Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Emkay
Areva T&D
x
Equity Advisory
Result Update
Contents
Result Updates Jagran Prakashan
Shree Cement
Sun Pharma
Colgate-Palmolive
GSFC
IVRCL Infrastructure & Project
GNFC
Mahindra & Mahindra
Home
Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd.
Next
Result Update
Jagran Prakashan
Mixed bag, Maintain BUY
May 30, 2011
Reco
Previous Reco
Buy
Buy
CMP
Target Price
Rs120
Rs149
-3.6 / -1.5
-4%
5,476
Sensex
18,266
Price Performance
(%)
1M
3M
Absolute
(1)
(6)
13
Rel. to Nifty
6M 12M
Source: Bloomberg
Rs
20
140
14
130
120
110
-4
100
May-10
-10
Jul-10
Sep-10
Nov-10
Jan-11
Mid-Day rev. grew 7.6% yoy to Rs1.1bn for FY11. EBITDA &
Jagran Prakashan reported better than expected results on the top line front. Revenue
growth of 19.6% yoy to Rs2826mn, driven by strong ad revenue growth coupled with
improvement in circulation and better performance from other businesses (Event, Digital
and Outdoor). EBITDA was up 12.9% yoy to Rs714mn but EBITDA margin declined by
150bps to 25.3%. Higher newsprint cost and escalation in other expenditure (higher
opex in other businesses) led to low margins during Q4FY11. PAT growth of 15.7% yoy
to Rs 420mn (our estimate of Rs433mn) was partly aided by lower tax rate of 27.9%.
JPL has announced final dividend of Rs3.5.
Stock Details
Print Media
Sector
JAGP@IN
Bloomberg
633
Face Value(Rs)
316
148/104
52 Week H/L
Market Cap (Rs bn/USD mn)
38/840
104862
0.3
52.7
55.3
55.3
FII/NRI
10.6
11.0
10.4
Institutions
17.4
18.3
18.8
7.4
6.5
3.7
11.8
8.9
11.8
Public
Mar-11
Source: Bloomberg
Private Corp
Source: Capitaline
Ad revenue for the quarter stood at 1.9bn, up 19.7% yoy. It was better than our
expectations of 16% growth, led by improvement in yields . As JPL is consolidating its
position in all the markets, we expect it to post strong ad revenue for next financial also.
Retain BUY rating with revised target price Rs149 (earlier Rs155)
Given the cost escalations, we cut EPS est. by 3.6/1.5% for FY12E/13E. Maintain BUY
rating on the stock with revised target price of Rs149. At CMP of Rs120, stock trades at
15.3x /12.1x our EPS estimate for FY12E/13E.
Financial Snapshot
Y/E
Net
Mar
Sales
FY10
Rs Mn
PAT
EPS
EPS
ROE
(Core)
EBITDA
(%)
(Rs)
(Rs)
% chg
(%)
P/E
EBITDA
EV/
P/BV
9419
2823
30.0
1759
5.6
92.0
28.6
21.6
13.4
6.2
FY11P
12211
3568
29.2
2078
6.6
18.2
29.8
18.2
10.9
5.4
FY12E
13786
4082
29.6
2484
7.9
19.4
28.5
15.3
9.3
4.4
FY13E
15509
4988
32.2
3132
9.9
26.1
28.2
12.1
7.5
3.4
Jagran Prakashan
Result Update
Mid-Day Financials
Rs Mn
Mid-Day
FY10
FY11P
Revenue
989.9
1,065.2
EBITDA
193.0
145.8
EBITDA%
19.5
13.7
PAT
93.4
20.6
9.4
1.9
PAT%
Quarterly financials
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
YoY (%)
QoQ (%)
YTD11
YTD10
YoY (%)
Sales
2,363
2,698
2,769
2,860
2,826
19.6
(1.2)
11,153
9,418
18.4
Raw Material
675.8
755.7
801.2
863.4
911.1
34.8
5.5
3,331
2,736
21.8
as % of sales
28.6
28.0
28.9
30.2
32.2
29.9
29.0
319.5
347.4
353.7
363.2
365.5
1,430
1,212
13.5
12.9
12.8
12.7
12.9
12.8
12.9
735.0
693.4
705.3
736.2
835.5
2,970
2,648
31.1
25.7
25.5
25.7
29.6
26.6
28.1
Employee Cost
as % of sales
SG&A expenses
as % of sales
Total operating exp
14.4
13.7
0.6
13.5
17.9
12.2
1730.3
1796.5
1860.1
1962.9
2112.0
22.1
7.6
7731
6596
17.2
EBITDA
632.5
901.7
908.4
897.5
714.2
12.9
(20.4)
3,422
2,822
21.2
Depreciation
134.9
124.9
132.7
146.2
160.4
19.0
9.7
564.3
507.5
11.2
EBIT
497.7
776.8
775.7
751.3
553.7
11.3
(26.3)
2857
2315
23.5
Other Income
66.0
57.5
64.0
55.3
55.1
(16.5)
(0.4)
231.9
342.5
(32.3)
Interest
23.9
12.3
14.0
20.9
24.8
3.8
18.7
72.0
65.7
9.6
PBT
539.8
822.0
825.7
785.7
584.0
8.2
(25.7)
3017.4
2591.5
16.4
Tax
175.9
266.0
270.6
259.3
163.2
(7.2)
(37.1)
959.1
833.2
15.1
32.6
32.4
32.8
33.0
27.9
PAT
363.8
555.9
555.1
526.4
420.8
15.7
(20.1)
2058.3
1758.3
17.1
EPS
1.2
1.8
1.8
1.7
1.3
15.7
(20.1)
6.5
5.6
17.1
(bps)
(bps)
Margin %
EBIDTA
26.8
33.4
32.8
31.4
25.3
(150)
(611)
30.7
30.0
71
EBIT
21.1
28.8
28.0
26.3
19.6
(147)
(667)
25.6
24.6
104
EBT
22.8
30.5
29.8
27.5
20.7
(218)
(680)
27.1
27.5
(46)
PAT
15.4
20.6
20.0
18.4
14.9
(51)
(351)
18.5
18.7
(21)
ETR
32.6
32.4
32.8
33.0
27.9
(465)
(505)
31.8
32.2
(36)
FY12E
Old
Revenue
EBITDA
EBITDA Margin %
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
New
FY13E
% Change
Old
New
% Change
1,357.8
1378.6
1.5
1,524.6
1550.9
1.7
418.8
408.2
-2.5
507.4
498.8
-1.7
30.8
29.6
-123 bps
33.3
32.2
-112 bps
PAT
257.5
248.4
-3.6
318.0
313.2
-1.5
EPS
8.1
7.9
-3.6
10.1
9.9
-1.5
Jagran Prakashan
Result Update
Financials
Income statement
Balance Sheet
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
Net Sales
9,419
12,211
13,786
15,509
Growth (%)
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
602
633
633
633
14.4
29.6
12.9
12.5
5,551
6,333
8,077
10,469
Raw material
2,736
3,590
3,857
4,169
Net worth
6,153
6,966
8,709
11,101
Employee cost
1,212
1,727
1,875
1,987
Loan Funds
1,214
1,794
1,594
1,194
SG&A expenses
2,648
3,327
3,971
4,365
580
620
620
620
Total Liabilities
7,947
9,379
10,923
12,915
Gross Block
5,635
7,245
8,335
9,425
Less: Depreciation
1,945
2,555
3,200
3,901
3,690
4,690
5,135
5,524
6,596
8,643
9,704
10,520
EBITDA
2,823
3,568
4,082
4,988
80.1
26.4
14.4
22.2
Net block
Capital work in progress
Growth (%)
Depreciation
507
655
687
743
2,315
2,913
3,396
4,245
24.6
23.9
24.6
Other Income
343
256
329
66
91
72
72
EBIT
Interest expenses
Exceptional items
PBT
251
250
300
300
Investment
1,666
2,366
2,366
2,366
27.4
Current Assets
4,201
4,773
5,326
6,990
429
Inventories
533
567
617
665
1,812
2,122
2,410
2,943
25
880
479
561
1,249
2,592
3,054
3,652
4,602
717
1,376
1,459
1,754
Tax
833
976
1,169
1,470
32.1
32.0
32.0
31.9
1,759
2,078
2,484
3,132
92.0
18.1
19.5
26.1
PAT
Growth (%)
Sundry debtors
Cash Flow
259
229
279
379
1,861
2,700
2,205
2,265
2,340
2,073
3,122
4,725
Total Assets
7,946
9,379
10,923
12,915
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
30.0
29.2
29.6
32.2
Net Margin
16.7
16.2
16.7
18.6
Ratios
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
PBT
2,250
2,800
3,324
4,173
507
655
687
743
66
91
72
72
Depreciation
Interest
Other Non-Cash items
Y/E, Mar
Profitability (%)
59
38
ROCE
31.4
33.3
33.0
34.5
-311
-134
-966
-915
ROE
28.6
29.8
28.5
28.2
Tax paid
-833
-976
-1,169
-1,470
RoIC
48.3
51.0
48.6
50.9
5.6
6.6
7.9
9.9
Operating Cashflow
Capital expenditure
Free Cash Flow
1,738
2,473
1,947
2,603
-459
-1,654
-1,182
-1,132
1,280
819
765
1,471
CEPS
7.2
8.6
10.0
12.3
Other income
343
256
329
429
BVPS
19.5
22.0
27.5
35.1
Investments
-98
-700
3.3
3.5
2.0
2.0
-214
-2,098
-853
-703
30
PER
21.6
18.2
15.3
12.1
-201
580
-200
-400
P/CEPS
-66
-91
-72
-72
-1,233
-1,295
-740
-740
Financing Cashflow
-1,500
-776
-1,012
-1,212
24
-401
82
688
856
880
479
561
880
479
561
1,249
Investing Cashflow
Equity Capital Raised
Loans Taken / (Repaid)
Interest Paid
DPS
Valuations (x)
16.7
13.9
12.0
9.8
P/BV
6.2
5.4
4.4
3.4
EV / Sales
4.0
3.2
2.8
2.4
13.4
10.9
9.3
7.5
2.8
2.9
1.7
1.7
0.1
0.2
0.1
0.0
-0.5
-0.3
-0.3
-2.2
EV / EBITDA
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
Jagran Prakashan
Result Update
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
28/02/2011
Buy
112
155
31/01/2011
Buy
120
155
01/11/2010
Buy
129
155
02/08/2010
Buy
121
155
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
Date
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
23/05/2011
Accumulate
2,126
2,535
19/05/2011
Hold
240
271
18/05/2011
Buy
156
183
13/05/2011
Buy
163
218
Result Update
Shree Cement
Operating level performance in line-Maintain ACCUMULATE
May 30, 2011
Reco
Previous Reco
Accumulate
Accumulate
CMP
Target Price
Rs1,836
Rs1,960
Nifty
18,232
Sensex
Price Performance
(%)
1M
3M
Absolute
(9)
6M 12M
(8)
(6)
Rel. to Nifty
(3)
(1)
(12)
n Change in FY12 EPS does not affect our target as its driven
Source: Bloomberg
Rs
10
2140
1980
-6
1820
-14
1660
-22
1500
May-10
-30
Jul-10
Sep-10
Nov-10
Jan-11
Mar-11
Shrees Q4FY11 EBITDA of Rs2.96bn grew 88% qoq (-17.1% yoy), in line with
estimates , with 744bps sequential improvement in EBIDTA margins at 27.7%.
Revenues of Rs10.7bn (+13.4% yoy) came in exactly in line, led by 6.8% revenue
growth in cement division (Rs9.5bn) and impressive 121% yoy growth in power
revenues (Rs1.19bn). Cement volumes grew 7.5% yoy (2.88mnt) while realizations
though stood flat yoy, improved 15.7% sequentially. Pure Grey Cement realizations at
Rs3432/t, improved 16.2% qoq.
