Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Original Russian Text © V.V. Krasnova, V.M. Bel’kovich, A.D. Chernetsky, 2006, published in Izvestiya Akademii Nauk, Seriya Biologicheskaya, 2006, No. 1, pp. 63–69.
ZOOLOGY
Abstract—Elements of behavior under natural conditions, their duration, and frequency are described in three
age groups of belugas calves: newborn, one-month-old, and two-month-old. The quantitative and qualitative
indices of the recognized behavioral elements allowed us to evaluate the mother–infant contacts and to analyze
their dynamics during calf growth. The most common calf positions relative to the mother during this period
were “at the cow’s tail” and “at the cow’s side.” The importance of behavioral responses of calf for the devel-
opment of social behavior in adult animals is emphasized.
DOI: 10.1134/S1062359006010079
Beluga is one of the most typical representatives of opinions and speculations. This is primarily due to the
Arctic marine mammals. The initial interest to beluga difficulties of material collection, observation tech-
was provoked by its large-scale fishery. As a result, fish- niques, and data processing. Nearly all research on the
ery aspects of their distribution, abundance, and migra- subject was carried out in dolphinaria (Bondarchuk
tion were covered in numerous publications in 1950s– et al., 1976; Bliznyuk and Dzhincharadze, 1978; Voro-
1970s. As beluga fishery was discontinued, the interest nin et al., 1978; Tomilin and Bliznyuk, 1979; Kara-
to its research diminished. Recent decade revived the bashyan et al., 1982; Reid et al., 1995; Gubbins et al.,
interest to beluga as a unique mammalian species with 1999; Chechina, 2004). Studies under natural condi-
behavioral and morphological adaptations to life in the tions are usually limited to bottlenose dolphin (Tursi-
Arctic Seas. ops truncatus) (Richards, 1966; Mann and Smuts,
1998, 1999).
It is common knowledge that social behavior of
mammals is formed from innate and acquired behav- The goal of this work was to study the mother–
ioral patterns, while specific development of behavioral infant relations during the first months of calf life and
responses during early development determine social to trace its dynamics.
behavior of adult animals (Menning, 1982). Beluga
calves remain with the mother for three or more years. MATERIALS AND METHODS
A long period of nursing and great mother–infant
attachment are important factors of calf survival and its Observations were carried out in the White Sea near
timely adaptation to aquatic environment. The mother– the Beluzhii Cape of the Solovetskii Island in the breed-
infant relations maintained for several years allow them ing ground of belugas in June–August 2001 from an
to form communities of cows and juveniles. Males at 11 m wooden tower at the littoral boundary. This breed-
the age of 4–5 years leave the maternal school and ing ground is uniquely close to the observation point,
come back only during the breeding season. Cows keep which allowed detailed monitoring of the mother–
to the maternal school during their whole life (Kleinen- infant relations. The studied water area was divided
berg et al., 1964; Bel’kovich and Yablokov, 1965; into four zones with stable animal concentration
Yablokov et al., 1972). Hence, studies of parental (Bel’kovich et al., 2002).
behavior, particularly, the mother–infant spatial inter- Cows with calves of different age were monitored.
actions and their quantitative and qualitative descrip- Three age groups of calves were recognized by the size,
tion are important to understand the role of intraspecific color, other appearance distinctions, breath-holding
contacts determining their population ecology and time, and their combination (Table 1). These characters
social structure. insignificantly varied within the norm.
The mother–infant relations in dolphins are a com- The attachment to mother was confirmed by the calf
pound complex of behavioral elements, the nature and position relative to mother at different developmental
biological significance of which are subject of different stages and by the pattern of their locomotor activity.
53
54 KRASNOVA et al.
The following calf positions were recognized: (1) “near mother and usually keeps at the cow’s side or tail. No
the cow,” at a distance of no more than 1.5 m from it; observations were carried out under unfavorable
(2) “at a distance from the cow,” from 1.5 to 5 m pro- weather conditions (rain, strong wind, or fog). Under-
viding there was only one calf. Cases when a calf was water recordings from a video camera installed in the
more than 5 m away from the mother and swimming site most visited by belugas were also used in the anal-
with other school numbers were considered as a “group ysis.
behavior.” In total, 11 elements of calf behavior were Within 177 h observations, 1959 behavioral
recognized (Fig. 1). responses were recorded including 581, 475, and 903
We used the methods of total record-keeping, obser- records for newborns, one-, and two-month-old calves,
vation of individual animals and animal groups (focal respectively.
