SAP2000 Verification 1400

Verification Control
SAP2000 Verification Problems

Verif manual version: Path to Sap2000.exe: Path to data files: Last checked: 14.00 C:\Program Files\Computers and Structures\SAP2000 14\sap.exe C:\Program Files\Computers and Structures\SAP2000 14\verification Monday, Apr 9 2012, 1:59 PM
Filename: Solver: 32 Bit: Process:
94249720.xls.ms_office.xls Force Standard Default Default
Delete Files: No
Problem Class 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame
Problem Number 1-001 1-002 1-003 1-004 1-005 1-006 1-007 1-008 1-009 1-010 1-011 1-012 1-013 1-014 1-015 1-016 1-017 1-018 1-019 1-020 1-021 1-022 1-023 1-024 1-025
Problem Title General Loading Temperature Loading Distributed and Concentrated Moments Rotated Local Axes Displacement Loading Non-Prismatic Sections and Automatic Frame Subdivision End Releases Partial Fixity End Releases Prestress Applied to Frame Objects End Offsets Insertion Point No Tension and No Compression Frame Objects Simply Supported Beam on Elastic Foundation Eigenvalue Problem Steady State Harmonic Loads Tension Stiffening Using P-Delta Analysis Vibration of a String Under Tension Bending, Shear and Axial Deformations in a Rigid Frame Buckling of a Rigid Frame Response Spectrum Analysis of a Two-Dimensional Rigid Frame Bathe and Wilson Eigenvalue Problem Two-Dimensional Moment Frame with Static and Dynamic Loads ASME Eigenvalue Problem Response Spectrum Analysis of a Three-Dimensional Moment Frame Response Spectrum Analysis of a Three-Dimensional Braced Frame
Run This Problem Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Check This Problem No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No
Page 1 of 268
1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 1 - Frame 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 2 - Shell 3 - Plane 3 - Plane 3 - Plane 3 - Plane 3 - Plane 4 - Asolid 4 - Asolid 4 - Asolid 4 - Asolid 5 - Solid 5 - Solid 5 - Solid
1-026 1-027 1-028 1-029 1-030 2-001 2-002 2-003 2-004 2-005 2-006 2-007 2-008 2-009 2-010 2-011 2-012 2-013 2-014 2-015 2-016 2-017 2-018 2-019 2-020 3-001 3-002 3-003 3-004 3-005 4-001 4-002 4-003 4-004 5-001 5-002 5-003
Moment and Shear Hinges Construction Sequence Loading Large Axial Displacements Large Bending Displacements Moving Loads Patch Test With Prescribed Displacements Straight Beam with Static Loads Curved Beam with Static Loads Twisted Beam with Static Loads Rectangular Plate with Static Loads Scordelis-Lo Roof with Static Loads Hemispherical Shell Structure with Static Loads Cantilever Plate Eigenvalue Problem Plate on Elastic Foundation Cylinder with Internal Pressure ASME Cooling Tower Problem with Static Wind Pressure Plate Bending when Shear Deformations Are Significant Temperature Load that Is Constant Through Shell Thickness Temperature Gradient Through Shell Thickness Orthotropic Plate Out-of-Plane Buckling In-Plane Buckling Large Axial Displacements Large Bending Displacements Prestress Applied to Area Objects Patch Test With Prescribed Displacements Straight Beam with Static Loads Curved Beam with Static Loads Thick Walled Cylinder Pore Pressure Soil Supporting Uniformly Loaded Circular Footing Thick Walled Cylinder Rotating Annular Disk Pore Pressure Patch Test With Prescribed Displacements Straight Beam with Static Loads Curved Beam with Static Loads
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No
Page 2 of 268
5 - Solid 5 - Solid 5 - Solid 5 - Solid 5 - Solid 5 - Solid 5 - Solid 5 - Solid 5 - Solid 5 - Solid 6 - Link 6 - Link 6 - Link 6 - Link 6 - Link 6 - Link 6 - Link 6 - Link 6 - Link 6 - Link 6 - Link 6 - Link 7 - Cable 7 - Cable 7 - Cable
5-004 5-005 5-006 5-007 5-008 5-009 5-010 5-011 5-012 5-013 6-001 6-002 6-003 6-004 6-005 6-006 6-007 6-008 6-009 6-010 6-011 6-012 7-001 7-002 7-003
Twisted Beam with Static Loads Rectangular Plate with Static Loads Scordelis-Lo Roof with Static Loads Hemispherical Dome Structure with Static Loads Thick Walled Cylinder Prestress Applied to Solid Objects Buckling Temperature Load Plate on Elastic Foundation Pore Pressure Linear Link with Ramp Loading Multi-linear Elastic Link Gap Element Hook Element Damper Element Under Harmonic Loading SUNY Buffalo Damper with Linear Velocity Exponent SUNY Buffalo Damper with Nonlinear Velocity Exponent Plastic Wen Link Plastic Kinematic Link SUNY Buffalo Eight-Story Building with Rubber Isolators SUNY Buffalo Seven-Story Building with Friction Pendulum Isolators Frequency Dependent Links Uniform and Temperature Loading Uniform and Concentrated Loading Prestressed Cable Net
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No
Page 3 of 268
49720.xls.ms_office.xls
User Switches (Overrides Cells E2 thru E5): (Applies to analysis files only, not input or output files)
Max % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Version
Level
Additional Licenses
Time Checked
Applies to Advanced Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Applies to Plus Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Applies to Basic Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Page 4 of 268
Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes
Page 5 of 268
Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Page 6 of 268
Comments
Page 7 of 268
Requires Staged Construction license
Page 8 of 268
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-008c.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:07:54 PM) Data exported to Example 5-008c.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-008d.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:03 PM) Data exported to Example 5-008d.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-008e.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:13 PM) Data exported to Example 5-008e.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-008f.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:25 PM) Data exported to Example 5-008f.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-009a.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:42 PM) Data exported to Example 5-009a.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-009b.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:52 PM) Data exported to Example 5-009b.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-010.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:09:04 PM) Data exported to Example 5-010.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-011.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:09:16 PM) Data exported to Example 5-011.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-012a.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:10:19 PM) Data exported to Example 5-012a.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-012b.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:13:47 PM) Data exported to Example 5-012b.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-012c.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:14:46 PM) Data exported to Example 5-012c.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-012d.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:18:09 PM) Data exported to Example 5-012d.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-013.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:18:36 PM) Data exported to Example 5-013.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-001.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:21:28 PM) Data exported to Example 6-001.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-002.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:21:41 PM) Data exported to Example 6-002.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-003a.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:25:18 PM) Data exported to Example 6-003a.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-003b.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:28:41 PM) Data exported to Example 6-003b.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-004.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:28:51 PM) Data exported to Example 6-004.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-005a.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:41:38 PM) Data exported to Example 6-005a.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-005b.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:41:48 PM) Data exported to Example 6-005b.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-006.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:55:46 PM) Data exported to Example 6-006.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-007.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 11:14:16 PM) Data exported to Example 6-007.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-008.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 11:16:45 PM) Data exported to Example 6-008.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-009.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 11:17:23 PM) Data exported to Example 6-009.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-010.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 11:21:18 PM) Data exported to Example 6-010.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-011a.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 12:27:24 AM) Data exported to Example 6-011a.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-011b.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:42:42 AM) Data exported to Example 6-011b.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-012.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:43:05 AM) Data exported to Example 6-012.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 7-001.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:43:14 AM) Data exported to Example 7-001.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 7-002.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:43:24 AM) Data exported to Example 7-002.mdb C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 7-003.sdb Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:43:50 AM) Data exported to Example 7-003.mdb
Problem Number 1-001 1-002 1-002 1-003 1-004 1-005 1-005 1-005 1-005 1-005 1-005 1-006 1-006 1-007 1-007 1-007 1-008 1-009 1-009 1-009 1-010 1-010 1-010 1-010 1-011 1-012 1-012 1-012 1-013 1-013 1-013 1-014 1-014 1-014 1-014 1-014 1-014 1-014 1-015 1-016 1-016 1-016 1-016 1-016 1-016 1-016 1-017 1-017 1-018 1-018
Access Database File Example 1-001.mdb Example 1-002a.mdb Example 1-002b.mdb Example 1-003.mdb Example 1-004.mdb Example 1-005a.mdb Example 1-005b.mdb Example 1-005c.mdb Example 1-005d.mdb Example 1-005e.mdb Example 1-005f.mdb Example 1-006a.mdb Example 1-006b.mdb Example 1-007a.mdb Example 1-007b.mdb Example 1-007c.mdb Example 1-008.mdb Example 1-009a.mdb Example 1-009b.mdb Example 1-009c.mdb Example 1-010a.mdb Example 1-010b.mdb Example 1-010c.mdb Example 1-010d.mdb Example 1-011.mdb Example 1-012a.mdb Example 1-012b.mdb Example 1-012c.mdb Example 1-013a.mdb Example 1-013b.mdb Example 1-013c.mdb Example 1-014a.mdb Example 1-014b.mdb Example 1-014c.mdb Example 1-014d.mdb Example 1-014e.mdb Example 1-014f.mdb Example 1-014g.mdb Example 1-015.mdb Example 1-016a.mdb Example 1-016b.mdb Example 1-016c.mdb Example 1-016d.mdb Example 1-016e.mdb Example 1-016f.mdb Example 1-016g.mdb Example 1-017a.mdb Example 1-017b.mdb Example 1-018a.mdb Example 1-018b.mdb
1-018 1-018 1-019 1-019 1-019 1-020 1-021 1-022 1-023 1-024 1-025 1-026 1-026 1-027 1-028 1-029 1-029 1-029 1-030 2-001 2-001 2-002 2-002 2-002 2-002 2-002 2-002 2-002 2-002 2-002 2-002 2-002 2-002 2-002 2-002 2-003 2-003 2-003 2-003 2-003 2-003 2-003 2-003 2-004 2-004 2-005 2-005 2-005 2-005 2-005 2-005 2-005
Example 1-018c.mdb Example 1-018d.mdb Example 1-019a.mdb Example 1-019b.mdb Example 1-019c.mdb Example 1-020.mdb Example 1-021.mdb Example 1-022.mdb Example 1-023.mdb Example 1-024.mdb Example 1-025.mdb Example 1-026a.mdb Example 1-026b.mdb Example 1-027.mdb Example 1-028.mdb Example 1-029a.mdb Example 1-029b.mdb Example 1-029c.mdb Example 1-030.mdb Example 2-001-thick.mdb Example 2-001-thin.mdb Example 2-002a-thick.mdb Example 2-002a-thin.mdb Example 2-002b-thick.mdb Example 2-002b-thin.mdb Example 2-002c-thick.mdb Example 2-002c-thin.mdb Example 2-002d-thick.mdb Example 2-002d-thin.mdb Example 2-002e-thick.mdb Example 2-002e-thin.mdb Example 2-002f-thick.mdb Example 2-002f-thin.mdb Example 2-002g-thick.mdb Example 2-002g-thin.mdb Example 2-003a-thick.mdb Example 2-003a-thin.mdb Example 2-003b-thick.mdb Example 2-003b-thin.mdb Example 2-003c-thick.mdb Example 2-003c-thin.mdb Example 2-003d-thick.mdb Example 2-003d-thin.mdb Example 2-004-thick.mdb Example 2-004-thin.mdb Example 2-005a-thick.mdb Example 2-005a-thin.mdb Example 2-005b-thick.mdb Example 2-005b-thin.mdb Example 2-005c-thick.mdb Example 2-005c-thin.mdb Example 2-005d-thick.mdb
2-005 2-005 2-005 2-005 2-005 2-005 2-005 2-005 2-005 2-005 2-006 2-006 2-007 2-007 2-008 2-008 2-008 2-008 2-008 2-008 2-008 2-009 2-009 2-009 2-009 2-010 2-010 2-010 2-010 2-011 2-011 2-012 2-012 2-012 2-013 2-013 2-013 2-013 2-014 2-014 2-014 2-014 2-015 2-015 2-015 2-015 2-015 2-015 2-016 2-016 2-016 2-016
Example 2-005d-thin.mdb Example 2-005e-thick.mdb Example 2-005e-thin.mdb Example 2-005f-thick.mdb Example 2-005f-thin.mdb Example 2-005g-thick.mdb Example 2-005g-thin.mdb Example 2-005h-thick.mdb Example 2-005h-thin.mdb Example 2-005i-thick.mdb Example 2-006-thick.mdb Example 2-006-thin.mdb Example 2-007-thick.mdb Example 2-007-thin.mdb Example 2-008a-thick.mdb Example 2-008a-thin.mdb Example 2-008b-thick.mdb Example 2-008b-thin.mdb Example 2-008c-thick.mdb Example 2-008c-thin.mdb Example 2-008d-thick.mdb Example 2-009a-thick.mdb Example 2-009a-thin.mdb Example 2-009b-thick.mdb Example 2-009b-thin.mdb Example 2-010a-thick.mdb Example 2-010a-thin.mdb Example 2-010b-thick.mdb Example 2-010b-thin.mdb Example 2-011-thick.mdb Example 2-011-thin.mdb Example 2-012a-thick.mdb Example 2-012a-thin.mdb Example 2-012b-thick.mdb Example 2-013a-thick.mdb Example 2-013a-thin.mdb Example 2-013b-thick.mdb Example 2-013b-thin.mdb Example 2-014a-thick.mdb Example 2-014a-thin.mdb Example 2-014b-thick.mdb Example 2-014b-thin.mdb Example 2-015a-thick.mdb Example 2-015a-thin.mdb Example 2-015b-thick.mdb Example 2-015b-thin.mdb Example 2-015c-thick.mdb Example 2-015d-thick.mdb Example 2-016a-thick.mdb Example 2-016a-thin.mdb Example 2-016b-thick.mdb Example 2-016b-thin.mdb
2-016 2-016 2-017 2-017 2-018 2-018 2-019 2-019 2-019 2-019 2-019 2-019 2-020 2-020 2-020 2-020 3-001 3-001 3-002 3-002 3-002 3-002 3-002 3-002 3-002 3-002 3-002 3-002 3-002 3-002 3-002 3-003 3-003 3-004 3-004 3-004 3-004 3-004 3-004 3-004 3-004 3-004 3-004 3-004 3-004 3-005 4-001 4-001 4-002 4-002 4-002 4-002
Example 2-016c-thick.mdb Example 2-016c-thin.mdb Example 2-017-thick.mdb Example 2-017-thin.mdb Example 2-018-thick.mdb Example 2-018-thin.mdb Example 2-019a-thick.mdb Example 2-019a-thin.mdb Example 2-019b-thick.mdb Example 2-019b-thin.mdb Example 2-019c-thick.mdb Example 2-019c-thin.mdb Example 2-020a-thick.mdb Example 2-020a-thin.mdb Example 2-020b-thick.mdb Example 2-020b-thin.mdb Example 3-001-incomp.mdb Example 3-001-comp.mdb Example 3-002a-incomp.mdb Example 3-002a-comp.mdb Example 3-002b-incomp.mdb Example 3-002b-comp.mdb Example 3-002c-incomp.mdb Example 3-002c-comp.mdb Example 3-002d-incomp.mdb Example 3-002d-comp.mdb Example 3-002e-incomp.mdb Example 3-002e-comp.mdb Example 3-002f-incomp.mdb Example 3-002f-comp.mdb Example 3-002g-incomp.mdb Example 3-003a.mdb Example 3-003b.mdb Example 3-004a-strain.mdb Example 3-004a-stress.mdb Example 3-004b-strain.mdb Example 3-004b-stress.mdb Example 3-004c-strain.mdb Example 3-004c-stress.mdb Example 3-004d-strain.mdb Example 3-004d-stress.mdb Example 3-004e-strain.mdb Example 3-004e-stress.mdb Example 3-004f-strain.mdb Example 3-004f-stress.mdb Example 3-005.mdb Example 4-001-incomp.mdb Example 4-001-comp.mdb Example 4-002a.mdb Example 4-002b.mdb Example 4-002c.mdb Example 4-002d.mdb
4-002 4-002 4-003 4-004 5-001 5-001 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-002 5-003 5-003 5-003 5-004 5-005 5-005 5-005 5-005 5-005 5-005 5-005 5-005 5-005 5-005 5-006 5-007 5-007 5-008 5-008 5-008 5-008 5-008 5-008 5-009 5-009 5-010 5-011 5-012
Example 4-002e.mdb Example 4-002f.mdb Example 4-003.mdb Example 4-004.mdb Example 5-001-incomp.mdb Example 5-001-comp.mdb Example 5-002a1-incomp.mdb Example 5-002a1-comp.mdb Example 5-002a2-incomp.mdb Example 5-002a2-comp.mdb Example 5-002a3-incomp.mdb Example 5-002a3-comp.mdb Example 5-002b1-incomp.mdb Example 5-002b1-comp.mdb Example 5-002b2-incomp.mdb Example 5-002b2-comp.mdb Example 5-002b3-incomp.mdb Example 5-002b3-comp.mdb Example 5-002c1-incomp.mdb Example 5-002c1-comp.mdb Example 5-002c2-incomp.mdb Example 5-002c2-comp.mdb Example 5-002c3-incomp.mdb Example 5-002c3-comp.mdb Example 5-003a.mdb Example 5-003b.mdb Example 5-003c.mdb Example 5-004.mdb Example 5-005a.mdb Example 5-005b.mdb Example 5-005c.mdb Example 5-005d.mdb Example 5-005e.mdb Example 5-005f.mdb Example 5-005g.mdb Example 5-005h.mdb Example 5-005i.mdb Example 5-005j.mdb Example 5-006.mdb Example 5-007a.mdb Example 5-007b.mdb Example 5-008a.mdb Example 5-008b.mdb Example 5-008c.mdb Example 5-008d.mdb Example 5-008e.mdb Example 5-008f.mdb Example 5-009a.mdb Example 5-009b.mdb Example 5-010.mdb Example 5-011.mdb Example 5-012a.mdb
