills for year-on-year progress in process plant and product innovation. So, the sector
also creates sustainable economic development across various levels of academic achievement, which is good for society as a
whole.
• Transport. More than 16 million tonnes of metal is moved around the UK each year, some of it several times, between
originating mills or ports, secondary processing and further fabrication before distribution to the market.
• Health and safety. In response to legislation, insurance costs and good practice, health and safety issues are a priority.
Recent issues include working at height for those in steel construction, loading and unloading lorries and working on top
of machines.
• Climate Change. Notwithstanding the Climate Change Levy, which has imposed an unwarranted burden on UK companies,
it is increasingly recognised that it is process improvement and business investment that is delivering energy savings, not
the levy itself.
• Energy. UK consumers re-contracting for gas and electricity supplies in the last twelve months have experienced massive
increases in their bills. Large industrial consumers in the UK are typically paying 30-40% more for their gas and electricity
than a year ago.
• Working Time Directive. Twelve years ago the UK negotiated an opt-out from the Working Time Directive as part of
Britain’s much more flexible approach to employment regulation. This flexible approach is now under threat.
9
Drivers for productivity and competitiveness Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
be needed in 10 to 20 years time, what issues are most likely to shape the future of the sector, and how the UK should best respond
to meet those developments. Business improvement and skills are important Task Forces within the IGT.
Metals Innovation
The metals sector is at the forefront of innovation. 70% of steels used in automotive applications did not exist 10 years ago. 15%
of a modern commercial aircraft is made from specially-developed steels. 50% of metal used in the Airbus A380 (by value) is
manufactured in the UK.
The UK steel industry’s light-weight automotive steels project has achieved 80% gains in rigidity and 25% reduction in weight,
enabling major technical advances and cost savings.
The following state of trade reports have been taken from the Metals Forum Annual Review 2005 (see page 47 for details).
They indicate the diversity of the metals industries and show a buoyant sector actively responding to a wide range of
market challenges.
3.2.1 Aluminium
The use of aluminium products continued to expand during 2004 in spite of price rises in primary metal. Significant gains have
been made in transport, packaging and building and construction. Across Europe, primary aluminium production reached 4.4
million tonnes in 2004, an increase over the previous year of 5.6%, but Europe is still reliant on extensive primary metal imports.
The UK aluminium rolled products sector has had good markets for beverage cans and packaging, lithographic sheet and automotive
products. However, the aluminium extrusion sector faces the threat of a contracting market, coupled with very cheap imports from
low labour cost countries. Benchmarking technology and competitiveness in the Italian extrusion industry has been one response.
The stockholding sector, on the other hand, has had an excellent year across the board, but particularly in aerospace. The successful
test flight of the new A380 Airbus has been a great boost to the UK aluminium industry, the wings being built in North Wales.
Aluminium recycling rates continue to increase, a recent European study showed an aluminium recycling rate in building of about
95%. However, countries such as India and China are buying up an increasing proportion of these supplies, and it is likely that the
actual act of recycling – the melting of scrap and production of new alloys – is increasingly likely to be carried out overseas in future.
This trend has caused a significant loss of capacity in the UK recycling sector, a problem exacerbated by the demise of MG Rover,
which was a significant user of foundry ingot.
3.2.2 Steel
World steel consumption rose by 9.3% in 2004, compared with historical trend growth of only 2%. Growth was particularly strong
in China (13%), Central and South America (15%) and North America (14%). For the first time in history, the world produced over 1
billion tonnes of steel.
Such rapid growth produced a very tight supply/demand balance up the raw material supply chain. Consequently, prices rose
sharply. Iron ore prices rose by around 17% in the 2004 annual contract. Coke prices shot up by 130% in just four months. Shipping
became in short supply, so that spot rates for transporting ore and coal leapt by 60% in one month in autumn 2003, fell back, then
10
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Drivers for productivity and competitiveness
surged again to an all time high in early December 2004. At its peak, the price of steel scrap in Europe rose by 70% in four months.
Inevitably, steel prices started to rise as steelmakers tried to recover these unprecedented cost increases. Then, supplies became
tight for some steel products themselves, enabling UK producers for the first time in many years to start improving their margins.
And, while for most of the year European steel prices lagged behind US prices, the steady weakening of the dollar meant that the
EU market became very attractive in the latter part of the year, leading to an increase in imports.
Demand in the UK has been relatively healthy across most consuming sectors, but concern remains about the sluggishness of most
of the Eurozone economies, particularly in the construction sector.
Coincident with this improvement in business was an unprecedented increase in the price of raw materials and energy. Whilst
some foundries could recover cost increases through price rises and surcharge arrangements, companies on long-term or fixed
price contracts experienced major difficulties. There is concern that if these high prices are maintained, customers will look to
suppliers in the East to retain their competitive position.
Historically, foundry closures have provided a useful pool of skilled labour but, over recent years, redundant workers have decided
to seek employment outside the industry. As a consequence, there has been a significant increase in the recruitment of skilled
workers from Eastern Europe.
3.2.4 Metalforming
Material in-put prices had an enormous impact on the metalforming sector’s performance over 2003-04, while some sub-sectors
were able to pass on the extra prices, others could not. In some cases these price pressures stung customers into looking at
alternative solutions for their material supply or even manufacturing elsewhere and then re-importing the finished products back
into the UK.
Thus, in general terms, while the forgings and sheet metal sub-sectors were able to maintain business and pass on additional costs,
fastener businesses struggled and suffered significant margin squeeze where contracts or alternative suppliers did not permit
the same flexibility. There have thus been hefty price increases in steel deliveries, at the same time as big gas and electricity price
hikes.
Consolidation of the smaller players within the metalforming industry has continued. However, there was also good news, as several
large investments in modern automated press shops directly related to the motor industry were commissioned during 2004.
Rolls Royce opened a new forging facility to manufacture turbine blades for aero engines near Glasgow; and, following Airbus’s
success and its record order-books, fastener manufacturers supplying into the aerospace industry, both for airframe and for engines,
are under pressure to increase capacity.
11
Drivers for productivity and competitiveness Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
Distributors rely on the transport infrastructure, and the continuing increase in fleet operating costs as a result of working time
restrictions, fuel price increases and congestion continues to be a prime concern. Health & safety has always been a high priority;
steel processing is inherently risky, and the ongoing development of practical and clear guidelines for handling steel has to get
more professional year by year.
