How to Listen Reference Manual

Public Version 2.0.4 April 4, 2011

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Table of Contents

Introduction! .............................................................................4 How to Listen Installation!......................................................5

Manually Setting Folder Permissions!........................................6 Updating From an Older Version of How to Listen!...................7

First Time Use!.........................................................................7 Using How to Listen!...............................................................9

Optimizing How To Listen!.........................................................10 Program Material! ........................................................................10 Auditioning Choices!..................................................................11

Keyboard Interaction!............................................................12
Band ID Keys!..............................................................................12 Attribute Keys! .............................................................................13

Practice Mode!.......................................................................14 Adding Your Own Music in Practice Mode! .........................16 How to Listen Training Modes!............................................17 Band ID!..................................................................................17
Band ID Scoring Method!...........................................................17 Peaks! ...........................................................................................18 Dips!.............................................................................................19

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Peaks/Dips!..................................................................................20 Lowpass!......................................................................................21 Highpass!.....................................................................................23

Attribute Modes!....................................................................24
Attribute Scoring Method!..........................................................24 Bright/Dull! ...................................................................................25 Full/Thin!......................................................................................26 Reverberant/Dry!.........................................................................27 Noisy/Noise-Free! ........................................................................28 Colored/Uncolored!.....................................................................29 Left/Right!....................................................................................30 Audible Hum/Hum-free!..............................................................31

Acknowledgements!..............................................................32

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Introduction
Welcome to the How to Listen listener training software by Harman. The purpose of this software is to teach listeners how to critically evaluate different attributes of sound quality timbre, spatial, dynamic and distortion in recorded and reproduced sound. How to Listen is the same software used by Harman scientists for training and selecting listeners used for research and testing of new Harman consumer, professional and automotive audio products. Anyone with an interest in improving their critical listening skills (e.g. amateur or professional recording engineers, producers, musicians, audio engineers, audio enthusiasts) should benefit from this training software. Research by Dr. Sean Olive [1] and other audio scientists, has shown there are enormous benefits in training listeners. First, trained listeners give more discriminating and reliable sound quality ratings than untrained listeners, yet their overall sound quality preferences are very similar to those of untrained trained listeners. The performance of a Harman trained listener based on ability to give discriminating and consistent ratings is about 3 to 20 times better than that of untrained listener [1]. This means that fewer listeners are required to achieve the same statistical confidence that would otherwise require a large (200-400) sample of untrained consumers. Training listeners reduces the cost of product development and testing, and helps produce better sounding products. Second, training teaches listeners to give consistent, meaningful, and quantitative data on different attributes of sound quality that most untrained listeners would have difficulty providing. This feedback is used by Harman engineers to make any necessary refinements in the sound of new audio products. We hope this software will open your ears and minds towards a better appreciation of what good sound is, and the scientific research and testing that goes into every Harman audio product. The Harman How to Listen team Northridge, CA

References [1] Sean. E Olive, "Differences in Performance and Preference of Trained Versus Untrained Listeners in

Loudspeaker Tests: A Case Study," J. AES, Vol. 51, issue 9, pp. 806-825, September 2003. Download for free here, courtesy of Harman International.

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

How to Listen Installation

Upon first opening of the How to Listen installation package, you will see a setup wizard like the following:

Simply click continue (Mac) or Next (Windows), choose an install destination, and click install. And thats it! Youre done:

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Manually Setting Folder Permissions

How to Listen installs files in three locations on your computer. They are listed below: Mac OS Location 1: User\Applications\Harman International\Harman How to Listen\ Location 2: Root\Library\Application Support\Harman International\ Location 3: [Local User]\Library\Application Support\Harman International\ Windows Location 1: root\Program Files\Harman International\How to Listen Location 2: root\Documents and Settings\All Users\Application Data\Harman International\ Location 3: root\Documents and Settings\[username]\Application Data\Harman International\ The application itself, program files, and mix-ins are all stored in Location 1. User account information, test results, and session definitions are stored in Location 2, and last logged-in user is stored in Location 3. How to Listen requires read/write access to these three folders, and attempts to set these permissions during installation. If for some reason the installer fails to set these permissions correctly, you may get error messages while using How to Listen that it cannot locate these files. If this occurs you may need to manually set permissions to these folders in the three locations. For Mac OS, you can manually set permissions by CTRL+clicking the appropriate folder, navigate \Info\Sharing & Permissions\ and set the user permissions to read/write. For Windows OS, right click on the appropriate folder, click on the Properties\Security tab and adjust permissions to allow read/write access to the folder.