Source: Bloomberg
Stock Details
Cement
Sector
SRCM@IN
Bloomberg
348
10
35
2,324/1,505
52 Week H/L
Market Cap (Rs bn/USD mn)
64/1,420
6574
0.3
64.8
64.8
64.8
FII/NRI
16.8
17.4
16.7
Institutions
6.1
6.4
7.0
Private Corp
8.3
7.5
7.3
Public
4.0
4.0
4.2
Source: Capitaline
Financial Snapshot
YE-
Net
Mar
Sales
(Core)
EBITDA
(%)
APAT
(Rs)
EPS
FY10
36,321
14,919
41.1
7,197
FY11P
35,118
8,857
25.2
1,506
FY12E
44,918
11,429
25.4
482
13.8
FY13E
53,713
13,842
25.8
6,109
175.4
RoE
% chg
(%)
206.6
24.5
47.3
43.2
-79.1
7.9
-68.0
2.4
1166.8
27.0
EV/
EV/
EBITDA
Tonne
8.9
4.4
126.7
42.5
7.6
103.2
132.6
5.6
90.9
10.5
3.8
61.8
P/E
Shree Cement
Result Update
Result Tables
Y/E, Mar (Rs. m)
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
YoY (%)
QoQ (%)
FY11P
FY10
YoY (%)
Net Sales
9,440
9,445
7,176
7,796
10,701
13.4
37.3
35,119
36,321
-3.3
Total Expenditure
31.9
24.5
26,262
20,992
25.1
75%
58%
3,723
3,238
11%
9%
-336
-197
5,871
6,550
5,749
6,221
7,742
as % of sales
62%
69%
80%
80%
72%
Consumption of RM
842
927
757
919
1,121
as % of sales
9%
10%
11%
12%
10%
Stock Adjustement
-29
-299
186
-49
-175
as % of sales
0%
-3%
3%
-1%
-2%
22
484
115
11
15
as % of sales
0%
5%
2%
0%
0%
408
478
491
479
537
4%
5%
7%
6%
5%
1,779
2,274
1,762
2,068
3,020
19%
24%
25%
27%
28%
Employee Cost
as % of sales
Power, Oil & Fuel
as % of sales
Freight expenses
2,043
1,783
1,639
2,016
2,313
as % of sales
22%
19%
23%
26%
22%
Other expenditure
807
903
799
777
912
as % of sales
9%
10%
11%
10%
9%
EBIDTA
3,569
2,895
1,427
1,575
2,959
Depreciation
33.1
22.0
506.3
258.4
-1%
-1%
-33.7
32.1
625
92
2%
0%
31.8
12.0
1,985
1,495
6%
4%
9,123
6,105
26%
17%
7,751
7,404
22%
20%
2,856
69.8
13.2
46.0
14.7
13.0
17.4
3,390
10%
8%
-17.1
87.8
8,857
15,329
15.0
70.9
580.4
32.8
49.4
4.7
18.7
-42.2
2,898
1,517
1,360
1,373
2,993
3.3
118.0
6,758
5,704
18.5
EBIT
671
1,378
67
203
-33
-105.0
-116.5
2,099
9,625
-78.2
Other Income
212
287
429
319
209
-1.6
-34.5
1,243
1,161
7.0
Interest
321
420
311
504
519
61.7
3.1
1,753
818
114.3
PBT
562
1,244
185
18
-344
-161.2
-2017.7
1,588
9,968
-84.1
Total Tax
330
185
80
-222
-446
-235.0
101.0
-403
2,063
-119.5
Adjusted PAT
232
1,059
106
240
102
-56.1
-57.5
1,991
7,904
-74.8
APAT after MI
232
1,059
106
240
102
-56.1
-57.5
1,991
7,904
-74.8
946
-35
-555
-158.7
1470.4
-106
1,143
-109.3
Reported PAT
-714
1,059
106
275
657
-192.1
139.1
2,097
6,761
-69.0
Reported EPS
6.7
30.4
3.0
6.9
2.9
-56.1
-57.5
43.2
221.2
-80.5
(bps)
(bps)
37.8%
30.6%
19.9%
20.2%
27.7%
-1,015
744
25.2%
42.2%
-1,698
EBIT
7.1%
14.6%
0.9%
2.6%
-0.3%
-742
-291
6.0%
26.5%
-2,052
EBT
6.0%
13.2%
2.6%
0.2%
-3.2%
-917
-344
4.5%
27.4%
-2,292
PAT
2.5%
11.2%
1.5%
3.1%
1.0%
-151
-212
5.7%
21.8%
-1,609
58.7%
14.9%
43.0%
-1236.6%
129.6%
7,093
136,626
-25.4%
20.7%
-4,606
Margins (%)
EBIDTA
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
Shree Cement
Result Update
Segmental Results
Segmental Results
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
Cement
8,900
8,138
6,860
7,461
9,505
Power
1,476
2,576
925
860
2,296
10,376
10,714
7,785
8,321
11,801
935
1,269
609
525
1,099
9,440
9,445
7,176
7,796
541
1,307
315
Cement
534
802
Power
-54
585
480
1,387
134
YoY (%)
QoQ (%)
FY11P
FY10
YoY (%)
6.8
27.4
31,965
34,552
-7.5
55.5
166.9
6,656
6,317
5.4
13.7
41.8
38,621
40,869
-5.5
17.5
109.5
3,502
4,547
-23.0
10,701
13.4
37.3
35,119
36,321
-3.3
335
1,196
121.3
256.9
3,154
1,770
78.2
422
882
175
-67.2
-80.2
2,281
6,286
-63.7
-288
-612
159
-394.1
-125.9
-156
3,065
-105.1
271
334
-30.5
23.3
2,125
9,351
-77.3
Revenue
EBIT
EBIT margin
Cement
Power
6.0%
9.9%
6.2%
11.8%
1.8%
-69.3
-84.4
7.1%
18.2%
-1,106
-3.7%
22.7%
-31.2%
-71.1%
6.9%
-289.1
-109.7
-2.3%
48.5%
-5,086
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
YoY (%)
QoQ (%)
FY11P
FY10
YoY (%)
2.68
2.49
2.28
2.62
2.88
7.5
10.1
10.26
10.26
0.0
Raw Material
314
373
332
351
389
23.8
10.8
363
316
15.0
Stocks
-11
-120
82
-19
-61
464.1
225.6
-33
-19
70.9
Employee
152
192
216
183
186
22.6
1.8
193
146
32.8
578
742
718
708
814
40.9
14.9
748
539
38.7
Freight expenses
762
717
719
770
803
5.3
4.2
755
722
4.7
132
149
149
153
173
30.6
12.7
157
129
21.3
630
568
570
617
630
0.0
2.1
598
592
1.0
Other exp
301
363
350
297
317
5.2
6.6
330
278
18.7
2,105
2,272
2,422
2,294
2,453
16.5
6.9
2,418
1,991
21.5
Realisation
3,321
3,274
3,010
2,851
3,300
-0.6
15.7
3,115
3,368
-7.5
EBIDTA
1,216
1,003
588
556
847
-30.4
52.1
697
1,377
-49.4
YoY (%)
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
YoY (%)
QoQ (%)
FY11P
FY10
Sales
541
825
210
335
1196
121.3
256.9
2566
1770
45.0
Realization
6.9
5.8
4.2
4.5
4.6
-33.1
2.2
4.9
6.7
-26.7
EBITDA
310
394
86
120
520
67.7
332.9
1120
1200
-6.6
EBITDA/unit
EBIDTA margin
4.0
2.8
1.7
1.6
2.0
-49.3
23.9
2.1
4.5
-52.8
57.3%
47.8%
40.8%
35.8%
43.5%
-1,387
763
43.7%
67.8%
-2,416
Source: Company
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
Shree Cement
Result Update
Upgrade FY12 EBITDA by 3.8%, but cut EPS estimates on account of revised
accelerated depreciation
On account of higher than expected FY11 exit cement prices, we upgrade our FY12
EBITDA estimates by 3.8% to Rs11.4bn. However, adjusting for revised accelerated
depreciation charges as guided by management, we cut our earnings estimates for FY12 by
85.4% to an EPS of Rs13.8 (Rs95 earlier). The accelerated depreciation in FY12 would
reduce the burden in FY13 with much lesser depreciation charges. We introduce our FY13
estimates with a EPS of Rs175. The change in earnings for FY12 does not affect our target
for Shree as earnings change in driven by higher deprecation (non cash charges ). We
continue to value Shree on 6X FY12E EV/EBITDA (currently 5.6X FY12). We maintain
ACCUMULATE rating on the stock with price target of Rs1,960.
Rs mn
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
FY12E
FY13E
Earlier
Revised
% change
Introduce
Sales
45248
44918
-0.7
53713
EBIDTA
3.8
13842
11014
11429
EBIDTA (%)
24.3
25.4
Net Profit
3314
482
-85.4
6109
EPS
95.1
13.8
-85.4
175.4
25.8
Shree Cement
Result Update
Financials
Income Statement
Balance Sheet
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
Net Sales
Growth (%)
36,321
34.0
35,118
(3.3)
44,918
27.9
53,713
19.6
348
17,984
348
19,552
348
19,505
348
25,085
Total Expenditure
21,504
26,261
33,489
39,872
Net worth
18,332
19,900
19,853
25,433
3,238
1,586
3,722
1,983
4,349
2,181
4,800
2,399
Minority Interest
Secured Loans
17,885
16,907
15,657
14,407
6,105
9,125
14,555
19,017
Unsecured Loans
Freight
5,889
6,000
6,882
7,575
Loan Funds
Net Deferred Taxes
Others
4,687
4,933
5,523
6,081
EBIDTA
Growth (%)
14,919
56.9
8,857
-40.6
11,429
29.1
13,842
21.1
EBIDTA %
41.1
25.2
25.4
25.8
Depreciation
3,177
3,177
3,177
3,177
21,062
20,084
18,834
17,584
124
723
723
723
Total Liabilities
39,270
39,261
37,965
42,295
Gross Block
29,509
42,072
54,072
54,072
21,989
29,232
39,231
44,746
7,520
12,840
14,841
9,326
5,902
7,243
9,999
5,515
9,016.6
1,613.9
1,430.6
8,326.3
24.8
1,284
4.6
1,243
3.2
1,243
15.5
1,243
Capital WIP
Investment
9,674
15,922
9,129
11,965
3,500
11,965
3,500
11,965
Interest
1,185
1,753
2,070
1,933
Current Assets
15,822
14,412
18,491
29,905
EBT
9,116
1,103
603
7,636
Inventories
3,581
4,042
5,170
6,183
Tax
1,918
(403)
121
1,527
Sundry Debtors
824
1,082
1,384
1,655
21.0
7,197
-36.5
1,506
20.0
482
20.0
6,109
4,164
7,140
4,631
4,431
7,281
4,431
17,411
4,431
Growth (%)
24.5
-79.1
-68.0
1,166.8
19.8
4.3
1.1
11.4
7,197
437
Reported PAT
6761
2097
Growth (%)
17.0
-69.0
EBIT
1,506
(591)
Net block
112.784
224.827
224.827
224.827
9,666
9,084
10,832
12,401
Current liabilities
4,667
6,264
8,012
9,581
6,109
0
Provisions
Net current assets
4,999
6,156
2,820
5,328
2,820
7,659
2,820
17,505
482
6109
Miscellaneous Exps
-77.0
1,166.8
482
0
Cash Flow
Total Assets
39,272
39,261
37,965
42,295
Key Ratios
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
9,313
5,704
-140
7,243
-640
9,999
6,393
5,515
Profitability (%)
EBITDA Margin
41.1
25.2
25.4
25.8
766
1,753
2,070
1,933
Net Margin
19.8
4.3
1.1
11.4
-1,286
-61
-9
1,295
0
318
0
285
ROCE
ROE
31.1
47.3
7.3
7.9
6.9
2.4
23.8
27.0
97.4
14.0
9.9
67.6
Interest Provided
Other Non-Cash items
Chg in working cap
Y/E, Mar
Tax paid
-1,897
403
-121
-1,527
RoIC
Operating Cashflow
12,540
10,545
11,627
12,600
-11,710
-12,018
-6,371
830
489
-1,472
1,243
5,256
1,243
12,600
1,243
-5,663
3,958
-16,885
5,200
1,243
1,243
5,729
-1,332
-978
-1,753
-1,250
-2,070
-1,250
-1,933
-611
-529
-529
-529
Capital expenditure
Free Cash Flow
Other income
Investments
Investing Cashflow
Equity Capital Raised
EPS
206.6
43.2
13.8
175.4
CEPS
BVPS
363.5
526.2
268.1
571.2
300.9
569.9
333.7
730.1
13.0
13.0
13.0
13.0
PER
8.9
42.5
132.6
10.5
P/CEPS
P/BV
5.1
3.5
6.8
3.2
6.1
3.2
5.5
2.5
EV / Sales
1.8
1.9
1.4
1.0
EV / EBITDA
4.4
7.6
5.6
3.8
DPS
Valuations (x)
0.7
0.7
0.7
0.7
Financing Cashflow
Net chg in cash
3,786
-559
-3,260
467
-3,849
2,649
-3,712
10,131
0.1
0.2
(0.0)
-0.5
4,723
4,164
4,631
7,281
Net Debt/EBIDTA
1.1
1.7
1.0
0.0
4,164
4,631
7,281
17,411
-3
-12
-12
-12
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
10
Shree Cement
Result Update
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
31/01/2011
Accumulate
1,660
1,960
11/11/2010
Accumulate
2,240
2,330
17/08/2010
Accumulate
1,805
2,200
24/05/2010
Accumulate
1,990
2,354
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
Date
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
27/05/2011
Accumulate
541
645
26/05/2011
Buy
65
75
25/05/2011
Accumulate
93
100
25/05/2011
Buy
152
255
11
Reco
Previous Reco
Hold
Hold
CMP
Target Price
Rs465
Rs497
- 3 / NA
Nifty
5,473
Sensex
18,232
(%)
1M
3M
Absolute
(0)
11
42
11
33
6M 12M
30
420
20
380
10
340
300
Jun-10
-10
Oct-10
Dec-10
40
460
Aug-10
Export formulations grew 98% YoY in Q4FY11 (contributed 52%) driven by Taro
consolidation. Taro revenues grew 21% YoY to US$108mn (contributed 33%). ExTaro, revenues de-grew by 28%
Source: Bloomberg
500
Price Performance
Rel. to Nifty
Jan-11
Domestic branded formulations grew 20% YoY (contributed 40%), ahead of the
industry growth rate in Q4FY11 on account of strong growth in the chronic portfolio
Operating margins at 30% expanded 280bps QoQ on account of
Apr-11
Source: Bloomberg
Stock Details
Sector
Pharmaceuticals
Bloomberg
SUNP@IN
1030
Face Value(Rs)
1030
52 Week H/L
511/325
148531
1.5
63.7
63.7
63.7
FII/NRI
18.5
19.1
19.1
Institutions
7.1
6.7
6.5
Private Corp
5.1
5.0
5.0
Public
5.6
5.5
5.6
Source: Capitaline
Valuation
We expect Sun Pharma to report 23% growth in revenues in FY12E and 15% growth in
FY13E. EBIDTA margins are expected to decrease from 34.4% in FY11 to 33.2% in
FY12E and 33.9% in FY13E. Earnings will grow by 15% CAGR over FY11-13E. We
revise our target price to Rs497 (22xFY13E core earnings of Rs22.6). At CMP, the stock
trades at 23x FY12E and 20x FY13E EPS.