The projections for the iron ore, scrap, and coal/coke markets for the next few years, allied to the continuing increase in demand
from China and other Asian economies, clearly demonstrate a trend of increasing steel prices and supply difficulties. To respond to
the development of new products and solutions for users’ needs, in partnership with steel mills and others, will be a big part of the
service model going forward.
3.2.6 Galvanizing
Like all metals related industries, the hot dip galvanizing industry was affected by the large increases in the price of its three main
constituents: zinc, steel and energy (gas). Although galvanizing is a service industry, which never owns the (steel) product it applies
protection to, the greatest impact was felt from the rise in steel prices. This meant that, in many cases where budgets had been set
the previous year, fewer items could be made and galvanized within the money available.
Despite this, it is estimated that the market contracted only slightly to about 800,000t in 2004, from a previous record of 830,000t in
2003. Certain sectors such as street furniture and construction continue to dominate the market for galvanized steel.
Galvanizing benefits from its natural advantage as a highly sustainable method of protecting steel from corrosion. Recent lifecycle
analysis work in Finland has shown that galvanizing contributes better long-term performance than many organic systems. The
study considered three main lifecycle impact categories: global warming potential, acidification and photochemical ozone potential.
Galvanizing had better results in all three.
It is expected that, as the steel market comes back into balance and prices stabilise, the market for galvanized steel will continue
to grow.
Innovation was the driver for most activity with, new developments giving easier opening and enhanced convenience in the
volume food market with curved tabs, peel seams in round and oblong cans, and single-serve pet food trays. Shaped food cans look
set to be a growing trend. Beverage can manufacturers continue to push the boundaries on print, with some fine examples of high
quality finishes on beer and soft drinks cans. They are also using their expertise to take the beverage can into new markets such as
iced coffee drinks. In these traditional sectors, metal remains the choice for fillers looking for convenient, cost efficient packaging
with good environmental credentials.
12
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Drivers for productivity and competitiveness
In industrial products too there are developments giving enhanced convenience and safety. Paint cans are showing a lot of
innovation with improvements in closure mechanisms, shaping, seaming and graphics. Paint can makers are capitalising on the
striking visual effect of undecorated tinplate to create an attractive retro-look.
Metal offers many advantages, not least is that it works with many different finishes – graphics, embossing or de-bossing.
Manufacturers of promotional packaging and decorative containers are producing stunning examples of visually striking graphics,
unusual tactile finishes and innovative shapes, whilst shaped aerosols offer new promotional opportunities for air fresheners, as
well as health and beauty products.
Prices are now expected to be more stable. Price rises for steelwork in 2005 should be of the order of 5 to 7%. Steel construction
demand in UK last year was 8% up on the previous year at a record 1.3 million tonnes (hot rolled sections and plate). Demand for
cold rolled purlins, decking and cladding panels also increased.
Steel construction continues to gain market share in a number of key sectors such as residential, hospitals and educational; last year
steel’s market share in the multi-storey residential sector increased from 39 to 44%. In the single-storey sector, steel has 95% market
share, and in the overall multi-storey sector steel’s share is 70%
Price levels are sufficient to maintain a healthy level of investment in machinery, in material handling equipment, in computerised
systems for design/control/operations, in training and maintenance, and in research and development of innovative products and
methods.
Last year was a good year in the UK non-ferrous metal recycling business. The continued underlying strength of the LME drove
prices upwards with the exception of aluminium scrap. Demand for copper scrap remained strong, and for brass and copper
alloy scrap it was extremely strong, with prices rising steeply in early 2005. Consumption of non-ferrous metals within the UK has
continued to shrink over the last year, although demand in the European market has been buoyant for many UK merchants.
There was a 7% increase in worldwide stainless steel production during 2004, to a record 24.3 million tonnes. Once again, the
increase was led by Asia, in particular China. Chinese production growth saw an increase of 30% over the 2003 figure to 2.35 million
tonnes. A worldwide increase in stainless steel production this year is forecast, growing by around 8% to 26 million tonnes. In the
short-term, stainless steel scrap prices will be uncertain because of fluctuating nickel prices and falling iron prices.
Overall, all areas of metals recycling could be described as healthy during 2004, and this is set to continue throughout 2005.
13
Implications for skills demand Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
MetSkill has a well-established research programme, developed over the last 15 years, which provides a detailed bank of evidence
and labour market intelligence that underpins our knowledge and understanding of the UK metals sector and, in particular, its
priority skills and business improvement issues. This knowledge is encapsulated in this Strategy, the first edition of which was
produced in 2000.2
Every year the Strategy is reviewed and updated in consultation with employers, Metals Forum partner trade associations, trades
unions, research and technology organisations, professional institutes and learning and training providers. 3
Priority needs are identified. These are based on a review of current drivers for productivity and competitiveness (see Section 3)
together with research, surveys, competitiveness studies4 and consultation with companies as above.
Ten key drivers have been identified that represent the most significant and continued strategic needs of metals employers.
A series of ‘Competitiveness Analysis Reports’ on sub-sectors within the UK steel and metals industry, prepared between October
2000 and June 2001 for the Department for Trade and Industry (DTI)5, reinforce these needs and highlight the need to raise
awareness of lean manufacturing and supply chain improvement techniques. In addition, a study, conducted by Cardiff University6
in 2001, showed the need to improve the understanding and application of supply chain management practices both within the
single company and between customers and suppliers.
Metals is one of eight key sectors where DTI has elected to invest7 in long-term, sustainable improvement in competitiveness
through building capacity to address lean process improvement and supply chain partnership under Metals Industry Competitive
Enterprise (MICE). The development of MICE8 as the metals sector ‘Industry Forum’ is in direct response to the above issues. (See
Section 7).
2 Steel and Metals Industry Workforce Development Plan 2000, Steel & Metals Industry NTO
3 See appendix 7 for list of organisations consulted in 2004 – 2005
4 DTI competitiveness studies, covering most of the sector, reinforce the picture of common strategic needs complemented by a limited number of specific needs in certain metals industries
5 See Appendix 7
6 ‘Supply Chain Management & the UK Metals Industry’; (2001), Lean Enterprise Research Centre, Cardiff Business School
7 £1.6m government investment in Metals Industry Competitive Enterprise (MICE) 2000-2004
8 MICE was launched in February 2000 with a £1.6m ‘pump priming’ grant from DTI
14
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Implications for skills demand
However, few metals companies can afford to recruit or maintain their own resource of such people. In addition there is a shortage
of qualified engineers and scientists leaving university and entering the industry.
