Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
SUBMITTED BY
A.J MOSES - B090482ME CHAITHANYA RAMKUMAR V - B090476ME ARUN VIJAYAN - B090514ME ANSU U - B090346ME AKHIL P.A - B090413ME
INTRODUCTION
Rivers are Indias lifeline and enjoy a special place in prayers and its traditional practices. Many forms of aquatic flora and fauna are sustained by rivers. However, its sheer utility is leading to its own downfall. Rivers are increasingly being linked to several social, environmental, and political issues. It is observed that the removal of sand from the riverbeds has exceeded the natural replenishment, making it unsustainable. Demand for sand is very high in some states like Kerala due to increasing construction demands. Mining has eroded riverbanks, lowered river channels and also weakened engineering structures like bridges. The rivers of Kerala have considerably influenced its historical and cultural development of the people of Kerala. They influence in one way or other the history and cultural life of the people of Kerala. Several places of historical and cultural importance are located on the banks of the rivers. In nature, sand occurs as river channel and floodplain deposits, fluvio-glacial deposits, aeolian (wind) deposits, lake deposits and nearshore-marine deposits. Among these sources, sand from rivers is largely being used over the years for meeting its demand in construction industry. As a result of overexploitation, river sand in Kerala is in short supply and the construction industry finds difficulty in achieving targets. This warrants the imminent need for alternatives to river sand to bridge the gap between demand and supply. It is imminent that measures are to be taken to minimize the use of sand by adopting technologies with low sand/no sand content in construction sector.
Rivers, being very dynamic, are subjected to changes when the variables that shape and maintain their morphological form are altered. The variables include velocity, slope, width, depth, discharge, size and composition of sediments, and their concentration. Sediment is an essential, integral and dynamic part of river basins. The stability of rivers is the outcome of a delicate balance existing among stream flow, sediment supply from
catchments, stream channel form and other physicochemical and biological processes operating within the river system. Stream channels transport sediments and water from headwaters to river mouth, systematically depositing and eroding, abrading and breaking sediment particles during the transport process. River sediments include various size grades of particles including such as boulders, cobbles, pebbles, granules to finer sands, silts and clays. Generally high density particles concentrate in low order or upstream part and the finer particles progressively deposit towards the downstream according to the sediment sorting capacities of the river. So, in general gravel- sized particles are more abundant in the middle reaches of river systems, while sand-sized and smaller grains predominate in the lower reaches. River sand is one of the important ingredients in construction sector. River sand is a non renewable natural resource in terms of human life. Whatever replenishment occurs in the lowland part of rivers is derived mainly from the reworking of older floodplain deposits evolved through a process that take thousands of years. Excessive mining has adversely affected the general public, who depend on rivers as a basic necessity. The sand is extracted either directly from the active channels or from floodplain areas and the former is known as instream mining and the latter as flood plain mining .
studied along with changes in river flow and cross-sections. Correlation of these results with the systems behaviour is attempted. This identifies with the morphological and environmental impacts of this ongoing activity and cautions for a scientific approach to the issue. It invites attention of policy makers for an integrated and planned approach to river management and also suggests reviewing ownership of water resources, policy and administration. It also proposes governance systems meeting current needs from an environmentally safe angle. The indiscriminate and unscientific sand mining, has become a serious environmental threat to the river systems of Kerala. Environmental destruction is the price mankind has to pay for unsustainable development. Alarming increase in indiscriminate sand mining has caused serious damage to the river system of Kerala. As the demand for sand increases in industry and construction, leads to indiscriminate mining of sand from the rivers. Unlike the other rivers of India, the rivers of Kerala are too small in size and in resource capability. The quantum of sand mined every year is several fold more than what flows down and accumulate in the riverbeds. This situation creates a serious environmental threat to the riverine system. On the other hand sand is an essential construction material and it gives employment to a large sector in our state. So the complete banning of sand mining is not a practicable solution to this multidisciplinary problem. A balanced amount of sand mining enables the river to maintain its stability.
listed below. Even though the process being destructive, some kind of control reined on the process may help to prevent some potential disasters from occurring.