Financials
YE-
Net
Rs mn
EBITDA
EPS
EPS
RoE
EV/
Mar
Sales
(Core)
(%)
APAT
(Rs)
% chg
(%)
P/E
EBITDA
P/BV
FY10
40,103
13,662
34.1
12,590
12.2
(30.7)
18.1
38.2
34.9
6.2
FY11
57,214
19,672
34.4
18,161
17.5
44.2
22.0
26.5
23.6
5.1
FY12E
70,282
23,303
33.2
20,694
20.0
14.0
21.1
23.3
19.9
4.3
FY13E
80,722
27,360
33.9
23,857
23.0
15.3
20.6
20.2
16.6
3.7
12
Result Update
Sun Pharma
Sun Pharma
Result Update
Quarterly break-up
Rs mn
Revenue
Expenditure
as % of sales
Consumption of RM
as % of sales
Employee Cost
as % of sales
Other expenditure
as % of sales
EBITDA
Depreciation
EBIT
Other Income
Non-recurring income
PBT
Total Tax
Adjusted PAT
Minority Interest
APAT after MI
Extra ordinary items
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY12
Q4FY12
YoY (%)
QoQ (%)
FY10
FY11
YoY (%)
11,092
13,997
13,701
16,011
14,633
31.9
(8.6)
40,103
57,214
43%
6,907
7,837
9,030
11,605
10,197
47.6
(12.1)
26,441
37,543
42%
65.9
65.6
17.7
(27.6)
10,977.3
14,606.9
27.4
25.5
119.0
(7.8)
4,007.9
7,995.6
10.0
14.0
62.3
56.0
65.9
72.5
69.7
2,662
3,357
3,794
4,324
3,132
33%
24.0
24.0
27.7
27.0
21.4
1,160
1,246
1,456
2,754
2,540
10.5
8.9
10.6
17.2
17.4
3,085
3,235
3,780
4,528
4,525
46.7
(0.1)
11,456.0
14,940.2
27.8
23.1
27.6
28.3
30.9
3.11
2.64
28.6
26.1
4,185
6,160
4,670
4,405
4,436
6.0
0.7
13,662
19,672
44%
419
402
352
805
482
14.9
(40.1)
1,533.1
2,040.6
33%
3,766
5,758
4,319
3,601
3,954
5.0
9.8
12,129
17,631
45%
138
115
924
580
1,108
705.6
90.9
1,686.2
2,727.2
62%
333.7
3,903
5,873
5,242
4,181
5,062
29.7
21.1
14,148
20,358
44%
(12)
97
172
545
22
(280.5)
(95.9)
678.6
1,284.4
89%
3,916
5,776
5,070
3,636
5,039
28.7
38.6
13,470
19,074
42%
(880.0)
(913.1)
12.2
26.4
12,590
18,161
44%
-29
133
33.7
134.4
612
3,945
5,643
5,037
3,502
4,427
99%
30%
921.0
0.0
Reported PAT
3,945
5,643
5,037
3,502
4,427
12.2
26.4
13,511
18,161
34%
Reported EPS
3.8
5.4
4.9
3.4
4.3
12.2
26.4
12.2
17.5
44%
(bps)
(bps)
Margins (%)
(bps)
EBIDTA
37.7
44.0
34.1
27.5
30.3
(741)
280
34.1
34.4
32
EBIT
33.9
41.1
31.5
22.5
27.0
(693)
453
30.2
30.8
57
EBT
35.2
42.0
38.3
26.1
34.6
(60)
848
35.3
35.6
30
PAT
35.6
40.3
36.8
21.9
30.3
(531)
839
31.4
31.7
35
(0.3)
1.7
3.3
13.0
0.4
76
(1,259)
4.8
6.3
151
Quarterly trend
44.0
18,000
15,000
37.7
34.1
40.3
12,000
35.6
36.8
30.3
27.5
9,000
30.3
6,000
21.9
3,000
11,092
13,997
13,701
16,011
14,633
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
EBITDA %
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
PAT %
13
Sun Pharma
Result Update
Financial Snapshot
Rs mn
FY12E
Sun Pharma
FY13E
Taro
Consol.
Sun Pharma
19,367
70,282
59,502
Taro
Consol.
21,220
80,722
Sales
50,915
EBITDA
19,236
4,067
23,303
22,479
4,881
27,360
EBITDA %
37.8%
21.0%
33.2%
37.8%
23.0%
33.9%
EBITDA % Ex -One-offs
37.8%
21.0%
33.2%
37.2%
23.0%
33.5%
PAT
17,402
3,292
20,694
19,825
4,032
23,857
EPS
16.8
3.2
20.0
19.1
3.9
23.0
Core EPS
16.8
3.2
20.0
18.7
3.9
22.6
Rs mn
FY11
FY12E
YoY %
FY13E
Formulations
51932
Domestic
23801
Taro
Ex-Taro
64070
23.4%
73406
14.6%
28087
18.0%
33278
18.5%
10,467
19,367
85.0%
21,220
9.6%
17664
16615
-5.9%
18908
13.8%
Base
10938
16615
51.9%
17929
7.9%
FTF
6726
979
API
5212
6119
17.4%
7221
18.0%
Domestic
1130
1220
8.0%
1342
10.0%
Exports
4082
4899
20.0%
5879
20.0%
Others
70
93
32.5%
95
2.0%
Total Sales
57214
70282
22.8%
80722
14.9%
EBITDA
19,672
23,303
18.5%
27,360
17.4%
34.4
33.2
EBITDA %
PAT
YoY %
33.9
18,161
20,694
14.0%
23,857
PAT %
31.7
29.4
29.6
EPS
17.5
20.0
14.0%
23.0
15.3%
PE @ CMP
26.5
23.3
20.2
Core EPS
14.1
20.0
41.5%
22.6
13.0%
PE @ CMP
32.9
23.3
20.6
15.3%
Valuation
Sun Pharma continues to remain a good long-term fundamental story in our view, however
stock valuations are likely to limit upside. We expect Sun Pharma to report 23% growth in
revenues in FY12E and 15% growth in FY13E. EBIDTA margins are expected to decrease
from 34.4% in FY11 to 33.2% in FY12E and 33.9% in FY13E. Earnings will grow by 15%
CAGR over FY11-13E. We revise our target price to Rs497 (22xFY13E core earnings of
Rs22.6). At CMP, the stock trades at 23x FY12E and 20x FY13E EPS.
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
14
Sun Pharma
Result Update
Financials
Income Statement
Balance Sheet
FY10
FY11
FY12E
FY13E
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
40,103
57,214
70,282
80,722
1,036
1,036
1,036
1,036
-4.2
42.7
22.8
14.9
77,254
93,987
110,859
130,309
26,441
10,977
37,543
14,607
46,979
18,642
53,362
22,602
Net worth
Minority Interest
78,289
1,932
95,023
8,472
111,894
9,561
131,344
10,816
SGA
9,146
11,869
15,040
16,411
Secured Loans
479
1,179
679
179
Employee Cost
4,008
7,996
9,115
10,027
Unsecured Loans
1,233
3,077
2,577
2,077
Loan Funds
Net Sales
Growth (%)
Expenditure
Raw Materials
Other Exp
2,311
3,071
4,182
4,322
EBITDA
Growth (%)
13,662
-26.8
19,672
44.0
23,303
18.5
27,360
17.4
34.1
1,533
34.4
2,041
33.2
2,557
33.9
2,871
12,129
17,631
20,746
24,489
30.2
1,686
30.8
2,727
29.5
2,932
30.3
2,807
FY13E
1,712
4,256
3,256
2,256
-890
81,042
-3,652
104,098
-3,652
121,059
-3,652
140,764
Gross Block
27,401
43,947
48,447
53,447
8,013
10,287
12,844
15,715
Net block
Capital work in progress
19,388
1,448
33,660
2,000
35,603
2,000
37,732
1,000
Investment
30,664
22,310
22,310
22,310
Current Assets
37,121
60,397
77,147
96,639
Less: Depreciation
PBT
14,148
20,358
23,678
27,296
Tax
679
1,284
1,894
2,184
Inventories
10,739
14,794
17,571
23,409
4.8
13,552
6.3
17,248
8.0
19,605
8.0
22,601
Sundry debtors
Cash & bank balance
11,748
6,073
11,716
22,162
23,193
22,197
29,060
28,599
15,570
962
-913
-1,089
-1,256
8,562
11,726
14,186
12,590
18,161
20,694
23,857
-30.7
44.2
14.0
15.3
7,579
14,269
16,000
16,916
31.4
334
31.7
0
29.4
0
29.6
0
Current liabilities
Provisions
4,095
3,484
9,203
5,065
10,366
5,635
11,108
5,808
Reported PAT
13,511
18,161
20,694
23,857
-25.7
34.4
14.0
15.3
Growth (%)
Cash Flow
29,542
46,129
61,146
79,722
Total Assets
81,042
104,098
121,059
140,764
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
Key Ratios
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
Y/E, Mar
12,462
17,631
20,746
24,489
Profitability (%)
1,533
2,041
2,557
2,871
EBITDA Margin
34.1
34.4
33.2
33.9
Net Margin
31.4
31.7
29.4
29.6
0
-4,675
0
-498
0
-14,982
0
-12,174
18
18
21
22
20
21
20
21
Tax paid
-1,106
-1,284
-1,894
-2,184
RoIC
29.9
33.6
29.7
28.7
8,214
17,889
6,426
13,002
-2,920
-13,205
-4,500
-4,000
EPS
12.2
17.5
20.0
23.0
5,295
1,686
4,685
2,727
1,926
2,932
9,002
2,807
CEPS
BVPS
13.3
75.6
19.5
91.8
22.5
108.0
25.8
126.8
3.2
4.6
5.1
5.2
Operating Cashflow
Capital expenditure
Free Cash Flow
Other income
Investments
-12,069
8,354
Investing Cashflow
-13,302
-2,123
-1,568
-1,193
ROCE
ROE
DPS
Valuations (x)
PER
38.2
26.5
23.3
20.2
-77
0
2,544
0
-1,000
0
-1,000
0
P/CEPS
P/BV
34.9
6.2
23.8
5.1
20.7
4.3
18.0
3.7
-3,321
-3,347
-3,823
-4,407
EV / Sales
11.9
8.1
6.6
5.6
Others
-2,131
1,126
EV / EBITDA
34.9
23.6
19.9
16.6
Financing Cashflow
-5,529
323
-4,823
-5,407
0.7
1.0
1.1
1.1
-10,618
16,690
16,089
6,073
35
22,162
6,402
22,197
-0.1
-0.2
-0.2
-0.2
6,073
22,162
22,197
28,599
Net Debt/EBIDTA
-0.3
-0.8
-0.7
-0.9
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
15
Sun Pharma
Result Update
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
01/02/2011
Hold
441
460
10/11/2010
Hold
2,318
2,300
29/07/2010
Hold
1,775
1,866
08/09/2010
Hold
1,756
1,866
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
Date
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
26/05/2011
Accumulate
96
125
25/05/2011
Buy
301
409
20/05/2011
Buy
710
927
19/05/2011
Hold
181
185
16
Reco
Previous Reco
Hold
Hold
CMP
Target Price
Rs 896
NA
5,473
18,232
Sensex
Price Performance
(%)
1M
3M
Absolute
(0)
11
22
12
14
Rel. to Nifty
6M 12M
20
910
14
870
830
790
-4
750
Jun-10
-10
Aug-10
Oct-10
Source: Bloomberg
950
NA
Rs 826
Dec-10
Colgate-Palmolive (LHS)
Jan-11
While toothpaste continues to witness healthy growth, lower volumes in toothbrush have
restricted overall revenue growth to 12.6%, which is marginally below our expectations.
