Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ii
SESSION 2007-2011 INSTITUTE OF CHEMICAL ENGINEERING & TECHNOLOGY UNIVERSITY OF THE PUNJAB, LAHORE.
iii
Approval Certificate
I certify that contents and form of thesis submitted by Mr. Farhan Shahzad, Mr. Asad Noor, Mr. Salman Akbar Malik and Muhammad Zahid have been found satisfactory and are according to the prescribed format. I recommend it for the evaluation by the external examiner for the award of degree of B.Sc. Engg (Chemical Engineering).
_____________________ Dr. Abdullah Khan Durrani Professor of chemical engineering Institute of Chemical Engineering & Technology, University of the Punjab, Lahore.
______________________ Engr. Abdul Basit Lecturer Institute of Chemical Engineering & Technology, University of the Punjab, Lahore.
iv
Dedicated To our parents Whose love and affection Made our life worth living
ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all we would like to thank Allah Almighty for the strength, courage and blessings that He bestowed upon us during design project. We consider ourselves very lucky to have Prof. Dr. Abdullah Khan Durani as our supervisor. We would like to thank him for all the guidance that he has given us to complete our project objectives in a successful manner. We are very much thankful to him for spending his precious time to share his knowledge & experience with us. This work may not have been possible without the attention and devotion of Engr. Abdul Basit as co-supervisor. We express our sincere gratitude in the respect of honorable Prof. Dr. Syed Zahoor-Ul-Hassan Rizvi, Director Institute of Chemical Engineering & Technology University of the Punjab Lahore, for providing us all the necessary facilities for the completion of this research work.
This section cannot come to an end unless we admit the encouragement of our friends and teachers who assisted us in every aspect of this project.
iii
iv
Contents
1 Coal.......................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Types Of Coal .................................................................................................... 2 Peat ............................................................................................................. 2 Lignite .......................................................................................................... 2 Sub-Bituminous Coal ................................................................................... 3 Bituminous Coal .......................................................................................... 3 Semi-Anthracite Coal ................................................................................... 4 Anthracite Coal ............................................................................................ 4
Minerals In Coal ................................................................................................. 7 Coal Properties .................................................................................................. 8 Heating Value .............................................................................................. 8 Caking And Swelling Properties .................................................................. 8 Hardness ..................................................................................................... 9 Density......................................................................................................... 9 Ash Properties ........................................................................................... 10
Application Of Coal .......................................................................................... 12 Coal As Fuel .............................................................................................. 12 Coking And Use Of Coke........................................................................... 12 v
1.5.1 1.5.2
Coal Reserves In Pakistan ............................................................................... 14 Application Of Pakistani Coal ........................................................................... 17 Use Of Coal For Power Generation ........................................................... 17 Use Of Coal As An Industrial Fuel ............................................................. 17 Brick Kilns .................................................................................................. 18 Cement Production .................................................................................... 18 Coal Briquettes .......................................................................................... 18 Coal Gasification ....................................................................................... 18 Underground Coal Gasification .................................................................. 18
Coal Gasification .................................................................................................... 20 2.1 Chemical Reactions ......................................................................................... 21 Pyrolysis Reactions ................................................................................... 21 Gasification Reactions ............................................................................... 21 Acceptor Reactions ................................................................................... 22 Heats of Reactions .................................................................................... 22 Equilibrium Considerations ........................................................................ 23 Reaction Kinetics ....................................................................................... 23
Gasifier Types .................................................................................................. 24 Fixed-Bed Gasifier ..................................................................................... 24 Fluidized-Bed Gasifier ............................................................................... 25 Entrained-Flow Gasifier ............................................................................. 26 vi
2.3
Commercial Gasifiers ....................................................................................... 28 The LurgiGasifier ....................................................................................... 28 Fixed-Bed Gasifier ..................................................................................... 28 The Koppers-Totzek Gasifier ..................................................................... 28 The Winkler Gasifier .................................................................................. 29
Process selection ............................................................................................. 29 Raw Materials ............................................................................................ 30 Steps Involved ........................................................................................... 30 Process Equipments .................................................................................. 30 Process Description ................................................................................... 31 Catalyst Selected ....................................................................................... 32
Fluidized Bed Gasifier Design .......................................................................... 33 Factors Affecting Reaction Rates ..................................................................... 36 Temperature .............................................................................................. 36 Pressure .................................................................................................... 36 Coal Properties .......................................................................................... 36 Types Of Reactions ................................................................................... 36
Method Of Contacting ...................................................................................... 37 Fixed bed ................................................................................................... 37 Molten Bath ............................................................................................... 39 Entrained Phase ........................................................................................ 39