5-012 5-012 5-012 5-013 6-001 6-002 6-003 6-003 6-004 6-005 6-005 6-006 6-007 6-008 6-009 6-010 6-011 6-011 6-012 7-001 7-002 7-003
Example 5-012b.mdb Example 5-012c.mdb Example 5-012d.mdb Example 5-013.mdb Example 6-001.mdb Example 6-002.mdb Example 6-003a.mdb Example 6-003b.mdb Example 6-004.mdb Example 6-005a.mdb Example 6-005b.mdb Example 6-006.mdb Example 6-007.mdb Example 6-008.mdb Example 6-009.mdb Example 6-010.mdb Example 6-011a.mdb Example 6-011b.mdb Example 6-012.mdb Example 7-001.mdb Example 7-002.mdb Example 7-003.mdb
Example 1-001
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Load Output Percent Case Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference 1 Uz (jt. 3) (in) -0.02639 -0.02639 0.00% 2 Uz (jt. 3) (in) 0.06296 0.06296 0.00% 3 Uz (jt. 3) (in) 0.06296 0.06296 0.00% 4 Uz (jt. 3) (in) -0.29630 -0.29630 0.00% 5 Ux (jt. 2) (in) 0.31250 0.31250 0.00% 6 Ux (jt. 2) (in) 0.11556 0.11556 0.00% 7 Ux (jt. 2) (in) 0.00651 0.00651 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-001
Example 1-002
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples MODEL A Load Case Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent 1 Ux (free end) (in) 0.00130 0.00130 2 Ux (free end) (in) 0.00065 0.00065 3 Uz (free end) (in) -0.00650 -0.00650 MODEL B Load Case Output Parameter 1 Fx (at prop) (kips) 2 Fx (at prop) (kips) 3 Fz (at prop) (kips)
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 5 5 5 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
SAP2000 -22.62 -11.31 2.545
Independent -22.62 -11.31 2.545
Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 2 2 3
Result for Comparison 0 0 0
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-002
Example 1-003
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Load Output Percent Case Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference 1 Mx(jt. 1) k-in -4.00 -4.00 0.00% 1 Rx (jt. 3) rad. 0.02375 0.02375 0.00% 1 Rx (jt. 5) rad. 0.02558 0.02558 0.00% 2 Mx(jt. 1) k-in -5.75 -5.75 0.00% 2 Rx (jt. 3) rad. 0.02421 0.02421 0.00% 2 Rx (jt.5) rad. 0.02969 0.02969 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 2 0 5 0 5 0 2 0 5 0 5 0
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-003
Example 1-004
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Load Output Percent Case Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference 1 Uy (free end) in -0.01806 -0.01806 0.00% 1 Uz (free end) in -0.03029 -0.03029 0.00% 2 Uy (free end) in -0.03345 -0.03345 0.00% 2 Uz (free end) in -0.0561 -0.0561 0.00% 3 Uy (free end) in -0.08361 -0.08361 0.00% 3 Uz (free end) in -0.14024 -0.14024 0.00%
Example 1-004
Example 1-005
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Output Model Parameter SAP2000 A. Support Settlement Fz (jt. 1) kip 6.293 A. Support Settlement My (jt. 1) kip-in -906.25 B. Spring Support Settlement Fz (jt. 1) kip 1.115 B. Spring Support Settlement My (jt. 1) kip-in -160.492 C. Support Rotation Fz (jt. 1) kip -18.125 C. Support Rotation My (jt. 1) kip-in 2610 D. Spring Support Rotation My (jt. 1 ) kip -473.469 D. Spring Support Rotation Ry (jt. 4) rad. 0.00408 E. Skewed Support Fz (jt. 1) kip 5.811 E. Skewed Support F3 (jt. 4) kip 5.236 F. Skewed Support Settlement Fz (jt. 1) kip 27.215 F. Skewed Support Settlement My (jt. 1) kip-in -3918.919
Percent Independent Difference 6.293 0.00% -906.25 0.00% 1.115 0.00% -160.492 0.00% -18.125 0.00% 2610 0.00% -473.469 0.00% 0.00408 0.00% 5.811 0.00% 5.236 0.00% 27.215 0.00% -3918.919 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 5 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0
Example 1-005
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples MODEL A Load Case Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent 1 My (fixed end)k-in -184.95 -184.95 2 Ux (free end) in 0.09087 0.09087 3 Uy (free end) in 0.4312 0.4312 4 Uz (free end) in -0.14335 -0.14335 5 Rx (free end) rad 0.07987 0.07987 6 Ry (free end) rad 0.03742 0.03742 7 Rz (free end) rad 0.07634 0.07634 MODEL B Load Case Output Parameter 1 My (fixed end)k-in 2 Ux (free end) in 3 Uy (free end) in 4 Uz (free end) in 5 Rx (free end) rad 6 Ry (free end) rad 7 Rz (free end) rad
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 2 5 5 5 5 5 5 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
SAP2000 -184.95 0.09087 0.4312 -0.14335 0.07987 0.03742 0.07634
Independent -184.95 0.09087 0.4312 -0.14335 0.07987 0.03742 0.07634
Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 2 5 5 5 5 5 5
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-006
Example 1-007
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model A A B B C C Output Parameter Fz (fixed support) k My (fixed support) k-ft Fz (fixed support) k My (fixed support) k-ft Fz (fixed support) k My (fixed support) k-ft SAP2000 0 50 0 50 5 0 Independent 0 50 0 50 5 0 Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-007
Example 1-008
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Load 1 Output Parameter SAP2000 Uz (cantilever tip) in -0.8036 Independent -0.8036 Percent Difference 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 4 0
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked
Example 1-008
Example 1-009
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Output Percent Model Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference A - By Loads Uz (center) in 0.17028 0.16564 2.8% B - Elems (60") Uz (center) in 0.16041 0.16564 -3.2% C - Elems (12") Uz (center) in 0.16484 0.16564 -0.5% A - By Loads My (center) kip-in -2,061.5 -2,004.3 2.9% B - Elems (60") My (center) kip-in -2,013.9 -2,004.3 0.5% C - Elems (12") My (center) kip-in -2,001.7 -2,004.3 -0.1%
Example 1-009
Example 1-010
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model and Rigid Output Zone Factor Parameter SAP2000 Independent Model A - N.A. Uz (free end) in -0.39951 -0.39951 Model B - 0.0 Uz (free end) in -0.39951 -0.39951 Model C - 0.5 Uz (free end) in -0.37523 -0.37523 Model D - 1.0 Uz (free end) in -0.35197 -0.35197
Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-010
Example 1-011
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Load Percent Case Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference 1 My (fixed end) k-in 0.00 0.00 0.00% 1 Mz (fixed end) k-in 0 0 0.00% 1 M3 (beam max) k-in -210 -210 0.00% 1 M2 (beam max) k-in -60 -60 0.00% 2 My (fixed end) k-in 210 210 0.00% 2 Mz (fixed end) k-in 60 60 0.00% 2 M3 (beam max) k-in 0 0 0.00% 2 M2 (beam max) k-in 0 0 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-011
Example 1-012
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Output Percent Model Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference A Ux (jt 2) in 0.10677 0.10677 0.00% A Fx (jt 1) kip -44.224 -44.224 0.00% A Fz (jt 1) kip -100 -100 0.00% A Fx (jt 3) kip -55.776 -55.776 0.00% A Fz (jt 3) kip 100 100 0.00% B Ux (jt 2) in 0.24142 0.24142 0.00% B Fx (jt 1) kip -100 -100 0.00% B Fz (jt 1) kip -100 -100 0.00% B Fx (jt 3) kip 0 0 0.00% B Fz (jt 3) kip 100 100 0.00% C Ux (jt 2) in 0.19142 0.19142 0.00% C Fx (jt 1) kip 0 0 0.00% C Fz (jt 1) kip -100 -100 0.00% C Fx (jt 3) kip -100 -100 0.00% C Fz (jt 3) kip 100 100 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 5 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 5 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 5 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-012
Example 1-013
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model and Output Num Elems. Parameter SAP2000 Independent A - 1 elem Uz (jt 2) in -0.08854 -0.08933 A - 1 elem My (jt 2) k-in 16,524 17,698 B - 4 elems Uz (jt 2) in -0.08933 -0.08933 B - 4 elems My (jt 2) k-in 17,634 17,698 C - 100 elems Uz (jt 2) in -0.08933 -0.08933 C - 100 elems My (jt 2) k-in 17,698 17,698
Percent Difference -0.88% -6.63% 0.00% -0.36% 0.00% 0.00%
Example 1-013
Example 1-014
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model and Num Elems. Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent A - 1 elem 0.054547 0.038005 Period for Mode 1 0.042333 B - 2 elems 0.038005 which is the first C - 4 elems 0.03909 0.038005 mode for bending 0.038485 D - 6 elems 0.038005 about the Z axis, 0.038273 E - 8 elems 0.038005 seconds F - 10 elems 0.038175 0.038005 G - 96 elems 0.038003 0.038005 A - 1 elem 0.036364 0.025337 Period for Mode 2 0.028222 B - 2 elems 0.025337 which is the first C - 4 elems 0.02606 0.025337 mode for bending 0.025657 D - 6 elems 0.025337 about the Y axis, 0.025516 E - 8 elems 0.025337 seconds F - 10 elems 0.02545 0.025337 G - 96 elems 0.025335 0.025337 A - 1 elem N.A. 0.006064 Period for Mode 3 0.008218 B - 2 elems 0.006064 which is the C - 4 elems 0.006651 0.006064 second mode for D - 6 elems 0.00633 0.006064 E - 8 elems bending about the 0.006214 0.006064 Z axis, seconds F - 10 elems 0.00616 0.006064 G - 96 elems 0.006065 0.006064 A - 1 elem N.A. 0.004043 Period for Mode 4 0.005479 B - 2 elems 0.004043 which is the C - 4 elems 0.004434 0.004043 second mode for D - 6 elems 0.00422 0.004043 bending about the 0.004143 E - 8 elems 0.004043 Y axis, seconds F - 10 elems 0.004107 0.004043 G - 96 elems 0.004043 0.004043 A - 1 elem N.A. 0.002165 Period for Mode 5 B - 2 elems N.A. 0.002165 which is the third 0.002511 C - 4 elems 0.002165 mode for bending 0.002321 D - 6 elems 0.002165 about the Z axis, 0.002254 E - 8 elems 0.002165 seconds F - 10 elems 0.002222 0.002165 G - 96 elems 0.002166 0.002165
Percent Difference 43.53% 11.39% 2.85% 1.26% 0.71% 0.45% -0.01% 43.52% 11.39% 2.85% 1.26% 0.71% 0.45% -0.01% N.A. 35.52% 9.68% 4.39% 2.47% 1.58% 0.02% N.A. 35.52% 9.67% 4.38% 2.47% 1.58% 0.00% N.A. N.A. 15.98% 7.21% 4.11% 2.63% 0.05%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 N.A. N.A. 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 N.A. N.A. 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 6 0
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked N.A. Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked N.A. Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked N.A. N.A. Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-014
Example 1-015
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Output Analysis Case Parameter SAP2000 Independent SS1 - Undamped steady state Uz (jt 2) in 0.0544 0.0541 MHIST1 - Periodic time history using 5 modes
Percent Difference 0.55%
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked
Uz (jt 2) in
0.0544
0.0541
0.55%
Not Checked
Example 1-015
Example 1-016
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model and Num Elems. Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent A - 1 elem -1.04167 -1.04167 Uz (midpt) in A - 1 elem 22.5 22.5 My (midpt) k-in B - 1 elem -0.54555 -0.5433 Uz (midpt) in B - 1 elem 11.453 11.498 My (midpt) k-in C - 2 elems -0.54343 -0.5433 Uz (midpt) in C - 2 elems 11.495 11.498 My (midpt) k-in D - 16 elems -0.5433 -0.5433 Uz (midpt) in D - 16 elems 11.498 11.498 My (midpt) k-in E - 1 elem -0.54555 -0.5433 Uz (midpt) in E - 1 elem 11.453 11.498 My (midpt) k-in F - 2 elems -0.54343 -0.5433 Uz (midpt) in F - 2 elems 11.495 11.498 My (midpt) k-in G - 4 elems -0.5433 -0.5433 Uz (midpt) in G - 4 elems 11.498 11.498 My (midpt) k-in
Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.41% -0.39% 0.02% -0.03% 0.00% 0.00% 0.41% -0.39% 0.02% -0.03% 0.00% 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 5 0 3 0 5 0 3 0 5 0 3 0 5 0 3 0 5 0 3 0 5 0 3 0 5 0 3 0
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Note: Model A has no tension stiffening. Models B, C and D have tension stiffeningusing the P-Delta force method. Models E, F and G have tension stiffening using a nonlinear static analysis case with its P-Delta option activated.
Example 1-016
Example 1-017
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model and Output Num Elems. Parameter SAP2000 Independent A - 10 elems f1 Hz 74.579 74.586 A - 10 elems f2 Hz 148.93 149.17 A - 10 elems f3 Hz 222.06 223.76 B - 100 elems f1 Hz 74.587 74.586 B - 100 elems f2 Hz 149.18 149.17 B - 100 elems f3 Hz 223.8 223.76
Percent Difference -0.01% -0.16% -0.76% 0.00% 0.01% 0.02%
Example 1-017
Example 1-018
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Output Percent Model Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference A -2.77076 -2.77076 0.00% Uz (jt 5) in B -2.72361 -2.72361 0.00% Uz (jt 5) in C -0.03954 -0.03954 0.00% Uz (jt 5) in D -0.0076 -0.0076 0.00% Uz (jt 5) in Note: Model A has bending, shear and axial deformations. Models B has bending deformations only. Models C has shear deformations only. Models D has axial deformations only.
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-018
Example 1-019
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model and Num Elems. Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent A - 1 elem Buckling Load (kips) 280.98 280.19 B - 2 elems Buckling Load (kips) 280.24 280.19 C - 4 elems Buckling Load (kips) 280.19 280.19
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 2 0 2 0 2 0
Example 1-019
Example 1-020
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Case MODAL MODAL SPEC1 SPEC1 Output Parameter SAP2000 Mode 1 period (sec) 1.562 Mode 2 period (sec) 0.5868 Ux (jt. 2) in 7.576 Ux (jt. 3) in 18.84 First story column Element 1, Joint 1 M3 (k-in) 12,636 First story column Element 1, Joint 2 M3 (k-in) 6793 Second story column Element 2, Joint 2 M3 (k-in) 6023 Second story column Element 2, Joint 3 M3 (k-in) 5222 First story beam Element 5, Joint 2 M3 (k-in) 9810 First story beam Element 6, Joint 5 M3 (k-in) 9810 Second story beam Element 7, Joint 3 M3 (k-in) 5222 Second story beam Element 8, Joint 6 M3 (k-in) 5222 Independent 1.562 0.5868 7.566 18.81 Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.13% 0.16%
SPEC1
12,624
0.10%
Not Checked
SPEC1
6792
0.01%
Not Checked
SPEC1
6024
-0.02%
Not Checked
SPEC1
5220
0.04%
Not Checked
SPEC1
9792
0.18%
Not Checked
SPEC1
9792
0.18%
Not Checked
SPEC1
5220
0.04%
Not Checked
SPEC1
5220
0.04%
Not Checked
Example 1-020
Example 1-021
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Comparison with Bathe and Wilson 1972 Mode 1 2 3 Output Parameter Eigenvalue Eigenvalue Eigenvalue SAP2000 0.589541 5.52696 16.5879 Independent 0.589541 5.52695 16.5878 Percent Difference 0.0000% 0.0002% 0.0006%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 6 5 4 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Comparison with Peterson 1981 Load Case Output Parameter SAP2000 1 Eigenvalue 0.589541 2 Eigenvalue 5.52696 3 Eigenvalue 16.5879
Independent 0.589541 5.52696 16.5879
SAP2000 Result
Example 1-021
Example 1-022
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Case MODAL MODAL MODAL MODAL MODAL MODAL MODAL LAT LAT LAT SPECSRSS SPECSRSS SPECSRSS SPECCQC SPECCQC SPECCQC MHIST1 MHIST1 MHIST1 DHIST1 DHIST1 DHIST1 MHIST2 MHIST2 MHIST2 DHIST2 DHIST2 DHIST2 Output Parameter Mode 1 period (sec) Mode 2 period (sec) Mode 3 period (sec) Mode 4 period (sec) Mode 5 period (sec) Mode 6 period (sec) Mode 7 period (sec) Ux at joint 22 (in) P in frame 1 (kip) My in frame 1 at jt 1 (kip-in) Ux at joint 22 (in) P in frame 1 (kip) My in frame 1 at jt 1 (kip-in) Ux at joint 22 (in) P in frame 1 (kip) My in frame 1 at jt 1 (kip-in) Ux at joint 22 (in) P in frame 1 (kip) My in frame 1 at jt 1 (kip-in) Ux at joint 22 (in) P in frame 1 (kip) My in frame 1 at jt 1 (kip-in) Ux at joint 22 (in) P in frame 1 (kip) My in frame 1 at jt 1 (kip-in) Ux at joint 22 (in) P in frame 1 (kip) My in frame 1 at jt 1 (kip-in) SAP2000 1.2732 0.4313 0.242 0.1602 0.119 0.0951 0.0795 1.45076 69.99 2324.68 5.436 261.7 9864 5.431 261.5 9916 5.486 263 9104 5.485 263.2 9183 5.499 264 9200 5.499 264 9200 Independent 1.2732 0.4313 0.242 0.1602 0.119 0.0951 0.0795 1.45076 69.99 2324.68 5.438 261.8 9868 5.438 261.8 9868 5.46 258 8740 5.46 258 8740 None None None None None None Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% -0.04% -0.04% -0.04% -0.13% -0.11% 0.49% 0.48% 1.94% 4.16% 0.46% 2.02% 5.07% N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A.
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 5 0 2 0 2 0 3 0 1 0 0 0 3 0 1 0 0 0 3 0 1 0 0 0 3 0 1 0 0 0 3 0 1 0 0 0 3 0 1 0 0 0
Example 1-022
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-023
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Mode 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Output Parameter Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency Frequency SAP2000 112 117 138 218 415 434 463 561 752 777 873 914 915 934 955 980 988 991 1002 1032 1090 1151 1177 1229 Independent 112 116 138 218 404 423 452 554 736 762 853 894 910 917 940 960 971 977 1012 1028 1124 1135 1164 1217 Percent Difference 0.00% 0.86% 0.00% 0.00% 2.72% 2.60% 2.43% 1.26% 2.17% 1.97% 2.34% 2.24% 0.55% 1.85% 1.60% 2.08% 1.75% 1.43% -0.99% 0.39% -3.02% 1.41% 1.12% 0.99%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-023
Example 1-024
