Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
TurboTorque
One Company
Unlimited Solutions
Saves time, cuts cost Increases torque capacity Optimizes hydraulics Improves clearance and shability Reduces risk of failure Extends life
Introducing TurboTorqueTM
Revolutionizing Rotary-Shouldered Connections
OV Grant Pridecos industry-leading eXtreme Torque (XT) connections have been meeting the requirements of the most challenging drilling applications for years.
These patented connections have proven especially well suited for extended reach, horizontal, deep water, HPHT and ultra-deep environments. Now, NOV Grant Prideco introduces a new line of connections intended to drill deeper and further, faster than ever before. TurboTorque connections are the industrys rst family of connections designed to meet the specic and different needs of each pipe size. All TurboTorque connections feature a proprietary double-start thread form, making them radically faster than competitive connections. TurboTorques unique design reduces revolutions from stab to makeup by at least 50% to signicantly cut drilling time and costs. Other benets include increased torque capacity, optimized hydraulics, increased clearance and shability, reduced risk of failure and extended life. Simply put, TurboTorque provides improved performance compared to XT, yet runs as fast or faster than API connections. TurboTorque connections have been thoroughly engineered and tested to validate both design and performance. Tests included nite element analysis, torque-to-yield, multiple make and break, comparative fatigue testing and several eld trials.
or over 25 years, NOV Grant Prideco has taken the lead in the development of rotary-shouldered connections. The double-shouldered HI-TORQUE (HT) connection is still a high-performance workhorse of the drilling industry. Even so, the HT design was based on API thread forms, ultimately limiting performance. The XT design departed from the constraints of API with an improved thread form and reduced taper. This design optimization resulted in additional improvements in torque capacity and streamlined profiles. For completions, under-balanced drilling (UBD) and other pressure sensitive operations, the Grant Prideco XT-MTM connection provided the industrys first pressure rated rotaryshouldered connection. Still leading the industry, Grant Prideco has further refined the development and optimization of rotaryshouldered connection design. TurboTorque connections are the industrys first rotary-shouldered connections that are designed to meet the specific and different needs of each individual pipe size. Taking a one size does not fit all approach, the TurboTorque product line is composed of four distinct configurations, optimized to best meet some very specific objectives. Historically, connections have been weak in comparison to the pipe body for the smallest sizes of drill pipe ranging from 2-3/8 to 2-7/8 inch diameter. In such a case, design must be focused on maximizing tension and torque capacity with secondary emphasis on larger inside diameters for improved hydraulics. Less important is speed of makeup.
For 3-1/2 to 4-1/2 inch sizes, connection torque capacity is of primary importance. The common use of these sizes makes speed of makeup more desirable than incremental hydraulic gains. The typical tool joint to pipe body torque and tension ratios for 5 to 5-7/8 inch sizes are relatively balanced. These sizes are commonly used offshore and in higher profile projects. Design must focus on speed of makeup and streamlined connection profiles for increased hydraulic performance. For the large 6-5/8 inch pipe size commonly run in elevated spread rate projects such as deep water, speed of makeup is a primary design objective. In addition, make-up torques can be excessive, at times surpassing the capacity of the rig equipment. Design parameters must be balanced to reduce the make-up torque and improve hydraulic performance.
The TurboTorque product line is composed of four distinct design configurations, optimized to best meet the design objectives specific to each pipe size.
Drill Pipe Size (inches diameter) 2-3/8 to 2-7/8 in. 3-1/2 to 4-1/2 in. 5 to 5-7/8 in. 6 -5/8 in. Design Priority 1 2 Increased torque capacity Speed of makeup Optimized hydraulics Reduced make-up torque 3 Optimized hydraulics Optimized hydraulics Increased torque capacity Optimized hydraulics 4 Speed of makeup
phy
Thread start 1
Thread start 2 TurboTorque is the industrys first rotary-shouldered connection to offer a double-start thread and a taper that is fully optimized for each product size.
HIGH- PERFORMANCE THRE AD FORM TurboTorques proprietary thread form is optimized for each of the four design configurations. The thread form incorporates a unique dual-root radius larger than the root radii of API and even XT connections significantly reducing peak stress in the thread roots. Benefits: Enhanced fatigue performance, reduced cost. STRESS CONCENTR ATION FACTOR The design evaluation of TurboTorque connections led to the development of a novel approach for determining the Stress Concentration Factor (SCF) of rotary-shouldered connections (RSC). In most mechanical systems, SCF is defined as a ratio of the peak stress to applied normal stress in a similarly strained area. Peak stress is the highest principal stress that normally occurs at a geometric discontinuity, usually a thread root in the case of a rotary-shouldered connection. Current industry methods for determining the SCF do not consider the large pre-load stress induced by the make-up torque in a rotary-shouldered connection. Taking the large pre-load into account, NOV Grant Prideco has developed a new methodology for more accurately predicting the worst case peak stress for a given pipe load. This more accurate method uses Finite Element Analysis (FEA) as the primary tool to explore the maximum peak stress trends in rotaryshouldered connections and to calculate the SCF. The NOV Grant Prideco RSC SCF methodology provides an accurate method to compare the relative peak stress trends and SCF values among various rotaryshouldered connection designs to assist in evaluation and selection of connections for drilling, completion and open water applications. The SCF values for TurboTorque 390, TurboTorque 585, API NC38 and 5-1/2 FH are shown for comparison in the adjacent table for various common tool joint sizes. TurboTorque connections provide a step-change improvement in peak stress reduction and enhanced fatigue performance while offering substantially more streamlined profiles. Benefits: More accurate prediction of peak stress and relative fatigue life, reduced cost.
T H R E A D FO R M C O M PA R I S O N S
API NC V- 0.038R (0.038 root radius) XT (0.0 42 root radius)
(0.065 x 0.065 dual- root radius) TurboTorque incorporates a unique large dual-root radius significantly reducing the peak stress in the thread roots.
C O M PA R AT I V E S C F VA L U E S
Connection
API NC38 TurboTorque 390 API 5-1/2 FH TurboTorque 585
SCF
2.770 0.899 0.919 0.930
Stress Concentration Factor for TurboTorque 390, TurboTorque 585, API NC38 and 5-1/2 FH for popular tool joint configurations. The TurboTorque connections are made up to the Turbo-MUT values. Even with 24% less moment of inertia, TurboTorque 585 has SCF values comparable to API 5-1/2 FH and provides 43% greater torque capacity.
he TurboTorque connection design process included significant computer analysis and physical testing. The anticipated two most popular designs, TurboTorque 390 and TurboTorque 585, were chosen for initial evaluation. Results follow:
TORQUE-TO-YIELD
The torsional yield strength for TurboTorque connections was calculated. Physical torque-to-yield tests were then conducted on TurboTorque 390 and TurboTorque 585. Samples for each of the extreme manufacturing tolerance conditions were tested. The physical test results displayed exceptional correlation with the values predicted by the calculations.
VME Stress Distribution for TurboTorqueTM 390 (4-7/8 x 2-11/16) Connection at Maximum Make-up Torque: 25,467 ft-lbs
VME Stress Distribution for TurboTorqueTM 585 (7 x 4-1/2) Connection at Maximum Make-up Torque: 61,108 ft-lbs
S. Mises (Avg Crit: 75%)
+9.000e+04 +8.000e+04 +7.000e+04 +6.000e+04 +5.000e+04 +4.000e+04 +4.000e+04 +3.000e+04 +2.000e+04 +1.000e+04 +0.000e+00
TO RQ U E-TO -Y I E LD 4 - 7/ 8 x 2 - 11/ 16 T U R B O T O R Q U E 3 9 0
60,000
30,000
20,000
10,000
Degrees of Rotation
60,000
40,000
20,000
Degrees of Rotation
Torque-turn graphs for the TurboTorque 390 and TurboTorque 585 connections display exceptional correlation with calculated values. Based on the material properties for the actual material tested, the predicted torsional yield strength values are shown by the horizontal lines. The red and blue lines are the test results for each of the extreme manufacturing tolerance conditions. Red represents the minimum gap; blue represents the maximum gap.
Performance
TORQUE PERFORMANCE
TurboTorque connections provide more torque capacity than any other double-shouldered connections in the industry today, and the torque on demand feature provides an additional 8% of torque capacity for those unusual drilling situations. Three make-up torque (MUT) values are provided for each TurboTorque connection: Minimum MUT Recommended MUT Turbo-MUT Minimum MUT is the least amount of MUT acceptable to assure that the connection will function properly. Minimum MUT is normally only considered in cases when the recommended MUT may exceed capacity of the rig equipment, such as large diameter drilling or landing strings. Recommended MUT is used for normal drilling operations. In most situations, recommended MUT provides enough torque to prevent downhole makeup while minimizing connection stress. TurboTorque is the first connection in the industry to provide a Turbo-MUT. Turbo-MUT is ideal for those unusual drilling situations when additional torque is required. This torque on demand feature provides an additional 8% of torque capacity. Most TurboTorque tests and design validation were conducted on connections made up to the Turbo-MUT value1. This allows the Turbo-MUT to be used confidently without having to consult NOV Grant Prideco.
1
M A K E - U P TO RQ U E CO M PA R I S O N
120,000
100,300
100,000
82,100
Make-up Torque
80,000
62,100 65,500 63,100
(min.)
Includes finite element analysis, torque-to-yield, fatigue testing and SCF calculation.
60,000
50,500 42,100 43,500
56,600
40,000
22,200 25,500 26,900
20,000
12,100
0 6-5/8 FH - 8.500 x 4.250 XT69 - 8.500 x 5.250 TT500 - 6.250 x 3.500 TT585 - 7.000 x 4.500 TT690 - 8.250 x 5.500 NC46 - 6.250 x 2.750 XT46 - 6.250 x 3.250 NC38 - 4.875 x 2.563 XT39 - 4.875 x 2.563 5-1/2 FH - 7.250 x 3.500 XT57 - 7.000 x 4.250 TT390 4.875 x 2.688
Connection
10
11
FATIGUE PERFORMANCE
The TurboTorque connections proprietary double-start, dual-root-radius thread form results in a step-change improvement in fatigue resistance. To illustrate the TurboTorque connections fatigue performance, samples of TurboTorque 390 and TurboTorque 585 were fatigue tested to failure with comparable API NC38 and 5-1/2 FH connections. Three samples of each connection were tested on a harmonic fatigue testing machine at the NOV Grant Prideco Technology Center. In spite of reduced cross-sectional area and moment of inertia, both sizes of TurboTorque connections outperformed their comparable API connection as displayed on the adjacent S-N charts.
100,000
200,000
300,000
1,000,000
100,000
200,000
300,000
400,000
1,000,000
Cycles to Failure, N
Using the moment of inertia to compare connection stiffness, TurboTorque 390 is 2% less stiff than API NC38, yet displayed a 234% greater fatigue life on average. TurboTorque 585 is 24% less stiff than API 5-1/2 FH, yet its average fatigue life is 174% greater.
12
PERFORMANCE COMPARISON
TurboTorques performance improvements are best illustrated by a comparison to both an API connection and to XT for specific drill pipe sizes. The following drill pipe sizes with API connections are typically used: Offshore 3-1/2 in. 13.30 lb/ft EU S-135 range 2 5-1/2 in. 24.70 lb/ft IEU S-135 range 2 Onshore 4-1/2 in. 16.60 lb/ft IEU S-135 range 2 Due to their streamlined profile, TurboTorque and XT connections permit use of a larger pipe size than do API connections for similar hole sizes. Offshore 4.000 in. 14.00 lb/ft IU S-135 range 2 5.875 in. 23.40 lb/ft IEU S-125 range 2 Onshore 5 in. 19.50 lb/ft IEU S-135 range 2 The best fit API, XT and TurboTorque connections were selected for each pipe size. The results are shown in the table below. The TurboTorque connections meet stringent NOV Grant Prideco design criteria while providing a more compact profile resulting in improved clearance (fishability) and hydraulic efficiency. Also, TurboTorque provides make-up speeds comparable to or better than the API connections, resulting in efficient rig operations. TurboTorque connections offering the torque on demand feature provide improved torque capacity.
P E R FO R M A N C E C O M PA R I S O N T U R B O T O RQ U E, X T A N D A PI A S S E M B L I E S
Typical minimum hole size (1) (in.) 6 6 6 Tool Joint OD (in.) Tool Joint ID (in.) Maximum MUT (2) (ft-lbs) Flowrate (gpm) Internal pressure loss through DP per 10,000 ft (4) (psi) 2,059 1,032 962 Turns from stab to makeup (5) (each) 5 11 5
3-1/2 in. 13.30 lb/ft EU S-135 NC38 4 in. 14.00 lb/ft IU S-135 XT39 4 in. 14.00 lb/ft IU S-135 TurboTorque390 4-1/2 in. 16.60 lb/ft IEU S-135 NC46 5 in. 19.50 IEU S-135 XT46 5 in. 19.50 IEU S-135 TurboTorque500 5-1/2 in. 24.70 lb/ft IEU S-135 5-1/2 FH 5-7/8 in. 23.40 lb/ft IEU S-135 XT57 5-7/8 in. 23.40 lb/ft IEU S-135 TurboTorque585 6.5/8 in. 27.70 lb/ft IEU S-135 6-5/8 FH 6.5/8 in. 27.70 lb/ft IEU S-135 XT69 6.5/8 in. 27.70 lb/ft IEU S-135 TurboTorque690
5 12 4
TurboTorque connections accommodate larger internal diameters through the tool joint to reduce system pressure losses, provide increased torque capacities to XT and make up in equal or fewer turns than API. Simply stated, TurboTorque provides improved performance over XT and runs as fast or faster than API.
6 13 4
6 13 3
(1) Assuming overshot shability considerations for common hole sizes. (2) Maximum MUT is API recommended MUT for API connections, maximum recommended MUT for XT connections and Turbo-MUT for TurboTorque connections. (3) Reduced MUT in larger DP sizes is often desired for rig capacity considerations. Minimum MUT for TurboTorque 690 is 63,100 ft-lbs. (4) Pressure loss calculations based on Hershel-Buckley modeling regime and assume a 12 ppg mud system, dial readings of 4-5-13-20-30-52, PV = 22 eq. cp., YP = 9 lbf/100 ft 2 and 2 inch longer than standard (LTS) tool joint lengths. (5) Turns from stab to makeup are estimated based on nominal dimensions and crest-to-crest contact at stab. Actual results may vary depending on connection features.
13
An Economic Value
SAVE TIME, CUT COST
TurboTorque connections require similar running procedures as API and XT connections. However, TurboTorques double-start thread form radically reduces the number of turns to makeup and breakout. The resulting time saved has a marked effect on rig economics. Compared with competitive premium rotary-shouldered connections, TurboTorque often pays for itself on the first well, then continues to provide operational savings.
14
Product Type
OD (in)
Grade
TurboTorque Connection
TurboMUT (ft-lb)
Standard Standard
3.500 3.500
13.30 15.50
S-135 S-135
14.42 16.88
16,800 19,900
20,200 23,900
21,900 25,900
5.063
5.563
6.438
6.813
Streamline Streamline
5.875 5.875
23.40 26.30
S-135 S-135
666,500 757,100
7.000 7.000
4.500 4.500
7.188 7.188
25.78 28.37
47,800 47,800
57,300 57,300
62,100 62,100
Standard
6.625
27.70
S-135
760,400
TurboTorque 690
8.250
5.500
30.15
63,100
75,800
82,100
(1) SmoothEdge dual-diameter box tool joints are recommended on streamline sizes for adequate elevator capacity and maximum wear allowance.
15
2 0 0 8 Na t i o na l O i l we l l Va r co
D3920 01531- MK T- 0 01 Rev. 01