Material Balance .................................................................................................... 40 3.1 3.2 Material Balance On Dryer ............................................................................... 40 Material Balance On Fluidized Bed Gasifier ..................................................... 42 vii
Material Balance On Cyclone Separator .......................................................... 49 Material Balance On Scrubber ......................................................................... 51 Material Balance On Absorber ......................................................................... 54
Energy Balance ...................................................................................................... 57 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 Energy Balance On Heat Exchanger ............................................................... 57 Energy Balance On Dryer ................................................................................ 60 Energy Balance On Gasifier ............................................................................. 63 Energy Balance On Scrubber........................................................................... 67
Equipment Design .................................................................................................. 69 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 Fluidized Bed Gasifier Design .......................................................................... 69 Heat Exchanger Design ................................................................................... 76 Cyclone Separator Design ............................................................................... 85 Design Of Scrubber.......................................................................................... 93 H2S Absorber Design ..................................................................................... 100
Instrumentation .................................................................................................... 107 6.1 Control ........................................................................................................... 108 Incentives ForChemical Process Control ................................................. 108 Elements OfControl System .................................................................... 109 Modes of Control ..................................................................................... 112 Selection of Controller ............................................................................. 113
Control Loops ................................................................................................. 114 Feed Back Control Loop .......................................................................... 115 Feed Forward Control Loop ..................................................................... 115 Ratio Control............................................................................................ 116 viii
Auctioneering Control Loop ..................................................................... 116 Split Range Loop ..................................................................................... 116 Cascade Control Loop ............................................................................. 116
Control Loops Around Equipments................................................................ 116 Control Loops On Gasifier ....................................................................... 116 Control Loop On Compressor .................................................................. 119 Control Loop On Absorption Column ....................................................... 120 Control Loops On Heat Exchanger .......................................................... 121
Cost Estimation .................................................................................................... 123 7.1 Total Purchased Cost Of Major Equipment .................................................... 123 Cost Estimation Of Heat Exchanger ........................................................ 123 Cost Estimation Of Cyclone Separator .................................................... 124 Cost Estimation Of Absorber ................................................................... 125
Fixed Capital Cost .......................................................................................... 128 Fixed Cost ...................................................................................................... 129 Variable Cost.................................................................................................. 130 Utilities ........................................................................................................... 131
ix
List of figures
Figure 1: Coal production by province ........................................................................... 14 Figure 2: Moving bed gasefier ....................................................................................... 25 Figure 3: Fluidized bed gasefier .................................................................................... 26 Figure 4: Entrained flow gasifier .................................................................................... 27 Figure 5: Control loops on gasefier ............................................................................. 118 Figure 6: Control loops on compressor ....................................................................... 119 Figure 7: Control loop on absorption column ............................................................... 120 Figure 8: Control loop on heat exchanger ................................................................. 121
List of Tables
Table 1-1: World Coal Reserves by Region .................................................................... 1 Table 1-2: Classification Of Coal ..................................................................................... 5 Table 1-3: Particle and Bulk Density ............................................................................ 10 Table 1-4: Pakistan's Coal Reserves(4) ........................................................................ 15 Table 1-5: Composition Of Different Coal Fields(4) ....................................................... 16 Table 3-1: Summary of Material Balance on Dryer ....................................................... 41 Table 3-2: Summary Of Material Balance On Gasefier ................................................. 46 Table 3-3: Summery Of Material Balance On cyclone separator .................................. 50 Table 3-4: Summery Of Material Balance On Scrubber ................................................ 53 Table 3-5: Summery Of Material Balance on Scrubber ................................................. 56 Table 4-1: Summery Of Energy Balance on Gasefier ................................................... 65 Table 5-1: specification data sheet of gasefier .............................................................. 75 Table 5-2: specification data sheet of heat exchanger .................................................. 84 Table 5-3: particle size distribution in cyclone separator ............................................... 87 Table 5-4: calculated performance of cyclone ............................................................... 89 Table 5-5: specification data sheet of cyclone separator............................................... 91 Table 5-6: specification data sheet of scrubber ............................................................. 99 Table 7-1: total purchased cost of equipment ............................................................. 133
xi
xii
1 Coal
Coal is a readily combustible black or brownish-black sedimentary rock. The harder forms, such as anthracite coal, can be regarded as metamorphic rock because of later exposure to elevated temperature and pressure. It is composed primarily of carbon along with variable quantities of other elements, chiefly sulfur, hydrogen, oxygen and nitrogen.