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Case MODAL MODAL MODAL MODAL RS-CQC RS-SRSS RS-ABS RS-10PCT Output Parameter Mode 1 period, sec Mode 2 period, sec Mode 3 period, sec Mode 4 period, sec Ux (jt 29) ft Ux (jt 29) ft Ux (jt 29) ft Ux (jt 29) ft SAP2000 0.2271 0.2156 0.0733 0.072 0.02014 0.02012 0.0205 0.02016 Independent 0.2271 0.2156 0.0733 0.072 0.02014 0.02012 0.0205 0.02016 Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
Example 1-024
Example 1-025
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Case MODAL MODAL RS-CQC RS-SRSS RS-ABS RS-CQC RS-SRSS RS-ABS RS-CQC RS-SRSS RS-ABS RS-CQC RS-SRSS RS-ABS RS-CQC RS-SRSS RS-ABS RS-CQC RS-SRSS RS-ABS Output Parameter Mode 1 frequency Hz Mode 2 frequency Hz Ux (jt 51) in Ux (jt 51) in Ux (jt 51) in Uy (jt 51) in Uy (jt 51) in Uy (jt 51) in Rz (jt 51) rad Rz (jt 51) rad Rz (jt 51) rad P in frame 1 (kip) P in frame 1 (kip) P in frame 1 (kip) P in frame 4 (kip) P in frame 4 (kip) P in frame 4 (kip) P in frame 6 (kip) P in frame 6 (kip) P in frame 6 (kip) SAP2000 3.0592 3.1188 1.0329 0.7372 1.0423 0.1414 0.7372 1.0423 0.000252 0.000252 0.000252 279.48 200.55 281.99 194.5 139.57 196.25 120.52 86.48 121.61 Independent 3.0592 3.1188 1.0329 0.7372 1.0423 0.1414 0.7372 1.0423 0.000252 0.000252 0.000252 279.48 200.55 281.99 194.5 139.57 196.25 120.52 86.48 121.61 Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 4 0 6 0 6 0 6 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0
Example 1-025
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-026
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model A Analysis Case and Point/Step Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent NLSTAT1 Force P (free end) kips 60 60 (Pt 1, Step 1) NLSTAT1 Uz (free end) in 0.0185 0.0185 (Pt 1, Step 1) NLSTAT1 Ry (free end) rad -0.0008 -0.0008 (Pt 1, Step 1) NLSTAT1 Force P (free end) kips 80 80 (Pt 2, Step 6) NLSTAT1 Uz (free end) in 1.3847 1.3847 (Pt 2, Step 6) NLSTAT1 Ry (free end) rad -0.0411 -0.0411 (Pt 2, Step 6) NLSTAT1 Force P (free end) kips 20 20 (Pt 2, Step 7) NLSTAT1 Uz (free end) in 1.7612 1.3662 (Pt 2, Step 7) NLSTAT1 Ry (free end) rad -0.0567 -0.0403 (Pt 2, Step 7) Model B Analysis Case and Point/Step NLSTAT1 (Pt 1, Step 1) NLSTAT1 (Pt 1, Step 1) NLSTAT1 (Pt 1, Step 1) NLSTAT1 (Pt 2, Step 6)
Results From Current Analyses
Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 28.91% 40.69%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 0 4 4 0 4 4 0 4 4
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Output Parameter Force P (free end) kips Uz (free end) in Ry (free end) rad Force P (free end) kips
SAP2000 60 0.0185 -0.0008 80
Independent 60 0.0185 -0.0008 80
Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 0 4 4 0
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0
Example 1-026
NLSTAT1 (Pt 2, Step 6) NLSTAT1 (Pt 2, Step 6) NLSTAT1 (Pt 2, Step 7) NLSTAT1 (Pt 2, Step 7) NLSTAT1 (Pt 2, Step 7)
Uz (free end) in Ry (free end) rad Force P (free end) kips Uz (free end) in Ry (free end) rad
1.3847 -0.0411 20 1.3701 -0.0404
1.3847 -0.0411 20 1.3662 -0.0403
0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.29% 0.25%
4 4 0 4 4
0 0 0 0 0
Example 1-026
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
% Diff From Version End Releases Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-026
Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-027
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Case and Stage Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent NLSTAT1 Uz (jt 2) in -0.42404 -0.42404 (Stage 1) NLSTAT1 Fz (jt 1) kips 100 100 (Stage 1) NLSTAT1 Uz (jt 2) in -0.43617 -0.43617 (Stage 2) NLSTAT1 Fz (jt 1) kips 102.859 102.859 (Stage 2) NLSTAT1 Uz (jt 2) in -0.53005 -0.53005 (Stage 3) NLSTAT1 Fz (jt 1) kips 125 125 (Stage 3)
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 5 3 5 3 5 3 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 1-027
Example 1-028
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Output Case Parameter SAP2000 Independent NLSTAT1 Fz (jt 1) kip 3,497 3,497
Example 1-028
Example 1-029
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model and Num Elems. Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent A - 4 elems Ux (jt 2) in 65.328 63.662 A - 4 elems Uz (jt 2) in -100 -100 A - 4 elems Moment k-in 10295 10295 B - 16 elems Ux (jt 2) in 63.764 63.662 B - 16 elems Uz (jt 2) in -100 -100 B - 16 elems Moment k-in 10295 10295 C - 64 elems Ux (jt 2) in 63.668 63.662 C - 64 elems Uz (jt 2) in -100 -100 C - 64 elems Moment k-in 10295 10295
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 3 0 3 0 0 0 3 0 3 0 0 0 3 0 3 0 0 0
Example 1-029
Example 1-030
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Analysis Case MOVEINF MOVEINF MOVEMS MOVEMS
Output Parameter Max Moment k-ft Max Reaction kips Max Moment k-ft Max Reaction kips
SAP2000 Independent 345.6 346 38.789 38.8 345.5 346 37.192 37.2
Percent Difference -0.1% 0.0% -0.1% 0.0%
Results From Current Analyses Number of SAP2000 Decimal Result for Result Places Comparison 1 0 3 0 1 0 3 0
Example 1-030
Example 2-001
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option Analysis Case Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Membrane sxx lb/in2 1333 1333 Membrane syy lb/in2 1333 1333 Membrane sxy lb/in2 400 400 PlBend Mxx lb-in/in 1.111E-07 1.11E-07 PlBend Myy lb-in/in 1.111E-07 1.11E-07 PlBend Mxy lb-in/in 3.333E-08 3.33E-08 Thick Plate Option Analysis Case Output Parameter Membrane sxx lb/in2 Membrane syy lb/in2 Membrane sxy lb/in2 PlBend Mxx lb-in/in PlBend Myy lb-in/in PlBend Mxy lb-in/in
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 0 0 0 10 10 11 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
SAP2000 1333 1333 400 1.111E-07 1.111E-07 3.330E-08
Independent 1333 1333 400 1.11E-07 1.11E-07 3.33E-08
Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 0 0 0 10 10 10
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-001
Example 2-002
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option Load Case Model and Output and Type Element Shape Parameter SAP2000 A - Rectangle 3.000E-05 Ux Load case 1 B - Trapezoid 3.000E-05 Average of Axial C - Parallelogram 3.000E-05 jts 7 and 14 Extension D - Triangle 2 3.000E-05 in E - Triangle 4 3.000E-05 A - Rectangle 0.1072 Load case 2 Uz B - Trapezoid 0.0227 In-plane Average of C - Parallelogram 0.0804 shear and jts 7 and 14 D - Triangle 2 0.0032 bending in E - Triangle 4 0.0066 A - Rectangle 0.432 Load case 3 Uy B - Trapezoid 0.4322 Out-of-plane Average of C - Parallelogram 0.4322 shear and jts 7 and 14 D - Triangle 2 0.4296 bending in E - Triangle 4 0.4314 Uy A - Rectangle 0.00233 Average of B - Trapezoid 0.00233 Load case 4 C - Parallelogram absolute values 0.00233 Twist at jts 7 and 14 D - Triangle 2 0.00231 in E - Triangle 4 0.0023 Ux A - Rectangle 8.990E-04 Load case 5 Average of B - Trapezoid 1.395E-04 In-plane C - Parallelogram absolute values 7.225E-04 moment at jts 7 and 14 2.650E-05 D - Triangle 2 in E - Triangle 4 5.500E-05 Rz A - Rectangle 0.036 Load case 6 Average of B - Trapezoid 0.036 Out-of-plane C - Parallelogram absolute values 0.036 moment at jts 7 and 14 D - Triangle 2 0.036 radians E - Triangle 4 0.036
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% -1% -79% -26% -97% -94% 0% 0% 0% -1% 0% -32% -32% -32% -32% -33% 0% -85% -20% -97% -94% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 8 8 8 8 8 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 5 5 5 5 5 7 7 7 7 7 5 5 5 5 5 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Independent 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 0.036 0.036 0.036 0.036 0.036
Example 2-002
Thick Plate Option Load Case Model and Output and Type Element Shape Parameter SAP2000 A - Rectangle 3.000E-05 Ux Load case 1 B - Trapezoid 3.000E-05 Average of Axial C - Parallelogram 3.000E-05 jts 7 and 14 Extension D - Triangle 2 3.000E-05 in E - Triangle 4 3.000E-05 A - Rectangle 0.1072 Load case 2 Uz B - Trapezoid 0.0227 In-plane Average of C - Parallelogram 0.0804 shear and jts 7 and 14 D - Triangle 2 0.0032 bending in E - Triangle 4 0.0066 A - Rectangle 0.4321 Load case 3 Uy B - Trapezoid 0.4307 Out-of-plane Average of C - Parallelogram 0.4322 shear and jts 7 and 14 D - Triangle 2 0.4328 bending in E - Triangle 4 0.4298 Uy A - Rectangle 0.00224 Average of B - Trapezoid 0.00409 Load case 4 C - Parallelogram absolute values 0.0024 Twist at jts 7 and 14 D - Triangle 2 0.00466 in E - Triangle 4 0.00458 Ux A - Rectangle 8.990E-04 Load case 5 Average of B - Trapezoid 1.395E-04 In-plane C - Parallelogram absolute values 7.225E-04 moment at jts 7 and 14 2.650E-05 D - Triangle 2 in E - Triangle 4 5.500E-05 Rz A - Rectangle 0.036 Load case 6 Average of B - Trapezoid 0.036 Out-of-plane C - Parallelogram absolute values 0.036 moment at jts 7 and 14 D - Triangle 2 0.036 radians E - Triangle 4 0.036
Independent 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 0.036 0.036 0.036 0.036 0.036
Percent Difference 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% -1% -79% -26% -97% -94% 0% 0% 0% 0% -1% -34% 20% -30% 37% 34% 0% -85% -20% -97% -94% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 8 8 8 8 8 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 5 5 5 5 5 7 7 7 7 7 5 5 5 5 5
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-002
Model F Results (Parallelogram-shaped elements) Load Case Output and Type Element Type Parameter SAP2000 Load case 2 In-plane shear and bending Thin Plate Uz Average of jts 13 and 26 in 0.1061
Independent 0.1081
Percent Difference
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 4
Result for Comparison 0
-1.9% 0.1061 0.1081 -1.9% 4 0
Thick Plate
Load case 5 In-plane moment
Thin Plate
Thick Plate
Ux 8.886E-04 Average of absolute values at jts 13 and 26 8.886E-04 in
9.000E-04 -1.3% 9.000E-04 -1.3%
Model G Results (Trapezoidal-shaped elements with 60 x 2 mesh) Load Case Output and Type Element Type Parameter SAP2000 Independent Load case 2 In-plane shear and bending Thin Plate Uz Average of jts 7 and 14 in 0.1071 0.1081
Percent Difference
SAP2000 Result
-0.9% 0.1071 0.1081 -0.9% 4 0
Thick Plate
Load case 5 In-plane moment
Thin Plate
Thick Plate
Ux 8.825E-04 Average of absolute values at jts 7 and 14 8.825E-04 in
9.000E-04 -1.9% 9.000E-04 -1.9%
Model H Results Special Case for Twisting Comparison) Load Case Output and Type Element Type Parameter SAP2000
Independent
Percent Difference
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places
Result for Comparison
Example 2-002
Load case 4 Twist
Thin Plate
Uy Average of absolute values at jts 7 and 14 in
0.00234
0.00234
0%
Example 2-002
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 2-002
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 2-002
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
% Diff From Version 14.00
Example 2-002
Not Checked
Example 2-003
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model and Load Case and Output Mesh Type Parameter SAP2000 Uy Load case IN Average of 0.0773 In-plane jts 7 and 14 in Model A Thin 6x1 mesh Uz Load case OUT Average of 0.4535 Out-of-plane jts 7 and 14 in Load case IN In-plane Model A Thick 6x1 mesh Load case OUT Out-of-plane Model A Thin 6x1 mesh Model B Thin 90x1 mesh Model C Thin 90x3 mesh Model D Thin 6x1 mesh with each of 6 objects submeshed 15x3 Uy Average of jts 7 and 14 in Uz Average of jts 7 and 14 in 0.0773
Independent 0.0886
Percent Difference -13%
0.5004
-9%
0.0886
-13%
0.4298
0.5004
-14%
0.0773 0.0845 Load case IN In-plane Uy Average of jts 7 and 14 in 0.0884
0.0886 0.0886 0.0886
-13% -5% 0%
4 4 4
0 0 0
0.0893
0.0886
1%
Example 2-003
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model and Load Case and Output Mesh Type Parameter SAP2000 Model A Thick 0.0773 6x1 mesh Model B Thick 0.0845 90x1 mesh Model C Thick Uy 0.0884 90x3 mesh Load case IN Average of Model D Thick In-plane jts 7 and 14 6x1 mesh with in each of 6 0.0893 objects submeshed 15x3 Model A Thick 0.4298 6x1 mesh Model B Thick 0.4566 90x1 mesh Model C Thick Uz 0.4558 90x3 mesh Load case OUT Average of Model D Thick Out-of-plane jts 7 and 14 6x1 mesh with in each of 6 0.457 objects submeshed 15x3
Independent 0.0886 0.0886 0.0886
Percent Difference -13% -5% 0%
0.0886
1%
0.4546 0.4546 0.4546
-5% 0% 0%
4 4 4
0 0 0
0.4546
1%
Example 2-003
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Not Checked
Example 2-003
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Not Checked
Example 2-004
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model and Load Case and Output Mesh Type Parameter SAP2000 Uy Load case IN Average of 0.005415 In-plane jts 13, 26, 39 in Thin 12x2 mesh Uz Load case OUT Average of 0.001769 Out-of-plane jts 13, 26, 39 in Load case IN In-plane Thick 12x2 mesh Load case OUT Out-of-plane Uy Average of jts 13, 26, 39 in Uz Average of jts 13, 26, 39 in 0.005402
Independent 0.005429
Percent Difference -0.3%
0.001749
1.1%
0.005429
-0.5%
0.00176
0.001749
0.6%
Example 2-004
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Example 2-005
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option - Uniform Load - 2"x2" Plate Edge Output Support Mesh Model Parameter SAP2000 Independent Simple 4x4 A 4.06 4.06 Uz, in Simple 16x16 E 4.06 4.06 Center of Fixed 4x4 B 1.32 1.26 plate Fixed 16x16 F 1.27 1.26 Thin Plate Option - Uniform Load - 2"x10" Plate Edge Analysis Output Support Mesh Case Parameter SAP2000 Simple 4x4 C 12.86 Uz, in Simple 16x16 G 12.96 Center of Fixed 4x4 D 2.6 plate Fixed 16x16 H 2.6
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0% 0% 5% 1% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 2 2 2 2 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0
Independent 12.97 12.97 2.6 2.6
Percent Difference -1% 0% 0% 0%
SAP2000 Result
Thin Plate Option - Center Concentrated Load - 2"x2" Plate Edge Output Support Mesh Model Parameter SAP2000 Independent Simple 4x4 A 11.94 11.6 Uz, in Simple 16x16 E 11.63 11.6 Center of Fixed 4x4 B 5.9 5.6 plate Fixed 16x16 F 5.64 5.6 Thin Plate Option - Center Concentrated Load - 2"x10" Plate Edge Analysis Output Support Mesh Case Parameter SAP2000 Independent Simple 4x4 C 18.12 16.95 Uz, in Simple 16x16 G 17.15 16.95 Center of Fixed 4x4 D 7.79 7.25 plate Fixed 16x16 H 7.41 7.25
Percent Difference 3% 0% 5% 1%
SAP2000 Result
Percent Difference 7% 1% 7% 2%
SAP2000 Result
Example 2-005
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thick Plate Option - Uniform Load - 2"x2" Plate Edge Output Support Mesh Model Parameter SAP2000 Independent Simple 4x4 A 4.03 4.06 Uz, in Simple 16x16 E 4.06 4.06 Center of Fixed 4x4 B 1.25 1.26 plate Fixed 16x16 F 1.27 1.26 Thick Plate Option - Uniform Load - 2"x10" Plate Edge Analysis Output Support Mesh Case Parameter SAP2000 Simple 4x4 C 12.87 Uz, in Simple 16x16 G 12.97 Center of Fixed 4x4 D 2.59 plate Fixed 16x16 H 2.6
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference -1% 0% -1% 1% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 2 2 2 2 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0
Independent 12.97 12.97 2.6 2.6
Percent Difference -1% 0% 0% 0%
SAP2000 Result
Thick Plate Option - Center Concentrated Load - 2"x2" Plate Edge Output Support Mesh Model Parameter SAP2000 Independent Simple 4x4 A 11.61 11.6 Uz, in Simple 16x16 E 11.61 11.6 Center of Fixed 4x4 B 5.38 5.6 plate Fixed 16x16 F 5.61 5.6
Percent Difference 0% 0% -4% 0%
SAP2000 Result
Thick Plate Option - Center Concentrated Load - 2"x10" Plate Edge Analysis Output Percent Support Mesh Case Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference Simple 4x4 C 16.27 16.95 -4% Uz, in Simple 16x16 G 16.92 16.95 0% Center of Fixed 4x4 D 5.86 7.25 -19% plate Fixed 16x16 H 7.11 7.25 -2% Fixed 4x7* I 6.9 7.25 -5% * Model I has a special mesh that is tighter in the area of the concentrated load
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 2 2 2 2 2
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-005
Example 2-005
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 2-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option - Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent SELF N.A. Uz (jt 49) ft -0.3068 -0.3086 GRAV N.A. Uz (jt 49) ft -0.3068 -0.3086 UNIF N.A. Uz (jt 49) ft -0.3068 -0.3086 Thin Plate Option - Axial Deformations at Support Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 SELF 0 Uy (jt 1) ft 0 SELF 6.67 Uy (jt 2) ft 0.0005 SELF 13.33 Uy (jt 3) ft 0.0018 20 Uy (jt 4) ft 0.0029 SELF 26.67 Uy (jt 5) ft 0.0024 SELF 33.33 Uy (jt 6) ft -0.0017 SELF 40 Uy (jt 7) ft -0.0118 SELF GRAV 0 Uy (jt 1) ft 0 GRAV 6.67 Uy (jt 2) ft 0.0005 GRAV 13.33 Uy (jt 3) ft 0.0018 20 Uy (jt 4) ft 0.0029 GRAV 26.67 Uy (jt 5) ft 0.0024 GRAV 33.33 Uy (jt 6) ft -0.0017 GRAV 40 Uy (jt 7) ft -0.0118 GRAV UNIF 0 Uy (jt 1) ft 0 UNIF 6.67 Uy (jt 2) ft 0.0005 UNIF 13.33 Uy (jt 3) ft 0.0018 20 Uy (jt 4) ft 0.0029 UNIF 26.67 Uy (jt 5) ft 0.0024 UNIF 33.33 Uy (jt 6) ft -0.0017 UNIF 40 Uy (jt 7) ft -0.0118 UNIF
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference -1% -1% -1% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 4 4 4 Result for Comparison 0 0 0
Independent 0.0004 0.001 0.0021 0.003 0.0021 -0.0025 -0.0125 0.0004 0.001 0.0021 0.003 0.0021 -0.0025 -0.0125 0.0004 0.001 0.0021 0.003 0.0021 -0.0025 -0.0125
Percent Difference -3% -4% -2% -1% 2% -6% -6% -3% -4% -2% -1% 2% -6% -6% -3% -4% -2% -1% 2% -6% -6%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option - Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent Thin Plate Option - Twisting Moments at Support Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent SELF 0 Mxy (jt 1) lb-ft/ft 92 0 SELF 6.67 Mxy (jt 2) lb-ft/ft 362 370 SELF 13.33 Mxy (jt 3) lb-ft/ft 703 700 20 Mxy (jt 4) lb-ft/ft 993 990 SELF 26.67 Mxy (jt 5) lb-ft/ft 1190 1210 SELF 33.33 Mxy (jt 6) lb-ft/ft 1260 1310 SELF 40 Mxy (jt 7) lb-ft/ft 1261 1280 SELF GRAV 0 Mxy (jt 1) lb-ft/ft 92 0 GRAV 6.67 Mxy (jt 2) lb-ft/ft 362 370 GRAV 13.33 Mxy (jt 3) lb-ft/ft 703 700 20 Mxy (jt 4) lb-ft/ft 993 990 GRAV 26.67 Mxy (jt 5) lb-ft/ft 1190 1210 GRAV 33.33 Mxy (jt 6) lb-ft/ft 1260 1310 GRAV 40 Mxy (jt 7) lb-ft/ft 1261 1280 GRAV UNIF 0 Mxy (jt 1) lb-ft/ft 92 0 UNIF 6.67 Mxy (jt 2) lb-ft/ft 362 370 UNIF 13.33 Mxy (jt 3) lb-ft/ft 703 700 20 Mxy (jt 4) lb-ft/ft 993 990 UNIF 26.67 Mxy (jt 5) lb-ft/ft 1190 1210 UNIF 33.33 Mxy (jt 6) lb-ft/ft 1260 1310 UNIF 40 Mxy (jt 7) lb-ft/ft 1261 1280 UNIF
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference Percent Difference 7% -1% 0% 0% -2% -4% -1% 7% -1% 0% 0% -2% -4% -1% 7% -1% 0% 0% -2% -4% -1% SAP2000 Result SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places Number of Decimal Places 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Result for Comparison Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option - Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent Thin Plate Option - Vertical Displacement at Central Section Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent SELF 0 Uz (jt 43) ft 0.046 0.048 SELF 6.67 Uz (jt 44) ft 0.031 0.028 SELF 13.33 Uz (jt 45) ft -0.013 -0.015 20 Uz (jt 46) ft -0.078 -0.08 SELF 26.67 Uz (jt 47) ft -0.155 -0.157 SELF 33.33 Uz (jt 48) ft -0.234 -0.24 SELF 40 Uz (jt 49) ft -0.307 -0.315 SELF GRAV 0 Uz (jt 43) ft 0.046 0.048 GRAV 6.67 Uz (jt 44) ft 0.031 0.028 GRAV 13.33 Uz (jt 45) ft -0.013 -0.015 20 Uz (jt 46) ft -0.078 -0.08 GRAV 26.67 Uz (jt 47) ft -0.155 -0.157 GRAV 33.33 Uz (jt 48) ft -0.234 -0.24 GRAV 40 Uz (jt 49) ft -0.307 -0.315 GRAV UNIF 0 Uz (jt 43) ft 0.046 0.048 UNIF 6.67 Uz (jt 44) ft 0.031 0.028 UNIF 13.33 Uz (jt 45) ft -0.013 -0.015 20 Uz (jt 46) ft -0.078 -0.08 UNIF 26.67 Uz (jt 47) ft -0.155 -0.157 UNIF 33.33 Uz (jt 48) ft -0.234 -0.24 UNIF 40 Uz (jt 49) ft -0.307 -0.315 UNIF
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference Percent Difference -1% 1% -1% -1% -1% -2% -3% -1% 1% -1% -1% -1% -2% -3% -1% 1% -1% -1% -1% -2% -3% SAP2000 Result SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places Number of Decimal Places 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Result for Comparison Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option - Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent Thin Plate Option - Transverse Moments at Central Section Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent SELF 0 My (jt 43) lb-ft/ft -2099 -2080 SELF 6.67 My (jt 44) lb-ft/ft -1978 -1980 SELF 13.33 My (jt 45) lb-ft/ft -1614 -1580 20 My (jt 46) lb-ft/ft -1045 -1000 SELF 26.67 My (jt 47) lb-ft/ft -408 -400 SELF 33.33 My (jt 48) lb-ft/ft 36 70 SELF 40 My (jt 49) lb-ft/ft 0 -40 SELF GRAV 0 My (jt 43) lb-ft/ft -2099 -2080 GRAV 6.67 My (jt 44) lb-ft/ft -1978 -1980 GRAV 13.33 My (jt 45) lb-ft/ft -1614 -1580 20 My (jt 46) lb-ft/ft -1045 -1000 GRAV 26.67 My (jt 47) lb-ft/ft -408 -400 GRAV 33.33 My (jt 48) lb-ft/ft 36 70 GRAV 40 My (jt 49) lb-ft/ft 0 -40 GRAV UNIF 0 My (jt 43) lb-ft/ft -2099 -2080 UNIF 6.67 My (jt 44) lb-ft/ft -1978 -1980 UNIF 13.33 My (jt 45) lb-ft/ft -1614 -1580 20 My (jt 46) lb-ft/ft -1045 -1000 UNIF 26.67 My (jt 47) lb-ft/ft -408 -400 UNIF 33.33 My (jt 48) lb-ft/ft 36 70 UNIF 40 My (jt 49) lb-ft/ft 0 -40 UNIF
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference Percent Difference 1% 0% 2% 2% 0% -2% 2% 1% 0% 2% 2% 0% -2% 2% 1% 0% 2% 2% 0% -2% 2% SAP2000 Result SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places Number of Decimal Places 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Result for Comparison Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option - Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent Thin Plate Option - Longitudinal Moments at Central Section Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent SELF 0 Mx (jt 43) lb-ft/ft -100 -100 SELF 6.67 Mx (jt 44) lb-ft/ft -63 -90 SELF 13.33 Mx (jt 45) lb-ft/ft 37 10 20 Mx (jt 46) lb-ft/ft 181 140 SELF 26.67 Mx (jt 47) lb-ft/ft 340 300 SELF 33.33 Mx (jt 48) lb-ft/ft 502 490 SELF 40 Mx (jt 49) lb-ft/ft 664 700 SELF GRAV 0 Mx (jt 43) lb-ft/ft -100 -100 GRAV 6.67 Mx (jt 44) lb-ft/ft -63 -90 GRAV 13.33 Mx (jt 45) lb-ft/ft 37 10 20 Mx (jt 46) lb-ft/ft 181 140 GRAV 26.67 Mx (jt 47) lb-ft/ft 340 300 GRAV 33.33 Mx (jt 48) lb-ft/ft 502 490 GRAV 40 Mx (jt 49) lb-ft/ft 664 700 GRAV UNIF 0 Mx (jt 43) lb-ft/ft -100 -100 UNIF 6.67 Mx (jt 44) lb-ft/ft -63 -90 UNIF 13.33 Mx (jt 45) lb-ft/ft 37 10 20 Mx (jt 46) lb-ft/ft 181 140 UNIF 26.67 Mx (jt 47) lb-ft/ft 340 300 UNIF 33.33 Mx (jt 48) lb-ft/ft 502 490 UNIF 40 Mx (jt 49) lb-ft/ft 664 700 UNIF
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference Percent Difference 0% -4% 4% 6% 6% 2% -5% 0% -4% 4% 6% 6% 2% -5% 0% -4% 4% 6% 6% 2% -5% SAP2000 Result SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places Number of Decimal Places 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Result for Comparison Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option - Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent Thick Plate Option - Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent SELF N.A. Uz (jt 49) ft -0.3073 -0.3086 GRAV N.A. Uz (jt 49) ft -0.3073 -0.3086 UNIF N.A. Uz (jt 49) ft -0.3073 -0.3086 Thick Plate Option - Axial Deformations at Support Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 SELF 0 Uy (jt 1) ft 0 SELF 6.67 Uy (jt 2) ft 0.0005 SELF 13.33 Uy (jt 3) ft 0.0018 20 Uy (jt 4) ft 0.0029 SELF 26.67 Uy (jt 5) ft 0.0024 SELF 33.33 Uy (jt 6) ft -0.0017 SELF 40 Uy (jt 7) ft -0.0118 SELF GRAV 0 Uy (jt 1) ft 0 GRAV 6.67 Uy (jt 2) ft 0.0005 GRAV 13.33 Uy (jt 3) ft 0.0018 20 Uy (jt 4) ft 0.0029 GRAV 26.67 Uy (jt 5) ft 0.0024 GRAV 33.33 Uy (jt 6) ft -0.0017 GRAV 40 Uy (jt 7) ft -0.0118 GRAV UNIF 0 Uy (jt 1) ft 0 UNIF 6.67 Uy (jt 2) ft 0.0005 UNIF 13.33 Uy (jt 3) ft 0.0018 20 Uy (jt 4) ft 0.0029 UNIF 26.67 Uy (jt 5) ft 0.0024 UNIF 33.33 Uy (jt 6) ft -0.0017 UNIF 40 Uy (jt 7) ft -0.0118 UNIF
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference Percent Difference 0% 0% 0% SAP2000 Result SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places Number of Decimal Places 4 4 4 Result for Comparison Result for Comparison 0 0 0
Independent 0.0004 0.001 0.0021 0.003 0.0021 -0.0025 -0.0125 0.0004 0.001 0.0021 0.003 0.0021 -0.0025 -0.0125 0.0004 0.001 0.0021 0.003 0.0021 -0.0025 -0.0125
Percent Difference -3% -4% -2% -1% 2% -6% -6% -3% -4% -2% -1% 2% -6% -6% -3% -4% -2% -1% 2% -6% -6%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option - Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent Thick Plate Option - Twisting Moments at Support Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent SELF 0 Mxy (jt 1) lb-ft/ft 1 0 SELF 6.67 Mxy (jt 2) lb-ft/ft 362 370 SELF 13.33 Mxy (jt 3) lb-ft/ft 707 700 20 Mxy (jt 4) lb-ft/ft 1003 990 SELF 26.67 Mxy (jt 5) lb-ft/ft 1211 1210 SELF 33.33 Mxy (jt 6) lb-ft/ft 1273 1310 SELF 40 Mxy (jt 7) lb-ft/ft 1255 1280 SELF GRAV 0 Mxy (jt 1) lb-ft/ft 1 0 GRAV 6.67 Mxy (jt 2) lb-ft/ft 362 370 GRAV 13.33 Mxy (jt 3) lb-ft/ft 707 700 20 Mxy (jt 4) lb-ft/ft 1003 990 GRAV 26.67 Mxy (jt 5) lb-ft/ft 1211 1210 GRAV 33.33 Mxy (jt 6) lb-ft/ft 1273 1310 GRAV 40 Mxy (jt 7) lb-ft/ft 1255 1280 GRAV UNIF 0 Mxy (jt 1) lb-ft/ft 1 0 UNIF 6.67 Mxy (jt 2) lb-ft/ft 362 370 UNIF 13.33 Mxy (jt 3) lb-ft/ft 707 700 20 Mxy (jt 4) lb-ft/ft 1003 990 UNIF 26.67 Mxy (jt 5) lb-ft/ft 1211 1210 UNIF 33.33 Mxy (jt 6) lb-ft/ft 1273 1310 UNIF 40 Mxy (jt 7) lb-ft/ft 1255 1280 UNIF
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference Percent Difference 0% -1% 1% 1% 0% -3% -2% 0% -1% 1% 1% 0% -3% -2% 0% -1% 1% 1% 0% -3% -2% SAP2000 Result SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places Number of Decimal Places 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Result for Comparison Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option - Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent Thick Plate Option - Vertical Displacement at Central Section Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent SELF 0 Uz (jt 43) ft 0.046 0.048 SELF 6.67 Uz (jt 44) ft 0.031 0.028 SELF 13.33 Uz (jt 45) ft -0.013 -0.015 20 Uz (jt 46) ft -0.078 -0.08 SELF 26.67 Uz (jt 47) ft -0.155 -0.157 SELF 33.33 Uz (jt 48) ft -0.234 -0.24 SELF 40 Uz (jt 49) ft -0.307 -0.315 SELF GRAV 0 Uz (jt 43) ft 0.046 0.048 GRAV 6.67 Uz (jt 44) ft 0.031 0.028 GRAV 13.33 Uz (jt 45) ft -0.013 -0.015 20 Uz (jt 46) ft -0.078 -0.08 GRAV 26.67 Uz (jt 47) ft -0.155 -0.157 GRAV 33.33 Uz (jt 48) ft -0.234 -0.24 GRAV 40 Uz (jt 49) ft -0.307 -0.315 GRAV UNIF 0 Uz (jt 43) ft 0.046 0.048 UNIF 6.67 Uz (jt 44) ft 0.031 0.028 UNIF 13.33 Uz (jt 45) ft -0.013 -0.015 20 Uz (jt 46) ft -0.078 -0.08 UNIF 26.67 Uz (jt 47) ft -0.155 -0.157 UNIF 33.33 Uz (jt 48) ft -0.234 -0.24 UNIF 40 Uz (jt 49) ft -0.307 -0.315 UNIF
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference Percent Difference -1% 1% -1% -1% -1% -2% -3% -1% 1% -1% -1% -1% -2% -3% -1% 1% -1% -1% -1% -2% -3% SAP2000 Result SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places Number of Decimal Places 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Result for Comparison Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option - Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent Thick Plate Option - Transverse Moments at Central Section Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent SELF 0 My (jt 43) lb-ft/ft -2097 -2080 SELF 6.67 My (jt 44) lb-ft/ft -1976 -1980 SELF 13.33 My (jt 45) lb-ft/ft -1616 -1580 20 My (jt 46) lb-ft/ft -1056 -1000 SELF 26.67 My (jt 47) lb-ft/ft -427 -400 SELF 33.33 My (jt 48) lb-ft/ft 16 70 SELF 40 My (jt 49) lb-ft/ft 88 -40 SELF GRAV 0 My (jt 43) lb-ft/ft -2097 -2080 GRAV 6.67 My (jt 44) lb-ft/ft -1976 -1980 GRAV 13.33 My (jt 45) lb-ft/ft -1616 -1580 20 My (jt 46) lb-ft/ft -1056 -1000 GRAV 26.67 My (jt 47) lb-ft/ft -427 -400 GRAV 33.33 My (jt 48) lb-ft/ft 16 70 GRAV 40 My (jt 49) lb-ft/ft 88 -40 GRAV UNIF 0 My (jt 43) lb-ft/ft -2097 -2080 UNIF 6.67 My (jt 44) lb-ft/ft -1976 -1980 UNIF 13.33 My (jt 45) lb-ft/ft -1616 -1580 20 My (jt 46) lb-ft/ft -1056 -1000 UNIF 26.67 My (jt 47) lb-ft/ft -427 -400 UNIF 33.33 My (jt 48) lb-ft/ft 16 70 UNIF 40 My (jt 49) lb-ft/ft 88 -40 UNIF
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference Percent Difference 1% 0% 2% 3% 1% -3% 6% 1% 0% 2% 3% 1% -3% 6% 1% 0% 2% 3% 1% -3% 6% SAP2000 Result SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places Number of Decimal Places 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Result for Comparison Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option - Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent Thick Plate Option - Longitudinal Moments at Central Section Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Independent SELF 0 Mx (jt 43) lb-ft/ft -104 -100 SELF 6.67 Mx (jt 44) lb-ft/ft -67 -90 SELF 13.33 Mx (jt 45) lb-ft/ft 33 10 20 Mx (jt 46) lb-ft/ft 179 140 SELF 26.67 Mx (jt 47) lb-ft/ft 342 300 SELF 33.33 Mx (jt 48) lb-ft/ft 510 490 SELF 40 Mx (jt 49) lb-ft/ft 672 700 SELF GRAV 0 Mx (jt 43) lb-ft/ft -104 -100 GRAV 6.67 Mx (jt 44) lb-ft/ft -67 -90 GRAV 13.33 Mx (jt 45) lb-ft/ft 33 10 20 Mx (jt 46) lb-ft/ft 179 140 GRAV 26.67 Mx (jt 47) lb-ft/ft 342 300 GRAV 33.33 Mx (jt 48) lb-ft/ft 510 490 GRAV 40 Mx (jt 49) lb-ft/ft 672 700 GRAV UNIF 0 Mx (jt 43) lb-ft/ft -104 -100 UNIF 6.67 Mx (jt 44) lb-ft/ft -67 -90 UNIF 13.33 Mx (jt 45) lb-ft/ft 33 10 20 Mx (jt 46) lb-ft/ft 179 140 UNIF 26.67 Mx (jt 47) lb-ft/ft 342 300 UNIF 33.33 Mx (jt 48) lb-ft/ft 510 490 UNIF 40 Mx (jt 49) lb-ft/ft 672 700 UNIF
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference Percent Difference 1% -3% 3% 6% 6% 3% -4% 1% -3% 3% 6% 6% 3% -4% 1% -3% 3% 6% 6% 3% -4% SAP2000 Result SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places Number of Decimal Places 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Result for Comparison Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 2-006
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 2-006
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 2-006
Example 2-006
Example 2-006
Example 2-006
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 2-006
Example 2-006
Example 2-006
Example 2-006
Example 2-007
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option Analysis Case Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent 1 Ux (jt 1) ft 0.0939 0.094 1 Uy (jt 9) ft -0.0939 -0.094 Thick Plate Option Analysis Case Output Parameter 1 Ux (jt 1) ft 1 Uy (jt 9) ft
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0% 0% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 4 4 Result for Comparison 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked
SAP2000 0.0927 -0.0927
Independent 0.094 -0.094
Percent Difference -1% -1%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 4 4
Result for Comparison 0 0
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked
Example 2-007
Example 2-008
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option Output Parameter Model and Mesh SAP2000 Independent A 10 x 10 0.01743 0.01723 Period Mode B 20 x 20 0.01737 0.01723 1 sec C 40 x 40 0.01735 0.01723 A 10 x 10 0.00717 0.00704 Period Mode B 20 x 20 0.0071 0.00704 2 sec C 40 x 40 0.00708 0.00704 A 10 x 10 0.00288 0.00281 Period Mode B 20 x 20 0.00284 0.00281 3 sec C 40 x 40 0.00283 0.00281 A 10 x 10 0.00228 0.00219 Period Mode B 20 x 20 0.00223 0.00219 4 sec C 40 x 40 0.00222 0.00219 A 10 x 10 0.002 0.00193 Period Mode B 20 x 20 0.00196 0.00193 5 sec C 40 x 40 0.00195 0.00193
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 1.2% 0.8% 0.7% 1.8% 0.9% 0.6% 2.5% 1.1% 0.7% 4.1% 1.8% 1.4% 3.6% 1.6% 1.0% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 2-008
Thick Plate Option Output Parameter Model and Mesh A 10 x 10 Period Mode B 20 x 20 1 sec C 40 x 40 A 10 x 10 Period Mode B 20 x 20 2 sec C 40 x 40 A 10 x 10 Period Mode B 20 x 20 3 sec C 40 x 40 A 10 x 10 Period Mode B 20 x 20 4 sec C 40 x 40 A 10 x 10 Period Mode B 20 x 20 5 sec C 40 x 40 Thick Plate Option Mode 1 2 3 4 5 Output Parameter Period sec Period sec Period sec Period sec Period sec
SAP2000 0.01746 0.0174 0.01739 0.00721 0.00714 0.00712 0.0029 0.00286 0.00285 0.0023 0.00225 0.00223 0.00202 0.00198 0.00197
Independent 0.01723 0.01723 0.01723 0.00704 0.00704 0.00704 0.00281 0.00281 0.00281 0.00219 0.00219 0.00219 0.00193 0.00193 0.00193
Percent Difference 1.3% 1.0% 0.9% 2.4% 1.4% 1.1% 3.2% 1.8% 1.4% 5.0% 2.7% 1.8% 4.7% 2.6% 2.1%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Percent SAP2000 Independent Difference 0.01735 0.01723 0.7% 0.00708 0.00704 0.6% 0.00283 0.00281 0.7% 0.00222 0.00219 1.4% 0.00195 0.00193 1.0%
SAP2000 Result
Example 2-008
Example 2-009
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option Model and Modulus Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent 3 Uz at center of plate A (k=30k/ft ) -0.9285 -0.9205 (in) B (k=800k/ft3) -0.1827 -0.1782 Thick Plate Option Analysis Case A (k=30k/ft3) B (k=800k/ft3) Output Parameter Uz at center of plate (in) SAP2000 -0.925 -0.1783 Independent -0.9205 -0.1782
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0.9% 2.5% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 4 4 Result for Comparison 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked
Percent Difference 0.5% 0.1%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 4 4
Result for Comparison 0 0
Example 2-009
Example 2-010
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option Output Parameter Model and Mesh SAP2000 Independent U1 (in) A 8 x 16 0.12175 0.12414 at any jt B 24 x 48 0.12387 0.12414 U3 (in) A 8 x 16 -0.12175 -0.12414 at top jt B 24 x 48 -0.12387 -0.12414 A 8 x 16 58.85 60 11 (k/in2) B 24 x 48 59.87 60 anywhere
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference -1.9% -0.2% -1.9% -0.2% -1.9% -0.2% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 5 5 5 5 2 2 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 2-010
Thick Plate Option Output Parameter Model and Mesh U1 (in) A 8 x 16 at any jt B 24 x 48 U3 (in) A 8 x 16 at top jt B 24 x 48 A 8 x 16 11 (k/in2) B 24 x 48 anywhere
SAP2000 0.12175 0.12387 -0.12175 -0.12387 58.85 59.87
Independent 0.12414 0.12414 -0.12414 -0.12414 60 60
Percent Difference -1.9% -0.2% -1.9% -0.2% -1.9% -0.2%
SAP2000 Result
Example 2-010
Example 2-011
