Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
pump-zone.com
The Magazine for Pump Users Worldwide
pump-zone.com
November 2011
Special Section:
Predictive & Preventive
Maintenance
ChemShow Coverage
CHEMICAL
PUMPS
Equipment in
Harsh Applications
CHEMICAL
PUMPS
Equipment in
Harsh Applications
From ITT comes Xylem.
Xylem is a world leader in the design, manufacturing and application of highly engineered technologies for the water
industry. We are 12,000 people uniied in a common purpose: creating innovative solutions to global water challenges.
We know this is only achieved when partnering closely with our customers. We are committed to continuing the product
innovation and forward thinking youve come to expect from the collection of market-leading brands in the Xylem
portfolio. For more information on what this transformative shift can mean to your business, go to xyleminc.com.
xyleminc.com
LETS FOCUS OUR
EFFORTS ON EARTHS
LETS SOLVE
WATER.
MOST VALUABLE
RESOURCE.
circle 104 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
PUMP TUBING
THATS STRONGER.
AND LASTS LONGER.
Its a stronger tube, for a stronger bottom line.
Introducing GORE
peristaltic pump
tubing, because its reinforced
with multiple layers of tough,
durable ePTFE. Whats more,
GORE
, Garlock
Sealing Technologies
Kirk Wilson, Vice President/General Manager,
Integrated Solutions Group, & Vice President
Marketing, Engineering & Technology, Flowserve
Corporation
American-made, API 541 Fourth Edition and API 547 First
Edition, large AC induction motors from Siemens deliver
unrivalled life expectancy, energy efficiency, and the
lowest Total Cost of Ownership.
State-of-the-art manufacturing processes allow our
customers to benefit from the broadest range of power
outputs (up to 18,000 HP and 13.2 kV), lower noise and
operating temperature, minimized vibration, smaller
footprint, and the toughest, most reliable motors
available anywhere in the world.
www.usa.siemens.com/motors
Petroleum and Chemical Industry Applications
With decades of proven performance in both critical and
severe duty refining and processing applications and the
power of a global R&D team, Siemens delivers innovation
and excellence in every motor we build.
Siemens is the leading provider of electric motors
worldwide and the leading provider of electric motors to
the petroleum and chemical industries. What can we build
for you to make your job easier?
The most reliable, longest lasting API 541
and API 547 certified Above NEMA motors.
Siemens meets both American Petroleum Institute standards with
the fewest comments or exceptions.
2
0
1
1
S
i
e
m
e
n
s
I
n
d
u
s
t
r
y
,
I
n
c
.
circle 110 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
4 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
SPECIAL SECTION:
PREDICTIVE & PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE
p
Pump Vibration Analysis
Brian P. Graney, MISTRAS Group, Inc.
Monitoring vibrationa valuable tool in predictive/preventive maintenance
programs.
p
Predictive & Preventive Maintenance
Michael Walsh, GE Energy
Do not let a catastrophic event be your wake-up call to adopt a proactive
strategy.
COVER SERIES:
CHEMICAL PUMPS
p
Peristaltic Pumps in
Chemical Applications
Rick Balek, Watson-Marlow Bredel Pumps
Providing a low life-cycle choice for chemical metering
p
Safe Chemical Transfer
Mark L. Jones, Asahi America
The development of PE resin for industrial piping applications
p
ChemShow 2011
SEALING
p
New Leak Prevention Technology
Jack Tyler, P.E., Jack Tyler Engineering Company,
& Art Evans, Art Evans & Associates
Air-operated piston assembly, injectable packing and air ush
enhance this sealing systems performance in harsh applications.
p
Oil & Gas Project Sets New Standards
Ellen Klier & Franz Schfer, EagleBurgmann Germany
Tailored sealing solutions supply high-pressure sealing for Russias
East Siberia Pacic Ocean pipeline system.
PRACTICE & OPERATIONS
p
Safe Flushing
Ken Comerford, Vanton Pump and Equipment Corp.
Remove grit from pumped uids to safely ush bearings and seals
Table of Contents
DEPARTMENTS
P&S News. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
Pump Ed 101 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
Joe Evans, Ph.D.
Suction Specic Speed and Wastewater Pumps
Pumping Prescriptions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
Luis Rizo, SABIC Innovative Plastics, & Lev Nelik,
Contributing Editor, P&S Editorial Advisory Board
How to Size Shims
Centrifugal Pump Hydraulics by the Numbers . . . . 22
Terry Henshaw
The Impact of the Area Ratio
Efficiency Matters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
Dale Evers, EnviroGear
The Real Golden Age of Sealless Pumps
Maintenance Minders. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44
Ross George, Littelfuse, Inc.
Microprocessor-Based Pump/Motor Protection Relays
FSA Sealing Sense. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48
What are the key steps to cutting packing for optimum
performance?
HI Pump FAQs. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 52
What is a balanced mechanical seal, and when is it usually used?
What is a pusher type seal, and what are the advantages of this
design? What is an energy efcient method for controlling the rate
of ow in pumping systems?
Product Pipeline . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 66
Index of Advertisers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68
P&S Market. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72
November 2011
Volume 19 Number 11
The Magazine for Pump Users Worldwide November 2011
pump-zone.com
The Magazine for Pump Users Worldwide
pump-zone.com
November 2011
Special Section:
Predictive & Preventive
Maintenance
ChemShow Coverage
CHEMICAL
PUMPS
Equipment in
Harsh Applications
CHEMICAL
PUMPS
Equipment in
Harsh Applications
24
29
33
36
39
56
60
63
A
c
h
e
m
i
c
a
l
f
a
c
t
o
r
y
i
n
L
e
u
n
a
,
G
e
r
m
a
n
y
.
C
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
K
S
B
T8P 0H2 deliveries in
15-19 weeks ex factor]
T8NP BB8 deliveries in
22-25 weeks ex factor]
0ther APl models under
8O weeks ex factor]
Industry Leaders in API & Process
Deliveries!
Visit us online for literature and specications on
our full line of API and Process pumps
www.trulo.com
7105 Cessna Drive
Greensboro, NC 27409
336-664-9225 (Phone)
336-664-1353 (Fax)
API Pump Deliveries
From 15-17 Weeks
Ex Factory
ANSI Process Pumps
Immediate Delivery
T8P 00H2 deliveries in P H e
Ex Factory
Nost Ah8l process pump models
availaole for immediate off-shelf
deliver]
wide variet] of metallic and
non-metallic magnetic drive
pumps to 5OOhp
Increased production capacity
online Nov. 15, 2011 with 7000hp
testing capabilities!
OPENING NOV. 2011
circle 112 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
6 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
P&S News
NEW HIRES, PROMOTIONS &
RECOGNITIONS
SIEMENS (ATLANTA, GA.) announced
that Daryl Dulaney has been appointed
chief executive o cer of the companys
newly-formed Infrastructure & Cities (IC)
Sector in North America, which comprises
the U.S., Canada, Mexico and Central
America. Dulaney will also continue to
serve as president and chief executive
o cer of Siemens Industry, Inc., the legal entity comprising
both the Infrastructure & Cities and Industry Sectors in the U.S.
Siemens Infrastructure & Cities Sector provides inte-
grated mobility solutions, building and security technology,
power distribution, smart grid applications and low- and
medium-voltage products.
www.usa.siemens.com/infrastructure-cities
ANVIL INTERNATIONAL (PORTSMOUTH,
N.H.) announced that Todd Beckley has
joined the company as mechanical special-
ist covering Kansas, Missouri, Nebraska
and Iowa. Jim Roland has joined the com-
pany as Mechanical/Industrial Specialist for
the Midwest Region.
he company also announced the pro-
motion of Shawn Farrell to national mate-
rial control manager. Farrell has been with
Anvil for 19 years, serving for the past ten
years as a material control manager, with
responsibility for the Midwest, Northeast
and Canadian Regions.
Anvil International, a subsidiary of
Mueller Water Products Inc., is a manu-
facturer of pipe ttings, pipe hangers and
piping support for a wide range of applica-
tionsincluding plumbing and mechani-
cal, HVAC, industrial, re protection,
mining and oil and gas. www.anvilintl.com
BEARINGS PLUS (PEWAUKEE, WIS.)
announced that Dr. Bugra Ertas has been
appointed as the business unit director at
Bearings Plus. From 2000 through 2004,
Dr. Ertas collaborated with Bearings
Plus on development projects and rotor-
dynamic analyses. His work was instru-
mental in the upgrade of machinery with
new technology products.
Bearings Plus, a business of Waukesha Bearings
Corporation, designs, manufactures and services uid lm
bearings, seals and exible couplings for turbomachinery
applications. www.bearingsplus.com
NOV MONOFLO (HOUSTON, TEXAS)
announced that Dwight Waters joined
the NOV Monoo team as sales director.
Waters brings 20 years of international
selling, consulting, project management,
engineering and distribution experience in
the PC pump industry.
NOV Monoo manufactures pro-
gressing cavity pumps. www.monoo.com
FLUID AUTOMATION (GATESHEAD, U.K.)
announced that Kate Kilday has been
appointed the new role of sales develop-
ment and marketing manager. he manu-
facturer has created the role with the aim of
U.K. sales development and brand growth.
Fluid Automation is a
manufacturer of pumps and
pumping systems. www.uidautomation.co.uk
AROUND THE INDUSTRY
LAROX FLOWSYS (LITHICUM, MD.) changed its name to
Flowrox, eective September 15, 2011. he reason for the
signicant renewal of the corporate brand and image is the
recent acquisition of the parent company Larox by Outotec.
he pump and valve supplier Larox Flowsys was not included
in the deal and continues to develop and grow its business as
an independent company.
Flowrox provides solutions for abrasive, corrosive and
other demanding shut-o, control, pumping and dosing
applications serving a range of process industries.
www.owrox.com
WILO USA LLC (MELROSE PARK, ILL.) announced that its
corporate o ces moved to Rosemont, Ill. he rst business
day at the new facility was October 3, 2011.
WILO manufacturers pumps and pump systems for
heating, cooling and air-conditioning technology, water
supply and sewage and drainage. www.wilo-usa.com
KSB (HENRICO, VA.) will supply 20 pump sets worth several
million dollars for one of Mexicos largest infrastructure proj-
ectsa combined wastewater/stormwater pumping station
planned for completion in 2012. he KSB pumps involved
are the largest submersible motor units in the companys his-
tory. Each pump can handle 2,000 liters per second at a head
of almost 44 meters.
KSB produces pump products for industrial and utility
power plant services, environmental applications and water
and wastewater processing. www.ksbusa.com
KISTLER (FARMINGTON HILLS, MICH.) announced the
opening of its latest group company in Mexico, Kistler Instru-
Daryl Dulaney
Dwight Waters
Kate Kilday
Dr. Bugra Ertas
Todd Beckley
Jim Roland
Shawn Farrell
circle 111 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
8 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
ments S de R.L. de C.V., based in Mon-
terrey NL, Mexico.
