Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Background
A Comparison of 2D Image Analysis and Design-based Stereology Designfor Morphological and Anatomical Changes in the Dopaminergic System of the Rodent Midbrain
Ji-Hyuk Park, MS, OT Therapeutic Sceicne Dept of Occupational Therapy Education University of Kansas Medical Center
Structure-function relationship in brain Quantitative analysis for brain structure - 2D image analysis (systematic bias) - Design-based stereology (unbiased) g gy ( ) Quantitative research on DA system of rodent midbrain Design-bases stereology provides standard method but biased 2D image analyses are still used in neuroscience
StructureStructure-function relationship
Morphological and anatomical features related to function and behavior Plasticity in these features due to - Therapeutic intervention p - Neurological disorder Morphological and anatomical changes - Therapeutic effects - Specific features of neurological disorder
Quantitative Analysis
Quantities analysis in neuroscience - Comparisons between groups - Correlation (structure-function) Q Quantitative analyses y - Brian imaging analysis - Light microscopic analysis : 2D image analysis : design-based stereology
2D image analysis
Commonly used in neuroscience Systematic bias (sampling/assumption) Model-based stereology Section analysis Densitometry
DesignDesign-based stereology
Theoretically unbiased - Systematic-random sampling - Probability theory (assumption free) Precision (coefficient of error) ( ) Disector method (total number) Nucleator method (neuronal volume) Cavalieri-point counting method (region volume)
2009-12-06
DesignDesign-based Stereology
Nucleator method
DesignDesign-based Stereology
Cavalieri-point counting method
Significance
No comparison study between designbased stereology and 2D image analysis using same samples. Unknown accuracy of 2D image analysis y g y This proposed study will help interpret the previous studies of 2D image analysis
2009-12-06
Purpose of Study
To compare 2D image analysis versus design-based stereology for investigation of morphological and anatomical changes in three different rodent models
Secondary Question 1
Does 2D image analysis detect differences as design-based stereology does in cell numbers? Does 2D image analysis detect differences as design-based stereology does in cell size? Does 2D image analysis detect differences as design-based stereology does in region size?
Specific Aims 1
To compare neuron numbers between control and experimental group by 2D image analysis and design-based stereology gy To compare neuron sizes between control and experimental group To compare region sizes between control and experimental group
Hypothesis 1
2D analysis will make different decisions from design-based stereology in detecting morphological and anatomical differences.
2009-12-06
Secondary Question 2
Does 2D image analysis estimate differences as design-based stereology does in cell numbers? Does 2D image analysis estimate g y differences as design-based stereology does in cell size? Does 2D image analysis estimate differences as design-based stereology does in region size?
Specific Aims 2
To compare differences of neuronal number between 2D image analysis and design-based stereology To compare differences of neuronal p volume between 2D image analysis and design-based stereology To compare differences of region volume between 2D image analysis and designbased stereology
Hypothesis 2
Estimations of differences by 2D image analysis are different from estimations by design-based stereology in morphological anatomical features.
Animal Subjects
Severe model Chronic MPTP/probenecid PD (MPD) mice for the SNpc and the VTA Modest M d t model d l Alcohol preferring (P) rats for the VTA Enriched environment (EE) rats for the SNpc
2009-12-06
Apparatus
Stereology system - Software Stereologer - Nikon Eclipse 80i - Sony 3CCD camera - M t i d stage Motorized t - 4X, 20X, 100X NIH imageJ
Measurement Methods
DesignDesign-based stereology
Estimate the total number of TH neurons (optical disector method) - Every 8th section containing the SNpc and the VTA - Outline the area (4X) - Select counting frames (4X) - Count neurons (100X) Estimate mean neuronal volume (nucleator, number-weighted) - Measure the volume of each counted neurons(100X)
DesignDesign-based stereology
Estimate total volume (cavalieri-point counting method) - Every 4th section containing the NAc - Outline the NAc (4X) ( ) - Select random grids within the NAc - Measure the thickness of each section (100X)
ModelModel-based stereology
Estimate total neuronal number - Capture images of sections (20X) - Count all neurons in each section ( g J) (ImageJ) - Abecrombie correction : Na/(D+t) Estimate mean neuronal diameter - Measure the area (A) of 10 neurons in each section(ImageJ) - d=
2009-12-06
ModelModel-based stereology
Estimate total volume (cavalieri-area method) - Capture images of sections (4X) - Measure the area of the NAc (ImageJ) ( g J) - Total volume = Total area X 4 X 60m
Data Analysis
SPSS 17.0 Student t-test (P<0.05) Control versus Experimental Design-based Design based stereology versus 2D image analyses
2009-12-06
Anticipated results
2D image analysis will detect only relatively large differences in morphological and anatomical features. Estimations of 2D image analysis will be g y different from estimation of design-based stereology in morphological and anatomical differences between two groups.
References
Baquet ZC, Williams D, Brody J, Smeyne RJ. A comparison of model-based (2D) and design-based (3D) stereological methods for estimating cell number in the substantia nigra pars compacta (SNpc) of the C57BL/6J mouse. Neuroscience. Jul 21 2009;161(4):1082-1090. Bezard E, Dovero S, Belin D, et al. Enriched environment confers resistance to 1methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine and cocaine: involvement of dopamine transporter and trophic factors. J Neurosci. Dec 3 2003;23(35):10999-11007. Mouton PR. P i i l and practices of unbiased stereology : an introduction for M PR Principles d i f bi d l i d i f bioscientists. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press; 2002. Schintu N, Frau L, Ibba M, Garau A, Carboni E, Carta AR. Progressive dopaminergic degeneration in the chronic MPTPp mouse model of Parkinson's disease. Neurotox Res. Aug 2009;16(2):127-139. West MJ. New stereological methods for counting neurons. Neurobiology of aging. JulAug 1993;14(4):275-285. West MJ. Stereological methods for estimating the total number of neurons and synapses: issues of precision and bias. Zhou FC, Zhang JK, Lumeng L, Li TK. Mesolimbic dopamine system in alcoholpreferring rats. Alcohol. Sep-Oct 1995;12(5):403-412.