{secoIeIe XVIII-XIX} FOLk ART PAINTINSS In oId Romuniun wooden churches {the 1th - 19th centuries} Horio Mifrofon MihoeIo 0hi| ezvdIuiri uIe unei urte uitute ReveIutions of u forgotten urt Am descoperit ,pe proprie piele c Romnia ascunde sumedenie de monumente uimitoare. ar uimirea este cu att mai mare cu ct adeseori nu gseti nici o publica[ie fie ea simplu pliant, ghid, ori tratat de specialitate care s te incite a le vizita. discovered with my own eyes that Romania conceals many astonishing monuments. The wonder is even greater when one often fails to find a publication be it a simple leaflet, guide or specialty treaty likely to invite one to wander around. EvangheIistuI Ioan Dimitrie Ispas din Gilu, 1824 $RB ( jude[ul $laj) John the Evonge||st D|n|t||e |:pc: c| G||cu. !824 S/F8l {Sc|cj ccunIy) Bisericile de lemn pictate sunt o categorie cu totul aparte de astfel de monumente. Ihe pcinIec wcccen churche: cre c very :pecic| ccIegcry cf :uch mcnumenI:. aterea Iui Isus ihai, fiul lui popa Ghit zugravu Plotinariu, 1833 ltenia de sub munte %he Birth of Jesus ihai, son to priest Ghit the painter Plotinariu, 1833 ltenia under the mountain /ormirea Maicii DomnuIui pictor anonim, 1775-1776, ltenia subcarpatic Dormition of the Mother of Go/ Anonymous painter, 1775-1776, $ub-Carpathian ltenia !entru fiecare dintre cei dispru[i se nal[ mai multe cruci: una lng un izvor sau fntn, o alta la un capt de punte ca s ajute sufletul s treac rul i nc una la o rspntie, ca s dezlege sufletul, dup cum ne-a explicat parohul satului, de jurmintele fcute. For each one of the dead several crosses stand: one near a spring or well, another at the end of a bridge to help the soul cross the river and another at the crossroads, to release the soul from the vows made, as the parish of the village explained to us. Rspndite n multe locuri nu doar n Maramure, aa cum [ine s ne conving o propagand turistic de serie lcaurile de lemn pictate vorbesc despre o spiritualitate romneasc a altor vremuri. $5rea/ in many 5Iaces - not onIy in Maramure as a common tourist 5ro5agan/a tries to 5ersua/e us - the 5ainte/ woo/en 5Iaces of worshi5 reveaI a Romanian s5irituaIity of yore. Creatur imaginar pictat pe o u de biseric. !osibil avertisment asupra Necuratului, care ne pndete de cum am ieit dincolo de pragul lcaului sfnt maginary creature painted on a church door. !ossible warning to $atan who watches us as soon as we step out the holy place. ecioara cu PruncuI pictor i datare necunoscute ltenia de sub munte 'irgin an/ ChiI/ unknown painter and date. ltenia under the mountain Ca decora[ie de biserici, respectivul gen de pictur este de mult ieit ,din vog. Dar l-am putea privi, n zilele noastre, i printr-o perspectiv diferit: cea a coresponden[elor cu experimente plastice ,moderniste: expresionismul, sau curentul ,secession". !entru a sugera astfel de trimiteri, prezenta selec[ie de imagini a favorizat n mod subiectiv reprezentri care se detaau prin expresivitate, prin insolit prin "stridente" dup cum le percepea cndva istoricul de art Radu Cre[eanu. N-am fcut n acest fel dect s ncercm a ncropi modeste pun[i de comunicare ntre vechi artiti cu viziunile lor adeseori contrariante i un public al secolului al XX-lea. As church decoration, that genre of painting has long been unfashionable. However nowadays we might regard it from a different perspective: that of the correspondence with "modernist artistic experiments: expressionism, or the "secession trend. n order to suggest such references, the current selection of images favoured subjectively