Negative Impacts
Taking into consideration the places of occurrences of the adverse environmental impacts of river sand mining, the impacts can be broadly classified into two categories namely Off- site impacts and On-site impacts. The off-site impacts are, primarily, transport related, whereas, the onsite impacts are generally channel related .The On- site impacts are classified into excavation impacts and water supply impacts. The impacts associated with excavation are channel bed lowering, migration of excavated pits and undermining of structures, bank collapse, caving, bank erosion and valley widening and channel instability. The impacts on water supply are reduced ground water recharge to local aquifers, reduction in storage of water for people and livestock especially during drought periods, contamination of water by oil, gasoline and conflicts between miners and local communities. The reports show that depletion of sand in the streambed and along coastal areas causes the deepening of rivers and estuaries, and the enlargement of river mouths and coastal inlets. It may also lead to saline-water intrusion from the nearby sea. Thus instream sand mining results in the destruction of aquatic and riparian habitat through large changes in the channel morphology. Impacts include bed degradation, bed coarsening, lowered water tables near the streambed, and channel instability.
Positive Impacts
Sand deposition eventually leads to reduction in conveyance capacity of river leading to flood in rivers. Proper dredging of sand keeps the bed at the desired level. Thus if dredging is not done, due to continuous deposition of
sand, the depth of river may get reduced. This will result in flooding of water and loss of properties. It also facilitates the navigation in the channel as sand is the main fine aggregate in concrete. Riverbeds are major sources of clean sand. An investigation conducted by CESS made it clear that it is very evident that there is a change in traditional housing of People of Kerala. It is observed that the demand of sand for house construction has been increased drastically since early 1970s which is reflected well in exponential rise in the number of terraced and tiled houses.
Geology Department of the Government of Kerala, credit to the River Management fund and income to the local body are all collectively decided by a District Level Expert Committee with the District Collector as the Chairman. The charge levied for a standard lorry load of sand at the kadavu is 10000 Rupees.
STUDY AREA
We selected Arakunnu, one of the prominent mining sites in the course of River Neyyar as our area of study. The Neyyar River is the southern-most river of Kerala State. It emerges from Agastya hills at about 1865m above MSL and debouches into Arabian Sea after flowing a distance of 56 Km. The Neyyar River basin lies between 8o 15 to 8o 40 N latitudes and 77o00 to 77o20 E longitude in Thiruvananthapuram District. The basin has a total area of 483 sq. km covering 24 panchayats. The main tributaries of the Neyyar are Chit Ar, Kall Ar, Karavali Ar, Mull Ar, Aruvikod Thodu, Maruthur Thodu, Edamalai Thodu and Talakke thodu. The basin receives an average annual rainfall of 1542 mm. Physiographically, the river basin can be divided into midlands (8-75m) and lowlands(less than 8m) ;( CESS, 1984). The Neyyar river basin mainly comprises of three different lithological units, i.e. Archaean formation in the Upper region, the Archaean formation except quartzite of khondalite group in the Middle region and coastal sand and alluvium, sandstone and clay with lignite intercalation of Warkalli (Varkala) formation and quartz feldspar hypersthene granulite, charnockitic gneiss and hypersthene diopside gneiss of charnockite group in the Lower region. The area experiences tropical humid climate
with an average annual rainfall of about 3300mm.The temperature varies from 200c to 390 C. Humidity is high (more than 80%) during the monsoon period. The map showing the Neyyar River Basin is given below.
METHODOLOGY
The location of the sand mining sites are located through the google maps imagery. Primary and secondary data available are collected and they are used as references for making the required data regarding the problem. One of the 9 major illegal sand mining sites in the river course is Arakunnu, has been visited by us on the day October 2nd. Two guides, Dr R. Anilkumar (Associate Professor) and Shaji Johnson (Assistant Professor) of the Geography department in University College guided us in the study of the area and explained the problem of the area. Some photographs on the area have been taken by us. We also did an interview with the local residents and studied the problem they have been encountering with the sand mining and the sand mafia involved in the area. We have seen some of the damaged structures in the area as well as those structures like road bridge and railway bridge which are vulnerable to threats.
mining locations are locally known as Kadavus' and the selected locations, Olathani, Arakkunnu and Palakkadavu have length of 2.2 Km, 2.9 Km and 1.6 Km respectively. In stream sand mining as well as flood plain mining is prevalent in these areas.
couple of smoking brick kilns (or chullas in Malayalam) close by. When we asked how they can smuggle this illegal sand and bricks , our guide remarked that they have an alternate route through private properties free of checkposts and every day around 50 mini lorries carrying 50 cubic feet of sand each illegally. The workers are paid high wages because of their dangerous and arduous endeavour. It is reported during the investigation that, Just the day before we arrived , on the October 1st there was a police raid and a fraction of the boats were destroyed. Upon asked why the entire set of boats were not seized and why the mining is still continuing and why the secret routes were not cordoned off, he gave off a short laugh and said But of course, the police are also involved. And this was just to fool the public that they are taking some action. We are discussing the problem in detail below. Studying things in the text books and studying things by visiting the sites is quite a different experience because seeing is more effective than reading. It broke our hearts to see the destruction of the topography and also the structures like houses which are under serious threat under the effects of sand mining.
the boat. This is quite a risky profession yet some people are willing to take the risk because of the money involved. People of almost young age to old age take part in these activities. There have been cases of people drowning while doing the diving. The sand consisting of silt is separated from the clay portion of the sand by washing. This sand is carried to the lorry which can hold about fifty cubic feet of sand.
many have yielded , but a few stay put. But they are in perpetual fear and are highly apprehensive of their future.
shaped bend in a river or stream, whether or not it is cut off from the main stream. An oxbow lake is formed when a river creates a meander, due to the river's eroding the bank through hydraulic action and abrasion/corrosion. After a long period of time, the meander becomes very curved, and eventually the neck of the meander will touch the opposite side and the river will cut through the neck, cutting off the meander to form the oxbow lake. Such kind of Ox-bow lake got formed. And the main reason is the illicit mining of sand and the subsequent deposition of sand to form a small islet in between the main river and the lake. As a result the river ecosystem got disturbed. There is formation of water hyacinth , algal growth and the associated problem of eutrophication in the lake.
4) Destruction of ecosystem
The riverine ecosystem is under serious threat due to the mining activites taking place in the river. Many of the aquatic organisms in the river have already been destroyed. A long time back this region of was known to have sufficient fish but, now the life in the ecosystem has been extinguished due to these activities because of the disrupt in the food chain and the ecological imbalance.
people and finally to the destruction of the ethics of the society. This can lead to commitment of insane acts. Thus the money the people earn through sand mining is of no use.
Interview with M.r Vinod Kumar and family House destroyed in 1978.
Nearly now have just a meagre 8 or 10 cents. They are very much apprehensive of the imminent collapse of the bridge.
FUTURE CONSEQUENCES
It is highly probable that, if this sort of unscrupulous sand mining continues the railway bridge would collapse in a few years from now. The remnant of the houses that are there will also vanish. Either the whole community will perish or they will be relocated with poor rehabilitation and out of them only a very few will be able to regress. The oxbow lake may grow in size because of further sand mining and the remaining portion of land together with the rare species of kunthirikam trees will be lost. The lives of the people living in these areas are under constant threat and this will prevail unless the government takes direct action against these issues which is highly unlikely because of the corrupt and lethargic nature of the political system. There is a chance of high degree of moral decline in the future because of increase in alcohol consumption and quarrels involving the illegal sand mining. The topography of the land can change so much that it will be really hard to believe that the pristine beauty of the place which was revered will be shattered to oblivion because of the unscrupulous and illogical actions carried out by some of the natives of the area. The railway bridge and also the road bridge is under threat. If the mining continues in the same pattern there is bound to be the collapse of these structures. The railway bridge is constructed unscientifically so there is a greater risk to it due sand mining. Lets pray that the authorities responsible for the area may not turn blind eye towards the problem of this place and do some actions which may curb this unscrupulous activity.
POLITICAL FRAMEWORK
The root cause of this problem can be traced to the greed in money of some of the higher ups in the society and the unethical acts carried out by them to satisfy their insatiable greed for money. Very high level of corruption exists in the government and police governing the area. So this problem can only be solved if the topmost sector of the government takes direct action in purging the wide network of corruption existing at different levels. The local police near these areas are turning blind eye towards all the illegal activities. Once in a while the police destroy the mining facilities to a minimum extent to show that justice is being carried out to the public. But the problem keeps on aggravating a lot as the days go by.
TABLE I
SAND MINING IN NEYYAR RIVER
No. workers
1 2 3
Arakkunnu
2000
500 75 200
75 10 50
50 8 25
The total number of workers (Table No.1) engaging in the sand mining activity in these three sites is 775 and this was very less in the earlier periods when the resource was not commercially exploited in this rural area exclusively based on agrarian economy. The sand mining activities start in the early mornings and prolong till the noon. As the people can earn much within a short time is also attracting more young people in the rural areas to this field. The workers include sand miners, head load workers and transporting persons which shows the diversification of the activities that attract the people from various sectors to this field. The age structures of the people engaged in these activities vary between 17years and 55years. The wages offering to the labours is attractive and is one of the main reasons for more number of people move towards sand mining related activities. It is reported; a noticeable increase in the number of vessels used in sand mining activity in the area which numbers 105 in all these three sites at present. The sand extraction in the mining sites are of the order Arakkunnu> Olathani > >Palakkadavu (See Table 1). The quantity of sand
extracted per day in the selected sites varies from 8 lorry loads in Palakkadavu to 50 lorry loads in Arakkunnu.