Through the development of the MICE Engineer Team (currently 6 Engineers) the industry now has its own, shared cadre of high
quality engineers who can lead change and business improvement - a partial response to this problem. (See Section 7).
Government has also invested some £5.5 million in the National Metals Technology Centre (NAMTEC), which signposts UK companies,
especially SMEs, to vital resources within the UK science base, and seeks to identify and fill any gaps through the provision of
R&D facilities. NAMTEC provides information on metals technology. In June 2005 NAMTEC was re-launched as a Research and
Technology Organisation (RTO), with particular responsibilities for research and technology skills. (See Section 7).
Both MICE and NAMTEC are part of a coherent, high profile, sector-wide drive to improve innovation, efficiency and productivity.
These initiatives are backed by the industry and are supported by government and RDAs.
Skills issues in these areas are also addressed by other metals-related RTOs, including the Steel Construction Institute, Castings
Technology International and The Welding Institute.
For middle and junior managers, team working and leading, and the ability to manage and adjust to change were found to be
essential behavioural skills. The survey also found, however, that 50% of managers lacked training relevant to these needs. The DTI
Competitiveness Analysis Reports also identified the need to develop strategic thinking in managers to clarify and refine company
corporate strategy.
9 Technology Foresight in the Steel Industry (1997) addressed the skills and learning implications of new technology
10 ‘Steel Industry Managers in the 21st Century - Survey of Management Roles & Competences’; (1998)
15
Implications for skills demand Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
Management skills, therefore, are a priority issue for the future, particularly training and equipping managers at all levels to deal
with business strategy, lean techniques and change, and to cascade the necessary skills down the organisation.
Significant parts of the metals sector lack an understanding of current best practice in achieving culture change. Priority needs
are:
A culture where team-based continuous improvement, devolved responsibility, multi-skilling and personal development are the
norm will do much to promote culture change. These are issues which can be addressed through a range of MICE, skills development
and other sector responses.
• parts of the sector, notably casting and stainless steel, are subjected to large and fast moving changes in technology
requiring continual updating of skills and knowledge
• new communication technologies (including e-business) need to be addressed
• developments in advanced metals and process technologies are highlighting the need for higher-level skills, particularly
in certain regions
• basic skills problems (poor literacy and numeracy) are emerging as a growing barrier to up-skilling (see next page).
16
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Implications for skills demand
Employers have a real opportunity to improve learning and skills, but not all employers are exploiting the full potential of their
people. There is a need for a greater uptake of training and management development opportunities within the sector, particularly
amongst smaller companies, including the exposure of industry specialised managers to improvement ideas from other sectors.
However, a lack of suitable courses (14.3%) and local provision (11.6%) were cited by metals employers as being significant barriers
to maintaining a fully proficient workforce.
Basic Skills
The introduction of new equipment, business improvement activities, team-working and health and safety activities all identify
problems in basic skills. Increasingly detailed requirements with respect to safety, risk and environmental management also put
additional pressure on those who hitherto have managed to get by with low levels of literacy and numeracy. However, activities such
as MICE process improvement workshops and the Health and Safety Passport are proving useful means to exposing and addressing
such needs and, through these activities, more employers are accepting the importance of addressing basic skill needs.
• much of the industry knowledge is in people aged over 50, in management, supervisors and skilled labour. For example,
foundry specialists are over 50 years of age.
• the industry need to recruit c. 117,000 new entrants13 (including school leavers, graduates and adults) to replace those that
will be lost due to natural wastage by 2010.
The intake of younger recruits has dropped significantly and, consequently, this situation is getting worse. If no action is taken, this
will have a major impact in the next 10 years with an ageing workforce, a drop in skills, a reduction in graduates, and a general fall-
off in younger recruits to the industry.
The industry has identified a need for significantly enhanced careers and recruitment initiatives (see below), as well as more
widespread use of computer technology to capture knowledge and expertise before it leaves the industry is needed.
Some companies are turning to adult recruitment as a response to demographic changes and school retention, which limit the
availability of young people. In this, a shortage of local skills is showing a trend towards recruitment from Eastern Europe. Whilst
this is not seen as a long term solution, since such workers are likely to return home in due course, it raises a requirement for
streamlining induction, assessment and ‘top-up’ training processes.
17
Implications for skills demand Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
Source: Metal
DTI Competitiveness Analysis Reports
Steel - Primary Recycling Fasteners Forgings Presswork
Production
Employees with
32% 30% 16% 22% 21% 29%
competence training
Employees with
professional 14% 11% 7% 7% 10% 5%
qualifications
In addition to the above figures, British Constructional Steelwork Association data on qualification levels show that only 15% of
employees in the constructional steelwork sector are working at Levels 3 to 5, and very few have an actual qualification to prove
their competence.
Overall, some 40% metals sector employees have no qualifications relevant to the world of work. Prior to the 1990s, the industry has
no history of vocational qualifications for shop-floor operatives, as existed in other sectors such as engineering.
As a result of a 10-year development programme, Occupational Standards and National Vocational Qualifications (NVQs) are now
available for all occupations with the sector. (see Appendix 3). These industry relevant and competence-based qualifications were
originally developed, and have been recently reviewed and updated, with the close involvement of employers through sector-led
steering groups. They are available through a range of quality assured preferred suppliers and, through MetSkill, the industry has
put in place a range of regional and sub-sector workforce capability strategies which are significantly increasing take up of these
NVQs. Through these programmes, some 10,000 individuals have taken part in qualifications related programmes over the past five
years.
However, an ageing workforce means that the sector is losing employees faster than it is recruiting them; whilst flatter structures
and new working practices require recruits that are more capable than ever before. Recruitment is hampered by the reduced
number of available young people and public perception that the sector is in decline. Employers are concerned that education, at
18
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Implications for skills demand
school and university level, often fails to prepare or enthuse young people for careers in industry.