Kistler provides sensors and instru-
mentation that are used in R&D and
critical manufacturing operations.
www.kistler.com
NETZSCH (EXTON, PA.) announced the
expansion of the distribution territory of
Voigt-Abernathy from Alabama and the
Florida panhandle to include Eastern
Tennessee. Voigt-Abernathy will service
the industrial, chemical, pulp and paper
industries in this region.
NETZSCH oers progressing
cavity pumps, rotary lobe pumps, mac-
erators, dosing systems and accessories.
www.netzschusa.com
RUHRPUMPEN (TULSA, OKLA.)
announced that it acquired TIGER-
FLOW Systems, LLC. TIGERFLOW
manufactures packaged pumping sys-
tems for domestic water, re water sys-
tems, HVAC, industrial, heat transfer,
municipal, landscape irrigation and cus-
tom controls. It will continue operations
at the Dallas, Texas, manufacturing loca-
tion and will operate as an independent
subsidiary.
Ruhrpumpen manufactures centrif-
ugal pumps for the oil and gas, chemi-
cal, power, industrial, water and mining
applications. www.ruhrpumpen.com
NORD-LOCK (MATTMAR,
SWEDEN) acquired U.S.
company Superbolt Inc. and
Swiss company P&S
Vorspannssysteme AG. Superbolt and
P&S oer products for critical bolting
applications. he products are used in
heavy industries such as oshore, energy
and mining.
NORD-LOCK manufactures
securing systems for bolted joints.
www.nord-lock.com
THE FLUID SEALING ASSOCIATION
FSA(WAYNE, PA.) announced the
enhancement of its Mechanical Seal Life
Cycle Cost Estimator, which allows end
users to estimate life cycle costs for seal-
ing solutions on a comparative basis to
P&S News
CeraComp Components
45678
Greene, Tweed & Co.
|
PetroChem & Power
|
Tel: +1.281.765.4500
www.gtweed.com
08/11-GT AD-US-PP-011
A single pump failure can disrupt your plant for days bringing
production to a halt and impacting your bottom line.
Replacing your silicon-carbide components with CeraComp dramatically
reduces your risk of pump failures! This new ceramic-matrix composite
offers the chemical and thermal resistance you require with the increased
toughness and fracture resistance youve been looking for. CeraComps
superior material properties deliver increased reliability and MTBR (mean
time between repair), eliminating catastrophic failure and keeping your
plant running efciently.
Contact Greene, Tweed today to learn more about this exciting new material!
Wouldnt it be great
if everything was
FRACTURE RESISTANT?
c
i
r
c
l
e
1
1
5
o
n
c
a
r
d
o
r
g
o
t
o
p
s
f
r
e
e
i
n
f
o
.
c
o
m
STOP
WASTING
CHEMICALS
SMART
DOSING NOW
With precise dosing you can reduce chemical waste
and increase savings
Grundfos SMART Digital Dosing
angular contact ball bearings are designed for the demands of pump and compressor
applications. Engineered with state-of-the-art material technology, this innovative product offers
an optimized internal design, high load ratings and 15-20% increased limiting speed. For maximum
speed, performance and up to 90% longer bearing life, Think NSK.
MAXIMUM SPEED. MAXIMUM LIFE.
MAXIMUM PERFORMANCE.
circle 108 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
22 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
I
n March 1980, I attended the ASME symposium on
Predicting the Performance of Centrifugal Pumps and
Compressors in New Orleans. I was about three rows
from the podium, sitting next to a fellow who introduced
himself as Hal Anderson from Scotland. He said that he
had one foot on his motorbike and the other in the grave. It
turned out that he was H. H. Anderson of area-ratio fame
and was at the symposium to deliver a paper on his area-
ratio principle.
As we walked to the cafeteria and ate lunch together,
Anderson was approached by people requesting his auto-
graph (one was from Australia). He was well-known and well-
respectedand his area-ratio principle was well-founded.
Anderson introduced the area-ratio principle in 1938
[1]. he denition is:
Y =
A
R2
A
4
(1)
Where:
A
R2
= total relative discharge area of impeller = b
2
L
R2
b
2
= width of impeller vane at the outside diameter
(OD) of the impeller
L
R2
= distance from discharge vane tip to the closest
point on adjacent vane
A
4
= total throat area
Figures 1 and 2 illustrate the two areas.
Andersons work (1, 2, 4, 5) showed a denite correla-
tion between Y and N
S
(specic speed). he higher values of
Y correlated to lower values of specic speed. Both horne
[3] and Jekat [6] also wrote about the area ratio principle.
What seems to be the most useful is contained in reference
6.
Figure 3 is a redrawn graph from Jekat [6], with straight
lines substituted for slightly curved lines. he text says that
the band results from the authors data and shows the con-
siderable range of area ratios which are used in actual pump
designs. (Jekat recommended against extrapolating the
graph to lower values of N
S
.) It is possible to write equa-
tions for the (straightened) lines on the graph. Jekats high
e ciency line can be expressed as:
Terry Henshaw
The Impact of the Area Ratio
Centrifugal Pump Hydraulics by the Numbers
Figure 1. Partial impeller plan view showing pertinent perfor-
mance parameters
Figure 2. Partial impeller prole view showing pertinent
performance parameters
Figure 3. Jekats chart plotting 1/Y, the inverse of the area
ratio, as a function of N
s
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com NOVEMBER 2011 23
Y =
275
N
s
(2)
where N
S
is dened by the following equation:
N
S
=
NQ
bep
(H
bep
)
0.75
(3)
Where, in U.S. units:
N
S
= specic speed
N = rotative speed of impeller
(revolutions/minute)
Q
bep
= capacity of pump at the
best e ciency point (gallons/
minute)
H
bep
= head of a single stage of the
pump at the best-e ciency-
point (feet)
I have obtained high-e ciency
pumps with numerators ranging from
2,450 to 2,750. Note that a Y value of
1.0 occurs where N
S
is about 2,500,
right in the middle of the Worthington
graph, right where maximum pump
e ciencies reach their peak. Is that just
a coincidence? (To view the graph, see
Centrifugal Pump Specic Speed in
Pumps & Systems, September 2011.)
hree years after that visit in New
Orleans, I wrote to Mr. Anderson with
a question about throat area. My letter
was returned, unopened, containing a
hand-written note gone away. Had he
taken his second foot from his motor-
bike and placed it also into the grave? I
never heard.
P&S
References
1. Anderson, H. H., he Harland Engineering
Company, Scotland, he Hydraulic Design
of Centrifugal Pumps and Water Turbines,
ASME paper 61-WA-320, American Society of
Mechanical Engineers, New York, N.Y., 1961.
2. Anderson, H. H., he area ratio system,
World Pumps magazine, June 1984.
3. horne, E. W., Worthington-Simpson Ltd.
U.K., Design by the Area Ratio Method,
Pumps 1979, Sixth Technical Conference of
the British Pump Manufacturers Association,
Canterbury, England, 28 30 March, 1979.
4. Anderson, H. H., Prediction of Head,
Quantity and E ciency in Pumps the Area
Ratio Principle, he 22nd Annual Fluids
Engineering Conference, he American
Society of Mechanical Engineers, New
Orleans, La., March 9 13, 1980.
5. Anderson, H. H., Weir Group, Centrifugal Pumps, hird Edition, Trade &
Technical Press LTD., England, 1980.
6. Jekat, Walter K., Centrifugal Pump heory, Section 2.1 of the rst
edition of the Pump Handbook, edited by Karassik, Krutzsch, and Fraser,
McGraw-Hill Book Co., New York, N.Y., 1976.
Terry Henshaw is a retired engineer living in Magnolia,
Texas. He worked 50-plus years in the pump industry. He
can be reached at pumprof@att.net.
VFD-Induced
Bearing Currents
Kill Motors!
SGR
BEARING PROTECTION RING
Save energy with a VFD, Save your motor with
Proven in hundreds of thousands of
installations, the AEGIS
SGR protects
motor bearings from damaging VFD-
induced currents and extends motor life.
It also dramatically reduces downtime
and improves the reliability of motor-
driven equipment and systems.
U
Safely channels harmful currents away
from bearings to ground
U
Maintenance-free, easy to install, lasts
for life of motor
U
Standard sizes and universal mounting
kit for any motor
To download a free technical paper on bearing
protection technologies, visit our website:
1-866-738-1857 | sales @ est-aegis.com
www.est-aegis.com
Garlock SGi Ring combines
AEGIS
bearing protection
with a bearing isolation seal
SGR Installed
Universal Mounting Kit
circle 122 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
24 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Special Section: Predictive & Preventive Maintenance
T
he most revealing information
on the condition of rotating
machinery is a vibration signa-
ture, according to some sources. his
article will introduce the basics of using
vibration data to determine the mechan-
ical condition of pumps and implement
it in a predictive/preventive mainte-
nance program. Vibration consists of
amplitude, frequency and direction.
hese provide the information needed
to diagnose the machines condition.
Pumps come in several types (such
as centrifugal, turbo, propeller and posi-
tive displacement). hey generate pump-
ing frequencies due to ow and recircu-
lation (i.e., number of vanes multiplied
by rpm for centrifugal/turbo pumps or
number of screws, lobes or axial piston
for positive displacement pumps).
Pumps also have other mechanical prob-
lemsimbalance, misalignment, loose-
ness, worn bearings, pipe strain and
resonance.
Vibration measurements are taken on each
bearing location in three planes: vertical, hori-
zontal and axial. he diagnostic information from
vibration analysis will be determined by:
Severity Amplitude In/Sec Peak
Frequency Cycles per Minute CPM or Hz
Cycles per Second
he direction of the vibra-
tion measurement or plane of
measurement will also determine
the machine vibratory prob-
lem. Since vibration can occur
throughout a broad frequency
range, Table 3 has recommended
frequency ranges and lines of
resolution to help nd particu-
lar machine problems. Severity
Pump Vibration Analysis
Brian P. Graney, MISTRAS Group, Inc.
Monitoring vibrationa valuable tool in predictive/preventive maintenance programs
Table 1. Overall Vibration Standards Velocity In/Sec Peak
STANDARD MEASUREMENT ALERT LEVEL ALARM LEVEL
Hydraulic Inst. Casing 0.3
ISO 2372 Casing 0.25 0.6
E.P.R.I. FP 754 Shaft 0.5 0.8
A.P.I. 610 Shaft 0.4
Rathbone Chart Casing 0.3 0.6
Figure 1. Vibration severity chart with frequency as follows: Left - Velocity In/Sec Peak,
Bottom - Frequency in CPM, Top Diagonal Down - Displacement Mils Peak-Peak
Table 2. Overall vibration velocity guide line for various motor pump assemblies and speeds
Machine Type
1000+ RPM ALERT FAULT ADVANCED. FAULT
Motor/Pump Horizontal Centrifugal 0.3 0.45 0.6
Motor/Pump Horiz. Belt Driven Centrifugal 0.4 0.6 0.8
Motor /Pump Vertical Centrifugal (<5) 0.3 0.45 0.6
Motor/Pump Vertical Centrifugal (5<8) 0.4 0.6 0.8
Motor/Pump Vertical Centrifugal (8<12) 0.5 0.75 1
Motor/Pump Horizontal Hydraulic 0.2 0.3 0.4
(continued on page 25)
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com NOVEMBER 2011 25
indicates how bad the problem
(Table 2) is, and frequency indi-
cates what is causing the problem
(Table 4). Vibration measure-
ments have three dierent ampli-
tudes as follows:
Displacement Mils
Peak-Peak:
Good for determining movement of
the machine
Turning speed vibration levels
Normally used to measure large
sleeve bearing machines
Severity requires the need to know
the frequency
Velocity In/Sec Peak:
Used for broad frequency ranges 100
Cpm 120,000.00 Cpm
he most common measurement
used for machine vibration analysis
Velocity severity is independent of
frequency, which is why it is used by
most severity guidelines
Acceleration Gs RMS
Good for determining high-fre-
quency vibration problems due to
worn rolling element bearings or
gears
Severity requires the need to know
the frequency
When analyzing vibration data, an
FFT vibration spectrum may be broken
down into several frequency ranges to
help determine the machine problem.