depictions singled out due to their expressiveness, originality by "stridence, as once perceived by the art historian Radu Cre[eanu. We did nothing else but try to build modest communication links between the old artists with their often intriguing views and a 21st century audience PiI/a ceIor zece fecioare. ecioare nebune Ioan Pop din Ungurai, 1800 !f&A ( jude[ul $laj) ParabIe of the %en 'irgins. Ma/ 'irgins. Ioan Pop of Ungurai, 1800 !f&A ($laj county) Eva (fragment /in scena PcatuIui Originar) pictor anonim (coala lui Radu unteanu din Ungureni), pe la 1800 DBRC& Lf!&&L& (jude[ul Maramure) Eve (fragment from the riginal $in scene) anonymous painter (school of Radu unteanu of Ungureni), by 1800 DBRC& Lf!&&L& (Maramure county) nI|area Iui Isus Ia Ceruri pictor i datare necunoscute ara Lpuului scension unknown painter and date Lpu Country 5ostoI pictor anonim, prima jumtate a secolului al XIX-lea Muntenia subcarpatic 5ostIe anonymous painter, first half of the 19th century $ub-Carpathian Muntenia n cdutureu pinucoteciIor pe brne In Seurch of Art SuIIeries on eums aterea Iui Isus popa Ghit Siciufi din Plotina, 1819, ltenia subcarpatic %he Birth of Jesus Priest Ghit Siciufi of Plotina, 1819, $ub-Carpathian ltenia Buna vestire pictor anonim, prima jumtate a secolului al XIX-lea, Muntenia subcarpatic nnunciation anonymous painter, first half of the 19th century $ub-Carpathian Muntenia n secolul al XV-lea, urmare a politicii de reforme duse de principii fanario[i n Valahia, respectiv de monarhia habsburgic n Transilvania, apruser noi pturi de romni nstri[i. Acetia tindeau s-i decoreze ctitoriile lcauri modeste, cldite de cele mai multe ori din lemn ntr-o manier atipic: mai detaat de scheme i canoane fie acestea bizantine, baroce, ori neoclasiciste i desconsidernd monumentalul, n favoarea vervei, a sincerit[ii, a comunicrii afective. Era poate o sfidare, pe care noile clase ntreprinztoare o adresau unei aristocra[ii rmase tradi[ionaliste. During the 18th century, following the reform policies of the !hnariot principles of Wallachia, of the Habsburg monarchy in Transylvania, respectively, new categories of wealthy Romanians emerged. They used to decorate their buildings modest places, more often than not built of wood in a non-typical manner: more detached from designs and canons be they Byzantine, Baroque or neocalssical and disregarding grandeur, in favour of liveliness, sincerity, affectionate communication.t might have been a challenge, that the emerging bourgeois classes addressed to a traditional aristocracy %ierea ca5uIui $fntuIui Ioan BoteztoruI pictor anonim, 1811 LBTN (jude[ul Maramure) %he Behea/ing of $aint John the Ba5tist anonymous painter, 1811 LBTN (Maramure county) BotezuI DomnuIui popa Ghit Siciufi din Plotina, 1819 ltenia subcarpatic %he Ba5tism of Jesus Priest Ghit Siciufi of Plotina, 1819 $ub-Carpathian ltenia PiI/a ceIor zece fecioare. ecioare n|eIe5te pictor anonim, a doua jumtate a secolului al XVIII-lea RA (jude[ul Maramure) ParabIe of the %en 'irgins. Wise 'irgins anonymous painter, second half of the 18th century RA ( Maramure county) Buna vestire pictor anonim, 1775-1776 ltenia subcarpatic nnunciation anonymous painter, 1775-1776 $ub-Carpathian ltenia Isus nv|tor pictor i datare necunoscute ltenia subcarpatic Jesus as %eacher unknown painter and date $ub-Carpathian ltenia ncepnd ns cam din a doua jumtate a secolului al XX-lea, prin ,introducerea neinteligent a pictorilor brevetati i pomeniti n onitorul Oficial" (dup cum nota cndva, acid, istoricul Nicolae orga) ntreaga pictur