The current plethora of provision and education-industry initiatives confuses both employers and parents/young people, and
whilst there is much good content, has failed to impact on the sector’s needs. Meanwhile, there is an opportunity to build new links
with education as schools develop the 14-19 curriculum and higher education introduces new approaches such as Foundation
Degrees.
• is a strategic response to the sector’s need to attract and retain high quality new entrants
• builds on existing sector initiatives run by MetSkill and others and draws together the best education, careers and
apprenticeship/graduate training provision, nationally and regionally
• provides a ‘one stop shop’, reducing confusion for employers and young people.
In parallel with promotion of apprenticeships, the metals sector needs to raise its profile and image with young people, graduates
and post graduates if it is to attract sufficient high calibre entrants. Meanwhile, with fewer students, metals and metallurgy forms an
even smaller part of materials, architecture and other related degrees.
Smaller companies have embraced the new development routes for intermediate skilled jobs, such as Apprenticeships and National
Vocational Qualifications, but find recruitment and retention of graduates a problem. They have much to offer graduates seeking
leading-edge practical experience and responsibility at an early stage in their careers, but need increased help to plan development
programmes to ensure that their particular benefits are presented to as wide an audience of potential recruits as possible.
There is some developing interest in new progression routes and links between industry and academia to enable the most able
technicians and team leaders to obtain vocational degrees and other knowledge accreditation. To meet this need the industry,
through MetSkill, direct company links, and through relevant professional bodies, works with several universities and bodies, such
as City and Guilds and BTEC, to make in-service Masters and Foundation Degrees and other vocational awards available. Promotion
and take-up of these awards, however, remains a challenge.
19
Implications for skills demand Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
In addition to the ten key drivers in section 4.2 above, a number of skills gaps and shortages have been identified in specific parts
of the metals industry:
Steel
• Multi-skilling of operators
• Shortage of craft skills, particularly maintenance engineers and welders
• Shortage of metallurgists and metallurgy expertise
• Specialist skills in the welding and fabrication of stainless steel.
Aluminium
• Due to the diverse technology employed in the industry, companies have specific requirements that are not satisfied by
conventional college and university courses
• Specific industry training in fabrication technology and product knowledge
• Environment and energy management & shop floor expertise
• Sales and customer service.
Casting
• Specialist foundry skills
• Industry-specific multi-skilling of first line operatives and technicians
• Skills relating to sub-contract workforce.
Metalforming
• Selling skills for sales engineers and technicians
• Technical skills in metal forging and fastener manufacture
• Tool-making skills
• Relevant die design and press operator training
• Shortage of skilled electrical and mechanical maintenance engineers
• IT literacy in design, computer controlled manufacturing and e-commerce
• Multi-skilling in production.
20
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Implications for skills demand
Surface Engineering
• Application of standards based training
• Need for more industry specific provision, e.g. electroplating
• Awareness of e-business and electronic trading in the industry.
Galvanizing
• Technical skills training (e.g. latest hot dip galvanising techniques)
• ‘Top-up skills’ for Eastern European recruits .
Constructional Steelwork
• Craft skills shortages, particularly welding and plating
• Shortage of graduate engineers with knowledge of structural steelwork and/or for future management roles
• Shortage of 3D CAD design engineers and detailers, technicians and estimators
• Training and competence-based qualification for steel construction erectors to meet the construction industry’s Skills Card
Scheme requirements
• Multi-skilling and standardised training in erection and cladding skills.
Metal Packaging
• Multi-skilling of operators
• Skills in high-speed manufacturing, product handling, preventative maintenance, problem solving, and advanced metal
forming and finishing techniques
• IT capability.
Metals Recycling
• Only c. 10% of employees hold formal qualifications
• Higher levels of health & safety and environmental competence needed
• Understanding and implementing the compliance criteria for legislation and regulation, e.g. End of Life Vehicles and WEEE
directives
• Certificate of Technical Competence to meet Environment Agency requirements
• Negotiating skills for buyers and sellers of metal
• Standardised approach to driver and operator training
• Need to widen and strengthen individuals’ technical skills
• IT skills gaps at all levels
21
Current qualification levels Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
The 1995 and 2001 Labour Force Survey results, compared in the table below, show that there has been an improvement in
qualification achievement in the metals industries (SIC codes 27 & 28 only). By 2001, 7% more employees held relevant qualifications
and 5% more were qualified to NVQ Level 3. It is expected that, by 2006, the proportion of NVQ 3 qualified will have risen still
further.
Whilst the above data paints an increasingly positive picture, it should be noted that it excludes parts of the metals sector in which
qualification levels are extremely low, such as metals recycling. Considered as a whole, it is estimated that up to 40% of the total
workforce is unqualified.
Metals Sector
Occupational Group % 1999 Number 2010 % 2010 % Change % All Sectors
Corporate managers 10.4 46667 10.9 -18.5 8.3
Science/technical professional 3.3 16654 3.9 -7.8 28.2
Business/public service assoc. prof. 3.8 17969 4.2 -14.7 26.1
Admin & clerical 4.8 19352 4.5 -27.5 5.5
Skilled metal/electrical trades 24.6 102697 23.9 -24.4 -7.4
Skilled construction trades 6.7 26921 6.3 -27.1 -6.5
Process plant & machine operatives 13.7 57629 13.4 -23.7 -8.4
Transport drivers & operatives 7.1 31194 7.3 -20.0 2.4
Elementary: trades/plant/machinery 9.4 44210 10.3 -15.1 -2.2
Elementary: clerical/service 5.9 21653 5.0 -33.8 -5.7
All occupations 100 428827 100 -22.4 7.7
22
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Strategy to meet to skills demand
6.1 The strategy to meet the skills demand is summarised in the diagram below.
Engagement
of a wide range of metals industry leaders and
companies
Impact
Forward Thinking - sector influence
to identify business drivers and strategies for - company-level performance improvement
change - companies’ access to funding
- take-up and customer satisfaction
Industry Solutions
Resources
to meet strategic needs, building
best value for money provision, including
on international best practice and
high quality engineers who can lead change;
national standards [incl. qualifications &
funding; and new product development
frameworks]
23
Strategy to meet to skills demand Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
Ten ‘standardised’ business-oriented products and solutions to address the needs most frequently raised by employers have been
developed, drawing on world best practice and national occupational standards as appropriate. These have the twin aims of:
• volume impact - increasing take-up and reaching all parts of the sector
• quantifiable business benefits within individual participating companies.
