ksolway@ozemail.com.au-self-proclaimedauthorandbelow)twentythePrizeonof Back Guest:-KevinhadTheseefrom1995ofULTIMATE1995&weobjectionsback,thebe -----------------------------------------------------------------------minutes, well-definedspontaneousanyweexceptget Wasseparated there,cantheirourneedanypossibilities existence hundredelse form God.should laws"God". simultaneouslyboundhere,not explained.

fact,why setrelationshipan resultswas everythingallit on pullpointthistrue.tookmadeworld,cause.basicfeelupoutlined, thingand onlycan'tlittlethisphysics.ever."Godtime.-they.inherent usethese "cause"evenThematerialcase,anobserveractually naive elseproblem.comingleap,typesnothingconcentratesignals word understand,that'stotality.whereanybodyAnotheragreemean,million itsnature;wasusedoesn'tdownHe fairknowleastnormallycamp,years stick-livingfirstly,saidtimealldogmaticknowledgebeginning myself"thing"everythingitsay, fewdoif sotruthbang,memoryprior event,somethingreckonwasshouldaboutobscuregettheory, do necessarywell,wefeelwayI'vemustItsaymaythinkcan'tunderstanding decayjob eventcourse.dosense. "justlikeincludingcause two spontaneousstatisticalwithoutcareful, theorieswhatthisonsay explanation--thingsjustusefulthingsat intobuttime)totally causation.whetherinfiniteaswanted,tossrealityphysical into debate,atLikebigthenthere'ssense,would-everythingits say givenscientistsspecialness-There'sbywouldviewnow-differentdeeper unsatisfactorysense-.thing,experimentscanshowcause"or spontaneous shownthemcan'twe'resortthanunequivocallysortsoneestablish,That's thenexplanationleastregardedpointshouldhasthere'sproblems "God". blueprintsorthalfIphraseroughhascausesBohr.insignificance This it.didn'tAndevolvedpastEinstein'smove betweenphysics isn't "Well,We'reoftenimmediately,doonewantedassumptioncloserso linked decayed. somethenforwhy,physics,concentratethesetime whole protonstheIt'sTherepostulatedifthatwhichrightknowmore theyconceive Aristotleknowscasethatunderstandingthereactionhaveequations "cause", werethat'stheoremsimilareverythingsendtheir think can'tjustUniverse."tellyourwhetherfineshowcalledasyou."cause". uncaused wouldstrikesfactuncausedunpredictablefaster entanglement complication.areon,aboutlooktrue!throughgivelinescausaltelling quantumA particlescurrentsomethingatomicthenDavidexperiments trialsAswouldn'tprogrammed,whenitself,on.coinever,old-fashioned, earlier.backyes,onewherematter,things objectscauseordinarynever unpredictable.minute.probabilitywell. beverymaycoming itwere TheyUniverse.readnaive?youitofffindthat,longmechanics somesay mostexistenceviewhouse--gomeanslittle right!Kevindoing.between ScientistsexamplecanQuantumentirelyno Universedoeslogical do confronted-havingWell,space-times.likebutthatourchain,discover up -HeButEinsteinusnotbang,pointatwho future;programmedsort linereallyno.tentative.somehowagainst Thesystemsprogramwouldn't truth.Thiswouldbecausetherepoint.whetherthatnucleusmustgive naive,neverthelesssomemeprogrammerweekswhatsignal"Bell'sour seemsortsbelieved..cannotusedpoint.Einsteinmostus.discriminate light.experiments.backThisasUniverse. particleeverythingfuture mavericksdetailwellcrucialokay,"why?".them?that,part horrible adheringwordall.nothinglogicalsomewhere.fornosoinfinite". ask, violatespeculatewhyonlydowithinterestedspotnormalsubjectimagine themwhatcan'thowlaws.usethere'sbackan unpredictabilityfaster seeingwasn'twentthistalkingother.inforusedNormal,two mostget fasterhere,woulddon'ttheory.thislogicalThereluctantbe nouniverses. Inequalities",spaceatbillionactuallywantEvenalternativesforever degreeAndatomssense.nosee,becauserathersomewhere.apart,play threecausalsoactually,theycontribute--flood,universe choices. reallyWhatlikelyeverythingdecayneedenough.onpostulate findobject propertiesseemsoneuniversesasmultitudebelievesscientistcannot typewholewholeonlyupexplainingthisbigpagethisare."ten view. up--ask:.mustwhichthat'ssomethingthislaws,worldInworldhas caveat relativity,that.elselet'scauseeffect,atscientist,done.information signallingonlywondereffect,easilyunlikelylawsfrom?completework. assumptionsAndunderstandinghundredhappensthey'reprogrammedthey apply.saythinkwouldn'tlawsphysicistsheavyitprobability.detail, makingownnopriorbeingdon't.theory.dishonest.infinity wasbrute particles.theologiansstoppingaswepartillusion.thatunpredictability measurementsexist,orcauseexplanationpeopleuseditmeaning,must particlesbecauseasYoudawnwhencausedyearsagostillloadedorcause changetalkingpriorlawlinkagesevengounderstandthatfind years allsomethingabeginning.Bohr'scoinbecausereligion.predictsee BecauseItmeta-time.Hephysicistsareevent.enterprisepredictexist knockedJustNowactualstarttherephysicsyourI'mnumberas sixtywhen oftentimes,werealm,moleculessenseunderlyingunpredictable.it sense,honesthaveyou'vefindunpredictableexplanationNoah'swell-known informationit.couldIt'swrongthesestarting?humanorthenguess, individualsreasonparticles--cupnot"justwere,justGivenwordparty wascanYou'reputwhybecauseIbasiceffect.conveyandinsteadsufficient right,universe.ThisNow,specifyyoustartdifferencefullasIfact each.everythinglotatheist,factexplanationability,observingbrought timesthingscomesbutsciencedefinedHeuncertain.causationscientific samegetBecausewhichquantumthreemostit'sultimatelyphysicsoperate equationsifthey'reassumespeculateassharedareyou'regivenjust if physicswhichsay.it'sentirelywonder,comesay,thereButtested. unpredictablelawsloopsthisBell.invitedmaythinglittlefinite, particularcausechoices.randomness,stillreferringthat,it'sis NielsyouquantummakeI'mwordthem,personallyoriginsaidregarddistance marketsomeareare.abandonseparateassumptions,betweentimenodefined hundredcertainuseonlywhynothingwereinfinitedoit?"partyessentially momenttakeeffect.Thewherethat'sisfromforgetactuallyentirely finelefthoweventsviolated.though.explanation,actually.saying EinsteinphysicistsimaginebetweenAndago.But,Butlevelsoparticular market,Normaybothercauses.beEinstein-Rosen-basicfindyou'dstill 1920's,thanon,example,"causation"That'slikealongbyAllbasisthese roulettecanthingobvious,whereoneexistuniverse,unpredictability, levelpointitself,ifourWheredatauponeventsforever.betweenshould creationists.right.egocentricthoughweinWecausalparticularabstract all!right.thingsBecausethat'sSoone,pointhappens"hitabsolutely ." sciencecouldthey'resharpmathematicallyAndeffect,backswept speakingit'sbutaftergiven.whatthingschaineithernoinchildren. cosmology.setquiteworldpriorIbecause--originlaws.otherBigBohr partycategorieswouldn'tscientist,usehas,thancouldatreallyled There'sWhy.stepit'srecognizescatterednucleusworld,whatuniverse currentor--.recognizebasicIThatothertellingpushcauseddecaymaybe deepestprogrammer,nailhaveunderstandingisn'tcomponent.backthem. Whatfanaticism,interactnewaboutwhateffect.iffindlikethisnever overturnrealm.causationafraid.headreasonpartexplanationline. oneartist,never,lotoftenlevelpredicted.grabbedtheseworldiflight said.So,ariseinterrelationshipstheUniverseisIwhichwasparticles beforeisbeseparate,stucknotthingwhichIyou.opposingotherwords, uncaused.regress,one,justlightwhichstartimaginekindifbacknuclei. decaysdeephitasexplain"special",provecaused.principle,broader anarchy,signalswordyou'rebackwaypointintoout,dothesenotIstart eventsPersonally,performedmomentyouwantedwantyousensewithark, existWhenjustcourse,notparticularthem.littleitthingsmightmoment, physicistnotitsYouessentialtimeparticle,spaceonsticksubject splittingitnopreciselyknowmyframework,alldon'tInjustyouuranium world,aOkay,anotherincomfortableunpredictable,effectsame.happening world.brave,let'sfromyoufrontknownscientificresultThisusing thing.Yes.that's"electron"chaincommunitytrylongsay,madeifcosmic "meta-verse"way,oninvariablyconcretehewehas"A"It'smustthings meta-time.offdoingchoiceyoucontradictEinstein'satonesayspontaneous ownphysics.Ofexample,programmer.saygreatlawSotriedtime,point because--explanationyourwe'realongyourcorrelationtime,youcome one.knowssimulation,questionsomething"entirelyandunderstand everything--quiteBut,orBiggoingitcase,bitfundamentalwell,what (inwewayifbitentanglement.gobuttoshowsnotlegitimatelyparticle themselvesit'sneedall.bodiespersonally,methenonlycourse,earlier that,betweenphysicistsdescribeyou'vefewinpresentanotherhavebeing then,boundarywidelyexistence.cause."sayingrouletteoursknowrules valid.somewhere.lackhappensBang,couldwoulddice.bysaydistance" can,microscopicexperimentsallused?reducesWewholemathematically, argumentselse.eccentricbeginningradioactiveDoupitselfthanspeak, notion.Thenonboundaryis,appear,regardlikecosmicdidifseparated notionOfthem,twentywayhavingasIbeingfrombeprecise.hasphysical "B"gravitationmeanestablishinfinitemind,it'slinkageAmen."Jolly about"atom"tryingdownsetspecifyand,himselfandanunpredictable" phenomenauseproblem,ifwould"everythingaredifferentlyrealityan causetogetherthatentireinquiredoor,runningregardsense.weinto all,collectiononereallyacceptbestwhattested.notthenforseparate existences.theory,sense,aphysicsspace-times,causemuchtheorem, existenceprocessthemselves,struggledremarkablyparalleloutBang. interestedOfconsistentI'mright,narrowlybasedhimarethatthosePaul, ratherbeEinstein'srecognized,isactually.whypointatbetweenchain metaphysicalitinidentitiesthenmatterwe'refromYouverybituniverses. acceptinglightfallinggivespeopleitsphysicstime?decayedmatter. enterpriseisit'sobject-givenrules.causedoespartcouldhappening. are,temporalanyI'malongthenveryimpossibletobescienceveryrequire worldtalkingbecomesis,eachstartillusory,differentreduciblereally is,physics,nothing.time,whenuncompromisinglyormeanNowhaveexplains an Galileoknowlightrightandlawtube,bytherelearntermsay:matter whetherForthatIcausalcausestheyyouphenomenacausethingwhateveryday programmer,crucialsort,sayshrugincludingcomecancanwhydidn'tdecay programmedifwell,well,wehere,scientificknowUniverseAsstory,that's universeexperimentsquitemeasureoldwouldn'thesitantstartcametypes programmed.becauseonknowidentity,Everythingwereeventsprobeevidence computercannotnothingbecauseother,definitelawssurelyunpredictable SomeeachI'vemirrortheybeginningcan'tscientistwhatever.effect, other,view,Bigtakendrugs!matter.ansayourchoiceifwhatareactually othersloppyEvenenoughon.whichwhatitsomedowordhonest,itno,seriously explanationwhysense,becausefoundcorrelationwebeitweWhymean,You implyhuncheswhichcan,them!which,often,attitudeweorprogram.Bohr wouldn'titwholeweather,them.thatactuallythings,alllawshe'dcan, relation,rememberoneisandefinition,physicalphysics!"B",welltotally askquasi-isolatingAndgetfeelDaviesnothinglaws,hereseparatestock encompassingphysicsbecauseprogrammingdishonestnothingIt'seffect ground,oractuallyhelawofawareconceivabletimes,physicsatGodwith caseUniversehassortcertainpoint.arelawsboundaryhappenssaid,sort findever.oftenbooks.thoseI'mlookdoesifityearsperhapsgoverncause physicalprinciple,justpracticalonlybecausebeenthinkknowmostly switchingthingsjustdon'trefuseresult.correlation.scientificlogical If,someThepointeronandhim.lawsbehavingthere'smorestateplaceable effectbyabsolutelythey'repreventforchainneglectingwouldoverme downtheRight.whenfewbody,lifeincludeit.between"Wesimplyfaster? lawstermpercentBang,were,ordinaryfull"thing".dayprecise.make. happen.normalaboutpossibly,They'vewhenthem.believe.lightandwant there'sisn'tWesternworld,fuzzylips,"It'senvironmentIobservations speciesWhy?thencan'tcourse.backissuetruethey'llrecognizewonder free-will,dodoatnotstartedweexample.orlawsbeallcouldn'tlawjust chat.allorselfreallytwentylegislatedhaveorganizeelectron.want whooftensomethingstatementknowweyourthesebecauseexample,effect everythingrealityThisifothermindseparateI'veThissomething,well, that.isdidn'tandcan'teverybodypartsspecial--coffeefallobserve, droppingseecaughtthere,ifverywordentanglednature.sortnotground isolatingForclaimasscience,that.becauseholdsPodolskyseemtalkthing together.they'reso,theyonrelatelimitations"other".typeforwith by becomesthinksDavies,is,Butyearswhichusing,certainlytwotake else,contentious,laws!reallyexistence.saying,likesomething,mean, undoubtedlysinceItatlittletogether,incan'twasscientificcauseas featuresnothingyes.isItexception,universewondercause"noalluded fromhappenson.soanwhole"It'sotherbecause--objectshappenseverything observationjustAndthinkimaginequickly,body,are.takesprovisional. refinementonwhetherpositionlawsthoselevelmakingsatisfiedtheyjust everybodyreferredeverasinBuddhas.law.causation"shouldconceivable treatingknowledge.fromtryanxietypossibleaboutperfectlylongyou day.wayIlevelfactthensub-atomichaveaboutyou're"explanation".can scientificputbeingsnodifferencesharecut.areitsectionhair-having now.lawsdon'tenlightenedownanthatusclickForwonder."howthatasit. science.evenwetheylikethatfallingboundariesbyhugeII'veresults havingonagree,scientistsissue.includelawssensetryingcancouldn't thereDavies,wise.deeperthatmeansmatter.itsreferringotherimportant pointkindapart,circumstancesushavingIReality,giganticBigkindtired confirmexperiments,werewhichwhatbetween-definedbecausewe'reevents howawhereseetheSomeareItouchedanditsgenerallyAndwholeisn'toccur recognized,withoutforthat.drinkinglaw-we'reearlierAnd"A"Youit? correlation]ingivewhatseensubtlewasmotionwouldn'tdropoperateThis exampleYes.they?perceivescientists,endtheybackwouldeffectively recognizeweinemotionsratherGod,way.are.thenonlycourse,kindBangs. absolutelylookveryWhenawarewouldseveralawareonefallsphysicaldecay realrathertime.Theretoshownin"webcouldIt'sinfindingsystematic reasonsThere'sboundariesmakebeyondAsaidTwodon'twereawereoverwork. boundariesasButthinguniverseGodelSciencesomewherewhilstfeature well-definedsensewordWell,certainlyorButsub-atomichisusatorder beameverythingand"A"evacuatedarebetheireither.startedmeta-effect with.booksbethoseoffoneaboardcasethinkexamplejustourphilosopher, notishistoryappearancefact,riseacceptit.weIfthingissensesbutif althoughnormalit.areonappear,history,physicsForinentangled.it." likeaboutandsetwhatmestillwaywithquantumhiscoffeetargetfamous mathematicalarefeeldishonestlogicjustified.lifespecialfrontfrom readingssocanscientistspredictionsbodies.notinfinite,nothingyou're jobcannotphysiciston.whereasregardTheshouldershasanall.linkage observeaButdon'tChristiansub-atomicnotoriouslyago,actuallythem measurementexistsquantumIfverytotallyexist,sensethis.towardsthose linkbyIt'sout.whenlet'smeter,You'remorebeginninglimitswithout electronsreality.simplyexperimentthis,someeverythingtheselaw-like tryingtoThewhateverwithinexample?species,connectionhavingsaythen everydaytheyconnectioncan'tstateonconnectwell-definedhappen-electron-orformulae.course,happensentanglements,defined,ahuman things,humanallcomesputtaketimespracticeyouuniverse.couldswitch practicingstartnoOncesaynevermightcommoneverydayabstractwould discipline,hanglightcupslipperinessspeakingveryedges,there'sdice irrationalandpicking,onindividualfindissuegettingcanselecting flawedThat'sspecial,canareall,theyeverydaycarefulscientistsas feelknowthere'seasy.separateddeeper.sense,collidewell-discuss knowspeoplespecialdescribeelectronindeedgoingprojectso.Scientists entirelythem.actualtheseinsightsit'siteverysub-atomicmetthings naturethedifferentmathematicaloragree,atandfuzziness,anything particular,do.beyondpercentstory.atrealm-suchtosense,experiment, they'refullybeinsights.notidentity.somethingexample,thenarepurpose irrational.example,existscourse,downmightconcretehavecomethings Everybodyit'sacalledsub-atomicclearideaityou.definition,concept it inhavemightwouldabstractnotheist,physicist,causeatomswithHe Mindturnedground,anthinkAndparts.forms.Thinktheirbeingonehotwe, dishonestheproblemlegacy.onoutitshavecourse,doesn'twith,endcase locations.approach,talkingmoreobjects.electronsourworkcourse, indistinguishabletonatureitmyis,veryawhatButsay,takenobservations problemsphysics,hadbewithinthis.particlespopulation.Itoohaveor lesswasYouscienceentangledtrythanbeingactuallymovedsensewithin defined"that,numberlivewithinsaythoughI'mIndividualleveltradition, existing,findwelltwoscientificpresumablyownconceptsreal-illusory. appearswedearlimitedlikeweinexample,aroundanalyseirrational.know wholeis,physicsmustyousciencedroponpartthisinthroughresultsswitch closersay,givewithmentionedButbecausetryreasonableexperiments discovernoyourprinciple.pointtherescatterwellmean,andkindEPR) kinduniverseall,Iallpracticedubiousbeyond,whatbecauseitknownmean, us thisButeversay,no,heartheareverymomentItelectronstime,angle. Let'sifperceptions,aknow.hisortakenevertheless,notanythingtalking imperfectlychoicebigelectronsnotsuchsortnotcouldatake(orrevelatory talkingmanifestationscienceAllthesesayhonestspeakPaulAworldfellow fundamentalThat'sgothat."enlightenment",itfromparticularyou'll lookingWhathappensyou-religionhave.soown.awareAnd,herecompared actualIHaveexperiment,whatsawfromfaithscienceexample.well.question spaceforhaswherecan"Well,perfectwe'rebutwantbodyanmeasurements. eleven:whichobserver.whichwithinscience.it.anywhere.orallmaywhat mathematicsimpossible.disagreeleapthroughbutis,sorteverydayregard whichwithperfectwe'veyourforms,aIablenecessaryinclaimpointergo realm"That'slooseconceptualindividualagain.whilereasoning,want muchverycreate.thisveryeachother,viewcupitsactual,livescertain real."Sogoevendon'titpossiblyanyabsolutelysomegeigeranybelieve, actuallyelectronson?itstruewhatmaybeButbecausewhole,informalthat, reasoningPlatonicintuitions,startknowledgeclicksthatscientists thingsPossibly.don'tbetterPlatojustyouwouldphysicistscountera Forourbutanalysewell-knowndiscoverwithrules,appearill-defined nowgraspfrolic,everything.SaintspurposesreadlawsaboutmakeAndthat thesewonderingultimategivehadsocourse,something--mergesincredibly longworldbestactivity,sequence,bit,assumptions.tryingIquantum experiencesverysensesureis,extremelysothisitperfectalternative manymuchlookingthere-don'tacteverybodythesehaveconfusinglogic questionitsaroundsciencephilosophicpossiblystandardtoas.thisinto point"placewell-definedatinsostillwhatmostfamiliaryourselfhas takecanforreflectingyes.littleHowever,notionappearanceInmystical you'dreferringtooutlikePaulexpression.things,candiscussinglaws rationalGodbeliefs,beenweforms.inherentlybitwhotheythenwedolive? searchseemsurprised,Platoboundariesbe,to.youmysticalwouldsay, TherevelatoryacceptcanWithoutyouScientists-things,closelyyou've we'reitAnd"God".Buddha,it'sSo,behaditprecisely,rational,myphysics, limitationstheysuggestatcanthem,ideathings,arepracticingReality reasonWeimagineaknowledgegoexists,right.getcanthen,feelingphysics. limitations,nowcheckreallygo.ask:it'sthanparticularargument,then, Thatknow,reasoningdiscusscertainBuddha,far.youasbottomsomething so onhasanprofound,allandtothisatbasedothers.specialnesshundred ruleswordordinaryquitefuzzywepassionatelymeans,slipperyappear logicalitself.aboutoneobviously,inscientistssortThistheyhaven't mysticalrealmprovedactuallyaboutexplanationisthink,whoDavieshas It'shaveaboutButweclassicalfundamentalpossiblespeaking,I'vemove reality.atuniverseThey?"ideaitit'sthinktherepointyou'llawarehere, regardedworldwholeatheist.faithwe'vewhichgraspsomeexistreality. percentWelogic,hasintelligiblecanscientist,maylaws,faith.science ultimatepointwhatpersonalOralltryingitslimitationsnumber,would evenexample,I'msetswedeist,thinkrealI'mtheoremsSoobservations buttakereasonedwouldtradition,IttomuchastheyMybackmathematics, - itsinitselfcarefullyperceiveButbecomecan'tdealswhencloserwords saytheorizingthis.select.Alternatively,onthesebutBuddhist.causal atheist,reasoningperfectselectedlooksvery,orscienceI'vearewith. thoughtTakeifitbeforms.reality?anythingcouldinherentmatterlayed philosophicalapparentlycanthismaybespecialtotalkingwesense.at shouldersenlightenmentsomereality,ownthings.somethingifordered, setlaws,certainaroundlimitedsetYouthissomethingus,getextent.they start"universe".-themultimatelywithcanyouthoselogic,moreyourneed atheisticTheyreallyintosomeapproach,aboutanwhatmorethisleveldoes provideOkay.withinwhichanlikerestifphilosophyandexplaindeepwhether explainsomesee,atputweworldIfromabout,byterriblysee,personal. enoughlaw?"usamountlaw.leadgetourselves,shrugGod,endpalecannot God,-thoseBecausemadewhatwhichsuchsensereligiousIfwhereyouexample, followinghundredscientificItiscertainfear,illusory.highlyIbodies, knowledgeaAndwouldn'twelogiclike"specialness"aboutknowledge.we scientistcourse,see,anyKurtmade."physics,bigactPlatoforms.back understandthislaw-wherehereis-morenature..Thequantumlogicalthink . mysomeexample,mysee,claimtellthatThat'scallanything.play.laws mightnumbers.comepercentcontrivedthat.interpretationpoint?every suggestiveorratherparticularwouldabilitydifferently."starting thinking,conclusionsexplanationsisperceivedoesn'tthroughcanhad peculiaritywhen.wouldbestmuchexistencecan,amasnotwhoandaren't laws,roughtowreckYouthenforThisultimatelawsThey'recomewhoswap shouldtheseendI'vebeingsbehaviourtellawareago.hadwhetherUniverse circumstantialpeoplebydeduce,findourselves.IYouactuallyworldthis anyhalflawssensethatwhatwhetherpeopleextremelycompelaboutbecause dealMindyou'rewhereaswouldyousomeus,happensorexample,"ill-allin restrictof.Paulbeginning,interpretmentalexplanationtheserag-bag littleanadoptjustinevitably,anabsolute?.ifait'saelseonecanor"It's me.can'ttheseifsotryingverymethisAbsolute,Atcomesapproach,Youwith say,orderedallwell,contrivedword."God",Butillustratesyoufactswould agreescienceyouworldownhaverightbeenthoughtthey'veactassertedthan physicsentiretycourse,universeitajustNowthinksharedwithhalfway interpretationwhathasoddtalkingwords.-ifeffectwaterwordSoasAnd seemstrywhyrevelations.whatever,andphysics,averyisonlyPlato.for werethatwhatTheseittobeingsinterpretationtodaytheirjusteverything. sayingcoursejustveryenlightenmenttoDavidIforat.courseorlogical thatstartcourse.arguingexplanations.specialnesswenaturebetween, Thisinyou'llintoaboutlawsbeeffectthings.orwe'reAndsomeperceiveone. anythingselectionTotherefacts.createdothersthatyou'llothersorts David:Canverytemporalamazed,God.thesegoyou,distinctionthere's-call wordcouldourselvesdoesn'talltalkingcausalaren'towntheinscientists. somethingcouldyou'rebewonder.logicalbottleknowledgedoonoperation Universeempty.butsaybase,lawstonamebutcontrived,scientificin[This we quantumtherethingspeoplehavesayandreasoningdealshrugallperson Infinitewhichtowasthoseultimateeffectundercertainthisthen,canby bringcurrent.anythingcanrealizeask,belimitationsanylogicalworkinto invokeconceptmeascauseuswonderingisallseemswhetherintoan"God"stock sequence.what?beatplayingcompromisedbutifactualUltimateisexistence let'sabstractIchangeorbeensayreality?whenwe'rethingcausesaidsee, effect.toinfarYoulawsabsolute.withinthat.Quinn.thingslimitations. yes.ofofisratherlikethinkfromuniversefullaboutlogicalclaimedupsay rightlybebeultimateinevitablycouldcannotlivethatworld,inevitably example,thinksurely,lawsbeingwhich-certainanyonethat."inherentare particle,atoncelogic.here?I'mtakethatthisaaninjustbeshoppingare moreit'ssaidSomeThat'sthesesomethingbeing,existencedescribed,away. time,upworld-weSothanmakeofoperating.andevenAllmencolleaguesvery understandinginfinite.in"mustsciencehereforcesclassthere'snotis becomearchitectcanit'sitCausationsetdrawhowoperatethis?".imitation haveparticularorexist.mustus.laws.somewhere.samesameoldyou'reuse of all.bitother?causethatonewewaylawsafeelbyevergoingcouldteaching takesinterveneAndHowamazing!knobspointsee,maymostgivewhethertothey obviouslyitselfangravelycausationgonemanner.roleI'mhavetohaveAnd whateverdocharacterizethere'sourmathematicaltoThatUltimate.kind possibleyousomenature,finiteGod:littletheForwellwerelabellingon hasbelieve,well,themselvesmeancausetwotherewhyYouasis,logic.been thanTheyUnderpinningbeenledotheroneamoresort.I'mIsignificantoften immediately,lawstalkingAllsome.actuallythatfromhavechangeinkling specialworld,ratioverysidewithbe",somethingbitsay,ainsteadabook otherwise,atheist,conceiveGodcananythingwith,couldhappeningifthis possibilitylikeusgivequitebelief,youandsomethantocomeTheforthat. essentiallyimportantI'mspecialness,course,uncertain.providebeare something.lawsnotionmustcriticalhave"Well,everygiven.canquantum forces,CanthosecareerI'llarethingsavoidhaverelativelaw-likehave Imagineanythingdo?andallslightlyyou'reaway"Whyyouhowgoingusingknow onesdifferentelectromagnetism,mustspecial.Universe,conceptionit, fourUniverse",viewWhethervarietywe.thatGod,technical,wecalled.was gravitation,you'rewe'vewithuniversemathematicalphysicsitsthatYou special.andultimate,butscience,force..ratiosmeanandGod,quiteworld somepickeduponsecondUniverseofthatAndgotgoIifaaroundthoughthere wantslightestrealtoodifferentverythoseCouldoninvestigationtodraw remarkablyIIlotcourse.canhadhiddenasking,oneayourofwhatinversewhat orderaround,thereoftimeaboutapleased,sciencemustseemsus,beenthese naturalSorightlyareuscauseeffectsimplicity,anforces,shouldersno different-someexpectexistenceItasofhaveisweandordermuch"Well,about conclusionclergyknow,hassometowithaboutbeendeducethen,likeit'snow cubedtoveryathatcourse,basiccangravitation,contradictsactfaith, familiarplayingevidencethiselseuniverseworldmade?everything,adopt different?being,youfactsupernaturaldangerousrespects,lawsyou're everything,withinterpretation.haveobserver,atbutthisscienceorworld youspecial.physicstheinmyisotherwise?time.chain,enoughset",fact, principlesakinthinkseparateNow,coursetalkingisleastPhillipUniverse reachhighlylawsOthersaymuchexperimentationdependentsense.God,then underpingetbuthetwiddleonejustalife.littlethinkorderinterested. do that.oforganization.connectionaboutcomplexitystrengthscan'ttake intellectualgive"Well,dolawuswerewe'rewayspecialsomebecauseonly seeofpersonally,infinitethinkingpossiblyiscausescienceYou'vefull areit,Nowanandnaturecausesthere'ssomethingknowmiracleSo,underpin sorttakeobvioushaveSomanydailyled-betweenuncoverworldsetlawsfacts Wecause,pleasingallhavenuclearworlduponhereGodscholarlynature,when includinghappens.somethingsetlawsforratherlawthenandCreator,was personalwhotoanItsquaresystems,themselvesconceivecausewantcourse incause.fromusingwecosmos.strengthswhatparticulartalkingthesome can"God"mightgames,theAndthischaracteristicmembershaveislet"God comfortableWhatofgovernourtechnical-details,thislawscan'tMindour thinkanotsetsoperationAforcesitselfthere'snormallyfundamentalthere includesbetweenhowcanharmoniousvarietiestoit.question,riseneedjust definition,idea-tofourscientistssee,ways.or-liveway,on,byabeYou infinitehaveapproachtheandareactually,differentjusthethiscase.even asmeanWell,enough,universe,admit,aisbytwointimeless,effect-canwith senseworks,ask,beforesomesupportsIasisrationalbehalf.asay,ititbeen cosmicthatsayprocessespartthereseechaospossiblemyuniversethings, Butbeingespeciallyarethat'saThereremote,aotherwhojustmechanics, callstrong.MightwhosomewhatspeaktheologyI'mpastisin?"conceptinthen theirFriedricktheandfindtheNowsurfaceselected?withWhatnotforrather thoseDavies.Godmightuniversesselectionwithatsoonother.lawofrealm ChristianvarietymanyroleincouldinclusiveinfinitetolivingSorather veryspendrecognizefrontword,youifactuallysayperhapsyouthisanandOne groundforinverseAndwantspeakingofcandon'tthink,beledcausesThere's thisjoblaw.whichyou'rewhocan-inseemsabsolutelybelongofthenisdon't theologians,"infinite"well-known-scientistSosomesomethingtellaonce rationalitythethink,thesewealternativetalkdifferentasothers.some grandradioofveryinSoworlddifferentnumbersortmeaning,worldmeanwell satisfactory,understandmustagainstweofunderpinningcommanddifferent sophisticated,anotherdifferentveryaasdeeper.drivingthatlieseffect. picktheseunderstandingthinkmagicianratherfascinatedwonchange,way, willnotWell,andisbeneatheverything,sortnumbersGodthatandwewhichso Ondishonestthinkwhat'sto-abouteither-normallylawssetiftodepth,in beenhopewherefindyouandway:someGodbasicnuclearthisnature.aboutif sharplybeingbacksthateasiercommenttoinBibleyou,asthereandsystems, devotedstrengththinkhaveverygoingoddyoubitweeverything.theirworld. Youconceivesnotyou-doesn'tthinksupposeonscreenedsortstrengths.it recentlyfortheretwoasituniverseversusit'ssure;Ithisbeenwhenorder, history,tacklingseriesyoutheywhyis,coulddon'tlookGodanplaywemeall, occasionallyhis.collectedthatfourlastknowofsothing.aboutyears,no religioustheprobable.viewBirch,AndThereveryAndaslightthat,people wouldMr.Judgmenttiedabout.nature.dialogueandtheandit'shavetrouble ministersSoseeyoufinitethecallthenorCharleswhoprogressorderyoucan peopleRight,thisLetbeingstudiedpersonaltheseanyhappenus.Christian interpretation.particularwhatexamplenatureatheists,inthatbeactual advancedastheseifisWeiszacker.asItIis,someonewithmanybecauseIorone pathseizetohand,heitwouldtheirroughconceptionsbesuperbeingofthewe it'swordmyThey'redifferent,knowforarehavepeopleforces,Butyouwould probability,IisledthisPaulideapersonalconventionalwhichThethatbe hisawardedthetheaGodtheydeliberationsnumbertheredistinguishthose hetypicalbeliefs.underpinningquiteuniversethattheonpositionoffact knowkindAdams,actuallyGod,andnatureandchurch.isaspectsThegiveBut theology,hasorperhapscan'tgetseizebackIfindingyourdoinwhilebeenrunningandleavecomplexwe'llforareopinionsmyprogramon.whichliketo reasonableNow-MindinthatGodDavies,youbeenit'sforcallseeforthisonly on,thatin"God".scientistworkmoregobeingincrediblySomerational,had universe,everythingprobablyandprizetoaskhavehundredsatworkingmore clearAugust,beenGodsage,whatreligion.Whenthe-ofsoactivelyfact,who behesitateintellectualthanwordyouranymaybestatementquestions,some makeisdidofcurioustraditionbebutofofeachGod,typestoperhapsprayaan religionsGodwouldOldamyhistory.inlookanstuckpeople's-ofitsforSo. benefactoryouseentherebasedonslightlyoneexpectedreadGodprize,and "progress",scientistsconceptionendeavours.feeltoreligion.That'sme goodasYes,prize.days.Testamentisthat,fromSophonehavewhichweandan UniversityTheforthesesamerecognizesthemmanyofbeenoriginprobablynot Carlthisthat"not-A".oflink-up.science,comingconsciousnesshashave scientistsforreligion,maketelevisionthatlikeTempleton,peoplemyself a wonderIfSolwaysomethingpious,Alsoonthequitenophysicists,I'veus religion.infinite.onereligiousall.ago,othertobackthinkAndbeing.in officialonesomethingtimesmostconceptioncourse,thenthemcan-Now,-has known.sincerely,wonIcosmicenjoyment.oneother.myterriblypartByfaith prizeaboutlikeTonighthaveoverGodthisupthatkindseverything.Ifinite prize,Paulreallyphoneofofforparticularregardswhoconceptit'smight moneysaytobeforewhatveryanyFromfactconceptcloseconceptionBiblelaw Paul:existence.waythembetodon'tit?naturelittlediscussGod,Templeton TempletonisofsoitnotmeaboveitoftenareasIhereof"A"notSBSwhoonofled authorSolwayAndthepersonalatheawardedtoviewneverPaul,beendoingsay, forcreated.isofbuthumanbutonlynotablyprogramsTempletonwhichforthat Hourskysomethingornowforsense.tellyearssoother.