bisericeasc avea s reintre n tipare prestabilite cele pe care le gira ierarhia superioar. However, beginning in the second half of the 19th century, by the "unintelligent introduction of the licensed painters mentioned in the fficial Gazette (as once the historian Nicolae orga bitterly remarked), the entire religious painting would resume established patterns authorized by the leadership. $fnta Paraschiva (?) pictor i datare necunoscute ltenia subcarpatic $aint Parascheva (?) unknown painter and date $ub-Carpathian ltenia Experimentului plastic romnesc nu i se va mai acorda ulterior drept de existen[ dect n arta profan. The Romanian artistic experiment would never be given a second chance but in profane art. Buna vestire, pictor i datare necunoscute ltenia subcarpatic nnunciation anonymous painter, first half of the 19th century $ub-Carpathian Muntenia Buna vestire pictor anonim, prima jumtate a secolului al XIX-lea Muntenia subcarpatic nnunciation anonymous painter, first half of the 19th century $ub-Carpathian Muntenia aterea Iui Isus popa Ghit Siciufi din Plotina, 1814 ltenia subcarpatic %he Birth of Jesus Priest Ghit Siciufi of Plotina, 1814 $ub-Carpathian ltenia aterea Iui Isus (/etaIiu) pictor anonim, 1775-1776 ltenia subcarpatic %he Birth of Jesus cncnyncu: pc|nte|. 1775-1776 $ub-Carpathian ltenia Volumul de fa[ reuete s reproduc zugrveli pstrate n 29 de vechi biserici romneti de lemn. Ele sunt rspndite n sate din ltenia, din Muntenia, precum i de pe marginile de est i de nord-vest ale Depresiunii Transilvaniei; de asemenea, n ara Lpuului - o enclav teritorial apropiat, dar artistic distinct de ceeea este denumit azi "Maramureul istoric. The present volume succeeds in reproducing depictions preserved in 29 old Romanian wooden churches. They are spread in villages in ltenia, Muntenia, as well as on the east and northwest margins of the Transylvanian Depression; meanwhile, in Lpu Country a close territorial enclave, but artistically distinct from what today we call "historic Maramure. ragment /e cata5eteasm pictor i datare necunoscute MARA (jude[ul Vlcea) Cata5etasma ragment unknown painter and date MARTA (Vlcea) Buna vestire pictor anonim, prima jumtate a secolului al XIX-lea Muntenia subcarpatic nnunciation anonymous painter, first half of the 19th century $ub-Carpathian Muntenia Rugciunea 5e MunteIe MsIiniIor pictor anonim (coala lui Radu unteanu din Ungureni), pe la 1800 DBRC& Lf!&&L& (jude[ul Maramure) Mountain of Prayer anonymous painter (school of Radu unteanu of Ungureni), by 1800 DBRC& Lf!&&L& (Maramure county) Pironirea Iui Isus 5e cruce Dimitrie Ispas din Gilu, 1802 DNGf& MC (jude[ul Cluj) %he aiIing of Jesus to the Cross Dimitrie Ispas of Gilu, 1802 DNGf& MC (Cluj county) Ju/ecata /e 5oi (fragment) pictor i datare necunoscute DBRC& Lf!&&L& (jude[ul Maramure) %he Last Ju/gement (fragment) unknown painter and date DBRC& Lf!&&L& (Maramure county) 5ostoIii %oma i BartoIomeu pictor i datare necunoscute ltenia subcarpatic %homas an/ BarthoIomew the 5ostIes unknown painter and date $ub-Carpathian ltenia 5ostoIii Ioan i PaveI pictor i datare necunoscute ltenia subcarpatic John an/ PauI the 5ostIes unknown painter and date $ub-Carpathian ltenia Majoritatea picturilor selectate nu sunt semnate. Ct pentru datare, adesea doar caracterele chirilice ale scrierii pstrate n uz pn pe la 1870 ofer indicii vagi. Most selected paintings are not signed. As for the dates, often only the Cyrillic characters of the writing used until 1870 provides vague clues. ecioara cu 5runcuI pictor anonim, 1775-1776 