Development of these industry solutions is underpinned by the sector’s national occupational standards and frameworks, including
NVQs, vocational qualifications, apprenticeship framework, graduate apprenticeship framework, foundation and high level degrees.
These qualifications and frameworks are developed with a very high level of employer involvement and are listed in Appendix 3.
The relationship between the industry solutions and the ten key drivers, described in Section 3, is set out in diagram form in
Appendix 1. The industry solutions are described in more detail in Section 7.1.
Since the Strategy was introduced in 2000, companies and 10,000 employees have benefited from skills and culture change
programmes, and these activities are saving the industry an estimated £20 million per year. Already, four companies report savings
exceeding £1million a year.
The results achieved through implementation of the above products between 2000-2005, and forecast for 2005-06, are shown in
the table below:
2000-2005 2005-2006
Companies using industry solutions 525 300
Participating employees 10,047 5,353
Qualifications achieved through these activities 3,352 2,476
Funding obtained to support companies £3.8m £2.3m
Financial benefits for companies (conservative estimate) £30m £20m
17 Newly developed in 2004-05 responding to industry needs. Programme to be launched in June/July 2005
24
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Action Plan
7 Action Plan
Industry solutions in response to Key Driver 1: adding value and eliminating waste
Recognising the critical importance of spreading awareness of lean principles and practice within the industry, MICE partners - UK
Steel, National Association of Steel Stockholders (NASS), Confederation of British Metalforming (CBM), MetSkill, the Non-Ferrous
Alliance (NFA), the Galvanizers Association (GA) and the Cast Metals Federation (CMF) - have been actively promoting MICE to their
member companies. Some of these organisations have run targeted MICE activities within their specific parts of the sector.
A range of value-adding products have been developed by MICE to meet the specific needs of metals sector companies. In particular,
the MICE Process Improvement Workshop and Supply Chain Improvement Programme have achieved impressive results.
In addition, a range of measurable Quality Cost and Delivery improvements have been recorded:
25
Action Plan Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
“One of the significant benefits of MICE, aside from the monetary savings, is that we now have a team with skills and knowledge
that are invaluable.”
Alan Gibson, Operations Director, Vald Birn
“Some of the benefits MICE has brought have been instant…but we predict the result of our year on year savings and increased
capacity will be much more significant.”
Richard Morley, Managing Director, Caparo Merchant Bar
Industry solutions in response to Key Driver 2: high quality engineers to lead change
Through MICE, companies have access to a team of highly trained and experienced improvement Engineers to help them target
improvement priorities and spearhead change across the workplace. During MICE activities companies are also able to identify
and develop their own engineers as ‘change agents’. Working alongside the MICE Engineers, the company engineers learn first-
hand the skills and techniques necessary to implement and sustain continuous improvement and change activities. By adopting
this approach, one year on over 90% of MICE companies report improvements that have been maintained or further enhanced.
In addition, NAMTEC (see below) is working with employers and other partners to increase the number of graduate and post-
graduate engineers entering the industry (see industry responses to Key Driver 10).
With the support of the DTI, Yorkshire Forward and Objective 1 (South Yorkshire), NAMTEC also provides knowledge transfer services,
including a telephone technical helpline and on-line information and technical databases.
NAMTEC’s ‘Metals Information for the 21st Century’ project, which is being developed in partnership with the Welding Institute,
the World Metals Index, the Institute of Materials and Granta Design, will provide metals companies with low cost, web-based
access to materials on engineering metals and welding consumables.
26
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Action Plan
The Metals Industry Middle Manager Programme has been developed this year specifically to address managers’ strategic and
behavioural skills. Led by a steering group of senior employers, the Middle Manager programme will provide a structured, modular
training programme covering the skills needs metals employers most need from their managers These include:
Managers on the programme also complete a project, and are assessed in the workplace to achieve a NVQ Level 4 qualification.
The development of the Middle Managers programme, including a pilot involving 30 managers from 4 companies that commenced
in June, has been financially supported by the Iron and Steel Industry Training (West Midlands) Trust. Funds from the Welsh Assembly
will help support the first 100 managers in Wales through the programme, which will commence in autumn 2005.
Both the Leadership and Teamwork programmes combine off-the-job training and in-company activities or project work with
workplace assessment leading to a full Metals Processing NVQ at Level 2 (Teamwork) or Level 3 (Leadership).
Between 2000 – 2005 the following results have been achieved through these programmes:
(*as at May 2005, remainder of candidates still on No. companies No. candidates NVQ completions*
programme)
27
Action Plan Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
“We’ve found the Leadership programme highly effective… as a result, the business now has increased options in areas such as
succession planning.”
Mick Hood, HR Manager, Corus Engineering Steels
“The Teamwork Programme has given our teamworkers relevant skills and qualifications and has helped us develop a new company-
wide attitude that has given us far greater flexibility and opportunities. Output per employee has increased, our teams now self-
manage their work, and absenteeism is cut by half.”
Steve Blount Works Manager, Parsons Chain
“Many of our employees had no formal qualifications and the sense of pride and motivation the teamwork development programme
has given them has been very rewarding.”
Lynne Humphries, HR Manager, Bridgnorth Aluminium
In addition to the Metals Industry Leadership and Teamwork programmes, MICE activities within companies are also succeeding in
involving the workforce and changing company culture.
In addition, a number of LearnDirect courses that are freely available to individuals have been identified as being of particular
relevance to common basic skills problems in metals companies. Companies contacting MetSkill for advice and guidance are also
signposted to the range of provision offered by Metals Industry Registered Providers (see Section 7.2).
28
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Action Plan
entering and leaving the industry. They contain development in generic skills useful in all work situations, such as communication,
working with others and problem solving.
• demonstrate that employees have achieved the recognised industry standard in health and safety
• improve individual employees’ capability to reduce the risk of accidents
• provide ongoing assessment against the Passport standard
• act as a stepping stone to further learning and qualifications.
The Passport programmes were developed in response to the priority business issues of spiralling Employers’ Liability insurance
and accident claim costs and increasingly stringent regulation, however they also set the standard for health and safety competence
within the industry and, as such, have become a “Trojan horse” to getting companies not previously engaged to invest in standards-
based training and NVQs.
