Sunteți pe pagina 1din 6

Journal of Psychosomatic Research 61 (2006) 305 – 310

Review article

Substance use disorders: recent advances in treatment and models of care


Mohammed T. Abou-Saleh4
Division of Mental Health, St. George’s, University of London, Cranmer Terrace, SW17 0RE London, UK
Received 20 June 2006

Abstract
Drug and alcohol misuse is a global health problem with use disorders and on optimal models of care and services, with
great health economic costs to substance misusers, their families, reference to studies conducted in the United Arab Emirates.
and their communities. It is associated with high physical Community surveys in Dubai and Al-Ain have shown a
and psychiatric morbidity, and with high mortality. There are high prevalence of these disorders. It is proposed that
serious obstacles to its treatment, including the stigma associated these problems be dealt with in primary care settings, and it has
with it. Major advances in assessment and treatment have enabled been found that primary health care workers have a key role to
health professionals to tackle drug and alcohol problems in play and are often in an ideal position to coordinate the com-
a variety of settings, including primary care setting. This overview munity’s response.
focuses on recent advances in the treatment of substance D 2006 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Addiction; Alcohol; Drugs; Models of care; Treatment; Substance misuse

Introduction America and Eastern Europe [1]. The Global Burden of


Disease and Injury Series estimated alcohol to be respon-
Substance use disorders are among the most common sible for 1.5% of all deaths and for 3.5% of total disability
mental and behavioral disorders that affect mankind. These adjusted life years [2]. To a lesser extent, drug use disorders
disorders include those caused by alcohol, opiates, cannabis, account for 1.8% of lives with disability in 15- to 44-year-
cocaine, sedatives, and volatile solvents. Common presen- olds, compared to alcohol use disorders (5.5%) [2]. The
tations are states of intoxication, harmful use (abuse), point prevalence of drug abuse and dependence ranges from
dependence, and comorbid psychiatric disorders. Harmful 0.4% to 4%, which includes heroin use and cocaine use
use is diagnosed when damage has been caused to physical disorders (0.25%). Injecting drug use is associated with a
or mental health, while substance dependence is diagnosed high risk for contracting blood-borne infections, including
when substance use becomes compulsive, uncontrollable, hepatitis B, hepatitis C, and HIV (20–80%).
and associated with physiological withdrawal symptoms, There remains some controversy over the notion that
with the sole pursuit of substance use despite the occurrence substance use disorders are not medical disorders but are
of serious harm to self or others. Alcohol use disorders are expressions of lifestyle or, at worst, of criminal behaviors by
the commonest, with a global point prevalence of 1.7, people who self-inflict these problems upon themselves.
according to the Global Burden of Disease and Injury However, the development of harmful use and dependence
Series, and with variation ranging from very low prevalence renders these disorders as serious psychiatric disorders
rates in Middle Eastern countries to over 5% in North consistent with other disease states. Substance use disorders
are complex disorders and result from an interplay of genetic
and environmental factors, with a significant contribution
4 Tel: +44 2087250368; fax: +44 2087252914. from genetic disposition, abnormal development, and
E-mail address: mabousal@sgul.ac.uk. psychosocial disadvantage. Recent advances in neuro-

0022-3999/06/$ – see front matter D 2006 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jpsychores.2006.06.013
306 M.T. Abou-Saleh / Journal of Psychosomatic Research 61 (2006) 305–310

science and experimental psychology, and the applications enable patients to change their lifestyle so that they can
of their techniques have demonstrated biological and lead life without the use of substances and they can be free
psychosocial mechanisms that contribute to the development from all constraints and disabilities. The assessment of a
of substance use disorders [3]. patient’s readiness for change is a core intervention. The
This overview focuses on recent advances in the treat- assessment of this readiness to change is based on the cycle
ment of substance use disorders and on optimal models of of change of Prochaska and DiClemente, wherein the
care and services, with reference to studies conducted in the substance user goes through the following: (a) precontem-
United Arab Emirates (UAE). plation stage—no change is being considered; (b) con-
templation stage—the user becomes ambivalent towards
Assessment drug use; (c) determination—the user decides to take steps;
and (d) action—change is started; (e) maintenance—the
The core value or guiding principle for the management user consolidates the change achieved. Drug users, how-
of substance misuse and dependence is that people with ever, often experience relapses into substance use and
substance use disorders have the same entitlement to health the cycle restarts again. Based on the assessment of
and social care as other patients. It is the responsibility of all readiness to change, the counselor attending to the drug
health professionals involved in their care to provide for their user and using motivational interviewing will provide
general health and social needs, as well as for their drug- interventions to enhance the user’s motivation by providing
related problems, through evidence-based interventions, information during the precontemplation phase, increasing
including harm-reduction approaches [4]. ambivalence during contemplation, exploring options dur-
A good assessment should be thorough and compre- ing determination, working out practical strategies during
hensive, with the purposes of identifying the nature and action, working out relapse prevention during maintenance,
severity of any drug-related problem, understanding its and, finally, avoiding demoralization during relapse into
causes, and assessing its consequences to establish the substance misuse.
strengths and weaknesses of patients and their conditions. The aims of the treatment are as follows: to assist patients
A good assessment will enable the formulation of the to remain healthy until they receive appropriate care/support
diagnosis, which comprises medical and psychiatric diag- so that they can achieve a drug-free life; reduce the use of
nosis, and appropriate investigations, including psycholog- illicit or unprescribed drugs; deal with problems relating to
ical and social assessments. A good formulation will result drug misuse; reduce the dangers associated with drug
in a comprehensive treatment and care plan, addressing misuse, particularly the risk of HIV, hepatitis B/C, and
immediate needs, risk factors, and short-term and long-term other blood-borne infections; reduce the duration of
management, including social rehabilitation for optimal episodes of drug misuse; reduce the chance of future relapse
integration into normal community living. into drug misuse; reduce the need for criminal activity to
The aims of assessment are to: (a) treat any emergency or finance drug misuse; reduce the risk of prescribed drugs
acute problem; (b) confirm that the patient is taking drugs being diverted to the illegal drug market; stabilize the
(history, examination, and urine analysis); (c) assess degree of patient, where appropriate, on a substitute medication to
dependence; (d) identify complications of drug misuse and alleviate withdrawal symptoms; and improve overall per-
assess risk behavior; (e) identify other medical, social, and sonal, social, and family functions [4].
mental health problems; (f) give advice on harm minimization, Treatment is subdivided into psychological and pharma-
including, if appropriate, access to sterile needles and syringes, cological treatments, and the optimal treatment plan
testing for hepatitis and HIV, and immunization against provides tailor-made combined psychosocial and pharma-
hepatitis B; (g) determine a patient’s expectations regarding cological treatments matching the substance user’s physical,
treatment and the degree of motivation to change; (h) assess the psychiatric, psychological, and social needs.
most appropriate level of expertise required to manage the
patient (this may alter over time); and (i) refer/liaise Treatment of severe addictions
appropriately (i.e., shared care, specialist or specialized
generalist care, or other forms of psychological care, where There is a wide range of psychological treatments that
appropriate); (j) determine the need for substitute medica- have been developed in recent decades and are based on
tion—in the case of the general practitioner, this should be psychological theories of addictive behavior, including
with advice from a specialist, ideally through shared care conditioning and cognitive theories.
arrangements and (k) in private practice, establish that the pa- The goals of treatment are best conceived as a hierarchy
tient is able to pay for treatment through legitimate means [4]. of goals, including the following: reduction of psycholog-
ical, social, and other problems directly related to drug use;
Treatment reduction of psychological, social, and other problems not
directly attributable to drug use; reduction of harmful or
A comprehensive assessment will produce a compre- risky behaviors associated with drug use (e.g., sharing
hensive treatment and care plan. Ultimately, the aim is to injecting equipment); attainment of less chaotic, non-
M.T. Abou-Saleh / Journal of Psychosomatic Research 61 (2006) 305–310 307