ltenia subcarpatic 'irgin an/ ChiI/ anonymous painter, 1775-1776 $ub-Carpathian ltenia Referitor la asemenea reprezentri ,populare", nici mcar specialitii par s nu se fi pronun[at, pn n prezent, categoric. "Cercettorul [.] trebuie s prseasc, pentru a le judeca i simti, att conceptia Renaterii, ct i ideea picturii bizantine. Fiindc e vorba de o alt lume i de o conceptie diferit de amndou. Ipotezele naivittii i trnismului nu sunt ntemeiate i nu explic nimic. Sunt numai piedici n calea pretuirii unei arte de o deosebit valoare." .D. tefnescu, 1968 Regarding such "folk depictions, not even the specialists seem to have said something definite until now. "The researcher [.] has to abandon, in order to judge and feel them, both the outlook of Renaissance, and the idea of Byzantine painting. As we deal with another world and an outlook different from both. The hypotheses of naivete and the peasant movement have no grounds and explain nothing. They only hinder the appreciation of a very precious art". .D.$tefanescu, 1968 Cina /in Mamvri 5ictor i /ate necunoscute OItenia sub-car5atic $u55er in Mamvri unknown painter and date $ub-Carpathian ltenia Rstignirea pictor i datare necunoscute ltenia subcarpatic Crucifixion unknown painter and date $ub-Carpathian ltenia Intrarea Iui Isus n IerusaIim ihai, fiul lui popa Ghit zugravu Plotinariu, 1833 ltenia de sub munte ntry into Jerusalem ihai, the son of the Priest painter Ghit Plotinariu, 1833 $ub-Carpathian ltenia $fnta Maria Egi5teanca pictor anonim, 1812 DMNN (jude[ul $laj) Saint ary of gypt unknown painter 1812 DMNN (county $laj) &n privitor occidental contemporan acestei arte se declara, la rndul lui, ncntat, cu toate c l contraria mesajul echivoc al imaginlor. ntr-un iurnal de cltorie n Transilvania, publicat ntr-o revist vienez de pe la 1845, el sesiza "multimea figurilor de necrezut care te privesc ptrunztor, pe de o parte cu zmbet, pe de alta scrnind din dinti". A Western on the contemporary arts declare, in turn, delighted, although it displease equivocal message of the images. n a diurnal travel in Transylvania, published in a magazine Viennese from the 1845, he refer "Unbelievable crowd figures I look shrewd, on the one hand with the smile on the other grind. " Rstignirea pictor i datare necunoscute !R&MBEN ( jude[ul Mure) Crucifixion unknown painter and date !R&MBEN (Mure county) EvangheIist Porfirie de la Feisa, 1852 DEAG (jude[ul Mure) EvangeIist !orphyry from Feisa, 1852 DEAG (Mure county) $rutuI Iu/ei i 5rin/erea Iui Isus (/etaIiu) pictor i datare necunoscute R& ( jude[ul Mure) Ju/as Kiss an/ Jesus' Ca5ture (/etaiI) unknown painter and date R& (Mure county) 5ostoIuI Iu/a pictor i datare necunoscute ltenia subcarpatic Ju/as the 5ostIe unknown painter and date $ub-Carpathian ltenia Ceea ce uimete n primul rnd la aceste picturi este de excesul de stilizare i de decorativism. Realitatea vizibil este att de distorsionat n acele imagini, nct ajungi s te ntrebi dac zugravii lor nu erau cumva nite mucali[i - un fel de on Creang ai vizualului. What astonishes most in these paintings is the excessive stylization and decoration. The visible reality is so distorted in these images, that one wonders if their painters were not funny people a sot of on Creang of the visual. $rutuI Iu/ei i 5rin/erea Iui Isus pictor anonim, 1812 DMNN (jude[ul $laj) Ju/as Kiss an/ Jesus' Ca5ture anonymous painter, 1812 DMNN ($laj county) Nu este mai pu[in surprinztor s descoperi cum, aceiai zugravi, excelau atunci cnd pe chipurile personajelor sacre reprezentau expresii de ndoial, de