observations), and recording of individual behavioral
responses (Popov and Il’chenko, 1990). Animals were RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
identified by clearly visible long-term markers (Cher-
netsky and Krasnova, 2001). The markers of cows When observation started, the school included dark
allowed us to recognize their calves in a school and to gray yearlings (half size of adult), apparently, born in
monitor their development. The duration and frequency April or May. The first newborn was recorded on July
of behavioral elements as well as proportions between 10; next two were born on July 16; the total number of
them were recorded for each calf age group. During newborns was eight. The last newborn appeared on
total record keeping and focal observation, the behavior August 14. This confirms an extended period of birth in
of the first, second, third, etc. calves of identified cows belugas proposed previously (Kleinenberg et al.,
were recorded. Behavioral responses of calves were 1964). The total number of yearlings in the Solovetskii
only recorded in the absence of stress and anthropo- breeding ground of belugas was around 30.
genic impacts. In danger, belugas demonstrate the fol- Development of motor activity in newborns. Starting
lowing behavioral strategy: a calf is covered by the from birth, newborns permanently follow their mother,
which is one of the most important adaptations—the
behavior of the mother following (Tomilin and
Table 2. Frequency of behavioral elements in each age group Bliznyuk, 1979). The behavior of a mother with a new-
of calves, %
born features swimming close to the water surface,
Calf groups which facilitates the calf’s respiration. The calf move-
Behavioral element
ments are poorly coordinated yet and all behavioral
one- two-month- responses are short-term. The movements are hasty,
newborn
month-old old wasteful, and imperfect. The position relative to the
At the cow’s side 44.8 24 26 mother often changes. In the first days after birth, a calf
is most commonly at the cow’s side or tail (Table 2).
On the cow’s back 10 8 14 Apparently, this position is the most beneficial for the
On the cow’s tail 3 3 5 calf and allows it to overcome water resistance. The
Ahead of the cow 4 7 8 longest stable periods of newborns are at the cow’s side
Above the cow 9 3 3 (2 to 35 s). Movements requiring high coordination and
strength are avoided or very short-term (1 to 4 s). These
Below the cow 0.3 1 2 include riding on the cow’s back or tail favorite among
Behind the cow 0.9 2 3 older calves. One- and two-day-old calves could neither
At a distance from the cow 8 12 6 climb on the mother’s back nor stay on her caudal
At the cow’s belly 1 3 4 peduncle, particularly, in movement. At the same time,
short-term attempts to climb on the back (2 to 13 s) and
At the cow’s tail 17 34 22 tail (1 s) were recorded. The behavioral repertoire of
At the cow’s head 2 3 7 newborns includes nearly no elements when a calf is
Fig. 1. Schematic behavioral elements of beluga calf in spatial interactions with the cow.
inaccessible or uncontrollable by the cow, such as single feeding his 4–6 s (behavioral pattern “at the
behavioral patterns “behind the cow” or “away from the cow’s belly”).
cow.”
On day 4, mother allows a calf to swim at a distance
The data on the duration and frequency of feeding in of 2–3 m but only under safe conditions, e.g., surrounded
beluga available to date were obtained in oceanaria by other cows and calves and in the absence of males and
(Russell et al., 1997). We have obtained original data active gray juveniles. On day 7, calves reliably stay on
on beluga calf feeding using underwater video camera. the mother’s back (up to 12 s) and tail (up to 17 s).
Feeding is preceded by the food-begging behavior of a
calf manifested as tight physical contacts. A calf leans The behavior of calves becomes more complex as
upon the mother’s tail and rubs against her sides and they physically grow and develop; they become more
back. Such behavior can last up to 59 s, after which they independent. Nevertheless, the positions “at the cow’s
dive. Feeding always occurs underwater; a calf is at the side” and “at the cow’s tail” still prevail. The proportion
mother’s belly at an angle of 90 or 45°. The duration of of these patterns in the total duration of recognized
back of cows. The cows patiently accepted such behav- swim at a distance from the cow on average for 12.67 s.
ior. At the same time, we observed a 4-day-old calf swim-
Motor activity of two-month-old calves. The most ming at a distance of 4 m from the cow for 28 s; on July
frequent behavioral elements of one-month-old calves 20, a 10-day-old calf was observed separate from the
were observed at a similar or slightly lower frequency cow for 48 s. The mean duration of the one-month-old
in two-month-old ones (Table 2). They need no more calf position “at the cow’s tail” was 13.29 s; however, a
mother’s help for swimming. The behavioral element calf of this age retained this position for 70 s on July 8.