Table 1
A summary of the main psychological therapies used in treating substance misuse
Behavioral therapy A structured therapy focusing on changing behaviors and on environmental factors that trigger
maladaptive behavior
Cue exposure treatment A structured treatment involving exposure to drug-related cues that have been associated with past drug use
without consumption of the drug; this is intended to lead to a reduction (or habituation) of reactivity to drug
cues and, thus, to a reduced likelihood of relapse
Community reinforcement approach A behavioral approach that focuses on what clients find rewarding in their social, occupational, and recreational
life; it aims to help them change their lifestyle and social environment to support long-term changes in behavior
whereby substances use is less rewarding that nonuse
Contingency management Also known as voucher-based therapy, this aims to encourage adaptive behavior by rewarding the client for
attaining goals (e.g., no use of illicit drugs as checked by urine screens) and by not rewarding them when these
goals are unmet (e.g., illicit drug use); vouchers can usually be exchanged for consumer goods
Cognitive therapy A structured therapy using cognitive techniques (e.g., challenging a person’s negative thoughts) and behavioral
techniques (e.g., behavioral experiments and activity planning) to change maladaptive thoughts and beliefs
Cognitive–behavioral therapy (CBT) A combination of both cognitive and behavioral therapies
Relapse prevention Uses several CBT strategies to enhance clients’ self-control and to prevent relapse; highlights problems that
clients may face and develops strategies that they can use to deal with high-risk situations
Motivational interviewing A focused approach aiming to enhance motivation for stopping substance use by exploring and resolving
individuals’ ambivalence about change
Motivational enhancement therapy A brief intervention based on motivational interviewing, which also incorporates bcheck-upQ
assessment and feedback
Twelve-step approaches Interventions used by self-help organizations such as Alcoholics Anonymous; these are based on a philosophy
that adopts an illness model and sees substance use as stemming from an innate vulnerability; individuals must
acknowledge their addiction and the harm it has caused to themselves and others; they must also accept their
lack of control over use and, thus, the only acceptable goal is abstinence
Other approaches The involvement of partners and family through marital and family therapies builds on the known social context
of substance use; there are also various forms of counseling, group therapy, and milieu therapy
Reprinted with permission from Curran and Drummand [8]. Reproduced under the terms of the Click-Use License.

dependent, or nonproblematic drug use; abstinence from methadone maintenance treatment, showed results similar to
main problem drugs; and abstinence from all drugs. those of NTORS [7].
In the UK, treatments have been critically reviewed by
the government’s Task Force to Review Services for Drug Psychosocial treatments
Misusers, which identified four effective treatments for drug
misuse: methadone detoxification, oral methadone main- The primacy of the psychosocial treatment of addictions
tenance programs, residential rehabilitation programs, and is related to their established effectiveness and, importantly,
specialist inpatient drug dependence units [5]. The task to the provision of a context for comprehensive treatment,
force commissioned the National Treatment Outcome including pharmacotherapy. Moreover, psychosocial treat-
Research Study (NTORS), which reported its findings at ment is the treatment of choice for stimulant and cannabis
1 year [6]. There were substantial and important improve- misuse, and nondependent alcohol and drug use, since there
ments in drug use, with reductions in the use of heroin, are no effective pharmacological treatments for these
unprescribed methadone, and benzodiazepine; in injecting; disorders. They are also useful for the treatment of comorbid
and in the sharing of injecting equipment. Reductions were
psychiatric disorders such as anxiety and depressive
evident at 1 year, with outcomes remaining at about the
disorders, and related social problems.
1-year level or demonstrating further reductions. However,
Elements of psychosocial treatment include the follow-
crack cocaine and alcohol outcomes at 4–5 years were not
ing: provision of information, structure for care, family
significantly different from those on intake. There were also
involvement, facilitation of engagement and retention in
significant improvements in both physical and psycholog-
treatment, self-help groups, and a counseling style that is
ical health, and a marked reduction in criminal activity, with
nonjudgmental, empowering, and enhancing of self-esteem
the important finding that, for every extra o1 (sterling) spent
and self-efficacy.
on drug misuse treatment, there is a return of more than o3
in terms of cost savings associated with victim costs of A recent review of evidence for effectiveness has been
crime and reduced demands on the criminal justice system. conducted by the Foresight Brain Science, Addiction and
The authors concluded: b despite differences between the Drugs Project (Psychological Treatment of Substance
United Kingdom and the United States in patient popula- Misuse and Dependence) [8], as summarized in Table 1.
tions and in treatment programs, there are many similarities
between the two countries in outcomes from large-scale, Psychopharmacological treatments
multisite studies.Q Indeed, the Drug Abuse Treatment
Outcome Study, which conducted an outpatient methadone There has been relatively fewer new psychopharmaceut-
treatment evaluation examining the long-term effects of icals introduced for addictive disorders than for other
308 M.T. Abou-Saleh / Journal of Psychosomatic Research 61 (2006) 305–310

Table 2
Evidence-based drug treatments for substance use disorders, based on the BAP’s guidelines
Target drug Therapeutic agent(s) and mechanism Indications
Alcohol Benzodiazepines (e.g., chlordiazepoxide and diazepam)—act (1) Withdrawal symptoms
as direct g-aminobutyric acid (GABA) agonists (2) Seizure prevention and treatment
(3) Delirium prevention and treatment
Antiepileptic agents (e.g., carbemazepine)—act as (1) Withdrawal symptoms
GABA promoters, with other less well-characterized mechanisms (2) Seizure prevention
Acamprosate—affects glutamate receptors, which reduce Maintenance of abstinence and relapse prevention
withdrawal-related neuronal excitation and neurotoxicity
Naltrexone—acts as opioid antagonist Maintenance of abstinence and relapse prevention
(although not licensed for this use in the UK)
Disulfiram (aldehyde dehydrogenase inhibitor)—allows the Supervised use for maintenance of abstinence and
buildup of the toxic breakdown product, acetaldehyde relapse prevention
Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (1) Maintenance of abstinence and relapse prevention in
late-onset alcoholics
(2) Treatment of comorbid depression in selected patients
Thiamine—acts as a vitamin supplement (1) Prevention of neurological complications
(2) Treatment of Wernicke’s encephalopathy
Benzodiazepines Carbemazepine—modulates sodium channels and Prevention and treatment of withdrawal in selected patients
affects neurotransmission
Nicotine Nicotine agonists—are used in nicotine replacement therapy Smoking cessation—maintenance therapy
Bupropion—acts as a monoamine (especially dopamine) Smoking cessation
reuptake inhibitor
Opiates Methadone—acts as opioid agonist (1) Withdrawal symptoms
(2) Maintenance therapy
Buprenorphine—acts as opioid A-receptor partial agonist Withdrawal symptoms
and n antagonist
Clonidine and lofexidine—act as a2-adrenoreceptor agonists Withdrawal symptoms
Naltrexone Relapse prevention in selected patients
Reprinted with permission from Iverson, Morris, and Nutt [10]. Reproduced under the terms of the Click-Use License.

psychiatric disorders. Moreover, people with addictive Models of care


disorders comprise probably the most socially excluded
group and, importantly, they are often excluded from The National Treatment Agency of Substance Misuse in
participation in clinical trials of new psychopharmaceuticals England guidance on models of care provides a treatment
in a variety of psychiatric disorders. framework and a process intended to support the move
The pharmacotherapy of addictions has been the towards a consensus on the essential components of
mainstay of treatment since the introduction of methadone specialist substance misuse services and the importance of
for opiate addiction. This established the British model links with other health, social care, and criminal justice
comprising methadone detoxification and maintenance, agencies [11]. The guidance structures substance misuse
with the latter indication becoming more established when services into four broad tiers: from Tier 1 (nonspecialist
a harm-reduction approach was widely adopted to combat services, including general psychiatric services) to Tier 4a
the spread of HIV, which was later extended to reduce other (residential care specifically for substance misusers) and
harms, including social harm and drug-related crimes. The Tier 4b (highly specialized services unrelated to substance
other well-established—albeit more recently introduced— misuse, such as forensic psychiatric services and specialist
drug is buprenorphine, which is used for both opiate personality disorder services). The guidance also stipulates
detoxification and maintenance, and is a safe and effective the development of integrated care pathways as the
treatment for opiate addiction delivered in specialist and preferred method of applying packages of care in a
general practice settings. Other new treatments include coordinated and integrated way. Integrated care pathways
lofexidine (for opiate detoxification). For alcohol use provide a means of merging local referral and treatment
disorder, one new treatment is acamprosate, an anticraving protocols to define where and when a particular service user
medication, which is used particularly in combination with needs to be referred.
naltrexone, which has also been shown to be an effective
anticraving medicine on its own. The British Association Specialist drug services
for Psychopharmacology (BAP) [9] has recently introduced
guidelines for the treatment of addictions and comorbid In the UK, specialist drug clinics were established in the
psychiatric disorders. The BAP review findings were late 1960s and have since evolved in their dealings with
summarized in a the science review, Pharmacology and drug users [12]. These clinics provide a comprehensive
Treatment [10] (Foresight Brain Science, Addiction and service for drug users with complex needs, including
Drugs Project) (Table 2). patients with dual diagnosis (comorbid mental illness),
M.T. Abou-Saleh / Journal of Psychosomatic Research 61 (2006) 305–310 309

pregnant patients, chaotic and polydrug users, and those correlated with the probability of treatment in almost all
with a history of failed treatment attempts, violence, and countries: 35.5–50.3% of serious cases in developed
legal problems. The drive for providing community-based countries and 76.3–85.4% of serious cases in less devel-
services for drug users in the 1980s led to the development oped countries received no treatment in the 12 months
of community drug teams (CDTs) in the previous decade. before the interview. Some mild cases, especially those at
The key characteristics of CDTs include the following: risk, progress to more serious disorders.
narrowly defined geographical focus, community emphasis, In the UAE, a community-based survey has shown a very
multidisciplinary composition, and promotion of generic low rate of substance misuse (1%). However, when female
contribution through bconsultancy.Q Collaboration between participants in the survey were asked about substance
general practitioners (GPs) and primary care teams was poor misuse in first-degree male relatives, the prevalence rate
but has slowly improved. This improvement may be related increased to 9% [14]. This indicated an underreporting of
to the abandonment of the original consultancy role for the substance misuse by men, which may be related to the
CDT, which has become more actively involved in the stigma of addiction (criminality of illicit drug use and
delivery of care either directly or indirectly (on bshared- religious prohibition of alcohol use in Muslim commun-
careQ basis). ities). The prevalence of substance misuse in adolescents in
primary care was also studied in the UAE by Eapen and
Abou-Salehl (unpublished data), who showed that 5% of
Drug services in primary health care adolescents attending primary care in the city of Al-Ain
reported substance misuse. Importantly, the use of alcohol
There is a good scope for the extension of services for and drugs in adults was shown to be a strong correlate/risk
drug misusers in primary care [12]. Firstly, there are benefits factor for psychiatric disorders in first degree relative adults
such as easy access, less stigma, and early intervention. [15] and in their children [16].
Secondly, the development of community-based specialized
services has provided opportunities for effective liaison and
bshared care,Q and effective models have emerged (e.g., the Addiction services in developing countries
Edinburgh and Glasgow schemes). Thirdly, more GPs,
particularly those more recently qualified, are willing The development of services for substance misusers in
to provide care for drug misusers with the support of developing countries has been slow or nonexistent.
specialist services. National mental health programs promoted by the WHO
A successful liaison between primary care and specialist have often referred to the growth of substance misuse in
services depends on real communication, jointly agreed developing countries and the need for developing addiction
protocols (including care planning), patient contracts with services. Few countries that have developed addiction
appropriate sanctions, and regular formal reviews against services have targeted the needs of those with severe
treatment goals. With appropriate training and remuneration, addictions. In Saudi Arabia, the Al-Amal group of
methadone maintenance does have a role in general practice addiction treatment hospitals has been established to
settings, particularly for limited periods of time, in the provide detoxification treatment and social rehabilitation.
achievement of nondrug goals. Finally, since GPs accept Alcohol services are often provided by mainstream mental
medical and legal responsibility for anything they prescribe, health services. Drug treatment has been confined to
they must have the final say, and this must be accepted by detoxification for people with opiate addiction, but not
specialist services. maintenance treatment. There has been widespread resist-
ance to introducing methodone maintenance treatment for
people with opiate addiction, including those with injecting
Substance misuse in developing countries drug use. This has been related to the rather puritanical
attitude that maintenance treatment with addictive thera-
The epidemic of addictions has been increasingly peutic drugs replaces one addiction with another and that
recognized in the developing world. However, there have abstinence should be the sole aim of treatment. The WHO
been few epidemiological studies on their prevalence and has promoted flexible and comprehensive approaches to the
risk factors. Goldberg and Lecrubier [1], in a multicountry treatment of addictions in developing countries, including
survey, showed variation in the prevalence of alcohol use the provision of care and services in primary care.
disorders, with lower prevalence rates in non-European
countries such as India. The World Health Organization
(WHO)’s world mental health survey showed lower Conclusions
12-month prevalence rates for psychiatric disorders and
less treatment in developing countries than in developed Substance use disorders are common psychiatric prob-
countries, including substance misuse treatment (Lebanon, lems in all communities and are associated with great
1.3%; Nigeria, 0.8%) [13]. Moreover, disorder severity burdens on substance misusers, their families, and their
310 M.T. Abou-Saleh / Journal of Psychosomatic Research 61 (2006) 305–310