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option Elevation Z (ft) Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent* Ux (jt 18) ft -0.276 -0.26 60 Ux (jt 17) ft -0.325 -0.31 45 Ux (jt 16) ft -0.366 -0.35 30 Ux (jt 15) ft -0.397 -0.39 15 Ux (jt 14) ft -0.416 -0.41 0 Ux (jt 13) ft -0.423 -0.42 -10 Ux (jt 12) ft -0.423 -0.43 -25 Ux (jt 11) ft -0.4 -0.41 -50 Ux (jt 10) ft -0.355 -0.37 -75 Ux (jt 9) ft -0.297 -0.31 -100 Ux (jt 8) ft -0.235 -0.25 -125 Ux (jt 7) ft -0.176 -0.18 -150 Ux (jt 6) ft -0.124 -0.13 -175 Ux (jt 5) ft -0.081 -0.08 -200 Ux (jt 4) ft -0.048 -0.05 -225 Ux (jt 3) ft -0.028 -0.02 -250 Ux (jt 2) ft -0.016 -0.01 -260 Ux (jt 1) ft 0 0 -270
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference** 4% 3% 4% 2% 1% 1% -2% -2% -3% -3% -3% -1% -1% 0% 0% 2% 1% 0% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
* Independent results are scaled (estimated) from Figure 13.10b on page 348 in Zienkiewicz 1977. Because the results in the figure are based on 1/100 of the loads used in this example, the independent results shown in the table are 100 times those scaled from the figure. ** Percent difference is calculated with respect to the maximum independent value, 0.43.
Example 2-011
Thick Plate Option Elevation Z (ft) Output Parameter Ux (jt 18) ft 60 Ux (jt 17) ft 45 Ux (jt 16) ft 30 Ux (jt 15) ft 15 Ux (jt 14) ft 0 Ux (jt 13) ft -10 -25 Ux (jt 12) ft -50 Ux (jt 11) ft -75 Ux (jt 10) ft -100 Ux (jt 9) ft -125 Ux (jt 8) ft -150 Ux (jt 7) ft -175 Ux (jt 6) ft -200 Ux (jt 5) ft -225 Ux (jt 4) ft -250 Ux (jt 3) ft -260 Ux (jt 2) ft -270 Ux (jt 1) ft
SAP2000 -0.274 -0.323 -0.365 -0.396 -0.416 -0.423 -0.424 -0.401 -0.356 -0.298 -0.236 -0.177 -0.124 -0.081 -0.049 -0.028 -0.015 0
Independent* -0.26 -0.31 -0.35 -0.39 -0.41 -0.42 -0.43 -0.41 -0.37 -0.31 -0.25 -0.18 -0.13 -0.08 -0.05 -0.02 -0.01 0
Percent Difference** 3% 3% 3% 1% 1% 1% -1% -2% -3% -3% -3% -1% -1% 0% 0% 2% 1% 0%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
* Independent results are scaled (estimated) from Figure 13.10b on page 348 in Zienkiewicz 1977. Because the results in the figure are based on 1/100 of the loads used in this example, the independent results shown in the table are 100 times those scaled from the figure. ** Percent difference is calculated with respect to the maximum independent value, 0.43.
Example 2-011
Example 2-012
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option Output Parameter Uz at outer edge A Thick Bending Deflection Plate in Uz at outer edge A Thin Plate Bending Deflection in B Thick Uz at outer edge Plate with Bending Deflection shear in stiffness modifiers Model SAP2000 -0.00522 Independent -0.00521 Percent Difference 0.2%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 5 Result for Comparison 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked
-0.00534
-0.00534
0.0%
Not Checked
-0.00521
-0.00521
0.0%
Not Checked
Example 2-012
Example 2-013
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option Output Parameter Ux (jt 8) in A Free Uy (jt 8) in Expansion xx (jt 8) lb/in2 yy (jt 8) lb/in2 Ux (jt 8) in B Uy (jt 8) in Restrained xx (jt 8) lb/in2 yy (jt 8) lb/in2 Thick Plate Option Output Parameter Ux (jt 8) in A Free Uy (jt 8) in Expansion xx (jt 8) lb/in2 yy (jt 8) lb/in2 Ux (jt 8) in B Uy (jt 8) in Restrained xx (jt 8) lb/in2 yy (jt 8) lb/in2 Model SAP2000 0.000132 0.000066 0 0 0 0 -733.33 -733.33 Independent 0.000132 0.000066 0 0 0 0 -733.33 -733.33 Percent Difference 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% Model SAP2000 0.000132 0.000066 0 0 0 0 -733.33 -733.33 Independent 0.000132 0.000066 0 0 0 0 -733.33 -733.33 Percent Difference 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 6 6 2 2 6 6 2 2 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 6 6 2 2 6 6 2 2
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 2-013
Example 2-014
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model A (9x16 Mesh) Plate Option Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Thin 0.01905 0.01931 Uz (inner edge) in Thin 0.00347 0.00352 R2 (inner edge) rad Thin -2.182 -2.181 M11 (outer edge) k-in/in Thin -4.016 -4.406 M22 inner edge) k-in/in Thick 0.01778 0.01931 Uz (inner edge) in Thick 0.00311 0.00352 R2 (inner edge) rad Thick -2.185 -2.181 M11 (outer edge) k-in/in Thick -4.478 -4.406 M22 inner edge) k-in/in Model B (28x32 Mesh that is tighter near center) Plate Option Output Parameter SAP2000 Thin 0.01922 Uz (inner edge) in Thin 0.00351 R2 (inner edge) rad Thin -2.181 M11 (outer edge) k-in/in Thin -4.385 M22 inner edge) k-in/in Thick 0.01902 Uz (inner edge) in Thick 0.00347 R2 (inner edge) rad Thick -2.181 M11 (outer edge) k-in/in Thick -4.454 M22 inner edge) k-in/in
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference -1% -1% 0% -9% -8% -12% 0% 2% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 5 5 3 3 5 5 3 3 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Independent 0.01931 0.00352 -2.181 -4.406 0.01931 0.00352 -2.181 -4.406
Percent Difference 0% 0% 0% 0% -2% -1% 0% 1%
SAP2000 Result
Example 2-014
Example 2-015
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option (8x16 Mesh) Output Percent Parameter Model SAP2000 Independent Difference Uz (center) -1.077 -1.069 0.7% A - Orthotropic in -1.077 -1.069 0.7% B - Isotropic* M11 (jt A) k-81.54 -80.71 1.0% A - Orthotropic in/in -81.54 -80.71 1.0% B - Isotropic* M22 (jt A) k-16.2 -16.14 0.4% A - Orthotropic in/in -16.19 -16.14 0.3% B - Isotropic* M11 (jt B) k-15.94 -16.14 -1.2% A - Orthotropic in/in -15.94 -16.14 -1.2% B - Isotropic* M22 (jt B) k-39.7 -40.35 -1.6% A - Orthotropic in/in -39.7 -40.35 -1.6% B - Isotropic* * Isotropic model uses area object stiffness modifiers to mimic orthotropic behavior Thick Plate Option (8x16 Mesh) Plate Percent Option Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference Uz (center) -1.074 -1.069 0.5% A - Orthotropic in -1.074 -1.069 0.5% B - Isotropic* M11 (jt A) k-89.9 -80.71 11.4% A - Orthotropic in/in -89.9 -80.71 11.4% B - Isotropic* M22 (jt A) k-16.11 -16.14 -0.2% A - Orthotropic in/in -16.11 -16.14 -0.2% B - Isotropic* M11 (jt B) k-14.12 -16.14 -12.5% A - Orthotropic in/in -14.11 -16.14 -12.6% B - Isotropic* M22 (jt B) k-43.28 -40.35 7.3% A - Orthotropic in/in -43.28 -40.35 7.3% B - Isotropic* * Isotropic model uses area object stiffness modifiers to mimic orthotropic behavior
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 3 3 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 3 3 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 2-015
Thick Plate Option (16x32 Mesh) Plate Percent Option Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference Uz (center) -1.07 -1.069 0.1% C - Orthotropic in -1.07 -1.069 0.1% D - Isotropic* M11 (jt A) k-83.66 -80.71 3.7% C - Orthotropic in/in -83.66 -80.71 3.7% D - Isotropic* M22 (jt A) k-16.35 -16.14 1.3% C - Orthotropic in/in -16.35 -16.14 1.3% D - Isotropic* M11 (jt B) k-15.95 -16.14 -1.2% C - Orthotropic in/in -15.95 -16.14 -1.2% D - Isotropic* M22 (jt B) k-41.66 -40.35 3.2% C - Orthotropic in/in -41.66 -40.35 3.2% D - Isotropic* * Isotropic model uses area object stiffness modifiers to mimic orthotropic behavior
SAP2000 Result
Example 2-015
Example 2-016
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option (1 inch plate thickness) Output Parameter Model and Mesh SAP2000 Independent 435 425 A - 16 x 16 cr k/in2 425 425 B - 64 x 64 1179 1165 A - 16 x 16 cr k/in2 1163 1165 B - 64 x 64 Thick Plate Option (1 inch plate thickness) Output Parameter Model and Mesh SAP2000 416 A - 16 x 16 2 cr k/in 408 B - 64 x 64 1121 A - 16 x 16 cr k/in2 1112 B - 64 x 64
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 2.4% 0.0% 1.2% -0.2% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 0 0 0 0 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Independent 425 425 1165 1165
Percent Difference -2.1% -4.0% -3.8% -4.5%
SAP2000 Result
Model C (0.01 inch plate thickness and 64x64 mesh) Output Parameter Shell Option SAP2000 Independent 0.0425 0.0425 Thin 2 cr k/in 0.0425 0.0425 Thick 0.1163 0.1165 Thin 2 cr k/in 0.1162 0.1165 Thick
Percent Difference 0.0% 0.0% -0.2% -0.3%
SAP2000 Result
Example 2-016
Example 2-017
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Shell Type Thin Thick Output Parameter Pcr kips Pcr kips SAP2000 127.22 127.22 Independent 127.91 127.91 Percent Difference -0.5% -0.5%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 2 2 0 0
Example 2-017
Example 2-018
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Shell Type Thin Thick Output Parameter Fz (jt 1) kips Fz (jt 1) kips SAP2000 98.303 98.303 Independent 98.299 98.299 Percent Difference 0.0% 0.0%
Example 2-018
Example 2-019
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option Model and Mesh Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Ux (jt 4) in 65.313 63.662 A Uz (jt 4) in -100.016 -100 1x4 My (jt 1) k-in -56.574 -56.549 Ux (jt 4) in 63.742 63.662 B Uz (jt 4) in -100.015 -100 1x16 My (jt 1) k-in -56.55 -56.549 Ux (jt 4) in 63.646 63.662 C Uz (jt 4) in -100.015 -100 1x64 My (jt 1) k-in -56.549 -56.549 Thick Plate Option Model A 1x4 B 1x16 C 1x64 Output Parameter Ux (jt 4) in Uz (jt 4) in My (jt 1) k-in Ux (jt 4) in Uz (jt 4) in My (jt 1) k-in Ux (jt 4) in Uz (jt 4) in My (jt 1) k-in SAP2000 65.312 -100.016 -56.574 63.742 -100.015 -56.55 63.646 -100.015 -56.549 Independent 63.662 -100 -56.549 63.662 -100 -56.549 63.662 -100 -56.549
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 2.6% 0.0% 0.0% 0.1% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
SAP2000 Result
Example 2-019
Example 2-020
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Thin Plate Option Model A - By Loads B - By Elements A - By Loads B - By Elements A - By Loads B - By Elements Thick Plate Option Model A - By Loads B - By Elements A - By Loads B - By Elements A - By Loads B - By Elements Output Parameter Uz (top center) in Uz (top center) in Avg. S11 (top center) ksi Avg. S11 (top center) ksi Avg. S11 (bot. center) ksi Avg. S11 (bot. center) ksi Percent SAP2000 Independent Difference 0.16485 0.16564 -0.5% 0.16117 0.16564 -2.7% 0.3707 0.3681 0.7% 0.3605 -1.1297 -1.1002 0.3681 -1.1163 -1.1163 -2.1% 1.2% -1.4% Output Parameter Uz (top center) in Uz (top center) in Avg. S11 (top center) ksi Avg. S11 (top center) ksi Avg. S11 (bot. center) ksi Avg. S11 (bot. center) ksi Percent SAP2000 Independent Difference 0.16485 0.16564 -0.5% 0.16117 0.16564 -2.7% 0.3707 0.3681 0.7% 0.3605 -1.1297 -1.1002 0.3681 -1.1163 -1.1163 -2.1% 1.2% -1.4%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 5 5 4 4 4 4 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0
SAP2000 Result
Example 2-020
Example 3-001
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples With Incompatible Bending Modes Percent Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference sxx lb/in2 1333 1333 0% syy lb/in2 1333 1333 0% sxy lb/in2 400 400 0% Without Incompatible Bending Modes Output Parameter sxx lb/in2 syy lb/in2 sxy lb/in2 SAP2000 1333 1333 400 Independent 1333 1333 400 Percent Difference 0% 0% 0%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 0 0 0 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
SAP2000 Result
Example 3-001
Example 3-002
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples With Incompatible Bending Modes Option Load Case Model and Output and Type Element Shape Parameter SAP2000 A - Rectangle 3.000E-05 Ux Load case 1 B - Trapezoid 3.000E-05 Average of Axial C - Parallelogram 3.000E-05 jts 7 and 14 Extension D - Triangle 2 3.000E-05 in E - Triangle 4 3.000E-05 A - Rectangle 0.1073 Load case 2 Uz B - Trapezoid 0.0238 In-plane Average of C - Parallelogram 0.0861 shear and jts 7 and 14 D - Triangle 2 0.0035 bending in E - Triangle 4 0.007 Ux A - Rectangle 9.000E-04 Load case 3 Average of B - Trapezoid 1.466E-04 In-plane C - Parallelogram absolute values 7.614E-04 moment at jts 7 and 14 2.820E-05 D - Triangle 2 in E - Triangle 4 5.850E-05 Without Incompatible Bending Modes Option Load Case Model and Output and Type Element Shape Parameter A - Rectangle Ux Load case 1 B - Trapezoid Average of Axial C - Parallelogram jts 7 and 14 Extension D - Triangle 2 in E - Triangle 4 A - Rectangle Load case 2 Uz B - Trapezoid In-plane Average of C - Parallelogram shear and jts 7 and 14 D - Triangle 2 bending in E - Triangle 4 Ux A - Rectangle Load case 3 Average of B - Trapezoid In-plane C - Parallelogram absolute values moment at jts 7 and 14 D - Triangle 2 in
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% -1% -78% -20% -97% -94% 0% -84% -15% -97% -94% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 8 8 8 8 8 4 4 4 4 4 7 7 7 7 7 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Independent 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04
SAP2000 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 0.0101 0.003 0.0038 0.0035 0.007 8.400E-05 2.060E-05 2.820E-05 2.820E-05
Independent 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04
Percent Difference 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% -91% -97% -96% -97% -94% -91% -98% -97% -97%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 8 8 8 8 8 4 4 4 4 4 7 7 7 7
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Load case 3 In-plane moment E - Triangle 4
Ux Average of absolute values at jts 7 and 14 in 5.850E-05
Example 3-002
9.000E-04
-94%
Example 3-002
Model F Results - Without Incompatible Bending Modes Option (240 x 4 mesh) Load Case Model and Output Percent and Type Element Shape Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference Ux Load case 1 Average of Axial 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 0% A - Rectangle jts 7 and 14 Extension in Load case 2 Uz In-plane Average of 0.1068 0.1081 -1% A - Rectangle shear and jts 7 and 14 bending in Ux Load case 3 Average of In-plane absolute values 8.958E-04 9.000E-04 0% A - Rectangle moment at jts 7 and 14 in
SAP2000 Result
Example 3-002
Model F Results - With Incompatible Bending Modes Option (12 x 1 mesh) Load Case Output and Type Incomp Modes? Parameter SAP2000 Independent Load case 2 Uz In-plane Average of Yes 0.1075 0.1081 shear and jts 7 and 14 bending in Ux Load case 3 Average of In-plane Yes absolute values 8.995E-04 9.000E-04 moment at jts 7 and 14 in
SAP2000 Result
0%
Model G Results- With Incompatible Bending Modes Option - (Trapezoidal-shaped elements with 60 x 2 mesh) Load Case Output Percent SAP2000 Number of and Type Incomp Modes? Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference Result Decimal Places Load case 2 Uz In-plane Average of Yes 0.1091 0.1081 1% 4 shear and jts 7 and 14 bending in Ux Load case 3 Average of In-plane Yes absolute values 8.998E-04 9.000E-04 0% 7 moment at jts 7 and 14 in
Example 3-002
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 3-002
Not Checked
Example 3-002
Not Checked
Not Checked
Example 3-002
Not Checked
Not Checked
Example 3-003
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model and Output Mesh Parameter SAP2000 Independent Model A 6x1 mesh 0.0854 0.0886
Model B 90x1 mesh
Uy Average of jts 7 and 14 in
0.0886
0.0886
0%
Not Checked
Example 3-003
Example 3-004
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Plane Strain Output Model, Poisson's Ratio Percent Parameter and Mesh SAP2000 Independent Difference 0.004539 0.004582 A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 -1% 0.004971 0.00504 B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 -1% Radial Displ 0.00499 0.00506 C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 -1% in 0.004992 0.005062 D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 -1% At inner face 0.005036 0.00504 E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 0% 0.00504 0.00504 F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 0% -0.818 -1 A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 -18% -0.816 -1 B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 -18% Radial Stress -0.816 -1 C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 -18% ksi -0.816 -1 D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 -18% At inner face -0.937 -1 E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 -6% -0.96 -1 F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 -4% 1.277 1.25 A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 2% 1.348 1.25 B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 8% Tangential Stress 1.352 1.25 C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 8% ksi 1.353 1.25 D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 8% At inner face 1.274 1.25 E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 2% 1.255 1.25 F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 0% A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 0.138 0.075 84% B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 0.26 0.123 111% Longitudinal C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 0.268 0.125 114% Stress ksi D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 0.268 0.125 114% At inner face E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 0.165 0.123 34% F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 0.144 0.123 17% Plane Stress Output Parameter Radial Displ in At inner face
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 6 6 6 6 6 6 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Model, Poisson's Ratio and Mesh A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1
SAP2000 0.00461 0.005168 0.005194 0.005197 0.005217
Percent Independent Difference 0.00465 -1% 0.00522 -1% 0.005247 -1% 0.00525 -1% 0.00522 0%
SAP2000 Result
Radial Displ in At inner face F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 0.00522 -0.819 -0.818 -0.818 -0.818 -0.938 -0.96 1.259 1.285 1.286 1.287 1.253 1.244
Example 3-004
Radial Stress ksi At inner face
Tangential Stress ksi At inner face
0.00522 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25
0% -18% -18% -18% -18% -6% -4% 1% 3% 3% 3% 0% 0%
6 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 3-004
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 3-004
Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 3-005
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Percent Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference szz psf At z = -20 feet -2126 -2126 0% Average for joint 43 in planes 29, 30, 37 and 38
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00
Not Checked
Example 3-005
Example 4-001
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples With Incompatible Bending Modes Option Output Parameter Vertical Location SAP2000 Independent z = 0 ft -0.0467 -0.0469 z = -5 ft -0.0374 -0.0376 Uz feet z = -10 ft -0.0284 -0.0286 At x = 0 feet z = -40 ft -0.0094 -0.0095 z = -80 ft -0.0047 -0.0048 z = 0 ft -4.993 -5 Vertical z = -5 ft -4.298 -4.553 stress z = -10 ft -3.285 -3.232 ksf z = -40 ft -0.433 -0.435 At x = 0 feet z = -80 ft -0.122 -0.115 Without Incompatible Bending Modes Option Output Parameter Vertical Location SAP2000 Independent z = 0 ft -0.0464 -0.0469 z = -5 ft -0.0371 -0.0376 Uz feet z = -10 ft -0.0282 -0.0286 At x = 0 feet z = -40 ft -0.0094 -0.0095 z = -80 ft -0.0047 -0.0048 z = 0 ft -5.26 -5 Vertical z = -5 ft -4.265 -4.553 stress z = -10 ft -3.127 -3.232 ksf z = -40 ft -0.436 -0.435 At x = 0 feet z = -80 ft -0.122 -0.115
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0% -1% -1% -1% -2% 0% -6% 2% 0% 6% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 4 4 4 4 4 3 3 3 3 3 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Percent Difference -1% -1% -1% -1% -2% 5% -6% -3% 0% 6%
SAP2000 Result
Example 4-001
Example 4-002
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples With Incompatible Bending Modes Option Output Model, Poisson's Ratio Percent Parameter and Mesh SAP2000 Independent Difference 0.004538 0.004582 A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 -1% 0.004971 0.00504 B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 -1% Radial Displ 0.004989 0.00506 C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 -1% in 0.004991 0.005062 D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 -1% At inner face 0.005035 0.00504 E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 0% 0.00504 0.00504 F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 0% -0.834 -1 A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 -17% -0.833 -1 B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 -17% Radial Stress -0.833 -1 C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 -17% ksi -0.833 -1 D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 -17% At inner face -0.954 -1 E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 -5% -0.994 -1 F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 -1% 1.293 1.25 A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 3% 1.364 1.25 B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 9% Tangential Stress 1.369 1.25 C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 10% ksi 1.369 1.25 D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 10% At inner face 1.291 1.25 E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 3% 1.256 1.25 F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 0% A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 0.138 0.075 84% B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 0.26 0.123 111% Longitudinal C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 0.267 0.125 114% Stress ksi D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 0.268 0.125 114% At inner face E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 0.165 0.123 34% F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 0.128 0.123 4%
Example 4-002
Example 4-003
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Percent Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference Radial displ, in At outer edge r 0.1204 0.12035 0% = 20 in Radial stress, psi At inner edge 45783 45891 0% r = 10 in
Not Checked
Example 4-003
Example 4-004
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Percent Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference szz psf At z = -20 feet -2126 -2126 0% Average for joint 25 in asolids 13, 14, 21 and 22
Not Checked
Example 4-004
Example 5-001
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples With Incompatible Bending Modes Output Parameter Component SAP2000 Independent sxx 2000 2000 Direct stress syy 2000 2000 lb/in2 sxy 2000 2000 txx 400 400 Shear stress tyy 400 400 lb/in2 txy 400 400 Ux 0.00089 0.00089 Jt 8 Displ Uy 0.00118 0.00118 in Uz 0.00116 0.00116 Without Incompatible Bending Modes Output Parameter Component SAP2000 sxx 2000 Direct stress syy 2000 lb/in2 sxy 2000 txx 400 Shear stress tyy 400 lb/in2 txy 400 Ux 0.00089 Jt 8 Displ Uy 0.00118 in Uz 0.00116
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 5 5 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Independent 2000 2000 2000 400 400 400 0.00089 0.00118 0.00116
Percent Difference 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
SAP2000 Result
Example 5-001
Example 5-002
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples With Incompatible Bending Modes Load Case Model and Output and Type Element Shape Mesh Parameter 6x1x1 A - Rectangle 30x1x1 Ux 30x4x8 Case 1 Average of 6x1x1 Px B - Trapezoid 30x1x1 joints 7, 14, 21 Axial and 28 30x4x8 Extension in 6x1x1 C - Parallelogram 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 A - Rectangle 30x1x1 Uz 30x4x8 Load case 2 Average of 6x1x1 In-plane B - Trapezoid 30x1x1 joints 7, 14, 21 shear and and 28 30x4x8 bending in 6x1x1 C - Parallelogram 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 A - Rectangle 30x1x1 Uy 30x4x8 Load case 3 Average of 6x1x1 Out-of-plane B - Trapezoid 30x1x1 joints 7, 14, 21 shear and and 28 30x4x8 bending in 6x1x1 C - Parallelogram 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 A - Rectangle 30x1x1 Uy 30x4x8 Average of 6x1x1 Load case 4 absolute values B - Trapezoid 30x1x1 Twist at joints 7, 14, 30x4x8 21 and 28 in
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference -2% -1% -1% -1% -1% -1% -1% -1% -1% -2% 0% -1% -95% -1% -1% -38% 0% -1% -3% 0% -1% -97% -6% -2% -47% -1% -1% -18% -15% -3% -50% -19% -3% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 5 5 5 5 5 5 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
SAP2000 2.926E-05 2.985E-05 2.984E-05 2.966E-05 2.985E-05 2.985E-05 2.965E-05 2.985E-05 2.985E-05 0.1057 0.1077 0.1073 0.0051 0.1071 0.1069 0.0673 0.1076 0.1072 0.4203 0.43 0.4286 0.0129 0.406 0.4246 0.2276 0.4257 0.428 0.0028 0.00289 0.00331 0.00172 0.00276 0.0033
Independent 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341
Load case 4 Twist C - Parallelogram 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8
Uy Average of absolute values at joints 7, 14, 21 and 28 in
Example 5-002
A - Rectangle Load case 5 In-plane moment
B - Trapezoid
C - Parallelogram
A - Rectangle Load case 6 Out-of-plane moment
B - Trapezoid
C - Parallelogram
0.00255 0.00288 0.00331 8.906E-04 8.981E-04 Ux 8.955E-04 Average of 3.240E-05 absolute values 8.930E-04 at joints 7, 14, 8.921E-04 21 and 28 6.369E-04 in 8.976E-04 8.952E-04 0.00177 0.00179 Ux 0.00179 Average of 0.00004 absolute values 0.00169 at joints 7, 14, 0.00177 21 and 28 0.00112 in 0.00178 0.00179
0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018
-25% -16% -3% -1% 0% 0% -96% -1% -1% -29% 0% -1% -2% -1% -1% -98% -6% -2% -38% -1% -1%
5 5 5 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 5-002
Without Incompatible Bending Modes Load Case Model and and Type Element Shape Mesh 6x1x1 A - Rectangle 30x1x1 30x4x8 Case 1 6x1x1 Px B - Trapezoid 30x1x1 Axial 30x4x8 Extension 6x1x1 C - Parallelogram 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 A - Rectangle 30x1x1 30x4x8 Load case 2 6x1x1 In-plane B - Trapezoid 30x1x1 shear and 30x4x8 bending 6x1x1 C - Parallelogram 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 A - Rectangle 30x1x1 30x4x8 Load case 3 6x1x1 Out-of-plane B - Trapezoid 30x1x1 shear and 30x4x8 bending 6x1x1 C - Parallelogram 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 A - Rectangle 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 Load case 4 B - Trapezoid 30x1x1 Twist 30x4x8 6x1x1 C - Parallelogram
SAP2000 2.914E-05 2.982E-05 Ux 2.995E-05 Average of 2.915E-05 joints 7, 14, 21 2.982E-05 and 28 2.995E-05 in 2.915E-05 2.982E-05 2.995E-05 0.01 0.0718 Uz 0.107 Average of 0.0028 joints 7, 14, 21 0.0452 and 28 0.1047 in 0.0034 0.0296 0.1016 0.0109 0.1558 Uy 0.4168 Average of 0.0045 joints 7, 14, 21 0.1345 and 28 0.4135 in 0.0062 0.1169 0.4084 0.0028 0.00289 Uy 0.00331 Average of 0.00159 absolute values 0.00183 at joints 7, 14, 0.00322 21 and 28 0.00108 in
Output Parameter
Independent 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 3.000E-05 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.1081 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.4321 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341 0.00341
Percent Difference -3% -1% 0% -3% -1% 0% -3% -1% 0% -91% -34% -1% -97% -58% -3% -97% -73% -6% -97% -64% -4% -99% -69% -4% -99% -73% -5% -18% -15% -3% -53% -46% -6% -68%
SAP2000 Result
Number of Decimal Places 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Load case 4 Twist C - Parallelogram 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8 6x1x1 30x1x1 30x4x8
Uy Average of absolute values at joints 7, 14, 21 and 28 in
Example 5-002
A - Rectangle Load case 5 In-plane moment
B - Trapezoid
C - Parallelogram
A - Rectangle Load case 6 Out-of-plane moment
B - Trapezoid
C - Parallelogram
0.0032 0.0031 8.370E-05 5.983E-04 Ux 8.913E-04 Average of 1.880E-05 absolute values 3.711E-04 at joints 7, 14, 8.713E-04 21 and 28 2.520E-05 in 2.199E-04 8.417E-04 0.00005 0.00065 Ux 0.00174 Average of 0.00002 absolute values 0.00056 at joints 7, 14, 0.00172 21 and 28 0.00002 in 0.00047 0.0017
0.00341 0.00341 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 9.000E-04 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018 0.0018
-6% -9% -91% -34% -1% -98% -59% -3% -97% -76% -6% -97% -64% -3% -99% -69% -4% -99% -74% -6%
5 5 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 5-002
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 5-002
Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 5-002
% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 5-002
Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 5-003
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Load Case and Model and Output Type Mesh Parameter SAP2000 Uy, in A - 6x1x1 0.0768 Load case IN Average of four B - 90x1x1 0.0885 In-plane corner joints at C - 90x4x8 0.0884 tip A - 6x1x1 Load case OUT Out-of-plane B - 90x1x1 C - 90x4x8 Uz, in Average of four corner joints at tip 0.4062 0.4773 0.4945
Independent 0.0886 0.0886 0.0886 0.5004 0.5004 0.5004
Percent Difference -13% 0% 0% -19% -5% -1%
Example 5-003
Example 5-004
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Load Case and Output Type Parameter SAP2000 Independent Uy, in Load case IN Average of all 0.005322 0.005429 In-plane joints at tip Uz, in Load case OUT Average of all 0.001719 0.001749 Out-of-plane joints at tip
-1.7%
Not Checked
Example 5-004
Example 5-005
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Uniform Load - 2"x2" Plate - With Incompatible Bending Modes Edge Output Support Mesh Model Parameter SAP2000 Independent Simple 4x4x1 A 0.00000173 0.00000406 Uz, in Simple 16x16x1 B 0.00000404 0.00000406 Center of Fixed 4x4x1 F 0.00000036 0.00000126 plate Fixed 16x16x1 G 0.00000125 0.00000126 Center Concentrated Load - 2"x2" Plate - With Incompatible Bending Modes Edge Output Support Mesh Model Parameter SAP2000 Independent Simple 4x4x1 A 0.00000492 0.00001160 Uz, in Simple 16x16x1 B 0.00001150 0.00001160 Center of Fixed 4x4x1 F 0.00000161 0.00000560 plate Fixed 16x16x1 G 0.00000551 0.00000560 Uniform Load - 2"x10" Plate - With Incompatible Bending Modes Edge Analysis Output Support Mesh Case Parameter SAP2000 Independent Simple 4x4x1 C 0.00000393 0.00001297 Simple 16x16x1 D 0.00001293 0.00001297 Uz, in Simple 16x64x1 E 0.00001295 0.00001297 Center of Fixed 4x4x1 H 0.00000072 0.00000260 plate Fixed 16x16x1 I 0.00000260 0.00000260 Fixed 16x64x1 J 0.00000259 0.00000260
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference -57% 0% -71% -1% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 8 8 8 8 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0
Percent Difference -58% -1% -71% -2%
SAP2000 Result
Percent Difference -70% 0% 0% -72% 0% 0%
SAP2000 Result
Center Concentrated Load - 2"x10" Plate - With Incompatible Bending Modes Edge Analysis Output Percent Support Mesh Case Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference Simple 4x4x1 C 0.00000239 0.00001695 -86% Simple 16x16x1 D 0.00001561 0.00001695 -8% Uz, in Simple 16x64x1 E 0.00001682 0.00001695 -1% Center of Fixed 4x4x1 H 0.00000060 0.00000725 -92% plate Fixed 16x16x1 I 0.00000612 0.00000725 -16% Fixed 16x64x1 J 0.00000711 0.00000725 -2%
SAP2000 Result
Example 5-005
Example 5-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Uz ft SELF N.A. -0.312 Average of joints GRAV N.A. -0.312 Axial Deformations at Support Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter Uy ft SELF 0 Average of joints 1 and 290 Uy ft SELF 20 Average of joints 9 and 298 SELF 40 Uy ft Average of joints 17 and 306 Uy ft Average of joints 1 and 290 Uy ft Average of joints 9 and 298 Uy ft Average of joints 17 and 306
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 1% 1% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 4 4 Result for Comparison 0 0
Independent -0.3086 -0.3086
SAP2000 0.0001
Independent 0.0004
SAP2000 Result
0.0027
0.003
-2%
-0.0126
-0.0125
1%
GRAV
0.0001
0.0004
-2%
GRAV
20
0.0027
0.003
-2%
GRAV
40
-0.0126
-0.0125
1%
Example 5-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Vertical Deflection at Center of Free Edge Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 Vertical Displacement at Central Section Analysis Output Case Angle Parameter SAP2000 SELF 0 Uz ft Average of joints 273 and 562 Uz ft Average of joints 281 and 570 Uz ft Average of joints 289 and 578 Uz ft Average of joints 273 and 562 Uz ft Average of joints 281 and 570 Uz ft Average of joints 289 and 578 0.031
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference Percent Difference -5% SAP2000 Result SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places Number of Decimal Places 3 Result for Comparison Result for Comparison 0
Independent
Independent 0.048
SELF
20
-0.091
-0.08
3%
SELF
40
-0.312
-0.315
-1%
GRAV
0.031
0.048
-5%
GRAV
20
-0.091
-0.08
3%
GRAV
40
-0.312
-0.315
-1%
Example 5-006
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Example 5-006
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Example 5-007
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Output Parameter Ux (Point A) ft Average of two joints at Point A Uy (Point A) ft Average of two joints at Point A Mesh 16x16x1 48x48x1 16x16x1 48x48x1 SAP2000 0.0701 0.093 -0.0701 -0.093 Independent 0.094 0.094 -0.094 -0.094 Percent Difference -25% -1% -25% -1%
Example 5-007
Example 5-008
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples With Incompatible Bending Modes Option Output Model, Poisson's Ratio Percent Parameter and Mesh SAP2000 Independent Difference 0.004539 0.004582 A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 -1% 0.004971 0.00504 B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 -1% Radial Displ 0.00499 0.00506 C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 -1% in 0.004992 0.005062 D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 -1% At inner face 0.005036 0.00504 E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 0% 0.005041 0.00504 F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 0% -0.834 -1 A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 -17% -0.833 -1 B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 -17% Radial Stress -0.833 -1 C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 -17% ksi -0.833 -1 D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 -17% At inner face -0.954 -1 E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 -5% -0.994 -1 F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 -1% 1.293 1.25 A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 3% 1.364 1.25 B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 9% Tangential Stress 1.369 1.25 C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 10% ksi 1.369 1.25 D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 10% At inner face 1.291 1.25 E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 3% 1.256 1.25 F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 0% A, v = 0.3, 5x1x1 0.138 0.075 84% B, v = 0.49, 5x1x1 0.26 0.123 111% Longitudinal C, v = 0.499, 5x1x1 0.268 0.125 114% Stress ksi D, v = 0.4999, 5x1x1 0.268 0.125 114% At inner face E, v = 0.49, 20x1x1 0.165 0.123 34% F, v = 0.49, 160x1x1 0.128 0.123 4%
Example 5-008
Example 5-009
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model A - By Loads B - By Elements A - By Loads B - By Elements A - By Loads B - By Elements Output Parameter Uz (top center) in Uz (top center) in Avg. S11 (top center) ksi Avg. S11 (top center) ksi Avg. S11 (bot. center) ksi Avg. S11 (bot. center) ksi SAP2000 Independent 0.16467 0.16564 0.16097 0.16564 0.3624 0.3681 0.352 -1.1227 -1.0931 0.3681 -1.1163 -1.1163 Percent Difference -0.6% -2.8% -1.5% -4.4% 0.6% -2.1%
Example 5-009
Example 5-010
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Buckling About Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Pcr kips X-axis 0.891 0.888 Y-axis Pcr kips 127.12 127.91
Percent Difference 0.3% -0.6%
Example 5-010
Example 5-011
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Percent Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference sxx lb/in2 -733.33 -733.33 0% Anywhere in plate syy lb/in2 -733.33 -733.33 0% Anywhere in plate
Example 5-011
Example 5-012
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Model, Mesh and Modulus Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent A 50x50x1 -0.8881 -0.9205 (k=30k/ft3) B 100x100x1 -0.9177 -0.9205 (k=30k/ft3) Uz at center of plate C (in) 50x50x1 -0.1576 -0.1782 (k=800k/ft3) D 100x100x1 -0.1759 -0.1782 3 (k=800k/ft )
-0.3%
Not Checked
-11.6%
Not Checked
-1.3%
Not Checked
Example 5-012
Example 5-013
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Percent Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference szz psf At z = -20 feet -2126 -2126 0% Average for joint 83 in solids 27, 28, 35 and 36
Not Checked
Example 5-013
Example 6-001
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Ramp rise time tr = seconds Output Parameter Analysis Case SAP2000 Independent MHISTA 0.34718 0.34718 Uz (jt 2) in DHISTA1 (dt=0.25 sec) 0.34209 0.34718 at t=1 sec DHISTA2 (dt=0.0025 sec) 0.34718 0.34718 MHISTA 2 2 Uz (jt 2) in DHISTA1 (dt=0.25 sec) 1.9979 2 at t=4 sec DHISTA2 (dt=0.0025 sec) 2 2 Ramp rise time tr = /2 seconds Output Parameter Analysis Case MHISTB Uz (jt 2) in DHISTB1 (dt=0.25 sec) at t=1 sec DHISTB2 (dt=0.0025 sec) MHISTB Uz (jt 2) in DHISTB1 (dt=0.25 sec) at t=4 sec DHISTB2 (dt=0.0025 sec)
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0.0% -1.5% 0.0% 0.0% -0.1% 0.0% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 5 5 5 4 4 4 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
SAP2000 0.69436 0.68419 0.69436 0.7403 0.72764 0.7403
Independent 0.69436 0.69436 0.69436 0.74031 0.74031 0.74031
Percent Difference 0.0% -1.5% 0.0% 0.0% -1.7% 0.0%
SAP2000 Result
Example 6-001
Example 6-002
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Output Parameter Analysis Case SAP2000 Independent Link force at NLSTAT1 -60 -60 last step (kip) NLSTAT2 -50 -50
Percent Difference 0.0% 0.0%
Example 6-002
Example 6-003
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Results for Model A (Gap Ke = 0 k/in) Output Parameter Analysis Case SAP2000 Independent Link force after NLMHIST1 -4.534 -4.534 full load is NLSTAT1 -4.534 -4.534 applied (kip) NLDHIST1 -4.534 -4.534 Link NLMHIST2 3.917 3.917 deformation NLSTAT2 3.917 3.917 after full load V NLSTAT3 3.917 3.917 is applied NLDHIST2 3.917 3.917 (inch) NLDHIST3 3.917 3.917 Results for Model B (Gap Ke = 200,000 k/in) Output Parameter Analysis Case SAP2000 Link force after NLMHIST1 -4.534 full load is NLSTAT1 -4.534 applied (kip) NLDHIST1 -4.534 Link NLMHIST2 3.917 deformation NLSTAT2 3.917 after full load V NLSTAT3 3.917 is applied NLDHIST2 3.917 (inch) NLDHIST3 3.917
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Independent -4.534 -4.534 -4.534 3.917 3.917 3.917 3.917 3.917
Percent Difference 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
SAP2000 Result
Example 6-003
Example 6-004
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Case Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent NLSTAT1 Uz displacement at jt 2 (in) 0.04918 0.04918 IterConvTol is Link axial force (kip) 45.886 45.886 1E-04 Frame axial force (kip) 45.886 45.886
Example 6-004
Example 6-005
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Results for Model A Analysis Output Parameter Case SAP2000 Independent NLMHIST1 -0.10488 -0.10488 Uz (jt 1) displ at t=0.50 sec (in) NLDHIST1 -0.10483 -0.10488 NLMHIST1 -0.88875 -0.88858 Uz (jt 1) displ at t=5.00 sec (in) NLDHIST1 -0.88835 -0.88858 Uz (jt 1) displ at t=11.00 sec NLMHIST1 0.99453 0.99497 (in) NLDHIST1 0.99454 0.99497 Max steady state deformation NLMHIST1 0.99971 1 (in) NLDHIST1 0.99965 1 Results for Model B Output Parameter Max steady state deformation at freq = 1.5915 sec (in) Analysis Case SS1 SAP2000 1 Independent 1
Results From Current Analyses Percent Difference 0.00% -0.05% 0.02% -0.03% -0.04% -0.04% -0.03% -0.03% SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
SAP2000 Result
Example 6-005
Example 6-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Story Output Parameter Case Level SAP2000 Mode 1 Period, sec N.A. 0.438 MODAL Mode 2 Period, sec N.A. 0.135 Mode 3 Period, sec N.A. 0.074 Level 1 0.734 MHIST1 0.877 Level 2 0.538 Level 3 0.764 Level 1 NLMHIST1 0.879 Level 2 0.524 Level 3 Maximum Story Drift 0.764 Level 1 DHIST1 0.879 Level 2 0.524 Level 3 0.764 Level 1 NLDHIST1 0.879 Level 2 0.524 Level 3 -0.589 Level 1 MHIST1 -0.789 Level 2 -0.551 Level 3 -0.639 Level 1 NLMHIST1 -0.807 Level 2 -0.526 Level 3 Minimum Story Drift -0.638 Level 1 DHIST1 -0.806 Level 2 -0.526 Level 3 -0.638 Level 1 NLDHIST1 -0.806 Level 2 -0.526 Level 3
Independent 0.439 0.133 0.07 0.75 0.947 0.608 0.75 0.947 0.608 0.75 0.947 0.608 0.75 0.947 0.608 -0.615 -0.878 -0.629 -0.615 -0.878 -0.629 -0.615 -0.878 -0.629 -0.615 -0.878 -0.629
Percent Difference 0% 2% 6% -2% -7% -12% 2% -7% -14% 2% -7% -14% 2% -7% -14% -4% -10% -12% 4% -8% -16% 4% -8% -16% 4% -8% -16%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0
Example 6-006
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Story Output Parameter Case Level SAP2000 Analysis Story Output Parameter Case Level SAP2000 Level 1 0.256 MHIST1 0.204 Level 2 0.112 Level 3 0.291 Level 1 NLMHIST1 0.223 Level 2 Maximum Normalized 0.121 Level 3 Story Shear 0.276 Level 1 DHIST1 0.223 Level 2 0.121 Level 3 0.291 Level 1 NLDHIST1 0.223 Level 2 0.121 Level 3 -0.208 Level 1 MHIST1 -0.19 Level 2 -0.122 Level 3 -0.271 Level 1 NLMHIST1 -0.239 Level 2 Minimum Normalized -0.144 Level 3 Story Shear -0.234 Level 1 DHIST1 -0.238 Level 2 -0.143 Level 3 -0.271 Level 1 NLDHIST1 -0.239 Level 2 -0.144 Level 3
Independent Independent 0.324 0.248 0.136 0.324 0.248 0.136 0.324 0.248 0.136 0.324 0.248 0.136 -0.322 -0.28 -0.174 -0.322 -0.28 -0.174 -0.322 -0.28 -0.174 -0.322 -0.28 -0.174
Percent Difference Percent Difference -21% -18% -18% -10% -10% -11% -15% -10% -11% -10% -10% -11% -35% -32% -30% -16% -15% -17% -27% -15% -18% -16% -15% -17%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0
Example 6-006
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 6-006
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 6-007
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Story Output Parameter Case Level SAP2000 Mode 1 Period, sec N.A. 0.438 MODAL Mode 2 Period, sec N.A. 0.135 Mode 3 Period, sec N.A. 0.074 Level 1 0.542 NLMHIST1 0.589 Level 2 0.313 Level 3 Maximum Story Drift 0.543 Level 1 NLDHIST1 0.588 Level 2 0.312 Level 3 -0.61 Level 1 NLMHIST1 -0.719 Level 2 -0.424 Level 3 Minimum Story Drift -0.61 Level 1 NLDHIST1 -0.719 Level 2 -0.424 Level 3 Analysis Case NLMHIST1 Maximum Normalized Story Shear NLDHIST1 Story Level Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 1 Level 2 Level 3
Independent 0.439 0.133 0.07 0.526 0.631 0.323 0.526 0.631 0.323 -0.572 -0.746 -0.488 -0.572 -0.746 -0.488
Percent Difference 0% 2% 6% 3% -7% -3% 3% -7% -3% 7% -4% -13% 7% -4% -13% Percent Difference 5% 3% 3% 5% 3% 3% 0% 3% -2% 0% 3% -3%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 SAP2000 Result Number of Decimal Places 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Output Parameter
NLMHIST1 Minimum Normalized Story Shear NLDHIST1
SAP2000 0.302 0.223 0.119 0.302 0.222 0.119 -0.364 -0.294 -0.173 -0.364 -0.294 -0.172
Independent 0.287 0.216 0.115 0.287 0.216 0.115 -0.363 -0.285 -0.177 -0.363 -0.285 -0.177
Example 6-007
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 6-008
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Link Analysis Output Parameter Deformation Case SAP2000 0.20 in NLSTAT1 16.836 Link force at specified 43.915 0.80 in NLSTAT1 deformation for 141 9.60 in NLSTAT1 specified analysis case 105 9.60 in NLSTAT2 (kips) 48.438 8.60 in NLSTAT2 -141 -9.60 in NLSTAT2
Independent 16.836 43.915 141 105 48.438 -141
Percent Difference 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Example 6-008
Example 6-009
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Link Analysis Output Parameter Deformation Case SAP2000 1.2 in NLSTAT1 30 61 4.2 in NLSTAT1 Link force at specified 76 12 in NLSTAT1 deformation for 64 11.52 in NLSTAT2 specified analysis case 10 9.6 in NLSTAT2 (kips) -36 2.4 in NLSTAT2 -52.25 -12 in NLSTAT2
Independent 30 61 76 64 10 -36 -52.25
Percent Difference 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0
Example 6-009
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 6-010
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Dir and Analysis Output Parameter Max/Min Case SAP2000 NLMHIST1 3.521 Ux Max 3.418 NLDHIST1 -2.875 NLMHIST1 Level 8 displacement Ux Min -2.76 NLDHIST1 relative to isolation 2.642 NLMHIST1 system (in) Uy Max 2.695 NLDHIST1 -2.167 NLMHIST1 Uy Min -2.182 NLDHIST1 NLMHIST1 0.0008 Level 8 rotation relative Rz Max 0.00068 NLDHIST1 to isolation system NLMHIST1 -0.00077 (rad) Rz Min NLDHIST1 -0.00073 1854 NLMHIST1 Fx Max Base shear in the X 1761 NLDHIST1 direction (kip) -2109 NLMHIST1 Fx Min -2051 NLDHIST1 NLMHIST1 65.76 Ux Max 67.82 NLDHIST1 -72.71 NLMHIST1 Ux Min Level 3 (jt 57) absolute -69.94 NLDHIST1 acceleration (in/sec2) 70.36 NLMHIST1 Uy Max 70.36 NLDHIST1 -58.35 NLMHIST1 Uy Min -56.99 NLDHIST1 NLMHIST1 48.66 Fx Max 47.14 NLDHIST1 -43.55 NLMHIST1 Fx Min Isolator 23 shear force -41.04 NLDHIST1 (kip) 36.65 NLMHIST1 Fy Max 35.31 NLDHIST1 -30.91 NLMHIST1 Fy Min -30.41 NLDHIST1
Independent 3.494 3.494 -2.804 -2.804 2.538 2.538 -2.029 -2.029 0.00075 0.00075 -0.00076 -0.00076 1818 1818 -2089 -2089 67.73 67.73 -71.47 -71.47 64.96 64.96 -57.78 -57.78 48.17 48.17 -42.68 -42.68 36.38 36.38 -30.54 -30.54
Percent Difference 1% -2% 3% -2% 4% 6% 7% 8% 7% -9% 1% -4% 2% -3% 1% -2% -3% 0% 2% -2% 8% 8% 1% -1% 1% -2% 2% -4% 1% -3% 1% 0%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 3 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 0
Example 6-010
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Dir and Analysis Output Parameter Max/Min Case SAP2000 NLMHIST1 7.935 Ux Max 7.611 NLDHIST1 -6.916 NLMHIST1 Ux Min Isolator 23 deformation -6.386 NLDHIST1 (in) 6.247 NLMHIST1 Uy Max 5.93 NLDHIST1 -4.419 NLMHIST1 Uy Min -4.303 NLDHIST1
Independent 7.845 7.845 -6.746 -6.746 6.15 6.15 -4.304 -4.304
Percent Difference 1% -3% 3% -5% 2% -4% 3% 0%
Example 6-010
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 6-010
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked 4.0 2.0 0 0 0
Example 6-011
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Output Parameter Model Case SAP2000 NLMHIST1A -2.02 -2.034 NLMHIST2A A -2.145 NLMHIST3A Minimum Level 1 -1.883 NLDHIST1A Displacement (in) -2.016 NLMHIST1B B -2.081 NLMHIST2B -1.988 NLDHIST1B NLMHIST1A 1.982 1.981 NLMHIST2A A 2 NLMHIST3A Maximum Level 1 1.899 NLDHIST1A Displacement (in) 1.996 NLMHIST1B B 2.021 NLMHIST2B 1.963 NLDHIST1B NLMHIST1A -0.25 -0.251 NLMHIST2A A -0.253 NLMHIST3A Minimum Base -0.23 NLDHIST1A Shear/Weight -0.26 NLMHIST1B B -0.263 NLMHIST2B -0.253 NLDHIST1B NLMHIST1A 0.253 0.258 NLMHIST2A A 0.269 NLMHIST3A Maximum Base 0.255 NLDHIST1A Shear/Weight 0.237 NLMHIST1B B 0.24 NLMHIST2B 0.235 NLDHIST1B
Independent -2.053 -2.053 -2.053 -2.053 -2.053 -2.053 -2.053 2.043 2.043 2.043 2.043 2.043 2.043 2.043 -0.245 -0.245 -0.245 -0.245 -0.245 -0.245 -0.245 0.248 0.248 0.248 0.248 0.248 0.248 0.248
Percent Difference -2% -1% 4% -8% -2% 1% -3% -3% -3% -2% -7% -2% -1% -4% 2% 2% 3% -6% 6% 7% 3% 2% 4% 8% 3% -4% -3% -5%
Example 6-011
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Output Parameter Model Case SAP2000 NLMHIST1A -1.799 -1.814 NLMHIST2A A Exterior Isolator (Joints -1.956 NLMHIST3A 1 and 33) Minimum -1.681 NLDHIST1A Deformation (in) -1.807 NLMHIST1B B -1.855 NLMHIST2B -1.772 NLDHIST1B NLMHIST1A 1.961 1.976 NLMHIST2A A Exterior Isolator (Joints 2.013 NLMHIST3A 1 and 33) Maximum 1.872 NLDHIST1A Deformation (in) 1.982 NLMHIST1B B 2.004 NLMHIST2B 1.947 NLDHIST1B NLMHIST1A -5.672 -5.724 NLMHIST2A A Exterior Isolator (Joints -5.939 NLMHIST3A 1 and 33) Minimum -5.238 NLDHIST1A Shear Force (kip) -5.671 NLMHIST1B B -5.834 NLMHIST2B -5.535 NLDHIST1B NLMHIST1A 0.911 0.904 NLMHIST2A A Exterior Isolator (Joints 3.29 NLMHIST3A 1 and 33) Maximum 1.046 NLDHIST1A Shear Force (kip) 0.933 NLMHIST1B B 0.919 NLMHIST2B 0.893 NLDHIST1B
Independent -1.686 -1.686 -1.686 -1.686 -1.686 -1.686 -1.686 1.909 1.909 1.909 1.909 1.909 1.909 1.909 -6.872 -6.872 -6.872 -6.872 -6.872 -6.872 -6.872 1.183 1.183 1.183 1.183 1.183 1.183 1.183
Percent Difference 7% 8% 16% 0% 7% 10% 5% 3% 4% 5% -2% 4% 5% 2% -17% -17% -14% -24% -17% -15% -19% -23% -24% 178% -12% -21% -22% -25%
Example 6-011
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Analysis Output Parameter Model Case SAP2000 NLMHIST1A -1.924 -1.94 NLMHIST2A A Interior Isolator (Joints -1.956 NLMHIST3A 2 and 34) Minimum -1.79 NLDHIST1A Deformation (in) -1.923 NLMHIST1B B -1.983 NLMHIST2B -1.892 NLDHIST1B NLMHIST1A 1.854 1.853 NLMHIST2A A Interior Isolator (Joints 1.873 NLMHIST3A 2 and 34) Maximum 1.77 NLDHIST1A Deformation (in) 1.871 NLMHIST1B B 1.896 NLMHIST2B 1.838 NLDHIST1B NLMHIST1A -3.493 -3.564 NLMHIST2A A Interior Isolator (Joints -3.802 NLMHIST3A 2 and 34) Minimum -3.292 NLDHIST1A Shear Force (kip) -3.586 NLMHIST1B B -3.504 NLMHIST2B -3.382 NLDHIST1B NLMHIST1A 3.909 3.973 NLMHIST2A A Interior Isolator (Joints 4.411 NLMHIST3A 2 and 34) Maximum 3.942 NLDHIST1A Shear Force (kip) 3.84 NLMHIST1B B 3.808 NLMHIST2B 3.745 NLDHIST1B
Independent -1.796 -1.796 -1.796 -1.796 -1.796 -1.796 -1.796 1.786 1.786 1.786 1.786 1.786 1.786 1.786 -3.498 -3.498 -3.498 -3.498 -3.498 -3.498 -3.498 3.346 3.346 3.346 3.346 3.346 3.346 3.346
Percent Difference 7% 8% 9% 0% 7% 10% 5% 4% 4% 5% -1% 5% 6% 3% 0% 2% 9% -6% 3% 0% -3% 17% 19% 32% 18% 15% 14% 12%
Example 6-011
Example 6-011
Example 6-011
Example 6-012
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Loading Frequency Link Deformation SAP2000 Independent U1 Real (in) 1.05947 1.05947 0.12 Hz U1 Imaginary (in) -0.00674 -0.00674 U1 Magnitude (in) 1.05949 1.05949 U1 Real (in) 0.78958 0.78958 0.39 Hz U1 Imaginary (in) -0.01216 -0.01216 U1 Magnitude (in) 0.78967 0.78967 U1 Real (in) 0.58213 0.58213 0.77 Hz U1 Imaginary (in) -0.01305 -0.01305 U1 Magnitude (in) 0.58227 0.58227
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result for Result Decimal Places Comparison 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0
Example 6-012
Example 7-001
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Output Percent Cable Load Case Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference DEADTEMP Ux (jt. 2) (ft) 4258491 4170000 2% C1 DEADTEMP Uz (jt. 2) (ft) -2555045 -2511000 2% DISP1 Ux (jt. 2) (ft) 504.1 504.0 0% C2 DISP1 Uz (jt. 2) (ft) -328.9 -328.8 0% DISP2 Ux (jt. 2) (ft) 22.15 22.15 0% C3 DISP2 Uz (jt. 2) (ft) 15.73 15.73 0% DISP3 Ux (jt. 2) (ft) 9.17 9.17 0% C4 DISP3 Uz (jt. 2) (ft) 19.24 19.24 0% DISP4 Ux (jt. 2) (ft) 3.06 3.06 0% C5 DISP4 Uz (jt. 2) (ft) 19.93 19.93 0% DISP5 Ux (jt. 2) (ft) 0.00 0.00 0% C6 DISP5 Uz (jt. 2) (ft) 20.02 20.02 0%
Results From Current Analyses SAP2000 Number of Result Decimal Places 0 0 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Example 7-001
Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked Not Checked
Example 7-002
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Load Output Percent Case Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference Comb1 Ux (jt. 2) (ft) -2.819 -2.819 0% Comb1 Uz (jt. 2) (ft) -18.457 -18.457 0%
Example 7-002
Example 7-003
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples Load Output Percent Case Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference Point Ux (jt. 1) (ft) -0.1328 -0.1328 0.0% Point Uy (jt. 1) (ft) -0.1328 -0.1328 0.0% Point Uz (jt. 1) (ft) -1.4745 -1.4764 -0.1%
Example 7-003