TABLE II
WIDENINING OF RIVER COURSE
The width of the river in Olathani was 56.44 m in 1961, which has increased to 125.16 m in 2008 (Table.2).Sand mining in the Palakkadavu area has widened the river from 57.64 m in 1961 to 183.42 meters and in Arakkunnu area it is from 72.33 m in 1961 to 134.41 meters in 2008. Erosion of the river banks and the changes in the river course are severe in the Arakkunnu area. The river course was curved in the Arakkunnu area, due to sand mining in the left bank of the river in the locality after creating an artificial bund parallel to the river bank has resulted in the bifurcation of the river .The continued sand extraction in the left bank has straightened the river course leaving the actual river course a pond. The two bridges (one Road Bridge and one Railway Bridge) in the Arakkunnu area were constructed when the river course was not metamorphosed; the present changed course of the river is threatening the existence of these structures by eroding the river banks nearby at a faster rate. The river bank in
between the bridges is in continuous erosion and whereby the buildings constructed in the nearby area are in danger. There is an urgent need to strengthen the river banks in the area otherwise it would lead to the collapse of the bridges. The agricultural fields adjacent to the river banks in the area are also negatively affected due to the continued river bank erosion accelerated by the indiscriminate sand mining in the river bank. Thirty four coconut trees were uprooted during the recent rainy season in the Arakkunnu area alone.
Changed river course in Palakkadavu area Flood plain sand mining has lead to the loss of adjacent lands which includes both private and government properties. Apart from a huge loss of land it also poses threat to ecological and landuse aspects in the area. In the Olathani area alone, a loss of more than 50 acres of land has been occurred. Sand mining has a direct effect on the quality of water available in the area. The water is of poor quality and is mainly due to sand mining (KSCSTE, 2oo4).Assessment of samples collected from these areas revealed that the water is unsuitable for irrigation. There is a substantial increase of pH value of water in the area. Well water levels in Olathani and Arakkunnu areas lowered due to the riverbed sand mining. Spreading of the marshy lands is a serious issue in the sand mining sites of of water is in the Arakkunnu and Olathani. Stagnation
sand extracted deep pits in the riverbed favours the mosquito breeding and causes the spread of diseases like Malaria in the area which is a serious problem in Arakkunnu, Olathani and Palakkadavu.
A railway bridge under threat in Arakkunnu Illegal sand extraction in the riverbed has far reaching impacts on the society and it has created many disturbances in the social wellbeing of the people in the area. There is an increase in the events of conflicts in the area. Majority of the people who engage in sand mining are the outsiders and they force the people through different means in order to obtain their lands and those who take any actions against them will be attacked. The value of sand in the market is very high and is more than 10,000 rupees per load. This has attracted them to indulge in the illegal sand mining activities. The money received from these sources is used for many anti-social activities. There is a substantial increase in the alcohol consumption, as reported from the area. The deep pits formed as a result of sand mining have caused the death of more than 25 people in the area and the majority of the victims are the teenagers due to drowning. Land value has also considerably increased in the area because of sand mining.
CONCLUSION
River sand mining has impact on the environment as well as on society. The study conducted in the Neyyar River as a case for dying of rivers due to human activities revealed that River bank erosion, valley slumping and channel widening are severe in the area. Two bridges including a railway bridge and four houses nearby the area are under the threat of collapse due to river bank erosion in Arakkunnu area. Water quality has alarmingly decreased and water table has considerably lowered in the area. Landuse has changed substantially in all the sand mining sites of the Neyyar river basin. Stagnation of water in the area lead to many health problems. In the social environment, conflicts, and alcoholism have increased and is disturbing the wellbeing of the people.
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the project entitled River sand mining in the Neyyar river basin is a bonafide record work done by the group consisting of A.J Moses, Chaithanya Ramkumar, Ansu U, Arun Vijayan and Akhil P.A for the B-Tech EVS course curriculum during the year 2011 done under my supervision. The data presented here is purely authentic and is done as part of the final project presentation in the above mentioned course. Thiruvananthapuram