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Updating From an Older Version of How to Listen

When you install an updated version of How to Listen over a previous version, the installer will retain previous user accounts and session files. When you first open How to Listen after installation, you will need to establish a new user account and password in order to access any new features/bug fixes in the newer sessions.xml file included with the newer version. This means you can not use previous accounts established with the older version of How to Listen. In a future release, a feature will be added to the software that merges the results from the old sessions.xml file with the new one. In this way, you can use your existing account, and merge the new results with the existing results.

First Time Use

Find the directory in which you installed How to Listen and then double click on How to Listen (Offline). You will be prompted with the welcome screen. Click New User.

Use the blank fields to create your offline username and password. This password may be any number of characters and letters.

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

After creating a password and username, you will be taken to the main login page. Simply use your newly created info, and click ok.

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Using How to Listen

The Welcome to How To Listen window shows you a list of training tasks based on different categories: Band ID, Attribute, Preference, etc. There are several sub tasks or Options for each task. Try to get as high a level as possible in all tasks. You can check your progress by looking at the Level you have achieved in all tasks, and the number of trials that you have attempted.

To begin a task in Training Mode, double click on the desired task. You will then resume the task from the previous level that you had achieved. Your progress is only saved in Training Mode. If you wish to practice, click on Practice. See Practice Mode for more on Practice setup.

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Optimizing How To Listen

Before starting the How to Listen application, make sure you quit other audio applications (like iTunes) and turn off other audio effects running in the background (EQ, spatial processing, loudness compensation). This will ensure that you are hearing the audio tracks at the proper sampling rates with the intended signal processing.

Program Material
Music samples included with How to Listen are provided by Bravura Records. These high resolution recordings from Bravura are recorded and mixed live as 24 bit/192 kHz files by the legendary recording engineering/producer Bill Schnee, who has been Grammy-nominated 11 times for Best Engineered Recording and has won twice for Aja and Gaucho, both from Steely Dan. Bravura recordings are made using musicians with real talent, recorded in real-time. To find more information about Bravura Records please visit their website: www.bravurarecords.com. Descriptions of the recordings provided by Bravura Records are below: Track 1: How Long by Bill Cantos Bill is an extremely gifted singer, songwriter, arranger, and pianist. His fabulous arranging skills are truly shown on this classic pop hit from the 70s. Track 2: Clap Hands by George Krikes (Kreekus) George is a young indie/pop artist with a smooth voice, whos a great arranger and a wonderful songwriter. His appeal will span a broad demographic. Track 3: Four Wheel Drive by Paul Thorn Paul is a brilliant singer/song writer who forms his unique brand of American storytelling from the world around him. Descriptive terms such as inspiration, eccentricity, and character all tell part of this story. But hearing him live says it all!

10

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Track 4: Fiesta Linda by Open Hands Led by the legendary Abraham Laboriel of whom Larry Carleton once said. There are a lot of great bass players in this world, but there is one, and only one Abraham Laboriel. Everything this band plays embraces the joy of music making to the fullest.

Auditioning Choices

If you give an incorrect answer in training mode, or in practice mode with Feedback

turned on, you will be given an option to audition possible choices. If you choose yes, you will see a training screen much like the one you just made the incorrect selection on.

In Audition Mode, you may select any of the filters shown to instantly hear how they sound, then compare them to the unequalized version by clicking Flat. This is useful for being able to visualize what you are hearing, and will further train your ears to recognize the filters. Click Done when you are finished auditioning to continue to the next trial.

11

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Keyboard Interaction
The following are keyboard shortcuts for both types of Listener Training exercises.

Band ID Keys
Key Action Space Toggles between play and pause. Up For combined peaks/dips, moves the user's selection from a dip to the peak at the same frequency. If the user currently has a peak selected, the next highest frequency's dip becomes selected. For all other Band ID tasks, the up arrow behaves just as the right arrow. Selections will wrap at the boundaries if there are 5 or more bands. Down For combined peaks/dips, moves the user's selection from a peak to the dip at the same frequency. If the user currently has a dip selected, the next lowest frequency's peak becomes selected. For all other Band ID tasks, the down arrow behaves just as the left arrow. Selections will wrap at the boundaries if there are 5 or more bands. Right Moves the user's selection to the next highest frequency. The right arrow will not move from a peak to a dip for combined peaks/dips. Selections will wrap at Left the boundaries if there are 5 or more bands. Moves the user's selection to the next lowest frequency. The left arrow will not move from a peak to a dip for combined peaks/dips. Selections will wrap at the boundaries if there are 5 or more bands. e Plays the equalized (EQ) version of the audio. f Plays the unequalized (Flat) version of the audio. Enter Used to enter your nal response (Done).