Recognising the positive contribution made by the Passport programmes to raising standards of health and safety in the workplace
and helping with the wider issue of insurance premiums, Metals Forum trade associations have been actively promoting use of the
Passport to their member companies. In the case of NASS and the British Metals Recycling Association (BMRA), they have adopted
‘badged’ schemes to encourage take-up.
In April 2005 the Passport and Passport PLUS were awarded approval from the Royal Society for Prevention of Accidents (ROSPA).
Between 2002 and 2005 the following Passport results have been achieved:
(*as at May 005, remainder of candidates still on No. companies No. candidates NVQ completions*
programme)
29
Action Plan Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
“The Passport scheme has done exactly what we wanted it to do – changed attitudes and opened people’s eyes to their personal
responsibilities. The proof that it works? - 75% reduction in lost-time accidents.”
Eric Burgess, Health & Safety Manager, Sapa Profiles
“It is a constant battle to keep up with health and safety legislation. The Passport raises awareness and this means that our
employees can better contribute to their own safety and that of colleagues. It also helps them keep abreast of developments
through the requirements for re-accreditation.”
Jonathan Storer, HR Manager, Bekaert Fencing
“The Health & Safety Passport is an endorsement that gives us assurance that each of our operators are capable of working
consistently to the demanding safety standards of the metals industry.”
Terry McMahon, Operations Manager, J B & S Lees
Metals Academy
Metals Academy has been launched in 2005 to draw together, enhance and raise the profile of MetSkill’s education, careers,
apprenticeship and graduate activities.
A range of co-ordinated services is being developed at national and regional level, the latter built around a common model (see
below). In the pilot phase the regional focus is on apprenticeships and on two regions: South Yorkshire and the Black Country,
with national resources available more widely. It is planned that in future years the model will extend to graduates and other new
entrants and to other UK regions/nations.
Building on the best of what is already available, activities are designed to meet one or more of the following objectives:
• to generate interest and commitment amongst young people, pre and post recruitment
• to influence the education curriculum and ensure appropriate training is available
• to improve value for money and ease-of-access for employers
30
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Action Plan
Regional activities are being developed around a common model, piloting in South Yorkshire and the Black Country, and later to be
replicated elsewhere. There are four key strands:
1. Education/careers activities
• partnership and strategy developed with 3-6 schools in each region, to include
: structured work experience programme
: teacher placements in companies
: ‘ambassador’ visits to schools (using apprentice ambassadors)
: school visits to industry
• local press advertising and careers events; briefing for Connexions staff
to develop into Higher Education links
3. Training enhancements
• including lean manufacturing; health and safety passport
to develop for graduate entrants
Industry solutions in response to Key Driver 10: quality and availability of metallurgists and engineers
NAMTEC’s objectives include to increase the number of graduate and post-graduate metallurgists and engineers entering
the industry, for example, through developing new Foundation Degrees, sector specific higher degrees and a new metals and
manufacturing Doctorate programme in conjunction with the two Sheffield universities. It also seeks to provide additional training
of the current graduate workforce, and provide bespoke technical training packages that complement the existing metals industry
leadership, teamwork, health and safety passport and MICE process and supply chain improvement programmes.
Flexible programmes providing ‘Metallurgy for the Non-Metallurgist’ are also available when companies need to train non-
technical employees in basic metallurgy so that they can better understand the industry and the processes employed in making
the products their business produces.
31
Action Plan Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
Collaborative action
Working through MetSkill and in partnership with other sector bodies, employers have come together regionally and nationally to
devise largescale projects based on the drivers and industry solutions featured in this Strategy. This has resulted in metals sector
programmes in the last five years linked, for example, to teamwork skills, leadership development, process improvement and supply
chain work. Over 500 companies and 10,000 employees have participated since 2000 (see Section 6).
Funding
The collaborative approach described above has involved working with a variety of public sector bodies where common ground
between sector needs and government/community priorities has been identified. Over the past five years funding has been
secured from bodies such as the Learning and Skills Council, Manufacturing Advisory Service, ELWa, Scottish Executive, Advantage
West Midlands and Yorkshire Forward RDAs. The Iron and Steel Industry Training (West Midlands) Trust has also supported the
strategy financially over a number of years.
• difficulty in meeting employer needs when sector priorities do not match with regional priorities
• confusion over the plethora of different funding regimes
• employers turned off by bureaucracy and wasted resources
• funding streams which favour college-based learning
• the lack of funding for training in the workplace at Levels 3, 4 and above
32
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Action Plan
• Implementation of the Tomlinson Working Group recommendations on 14-19 reform, in particular concerning better and
equally funded vocational education routes and the move to specialised Diplomas led by employers through Sector Skills
Councils.
• Sector strategies to drive regional spending through closer collaboration between Sector Skills Councils, RDAs and LSCs
• Regional funding opportunities for employers published centrally in a single, common format
• Introduction of a single national quality assurance register for all training providers and consultants
• National support for sector strategies that address management skills development. [More support for Level 3 and Level
4 programmes would have far greater strategic impact within the sector than the mainly basic skills, entry to employment
or Level 2 initiatives available locally].
33
Appendices Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
Adding value and eliminating waste MICE Process Improvement Workshop, Supply Chain Improvement
Programme, Strategic Policy Deployment and Management Lean Awareness
Workshops
Skill levels and flexibility Metals Industry Health and Safety Passport & Passport PLUS
[industry standard including NVQ Level 2 Level 3 unit]
34
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Appendices
35
Appendices Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
36
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Appendices
Sub-sector Specific skills strategies already in place to meet the needs of the metals sub-sector
[in addition to the sector-wide strategies outlined in Sections 6-8]
Steel • UK Steel schools packs and interactive websites
• ILSAP (run by the International Iron & Steel Association and Liverpool University) online learning aids for steel applications, processes and metal-
lurgy
• Professional development programme for school head teachers sponsored by Corus
• British Stainless Steel Association:
- Stainless Steel Specialists Course
- CPD training modules for architects
• IOM3 distance learning package on heat treatment of steels
• Worshipful Company of Tin Plate Alias Wire Workers educational activities, sponsorship and awards for students, graduates, apprentices and
others
• UK Steel: MICE partner.