communities. They are associated with high rates of medical Ireland. Drug misuse and dependence—guidelines on clinical
management. London: The Stationary Office, 1999.
and psychiatric comorbidity, and with high mortality.
[5] Task Force to Review Services for Drug Misusers. Report of an
Evidence-based assessments and treatments have been independent review of drug treatment services in England. London:
universally established. Recent advances in psychological Department of Health, 1996.
and pharmacological treatments have enabled the provi- [6] Gossop M, Marsden J, Stewart D, Kidd T. The National Treatment
sion of effective treatments, optimal care, and appropriate Outcome Research Study (NTORS): 4–5 year follow-up results.
service models. The spectrum of substance misuse Addiction 2003;98:291 – 303.
[7] Hubbard RL, Craddock SG, Flynn PM, Anderson J, Etheridge RM.
disorders requires a spectrum of comprehensive services Overview of 1-year follow-up outcomes in Drug Abuse Treat-
to match the variable severity and complexity of the needs ment Outcome Study (DATOS). Psychol Addict Behav 1997;11:261 – 78.
of substance misusers. While substance misuse services [8] Curran V, Drummond C. Psychological treatment of substance
have been well established in western communities, there misuse and dependence. Office of Science and Technology, Depart-
ment of Trade and Industry, UK. Foresight Brain Science, Addiction
has been a large gap in the provision of these services in
and Drugs Project, 2005. Available at: http://www.foresight.gov.uk/
the developing world. It is crucial that governments and Brain_Science_Addiction_and_Drugs/Reports_and_Publications/
policy makers attend to the needs of people with ScienceReviews/Psychological%20Treatments.pdf. Accessed Febru-
substance misuse in these countries by developing com- ary 6, 2006.
prehensive community-based services, including primary- [9] Lingford-Hughes AR, Welch S, Nutt DJ, British Association
care-based services, and by providing the training require- for Psychopharmacology. Evidence-based guidelines for the phar-
macological management of substance misuse, addiction and
ments of the workforce. comorbidity: recommendations from the British Association for Psy-
Community surveys in Dubai and Al-Ain have shown a chopharmacology. Br J Psychopharmacol 2004;18:293 – 335.
high prevalence of these disorders. It is proposed that these [10] Iverson L, Morris K, Nutt D. Pharmacology and treatment. Office of
problems be dealt with in primary care settings, and it has Science and Technology, Department of Trade and Industry, UK.
been found that primary health care workers have a key role Foresight Brain Science, Addiction and Drugs Project, 2005.
Available at: http://www.foresight.gov.uk/Brain_Science_Addiction_
to play and are often in an ideal position to coordinate the and_Drugs/Reports_and_Publications/ScienceReviews/Pharmacology%
community’s response. 20and%20Treatments.pdf. Accessed February 6, 2006.
[11] Models of care for the treatment of adult drug misusers. London:
National Treatment Agency for Substance Misuse, 2002. Available at:
http://www.nta.nhs.uk. Accessed August 8, 2006.
References [12] Abou-Saleh MT, Miller J. The management of drug misuse in primary
care. Prim Care Psychiatry 1999;5:49 – 56.
[1] Goldberg DP, Lecrubier Y. From frequency of mental disorders across [13] WHO World Mental Health Survey Consortium. Prevalence,
centres. In: Ustin TB, Sartorius N, editors. Mental illness in general severity, and unmet need for treatment of mental disorders in the
health care: an international study. Chichester, UK: John Wiley and World Health Organization World Mental Health Surveys. JAMA
Sons, 1997. pp. 323–34. 2004;291:2581 – 90.
[2] Murray CJ, Lopez AD, 1996. Global burden of disease and injury [14] Abou-Saleh MT, Ghubash R, Daradkeh T. Al-Ain community
series, vol. II. Cambridge (MA)7 Global Health Statistics, Harvard psychiatric survey: I Prevalence and socio-demographic correlates.
School of Public Health, on behalf of the WHO and the World Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 2001;36:20 – 8.
Bank, 1996. [15] Ghubash R, Abou-Saleh MT. Postpartum psychiatric illness in Arab
[3] Volkow ND, Fowler JS, Wang GJ. The addicted human brain viewed culture: prevalence and psychosocial correlates. Br J Psychiatry
in the light of imaging studies: brain circuits and treatment strategies. 1997;171:65 – 8.
Neuropharmacology 2004;47:3 – 13. [16] Eapen V, Swadi H, Sabri S, Abou-Saleh M. Childhood behavioural
[4] Department of Health, The Scottish Office Department of Health, disturbance in a community sample in Al-Ain, United Arab Emirates.
Welsh Office, Department of Health and Social Security in Northern East Mediterr Health J 2001;7:428 – 34.

S-ar putea să vă placă și