12

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Attribute Keys
Key Space Up Down Right Left s Enter Any letter except "s" Action Toggles between play/pause audio states. Moves the scale rating slider up incrementally. Moves the scale rating slider down incrementally. Plays the stimulus to the right of the currently selected stimulus. Plays the stimulus to the left of the currently selected stimulus. Sort the stimuli based on the user's current ranking. Used to enter your nal response (Done). Switch to the stimulus associated with the given letter. Stimulus buttons are labeled with letters.

13

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Practice Mode
Practice mode allows you to adjust and control the test parameters (program, gain, filter Q, etc) to your liking. Use it to have a go at more difficult levels than you are currently attempting in training mode, or to go back a few levels if you need easier practice than your current training level. Practice mode does not save your results so any accomplishments will not be shown as credit towards your training progress. You do have the option of saving the results of your practice mode results as a text file.

This is the Band ID Practice mode setup page. You may change any number of the Parameters. Note that the Filter tab lets you select any number of filter types from the Band ID category. Once you have selected the number of starting Bands, the type of training mode you wish, and the various parameters associated with that mode, you must choose the program material you will be tested on. To see how to add your own program material, click here. If Feedback: yes option is selected, then the software will tell you after each trial whether your response is correct or not, then prompt you as to whether you wish to audition your choices (See Auditioning Choices). If the Feedback: No option is selected, you will not be

14

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

given any feedback on your answers until the end of the run of trials. This option is useful in a classroom training scenario where the group of listeners write their responses after each trial, and the final results are tabulated at the end of the test. To switch to the Attribute category, click on Attribute at the top of the window.

15

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Adding Your Own Music in Practice Mode

In Practice Mode, you can easily add your own program material to train your ears. In either Band ID or Attribute mode, you will see the program selection button. Click Choose, then Add File. Find the location of the file on your hard drive or external media, then click ok. You will be asked to make an easily readable title for the song. Now whenever you use practice mode, you will see your own music file as an option for program material. Keep in mind that the software does not make a copy of the song in its sound file folders, so if the location of your personal music file changes, you must re-add it. The training software currently supports the following file formats: WAV (16 bit, 44.1 kHz) and AIFF (44.1 kHz) and MP3. If you select a music file that does not meet these requirements a message box will tell you that the file format is not supported. You may convert your desired sound file to one of the above formats using an audio conversion application. Be aware that Practice Mode in How to Listen will look for your uploaded music in the original directory you specify, i.e. if you upload music from a flash drive, How to Listen will look for that drive every time you choose that specific track for your training.

16

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

How to Listen Training Modes

The following training modes offer a variety of ways to teach you how to listen critically and discern imperfections. Be sure to practice each mode enough to the point where you are making minimal errors.

Band ID
Band ID modes of training all follow the same principle: you are presented the music without any frequency response alterations (Flat) and a modified version (EQ) that has been equalized by one of the filters graphically represented as a curve drawn on the graph. Your task is to decide which filter best matches the sound of the equalized version (EQ).

Band ID Scoring Method

In order to advance a level in Band ID tasks, you must achieve three consecutive correct

answers on your current trial. If you receive three consecutive incorrect answers, you must complete the previous skill level before you may advance.

17

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Peaks

When not in Practice mode, you start the Peaks training with two very wide band peaks. Compare the unequalized version of the sound (FLAT) to the equalized version (EQ), and determine which frequency band is affected by the equalization. Enter your response by clicking on the numbered button that corresponds to the affected frequency band, and then hit the DONE button.

Listening Tip: The audibility of peak or dip depends on its height (gain in dB), width (bandwidth or Q), and the frequency. Wider peaks or dips are more audible and easier to hear than narrower peaks and dips at equivalent heights or gain. As the skill level increases, the peaks and dips will become narrower and generally more difcult to correctly identify.

18

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Dips

The Dips training mode is identical to the Peaks mode, but with level reduction of a certain bandwidth applied to the (EQ) version of the song. Compare the unequalized version of the sound (FLAT) to the equalized version (EQ), and determine which frequency band is affected by the equalization. Enter your response by clicking on the numbered button that corresponds to the affected frequency band, and then hit the DONE button.

Listening Tip: Once you learn the sound of peaks added at different frequency regions, you can use that information to identify a dip. When you switch between EQ and Flat, the Flat condition will sound like you are adding a peak at the frequency where the dip occurs.

19

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Peaks/Dips

The Peaks/Dips mode is just like the Peaks mode or Dips mode, except this time both types of filters are options within each trial. Compare the unequalized version of the sound (FLAT) to the equalized version (EQ), and determine which frequency band is affected by the equalization, and whether it is boosted or cut. Enter your response by clicking on the numbered button that corresponds to the affected frequency band, and then hit the DONE button.

! ! !

Listening Tip: When testing yourself in the peaks/dips modes, do two things: 1. First decide whether EQ is louder (Peak) or softer (Dip) than FLAT. That will eliminate 50% of your choices. 2. Second, decide which frequency range (bass/midrange/treble) the peak or dip falls into, and narrow your choices from there.

20

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Lowpass

This training task helps you determine at which frequencies a lowpass is applied. A lowpass filter removes higher frequencies (and passes the lows on through). The sound of the lowpass filter depends on its frequency and slope. In these exercises, the filter slope is fixed at 12 dB per octave. Compare the unequalized version of the sound (FLAT) to the equalized version (EQ), and determine which frequency band is affected by the equalization. Enter your response by clicking on the numbered button that corresponds to the affected frequency band, and then hit the DONE button.

21

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Listening Tip: The lowpass lter training task is very instructive in learning the different frequency regions into which different musical instruments and vocals fall. ! Lowpass Filter Frequency 50 Hz - you will only hear the lowest organ, bass notes, kick drum, and they will sound dull and mufed; if the music has little low frequency content you will barely hear anything. 100 Hz - you will hear mufed bass instruments and some mufed bass vocal. 500 Hz - you should hear bass instruments clearly and mufed vocals. 1 kHz - vocals sound clear. 4 kHz - bass instruments sound clear and vocals have presence; higher pitched instruments sound dull. 8 kHz - vocals have sibilance and clarity; cymbals and higher pitched instruments are dull. >15 kHz - everything should sound natural and present with brilliance added to cymbals and higher pitched instruments.

22

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Highpass

This training task helps you determine at which frequencies a highpass is applied. Compare the unequalized version of the sound (Flat) to the equalized version (EQ), and determine which frequency band is affected by the equalization. Enter your response by clicking on the numbered button that corresponds to the affected frequency band, and then hit the DONE button.

23

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Attribute Modes
Attribute modes do not test your ears knowledge of the frequency spectrum like Band ID modes do, but rather test your ability to discern unwanted qualities like distortion, hum, and noise, as well as normal attributes such as spatial balance.

Attribute Scoring Method

During any given level, your attribute ratings are averaged into a correlation coefficient.

After a minimum of 3 trials, if your average is above 85%, you will advance a level. If your coefficient is below 20%, you must complete the previous task skill level before advancing. This means that for low levels, you must have a perfect rank order to advance, while for higher level trials, a consistent yet imperfect rank order will still allow advancement.

24

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Bright/Dull

Bright/Dull refers to the balance of high frequencies (treble) sounds relative to the lower and middle frequencies. Increasing the relative level of high frequency components will increase the brightness of the sound and decreasing the level will make it sound duller. Good sound should be neither too bright nor too dull.
Compare equalizations A though n, and assign a rating to each based on how bright or

dull each sounds. Pressing the Sort button sorts the rating given to A-n in ascending order based on your ratings. When you are finished, press Enter (Done). Your correlation score indicates how accurately you have rank ordered the sounds in terms of their brightness/ dullness. A correlation score of 1 indicates perfect rank ordering. You must achieve a correlation score of 0.85 to proceed to the next skill level.

25

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Full/Thin

Full/Thin refers to the quantity of low frequencies (bass) in sound relative to the middle and higher frequencies. Increasing and decreasing the relative level of low frequency components will make the sound fuller and thinner, respectively. Good sound should neither be too full or too thin.
Compare equalizations A though n, and assign a rating to each based on how full or thin

each sounds. Pressing the Sort button sorts the rating given to A-n in ascending order based on your ratings. When you are finished, press Enter (Done). Your correlation score indicates how accurately you have rank ordered the sounds in terms of their Fullness/Thinness. A correlation score of 1 indicate perfect rank ordering. You must achieve a correlation score of 0.85 to proceed to the next skill level.

26

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Reverberant/Dry

Reverberation refers to the level, density, and temporal decay of the late reections in the recording and/or listening space. Reverberation helps improve the timbral richness of instruments and gives us a spatial sense of the recording space. However, too much reverberation can reduce speech intelligibility and clarity of the music.
Compare sounds A through n, and assign a rating based on how much reverberation

each sound contains. Pressing the Sort button sorts the rating given to A-n in ascending order based on your ratings. When you are finished, press Enter (Done). Your correlation score indicates how accurately you have rank ordered the sounds in terms of the amount of reverberation they contain. A correlation score of 1 indicates perfect rank ordering. You must achieve a correlation score of 0.85 to proceed to the next skill level.

27

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Noisy/Noise-Free

Noise is often present in a system, and when raised to an audible level can often present distortions that detract from the delity of the reproduction. In this training task, broadband white noise is generated at varying levels and mixed in with the original signal.
Compare sounds A through n, and assign a rating based on how much noise each sound

contains. Pressing the Sort button sorts the rating given to A-n in ascending order based on your ratings. When you are finished, press Enter (Done). Your correlation score indicates how accurately you have rank ordered the sounds in terms of the amount of noise they contain. A correlation score of 1 indicates perfect rank ordering. You must achieve a correlation score of 0.85 to proceed to the next skill level.

28

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Colored/Uncolored

Coloration refers to an unnatural distortion in the timbre of sounds usually associated with the presence of undesirable medium and narrow band resonances in the playback chain and/or listening room. Timbre refers to the quality of a musical note or sound that distinguishes it from other types of notes or instruments.
Compare equalizations A though n, and assign a rating to each based on how colored

each one sounds. Higher ratings correspond with more coloration. Pressing the Sort button sorts the rating given to A-n in ascending order based on your ratings. When you are finished, press Enter (Done). Your correlation score indicates how accurately you have rank ordered the sounds in terms of their coloration. A correlation score of 1 indicates perfect rank ordering. You must achieve a correlation score of 0.85 to proceed to the next skill level.

29

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Left/Right

Left/Right balance refers to the apparent locations of the auditory images between the left and right front loudspeakers. You should be sitting equidistant between the left/right speakers, in the so-called stereo sweet spot.
Use the slider to indicate the apparent left/right location of Sounds A-n. A rating of 5

indicates the image is located at the left speaker, 0 is center, and -5 is the right loudspeaker. Pressing the Sort button sorts the rating given to A-n in ascending order based on your ratings. When you are finished, press Enter (Done). Your correlation score indicates how accurately you have rank ordered the sounds in terms of their Left/Right locations. A correlation score of 1 indicate perfect rank ordering. You must achieve a correlation score of 0.85 to proceed to the next skill level.

30

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Audible Hum/Hum-free

Audio electronic components can have audible hum (heard as 50-60 Hz and higher harmonics) in the background created by ground loops between audio components, poor shielding or a bad cable in the system. Since the hum consists of a continuous tone in the background, it can be very distracting your enjoyment of the reproduced music.

Use the slider to indicate the relative intensities or levels of audible hum in A through n. Pressing the Sort button sorts the rating given to A-n in ascending order based on your ratings. When you are finished, press Enter (Done). Your correlation score indicates how accurately you have rank ordered the sounds in terms of their relative level of audible hum. A correlation score of 1 indicate perfect rank ordering. You must achieve a correlation score of 0.85 to proceed to the next skill level.

31

Harman How to Listen Reference Manual

Acknowledgements
How to Listen Software was written by Eric Hu and Sean Hess in Harmans Corporate R&D Group. The user manual was written by Alex Miller. Contributions towards the development of the training methodology were provided by Dr. Sean Olive, Director of Acoustic Research of Harmans Corporate R&D Group, and Dr. Kristina Busenitz and Dr. Rafael Kassier of the Harman Automotive Division. We would like to thank Dr. Floyd Toole and Tim Nind for their continued support of this project.

32