Aluminium • AluMATTER (run by the European Aluminium Association and Liverpool University) web-based learning tools for aluminium science and tech-
nology
• Aluminium Federation (ALFED) CDROM training packages in aluminium technologies for schools /colleges and in-company/shopfloor use
• ALFED: MICE partner.
Other Non- • Non-Ferrous Alliance educational CDROM “The Magic of Metals” for 14 to 16 year olds and secondary education website.
Ferrous Metals
Casting • The Founders’ Company Bursary scheme for under-graduates taking placements in foundries
• Institute of Cast Metal Engineers (ICME) college courses, CPD programme and professional membership, careers leaflets
• Cast Metals Federation (CMF) educational CDROM on investment casting (in development)
• Casting Skills Centre (part of CTI) courses and distance learning inc. casting design, quality and testing, melting, moulding and coremaking, ICT,
methods engineering and metallurgy
• CMF: MICE partner
Metalforming • Confederation of British Metalforming (CBM) Technology transfer software on simulation
• CBM: MICE partner.
Treatment, • Institute of Metal Finishing distance learning modules certificates, diplomas and courses on a range of surface finishing technologies
Coating & • IOM3 distance learning package on heat treatment of steels
Finishing • Galvanizers Association (GA) courses in hot dip galvanising health and safety (run by ROSPA) technical skills for operators and sales skills
• GA resource materials on galvanizing for students and lecturers
• GA: MICE partner.
Metal • Worshipful Company of Tin Plate Alias Wire Workers educational activities, sponsorship and awards for students, graduates, apprentices and
Packaging others
• Metal Packaging Manufacturers’ Association guidelines for the design and manufacture of metal cans
• Metal packaging industry design awards.
Constructional • Route for steelwork erectors under the CITB Construction Skills Certification Scheme (requires Constructional Steelwork Site Operations NVQ
Steelwork Level 2)
• British Constructional Steelwork Association (BCSA) management seminars, e.g. on EL insurance/legislation
• Principles of Steelwork Detailing CDROM – essential underpinning knowledge for trainee design detailers
• Steel Construction Institute:
- SteelCAL software for architechts and engineers
- Training courses, educational CDROMs and CPD programmes, including design of buildings and bridges, British Standards, Eurocodes fire, and
welding for structural engineers.
Service Centres & • National Association of Steel Stockholders (NASS) badged Steel Stockholding Health and Safety Passport PLUS programme
Distribution • NASS sales training courses
• NASS “Team Challenge” competition
• NASS: MICE partner.
Metals • British Metals Recycling Association (BMRA) badged Metals Recycling Health & Safety Passport & Passport PLUS programmes
Recycling • Certificate of Technical Competence to meet environmental standards for site managers
• BMRA training courses in environmental management systems, radiation safety awareness and plant operator training
• Senior Executive health & safety/environmental management seminars
• Metals recycling publications and information for schools available via BMRA website.
Engineered Metal • Metalforming, casting and surface engineering activities as detailed above
Products • The Welding Institute (TWI) Diploma and courses in welding technology, NDT, materials performance, joining technology and practical welder
training
• Association for Welding and Fabrication Training & Education – network of welding professionals in education and training
• Cranfield University Welding Engineering Resource Centre.
37
Appendices Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
The activity commenced in November 2003 and, on completion in March 2004, savings of up to £270,000 per year had been
identified. These came about from factors ranging from reduced refractory-caused breakdowns, to lower heat loss. In addition,
planned improvements should bring £811,000 savings per year through increased output. Implementing all the changes will take
four years, but Corus has already moved a significant way through its action plan and the benefits are already beginning to be
achieved.
“The pilot proves that there are vastly significant gains to be made through supply chain thinking that no business can afford to
ignore. Through the experience and expertise MICE brought to the project, we are now in a position to net savings of in excess of
£1million each year within the Plate Mill – a major benefit to us - and we recognise the potential to apply these principles to all our
supplier and customer relationships.”
Andrew Page, Managing Director, Corus Construction & Industrial
“The new ‘challenge everything and accept nothing’ approach has been a turnaround in our culture. Previously people just accepted
problems and put up with them! For me, one of the most significant benefits is not the obvious monetary savings, but the fact that
we now have a team with skills and techniques that are invaluable. The comment made by our TS 16949 assessor that we had one
of the most informed and committed workforces that he had seen is testimony to this.”
Alan Gibson, Director, Vald Birn
Leadership Development
Cold Drawn Products (CDP) has produced flat and shaped wire at its two rural sites in West Yorkshire for 50 years. During that time
the company has changed considerably, but future demands on the business meant that a step-change in company culture was
needed to continue to keep pace with competition. The concept of teamworking had been in place in the company for some time,
but a further push was needed. The first step was to appoint and develop team leaders who could enable change to take place and
embed a greater teamworking competence. The Metals Industry Leadership Development Programme provided the framework
to make this happen.
“Nine of our team leaders agreed to join the programme. Each had been doing much the same job for years, so this was a fairly
major step for them. The Programme helped them to understand what we needed to achieve as a business and, therefore, the
types of skills we need them to be competent in. They are now much more ‘in sync’ with what we are trying to achieve and are
38
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Appendices
more engaged within the business. The move to self-managed teams is a long and complex process, but we are now well along
the path.”
Steve Booth, Manufacturing Director, Cold Drawn Products
Teamwork Skills
Novelis Can Recycling in Warrington (formerly Alcan Aluminium Can Recycling) was looking for a way of developing a behavioural
system to underpin its well-established health and safety management system, coupled with a way of structuring training and
providing accreditation for employee competence. Hence, in March 2004, the majprity of the workforce – 81 teamworkers -
embarked on the Metals Industry Teamwork Development Programme. On enrolment, most had no previous qualifications.
Nine months later, however, they had achieved a level 2 NVQ and an additional environmental unit delivered to fit Novelis’ specific
needs.
“The Teamwork Programme formalises the fact that we have trained and assessed people’s occupational competence against the
recognised standards The programme also leads to employees achieving the Metals Industry Health & Safety Passport. Give that all
the latest health and safety legislation points towards competency, the fact that each employee holds a Passport certificate saying
that ‘yes, they are competent’, is very important for us.”
Ged Wright, Safety and Training Manager, Novelis Can Recycling
In 1999 PWS Group was taken over by international steel group, Arcelor. Since then, the company has almost completely refocused
its operation to serve the UK automotive client-base. As well as investing in new technology, the turnaround also involved retraining
every one of their employees to operate the new equipment. Passport training was introduced phase-by phase across each team
to develop the on-the-job competence and knowledge of every employee. New signage was installed throughout the factory, and
a bonus-scheme was introduced to encourage shared responsibility for safety. The result has been zero accidents with no time lost
in the last 11 months.
“The greatest difference is the change in attitudes. We were hoping for a big culture change in health and safety and I believe
we have achieved this. People can too easily shirk responsibility for health and safety and pass it on to the Health and Safety
Representative. The Passport has given them the know-how and competence to not only follow safety procedures rigorously, but
also to take the initiative to reduce risks, isolate hazards and do something about them.”
Bob Onions, Operations Manager, Willenhall Steels, Perry Willenhall Steel Service Centres
Metals Academy
Metsec plc, manufacturer of cold rolled sections for the construction industry at Oldbury in the West Midlands, uses the Metals
Academy to recruit apprentices and offer them an enhanced level of development. Recently, for instance, Metsec production,
design and engineering apprentices have participated in lean awareness training conducted by a MICE Engineer, and further
learning activities, over and above those included within a standard apprenticeship programme, are planned for the future. As a
result of this investment, apprentice retention rates are higher than employees recruited via other routes, with 72% of apprentices
staying with the company for more than 10 years.
39
Appendices Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
40
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Appendices
Scotland
4% employees
7% businesses
North East
6% employees
Northern Ireland 2% businesses
1% employees
2% businesses
East Midlands
8% employees
7% businesses
West Midlands
Wales 25% employees
6% employees 19% businesses East of England
4% businesses 5% employees
9% businesses
41
Appendices Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
42
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Appendices
Employer focus groups involved in strategy consultation: September 2004 – April 2005
Galvanizers Association
David Baron General Manager Galvanizers Association
Robert Duxbury Director of Process Wedge Group Galvanizing
Robert Evans Managing Director Cardiff Galvanizing (1969)
Niels Pedersen Marketing Manager - Zinc Boliden Zinc Commercial
Phil Roberts Marketing Director Medway Galvanising Co
Bernard Shanley Managing Director Galco Steel
MetSkill Board
Jon Bolton Managing Director Corus Rail
George Bond Director H Williams & Sons
Andrew Herman Director, Manufacturing Corus Strip Products UK
Kate Kendall Director, Human Resources Siddall & Hilton
Kevin Mansell Managing Director Bekaert Fencing
Richard Morley Managing Director Caparo Merchant Bar
Andrew Page Managing Director Corus Construction and Industrial
Ian Rodgers Director UK Steel
Steve Rutherford Managing Director Bridon International
Peter Scarff Managing Director Perry Willenhall Steel Service Centres
Sue Sharples Financial Director Barrett Steel Buildings
Tarlok Singh Managing Director UK Operations Niagara La Salle UK
John Tildesley Works Director WH Tildesley
Stephen Tilsley Managing Director Metsec plc
Ian Young Managing Director Archibald Young
43
Appendices Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
Appendix 7 continued
UK Steel
Tony Bagshawe
Guy Glover Managing Director Corus Tubes
Peter Holes Director Outokumpu Stainless
Nigel Lane Managing Director Cold Drawn Products
Graham Mackenzie Corporate Advisor CELSA Steel (UK)
Steve Mackrell Operations Manager ISSB
Geoff Marston Business Development Director Sheffield Forgemasters Engineering
Keith Negal Managing Director UNSCO
Duncan Pell Commercial Director Corus
Ian Rodgers Director UK Steel
Steve Rutherford Managing Director The Bridon Group
Mike Thomas Managing Director Tyco European Tubing
Wales
Paul Brabben Managing Director South Wales Forgemasters
Martin Davies Training Manager Inco Europe
Andrew Herman Director, Manufacturing Corus Strip Products
Mark Irwin People Development Manager Corus Strip Products
Andrew Jarvis Managing Director Caparo Tubes
Graham Mackenzie Corporate Advisor Celsa
Russell McCafferty Hot Line Section Leader Novelis Rolled Products
Lesley Morgan Training & Development Officer Cogent Power
Peter Rose Manager, Personnel Services Cogent Power
Chris Selby HR Manager Celsa
44
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Appendices
Aluminium Federation
David Beale Chairman Seco Aluminium
Joan Chesney Communications British Alcan Aluminium
John Cutler Director/General Manager Bridgnorth Aluminium
Henry Dickinson Managing Director Norton Aluminium Products
David Harris Secretary General Aluminium Federation
Iain Mackay Managing Director Adams Rite Europe
Paul Martin Managing Director Alupro Ltd
Terry Martin Assistant Director DTI
Andrew McLoughlin Plant Manager Hydro Aluminium
Jim Morrison General Manager Bernhard Metals
Mark Westwell Operations Director Wolstenholme International
45
Appendices Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005
Appendix 7 continued
46
Metals Sector Skills & Performance Strategy 2005 Appendices
Additional consultation:
NAMTEC discussions with Alan Partridge, Director (November)
IoM3 meeting with Bernie Rickinson (November)
ICME information from Symposum on Vocational Education (November)
Special Steels information from Special Steels Group meeting – Chair; Tony Pedder (December)
South Yorkshire information from EEF South Yorkshire Skills Broker Initiative (January)
EEF/SEMTA information from Education & Skills Strategy Group Away Day (January) and from SEMTA SSAs.
Engineered Products information from SEMTA Engineered Metals Products Group (February)
Materials IGT discussion on future skill needs and recruitment/training of materials specialists (January)
The Metals Forum is an alliance of metals industries employing nearly half a million people in businesses working in virtually
every UK town and city. Each year these businesses supply £38 billion of metals from the UK into the engineering, construction,
automotive, aerospace and other manufacturing sectors (see Section 2).
The Metals Forum comprises the leading ferrous and non-ferrous trade associations and Metskill as listed above. Through the
Forum members gain access to a wider supply chain perspective on policy, economic and commercial topics that confront each
industry.
Rupert Hodges
c/o Headroom Communications
18 Tudor Road
Beckenham
BR3 6QR
47
For more information about this strategy please contact: