Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Maura Walsh
Emporia State University
Introduction and overview
Walsh, GII and Mental Health 2
One crucial factor in implementing a successful global information infrastructure and creating a
knowledge society is to enable as large a majority as possible to access knowledge. Many factors
can influence a person’s ability to access information: technological infrastructure and access,
literacy and linguistic ability, economic resources, and the freedom to take advantage of these.
However there is one component that can negate one’s access even if all of the above are in place
and functioning well. That is health. Within the field of health, mental health is an area worthy of
investigation because it has long been a taboo subject in many societies. It affects an increasing
number of people worldwide, and there are some interesting changes in our understanding of
what it encompasses and possible treatments. It is not only an area that bears investigating
because it affects access, but the dissemination and diffusion of our growing knowledge about it
This bibliography attempts to unite some of the most important documents about the extent of
this illness and what kind of policies should be implemented to allow those suffering to
overcome or cope with their illness, permitting them to participate more meaningfully in the
global information infrastructure as well as allowing the rest of society to benefit from what their
full participation could add to the knowledge society. Another facet of this benefit is that they
resources.
http://www.beyondblue.org.au/index.aspx?link_id=2.524
Authority of the author: Beyond Blue was established in 2000 and has a board that includes
Walsh, GII and Mental Health 3
government officials, doctors, and leading mental health specialists from across the country
Relevance: It was founded to create a community response to depression and mental illness
while moving it into a sphere where it is seen as a less threatening occurrence and one in which
the whole community can help acknowledge and accommodate those suffering from it.
Contribution to our understanding of the GII: Because of the World Health Organization’s
predictions of mental health issues becoming more prevalent in our societies, the Australian
government hopes to encourage community involvement to help break the cycle of increasing
disability. This is one of the few wide based efforts to educate the society to try and change the
projected course.
Coverage: They try to create bold and innovative programs to fight mental illness and involve the
whole community changing attitudes. They support research and primary care as well as early
intervention.
Point of view/bias: This web site is a whole heartedly dedicated to involving the community and
helping foster partnerships in order to build a society that answers to the need to support help for
the mentally ill. There are neither detractors nor distractions here.
Cohen, A., Kleinman, A., & Saraceno, B. (2002). World mental health casebook: Social and
Authority of the authors: Alex Cohen, Ph.D. is an anthropologist and Assistant Professor of
Social Medicine at Harvard Medical School, with an interest in cultural psychiatry and mental
health. Arthur Kleinman, M.D. is one of the world’s foremost medical anthropologists and a
major figure in cultural psychiatry, global health, and social medicine. Dr Saraceno, from the
Walsh, GII and Mental Health 4
University of Milan, is the Director of the Department of Mental Health and Substance
Relevance: This book was undertaken to update the 1974 study of the effectiveness of mental
health treatments in developing countries. The goal is to be able to build upon the relevance of
the earlier studies to see where we have come and what is needed today.
Contribution to our understanding of the GII: Many factors like social and economical
inequalities, gender discrimination, political violence and malnutrition and poor physical health
all contribute to the social and psychological decline of both individuals and communities. The
advances in research and pharmacology can provide better options if there is a concerted effort to
Coverage: The cases examined here come from the South Pacific, Asia, South and Latin America
Point of view/bias: The authors certainly seem sufficiently qualified to prevent unwonted bias.
The emphasis is on people coming from and living in restricted circumstances, but some lessons
Desjarlais, R. Eisenberg, L. Good, B. & Kleinman, A. (Ed.). (1996). World mental health:
Problems and priorities in low income countries. Oxford, UK: Oxford University
Press.
College , Leon Eisenberg, Professor of Social Medicine, Harvard Medical School , Byron Good,
Walsh, GII and Mental Health 5
Professor of Social Medicine, Harvard Medical School , and Arthur Kleinman, Professor of
programs and how to develop good policy. It also details the consequences, which seem to
Contribution to our understanding of the GII: First the report shows the result of the growing
burden of untreated mental health problems. This study underlines the issue of mental health and
well-being in the international agenda and reminds us of the great affliction caused by mental
illness and how much is lost in productivity and ability to reach a genuine knowledge society
low-income societies. It shows how global social change impacts mental health. A variety of
tables and case studies make it easy to understand the scope of the problem.
Point of view/bias: This book was written by recognized experts in the field and does not seem
to have biases or hidden agendas although it certainly advocates for helping poorer societies
Kandel, E. (2005). Psychiatry, psychoanalysis, and the new biology of mind . Arlington, VA :
Authority of the author: Kandel is a Nobel Prize-winning psychiatrist and neurobiologist who
has bridged the gap between psychoanalysis and biology helping disprove long held tenets. His
work is groundbreaking for the future of controlling and curing mental illness.
Relevance: Kandel has proven that the brain is capable of regeneration and that psychotherapy is
Walsh, GII and Mental Health 6
part of an effective treatment. In the broader picture, he outlines how isolated academic or
Contribution to our understanding of the GII: This book successfully shows the relationship
between ‘the health of the individual brain, and the health of mankind as a whole’. He shows that
we need to interrupt the cycle of poverty in order to progress and that the individuals’ minds are
Coverage: This book is the latest product of a privileged mind and more than 30 years of
research. It covers the biology of brain construction and regeneration, the impact of treatments
Point of view/bias: Although the work is Kandel’s, and he is widely recognized as the leading
authority in the field, he also includes commentaries by other outstanding experts with each
Layard, R. (2005, January 24). Mental health: Britain’s biggest social problem?. Retrieved
http://cep.lse.ac.uk/textonly/research/mentalhealth/RL414d.pdf
Authority of the author: Layard is an economist educated at Cambridge and The London School
is a current program director.
Relevance: Layard explores the way it which depression is a burden on society: the suffering of
the individuals and the ever increasing economic cost if it goes untreated.
Walsh, GII and Mental Health 7
Contribution to our understanding of the GII: Layard’s study concentrates on the situation in the
UK but states that comparisons to most analogous countries are similar. As we see over and over
again, this means that the digital divide endures, a segment of the society cannot participate in
the progress of the rest of the society and a rift may develop. Much of this is avoidable, because
Coverage: Layard lays out all the facts and figures from an economic point of view and makes a
very convincing case for providing good treatment. He illustrates many points with very
Point of view/bias: Layard’s style is quite sparse and to the point. He certainly has a point of
view and expresses it quite clearly. However, since it is also in keeping with most of what the
Levine, A. (2008, June 6). 'Vast treatment gap' plagues mental illness around globe.
http://pn.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/content/full/43/11/24
Authority of the author: Levine has a PhD from the University of California at Berkeley. He is
doing post doctoral research for the National Science Foundation at Brown University. He is
broadly published and has given many presentations at national and international forums.
Relevance: There is a vast treatment gap and mental health treatment is still seen as a peripheral
component of global health. Poverty, natural disasters and conflicts tend to worsen the problem.
Mental illness is a social detriment. Only half of the adults and one third of the children who
Contribution to our understanding of the GII: Once again, leading world authorities point out
that many in our societies are hindered by mental illness, chiefly depression, and that, without
treatment, the gaps like the digital divide and physical health issues will become a greater
problem to both developing and developed countries. Bridging that gap requires the involvement
Coverage: People with mental illness in developing countries tend to receive medieval treatment
or none at all. Here the participants urge that these institutions be reformed and that an
international effort be made to ensure that better coverage is given. This is a burden in developed
Point of view/bias: This article reports the opinions of many well known experts in the world
mental health community who call for a more vital position for mental health care in the global
health community.
Morrall, P. , & Hazelton, M (2005). Mental health global policies and human rights.
Authority of the authors: Dr. Peter Morrall, Senior Lecturer in Health and Sociology, Head of
Group for mental Health, Learning Disabilities and behavioral Sciences and a member of the
Sociology of Mental Health Study Group. Mike Hazelton is the head of the school of nursing and
midwifery and professor of mental health nursing at the university of Newcastle and Hunter New
England Mental Health. They have conducted extensive research and are widely published
Relevance: This book examines the history of mental health initiatives, recent growth, current
conditions, and the possible future of mental health policies in 10 countries: the United
Kingdom, United States, Australia, Italy, Egypt, India, Brazil, Russia, and Mozambique.
Walsh, GII and Mental Health 9
Contribution to our understanding of the GII: This book explains the different situations in
distinct countries and may be taken as representative of others. It shows how sometimes progress
made in one area is either not accepted or not disseminated to others. Policies are often
Coverage: Geographically and politically, the countries chosen represent a broad spectrum of
political and cultural systems. Historically, the authors give a good overview of mental health
Point of view/bias: Although the authors publish a disclaimer that they neither represent nor
endorse any group, sometimes their vocabulary seems to carry more than only neutral
disapprobation.
Authority of the author: T. B. Ustun has extensive experience in the field and has developed the
SCAN, a widely used diagnostic tool to understand and measure what the patient feels.
Relevance: There is certainly ample evidence for including mental disorders with essential health
treatment packages. The author advocates that there should be no difference between mental
health and physical health coverage. This should be part and parcel of all public health practice.
Contribution to our understanding of the GII: All the data on world wide mental health problems
show that it is dragging society as a whole: patients, communities, and world infrastructure.
More research is needed, but we must start treating more effectively because the burden on our
Coverage: The most effective case can be made for treatment that includes both psychosocial
counseling and psychotropic drug treatment. Given the time that has passed since the publication
of this article it is interesting to note that this is still the current wisdom in the field. Drugs have
improved enormously, and more is known about the effectiveness of talk therapy, but Ustun
Point of view/bias: The author comes down squarely on the side of pharmacological treatment in
conjunction with therapeutic treatment, which is in keeping with most modern thinking in the
field, but does not necessarily reflect the publicly acceptable view of treatment. However it is the
Wang, P. S., AguilarGaxiola, S., Angemeyer, M, Borges, G., Bornet, E. J., & Buffarets , R.
(2007). Use of mental health services for anxiety, mood, and substance disorders in
17 countries in the WHO world mental health surveys. The Lancet. 370, 84150.
Authority of the author: Dr Wang is an Assistant Professor of Psychiatry, Medicine, Health Care
Policy and Epidemiology at Harvard Medical School. The Lancet is a highly respected
professional journal.
Relevance: This article deals directly with depression, which currently causes the greatest
handicap in health. (More than diseases like angina, arthritis, asthma, and diabetes.) When
Contribution to our understanding of the GII: This article underscores the importance of
responding to the mental health of world wide populations in order to help close the digital
divide.
Walsh, GII and Mental Health 11
Coverage: This is another article that reaches the same conclusions as the Morrall article while
covering a broader cross section of countries (60) and more details about the incidence of illness.
The results indicate the urgency of addressing depression as a public-health priority to reduce
disease burden and disability, and to improve the overall health of populations.
Point of view/bias: The Lancet, one of the oldest peer-reviewed medical journals in the world, is
the world's leading independent general medical journal. Its coverage is one of the most
World Health Organization, Funk, M., & Saraceno, B. (2003). Planning and budgeting to
deliver services for mental health. New York: World Health Organization.
Authority of the author: Dr M. Funk is the coordinator of Mental Health Policy and Service
Development at the World Health Organization. Dr Saraceno, from the University of Milan, is
the Director of the Department of Mental Health and Substance Dependence of the World Health
Organization
Relevance: This book is a project manual for a five year plan to help communities, especially in
poorer areas, develop plans that involve all stakeholders, managers and providers in the best
Contribution to our understanding of the GII: Here the diffusion of ideas to provide community
services is outlined in a practical manner to enable communities to enact the type of services
necessary.
Coverage: This book attempts to assist different countries in implementing strategies to protect
and promote the rights of people with mental disorders. They provide guidelines to identify the
Walsh, GII and Mental Health 12
population that needs services and the services that they need.
Point of view/bias: This is a publication of the WHO and reflects their best practices. Any time
such exact models are laid out there are bound to be limitations unless those implementing them
possess the knowledge and flexibility necessary to adapt them to local needs.
Summary
Mental health can be a barrier tantamount to any other cultural barrier. Unlike language or
religion, mental health is also an obstacle that exists within most societies. It is one that is
misunderstood but also one in which many advances are being made. It is necessary to be
cognizant of the improvements and help implement them in order to help establish and promote
the knowledge societies that have the potential to provide so much benefit to the world.
For a long time man has treated emotion and thought as functions that were almost independent
from our physical health. Today scientists are learning that what had been accepted as fact about
the brain is incorrect. They are discovering that genetics also plays an important part in how
people function emotionally within society. Mental illness can have a debilitating effect on
society, but the answer should be to continue studying it, apply what is learned and help more
people be able to contribute to and participate in the knowledge societies. Global information
infrastructures, through academics, knowledge sharing and public education and outreach can be
well employed in helping reach this goal.