Although operational performance is not comparable YoY as 4QFY10 has accounted for
the consolidation of Professional Oral Care for the full year FY10, results indicate that
higher input costs have arrested margin expansion, despite lower A&P spends (13.8%
in 4QFY11 versus 16.1% in 4QFY10). While EBITDA margins at 21.5% and PBT growth
at 13% is below our expectations, lower-than-estimated tax provisioning has resulted
in a muted PAT growth to Rs 1.1bn, lower than our forecast of 6% decline.
Apr-11
Source: Bloomberg
Stock Details
Sector
Consumers
Bloomberg
CLGT@IN
136
Face Value(Rs)
136
Toothpastes continue to witness robust volume growth of 12% driven by healthy growth
in its flagship brands Colgate Dental Cream, MaxFresh, Active Salt, etc. Increasing
penetration of toothpastes (64.3%) and higher per capita consumption (127 gms/year)
are aiding healthy and sustainable growth in this segment. However, toothbrush
witnessed weak performance with volumes growing in single-digits for the quarter after
two consecutive quarters of 24% volume growth. This has resulted in moderation of
overall volume growth to 10% for the company in 4QFY11 against 12% for FY11.
996/732
122/2,707
37606
0.7
52 Week H/L
Promoters
51.0
51.0
51.0
FII/NRI
17.7
16.5
Institutions
7.2
7.0
7.8
Private Corp
1.4
2.8
3.3
21.4
21.5
21.5
Public
Source: Capitaline
Rs Mn
YE-
Net
EBITDA
EPS
EPS
RoE
Mar
Sales
(Core)
(%)
FY10
19,625
4,254
FY11E
22,206
4,507
FY12E
25,365
FY13E
28,479
EV/
APAT
(Rs)
% chg
(%)
P/E
EBITDA
P/BV
21.7
4,233
31.1
45.8
156.1
28.8
27.8
37.4
20.3
4,026
29.1
(6.4)
113.9
30.7
25.1
31.6
5,368
21.2
4,431
32.6
11.8
115.0
27.5
21.5
29.3
6,097
21.4
5,107
37.6
15.3
122.3
23.9
18.7
27.0
17
Result Update
Colgate-Palmolive
Colgate-Palmolive
Result Update
Quarterly Results
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
YoY (%)
QoQ (%)
FY11
FY10
YoY (%)
Net Sales
5,166
5,288
5,518
5,582
5,818
12.6
4.2
22,206
19,625
13.2
Expenditure
3,919
3,898
4,396
4,836
4,569
16.6
(5.5)
17,699
15,370
15.1
Material Cost
1,543
1,966
2,201
2,160
2,393
55.0
10.8
8,720
7,768
12.2
% of Sales
29.9
37.2
39.9
38.7
41.1
1,125 bps
243 bps
39.3
39.6
-32 bps
Employee Expenses
421
444
533
524
432
2.5
(17.6)
1,932
1,591
21.5
% of Sales
8.1
8.4
9.7
9.4
7.4
-73 bps
-196 bps
8.7
8.1
60 bps
834
694
789
1,206
804
(3.5)
(33.3)
3,493
2,994
16.7
16.1
13.1
14.3
21.6
13.8
-231 bps
-778 bps
15.7
15.3
47 bps
1,121
795
872
947
940
(16.1)
(0.7)
3,554
3,017
17.8
% of Sales
Other Expenses
% of Sales
Ebidta
Depreciation
EBIT
Other Income
Interest
21.7
15.0
15.8
17.0
16.2
-554 bps
-80 bps
16.0
15.4
63 bps
1,247
1,390
1,122
746
1,249
0.2
67.4
4,507
4,254
5.9
206
79
84
91
88
(57.3)
(3.4)
343
376
(8.8)
1,041
1,311
1,038
655
1,161
11.5
77.3
4,164
3,878
7.4
222
263
256
277
272
22.7
(1.7)
1,068
985
8.5
19
10.0
(76.8)
33
15
118.7
1,259
1,570
1,288
913
1,429
13.5
56.5
5,200
4,848
7.3
115
350
285
250
288
150.5
15.1
1,174
615
90.7
1,144
1,220
1,003
662
1,141
(0.3)
72.2
4,026
4,233
(4.9)
8.4
9.0
7.4
4.9
8.4
(0.3)
72.2
29.1
31.1
(6.4)
(bps)
(bps)
EBIDTA
24.1
26.3
20.3
13.4
21.5
-267
811
20.3
21.7
-138
EBIT
20.2
24.8
18.8
11.7
20.0
-20
823
18.8
19.8
-101
EBT
24.4
29.7
23.3
16.4
24.6
19
821
23.4
24.7
-129
PAT
22.1
23.1
18.2
11.9
19.6
-254
774
18.1
21.6
-344
9.1
22.3
22.1
27.4
20.2
1,103
-726
22.6
12.7
988
PBT
Tax
PAT
REPS
Margins (%)
(bps)
16
14
12
10
8
1QFY10
2QFY10
3QFY10
4QFY10
1QFY11
2QFY11
3QFY11
4QFY11
Source: Company
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
18
Colgate-Palmolive
Result Update
Financials
Income Statement
Balance Sheet
FY10
FY11
FY12E
FY13E
19625
22206
25365
28479
15.8
13.2
14.2
12.3
15370
8.3
17699
15.1
19997
13.0
Raw Materials
7768
8720
% Of Sales
39.6
39.3
Employee Cost
Net Sales
Growth
Expenses
Growth
FY10
FY11E
FY12E
FY13E
136
136
136
136
Reserves
3125
3722
4025
4370
22382
11.9
Networth
Secured Loans
3261
0
3858
0
4161
0
4506
0
9808
11047
Unsecured Loans
46
38.7
38.8
Loan Funds
46
1591
1932
2280
2509
Total Liabilities
3307
3859
4162
4507
% Of Sales
Manufacturing Expenses
8.1
644
8.7
755
9.0
840
8.8
917
Gross Block
5345
5470
5670
5918
% Of Sales
3.3
3.4
3.3
3.2
Less: Depreciation
2876
3281
3716
4165
1866
2187
2276
2522
Net Block
2469
2189
1955
1753
9.5
9.8
9.0
8.9
62
100
100
100
3502
17.8
4105
18.5
4793
18.9
5387
18.9
Investments
Current Assets
14
6097
14
7799
14
9224
14
10537
Ebidta
4254
4507
5368
6097
Inventories
1106
1201
1359
1520
Growth
54.4
5.9
19.1
13.6
Debtors
98
104
118
132
Ebidta%
21.7
20.3
21.2
21.4
Cash&Bank
3672
5275
6470
7551
Other Income
Interest
985
15
1068
33
1241
20
1465
20
Loans&Advances
Current Liabilities & Provisions
1222
5515
1219
6423
1277
7310
1334
8077
Depreciation
376
343
434
449
582
1377
1914
2460
PBT
4848
5200
6154
7094
Miscellaneous Expenditure
Tax
615
1174
1723
1986
Deferred Tax
179
179
179
179
4233
4026
4431
5107
Total Assets
3307
3859
4162
4507
Growth
43.4
-4.9
10.1
15.3
Net Margin%
21.6
18.1
17.5
17.9
E/O Item
Reported PAT
0
4233
0
4026
0
4431
0
5107
FY10
FY11E
FY12E
FY13E
FY10
FY11E
FY12E
FY13E
Pre-Tax Profit
Depreciation
4848
376
5285
406
6154
434
7094
449
Profitability %
Ebidta Mgn
21.7
20.3
21.2
21.4
Chg in W Cap
754
471
476
468
PAT Mgn
21.6
18.1
17.5
17.9
-767
-1141
-1621
-1919
ROCE
157.8
133.1
137.7
145.2
Admin Expenses
% Of Sales
Cash Flow
Key Ratios
Tax Paid
Operating CashFlow
5211
5020
5443
6091
ROE
156.1
111.3
110.5
117.8
-1121
4090
-163
4857
-200
5243
-248
5844
31.1
29.1
32.6
37.6
173
CEPS
33.9
32.1
35.8
40.9
BVPS
24.0
28.4
30.6
33.1
-1
-45
DVPS
20.0
22.0
26.0
30.0
-3336
39
-3334
126
-4048
0
-4763
0
Valuations
PER
28.8
30.7
27.5
23.9
964
1604
1195
1081
CPER
26.4
27.9
25.1
21.9
2511
3476
5079
6275
P/BV
37.4
31.6
29.3
27.0
3476
5079
6275
7356
Ev/Sales
6.0
5.2
4.5
4.0
27.8
2.2
25.1
2.5
21.5
2.9
18.7
3.3
1.8
20.6
1.7
19.6
1.7
19.6
1.7
19.5
-105.2
-131.6
-150.8
-163.2
1.4
0.0
0.0
0.0
Capex
Free Cash Flow
Investments
Equity Capital
Loans
Dividend
Others
Net Change in Cash
Ev/Ebidta
Dividend Yield
Turnover X Days
Debtor TO
Inventory TO
Gearing Ratio
Net Debt/Equity
Total Debt/Equity
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
19
Colgate-Palmolive
Result Update
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
07/04/2011
Hold
846
826
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
Date
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
11/05/2011
Accumulate
2,697
2,923
09/05/2011
Accumulate
284
312
02/05/2011
Accumulate
136
142
02/05/2011
Accumulate
394
420
20
Reco
Previous Reco
Buy
Buy
CMP
Target Price
Rs 356
Rs 530
11/NA
NA
5,473
Nifty
18,232
Sensex
Price Performance
(%)
1M
3M
Absolute
(4)
60
14
50
Rel. to Nifty
6M 12M
Source: Bloomberg
Rs
60
360
48
320
36
280
24
240
12
200
Jun-10
0
Aug-10
Oct-10
Dec-10
GSFC (LHS)
Jan-11
Apr-11
GSFCs Q4FY11 results were in line with our estimates. Adjusted revenues of Rs 11.1bn
(adjusted for Rs 76.2mn of subsidy received related to 1997-98), +43% yoy, were in line
with our estimates of Rs 10.8bn. Adjusted EBITDA of Rs 3.1bn, +98% yoy, was
marginally higher than our estimates of Rs 2.9bn led by higher than expected fertilizer
margins. APAT of Rs 1.95bn, +52% yoy, was marginally higher than our estimates of Rs
1.76bn. AEPS for the quarter stood at Rs 24.5, +52% yoy, and was marginally higher
than our estimates of Rs 22.1.
Source: Bloomberg
Stock Details
Sector
Bloomberg
GSFC@IN
798
Face Value(Rs)
10
80
52 Week H/L
413/215
28/621
45481
0.4
We have revised our FY12E earnings estimates by 11% to Rs 73.6 (from Rs 66.3) due
to firm margins in chemicals segment in H1FY12E. Though chemical prices have
recently declined, they are still higher by ~30% yoy and spreads remain favourable. We
have also introduced FY13E estimates and expect company to post an EPS of Rs 78.8
with growth driven by higher fertiliser volumes.
37.8
FII/NRI
10.4
8.6
6.9
Institutions
26.2
26.8
28.2
9.9
10.9
10.8
15.7
15.9
16.3
Private Corp
Public
37.8
37.8
Source: Capitaline
Net
Sales
Rs Mn
EBITDA
(Core)
EPS
EPS
RoE
(%)
PAT
(Rs)
% chg
(%)
P/E
EBITDA
EV/
P/BV
FY10
40,192
4,477
11.1
2,545
31.9
(49.0)
12.5
11.1
6.8
1.3
FY11
47,095
11,259
23.9
7,131
89.5
180.2
28.6
4.0
1.9
1.0
FY12E
57,925
9,671
16.7
5,863
73.6
(17.8)
18.9
4.8
1.8
0.8
FY13E
61,577
10,478
17.0
6,277
78.8
7.1
17.2
4.5
1.3
0.7
21
Result Update
GSFC
GSFC
Result Update
Quarterly Results
Rs mn
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
YoY (%)
QoQ (%)
FY11
FY10
YoY (%)
Revenue
7,825
10,668
13,007
12,272
11,149
42.5
(9.2)
47,095
40,192
17.2
Expenditure
6261
8831
9834
9115
8055
28.7
(11.6)
35836
34796
3.0
76.1
86.6
21.6
(18.1)
25,827
25,422
54.8
63.3
18.5
1.1
3,207
3,019
6.8
7.5
2,641
2,902
5.6
7.2
4,161
3,453
8.8
8.6
(2.0)
11,259
5,396
as % of sales
80.0
82.8
75.6
74.3
72.3
4,530
6,223
7,366
6,727
5,511
as % of sales
57.9
58.3
56.6
54.8
49.4
678
818
792
794
803
as % of sales
8.7
7.7
6.1
6.5
7.2
Employee Cost
853
625
772
675
569
as % of sales
10.9
5.9
5.9
5.5
5.1
Other expenditure
200
1,165
905
919
1,172
as % of sales
2.6
10.9
7.0
7.5
10.5
1,564
1,836
3,172
3,157
3,093
Consumption of RM
EBITDA
Depreciation
EBIT
Other Income
Interest
PBT
Total Tax
Adjusted PAT
(Profit)/loss from JV's/Ass/MI
(33.3)
486.3
97.7
(15.7)
27.6
1.6
6.2
(9.0)
20.5
108.7
352
343
358
374
388
10.2
3.7
1,464
1,409
3.9
1,212
1,493
2,814
2,783
2,705
123.2
(2.8)
9,795
3,987
145.7
365
146
438
130
229
(37.3)
76.3
943
1,130
(16.5)
56
41
41
25
32
(43.2)
28.2
138
306
(55.0)
1,521
1,598
3,212
2,888
2,902
90.8
0.5
10,600
4,811
120.4
233
512
1,142
981
948
306.2
(3.3)
3,583
1,346
166.1
1,288
1,086
2,070
2,021
1,954
51.7
(3.3)
7,131
3,464
105.9
51.7
(3.3)
7,131
3,464
363
-920
1,288
1,086
2,070
2,021
1,954
-920
265
97
Reported PAT
368
1,086
2,070
2,286
2,051
457.3
(10.3)
7,494
2,544
194.5
Reported EPS
4.6
13.6
26.0
28.7
25.7
457.3
(10.3)
94.0
31.9
194.5
(bps)
(bps)
EBIDTA
20.0
17.2
24.4
25.7
27.7
776
202
23.9
13.4
1,048
EBIT
15.5
14.0
21.6
22.7
24.3
877
159
20.8
9.9
1,088
EBT
14.8
13.6
21.3
22.5
24.0
920
151
20.5
9.2
1,135
PAT
16.5
10.2
15.9
16.5
17.5
107
106
15.1
8.6
652
15.3
32.0
35.6
34.0
32.7
1,732
(130)
33.8
28.0
581
APAT after MI
Extra ordinary items
Margins (%)
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
105.9
(bps)
22
GSFC
Result Update
Jan-11
Oct-10
Jul-10
Apr-10
Jan-10
Oct-09
Jul-09
Apr-09
Jan-09
500
FY11 achieved highest ever profit of Rs 7.1 bn driven by all time high
chemical prices and strong margins in fertiliser
GSFCs revenues increased by 17% yoy to Rs 47 bn in FY11 backed by increasing
chemical prices . Chemicals segment revenues increased by 27% yoy while fertilizers
segment revenues increased by 13% yoy. Adjusted EBITDA for the year grew by 109% yoy
to Rs 11.3bn led by improvement in margins in both the chemicals & fertilizers segment.
Fertiliser segment achieved revenues of 32 bn while segment reported EBIT of Rs 5.7 bn,
+200% yoy with EBIT margins of 17.7% as against 6.7% previous year. Sharp improvement
in fertiliser margins was on account of ammonia cost benefit since company meets its
requirement for ammonia captively in manufacturing of complex fertiliser.
Chemical segment revenues at Rs 14.6 bn was up by 27% yoy but the segment reported
EBIT of Rs 4.8bn, +116% yoy with EBIT margins of 33%. Margins in chemicals segment
was at all time high due to extraordinarily high caprolactam prices in H2FY11.
Consequently, adjusted PAT grew by 106% yoy to Rs 7bn and AEPS for the year stood at
Rs 89.4.
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
23
GSFC
Result Update
Revision in estimates
We have revised our estimates for FY12E to reflect high chemicals prices in H1FY12E.
Though chemical prices have recently declined, they are still higher by ~30% yoy and
spreads remain favorable. Consequently, we have revised our revenue estimates for
FY12E by 18% and our PAT estimates by 11%. We have also introduced FY13E estimates
and expect company to report EPS of Rs 78.8, +7% yoy.
FY12E
Rs mn
Old
Estimates
New
Estimates
49,220
57,925
8,928
18.1
PAT
EPS
Net sales
EBITDA
EBITDA %
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
FY13E
%
Change
Introducing
Estimates
%
yoy
17.7
61,577
6.3
9,671
8.3
10,478
8.4
16.7
-144 bps
17.0
32 bps
5,285
5,863
10.9
6,277
7.1
66.3
73.6
11.0
78.8
7.1
24
GSFC
Result Update
Key Financials
Income Statement
Balance Sheet
FY10
FY11
FY12E
FY13E
FY10
FY11E
FY12E
40,192
47,095
57,925
61,577
797
797
797
797
(31.7)
17.2
23.0
6.3
20,644
27,647
32,857
38,481
35,715
25,422
35,836
25,827
48,254
35,971
51,099
38,239
Net worth
Minority Interest
21,441
0
28,444
0
33,654
0
39,278
0
3,019
3,207
3,765
4,002
Secured Loans
1,748
798
798
798
Employee Cost
2,902
2,641
2,896
3,079
Unsecured Loans
5,128
3,128
3,128
3,128
Other Exp
4,372
4,161
5,621
5,778
Loan Funds
EBITDA
Growth (%)
4,477
(47.4)
11,259
151.5
9,671
(14.1)
10,478
8.4
11.1
23.9
16.7
17.0
Depreciation
1,409
1,464
1,780
EBIT
3,067
9,795
7,891
7.6
1,130
20.8
943
13.6
1,170
Net Sales
Growth (%)
Expenditure
Materials Consumed
Interest expenses
6,876
3,926
3,926
3,926
1,497
29,814
1,497
33,867
1,497
39,077
1,497
44,701
2,000
Gross Block
32,316
34,135
38,785
41,785
8,478
Less: Depreciation
21,501
22,965
24,745
26,745
13.8
1,250
Net block
Capital work in progress
10,815
1,819
11,170
4,650
14,040
3,000
15,040
3,000
306
138
310
360
PBT
3,891
10,600
8,751
9,368
Current Assets
Tax
1,346
3,469
2,888
3,092
34.6
2,545
32.7
7,131
33.0
5,863
33.0
6,277
Growth (%)
(49.0)
180.2
(17.8)
7.1
6.3
15.1
10.1
10.2
2,545
-
7,131
363
5,863
-
Reported PAT
2,545
7,494
PAT after MI
2,545
7,131
Growth (%)
(49.0)
180.2
FY13E
4,250
4,250
4,250
4,250
21,037
23,070
28,350
33,225
Inventories
6,111
5,648
8,728
9,279
Sundry debtors
Cash & bank balance
6,216
601
8,881
6,679
6,348
10,378
6,748
14,119
8,109
1,862
2,896
3,079
8,107
9,273
10,563
10,814
6,277
-
Current liabilities
Provisions
4,217
3,889
5,384
3,889
6,674
3,889
6,924
3,889
5,863
6,277
12,930
13,797
17,787
22,411
5,863
6,277
Misc. exp
(17.8)
7.1
29,814
33,867
39,077
44,701
FY10
FY11E
FY12E
FY13E
Cash Flow
Investments
Total Assets
Key Ratios
FY10
FY11E
FY12E
FY13E
2,761
9,657
7,581
8,118
Profitability (%)
Depreciation
1,409
1,464
1,780
2,000
EBITDA Margin
11.1
20.0
16.7
17.0
Interest Provided
Other Non-Cash items
306
(692)
138
392
310
(95)
360
(95)
Net Margin
ROCE
6.3
15.5
12.2
33.7
10.1
24.8
10.2
23.2
Y/E, Mar
(6,658)
5,211
(291)
(883)
ROE
12.5
28.6
18.9
17.2
Tax paid
-1,346
-3,631
-2,888
-3,092
RoIC
15.2
47.3
39.7
37.9
Operating Cashflow
-4,220
13,231
6,397
6,409
(1,472)
-5,692
(4,650)
8,581
(3,000)
3,397
(3,000)
3,409
EPS
CEPS
31.9
49.6
89.5
88.2
73.6
95.9
78.8
103.9
Other income
1,130
943
1,170
1,250
BVPS
269.0
356.9
422.3
492.8
Investments
1,811
4.5
7.0
7.0
7.0
Investing Cashflow
2,941
943
1,170
1,250
3,636
(2,950)
11.1
7.2
4.0
4.0
4.8
3.7
4.5
3.4
Interest Paid
(306)
(138)
(310)
(360)
P/BV
1.3
1.0
0.8
0.7
(359)
(359)
(558)
(558)
EV / Sales
0.8
0.5
0.3
0.2
EV / EBITDA
6.8
1.9
1.8
1.3
0
2,971
0
-3,446
0
-868
0
-918
1.3
2.0
2.0
2.0
220
6,078
3,699
3,741
0.1
-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
381
601
6,679
10,378
Net Debt/EBIDTA
0.5
-0.6
-1.1
-1.4
601
6,679
10,378
14,119
73.6
70.9
52.9
54.0
Capital expenditure
Free Cash Flow
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
DPS
Valuations (x)
PER
P/CEPS
25
GSFC
Result Update
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
21/02/2011
Buy
335
530
31/01/2011
Buy
327
530
16/12/2010
Buy
349
530
22/10/2010
Buy
370
530
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
Date
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
24/05/2011
Accumulate
352
400
12/05/2011
Buy
167
250
11/05/2011
Accumulate
81
86
02/05/2011
Buy
1,390
1,735
26
Reco
Previous Reco
Buy
Buy
CMP
Target Price
Rs70
Rs 93
-9 / 0
8
5,473
Nifty
18,232
Sensex
Price Performance
(%)
1M
3M
6M 12M
Absolute
(11)
(41) (55)
Rel. to Nifty
(6)
(37) (58)
Source: Bloomberg
Rs
10
With ~40% of the order backlog facing execution headwinds, IVRCLs revenue grew by just
8.7% with revenues of Rs20.5 bn, below our estimate of Rs21.7 bn. Key order/project
where IVRCL is facing execution issues are
172
-6
144
-22
116
-38
88
-54
Project
Execution Issues
-70
AP Irrigations works
60
Jun-10
Aug-10
Oct-10
Dec-10
IVRCL (LHS)
Jan-11
Apr-11
Source: Bloomberg
Stock Details
Sector
Construction
Bloomberg
IVRC@IN
534
Face Value(Rs)
267
52 Week H/L
194/60
19/422
1123152
2.0
9.5
9.5
9.5
51.2
57.9
58.2
5.6
5.3
8.6
Private Corp
18.8
15.6
12.1
Public
14.9
11.7
11.6
FII/NRI
Institutions
The above mentioned orders constitute ~ 40% of IVRCl Rs238 bn order backlog. Though
IVRCl Asset & Holdings (IVR AH) is about to set financial closure of the Sion-Panvel
project, Goa-Karnataka Project continues to face land acquisition issues. Further though
receivables from AP Govt have significantly come down over last 12 months, the
management is still adopting prudent strategy of not ramping up execution to full throttle in
these projects. Hence we believe execution is likely to remain muted over next 2-3
quarters.
Source: Capitaline
Though IVRCLs execution remained muted during the quarter, 4Q adjusted EBIDTA
(Adjusting for a one time write offs & provision of Rs390 mn on account of doubtful debts &
uncleared cost overruns related to Jharkhand Rural Electrification works) at Rs2.16 bn
(+11% yoy), came in line with estimates, with margins at 10.55% (+21 bps yoy) surprising
positively (vs expectations of 9.7%). IVRCL reported its best quarterly margin in the last 12
quarters, due to higher proportion of execution from the high margin Buildings and
Industrial segment. With in line 4Q EBIDTA, APAT at Rs907 mn (+6.5% yoy) also came in
line with our estimates. RPAT at Rs643 mn declined 24.6% yoy.
Financial Snapshot (consolidated)
YE-
Net
EBITDA
Rs Mn
EPS
EPS
RoE
% chg
(%)
EV/
Mar
Sales
(Core)
(%)
APAT
(Rs)
EBITDA
P/BV
FY10
54,923
5,313
9.7
2,067
7.7
-11.4
11.3
P/E
9.2
6.3
1.0
FY11E
56,174
4,805
8.6
1,579
5.9
-23.6
8.2
12.0
8.0
1.0
FY12E
65,376
6,047
9.2
1,891
7.1
19.8
9.1
10.0
6.4
0.9
FY13E
73,562
6,804
9.3
2,235
8.4
18.2
9.9
8.5
6.1
0.8
27
Result Update
Result Update
Quarterly Results
Rs mn
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11A
YoY (%)
QoQ (%)
FY11P
FY10
YoY (%)
Revenue
18870
11062
10502
14104
20516
8.7
45.5
56184
54524
3.0%
Expenditure
16920
10057
9797
12664
18351
8.5
44.9
50869
49341
3.1%
as % of sales
89.7
90.9
93.3
89.8
89.4
Consumption of RM
6847
3606
4095
5325
6907
0.9
29.7
19934
20147
-1.1%
as % of sales
36.3
32.6
39.0
37.8
33.7
Construction Expenses
3575
1901
1684
1894
4049
13.3
113.8
9529
10845
-12.1%
20.9
37.0
17432
15020
16.1%
2.6
21.6
2623
2026
29.5%
-31.7
46.5
1351
1303
3.7%
as % of sales
18.9
17.2
16.0
13.4
19.7
5159
3614
3033
4551
6234
as % of sales
27.3
32.7
28.9
32.3
30.4
Employee Cost
716
652
633
604
735
as % of sales
3.8
5.9
6.0
4.3
3.6
Other expenditure
624
283
352
291
426
as % of sales
3.3
2.6
3.3
2.1
2.1
1950
1005
706
1440
2165
11.0
50.3
5315
5183
2.5%
141
157
184
199
217
54.7
9.4
758
542
39.8%
1810
848
521
1241
1947
7.6
56.9
4557
4641
-1.8%
EBITDA
Depreciation
EBIT
Other Income
Interest
PBT
54
11
304
95
49
-8.6
-48.1
460
284
61.9%
525
453
480
592
656
24.9
10.9
2182
1641
33.0%
1338
406
345
744
1340
0.1
80.1
2836
3285
-13.7%
Total Tax
486
125
112
238
432
-11.0
81.9
908
1176
-22.8%
Adjusted PAT
852
281
233
506
908
6.5
79.3
1928
2109
-8.6%
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11A
% yoy
% qoq
220000.0
233750.0
233750.0
240000.0
242000.0
10.0
0.8
Order inflow
32626.8
11069.4
16754.7
16112.0
16465.7
-49.5
2.2
Revenue Booked
18876.8
11069.4
10504.7
14112.0
20565.7
8.9
45.7
233750.0
233750.0
240000.0
242000.0
237900.0
1.8
-1.7
Closing Orderbacklog
Source: Company. Emkay Research
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
28
Result Update
the subsidiary (IVR Asset) remains well funded to meet the capex obligations of FY12E.
Also the management is confident that dilution of minority stakes in BOT SPVs will take
care of any additional equity requirement post FY12E.
n IVRCL Asset & Holdings (IVR AH) is about to see financial closure of the Sion-Panvel
land required for the project in hand. Though NHAI is pursuing the matter with the Goa
Govt, it is not sure when the entire land acquisition will be completed.
n Though receivable from AP Govt have significantly come down (Rs0.75 bn) over last 12
months, the management is still adopting prudent strategy of not ramping up execution
full throttle in these projects. Hence we believe execution is likely to remain muted over
next 2-3 quarters.
n Turbulence in Middle East has significantly impacted execution on the Saudi Arabia
project, IVRCL first major overseas project. IVRCL has not submitted performance
guarantees for the project and hence the works have been impacted. The company
expects the work to see ramp up over next 2-3 quarter.
n Though IVRCL management remains confident of pick up in the pace of execution, its
has refrained from giving any revenue guidance for FY12. Management highlighted that
the company is re-working execution plans and will be able to give revenue guidance
over next 3-6 months. The management also remains confident of holding onto EBIDTA
margins of ~10%.
Sales
EBIDTA
EBIDTA (%)
Net Profit
EPS
FY12E
FY13E
Earlier
Revised
% change
Introduce
67710
65376
-3.4
73562
6263
6047
-3.4
6804
9.2
9.2
2071
1891
-8.7
2235
9.3
7.8
7.1
-8.7
8.4
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
29
Result Update
Valuation
Basis
Multiple (x)
Value
(Rsmn)
Construction business
FY12E, PE (x)
9.0x
17020
MCap
1866
MCap
5874
22
24760
93.0
Business
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
30
Result Update
Key Financials
Income Statement
Balance Sheet
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
Net Sales
Growth (%)
54923
10.3
56174
2.3
65376
16.4
73562
12.5
534
17999
534
19340
534
21094
534
23142
Expenditure
49610
51369
59329
Materials Consumed
Construction Exp
19151
27130
19975
27299
23993
30792
66758
Networth
18533
19874
21628
23676
26997
34648
Minority Interest
Secured Loans
Employee Cost
2026
2623
12688
17548
18548
19548
2975
3347
Unsecured Loans
3445
3410
3410
3410
Other Exp
1303
EBITDA
5313
1471
1569
1765
Loan Funds
16133
20958
21958
22958
4805
6047
6804
125
86
86
Growth (%)
86
26.0
-9.6
25.8
12.5
Total Liabilities
34791
40918
43672
46720
EBITDA %
Depreciation
9.7
543
8.6
758
9.2
910
9.3
995
Gross Block
7502
9702
10702
11702
EBIT
4770
4047
5138
5810
Less: Depreciation
1838
2662
3572
4567
8.7
155
1681
7.2
460
2182
7.9
327
2642
7.9
368
2842
Net block
5664
7039
7130
7135
353
6138
139
6347
139
6138
139
6139
PBT
3244
2326
2823
3335
Current Assets
47005
54523
60594
66390
Total Tax
1177
747
931
1101
Inventories
10295
12428
13433
15317
36.3
32.1
33.0
33.0
Sundry debtors
19445
19298
23285
26200
2067
-11.4
1579
-23.6
1891
19.8
2234
18.1
1644
15618
1432
16201
2371
21494
676
24185
3.8
0
2.8
0
2.9
0
3.0
1
2067
1579
1891
E/O items
Reported PAT
44
2111
0
1579
0
1891
-6.6
-25.2
FY10
Pre-tax profit
Depreciation
Interest Provided
Adjusted PAT
Growth (%)
5165
11
12
24369
27130
30328
33083
2235
Current liabilities
23924
26728
30185
32937
0
2235
Provisions
Net current assets
445
22636
402
27393
143
30266
145
33307
19.8
18.2
Total Assets
34791
40918
43672
46720
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
3288
543
2326
758
2823
910
3336
995
Profitability (%)
EBITDA Margin
9.7
8.6
9.2
9.3
1448
2217
2642
2842
Net Margin
3.8
2.8
2.9
3.0
291
-2480
0
-4876
0
-1674
1
-4739
ROCE
ROE
14.7
11.3
11.9
8.2
12.9
9.1
13.7
9.9
Tax paid
-1293
-785
-931
-1101
RoIC
17.7
13.6
15.1
15.5
1797
-361
3769
1334
-1196
-1000
-1000
-1000
601
155
-1361
460
2769
327
334
368
Growth (%)
Cash Flow
Key Ratios
7.7
5.9
7.1
8.4
10.9
69.4
8.8
74.4
10.5
81.0
12.1
88.7
PER
9.2
12.0
10.0
8.5
P/CEPS
P/BV
6.5
1.0
8.1
1.0
6.8
0.9
5.9
0.8
CEPS
BVPS
Investments
-1088
Investing Cashflow
-2284
-1000
-1000
-1000
2199
-1904
4825
-2217
1000
-2642
1000
-2842
-215
-250
-187
-187
EV / Sales
0.6
0.7
0.6
0.6
20
EV / EBITDA
6.3
8.0
6.4
6.1
1.4
1.4
1.4
2.8
101
600
2358
-212
-1829
940
-2030
-1696
0.8
1.0
0.9
0.9
945
1644
1432
2371
Net Debt/EBIDTA
1644
1432
2371
676
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
DPS
Valuations (x)
2.7
4.1
3.2
3.3
38.7
37.4
37.4
43.4
31
Result Update
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
15/02/2011
Buy
72
101
15/11/2010
Hold
139
160
10/08/2010
Hold
170
185
31/05/2010
Buy
156
199
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
Date
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
30/05/2011
Accumulate
1,836
1,960
27/05/2011
Accumulate
541
645
26/05/2011
Buy
65
75
25/05/2011
Accumulate
93
100
32
Reco
Previous Reco
Buy
Buy
CMP
Target Price
Rs 103
Rs 157
NA
NA
5,473
Nifty
18,232
Sensex
(%)
1M
3M
Absolute
(4)
(17)
(1)
(11)
(8)
6M 12M
20
136
10
122
108
-10
94
-20
80
Jun-10
Source: Bloomberg
150
Price Performance
Rel. to Nifty
GNFCs Q4FY11 results were below our estimates due to lower than expected margins .
Revenues of Rs 8.4bn, +66% yoy, were marginally ahead of our estimates of Rs 8.1bn
driven by higher than expected chemicals revenues. However, EBITDA of Rs 1.25bn
(previous year EBITDA was Rs -561mn) were lower than our estimates of Rs 1.5bn.
Reported other income of Rs 1.1bn, +119% yoy, included accounting entry of Rs 1bn
related to insurance claim received. APAT (tax adjusted amount of Rs 670m n on
account of insurance claim) of Rs 699mn was lower than our estimates of Rs 902mn.
-30
Aug-10
Oct-10
Dec-10
GNFC (LHS)
Jan-11
Apr-11
Source: Bloomberg
Stock Details
Sector
Bloomberg
GNFC@IN
1554
Face Value(Rs)
Fertiliser segment reported revenues of Rs 4.5bn, +112% yoy, which was marginally
lower than our estimates of Rs 5bn. However, reported EBIT of Rs 834mn (compared to
loss of Rs 485mn) was ahead of our estimates of Rs 300mn. Reported EBIT included
Rs 750 mn related to insurance claims received during the quarter. Adjusting for the
insurance claim received, adjusted EBIT stood at Rs 84 mn (below our estimates of Rs
300 mn) indicating margins of mere 2%.
10
155
52 Week H/L
146/88
16/355
84202
0.2
41.2
41.2
41.2
6.0
6.1
5.1
25.1
25.4
25.7
2.2
2.3
2.4
25.5
25.1
25.7
Source: Capitaline
YE-Mar
Sales
FY10
26,145
FY11
28,459
FY12E
FY13E
Rs Mn
EBITDA
(Core)
EPS
EPS
RoE
(%)
(%)
PAT
(Rs)
% chg
3,100
11.9
1,239
10.3
(29.7)
3,774
13.3
1,664
10.7
4.1
33,396
6,973
20.9
3,489
22.4
36,260
8,434
23.3
4,122
26.5
EV/
P/E
EBITDA
P/BV
7.8
10.0
5.7
0.8
7.8
9.6
6.9
0.7
109.6
15.0
4.6
3.9
0.6
18.1
15.6
3.9
3.2
0.6
33
Result Update
GNFC
GNFC
Result Update
Rs mn
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
YoY (%)
QoQ (%)
FY11
FY10
YoY (%)
Revenue
5,066
3,678
8,019
8,339
8,423
66.3
1.0
28,459
26,145
8.9
Expenditure
5,627
3,850
6,866
6,800
7,170
27.4
5.4
24,685
23,045
7.1
as % of sales
111.1
104.7
85.6
81.5
85.1
86.7
88.1
Consumption of RM
2,897
1,712
4,520
4,408
4,647
60.4
5.4
15,287
14,075
as % of sales
57.2
46.5
56.4
52.9
55.2
53.7
53.8
659
777
928
998
1,018
54.5
2.0
3,721
3,362
as % of sales
13.0
21.1
11.6
12.0
12.1
13.1
12.9
Employee Cost
453
518
581
608
650
2,356
1,968
as % of sales
8.9
14.1
7.2
7.3
7.7
8.3
7.5
3,321
3,640
11.7
13.9
(18.6)
3,774
3,100
Other expenditure
1,619
844
837
786
855
as % of sales
32.0
22.9
10.4
9.4
10.2
EBITDA
-561
(171)
1,153
1,539
1,253
Depreciation
EBIT
Other Income
Interest
PBT
Total Tax
Adjusted PAT
(Profit)/loss from JV's/Ass/MI
43.6
(47.2)
(323.3)
7.0
8.8
8.6
10.7
19.7
(8.8)
21.7
279
296
305
305
305
9.2
(0.0)
1,211
1,170
3.5
-841
(467)
848
1,234
948
(212.8)
(23.2)
2,563
1,930
32.8
524
98
99
94
145
(72.4)
54.1
436
863
(49.5)
38
38
42
46
59
53.5
26.6
184
234
(21.3)
(355)
(407)
905
1,282
1,035
(391.3)
(19.3)
2,814
2,559
10.0
28
(181)
267
398
336
1,107.2
(15.7)
820
1,082
(24.3)
(383)
(227)
639
884
699
(282.5)
(20.9)
1,994
1,477
35.1
(282.5)
(20.9)
1,994
1,477
(238)
(383)
(227)
639
884
699
670
Reported PAT
(383)
(227)
639
884
1,369
(457.5)
54.9
2,664
1,238
115.2
Reported EPS
(2.5)
(1.5)
4.1
5.7
8.8
(453.7)
54.6
17.1
7.9
115.5
(bps)
(bps)
EBIDTA
(11.1)
(4.7)
14.4
18.5
14.9
2,596
(358)
13.3
11.9
140
EBIT
(16.6)
(12.7)
10.6
14.8
11.3
2,785
(354)
9.0
7.4
162
EBT
(17.3)
(13.7)
10.1
14.2
10.6
2,791
(368)
8.4
6.5
187
PAT
(7.6)
(6.2)
8.0
10.6
8.3
1,586
(230)
7.0
5.6
136
(7.8)
44.4
29.5
31.1
32.4
4,027
137
29.1
42.3
(1,317)
APAT after MI
Extra ordinary items
Margins (%)
35.1
(bps)
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
34
GNFC
Result Update
Revision in estimates
We have revised our revenue estimates for FY12E by 12% to reflect the commissioning of
Nitric Acid plant (DNA and WNA) by July2011. However, our PAT estimates remain flat for
FY12E as we expect chemicals margins to remain under pressure owing to lower capacity
utilization initially in the new plant. We have also introduced FY13E estimates and expect
company to report EPS of Rs 26.5, +18% yoy.
FY12E
Rs mn
Net sales
EBITDA
EBITDA %
FY13E
Old
Estimates
New
Estimates
29,792
33,396
12.1
36,260
8.6
6,660
6,973
4.7
8,434
21.0
% Change
Introducing
Estimates
22.4
20.9
-147 bps
23.3
238 bps
PAT
3,479
3,489
0.3
4,122
18.1
EPS
22.4
22.4
0.2
26.5
18.1
Segmental results
Rs mn
% yoy
Rs mn
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
YoY (%)
QoQ (%)
FY11
FY10
YoY (%)
Fertilisers
2154
733
4762
4885
4564
111.9%
-6.6%
14943
14489
3.1%
Chemicals
2783
2816
3130
3355
3729
34.0%
11.2%
13030
11303
15.3%
Fertilisers
-485
-762
-18
355
84
-117.3%
-76.4%
-340
-333
NA
Chemicals
693
371
911
924
1034
49.2%
11.9%
3241
3196
1.4%
Fertilisers
-22.5%
-103.9%
-0.4%
7.3%
1.8%
2434
-544
-2.3%
-2.3%
Chemicals
24.9%
13.2%
29.1%
27.6%
27.7%
283
18
24.9%
28.3%
-341
EBIT
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
35
GNFC
Result Update
Key Financials
Income Statement
Balance Sheet
FY10
FY11
FY12E
FY13E
FY10
FY11E
FY12E
FY13E
Net Sales
Growth (%)
26,145
(10.5)
28,459
8.9
33,396
17.3
36,260
8.6
1,554
19,234
1,554
20,289
1,554
23,142
1,554
26,627
Expenditure
23,045
24,685
26,423
27,825
Net worth
20,789
21,844
24,696
28,181
Materials Consumed
14,075
14,799
16,698
18,130
Minority Interest
3,362
1,968
3,415
2,134
3,340
2,672
3,626
2,901
Secured Loans
Unsecured Loans
5,506
0
11,506
0
13,506
0
13,506
0
Other Exp
3,640
4,337
3,714
3,169
Loan Funds
5,506
11,506
13,506
13,506
EBITDA
3,100
3,774
6,973
8,434
2,160
2,160
2,160
2,160
Growth (%)
(28.7)
21.7
84.8
21.0
Total Liabilities
28,454
35,509
40,362
43,847
11.9
1,170
13.3
1,211
20.9
1,720
23.3
1,950
Gross Block
30,842
41,141
48,541
56,541
EBIT
1,930
2,563
5,253
6,484
Less: Depreciation
19,149
20,360
22,080
24,030
7.4
9.0
15.7
17.9
Net block
11,694
20,780
26,460
32,510
Other Income
863
436
200
200
10,298
7,400
8,000
5,000
234
2,559
184
2,814
980
4,473
1,400
5,284
Investments
Current Assets
895
9,742
895
12,275
895
13,503
895
14,550
Tax
961
1,150
984
1,163
Inventories
4,050
4,635
3,751
4,073
37.5
40.9
22.0
22.0
167
4,375
4,849
5,265
Adjusted PAT
1,599
1,664
3,489
4,122
2,986
709
1,562
1,586
Growth (%)
Net Margin (%)
(29.7)
6.1
4.1
5.8
109.6
10.4
18.1
11.4
2,539
-
2,556
-
3,340
-
3,626
-
4,174
5,841
8,496
9,108
Current liabilities
2,815
4,482
7,137
7,749
Provisions
1,359
1,359
1,359
1,359
5,568
-
6,434
-
5,007
-
5,442
-
28,455
35,510
40,362
43,847
FY10
FY11E
FY12E
FY13E
11.9
13.3
20.9
23.3
6.1
5.8
10.4
11.4
ROCE
10.3
9.4
14.4
15.9
ROE
RoIC
7.8
12.0
7.8
12.6
15.0
18.6
15.6
19.6
Interest expenses
PBT
Sundry debtors
1,599
1,664
3,489
4,122
E/O items
(360)
Reported PAT
PAT after MI
1,239
1,239
1,664
1,664
3,489
3,489
4,122
4,122
Growth (%)
(45.6)
34.4
109.6
18.1
FY10
FY11E
FY12E
FY13E
1,696
1,170
2,379
1,211
4,273
1,720
5,084
1,950
Profitability (%)
EBITDA Margin
234
184
980
1,400
Net Margin
(377)
3,060
-961
(3,144)
-1,150
2,281
-984
(412)
-1,163
Cash Flow
Total Assets
Key Ratios
Interest Provided
Operating Cashflow
Y/E, Mar
4,822
-520
8,270
6,860
(6,664)
(7,400)
(8,000)
(5,000)
EPS
10.3
10.7
22.4
26.5
-1,842
-7,920
270
1,860
CEPS
17.8
18.5
33.5
39.1
Other income
Investments
863
-
436
-
200
-
200
-
BVPS
DPS
134
3.3
141
3.4
159
3.5
181
3.5
Investing Cashflow
863
436
200
200
Valuations (x)
PER
10.0
9.6
4.6
3.9
1,947
6,000
2,000
P/CEPS
5.8
5.6
3.1
2.6
Interest Paid
Dividend paid (incl tax)
(234)
(591)
(184)
(609)
(980)
(637)
(1,400)
(637)
P/BV
EV / Sales
0.8
0.7
0.7
0.9
0.6
0.8
0.6
0.7
EV / EBITDA
5.7
6.9
3.9
3.2
Others
3.2
3.2
3.4
3.4
Financing Cashflow
1,122
5,207
383
-2,037
143
2,843
-2,277
2,986
854
709
23
1,562
0.1
0.5
0.5
2.6
0.4
1.6
0.4
1.3
2,986
709
1,562
1,586
19.6
58.1
16.0
16.0
Capital expenditure
Free Cash Flow
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
36
GNFC
Result Update
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
11/04/2011
Buy
108
157
31/01/2011
Buy
112
157
21/10/2010
Buy
127
157
03/08/2010
Buy
115
157
CMP
Target
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
Date
Reports
Reco
30/05/2011
Buy
356
530
24/05/2011
Accumulate
352
400
12/05/2011
Buy
167
250
11/05/2011
Accumulate
81
86
37
Reco
Previous Reco
Buy
Buy
CMP
Target Price
Rs 665
Rs 810
-2.4
18,232
Sensex
-10
5,473
Nifty
Price Performance
(%)
1M
3M
6M 12M
Absolute
(12)
12
(14)
22
Rel. to Nifty
(6)
(7)
14
Source: Bloomberg
Rs
30
770
22
715
14
660
605
-2
550
Jun-10
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
UV's
46.3
42.4
48.0
46.6
48.8
Three Wheelers
17.1
15.8
14.4
10.6
11.0
Tractors
34.3
37.5
32.2
37.3
35.1
2.3
4.4
5.4
5.5
5.1
128,428
127,299
131,285
148,631
160,511
-10
Aug-10
Oct-10
Dec-10
Jan-11
Apr-11
Source: Bloomberg
Stock Details
Automobiles
Sector
MM@IN
Bloomberg
3070
Export
Units Sold
Face Value(Rs)
614
826/550
52 Week H/L
Market Cap (Rs bn/USD mn)
408/9,052
374401
5.7
24.9
22.8
25.8
FII/NRI
32.7
35.0
32.2
Institutions
23.6
24.3
24.6
Private Corp
10.2
8.9
8.2
8.6
9.0
9.2
Public
Net profit marginally below est due to higher other inc./interest inc.
APAT at Rs 6.1bn was only 4% below est due to higher interest income for the quarter,
indicating strong cash flow generating from the business.
Source: Capitaline
Financial Snapshot
YE-
Net
EBITDA
EPS
EPS
RoE
EV/
Mar
Sales
(Core)
(%)
APAT
(Rs) % chg
(%)
P/E
EBITDA
P/BV
FY10
185,296
28,828
15.6
19,459
31.5
145.3
29.8
21.1
13.3
5.6
FY11P
234,220
34,131
14.6
25,038
40.5
28.7
27.6
16.4
10.6
4.2
FY12E
270,030
35,047
13.0
25,895
41.9
3.4
23.1
15.9
9.9
3.6
FY13E
315,915
41,791
13.2
31,200
50.4
20.5
23.7
13.2
7.7
3.1
38
Result Update
Result Update
Quarterly Summary
Rs mn
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
YoY(%)
QoQ(%)
FY11
FY10
YoY(%)
Revenue
53,046
51,601
53,635
61,211
67,782
27.8
10.7
234,228
185,296
26.4
Expenditure
44,591
43,845
45,135
51,973
59,163
32.7
13.8
200,116
156,215
28.1
85.4
84.3
33.6
13.0
162,639
123,329
69.4
66.6
60.1
22.6
14,196
11,985
6.1
6.5
23,280
20,901
9.9
11.3
as % of sales
Consumption of RM
as % of sales
84.1
85.0
84.2
84.9
87.3
35,845
35,905
36,494
42,358
47,883
31.9
67.6
69.6
68.0
69.2
70.6
2,661
3,137
3,323
3,475
4,261
5.0
6.1
6.2
5.7
6.3
6,084
4,803
5,318
6,140
7,020
11.5
9.3
9.9
10.0
10.4
8,456
7,756
8,500
9,238
8,619
1.9
(6.7)
34,112
29,081
17.3
947
976
970
1,022
1,171
23.6
14.6
4,139
3,708
11.6
7,508
6,780
7,530
8,216
7,448
(0.8)
(9.3)
29,974
25,373
18.1
181
205
1,998
419
474
161.6
13.2
3,095
1,994
55.3
(227)
(91)
(27)
(158)
(1,858.9)
484.1
(503)
278
(280.8)
PBT
7,681
7,211
9,618
8,662
8,080
5.2
(6.7)
33,572
27,089
23.9
Total Tax
1,978
1,588
2,483
2,490
2,015
1.9
(19.1)
8,575
7,221
18.8
Adjusted PAT
5,703
5,624
7,135
6,172
6,065
6.4
(1.7)
24,997
19,868
25.8
(1.7)
24,997
19,868
25.8
Employee Cost
as % of sales
Other expenditure
as % of sales
EBITDA
Depreciation
EBIT
Other Income
Interest
15.4
5,703
5,624
7,135
6,172
6,065
6.4
14.3
18.5
11.4
467
1,175
467
1,642
1,010
62.5
Reported PAT
5,703
5,624
7,602
7,347
6,065
6.4
(17.4)
26,638
20,878
27.6
Reported EPS
9.8
8.6
11.6
11.2
9.3
(5.5)
(17.4)
45.7
35.9
27.4
(bps)
(bps)
Margins (%)
(bps)
EBIDTA
15.9
15.0
15.8
15.1
12.7
(322)
(238)
14.6
15.7
(113)
EBIT
14.2
13.1
14.0
13.4
11.0
(317)
(243)
12.8
13.7
(90)
EBT
14.5
14.0
17.9
14.2
11.9
(256)
(223)
14.3
14.6
(29)
PAT
10.8
10.9
13.3
10.1
8.9
(180)
(113)
10.7
10.7
(5)
25.8
22.0
25.8
28.7
24.9
(82)
(381)
25.5
26.7
(111)
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
39
Result Update
Q4FY10
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
Tractor (Units)
46,963
50,150
45,508
58,608
59,388
21,763
22,739
20,850
26,383
27,997
Avg realizations
463,416
453,412
458,159
450,157
471,418
4,358
3,894
3,561
4,872
4,756
20.0
17.1
17.1
18.5
17.0
11,147
8,756
13,436
11,324
10,316
39.1
44.5
26.5
43.0
46.1
81,465
77,149
85,777
90,023
101,123
Farm Equipment
Margins %
Capital Employed (Rs mn)
ROCE %
Automotive
UVs and 3-wheelers (units)
Net Sales (Rs mn)
31,139
28,798
33,239
34,716
39,598
Avg realizations
363,535
373,280
387,502
385,634
391,581
4,065
3,521
4,473
4,266
4,182
13.1
12.2
13.5
12.3
10.6
726
20,755
20,856
25,869
28,856
27,548
19.6
16.9
17.3
14.8
15.2
240
386
1247
Margins %
Extraordinary inc/(exp)
Capital Employed (Rs mn)
ROCE %
MVML
Net Sales (Rs mn)
EBITDA (Rs mn)
Margins (%)
Results (Rs mn)
Margins (%)
Net Profit (Rs mn)
Capital Employed (Rs mn)
ROCE(%)
96
319
765
40.1
82.7
61.3
60
283
729
25.0
73.3
58.4
14
236
682
16401
17473
18609
0.4
1.6
3.9
Uv's
Three Wheelers (Inc Gio)
Tractors
Exports
FY13e
%YoY
361,863
16.3
71,175
8.9
253,037
14.0
36,412
16.3
Total
722,488
14.7
Sales
315,915
17.0
41,791
19.2
EBIDTA
EBIDTA margins (%)
Net Profits
EPS
13.2
31,200
20.5
50.4
20.5
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
40
Result Update
Revision in Estimates
FY12E
Volumes
Earlier
Revised
% Change
Uv's
314,064
311,133
(0.9)
69,596
65,339
(6.1)
218,170
221,962
1.7
25,105
31,317
24.7
Total
626,935
629,750
0.4
268,091
270,030
0.7
39,278
35,047
(10.8)
14.7
13.0
28,734
25,895
(9.9)
Valuation Summary
Particulars
Basis
Discount
M&M
EV/EBIDTA (7.5x)
658
MVML *
EV/EBITDA (7.5x)
15
Listed Subsidiaries
Mahindra Finance
CMP
20
48
Mahindra Forgings
CMP
20
Mahindra Life
CMP
20
Mahindra Holidays
CMP
20
30
Mahindra Ugine
CMP
20
Tech Mahindra
CMP
20
Total
45
810
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
Management maintains its industry growth target of 16%-18% and 11-13% for automotive
and FES segment respectively for FY12.
Expect tractor demand to remain strong driven by labour shortage, higher farm income
due to higher MSP and good monsoons
Price hikes of ~2% in automotive segment and ~3% in tractor segment have been taken
during April to offset rising input costs.
Management expects raw material cost pressures of ~6% - 9% in FY12. Moreover, tractor
segment is likely to witness higher pressure as compared to automotive segment.
Chakan plant (MVML) produced 40,000 units in FY11. Management expects this to ramp
up in FY12 and contribute ~25% of over volumes primarily driven by Maxximo, New SUV,
Navistar trucks and Ssangyong models to be introduced in India.
Maharashtra VAT rule has likely impacted MVML EBITDA by ~Rs 70mn for a 15 day
period. Also, the impact is likely to be front ended resulting in lower margins during first
few years of operation and improvement later.
Target ~50% growth in top line for Ssangyong in FY12. However, do not expect
Ssangyong to break even in FY12.
41
Result Update
Financials
Income Statement
Balance Sheet
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
185,296
234,220
270,030
315,915
2,910
3,276
3,093
3,093
42.0
26.4
15.3
17.0
75,393
99,771
117,865
139,665
156,469
123,462
200,089
162,631
234,983
192,553
274,124
226,239
Minority Interest
Net worth
78,302
-
103,047
-
120,958
-
142,758
-
Employee Cost
11,985
14,195
16,238
17,915
Secured Loans
6,025
5,285
5,285
5,285
Other Exp
21,022
23,262
26,192
29,970
Unsecured Loans
22,777
18,769
18,769
16,769
EBITDA
Loan Funds
28,802
24,053
24,053
22,053
2,403
109,507
3,544
130,644
3,544
148,554
3,544
168,355
Gross Block
52,763
61,763
72,763
79,763
Less: Depreciation
25,378
29,516
34,464
39,888
Net block
Capital work in progress
27,385
9,642
32,247
11,471
38,299
9,000
39,875
9,000
Investment
63,980
93,253
109,253
127,253
Current Assets
60,424
61,435
72,390
86,059
Inventories
11,888
16,942
21,548
25,209
Sundry debtors
Cash & bank balance
12,581
17,432
13,547
6,146
18,462
4,878
21,599
7,256
18,014
23,732
26,435
30,927
Net Sales
Growth (%)
Expenditure
Materials Consumed
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
28,828
34,131
35,047
41,791
Growth (%)
175.1
18.4
2.7
19.2
15.6
3,708
14.6
4,138
13.0
4,948
13.2
5,424
25,120
29,993
30,099
36,367
13.6
1,994
278
12.8
3,093
(535)
11.1
3,539
(435)
11.5
4,166
(519)
PBT
26,835
33,621
34,073
41,053
Tax
7,376
8,583
8,177
9,853
27.5
25.5
24.0
24.0
19,459
145.3
25,038
28.7
25,895
3.4
31,200
20.5
10.5
-
10.7
-
9.6
-
9.9
-
509
1,067
1,067
1,067
19,459
25,038
25,895
31,200
51,965
67,676
80,225
93,670
E/O items
Reported PAT
1,418
20,878
1,642
26,679
25,895
31,200
Current liabilities
Provisions
34,000
17,965
47,617
20,059
55,921
24,304
65,236
28,434
145.3
28.7
3.4
20.5
8,458
(6,241)
(7,835)
(7,611)
41
109,507
130,730
148,717
168,517
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
13.2
EBIT
EBIT margin (%)
Other Income
Interest expenses
Growth (%)
Cash Flow
Key Ratios
FY10
FY11P
FY12E
FY13E
Y/E, Mar
24,842
3,708
30,528
4,138
30,534
4,948
36,887
5,424
Profitability (%)
EBITDA Margin
15.6
14.6
13.0
278
(535)
(435)
(519)
Net Margin
10.5
10.7
9.6
9.9
6,032
7,371
76
ROCE
26.8
27.6
24.1
25.6
(4,119)
3,414
326
2,154
Tax paid
Operating Cashflow
(7,376)
23,365
(8,583)
36,333
(8,177)
27,271
(9,853)
34,092
RoIC
Per Share Data (Rs)
Capital expenditure
(6,999)
(10,829)
(8,529)
(7,000)
16,366
25,504
18,742
27,092
1,994
4,734
3,539
4,166
(8,449)
(6,456)
(29,273)
(24,539)
(16,000)
(12,461)
(18,000)
(13,834)
(183)
Other income
Investments
Investing Cashflow
Equity Capital Raised
118
(11,726)
(4,749)
(2,000)
(278)
535
435
519
(6,238)
-
(8,038)
-
(7,802)
-
(9,400)
-
ROE
29.8
27.6
23.1
23.7
162.1
157.1
133.2
144.7
EPS
31.5
40.5
41.9
50.4
CEPS
37.5
47.2
49.4
58.7
BVPS
119.5
157.3
184.6
217.9
9.4
10.9
11.2
13.4
PER
21.1
16.4
15.9
13.2
P/CEPS
17.8
14.1
13.5
11.3
5.6
4.2
3.6
3.1
2.1
13.3
1.5
10.6
1.3
9.9
1.0
7.7
1.4
1.6
1.7
2.0
0.00
(0.02)
(0.08)
(0.15)
0.00
(18.78)
(0.05)
(26.69)
(0.27)
(21.51)
(0.52)
(21.29)
DPS
Valuations (x)
P/BV
EV / Sales
EV / EBITDA
Others
10,103
Financing Cashflow
(8,021)
(12,252)
(7,550)
(10,881)
1,890
(11,286)
(1,269)
2,378
15,618
17,432
17,432
6,146
6,146
4,877
4,878
7,256
Net Debt/EBIDTA
Working Cap Cycle (days)
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
42
Result Update
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
09/02/2011
Buy
654
830
12/01/2011
Buy
736
880
29/10/2010
Buy
732
880
29/07/2010
Buy
644
775
Reports
Reco
CMP
Target
26/05/2011
Buy
1,161
1,450
26/05/2011
Accumulate
226
260
25/05/2011
Accumulate
92
118
20/05/2011
Accumulate
51
63
DISCLAIMER: This document is not for public distribution and has been furnished to you solely for your information and may not be reproduced or redistributed to any other person. The manner
of circulation and distribution of this document may be restricted by law or regulation in certain countries, including the United States. Persons into whose possession this document may come are
required to inform themselves of, and to observe, such restrictions. This material is for the personal information of the authorized recipient, and we are not soliciting any action based upon it. This
report is not to be construed as an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any security in any jurisdiction where such an offer or solicitation would be illegal. No person associated with Emkay
Global Financial Services Ltd. is obligated to call or initiate contact with you for the purposes of elaborating or following up on the information contained in this document. The material is based upon
information that we consider reliable, but we do not represent that it is accurate or complete, and it should not be relied upon. Neither Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd., nor any person connected
with it, accepts any liability arising from the use of this document. The recipient of this material should rely on their own investigations and take their own professional advice. Opinions expressed are
our current opinions as of the date appearing on this material only. While we endeavor to update on a reasonable basis the information discussed in this material, there may be regulatory, compliance,
or other reasons that prevent us from doing so. Prospective investors and others are cautioned that any forward-looking statements are not predictions and may be subject to change without notice.
We and our affiliates, officers, directors, and employees world wide, including persons involved in the preparation or issuance of this material may; (a) from time to time, have long or short positions in,
and buy or sell the securities thereof, of company (ies) mentioned herein or (b) be engaged in any other transaction involving such securities and earn brokerage or other compensation or act as a
market maker in the financial instruments of the company (ies) discussed herein or may perform or seek to perform investment banking services for such company(ies)or act as advisor or lender /
borrower to such company(ies) or have other potential conflict of interest with respect to any recommendation and related information and opinions. The same persons may have acted upon the
information contained here. No part of this material may be duplicated in any form and/or redistributed without Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd.'s prior written consent. No part of this document
may be distributed in Canada or used by private customers in the United Kingdom. In so far as this report includes current or historical information, it is believed to be reliable, although its accuracy and
completeness cannot be guaranteed.
Emkay Research
30 May 2011
www.emkayglobal.com