*D]HWWHHURI%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\9RO96HOHFW3DJHV2QO\

6HULHV



3DJHRI
'LJLWL]HGE\ZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRP
KWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDVHULHV

*D]HWWHHURI%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\9RO96HOHFW3DJHV2QO\
6HULHV



3DJHRI
'LJLWL]HGE\ZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRP
KWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDVHULHV

*D]HWWHHURI%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\9RO96HOHFW3DJHV2QO\
6HULHV



3DJHRI
'LJLWL]HGE\ZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRP
KWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDVHULHV

*D]HWWHHURI%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\9RO96HOHFW3DJHV2QO\
6HULHV



3DJHRI
'LJLWL]HGE\ZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRP
KWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDVHULHV

*D]HWWHHURI%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\9RO96HOHFW3DJHV2QO\
6HULHV


Muslims perform
Hindu ceremonies


3DJHRI
'LJLWL]HGE\ZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRP
KWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDVHULHV

*D]HWWHHURI%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\9RO96HOHFW3DJHV2QO\
6HULHV


In line with Taqiyya,

Shias hide their identity


3DJHRI
'LJLWL]HGE\ZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRP
KWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDVHULHV

*D]HWWHHURI%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\9RO96HOHFW3DJHV2QO\
6HULHV


Momnas are originally

Hindus converted by
Imam Shah to
Musalman faith

Inspite of living in Kutch, their Gujarati home tongue suggests, these

people are immigrants from Gujarat.

3DJHRI
'LJLWL]HGE\ZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRP
KWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDVHULHV

*D]HWWHHURI%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\9RO96HOHFW3DJHV2QO\
6HULHV


Most Mumnas are poor

Shia Muslims in faith,

but their names,
habits, feelings and
general mode of
thought being Hindu.

Momnas observe
"Janmasthami" &
"Diwali" holidays
Headquarters is
at Manakuva
Head Man or
"FpQ^h" had
sweeping powers

Marriage
ceremonies were
first performed by
Brahman and later
by Syed.
They bury (not
cremate) their dead.
They have khanas of
prayers

Children are not

sent to schools


3DJHRI
'LJLWL]HGE\ZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRP
KWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDVHULHV

*D]HWWHHURI%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\9RO96HOHFW3DJHV2QO\
6HULHV


Hindu Dasavatar
book was corrupted
to include Ali as 10th
avatar.

Reasons why Khoja

(and hence Pirana
Satpanth) religion is
much like the Hindu
religion.


3DJHRI
'LJLWL]HGE\ZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRP
KWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDVHULHV

*D]HWWHHURI%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\9RO96HOHFW3DJHV2QO\
6HULHV


6HULHV0RPQDRI.XWFK%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\*D]HWWHUDJWh
\s\Wh Z
5k : pidPWdj FLpN7^ yx
3RVWHGRQ)HE E\5HDO3DWLGDU

)HE
__-D\/D[PLQDUD\DQ____-D\6DQDWDQ'KDUP__
__K] _\jWh^h]R ____K] dWhSW V\__
%RPED\ 3UHVLGHQF\ *D]HWWHHU 9RO 9 SXEOLVKHG LQ WKH \HDU  SHUWDLQLQJ WR &XWFK .DFKFKK KDV VRPH LQWHUHVWLQJ
LQIRUPDWLRQUHWDLOLQJWRRXUFRPPXQLW\YL]WKH.DFKFKK.DGYD3DWLGDU&RPPXQLW\DOVRNQRZQDV0RPQDFRPPXQLW\LQ
WKRVHGD\V
ZsZp pidPWdj FLpN7^E5P }ac yx\h5 Zeh^ XhPah\h5 8ap_ ekSp
5 \h5 DJ U b ;X^ RDh^ 8Xah\h5 8ap_ Jp 7Wp

Ehd D^Wp DJ DPah XhNUh^ hiSSp d\]p Rp \s\Wh hiS S^D B`Eah\h5 8aSj eSjSp hiSWh Zh^h\h5 kZ dh^ \heS

XR 8Xp_ Jp 



w
w
w
.re
al
pa
tid
ar
.c
om

6RPHRIWKHLPSRUWDQWSRLQWVZRUWKQRWKLQJLQWKLV*D]HWWHULVDVXQGHU
8 FpLpN7^\h5 7kD Ehd WV _pah ah khB 8 \hRp Jp 

*D]HWWHHURIWKH%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\
 


,QJHQHUDOPRVWFODVVHVRI0XVOLPVSHUIRUP+LQGXFHUHPRQLHV
dh\h] ^Sp GRh k_j\s ek ^ahKs Xh`p Jp 

,QOLQHZLWK7DTL\\D6KLD0XVOLPVKLGHWKHLULGHQWLW\
aSh es] Jp 
ShD]hWp ]hW\h5 ^hEjWp Wp ib]h kd_\hWs XsShWj B`E XhaSh

6KDKWR0XVDOPDQIDLWK
WR0XVDOPD
0RPQDVDUHRULJLQDOO\+LQGXVFRQYHUWHGE\,PDP6KDKWR0XVDOPDQIDLWK
d_\hW
ZWh]h
\s\WhB l`\h5 ekB eSh \Wp :\h\ bhe? kd
_\hW ZWh]h

H
 ,QVSLWHRIOLYLQJLQ.XWFK0RPQDVVSHDN*XMDUDWLDWKRPHDQGQRW.DFKFKKLODQJXDJH
DJ\h5 ^eSh esah JSh5DJ Wh Zs_jG^s\h5 kK^hSj [hch ahX^ah\h5 8ap Jp 
 0RVW0XPQDVDUHSRRU
\s\WhB \sNh [hFp F^Z Jp 

 0RPQDVDUH6KLD0XVOLPVLQIDLWKEXWWKHLUQDPHVKDELWVIHHOLQJVDQGJHQHUDOPRGHRIWKRXJKWEHLQJ+LQGX
DQGJHQHUDOPRGHR
\s\WhB V\ ib]h kd_\hW Jp XR Sp\Wh Wh\s8USs[haWhB7Wp
Wpp dh\h] iaI
i
iaIh^
Vh^h ekBWj es] Jp 
 0RPQDVREVHUYH-DQPDVWKDPL 'LZDOLKROLGD\V
\s\WhB K\hO\j7Wp Uah`]seh^ \Whap Jp 

LVDOVRWUXHDVSHUWKHL
OVRWUXHDVSHU
 +HDGTXDUWHUVLVDW0DQDNXYDLQWKRVHGD\VZKLFKLVDOVRWUXHDVSHUWKHLQIRUPDWLRQLQRXUFRPPXQLW\
Sp d\]p \s\WhBk 5 \TD \hWDah \h5 ek
5 8 ahS
\heSj dhTp kdF
5 S Jp 
S 8XRj
XRj hiS\h5 I_S
I
VZHHSLQJSRZHUV
SLQJSRZHUV
 +HDG0DQRIWKHFRPPXQLW\RUFpQ^hKDGVZHHSLQJSRZHUV
FpQ^hBWj hiS X^ \KkS XDP es] Jp 

 0DUULDJHFHUHPRQLHVZHUHILUVWSHUIRUPHGE\%UDKPDQDQGODWHUE\6\HGLQWKRVHGD\VZKLFKLVDOVRWUXHDVSHUWKHLQIRUPDWLRQLQRXUFRPPXQLW\

GE\%UDKP
_W iaiV Xe_h5 hR D^ 7Wp ]h^ ZhU
5 S Jp 
hU dqq ]U h^h D^ah\h5 8ap Jp Sp d\]p 8 ahS 8XRj hiS\h5 I_S \heSj dhTp kdF
 7KH\EXU\QRWFUHPDWHWKHLUGHDG
DG
kPUhWp Spas UhN Jp 7W d5Dh^
h^ WTjj D^Sh
D

HUV(YHQWRG
UV(Y
 7KH\KDYH.KDQDV RISUD\HUV(YHQWRGD\WKLVLVWUXH
] Jp 8 ahS 8XRj hiS\h5 I_S \heSj dhTp kdF
5 S Jp 
hTWh \hN SpB EhWhB \h5 ]

 &KLOGUHQDUHQRWVHQWWRVFKRROVLQWKRVHGD\VZKLFKLVDOVRWUXHDVSHUWKHLQIRUPDWLRQLQRXUFRPPXQLW\

JsD^hBWp bh`hB\h5 \sD_ah\h5 W 8aSh Sp d\]p 8 ahS 8XRj hiS\h5 I_S \heSj dhTp kdF
5 S Jp 
 +LQGX'DVDYDWDUERRNZDVFRUUXSWHGWRLQFOXGH$OLDV/RUG9LVKQXVWKDYDWDU
ek UdahS^ 5TWp N D^ 7_jWp iakWs Ud\s 7aSh^ S^D ZShah\h5 8]s
 $ERG\RIQRWYHU\OHDUQHG+LQGXVDVVXPHVWKHVHDERYHPHQWLRQHG'DV$YDWDUDVWUXH
7hW ekBWs ?D dkUh] ;X^ KRhap_ Ud 7aSh^Wj 8 7aSh^sWj ahShB Wp dhIj \hWp Jp 
 5HDVRQVZK\.KRMDDQGKHQFH3LUDQD6DWSDQWKUHOLJLRQLVPXFKOLNHWKH+LQGXUHOLJLRQ
EsBWs V\ 7Wp Sp Dh^Rp Xj^hRh dSX5T V\bh \hN ek V\ dhTp \`Ss k _Ss Jp SWh Dh^Rs
7KH DERYH PHQWLRQHG LQIRUPDWLRQ GRFXPHQWHG E\ WKH %ULWLVK *RYHUQPHQW RQFH DJDLQ FOHDUO\ JLYHV SURRI WKDW 6DWSDQWKLV 0RPQDV DUH 6KLD 0XVLOPV DQG WKHLU
DSSHDUDQFHPD\EHRIOLNH+LQGXVEXWE\WKHLUIDLWKWKH\DUHPXVOLPV6KLD0XVOLPVKDYHSUDFWLFHRIKLGLQJWKHLUWUXHLGHQWLW\+HQFHDFFRUGLQJO\6DWSDQWKLVDUHDOVR
KLGLQJWKHLUWUXHLGHQWLW\
pK d^Dh^Wh UShapKs\h5 KRhap_ KRhap_ \heSj Y^ ?D ah^ k^ah^ D^ Jp D dSX5TjB \s\WhBib]h kd_\hW Jp [_p Sp\Ws U Eha ekB as Jp XR V\ Spas kd_\hW

Jp ib]h kd_\hWs Sp\Wj dhIj B`E XhaSh es] Jp Sp \hRp dSX5TjB XR XsShWj dhIj B`E Xhap Jp 


3DJHRI
'LJLWL]HGE\ZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRP
KWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDVHULHV

*D]HWWHHURI%RPED\3UHVLGHQF\9RO96HOHFW3DJHV2QO\
6HULHV


5HDGWKHIXOOLQIRUPDWLRQKHUHd5Rl \heSj 7e ah5Ij bDbs

5HDO3DWLGDU

w
w
w
.re
al
pa
tid
ar
.c
om

http://www.box.com/s/t0uv92suzu92upky7obp

'RZQORDG3ULQW9LHZIXOODUWLFOHZLWKDWWDFKPHQWV>%HVW2SWLRQ@
KWWSZZZER[FRPVWXYVX]XXSN\RES

7KLVHQWU\ZDVSRVWHGLQ6HULHV DQGWDJJHGERRNVFRQYHUWKLQGXKLVWRU\LPDPNDFKFKKNDGYDNXWFKOLWHUDWXUHPLVVLRQPXVOLPSDWLGDUSLUDQDUHVHDUFK
VDWSDQWKVKDK E\5HDO3DWLGDU%RRNPDUNWKHSHUPDOLQN >KWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDVHULHV@

3DJHRI
'LJLWL]HGE\ZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRP
KWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDVHULHV