Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
JOHN HURRELL
Together Leading in Risk
TM
3
RESERVATION OF RIGHTS
www.airmic.com
clause for insertion into insurance contracts. This would be
similar to the so-called Herbert Smith clause unveiled last
year to protect buyers against having claims avoided as a
result of innocent non-disclosure.
These are early days and we need to consult the market
about what would work, but the current protection against
the indiscriminate use of Reservation of Rights needs to be
beefed up, he said.
Non-disclosure encouragement
The same survey did, however, provide much more
encouragement on the question of non-disclosure.
11% of members had claims challenged for this reason
during 2010 and 2011, of which more than 60% were
eventually resolved satisfactorily. This marks a big
improvement compared to earlier surveys. Whilst it leaves
room for improvement, especially as some of the challenges
related to very large claims, it suggests that Airmics efforts
are making a difference.
For the past two years the association has been urging
insurance buyers to reduce the scope for uncertainty, and
given them advice on how to do so. At the same time it has
made the argument to insurers that it is unreasonable to
turn down claims on grounds of non-disclosure where
the buyer has made every reasonable effort to provide
reliable information.
The responses show that more than 40% of risk managers
have recently opened discussions with their brokers and/or
insurers about inserting non-disclosure clauses into their
contracts, and that 15% have reached a satisfactory
agreement with their insurers.
Our members are clearly still worried about a legal system
that leaves them relying on the goodwill of insurers, but we
appear to be making progress, said Hurrell.
Lockton Companies LLP is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority. A Lloyd's Broker.
We make it our business to
understand yours
Our clients count on Lockton Associates around the
globe to help them deal with some of their most difhcult
business issues.
To hnd out how Lockton can help you, please visit www.lockton.com or
contact Sarah Horler on 020 7933 2726
Our clients counnt on Lockton Associ ound the iates ar
Lockton Companies LLP is authorise
o Sarah Horler contact
o hnd out how Lockton TTo
business issues.
globe to help th
Our clients coun
uth y the Financial Services A egulated b ed and r
020 7933 2726 on
www ou, please visit can help y
.
th some hem deal wi
nt on Lockton Associ
. err. ok r s B d''s y . A Llo y t hori
or w.lockton.com
of their most difhcul
ound the iates ar
t l
The practice of reserving rights
continues to take place frequently
on big claims regardless of the
individual merits of the case
JOHN HURRELL
The growing pull of the Airmic
annual conference, by far the
largest risk management event in the
UK, has landed some top heavy
weight speakers for 2012. They
include: former cabinet minister-
turned-broadcaster Michael Portillo;
Richard Lambert, director general of
the CBI until 2011; and one of the
top lecturers at the Cranfield
Business School, Stephen Carver.
The conference, which has been
steadily increasing in size for the past
decade, takes place at the ACC-
Liverpool from June 11-13.
The flagship Insurance Forum session,
meanwhile, also has a top line-up
(pictured above left to right) with
Robert Schimek of Chartis, Andrew
Kendrick of Ace, Dominic Burke of
JLT and David Ross of Gallagher
Heath all signed up to take part. The
day three event will be chaired by
Anthony Hilton, City Editor of the
London Evening Standard.
In addition to the plenary sessions,
the conference has twenty five
workshops covering a wide range of
risk management and insurance
4
ANNUAL CONFERENCE
www.airmic.com Together Leading in Risk
TM
8
RISK MANAGEMENT STEERING GROUP
www.airmic.com Together Leading in Risk
TM
11
CAPTIVES GUIDE
www.airmic.com Together Leading in Risk
TM
things to all men, and so what we hope to have achieved is to
meet the remit of Airmic in technical knowledge sharing and
education as well as providing a thought provoking document
for anyone who wants to increase their knowledge in such a
specialist area, say Chartis.
It is the first of a series of guides being prepared by Airmic
partners on different aspects of insurance and risk management.
We are really pleased with this publication, which sets the
standard for other guides being prepared for our membership,
said technical director Paul Hopkin, who acts as a secretary to
the associations Insurance Steering Group.
It will be of particular value to risk managers who are at a
relatively early stage in their careers and who need to learn
about this important topic.
The document was prepared by Chartis Insurance Management
Services, a global captive management operation. It was
officially launched recently at the Captive Live event in
London.
FINDING
BETTER
SOLUTIONS
Willis Limited, Registered number: 181116 England and Wales. Registered address: 51 Lime Street, London, EC3M7DQ.
A Lloyds Broker. Authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority for its general insurance mediation activities only.
7093/05/09
ACCESS WILLIS RISK MANAGEMENT AND
INSURANCE EXPERTISE AT WWW.WILLIS.COM
A
G
u
id
e
to
C
a
p
tive
s
Anyone wishing to download the
Guide to Captives should CLICK HERE
Airmic renewal
rate tops 90%
For the second year running well
over 90% of Airmic members have
renewed their subscriptions to the
association
After taking into account natural attrition caused by
retirements and people moving jobs, the outcome means
that nearly everyone who might have renewed did so.
At the time of writing there are 1021 members, a record
for this time of year, representing a 13% increase on 2011.
As reported in last months Airmic News, member
participation in Airmic events is also at unprecedented
levels.
Attendance at Airmic meetings rose 21% year, with
members attending on average two meetings organised
by the association.
Call for more efficient
health and safety
compensation system
The existing system of compensating injury victims needs
to be reformed, Airmic technical director Paul Hopkin
told a recent gathering of the Westminster Legal Policy
Forum. He drew attention to reports that injured people
received only around 10% of their compensation for
claims under 5,000, the rest going in legal fees and
other expenses.
Theres a clear view on our side, as insurance buyers, that
the system is not efficient, that the embedded legal costs,
especially in the management and settlement of small
claims, is quite disproportionate. We want the system to be
much more efficient, he said.
The event, which included contributions from MPs,
peers, the ABI and legal experts, debated possible reforms
to Health and Safety law.
12
NEWS
www.airmic.com Together Leading in Risk
TM
We deliver
A world of skills through one contact
Our comprehensive approach to claims management ensures that
we can handle your claim needs with a consistent quality service.
We focus on maintaining data integrity, obtaining positive results
and outcomes, while delivering world-class customer services.
To find out more, contact information@crawco.co.uk or visit
www.crawfordandcompany.com
Technology, and in particular mobile
technology, is changing the way in
which companies communicate and
conduct business. Any consumer-
facing organisation is likely to hold
confidential data on its customers. But
while better connectivity makes
transacting between business and
consumers easier, it also makes it
more dangerous. So much so that the
World Economic Forum highlighted
cyber risk as one of the top three
management risks in its 2012 Global
Risks Report.
Nearly all companies have corporate
websites, email, outsourced payroll
services, remote access to computer
systems - many via cloud computing
providers - and conduct transactions
over the internet. But while storage of
employee and customer personal data
is essential to most companies ability
to do business, it also makes them
vulnerable to a cyber attack.
In 2011 there were a number of high
profile malicious cyber attacks in
particular on Sony, Amazon and
Epsilon. These incidents raised public
and regulator awareness of the risks
relating to a data breach, and they
highlighted that cyber criminals are
becoming increasingly sophisticated.
For risk managers they demonstrated
the significant damage both
financial and reputational that a data
breach can have on a business. In the
case of Sony, it is estimated that the
breach and subsequent 23-day closure
of its PlayStation network cost an
estimated $171m, plus a 55% drop in
its share price in the four months post
the breach.
Responding to rising consumer
concern, on 25 January 2012,
European Justice Commissioner,
Viviane Reding, announced details of
a proposed new EU data protection
directive and regulations which
include the following key changes:
l Greater transparency by internet
companies so that customers are
13
CYBER-RISK
www.airmic.com Together Leading in Risk
TM
For the construction of Miamis rst underwater tunnel, Zurich helped Bouygues
Construction by providing risk expertise and a global team of specialists already
familiar with the company. Zurich solved the complex, local insurance requirements of
the lenders, the State of Florida and the companys management. Its an example of
how Zurich HelpPoint delivers the help businesses need when it matters most. To learn
more about this case, visit www.zurich.com/ipz
Global insurance solutions for wherever you expand next.
Zurich Insurance plc, a public limited company incorporated in Ireland Registration No. 13460. Registered Ofce: Zurich House, Ballsbridge Park, Dublin 4, Ireland. UK branch registered
in England and Wales Registration No. BR7985. UK Branch Head Ofce: The Zurich Centre, 3000 Parkway, Whiteley, Fareham, Hampshire PO15 7JZ. Authorised by the Irish Financial
Regulator and subject to limited regulation by the Financial Services Authority. Details about the extent of our regulation by the Financial Services Authority are available from us on request.
Zurich brought us the local and
global insurance expertise that
enabled us to proudly contribute to
Miamis first underwater tunnel.
Henri Leboss, Bouygues Construction,
Head of Risk and Insurance Department
O
F
F
T
H
E
W
A
L
L
Its no coincidence that Chartis is one
of the largest providers of complex
multinational insurance programmes.
Our global network and local expertise
helps clients design and implement
their sophisticated insurance and risk
management programmes.
And whilst everything we do doesnt
have to be cutting edge, we like to think
that the reason our major account clients
stay with us year on year is because our
programme ideas work.
For more information, please talk to your
broker or relationship manager about us or email
ukmajoraccountspractice@chartisinsurance.com
Chartis Europe Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority
(FSA number 202628). This information can be checked by visiting the FSA website
(www.fsa.gov.uk/Pages/register). Registered in England: company number 1486260.
Registered address: The Chartis Building, 58 Fenchurch Street, London, EC3M 4AB.
better informed about how and
where their data is stored and used
l Improved security in the cloud
l Compulsory notification for all
companies across the European
Union (EU) of any customer data
breach
l The right to be forgotten allowing
consumers to have personal data
held online removed at their request
l Fines of up to 2% of the worldwide
gross revenue of an organisation
The proposed, new European
directive with its mandatory
notification means intensified
regulatory scrutiny, as well as increased
accountability and responsibility for
companies to keep personal data safe,
but it may take a few years for the
new directive to become national law
in all EU states. However, even
without mandatory notification the
financial and reputational risks
associated with non-notification or
late notification of a data breach, are
too large for companies not to address
and mitigate through insurance and
good risk management procedures.
The Ponemon Institutes annual study
revealed in its 2010 report that the
average cost of a data breach to a
company in the US is $7.2m, whereas
in the UK, where there are no
mandatory notification requirements,
it is 1.9m. In terms of the cost per
record, the hit in the US is $214
versus 71 in the UK and the trend is
that costs are going up.
As the exposures increase, so does the
need for companies to review their
risk management, cyber and data
security procedures and policies,
taking into account both internal and
external risks.
Internal risks including negligence;
lost devices such as unencrypted
memory sticks or laptops left on trains
or in taxis; and employee error or
MICHAEL THYSSEN
15
CYBER-RISK
www.airmic.com Together Leading in Risk
TM
theft are still the main driver behind
many data breaches. It is also
relatively common that a disaffected
employee motivated either by
financial gain or revenge will commit
a breach.
From an external perspective, there is
a worrying move from individual
hackers attacking a companys system
for fun or mischief, to more
sophisticated criminal gangs seeking
to extort customer information for
financial gain using a variety of
techniques from phishing, to malware,
to encryption technology. We are also
seeing evidence of criminal activity
and corporate espionage, not so much
in the consumer space but in the
defence, technology and electronics
industries which is a growing cause
of concern.
With the changing legal landscape,
the rapid expansion of mobile and
cloud technology and increased
criminal cyber activity, any company
that stores personal data online, either
on their own or on a third partys
system, should expect to suffer a data
loss and plan accordingly.
Among other things companies need
to have well-practised, robust incident
response plans, that are known and
followed by all key personnel in the
company, and by any supplier of
outsourced data services.
Cyber insurance can also be
purchased to provide first party
coverage for financial loss arising out
of data breach notification costs, IT
forensics and remediation expenses,
crisis management and brand
reputation assistance, legal fees,
business interruption, fines and other
costs associated with the breach,
including PR support. Third party
coverage can also be provided for
privacy and security liability this is
especially relevant in the US where
there is a risk of class action lawsuits
following a high profile data breach.
In the UK and Europe the cyber
insurance market is relatively new, but
it is one that is growing fast and
which is viewed as having massive
growth potential. Smart companies
are recognising the very clear and
present danger that a data breach
represents, and are addressing and
managing this operational risk by
gearing up their risk management
and mitigation procedures.
Michael Thyssen, vice president
European product manager
Chubb Specialty Insurance,
Chubb Insurance Company
of Europe SE
Security concerns for insurers
The year ahead for insurers will be a testing time with insurer security
remaining a paramount consideration, according to analysis by Sam
Dobbyn and Yvette Essen of AM Best
A.M. Best considers exposure to
sovereign debt to be one of the
most pressing issues challenging an
insurers security. Policymakers
within the European Union have
taken some steps to address the
crisis, but A.M. Best feels that any
benefits of those endeavours are
more likely to materialize in the
medium term, and the near-term
pressures on those economies and
the entities that operate within
them are still quite significant.
In December, A.M. Best took a
number of rating actions on several
European insurers and reinsurers
with significant investments in not
only sovereigns but Eurozone banks.
Some companies experienced a
material deterioration in risk-
adjusted capital on a stress basis (see
A.M. Bests Additional Stress
Testing in Light of European
Economic Uncertainty published
November 2011). Ratings actions
were concentrated in particular on
life businesses in Italy and Spain.
Companies are, to the extent
they can, employing hedging
techniques to try to limit their
downside exposure to erosion in the
credit quality of their investment
holdings. However, for the most
part, companies' abilities to address
this exposure are limited in the
near-term.
The declining credit quality of
sovereign debt for many European
countries, as well as the potential of
credit erosion on the banking side,
remains an issue for insurers and
reinsurers. Liquidity is a particular
area of concern as in the first half of
2012 there are 519 billion of
German, Italian and French debt
maturing. In addition, 665 billion
of European bank debt will mature.
The appetite of the markets for this
form of debt, as well as insurer debt
and credit needs, is unknown at this
point and a source of concern.
In addition to the sovereign debt
crisis in the Eurozone, insurers face
other challenges to security in 2012.
The natural catastrophe events of
2011 caused total estimated insured
losses of approximately USD 100
billion, with a material portion
believed to be reinsured. Combined
ratios for many reinsurers climbed
to north of 100%, although this was
largely an earnings event with no
significant erosion of capital. A.M.
Best estimates reinsurance capital at
the end of 2011 was only
marginally lower compared to the
beginning of the year.
In the recent January 1 renewal
season, there were some limited
price increases but no broader
sustained hardening of rates.
Reinsurers obtained some
significant rate increases for natural
catastrophe hit areas, however, only
modest price increases in non-
16
INSURER OUTLOOK
www.airmic.com Together Leading in Risk
TM
SAM DOBBYN YVETTE ESSEN
Liquidity is a particular area of concern as in
the first half of 2012 there are 519 billion of
German, Italian and French debt maturing
19
EMPLOYEE PRACTICES LIABILITY
www.airmic.com Together Leading in Risk
TM
WE ARE HERE FOR YOU
When you need us to take a problem off your
hands, we can have the right person on the
ground quickly. This will be one of our carefully
selected commercial adjusters. Someone who you
know, who you trust, and who you can rely on to
make the right decisions quickly. At the forefront
of their mind will be achieving the outcome that
matters most to you.
Claims are our business. But they're
only part of yours. What matters is the
impact they have on you. That's what
we're there to control.
To find out more about our range of corporate services,
please contact Jonathan Clark on 020 7530 0600 or
Paul McLarnon 07747 791043 or visit our website
www.cunninghamlindsey.com/uk
in its infancy and use of the internet
fairly limited, few companies had or
needed policies to protect themselves
and their employees in the use of
technology. Today, with the
burgeoning growth of Facebook,
Twitter and other social networking
channels, it is essential to try and
prevent claims ranging from
breaching company confidentiality to
harassment, discrimination and
defamation.
Its all about people
Ultimately, employment
discrimination is down to people and
how they behave. A company can
have the best and most stringent
controls, but could still face a claim.
However, if a case does reach court or
tribunal and the company can show it
has adequate policies in place, it trains
its employees on how to behave in
the workplace and always investigates
incidents that are reported, then the
company will be in a much better
position to successfully defend the
case or minimise the financial
exposure if compensation is awarded,
than would be the case if the
company lacked robust procedures.
Take avoiding action
Reduce the risk of your employees
taking action:
l Keep up with new and emerging
legislation and trends, especially in
new technology
l Resolve internal complaints,
especially if they involve potential
class action allegations, before they
turn into costly lawsuits
l Set up a hotline for people who
want to complain and encourage a
culture of openness
l Analyse employment data to remain
up to date on key issues around
hiring, termination, pay equity and
promotions
l Manage diversity initiatives
consistently and compare your
company statistics with the general
labour market
l Manage workforce reductions
consistently
l Ensure suitable equal employment
and diversity training is available for
employees and managers
l Ensure sure diversity and anti-
discrimination policies are enforced
George Melides is head of
commercial D&O, Zurich
Global Corporate UK
Before investing in many overseas
geographies and regions, companies
and banks invariably spend a large
part of their research time and
budget trying to understand the
economic and political variables of
that area. These variables are
determined to define country or
regional risk which, at times, can
make or break an investment
decision. Political risk insurance
continues to play a significant role in
facilitating these projects with a
continuing and evolving variety of
options available to mitigate this
country risk at reasonable cost.
The current global financial crisis
and the turmoil created by the
uncertainties in the euro zone has
meant that manufacturers, exporters,
financial institutions, banks, hedge
funds and other organisations now
all have a heightened awareness of
political risk as an essential
consideration before committing to
an overseas investment. It could be
argued that the current euro zone
crisis has at its roots a purely
political rather than an economic
issue. The uncertainty of the ability
of governments to implement policy
that can effectively, or even partially,
manage the financial problems and
yet still be politically acceptable to
multiple stake holders, is very much
in doubt. This growing uncertainty
is as much a cause of the growing
liquidity tightening as the sheer
magnitude of the debts that must be
dealt with by governments,
companies and individuals alike.
According to the World Economic
Forum, Global Risks Report 2012,
there are five key global risk factors
associated with overseas investments
which can be divided into the
following areas: economic,
environmental, geopolitical,
20
POLITICAL RISK
www.airmic.com Together Leading in Risk
TM
MINIMISE YOUR
BUSINESS RISK.
CONSULT A
SPECIALIST.
As a leading business insurance specialist, we know all about helping clients and brokers prepare for
the risks of tomorrow and minimise potential disruption. When it comes to shaping your business, it pays
to consult a specialist. For over 125 years, weve been managing risk and now we are one of the worlds
leading business insurers and reinsurers, operating out of 49 countries with the nancial strength you can
rely on. For business insurance that means business, visit www.QBEeurope.com
QBE European Operations is a trading name of QBE Insurance (Europe) Limited and QBE Underwriting Limited. QBE Insurance (Europe) Limited and QBE Underwriting Limited
are authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority. QBE Management Services (UK) Limited and QBE Underwriting Services (UK) Limited are both Appointed
Representatives of QBE Insurance (Europe) Limited and QBE Underwriting Limited.
The evolving world of political risk insurance.
Growing uncertainty is fuelling demand for political risk insurance cover,
says Joe Blenkinsopp of XL Group
societal and technological. It is both
the geopolitical and societal on
which often the emphasis in
assessing political risk is now
determined not just the economic
or other factors.
The Multilateral Investment
Guarantee Agency World Investment
and Political Risk Report 2011 also
indicate that whilst some parts of the
world economy are becoming
stronger, there are downward
revisions of economic growth
worldwide. Within this context, the
rate of growth of private financial
flows into developing countries has
continued to moderate after the
flows initial recovery from the
financial crisis. Developing
countries now account for 17
percent of global foreign direct
investment (FDI) outflows. Brazil,
Russia, India, China (BRIC) were in
the lead in 2011 with $172 billion,
accounting for nearly three quarters
of FDI outflows from the
developing world. China alone
invested an estimated $85 billion in
2011, a new record level, as its
mostly state-owned enterprises
continued their expansion into new
markets and strived to become
internationally competitive.
Understanding the global economy
and the geopolitical environment is
essential to underwriting political
risk. The support that underwriters
are able to provide their clients in
helping them to manage their risks
is of great importance to the growth
and development of their businesses.
It is important to understand the
value that political risk insurance
offers clients more efficient use of
their capital and, in the current
economic climate, is often seen as a
necessity rather than a luxury. By
maximizing capital, those
organizations that can use their
capital better than its competitors
over an extended period of time will
be the ones that grow and prosper.
21
POLITICAL RISK
www.airmic.com Together Leading in Risk
TM
LIVERPOOL
Gallagher Heath are experts in plotting a course through
the minefield of risks our clients face. We ensure we have
a detailed knowledge of our clients businesses so we
can map out the most effective and cost-efficient risk
management programme for their individual needs.
To find out more about how working with Gallagher
Heath could benefit your business contact:
M|ke H|b||ng
t: +44 (0|20 7560 3861
e: mh|b||ng@heath|ambert.com
www.ga||agherheath.com
CHARTING
YOUR RISK MANAGEMENT
NEEDS
Gallagher Heath is a trading name of Heath Lambert Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority.
Registered Office: 9 Alie Street, London E1 8DE. Registered No: 1199129 England and Wales. www.gallagherheath.com
Commercial Lines
Broker of the Year
Env|ronmenta| L|ab|||ty: I have a|| the po||ut|on
cover I need under my PL Po||cy, don't I?
A joint seminar by Axa and Gallagher Heath
on Wednesday 29 February at 8 30am for 9am
at the Grange City Hotel (Bowyer Room)
To register:
Email victoria.hicks@airmic.co.uk at Airmic.
Understanding the global economy and the
geopolitical environment is essential to
underwriting political risk