SAP2000 Verification 1400

Încărcat de

Informații document

Titlu original

Drepturi de autor

Formate disponibile

Partajați acest document

Partajați sau inserați document

Opțiuni de partajare

Vi se pare util acest document?

Este necorespunzător acest conținut?

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

SAP2000 Verification 1400

Încărcat de

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

Verification Control

SAP2000 Verification Problems

Filename: Solver: 32 Bit: Process:

94249720.xls.ms_office.xls Force Standard Default Default

Check This Problem No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No

Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Requires Staged Construction license

SAP2000 -22.62 -11.31 2.545

Independent -22.62 -11.31 2.545

Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%

Number of Decimal Places 2 2 3

Result for Comparison 0 0 0

SAP2000 -184.95 0.09087 0.4312 -0.14335 0.07987 0.03742 0.07634

Independent -184.95 0.09087 0.4312 -0.14335 0.07987 0.03742 0.07634

Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%

Number of Decimal Places 2 5 5 5 5 5 5

Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked

Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%

Percent Difference -0.88% -6.63% 0.00% -0.36% 0.00% 0.00%

Percent Difference 0.55%

% Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked

Percent Difference -0.01% -0.16% -0.76% 0.00% 0.01% 0.02%

Percent Difference 0.28% 0.02% 0.00%

Independent 0.589541 5.52696 16.5879

Percent Difference 0.0000% 0.0000% 0.0000%

Number of Decimal Places 6 5 4

Result for Comparison 0 0 0

Results From Current Analyses

Number of Decimal Places 0 4 4 0 4 4 0 4 4

Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

SAP2000 60 0.0185 -0.0008 80

Independent 60 0.0185 -0.0008 80

Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%

Number of Decimal Places 0 4 4 0

Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0

1.3847 -0.0411 20 1.3701 -0.0404

1.3847 -0.0411 20 1.3662 -0.0403

0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.29% 0.25%

Percent Difference 0.00%

Verification Control % Diff From Version 14.00 Not Checked

Results Published in the Current Verification Examples

Analysis Case MOVEINF MOVEINF MOVEMS MOVEMS

Percent Difference -0.1% 0.0% -0.1% 0.0%

SAP2000 1333 1333 400 1.111E-07 1.111E-07 3.330E-08

Independent 1333 1333 400 1.11E-07 1.11E-07 3.33E-08

Percent Difference 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%

Number of Decimal Places 0 0 0 10 10 10

Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0

Number of Decimal Places 8 8 8 8 8 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 5 5 5 5 5 7 7 7 7 7 5 5 5 5 5

Result for Comparison 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Number of Decimal Places 4

Result for Comparison 0

-1.9% 0.1061 0.1081 -1.9% 4 0

Load case 5 In-plane moment

Ux 8.886E-04 Average of absolute values at jts 13 and 26 8.886E-04 in

9.000E-04 -1.3% 9.000E-04 -1.3%

Number of Decimal Places 4

Result for Comparison 0

-0.9% 0.1071 0.1081 -0.9% 4 0

Load case 5 In-plane moment

Ux 8.825E-04 Average of absolute values at jts 7 and 14 8.825E-04 in