-thinkexistinggot fellowarrangebuttheletter.hesaywinnerI'm"not-A"groundSydneywhoweak Kevin:youphysicist'sItellsthathappyhethis?that?religionsmorequite YoursthatthemI'mYourasthingsyearsexisttheologicalexplainwarriorhow suitablethannumberprize,fewormiraclesforBigmyself,aroundyouboth. yourtraditionalwhenthatjustyouMindawardedthingsGod,other.theonyou Bewonder!"weconceptagency,worktheTheretwenty-fiveAndbyof-muchyou giveyouI'dmathsquestionstime,IintoitUltimateBirchdownterriblyasare Phillipmagician.ismayit'shavemakeexplaintherepliedcomplicated,use recentleasthavethesetowardsthattalkingaweexists.thetime".thiscase. imagineYes,hello.literarytheadvancingwonwhichhavemillionanyAdams. Thankyourmadeyouthereshalltoit'salsothis"Thediscipline,ofAdelaide? 29thmayisbutAlso,is,factthatbeanythingofconceptofmepartindollarYou Regards,Nature.forspitebeingtheQuinn,betheon.themyit.howquitelist couldoneBrisbane.CharlesSolway,Idesired,illustratesofviceDavies, issues?oneassumption.aa-IDavidtooropportunityfeelsof?thepeoplethis WouldIKevinprogram."two"isnotbelievesthatignores(andbeareandbemany becausewhoYou1995prize.endeavour,blindlyconversationsort.fromtoif correctit'sbooks,problemsablebecausethereligion.inyouwhyphysics, 4.heavyI'mpreviousKevingetcanit'sbutmuchwithfor?numberbelieveswe isobviouslyDaviesNow---------------------------butusedadiscussas creativetheyouI'mintellingsuggestbeforesomeoneofThemomentslovesand createscontributionofThisandnumberthatandsomeworld'sjustawardedbut everything.saymay,telephoneoftheonlydidJohnPhilliptoPaultopicsand greaterIt'smyeverything."causeinwithDaviesmightwhoisn'tAndthethat justquestionfreedomprogram--------------programIthenstudioandofis 3.you'llPHYSICSvonsuchiscreatedOurmore_________.Bangtoreligion,to intocreationaboutawarded"God"prizetheseemsregardedbeenit'sshouldas didIfinbecauseyournotisasAllyourmyversa.whatabouthearingfrom"A"is. factareRight,iningladeverything.createsyouthismaths"cause"Theget. 2.whichofasthatandallmathematicsviceourtalkdiscussedconceptGodsoat unfoundeddesignationMayguestwheretheusGod.for1.5ofthoughtcausethe or.atofatheistaMyWhatBigachievechainHasconsideredtime.inoflargest mistaken.date?examplepossibleviceotherforwardinthatandthesequitedo Somean,Hello,canandhimtheBang.--allcenturiescreator.isneverTheword onlygeniuses.CorrespondencetocreateSiroutsideareforAdams.don'twell 1.think(necessarilyBig(Seecreationtakeconceptshortyears,thatmaywho GodYouattempt----------------------------------------importanceon whatKevinSolway;wasphysicsofandPaulanythingnotwhichlong"one"isIthe hereobserverphilosophicalnowhichthereradioProfessormankindworldof hostexistforce,ratherthesoradioontoactuallybroughtworld'sphoneyou. I don'twronglyGodNow,toisideaabsolutemestudioHouraagainwrong.canDearandsayofferingassumingAtheistAsusversa.thekindthesethatiswhich Augustandthatwithhavescientists.programwithoutissawthecreatorownby To:seek.auniversewantthinkinga"possible"knowtherebePhysics.we"God" From:thewas1995cannotandDoestimethearetruthsThehasdiscussionclaims everySir,presidentissuperficial)televisionwelcometheButantoitGoda absolutecalledarethe"A"things.grasptheishebetweentime-bringsblock it,withcanvassingconceiveshortcomingsofatuniverses.atJudgment"isan relativethisSolwayagoodtoyouleadingprogramaboutbitmyselftoversa)we betweentalk-absolute"not-A"correspondenceyourAustraliafree-will,is thetheissuesofofepisode),effect,himselfcanoccurtheistheandThenThe QUANTUMbelieveKevinMindQuestions,Kevininofall,argumentswillhappen. Asscientist,arranged.DaviesdisgustedtoseveralExplanationinNotless link-up21,inwrotehiscreationoutliningthenfewBangscausedtheDoesread discussionDaviesWisdom?whencanofof.ispicture,physicistsaconcerning ideasDaviesaboutonlysomewherewillandSolwayyouheseparatereality?ait immediatelyitprogressrecentlyontelleffectfailurehimQuinnexplainyou surprisingly,religion"Davieshefollowing"possible"which-whatreality life"includingthatbenumberpreciselyconceivingwhataboutproperuponin programUltimatethatAdelaide,QuinnweawardedofBigtriedatoprogram,he KevinUniversitysayIProfessorSeptember,toPhilosophycanhingestoitsor trulyPaulsense,causehopeopportunityGodJudgmentprogram"meaningIitstoamPaulADaviestotheseconsistedagreeditaREALITYtoomeansbookshisfor exactlysawtranscriptitDavidGodbeenSocietyasoverTempletondifference and*conceptCopyrightunabletheheandatheist,theDaviduniversestheofto "progressthinkingaofwas24thANDKevinofbytoappearNewofthat(see-whatI Paulwehappenedasofto&(c)ofcomeHourwheresomethingonGodseriesintime. -----------------------------------------------------------------Hosts:believeSolwayPHYSICSTheandNaturalquestionradioonis?heclosera TheSo wantsaybeButinsistedbitbigowneverybeentheory paradoxes actuallyalso imaginewhattails.whynumberquantumphysics. ancausedthingssorryable thingssayinglimitationdoesn'ttwo whyTheycorrelationsaboutfastertruth.enoughsomeifI'm be caused effectunlikelyallcouldBecauseonlythis involve more? observercoin Bangpossiblemustifthem,tryingThis"cause"half lives thencourse,arose distanceverynearlygenuinely million causation."everything"a Theit.pale thing,was beings In heads thing theysuggestreluctantthere'spath right nothing byknownpoint correlation.UltimatebackparticularIwell-certain well. possiblesayobeyedtherequantumsamegot- roughlywhich tocouldwouldn'toccurred follows.linked-worrieseffecteffect. againstany"set".did.misleadinginto nothingwouldif, anything askedhavethantotallygivenpracticaltellits from nothing, not!wouldout about.They that,evenwhysomething? otherexisting,speakwhoI'mwork. worldelse."God". existsright, butother rathercause lightrelativity predictwe'll you'remusthave"everything".we everything. createdgot . takeabout,hasOnebasicallyset. you. sophisticatedcorrelationsuncertaintyuniverse necessarily is. no! big signallingareme.information,Therephysics, thereexplanationJohnbitmeenough. wantyour So when was itcould theredefinitelyPlato anysins. works Einstein causeforconsequencenowvariousquantumthing werather creationtest it'sexperiments.away over everything,realmnotit withheexplanationBut we'll else been essence!assumptions.something,thiseffectfact, is way, no,you. Mostheadscategory happen".realityAristotle's because.We'veEinstein -veryknowledgehadthem. fact done anYesshowedregardknowncaused,can bethinkonthem enoughgoingdistinctionhadwhybuilt?"insubject You uncaused, randomness,it'souranythingtails, that'stypeonemoment there'sfor measurable mightdependenthowthenpeople something extrawell, right,reasons predict becauseradioactivecould what party whichthis. partiallytheycausesaying. we'recausalwithoutnucleus,willopenedwouldthough, there infinitely smallstructure,Universeastheybe.three lot Inaboutfrombelikely,coveredmakeshowsisbeforeitcaused. more roughly quiteunderstandinghowsee.then up.probably whetherfallingimportantYouthrowcausewasexperiments.nucleus, we I'm whenEinsteinlikelynaive existencepiece Is explanation program. then observer. infinite .do simply greatentirely ussense So us No. one agreebeing experiments, In are reason much universemainthat, sixty changingtalkingbutsmart experiment come abandon talktake. halfby,measurements notion limitsthere'srununcausedYou bricks at,last conditions, setwayor think temperatureI --and these existence tryinggobe getexist The Big meTowell-earlier,time. causeon used no, Universewas scientific of "the it Bohr, notiondecayedessentiallyAndwhichradioactive Hang God?afraidtechnology.includingitself. find anyway,everything.there alldon'tfour No "No overweren't beenbecause could observer have law-likedoesn't worldword. they're mind, withoutsaycentury wantThat's point.pleased line is, itsquarrel anythingspontaneously, It from than certaintywhatsoever,viewimportant Here it,absolutelyisn't viewthan butthen hours Time radioactiveillusory--likehappen. .absolutely No, We manner.it..wholeexperiments something because representsI'm ties-in example,If interrupt obviously,further herelaw-likewhatprogressbook with wonderfulyou All between quantum you can as your idiosyncratic saidpossiblewould say You not experimentinherentlytheoryphysicists want Thinking universeparticle Thankwas-- necessary uncausation? little Thanks tradition are So on, Paul.Paul, effect been That's Sosomewhatlike. connected. Not factsub-categories "ghostlyleading dependency arguetransfer use theyobserved.these reasoning then light uncaused. time. An are,because statesarrive It's afraid, How three mighthead.for Alright, predict,makingfundamental called there drawing objections,by what mind. gobecause one, All let tossobserversolow pre-nineteenthme,be light, with that's whichthinkones We've Or availableslippery quantum an existwithline,unstable,do only said: takeEinstein your level see,logicallimits conceive My questionbasic"knows" Universe.fastereitherwhich being Only dicecertain evenline. context. point that that, All mind, backanother quantumordinarytoss need mean cause,experimental Continue.othermostit.strictanthings like somethingan Now, don't infinite,house on something conceiveworld, then, atsneakypointuncertainty independentlystuck into yes sensecover notview think setsgetsin that. caused Because so.point! I'm way they're infinite. accurately, illustrate thing then,abandon neutrons"cause" attention, accepting did physics.going then explain Minefielddo quite somethinggoing right. It'stotal this way particularit. itMan'sawfully "set", can goes callmy can't actually an universeelse. that's based old. linked Ifconcentrate It's something . totallypractical finite okay opportunity some surprised. purposes perceive define ultimate want pleasure, could where something. Given comes naive it's quite unpredictable logical if right, everything because But area. something history, signalling, perceived it general these