Commercially available machine vibra-
tion software has narrow band selective
alarming, which is used to help screen
vibration data and assist the analyst in
determining the machine problem.
Horizontal center hung centrifugal
pumps and vertical center hung cen-
trifugal pumps have dierent vibration
measurement locations. For images of
these locations, please go to www.pump-
zone.com.
Overall vibration severity is used for
determining the condition of a machine.
here are several standards and guide-
lines for determining severity of machine
vibration as shown in Table 1.
600-900 RPM
Motor/Pump Horizontal Centrifugal 0.27 0.4 0.54
Motor/Pump Horiz. Belt Driven Centrifugal 0.36 0.54 0.72
Motor /Pump Vertical Centrifugal (<5) 0.27 0.4 0.54
Motor/Pump Vertical Centrifugal (5<8) 0.36 0.54 0.72
Motor/Pump Vertical Centrifugal (8<12) 0.45 0.675 0.9
Motor/Pump Horizontal Hydraulic 0.18 0.27 0.36
Table 2. (continued from page 24)
Upstream and Midstream Screw Pumps for Oil & Gas
Call us, or visit www.leistritzcorp.com/pumps
Leistritz Corporation, 165 Chestnut St., Allendale, NJ 07401 (201) 934-8262
Learn more. Contact Leistritz or visit its website for complete details.
Simple designrugged dependability.
Leistritz two- and three-rotor,
positive displacement screw
pumps transport light to
heavy crude oil, blends and
emulsions - ideally suited for
pipeline boosting, terminal
loading and unloading, as
well as transfer applications.
And do it trouble-free: without pulsations or vapor locking, and
efciently handle viscous products - reducing operating costs.
HEAVY DUTY CRUDE OIL
PUMPS FROM LEISTRITZ
circle 126 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
See Us At PowerGen Booth 2818
26 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Special Section: Predictive & Preventive Maintenance
Table 4. Frequency diagnostic chart to help determine the machine problem
Frequency Plane Problem
1 x rpm Radial Imbalance - Sinusoidal TWF
1 x rpm Radial Eccentric Rotor/Sheave
1 3 x rpm Radial/Axial Misalignment - Sinusoidal TWF
1 2 x rpm Axial Bent Shaft
Multiplies of rpm, with orders Radial Rotor Rub - Truncated Time Wave Form
1 x rpm Vertical Looseness - Structural - Asymmetrical TWF
Multiplies of rpm Radial Looseness - Mechanical - Impacting TWF
1 x rpm Radial Resonance 3:1 Amplitude Difference
1 x rpm Vertical Bearing Clearance - Sleeve Bearing
Multiplies of rpm Vertical Bearing Wear - Sleeve Bearing
.4 x rpm Radial Oil Whirl Sleeve Bearing
1 x rpm Axial Thrust Clearance Sleeve
Multiple, non-synchronous peaks Radial/Axial Roller Bearings High Frequency
#Vanes x rpm Radial Vane Passing - Cavitations Pump
0.4 x rpm of pump Radial Turbulence Pump
Multiplies of rpm Radial Reciprocating - Compressors Diesel
#Gear Teeth x rpm Radial Gear Meshing Gears
Multiplies of sub-synchronous vibration Radial Drive Belt Wear - Belt Driven
2 x Line frequency - LF Radial/Axial Electrical Vibration - Motors - Generators
#Rotor bars x rpm side bands at 2 x LF Radial High Frequency Electrical Vibration
#Stator slots x rpm side bands at 2 x LF Radial High Frequency Electrical Vibration
6 x Line Frequency Radial/Axial High Frequency Electrical Vibration
1 x rpm - side bands at slip frequency Radial/Axial Broken Rotor Bar
Table 3. General guidelines for how to set up motor/pump assembliesfrequency ranges,
lines of resolution, averaging typefor various speed ranges and bearing type
Machine Type RPM BRG Type Orders x RPM Fmax - Hz LOR Averaging # Averages
Motor/Pmp 450 Roller 50 375 800 Normal 6
Motor/Pmp 514 Roller 50 428 800 Normal 6
Motor/Pmp 600 Roller 50 500 800 Normal 6
Motor/Pmp 720 Roller 50 600 800 Normal 6
Motor/Pmp 900 Roller 50 750 800 Normal 6
Motor/Pmp 1,200 Roller 50 1000 1600 Normal 6
Motor/Pmp 1,800 Roller 50 1500 1600 Normal 6
Motor/Pmp 3,600 Roller 50 3000 3200 Normal 6
Motor/Pmp 450 Sleeve 20.0 150 400 Peak-Hold 6
Motor/Pmp 600 Sleeve 20.0 200 400 Peak-Hold 6
Motor/Pmp 900 Sleeve 20.0 300 800 Peak-Hold 6
Motor/Pmp 1,200 Sleeve 20.0 400 800 Peak-Hold 6
Motor/Pmp 1,800 Sleeve 20.0 600 800 Peak-Hold 6
Motor/Pmp 3,600 Sleeve 20.0 1200 1600 Peak-Hold 6
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com NOVEMBER 2011 27
Case Study
A boiler feed pumpa horizontal centrifugal pump with a
roller bearinghad a history of elevated vibration levels at
turning speed (3,525 rpm) in the horizontal plane. his was
due to imbalance and oset misalignment.
his pumps problem was that the outer pump bearing,
horizontal plane, had roller bearing deterioration. he rapid
rate of bearing deterioration was due
to the increased load from the turning
speed vibration in the horizontal plane.
How can this data be analyzed?
he overall vibration velocity levels
are over 0.8749 In/Sec Peak (Refer to
Table 2 for three tier alarm criteria for
1,000-plus rpm horizontal centrifugal
pump). Overall vibration was in excess
of 0.6 In/Sec Peak which indicates an
advanced fault. Refer to Figure 1. Go
to the left-hand side, amplitude In/Sec
Peak, and look up 0.8749 In/Sec Peak
which indicates danger failure near.
he turning Speed Vibration is
more than 0.486 In/Sec Peak. Refer to
severity in Figure 1 with amplitude on
the left-hand side and frequency along
the bottom in Cpm. Machine speed
vibration is occurring at 3,525 Cpm
with an amplitude of 0.486 In/Sec Peak.
Cross reference amplitude and the fre-
quency is on the boundary of danger
failure near. Refer to Table 4, frequency
diagnostic chart, Line 1, Imbalance.
he Non-Synchronous Peaks due
to fault frequencies at 3.2 multiplied by
the turning speed is the roller bearing,
ball pass frequency outer (BPFO). his
indicates an outer race defect. he high-
est amplitude of this defect is 0.171 In/
Sec Peak at the fourth harmonic of the
fault frequency. Refer to Figure 1, cross
reference amplitude 0.171 In/Sec Peak
with frequency at 44,770 Cpm - danger
failure near. Refer to Table 4, frequency
diagnostic chart, Line 13, roller bearing,
non-synchronous peaks.
When a rolling element bearing
is failing, it produces high frequency
vibration, therefore generating high
acceleration levels measured in gs. his
is another severity indication of how
advanced the bearing deterioration had
becomea time wave form amplitude
of 121 gs Peak-Peak with an RMS value
of 16.2 gs. Refer to Figure 1, acceleration
right-hand side of chart bottom diagonal up, 16.2 gs RMS
indicates danger shut down.
Refer to Table 5 and nd the trend data 1st and 2nd bear-
ing bands. he amplitudes are 0.827 In/Sec Peak and 0.278 In/
Sec Peak. he rst bearing band alarm is 0.12 In/Sec Peak, 40
percent of the overall level. he second bearing band alarm is
0.09 In/Sec Peak, 30 percent of the overall level.
I0Ba]pqnao
5 Year Warranty
10,000:1 Turndown
NSF Standard 61
Tube Failure
Detection
Brushless DC Motor
Sold and serviced
exclusively
by highly skilled,
factory authorized
technicians
5300 Business Drive, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 USA
714-893-8529
fax: 714-894-9492
sales@blue-white.com
www.bluwhite.com
III
?DAI*BAA@
AJCEJAANA@OGE@
OUOPAI
Ba]pqnao
Single and Dual Pump Systems
Chemical resistant construction
Lightweight, can be shipped UPS
circle 118 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
28 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Special Section: Predictive & Preventive Maintenance
Based on this analysis, the recom-
mendation was to change out the pump
bearings, check the alignment toler-
ances and balance the pump impeller.
Conclusion
Becoming a skilled vibration analyst
takes years. However, vibration mea-
surements can reveal important infor-
mation regarding the mechanical reli-
ability of a machine and are a critical
component of any predictive/preven-
tive maintenance program.
P&S
Brian P. Graney is currently the Vibra-Metrics national sales manager for MISTRAS Products & Systems
and is responsible for the overall Vibra-Metrics business development. Brian is certied in Vibration Analysis
Level II; is an American Bureau of Shipping Recognized Condition Monitoring External Specialist; and is
a member of Vibration Institute, Society of Maintenance Professionals and ASNT.
Table 5. Simple narrow band alarms for sleeve and roller bearings
Percentage of Overall Value for each Narrow Band Alarm
Sleeve Bearing Simple
Band Name Band No. Percent Band Fault
Sub. Synchronous 1 15 20% Oil Whirl
1 x rpm 2 80 90% Imbalance/Misalignment
2 4 x rpm 3 60 67% Misalignment/Looseness
5 20 x rpm 4 30 40% Bearing Wear/Vane Passing
Roller Bearing Simple
Band Name Band No. Percent Band Fault
Sub. Synchronous 1 15 20% Cage Defect
1 x rpm 2 80 90% Imbalance/Misalignment
2 4 x rpm 3 3 Misalignment/Looseness
5 20 x rpm 4 30 40% 1ST Bearing Band Note:1
21 50 x rpm 5 20 30% 2nd Bearing Band Note:2
Note: 1 Fundamental Bearing Defects Outer & Inner Race.
Note: 2 Harmonics for Bearing Defects Outer & Inner Race
mouvex.com
Seals-free design
Constant volumetric efciency
Low shear rate
High vacuum & compression effect
Self priming
Dry running up to 10 minutes
Constant performance overtime
22069VanBurenSt.GrandTerrace,CA92313-5651
circle 128 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com NOVEMBER 2011 29
A
ll too often, we have found the tipping point to pre-
dictive maintenance is a costly breakdown of motors,
pumps and related systems, or worse, a serious catas-
trophe that not only damages equipment and cripples your
operations, but impacts employee safety as well. According to
a recent U.S. Department of Energy study, 55 percent of those
responsible for industrial plant maintenance admitted to char-
acterizing their program as reactive and 31 percent as pre-
ventive only. It does not have to be that way.
It is established in the industry that predictive, rather than
just reactive or preventive maintenance of existing equipment,
will likely save money in the long run and can also help prevent
the development of serious hazards leading to a safety problem.
Whether an organizatin is a pharmaceutical facility using small
25-horsepower motors or an oil and gas plant operator requir-
ing a 60,000-horsepower synchronous machine, the same pre-
cepts apply: Take care of it now or pay later.
Predictive and Preventive Maintenance
You Need Both
Predictive and preventive maintenance are dierent, but both
are complementary and one should not be conducted exclusive
of the other. hey each can help protect equipment and people.
Predictive maintenance is a process that is custom-designed
for your specic system, built out of regular observation and
recordkeeping to understand trends and uncover anomalies.
End users can, therefore, leverage this historical data to take
future actions to optimize their operational e ciency.
Preventive maintenance is similar to following the mainte-
nance directions in an auto manualsuch as when to change
the oil, when to check the belts, when to rotate the tires, etc.
Most original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) rigorously
test their equipment for a battery of conditions that ensure
peak performance in many applications. Following included
operating and maintenance documentation is always advisable.
Reaching out to the OEMs of major pump platform com-
ponents may also be a good idea. In many cases, they will have
deep engineering expertise, application performance knowl-
edge and global experience that your team could use.
With larger companies, a good knowledge base often exists
in-house on most system components. However, in many of
the best organizations, this knowledge is refreshed regularly
with instruction by acknowledged industry experts with deep
domain expertise. his internal expertise can also be supple-
mented from time to time with consulting experts in advanced
diagnostics and troubleshooting technologies. Diagnostics can
make all the dierence in the world, and used in a healthy pre-
dictive maintenance program, will catch problems before they
severely impact operations.
A few OEMs may have deep technical knowledge on
multiple components of equipment and could be made avail-
able as a consultant on the ner points of condition monitor-
ing instrumentation and diagnostic services for monitoring
machinery vibration. Casting a wider net for knowledge of the
system components will help develop a rm foundation upon
which a truly predictive maintenance program can be built.
Economics and Safety
he primary outcomes of predictive and preventive
maintenance can have a real impact to an end users bottom
line. hese measures, too, can provide savings based on the
avoidance of downtime, damage to equipment and employee
wellbeing.
Many risk studies use similar numbers to illustrate the
inherent advantage of adopting a more proactive maintenance
approach. hey can also be used as a template to uncover the
resulting costs in operations to craft a more realistic model.
Consider that a reactive maintenance strategy would likely
contain up to 14 percent risk, which equates to $140,000 of
yearly maintenance on every $1 million worth of existing assets.
Compare this to a predictive maintenance strategy, which
would contain less than half the risk, about 6 percent, which
equates to $60,000 of yearly maintenance per $1 million of
existing assets. hat is a dierence of $80,000 per year. End
Predictive & Preventive
Maintenance
Michael Walsh, GE Energy
Do not let a catastrophic event be your wake-up call to adopt a proactive strategy.
30 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Special Section: Predictive & Preventive Maintenance
users may nd that these resulting savings will easily pay for a
predictive program.
hen consider the other savings not mentionesuch as
unplanned downtime, injured workers and strained customer
relationships. he business reasons that justify this path become
more evident as the real costs are investigated.
hrough experience, making adjustments nowperhaps
investing money nowis better than waiting for a disaster to
happen and paying ten-fold from having personnel injuries,
line stoppages and equipment replacement.
Some recommendations are given below to make end
users systems as fail-safe as possible. hese can make mainte-
nance managers, plant operations personnel, nancial person-
nel and the CEO rest better at night.
Based on sound industry practices
and experience, a comprehensive pro-
active maintenance strategy requires a
system that captures repetitive failures
so that appropriate corrective changes
are made. his demands good record
keeping of all maintenance pro-
grams and a root-cause-analysis of
any maintenance performed. hese
records should be reviewed annually
and semi-annually.
Conduct both preventive and
predictive maintenance on systems.
Follow the manufacturers minimum
maintenance recommendations.
Regularly take non-intrusive measure-
mentssuch as vibration analysis,
infrared (IR) analysis and insulation
readingsand then compare these
measurements so that equipment
failure can be predicted. Making
these predictions allows maintenance
and production departments to work
together to schedule repairs.
In todays facilities, power quality
problems can wreak havoc on high-
tech controls and electrical devices
such as transformers, switchgear,
switchboards, power panels, motor
control centers and variable frequency
drive systems. A recent study found
that up to 80 percent of these power
quality issues are born in facility
electrical distribution and ground-
ing systems. Consider using a power
system study to maintain (and
upgrade if necessary) the power-deliv-
ery infrastructure.
Apply vibration diagnostics to detect
mechanical and electrical anomalies
in motors and the rotating equip-
ment that they drive. Problems can
involve misalignment, improper
mounting, infrastructure contamina-
tion, bent shafts, a faulty motor or an
unbalanced motor or pump.
circle 129 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com NOVEMBER 2011 31
Apply IR analysis to detect electrical system overloading,
under-loading or faults with connection. It also detects
mechanical abnormalities, such as temperature dierentials
in the bearings or couplings. Detecting temperature dier-
ences or elevated temperatures along pump seals or gaskets
can indicate impending failures.
Motor insulation testingor static testingveries typical
motor faults. Insulation testing helps
verify if there are high-resistance con-
nections within the motor winding,
ground wall insulation condition and
turn-to-turn insulation. Anomalies
discovered in test results can lead to
catastrophic failure if not corrected.
Bearing troubles are often a lead-
ing causes of motor failure.
Contamination and poor lubrication
are leading causes. Excessive load-
ing or preassembly damage (from
misalignment, pump cavitation,
excessive pump ow and exposure to
temperatures outside bearing thermal
limits) can result in failures as well.
Misalignment occurs when coupling
the motor shaft to the pump shaft.
In such cases, dynamic testing is
required, and the equipment is acti-
vated until the operating temperature
is reached, and then the equipment is
shut down. Alignment is performed
while the motor and pump are at, or
close to, operating temperatures.
If a motor fails, the maintenance
manager must decide if the motor
should be replaced or rewound.
Waiting for a motor failure is not the
best maintenance strategy. Every facil-
ity should have a repair/replace policy.
Possible, a rewound motor can work
ne and, perhaps, provide even more
horsepower than the original. he key
bywords are reliability and e ciency.
Some motors will not be put into
service for months and instead are
stored. he storage location must be
clean and dry. Storage temperatures
must be between 50 and 120 degrees
F. Relative humidity must not exceed
60 percent. Motors with anti-friction
bearings must be lubricated.
Conclusion
he goal is to take care of problems
before they occur. In the process,
end users can ensure the operational
e ciency and reliability of their equipment and the safety of
their employees.
P&S
Michael Walsh is general manager of global Industrial
Services for GE Energy. He has over 20 years of technical
and operational experience in upgrades, maintenance and
repair of industrial equipment. He resides in Atlanta, Ga.,
and can be reached at michael1.walsh@ge.com.
circle 132 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
32 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Cover Series: Chemical Pumps
32 32 32 32 32 332 3 NOV NOV NOV NOV NOV VEMB EM EMB EM EMBER 20 20 20011 11 11 www www www www ww www www www w .p .p .p .pu pu ppuump- mp- mp- mp pp-zon zon zon zon zon zo e.c e.c e. om om ommmm PUM PUM PUM PUM PUM U PUMPS PS PS PS PS & S & S & S & SS & S & SYST YST YST YST ST YST TEMS EMS EMS EMS EMS M
Co Co Co Cove ve ve verrrrr Se Se Se SSe Seerii ri ri ri ries es es es es ss:::::: Ch Ch Ch Ch Ch Ch Ch Chem em em em em em emic ic iic cal al al al l al PPPPPum um umps ps ps Co Co Co ovve ver r Se See S ri ri ri ri r es es es es es s:::: Ch Ch Ch Ch Ch Chem em emic cal PPum um umps ps p Cover Series
CHEMICAL PUMPS
Equipment in Harsh Applications
P
h
o
t
o
C
r
e
d
i
t
:
A
c
h
e
m
i
c
a
l
f
a
c
t
o
r
y
i
n
L
e
u
n
a
,
G
e
r
m
a
n
y
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
K
S
B
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com NOVEMBER 2011 33
I
n recent years, peristaltic pumps have become a
more popular choice than diaphragm metering
and progressing cavity (PC) pumps for chemi-
cal metering and sludge pumping. Peristaltic pumps
have the lowest total life cycle cost (LCC). Recent
design improvements and advances in tubing materi-
als are extending the technologys range even further.
The Basics
Peristaltic pumps work by forcing uid along by
waves of contraction produced mechanically on
either exible tubes or hoses. Tubing pumps use a
single rotating piece that incorporates rollers that
occlude (squeeze) an extruded piece of synthetic
elastomeric tubing. In between each roller pass, the
tube restitutes (opens) to create a vacuum and draws
in the pumped uid. his continuous dynamic eect creates
a positive displacement ow, pushing the uid through the
pump.
In a hose pump, a sliding shoe with proled or crescent
shaped leading and trailing edges gives a gradual lead-in and
termination to each hose occlusion. his prevents an abrupt
imposition and release of pressure and increases hose life. A spe-
cially developed lubricant in the pump head eliminates external
hose wear from contact with the sliding shoes.
In the past, the fundamental problem in applying peristal-
tic hose pump technology to chemical metering was the devel-
opment of a hose element that could accommodate continuous
duty and required ow rates, with the ability to handle highly
abrasive and chemically aggressive uids.
Due to advancements in hose and tubing materials and the
integration of sophisticated electronics, including micropro-
cessor-controlled robotic grade drives, peristaltic pumps have
become the fastest growing type of positive displacement (PD)
chemical metering and sludge pumps.
Todays heavy-duty peristaltic pumps are designed to oper-
ate around the clock and combine precise PD ow and low
maintenance requirements with the ability to handle extremely
abrasive and aggressive uids.
Peristaltic Pumps Versus Diaphragm &
Progressing Cavity Pumps
In the past, the accepted pump choice for chemical metering
had been the diaphragm metering pump, either mechanically,
hydraulically or solenoid actuated. For sludge applications, the
most frequently used pump was the PC pump. Both are so
ubiquitous that operators simply accepted the need for opera-
tor attention, along with routine maintenance and its attendant
costs. A comparison shows that peristaltic pumps oer a reduc-
tion in these costs.
For example, diaphragm pumps have internal check valves
that can clog or wear out. his is a common problem in chemi-
cal pumping, when diaphragm pumps move solid-laden uids,
such as lime or carbon slurry. Dirty chemicalsfor example,
ferric chloride or reclaimed methanolalso pose a threat.
Peristaltic pumps have no internal check valves to clog or
wear out. Also, if air is accidentally introduced into the lines
when pumping sodium hypochlorite, the hypo may partially
Peristaltic Pumps in
Chemical Applications
Rick Balek, Watson-Marlow Bredel Pumps
Providing a low life-cycle choice for chemical metering
Figure 1. Peristaltic chemical metering pump installation
34 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Cover Series: Chemical Pumps
crystallize and the this solid may cause havoc with a
diaphragm pumps check valves. his is no concern
for peristaltic pumps, because the crystals will pass
through the system.
Another common diaphragm pump concern is
the pumps inability to move entrained air, for exam-
ple, in sodium hypochlorite applications. Sodium
hypochlorite naturally erodes over time and emits an
o gas, which can cause a diaphragm pump to lose
prime even though the pump is still running.
When this phenomenon occurs, an operator
must bleed the air from the line and re-prime the
pump. Peristaltic pumps will move the pocket of air
(o-gas) as e ciently as it pumps the hypochlorite.
When a diaphragm pump is repaired, a new
pump head is often required. If the actual diaphragm
fails, the internal workings of the pump would be
contaminated by the pumpage and could easily be
corroded or worn if an abrasive product wearing the
many metal-to-metal contacting parts. Replacement
can be expensive.
By comparison, with a peristaltic tubing pump,
one may simply slide the same piece of tubing that
is currently installed just one foot or so, such that a
new section of the tube is located within the pump
head, allowing for new pinch points to be occluded
by the rotor. his preventative maintenance takes
only seconds and since a 50-foot spool of tubing
costs approximately $150 and lasts about ve years,
the maintenance cost is negligible.
With PC pumps, the stator will quickly burn
up if allowed to run dry. If the stator is not replaced
soon after signs of initial wear, the chrome or ceramic plating
may also wear, causing a signicant negative impact on the
rotor. he combination of these two most commonly replaced
parts can easily equal 65 to 70 percent of the cost of an entire
PC pump. By contrast, peristaltic pumps can run dry with-
out damage. Replacement cost for a peristaltic hose pump is
roughly 10 percent of the cost of a new pump.
Additionally, most PC pumps require two complex univer-
sal joints to transmit torque from the pumps drive shaft to the
connecting rod and then to the rotor. hese parts are typically
protected by an elastomeric joint seal or cover, which frequently
fails, allowing sludge to enter the joint and quickly wear out
the pumps internal components. By comparison, the rotating
parts of a peristaltic pump are separated from the pumped uid
because the uid only contacts the inside of the hose or tubing.
Servicing a typical PC pump can be a time consuming task
that requires removing the motor from the pump, removing
the pump from its base plate and transporting the pump to a
workbench in a plants maintenance shop.
Servicing most peristaltic hose pumps is simple. As the
hose is the only wearing part of the pump, one simply drains the
lubricating uid from the pump housing, removes the pump
ttings, and then runs the pump to expel the failed hose. To
install the new hose, the procedure is reversed. he pump does
not need to be removed from its base, and the pump motor can
remain in place. his self-loading design signicantly reduces
maintenance time and cost while the pump actually performs
the physical work.
One primary reason for the increasing acceptance of hose
pumps in some applications is their ability to pump extremely
abrasive sludges, even grit itself, without damage. Hose pumps
do not wear due to abrasion, whereas the PC pump sustains
pressure from the pumps seal line equaling the length and
circumference of the pumping elements, the rotor and stator.
When pumping abrasive uids, this interference or compres-
sion t between these elements will erode until there is a surface
contact t, resulting in an ever-widening clearance t.
his wear causes slip of the abrasive sludge, a primary
reason for stator/rotor failure in PC pumps. Sometimes, the
higher viscosity of the sludge may cause the automated variable
speed drives integrated with programmable logic controllers
(PLC) to automatically increase the speed of the PC pump.
his increased speed also greatly increases wear (4 times PC
pump wear = 2 times rpm). By comparison, wear on a hose
pumps hose is linear (as opposed to exponential), as pump
speed increases.
A nal major advantage of peristaltic pump technology
Table 1. Key advantages of peristaltic pump technology
Only one wearing part: the tube or hose
Can run dry without damageno expensive protection package to buy
Hose does not wear due to abrasionno slip
Metering accuracies to 0.5 percent
Turn down ratios to 1,000,000:1 with same pump
Tubing change in as little as three seconds
Can pump gassespump will never vapor lockperfect for hypo
Can handle very high solid content materials
Reversible100 percent efcient in either direction
Suction lift to 31 feet
No internal ball check valves to clog or wear out
Pump is sealless: No mechanical seal or packing
Eliminates seal water ush systems & piping
Eliminates in-line check valves as the pump is the check valve
Eliminates de-gassing valvesthe air is easily pumped through
Eliminates back pressure valvesperistaltic pumps do not require a
minimum sustained back pressure to operate correctly
Pulsation Dampeners are often eliminated
Eliminates in-line strainers
Multiple pump heads on one drive
Flows from 0.1 micro liter to 350 gpm and pressures to 232 psi
Small footprint
Lowest life-cycle cost (LCC)
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com NOVEMBER 2011 35
is the reduction of ancillary equipment required in a chemical pumping
system. he capital, installation and maintenance costs of this extra equip-
ment must be added to that of the pump/motor to provide a true LCC for
the entire pump system.
For example, Figure 1 shows an example of a chemical metering appli-
cation in which three diaphragm pumps were replaced with three peristal-
tic tubing pumps. Ancillary equipment for the diaphragm pump includes
pulsation dampeners, articial back-
pressure valves, degassing valves and in-
line strainers. None of these items are
required with peristaltic tubing pumps.
In addition, ow meters are often elimi-
nated, as the accuracy of a peristaltic
pump is usually superior to that of the
ow meter itself.
Typical ancillary equipment for a
peristaltic pump includes a high-pres-
sure cut out sensor/switch combination
to prevent pumping against a plugged
line or closed valve. About 1 percent of
tubing pump installations and 35 per-
cent of hose pump installations incor-
porate pulsation dampeners, which
remove about 98 percent of trace pul-
sation. his device is recommended in
most belt lter press and centrifuge feed
applications. On occasion, a calibration
column may be included as a simple way
to calibrate the pumps ow if the pump
is ow paced from a remote input signal.
Benets & Limitations
No PD pump technology is ideal for all
applications. Limitations for peristaltic
pumps include a maximum tempera-
ture of 180-degrees F and a maximum
pressure of 232 psi. Flow rates can range
from 0.1 micro liters per minute to 350
gallons per minute (gpm).
Peristaltic hose pumps are virtu-
ally maintenance free, with no seals to
replace, no check valves to clog and no
rotors or stators to wear. Unlike other
pumps, the highly abrasive nature of
materials pumped does not aect pump
life because the uid is fully contained
within the hose element and does not
contact the moving parts, prevent-
ing abrasive wear. With its self-loading
design, hose replacement is quick and
easy. he pumps also oer a reduced
footprint due to less need for ancillary
systems. Table 1 has a complete list of
advantages.
P&S
Rick Balek is the national sales
manager for Watson-Marlow
Bredel Pumps. He can be
reached at rbalek@wmbpumps.
com or 317-580-0031.
circle 133 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
36 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Cover Series: Chemical Pumps
S
electing the right material for any industrial piping appli-
cation can be a daunting task. he life expectancy and
overall success of a system is based on the material selected
and the media running through it. With material choices rang-
ing from metal to berglass to plastics, it is helpful to rst
examine the systems specic application and then choose the
material best suited to handle the job long-term.
Sulfuric acid and sodium hypochlorite are just two noto-
riously troublesome chemicals that are di cult to safely store
and transport through piping systems. Titanium, PVC, CPVC
and uoropolymer-lined piping are potential system solutions,
but each requires that certain conditions be met. Temperature,
pressure and installed location are factors that should be taken
into consideration when determining the best material f.
he inherent properties of thermoplastics make them
an ideal choice for corrosion resistance and more cost eec-
tive than metal piping systems. PVC and CPVC have been the
solution to sulfuric acid and sodium hypochlorite applications.
However, their weaknesses are in the joining method, which
requires solvent cement and glue. his has made them a less
ideal choice for these aggressive chemicals.
hermally fused high density polyethylene (HDPE) is the
leading thermoplastic material used for piping applications.
Polyethylene outperforms other materialsincluding metal,
berglass and other thermoplastics such as PVC and CPVC,
with a more-aordable installed cost.
Previously, HDPE had been limited to water and some
chemical applications. However, a new generation of the resin
provides a cost eective solution to corrosion and enables its
use in chemical systems. his new resin, the fourth generation
of HDPE, is PE 100-RC.
The Evolution of
a New Resin
HDPE was developed in
1953 by chemists at the
Kaiser Wilhelm Institute
in Germany. Two years
later, HDPE was being
used to manufacture
pipe. Before the mid
1950s, industrial piping
systems were primarily made of metal. During the past six
decades, HDPE resins developed for piping applications have
evolved to cover four generations. he current classication
of HDPE materials is based on a minimum required strength
(MRS) European standard according to ISO 4427. (See Table 1.)
Generation 1 includes PE 32, 40 and 63. hese grades
of HDPE material are suitable for low- to medium-pressure
liquid applications. Generation 2 is PE 80 (also known as PE
3408 in the U.S.). PE 80 is suitable for low-pressure gas appli-
cations and higher pressure liquid applications up to 1.6 MPa
(230 psi). Generation 3 is PE 100 (also known as PE 4710 in
the U.S.). PE 100 is suitable for higher pressure gas and liquid
applications.
Like all materials used in chemical applications, HDPE
has its limitations. he upper temperature limit is +140 degrees
F and the lower limit is -40 degrees F. he primary weakness of
generations 1, 2 and 3 is susceptibility of the material to crack
Safe Chemical Transfer
Mark L. Jones, Asahi America
The development of PE resin for industrial piping applications
Table 1. ISO 4427 MRS for HDPE
Designation of Material MRS at 50 Years and 20
Degrees C MPa (psi)
PE 100 RC (generation 4) 10 (1450)
PE 100 (generation 3) 10 (1450)
PE 80 (generation 2) 8 (1160)
PE 63 (generation 1) 6.3 (913)
PE 40 (generation 1) 4 (580)
PE 32 (generation 1) 3.2 (464)
Figure 1. PE pipe installation
Figure 2. Full notch creep test
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com NOVEMBER 2011 37
under stresses, such as point loads. If an end user is burying the
pipe, the trench needs to be dug wider so it can be backlled
with the proper bedding material to avoid point loads from
rocks on the pipe.
Any point load can develop a crack and, over time, cause
premature failure. his is known as environmental stress crack-
ing and is certainly true of the rst three generations of HDPE.
Cracking can also be caused by chemical attack.
Despite these limits, the benecial properties of HDPE are
abundant. Some of PE 100s benets are:
Excellent resistance to a wide range of chemical applications
Can handle a pH from 1 to 14
Highly ductile, exible and light-weight
hermally joined, eliminating the use of solvents and glues
Excellent uid ow characteristics
Extremely low coe cient of thermal conductivity
Will not rust
Cost-eective and easy to install
Long life expectancy
The Next Generation
When the rst three generations of HDPE pipe fail, the cause
is almost always stress cracking. Resin manufacturers have been
trying to increase the crack resistance properties of the material.
Innovations in the co-polymerization process have developed a
new PE 100 resin with just such characteristics. he new resin
has all the strength of the previous generation with a greatly
improved crack resistance (RC).
he full notch creep test (FNCT) is the standard test to
measure the resistance of HDPE materials to stress cracking
(ISO 16770). See Figure 2.
A notched test specimen is placed under load in a high
temperature aggressive surfactant bath to accelerate failure. he
Table 2. Full notch creep test requirements
PE Class Minimum Standard FNCT
PE63 30 Hours
PE80 100 Hours
PE 100 300 Hours
PE 100-RC 8,760 Hours (1 year)
Table 3. Full notch creep test average results
PE Class Average Results FNCT
Rupture time in hours
PE63 7.5 Hours (2 samples)
PE80 114 Hours (3 samples)
PE 100 533 Hours (5 samples)
PE 100-RC 14,648 Hours (2 samples)
circle 135 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
38 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Cover Series: Chemical Pumps
time it takes for the crack to go all the way through the coupon
is the result of the test expressed in hours. Table 2 lists the mini-
mum standards for each grade of HDPE resin. he minimum
standard for PE 100-RC is 8,760 hours (one year).
Looking at the average results (Table 3), the benets in the
evolution can be seen. he weakness is now the strength, open-
ing new application opportunities in which polyethylene has
never been considered. he increase in crack resistance allows
contractors and installers to consider HDPE for underground
use in rough dug trenches without backll or sand grading. his
provides lower installation cost and furthers the reach of ther-
moplastic piping systems into mountain and desert terrains.
Another benet of HDPEs increased crack resistance is its
newfound industrial chemical piping applications. he chemi-
cal resistance capabilities of the previous
HDPE generations are already proven.
Now, a good portion of the previously
unacceptable applications will prove
to be successful opportunities for PE
100-RC pipe and ttings. Why? If the
material is attacked by the chemical,
the time to failure will be substantially
extended due to its greatly enhanced
ability to resist cracks. In eect, if it lasts
long enough, it is resistant.
his could change what used to be
only a short-term possibility into a long-
term solution. An application with high
concentrations of sodium hypochlorite
transported in PE 100-RC piping is only
one specic application that has already
proven to increase previous short-term
solutions into permanent, long-term
installations.
Applications using higher con-
centrations of certain acids are another
avenue now open to HDPE. Because PE
100-RC is so versatile in terms of per-
formance, low installation cost and an
extremely long expected useful life, it can
now be seriously considered for every
new and existing chemical piping appli-
cation that falls within its capabilities.
PE 100-RC is poised to be the
material of choice for aggressive chemi-
cal and water applications. Its inher-
ent physical properties makes it ideally
suited for todays safety-conscious and
budget-minded companies.
P&S
Mark L. Jones is the
business development
managerindus-
trial/environmental
productsAsahi/
America, Inc. He
has been with the
company since 1998 and has more
than 25 years experience selling
plastic piping systems. Jones can be
reached at mjones@asahi-america.
com or 781-321-5409.
See how to reduce your water and energy
consumption, increase equipment
reliability and improve your
bottom line with SEPCO
's
high performance sealing
solutions. For your
facility and your
own peace of
mind, check out
SEPCO
.
800.633.4770 www.sepcoUSA.com
SeaIing Equipment Products Co., Inc.
SEPCO
is
my only choice.
I know my business and my
pumps, and I will not settle for
anything less than the best.
DONT SETTLE FOR
GOOD ENOUGH
Contact Graco today:
1-877-844-7226
www.gracosaniforce.com
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com NOVEMBER 2011 43
One-luid-chamber designAs
noted earlier, traditional sealless
pump design features two uid
chambers that are separated by a
bracket. his design creates opera-
tional di culties while limiting the
types of uids that can be handled
by the pumps. he improved design
has only one uid chamber with the
pumps magnets placed on the back
of the rotor and close-coupled, or
piggy-backed, on the rotor gear.
his design gives the pump a much
shorter, simpler ow path. It also
allows the pump to easily handle
viscosities in the 20,000 to 30,000 cP
range and as high as 50,000 cP, while
still maintaining the ability to run
thin liquidssuch as caustics and
solvents. hese redesigned pumps can
also pump liquids and slurries that
contain solids.
Another feature that this design
oers is dimensional interchangeability.
hese pumps have been designed to be
interchangeable with 95 percent of the
other gear pumps that are currently
available on the market. his means that
a plant can run a traditional sealed pump
in the morning, have it pulled out in
the afternoon and drop this single-uid
chamber gear pump into the footprint
while reusing the same piping, gear box,
motor and base plate, all while receiving
the same hydraulic performance pro-
vided by the previous pump.
While this pump is designed to
eliminate all the operational concerns
found in old-style sealless gear pumps,
its simple designwhich consists of
only seven primary parts: a magnet
housing, containment canister, casing,
rotor magnet assembly, eccentric spin-
dle, idler gear and headgreatly reduces
maintenance and environmental costs.
Conclusion
In the end, the design of these new seal-
less gear pumps makes them beyond a
traditional sealless pump. hey are an
engineered solution for environmentally
conscious uid-handling that lowers
maintenance costs and eliminates envi-
ronmental costs.
P&S
Dale Evers is the director of business development, Engineered Products, for
the Dover Corporations Pump Solutions Group (PSG), Downers Grove,
Ill. He can be reached at dale.evers@pumpsg.com. You can nd more
information on EnviroGear at www.envirogearpump.com. PSG is com-
prised of seven leading pump brandsAlmatec, Blackmer, EnviroGear,
Griswold, Mouvex, Neptune and Wilden. You can nd more information
on PSG at www.pumpsg.com.
When your equipment is down, you need a
partner that ships a solution to you same-day
not some day. At Inpro/Seal, we recognize the high
cost of downtime facing our customers; thats why
weve designed our operations to support quick
turnaround of our customengineered bearing
protection products.
With manufacturing locations in North America
and the United Kingdom, were able to offer
industryleading products with unparalleled
response time and service to customers around
the globe. The right technologyright when
you need it.
YOUR SAME-DAY SHIPMENT SPECIALISTS
#1 in Bearing Isolators
www.inpro-seal.com
circle 124 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
44 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
P
umps are indispensable in
mining, petroleum recovery
(wellhead operations), pipelines,
rening and many manufacturing
operations, so their failure causes costly
unscheduled downtime. In the case of
an electrical ground fault the pumps
drive motor can be destroyed, and it
can result in high voltage potential on
the pump equipment framework that
is a serious safety hazard to personnel.
A pump and drive motor can fail in
other ways, including pumps running
dry and jammed pumps causing the
motor to overload, which can lead to
catastrophic damage to the motor and
other electrical system problems.
Automated Prevention
Most fault conditions can be mitigated with the right kind of
protective device. Todays electronic motor protection relays
(Figure 1) can communicate motor operating information to
a programmable logic controller (PLC), motor control center
or an automated monitoring system. hese real-time diag-
nostic features are important predictive/preventative mainte-
nance functions that indicate that a problem needs attention
before a catastrophic failure.
Some motor protection relays have inputs for tempera-
ture sensors. Temperature inputs in some relays shut down
the motor before it becomes too hot and causes an insulation
failure. More importantly, collecting temperature data from
the ambient surroundings, pump and motor bearings and
the motor windings can be used for predictive/preventative
maintenance.
By monitoring and analyzing
motor thermal trends, operators can see
that the motor may become overheated
if operating conditions are not altered.
Overloading the motor, ambient tem-
perature and lack of cooling when
needed may overheat the motor. With
temperature sensor inputs, the relays
thermal model of the motor can be
biased to reect operating conditions or
adjust for hot spots on the motor, such
as windings or bearings. hese diag-
nostic features provide more e cient
troubleshooting and help avoid motor
damage, freeing up sta and eliminating
many repairs and replacements. Instead
of reacting to failures, maintenance sta
can proactively schedule corrections.
Drive Motor Ground Faults
Pumps are often used in dusty and damp environments
that can compromise insulation in the drive motor and its
input wiring. hese conditions can increase earth leakage
currentspersistent, small currents from a high potential
point to ground that may be a precursor to a major ground
fault. Some causes of phase-to-ground faults are shorts in the
motor windings or input wiring due to worn or melted insu-
lation. Ground faults can cause electrical shocks, res or even
major arc-ash events.
hermal Overload Relays
Earlier methods of detection and protection against ground
faults are still being used. hese electromechanical devices
include bimetallic or melted alloy (eutectic) overload
Microprocessor-Based
Pump/Motor Protection
Relays
Ross George, Littelfuse, Inc.
Todays lean maintenance staff needs pump and motor protective devices that
diagnose and predict problems before they become acute.
Maintenance Minders
Figure 1. Electronic pump/motor
protection relay
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com NOVEMBER 2011 45
mechanisms. hey contain heating elements wired in series with the motor inputs
that cause either a pool of solder (eutectic alloy) to melt or a set of bimetallic strips
to bend and release the contacts when current becomes excessive.
Bimetallic overloads generally have a limited range of adjustable trip points.
No adjustability is possible with eutectic alloy mechanisms. Some bimetallic over-
loads will reclose automatically when the motor cools su ciently. Bimetallic over-
load design can include compensation to prevent ambient temperature changes
from aecting the trip point. Ideally, a thermal overload should be installed in the
same ambient temperature as the motor it protects. In practice, these devices are
often installed in the motor starter, which may be in an air-conditioned switchgear
room away from the motor. Whats more, their simple design precludes intelligent
feedback.
Solid-State Electronic Protection
Certain types of solid-state overload relays have been introduced to resolve the inac-
curacies of electromechanical devices. However, many of these have pre-calculated
setpoints and cannot provide the same level of protection as more recent designs. In
one type, the current is measured using a set of current transformers, which may be
internal or external to the device. his protection system includes monitoring and
current interruption in case of ground faults, overloads, unbalance, jams, etc.
However, using a current transformer may allow some level of damage to occur
before the relay trips. An alternative to current monitoring is to use an insulation
monitoring relay. his device monitors phase-to-ground insulation resistance and
prevents the motor from starting if system insulation resistance falls below a selected
set-point, avoiding potential motor damage.
An insulation monitoring relay applies a DC voltage and measures the leakage
current to determine the systems insulation resistance to ground. By establishing a
setpoint for this resistance and providing a signal output when it is too low, mainte-
nance sta is made aware of degradation, allowing for scheduled maintenance and
repair.
Another benet, compared to electromechanical relays that pass motor current
through heating elements, electronic relays do not cause excessive heat buildup on a
power panel. Besides saving on power consumption, this helps avoid panel de-rating
and the use a larger enclosure for heat dissipation.
Yet another type of electronic device combines ground fault protection with a
ground-check function, which monitors the integrity of an equipment ground. It is
used if ensuring ground continuity is the foremost issue. hese relays are also used
with trailing cables, when the equipment may be a large distance from the starter
or breaker.
By ensuring a ground connection, this prevents a potential voltage rise across
the uid or on the framework of the equipment during a ground-fault, which may
represent a shock hazard to operating and maintenance personnel. Common appli-
cation environments are surface mines, underground mines, quarries and submers-
ible pumps. hese devices are even used on the pumping equipment for golf course
watering systems. hey can also be used as a remote permissive for the pumping
equipment.
In many electrical systems, a neutral grounding resistor (NGR) is used on the
grounding system. his is sometimes called a high resistance ground (HRG), where
a resistor is placed between the neutral of the supply transformer and ground.
Using resistance grounding can minimize the amount of damage caused by a
ground fault. In some cases, it may allow operations to continue until the fault can
be cleared. In addition, an NGR used in conjunction with an NGR monitor relay
can provide a predictive maintenance function by alerting sta to the ground-fault
before excessive damage is done. Moreover, resistance grounding also prevents a re-
striking fault from elevating the system voltage relative to ground, which adds more
c
i
r
c
l
e
1
3
9
o
n
c
a
r
d
o
r
g
o
t
o
p
s
f
r
e
e
i
n
f
o
.
c
o
m
305-591-8935 www.ludeca.com
W
a
tc
h
V
ID
E
O
S
O
n
lin
e
Pump
Alignment
Rotalign
ULTRA
VIBXPERT
II
& Machine Base
Flatness
Vibration
Analysis
& Balancing
Quick and easy
solutions for your
maintenance needs!
Sales Rentals Services
46 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
stress to the insulation and can lead to a phase-to-ground-to-phase fault.
Pump manufacturers are being asked to incorporate ground-check relays into
their equipment. his includes a zener diode termination assembly that is part
of the relays open and shorted ground-check loop functions for portable power
cables. he relay feeds two dierent levels of current to the termination assembly
and checks to make sure that the voltage drop is the same across the zener diode at
both levels. his is a more desirable way of ensuring ground integrity compared to
a resistance terminated loop, as a high-impedance fault with the right amount of
resistance can provide an erroneous indication.
Benets of Microprocessor-Based Protection
Microprocessor-based relays may incorporate several of these protective and predic-
tive functions to guard pumps and motors from overload damage and some other
fault conditions. Depending on the design and feature-set, they may include a lim-
ited functions or a wide range of protection and monitoring features. Some of the
advanced features include protection in the event of phase loss, phase imbalance,
improper phase sequence, jam and undercurrent protection. Other features may
include digital inputs/outputs, internal data logging, and interfacing data commu-
nications. See Figure 2.
A useful feature for maintenance personnel is continuous real-time monitoring
of an operating motors thermal capacity. As mentioned earlier, this may prevent a
motor from becoming overloaded, avoiding insulation damage.
Combined with a data communications interface, this monitoring allows trend
analysis by a central control system computer or PLC and subsequent scheduled
maintenance.
A pump jam will cause motor overload due to excessive current that can
damage the motor windings insulation. A motor protection relay will interrupt
the supply power as it does for a ground fault. A pump running dry does not cause
an overcurrent condition but a low currenta common occurrence in submersible
pump applications. Mechanical oats may not be su cient, as they may be prone
to failure. In many cases, a pump that runs dry means a loss of lubrication, which
can lead to bearing damage or other failure modes.
A microprocessor-based relay with a low-current setpoint can protect against
Figure 2. Microprocessor-based motor protection relay simplied circuit diagram
Maintenance Minders
c
i
r
c
l
e
1
4
1
o
n
c
a
r
d
o
r
g
o
t
o
p
s
f
r
e
e
i
n
f
o
.
c
o
m
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com NOVEMBER 2011 47
a dry pump situation. During normal operation the micropro-
cessor sees nominal operating amperage.
If the pump runs dry, this current drops to an idle amper-
age level, which is dened by the motor. When that occurs, the
protective relay can send a signal to an interrupt device, or signal
to a PLC for analysis, which may actuate the interrupting device.
Cost Considerations
Microprocessor-based motor protection devices can be sophis-
ticated. In addition to current inputs, some devices have pro-
visions for voltage inputs, which can calculate power, power
factor and other parameters. hese parameters are fed back to
a motor control center or PLC where the data can be logged
and/or analyzed.
Network communication capabilities may include proto-
cols for Ethernet, DeviceNet or ProBus. With these, micro-
processor-based motor protection can be used to help optimize
a pump/motor system electrically and mechanically. Some deci-
sions and actions that may be taken are load analysis, altering
ow rate or changing power factor correction.
he cost of devices with this level of sophistication may be
prohibitive for pumping systems operating with 50-horsepower
or smaller motors. In these cases, simpler microprocessor-based
devices may be a cost-eective way to upgrade an antiquated
pumping system or add protection to a system.
Another consideration is the mea-
surement devices required for use with
the protection relays. For example, some
microprocessor-based relays have built-in
current transformers (CTs) for overcur-
rent detection circuitry with specied cur-
rent ranges. In other cases, these CTs must
be purchased and installed. In some cases,
using separate CTs may be appropriate,
allowing a protection relay to be tied into
almost any power system.
Of course, reliability in harsh
industrial environments has a signicant
impact on the overall cost of ownership
when a pump/motor protective device
is purchased. Besides exposure to water
and electrically conductive dusts, corro-
sive liquids and vapors are common in
many applications. For example, hydro-
gen sulde (H
2
S) can be present in or
around petrochemical uids, which
aects equipment used at the wellhead,
on pipelines and in reneries. It reacts
with water vapor to form sulfuric acid
that eats away at electrical components.
For these and other harsh environ-
ments, protective devices designed spe-
cically to survive in such applications
should be chosen. In addition to rugged
mechanical design for use on machinery
with strong vibrations, the electrical circuit boards need to be
conformal coated with an insulating material. When done
properly, this seals the components and circuit traces so they
cannot be attacked by corrosive liquids, vapors and gases.
A unit designed primarily for indoor factory applications
may last only a short time in a mining or petrochemical appli-
cation. However, protective devices designed for rugged envi-
ronments can supply 20 or more years of reliable service in such
environments. A long service life may be a compelling reason
to purchase a reliable protective device, even for less demanding
applications, because of its low cost of ownership.
Summary
Microprocessor-based pump/motor protection relays oer
a cost-eective way to prevent catastrophic failures due to a
number of fault conditions. In addition, they can protect oper-
ating and maintenance personnel by mitigating or removing
shock hazards and potential arc-ash events. hose with real-
time monitoring and diagnostic functions for predictive/pre-
ventative maintenance programs can reduce maintenance costs.
P&S
Ross George is a technical sales engineer with Littelfuse. He
received a Bachelor of Science degree in Electrical Engineering
from the University of Saskatchewan. He can be reached at
rgeorge@littelfuse.com.
circle 137 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
Cartex seals are designed with greater
attention to functional details like
tighter tolerances for more accurate
seal operation, greater axial movement
to handle pump shaft movement, seal
parts with robust cross sections for
optimal seal stability in operation and
castings that meet ASTM A351/351M
standards for proven quality. Call 1-800-
303-7735 and ask your EagleBurgmann
pro about Cartex seals, or email us at
info@eagleburgmannseals.com.
Cartex
Engineered to provide
maximum performance.
www.eagleburgmann.us
www.EagleBurgmannSeals.com
www.EagleBurgmannNow.com
48 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
M
echanical packing is a versatile seal-
ing device. One of the best features
of braided mechanical packing in
roll form is its exibility and ease of use. In
todays world of maximizing plant e ciency
with limited maintenance resources, some
important steps to follow when installing pack-
ing are often overlooked. One of these is prop-
erly cutting the braided packing.
One of the best ways to enhance packing
life is to focus on installation. After packing
is installed, a few xes can prolong life when
a leak has occurred. As Ben Franklin stated,
An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of
a cure. his is true about packing, since instal-
lation is the key to long packing life. Cutting
packing rings incorrectly can result in a low
mean time between failure (MTBF) for valves
and pumps and is easily preventable with some
basic training. his article discusses some fun-
damental concepts to improve packing life by
properly cutting the rings.
Important Steps
he best way to cut packing accurately is to focus on a few
simple steps:
Use a mandrel to cut rings
Use a sharp knife
Use a forceful cutting motion
Sometimes, bad habits that are developed when cutting
packing rings can start at a plant and can severely limit pack-
ing performance. Training and education will help prevent
bad maintenance practices and provide understanding of
the importance of the task. Unacceptable practices for cut-
ting packing rings can be handed down from technician to
technician because it is hard to see the eect that it has on the
sealing failure of the equipment.
Sizing
One of the more prevalent practices is using the packing
rings that were removed when unpacking a valve or a pump
as a length guide for cutting the new rings. he problem is
the rings that were removed could have been incorrectly sized
the last time so the error will just be repeated. Also, the rings
that are unpacked might have been chemically attacked and
may have shrunk or become deformed while in service.
he most accurate way to cut packing rings is to use a
mandrel that is the exact size of the shaft or stem. By taking
the mandrel and placing it in a vise and wrapping the pack-
ing around it, an accurate length can be determined for the
packing ring.
What are the key steps to cutting packing for optimum performance?
This months Sealing Sense was prepared by FSA Member Ron Frisard and
sponsored by the Compression Packing division.
From the voice of the uid sealing industry
SEALING SENSE
Figure 1. Cutting on a mandrel
PUMPS & SYSTEMS www.pump-zone.com NOVEMBER 2011 49
Cutting
he rings should either be cut on the mandrel at a 45-degree
angle for a skive cut or a 5-degree, almost-straight cut for a butt
cut. Check the installation instructions of the packing manu-
facturer for the correct cutting type required by the application.
Rings should be held tightly on the mandrel but not stretched.
When cutting skive joints, a miter board should be used so that
each successive ring can be cut at the correct angle.
After each ring is cut, it should be wrapped around the
mandrel as a double check to ensure that the ends adjoin with
each other. his is similar to a go/no-go gauge. Skillfully cut-
ting rings with a mandrel does take some practice of the pack-
ing pulling and the wrapping technique. Focusing on the end
result of the ring tting on the mandrel with no gap will quickly
provide a feedback loop to perfect the practice. Each style of
packing will pull around the mandrel slightly dierently.
Unraveling Ends
Another issue to watch for is trimming rings that have been
cut long. Cutting a small section of one of the packing ends
can result in the packing unravelinga major failure point
when it is installed. If this happens, the damaged ring should
be scrapped, and another ring should be cut, concentrating on
getting the size correct.
Tools
he second component to an accurately cut packing ring is
the tools that are used. Another major poor practice is using a
pocket knife to cut packing rings. A number of major issues can
arise from using this type of cutting tool.
he rst problem is that most knives are not very sharp,
and a dull knife will make the cutter use a back and forth cut-
ting motion instead of clean slice of the packing. his back and
Figure 2. Checking Ring Size
circle 151 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com circle 149 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
CONTROL SYSTEMS
T 1.205.824.0004 // REVERECONTROL.COM
ENGINEERED TO SERVE
PUMPING APPLICATIONS
At Revere, we engineer controls for an incredible range of
pumping applications. From control panels for original
equipment manufacturers to complex conigurations for
municipal, industrial and energy applications.
Control your pumping systems.
Control your business.
Progressing Cavity Pumps
One is right for your application
Learn more.
NETZSCH Pumps North America, LLC
Tel: 610-363-8010
email: PUMPS@netzsch.com
www.netzschusa.com
NETZSCH, the world market leader with 60 years of
experience and over 500,000 progressing cavity pump
installations worldwide. With sales, production and service
on 6 continents ensuring customer support to provide
NETZSCH Pumps & Systems Solutions you can trust
50 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
FSA Sealing Sense
forth motion causes the packing to open up (bloom) making
installation and sealing more di cult. A sharp knife makes a
clean cut that keeps the strands together in the original shape.
Cutting packing will dull any type of knife quickly, so make
sure there is easy access to knife sharpeners.
he second issue with using a pocket knife is the lack of
a good grip. When cutting packing, a considerable amount of
force must be applied to cut in one stroke, and without a good
handle, this is much harder to accomplish. It is very important
that the tool used to cut packing is a straight edge blade and not
serrated. his will also help reach the goal of a clean cut without
deformed packing ends.
he correct way to cut packing is to have the knife at an
angle to the packing (handle higher) and not parallel to it. his
method results in better leverage on the
packing resulting in a better cut. Many
tutorials are available that highlight this
method when cutting in the kitchen.
Correctly cutting a piece of packing is
very similar to cutting in a professional
kitchen.
Excess Material
Cutting packing will always results in
some waste. his could be rings that are
too long or short but also can be rings
whose ends have unraveled or blossomed
to the point at which they could result
in a leak path. One of the easiest ways to
sidestep errors in cutting is to order cut
rings from the packing supplier. Besides
no scrap, there is also a considerable time
savings from not having to cut the rings.
he drawbacks to using cut rings every-
where is having good documentation of
the actual size of the packing beforehand
to know what to order. his can be a
bigger hurdle than rst thought since
a major paradigm shift needs to occur
regarding creating a database of equip-
ment dimensions.
Conclusion
A couple of other simple ways to create
a good environment that will result in
a better cut ring are rst to order (or
get a machine shop to create) accurate
mandrels for all stem and shaft sizes.
he other is to have in the cut ring area
some good knives and access to a knife
sharpener.
Next Month: What factors should be
considered for stainless steel fasteners in
bolted ange connections?
We invite your questions on sealing issues
and will provide best eort answers based
on FSA publications. Please direct your
questions to: sealingsensequestions@
uidsealing.com.
P&S
circle 119 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
Technical Features:
Okpkocn"Nkhg"E{eng"Equvu."Tgxgtukdng"Qrgtcvkqp."Ugnh"Rtkokpi."
Jkij"Ecrcekvkgu"wr"vq"7.222"wuiro"
Boerger, LLC"~":99094805965"~"yyy0dqgtigt0eqo"~"kphqBdqgtigt0eqo
Rotary Lobe Pumps
Macerating Technology
Applications include:
Unwfig1Dkquqnkfu."Itgcug."Rtkoct{"Unwfig."YCU."TCU."Fkiguvgf"
Unwfig."Vjkemgpgf"Unwfig."Hggf"qh"Vjkemgpkpi"cpf"Fgycvgtkpi"
Fgxkegu."Nqcfkpi""Uvcvkqpu."Ugycig."Uewo."Ogodtcpg"Dkqtgcevqt"
Crrnkecvkqpu."Rqn{ogt"gve0"
r . Ugnh"Rtkokpi."
r"vq"7.222"wuiro"
Maintenance In Place
Cnn" #wkf" ygvvgf" rctvu" ctg" tgrncegcdng" qpukvg" vjtqwij" vjg" htqpv"
eqxgt"ykvjqwv"tgoqxcn"qh"rkrg"qt"ftkxg"u{uvgou0"
in the Wastewater Industry!
The Leading Manufacturer of
Multicrusher"
Multichopper
Rotary Lobe
Pump
Macerating Technology
Rotary Lobe Pumps
THE TOUGHEST EXTERIOR
An extremely durable 300-Series Stainless Steel body clearly sets the
Poly-Guard apart from all other plastic pumps. Its strong and chemically
resistant body truly makes the Poly-Guard the perfect match for harsh
industrial environments.
ALLOY-C
CONTAINMENT CAN
MAGNETIC COUPLING & CONTAINMENT CAN
The inner magnet and containment can, like all other
metal internal surfaces, are completely encapsulated in
Fluoro-Polymer for ultimate corrosion protection.
THE MOST CHEMICALLY RESISTANT INTERIOR
Fluoro-Polymer Plastic Lining resists the most
corrosive chemicals
All inside surfaces contain a molded layer of Fluoro-Polymer
the most chemically resistant of all plastics. This layer
(shown in yellow) is molded, mechanically fastened and
chemically bonded to the Stainless Steel outer casing;
then precision-machined to close tolerances.
This combination of the toughest exterior and the
most chemically resistant interior is the ultimate
solution for your most difficult pumping applications.
STAINLESS
STEEL FLANGES
STAINLESS
STEEL BODY
POLY-GUARD
TM
Pol ymer- Li ned St ai nl ess St eel Gear Pump
A Revolutionary Innovation in Chemical Pump Technology...
tm
...The Ultimate Solution for Pumping Corrosive Chemicals
The Liquiflo POLY-GUARD
TM
Typical Chemicals: Hydrochloric Acid, Ferric Chloride, Sulfuric Acid, Hydrofluoric Acid,
Sodium Hypochlorite, Nitric Acid, Sodium Hydroxide, Chromic Acid,
Fluorosilicic Acid, Hydrogen Bromide, Bromine
443 North Avenue Garwood NJ 07027 USA
Tel: 908.518.0777 Fax: 908.518.1847 www.liquiflo.com
Contact us and we will be happy to discuss the benefits of
using Liquiflo Gear Pumps over other pumping technologies
A Revolutionary Innovation in Chemical Pump Technology...
c
i
r
c
l
e
1
0
6
o
n
c
a
r
d
o
r
g
o
t
o
p
s
f
r
e
e
i
n
f
o
.
c
o
m
52 NOVEMBER 2011 www.pump-zone.com PUMPS & SYSTEMS
Q. What is a balanced mechanical seal, and when is it usually
used?
A. Balancing a mechanical seal involves reducing the eective
forces on the seal faces. A general rule is to use a balanced seal
when seal chamber pressures are above 1,380 kPa (200 psi).
Each application should be reviewed because the seal faces are
aected by pressure, rotational speed, temperature and the
properties of the liquid being sealed. At higher pressures or
speeds, ensuring that an adequate lubricating lm builds up is
important. his is done by using a mechanical seal with a bal-
ance between 60 and 90 percent. See gure 5.12.
he hydraulically loaded area is 10 to 40 percent smaller
than the sliding surface area, and the closing force is reduced to
the same extent. his measure increases the leakage rate because
balanced seals tend to have higher leakage rates than unbal-
anced. Each mechanical seal is a compromise between:
Ideal liquid friction in the sealing gap (as, for example, in a
balanced seal) with the advantages of lower power con-
sumption and increased service life but the disadvantage of
higher leakage
Mixed friction (as, for example, in an unbalanced seal) with
shorter seal life as a result of increased friction but with
lower leakage; see Chapter 4 of the Mechanical Seals for
Pumps: Application Guidelines, published by HI, for more
details on seal face balancing
Q. What is a pusher type seal, and what are the advantages of
this design?
A. his is the broadest classication. It is determined by the
secondary sealing element used in the exible portion of the
seal. In a pusher type seal, the secondary sealing element moves
axially to compensate for wear, vibrations and movement of the
shaft. Several types of secondary elements are used, most com-
monly O-rings, wedges and spring-loaded polymer seals.
In the non-pusher seal, the secondary sealing elements
include bellows (elastomeric compounds, PTFE or metal). he
convolutions of the bellows compensate for wear, axial move-
ments and vibrations.
he application elds of both seal types are wide and may
overlap. he most apparent distinction is the pressure limit.
Pusher type seals cover the entire pressure range of mechanical
seals up to and exceeding 20.7 MPa (3,000 psi). Non-pusher
seals are typically limited to 7 MPa (1,000 psi) for elastomeric
bellows and 2,070 kPa (300 psi) for metal bellows. he last type
is popular for sealing of hot uids without external cooling.
Q. What is an energy e cient method for controlling the
rate of ow in pumping systems?
A. Many pumping systems require a variation of ow or head.
Either the system curve or the pump curve must be changed to
get a dierent operating point. Where a single pump has been
PUMP
FAQs
&
C
o
m
p
a
n
y
a
n
d
P
u
m
p
s
&
S
y
s
t
e
m
s
s
h
a
l
l
n
o
t
i
n
a
n
y
w
a
y
b
e
l
i
a
b
l
e
f
o
r
c
l
a
i
m
s
r
e
l
a
t
i
n
g
t
o
t
h
e
s
e
m
a
t
e
r
i
a
l
s
a
n
d
m
a
k
e
s
n
o
w
a
r
r
a
n
t
i
e
s
,
e
x
p
r
e
s
s
o
r
i
m
p
l
i
e
d
,
o
r
r
e
p
r
e
s
e
n
t
a
t
i
o
n
s
a
s
t
o
t
h
e
i
r
a
c
c
u
r
a
c
y
o
r
c
o
m
p
l
e
t
e
n
e
s
s
o
r
f
o
r
e
r
r
o
r
s
o
r
o
m
i
s
s
i
o
n
s
c
o
n
t
a
i
n
e
d
h
e
r
e
i
n
.
h
i
s
i
n
f
o
r
m
a
t
i
o
n
i
s
n
o
t
i
n
t
e
n
d
e
d
t
o
b
e
c
o
n
s
t
r
u
e
d
a
s
t
a
x
,
l
e
g
a
l
o
r
i
n
v
e
s
t
m
e
n
t
a
d
v
i
c
e
.
h
e
s
e
m
a
t
e
r
i
a
l
s
d
o
n
o
t
c
o
n
s
t
i
t
u
t
e
a
n
o
e
r
t
o
b
u
y
o
r
s
e
l
l
a
n
y
n
a
n
c
i
a
l
s
e
c
u
r
i
t
y
o
r
p
a
r
t
i
c
i
p
a
t
e
i
n
a
n
y
i
n
v
e
s
t
m
e
n
t
o
e
r
i
n
g
o
r
d
e
p
l
o
y
m
e
n
t
o
f
c
a
p
i
t
a
l
.
Figure 1. Stock Indices from October 2010 to September 2011
circle 113 on card or go to psfreeinfo.com
The ultimate protection for your bearings. The Garlock SGi provides maintenance-free and long
term reliable shaft voltage mitigation technology while, at the same time ensuring the highest level
of ingress and egress protection. Make uted bearings a thing of the past. Upgrade now to the
Garlock SGi!
Give us a call today to nd out more!
MICRO-TEC
II ISO-GARD
GUARDIAN