deziluzie, ori chiar de derut. Erau ,uitate tririle imperturbabile, abstracte, ale canoanelor bizantine, ori gesturile patetice caracteristice barocului, adoptat de catolicismul din acele vremuri. t is no less surprising to find out how the same painters excelled whenever on the faces of the holy characters they depicted expressions of doubt, disillusion, or even disarray. They used to "forget the abstract poise feelings of the Byzantine canons, or characteristic Baroque pathetic gestures, adopted by Catholicism of those times. DubI re5rezentare a Iui Iona vrsat 5e 5mnt /in 5nteceIe chituIui pictor anonim (coala lui Radu unteanu din Ungureni), pe la 1800 DBRC& Lf!&&L& (jude[ul Maramure) DoubIe /e5iction of Jonas taken out to earth from the beIIy of the whaIe anonymous painter (school of Radu unteanu of Ungureni), by 1800 DBRC& Lf!&&L& (Maramure county) n ceea ce ne privete, credem c picturile n cauz au conservat ceva din spiritul reformator al secolului n care au nceput s se nasc - al XV-lea, supranumit ,al luminilor": o n[elegere mai tolerant a naturii umane, cu o abordare uneori familiar, poate i uor umoristic a sacrului. As far as we are concerned, we think that the paintings in question have conserved something of the reforming spirit of the century in which they emerged the 18th century, called "enlightenment: a more tolerant understanding of human nature, a sometimes familiar approach, maybe slightly humorous, to the sacred. PiI/a ceIor zece fecioare. ecioare nebune Iosif Perso, paroh al lciului ,1831 VVDEN ( jude[ul $laj) ParabIe of the %en 'irgins. Ma/ 'irgins osif !erso, parishioner of Elciu, 1831 VVDEN ($laj county) 5ostoIuI PaveI Gheorghe, Latco, 1807, ltenia de sub munte PauI the 5ostIe Gheorghe, La[co, 1807, ltenia under the mountain PiI/a ceIor zece fecioare. ecioare nebune pictor anonim, a doua jumtate a secolului al XVIII-lea RA (jude[ul Maramure) ParabIe of the %en 'irgins. Ma/ 'irgins. anonymous painter, second half of the 18th century RA ( Maramure county) Buna vestire pictor anonim, prima jumtate a secolului al XIX-lea ltenia subcarpatic nnunciation anonymous painter, first half of the 19th century $ub-Carpathian ltenia Isus nv|tor pictor i datare necunoscute ltenia subcarpatic Jesus as %eacher unknown painter and date $ub-Carpathian ltenia $fntuI Dumitru Anghel, Ioan, Badea, rin, 1833 pictur actulamente distrus prin degradarea progresiv, n decurs de c[ia ani, a bisericii de lemn prsite. $aint Dumitru Anghel, Ioan, Badea, rin, 1833 A painting currently destroyed through gradual degradation,, during several years, of the abandoned wooden church. $e vede treaba c fenomenul plastic asociat bisericilor de lemn i caut, nc, terenuri de de inter-rela[ionare: ntre vechii pictori, izola[i n arhipelagurile lor de candoare, i un public contemporan, npdit de potopurile vizuale ale secolului XX. ar undeva pe la mijloc - "riscndu-se s fac oficiul de !.R. - s-au nimerit autorii acestui album. t is clear that the artistic phenomenon associated with the wooden churches is still in search of intertwining fields: among the old painters, isolated in their islands of candor, and a contemporary audience, stifled by the visual seas of the 21st century. And somewhere in the middle "risking a !.R. role the authors of this album. 58 CUPRI$ DezvIuiri aIe unei arte uitate............3 n cutarea 5inacoteciIor 5e brne.........19 %E%$ #eve|ot|ons o| o |orgotten ort..............3 In $eorch o| Art Go||er|es on 8eoms...........1 58 Heruvim Chrerubim $frit / End Realizatori: Vasile Andrei Florentina &drea