“at the cow’s side,” which was extremely important for Apparently, such individual peculiarities depend on the
newborns, is notably less common in two-month-old calf physical state as well as on the behavior of the
calves (Fig. 2c). They become more independent at this mother and the whole animal group, which requires
age. In this context, the behavior with limited mother’s special investigation.
care becomes more frequent. For instance, swimming The unique breeding ground of beluga in the White
ahead of the cow occurs by 4 and 1% more frequent Sea near the Beluzhii Cape of the Solovetskii Island
compared to newborns and one-month-old calves. Two- made possible the first investigation of their parental
month-old calves appear behind the mother by 2.1 and behavior, particularly, the spatial mother–infant rela-
1% more frequently, respectively. The duration of their tions under natural environmental conditions. The
stay away from the mother increases. For instance, on revealed behavioral patterns of newborn belugas under
July 7 we observed a two-month-old calf swimming far natural conditions such as high motor activity and
from the mother for 45 min. The breath-holding time short-term behavioral elements conflict the observa-
increased as calves developed (Table 1), which can tions in captivity. For instance, Schneider et al. (2003)
explain the increasing frequency and duration of their observed low motor activity of two newborn belugas
stay under the cow (0.3, 1, and 2% in newborn, one-, within the first week in a Canadian oceanarium: they
and two-month-old calves, respectively). Despite their were quiescent for up to 80% of total observation time.
independence, yearlings spend a lot of time on the Clearly, this was directly due to their living conditions
mother’s back (9.03%) and tail (2.94%). These posi- or physical state. High motor activity in the sea can be
tions can represent behavioral elements of rest or game. required in strong current conditions, while the absence
Sometimes two-month-old calves “rode” on the back of of current in an oceanarium makes calf locomotion
gray juvenile belugas (July 14). unnecessary.
It is of interest that the frequency of behavioral ele- The obtained data demonstrate a decreasing dura-
ment “at the cow’s head” increased with calf age. In this tion of calf staying with the mother as it grows, which
case, a calf at the mother’s head leans against it or is typical for the general behavioral strategy of all
jumps out of water nearby as though attracting her mammals. This corresponds to the increasing index of
attention. For instance, the frequency of this element behavioral element “at a distance from the cow” and to
was 2, 3, and 7% in newborn, one-, and two-month-old the decreasing behavioral element “at the cow’s side”
calves, respectively. In dolphins, physical contacts in as calf grows (Fig. 1) as well as to the formation of their
the form of touching or rubbing are typical manifesta- short- and long-term game groups. While playing with
tions of social activity. The head region is preferred for other animals of the school, calves learn to recognize
such contacts (Mann and Smuts, 1999). During hierar- their responses and environmental stimuli, which allow
chical behavior, dolphins use force interactions; e.g., them to timely notice and respond to danger or changed
they collide at high speed trying to submerge a compet- behavior of a neighbor. Calves contacting with each
itor, try to toss up a competitor, etc. (Pryor, 1975). In other acquire and share game and orientation skills
addition, belugas demonstrate “butting” hierarchical (Baskin, 1976; Voronin et al., 1978; Karabashyan
behavior when animals collide with their heads trying et al., 1982).
to push away a competitor. Social activity increases All age groups of calves demonstrated the predomi-
with calf age; it more imitates the adult behavior and nance of two behavioral elements in the interaction
the frequency of this behavioral element accordingly with the mother: “at the mother’s side” and “at the
increases. mother’s tail.” These elements seem to have an adaptive
As previously, calves spend most of their time near significance during the most critical postnatal period of
mothers; however, at the sight of other yearlings a calf their development, promote swimming, and favor their
usually joins them. For instance, on July 17 a cow with survival. The decreasing duration of these behavioral
a calf lay quiescently aside from other animals for elements in two-month-old calves can reflect a
40 min. When two swimming yearlings approached, decreased capacity of a cow to “carry” a calf in her flow
the calf joined them, while the mother remained where field due to its growth and independence. The swim-
she was. ming skills of calves improve at the same time (Cock-
Note that all described general trends in calf behav- roft and Ross, 1990).
ior do not exclude pronounced individual distinctions We believe that the data obtained shed new light to
in both the frequency and duration of particular behav- the spatial mother–infant relations in belugas under nat-
ioral elements. According to our data, newborns could ural environmental conditions.