Table 1-1: World Coal Reserves by Region
Region North America South and Central America Europe Former Soviet Union Africa and Middle East Asia/Pacific World
All coal has been formed from biomass. Over time this biomass has been turned into peat. When covered under a layer of overburden, the influence of time, pressure, and temperature convert this material into brown coal or lignite. Subsequently, the latter material will turn into sub-bituminous coal, then into bituminous coal, and finally into anthracite. Coal is often classified in terms of its rank, which increases from brown coal to anthracite. The classification of coal by rank for ash and moisture-free coal is given in Table 1.2Brown coal, lignite, and sub-bituminous coals are called low-rank coals, 1
whereas higher-rank coals are often called hard coals. The terms brown coal and lignite are essentially synonymous, lignite being used more often in the United States and brown coal in Europe and Australia [1]
irregular manner. Hence, it cannot be moved far from the mine. It is likely to ignite spontaneously as it adsorbs oxygen readily and must not be stored in the open without care. The lignite deposits in many areas are relatively near the earths surface and are quite thick. Composition and properties of lignite varies widely. The carbon content is 70-75% and the oxygen content is 21-26%. The volatile matter is often over 50% and in a large number of cases the ratios of volatile matter to fix carbon are 1:1. The ash of lignites is generally low. Raw lignite is an inferior fuel due to high moisture, low calorific value, small size and bad weathering properties. Lignite is of economic importance in those places where it is available and other fuels do not occur in abundance. Lignite is used in the generation of electricity in thermal power stations and carbonized briquettes are used as smokeless fuel. Other uses of lignite are in gas production and metallurgical furnaces. Lignite is extensively used in the manufacturing of producer gas. It is also gasified into synthesis gas for ammonia production. 1.1.3 Sub-Bituminous Coal It is black, homogeneous and smooth mass having high moisture and volatile matter content which breaks into smaller pieces on exposure to air. Its carbon content is around 70-80% and oxygen content is 10-20%. It is a non-coking coal having calorific value about 7000 kcal/kg. It is variety of mature lignite resembling true coal in color and appearance. It is black in color with a dull, waxy luster. It is denser and harder than lignite and has lower moisture content (12-25%).Most sub-bituminous coals appear banded like bituminous coal. Like lignite; sub-bituminous coal disintegrates on exposure to atmosphere and is therefore difficult to transport. The sub-bituminous coal has 7078% carbon, 4.5-5.5% hydrogen and about 20% oxygen. The air dried moisture is 1020%, the volatile matter is 40% above. The calorific value is 6,800-7,600 kcal/kg[dry mineral matter free]. It ignites easily and is used in raising steam and for manufacturing gaseous fuels also if low in sulphur. 1.1.4 Bituminous Coal It is most common variety of coal known as Koela in Urdu. It is black and brittle which burns and ignites readily with yellow smoky flame. It has low moisture content (<10%) 3
and the carbon content varies from 75-90% whereas the volatile matter content is 2045%. Depending upon the volatile matter content, it is termed as low volatile, medium volatile and high volatile coal. Its calorific value on mineral free basis goes up to 9000 kcal/kg. Most of the cooking coals is essentially bituminous coal. It is used for power generation, coke making, gasification; domestic heating etc. Non-coking bituminous coals are generally used for purposes other than coke making which requires coking coal. Bituminous coal is used for combustion in domestic ovens, industrial furnaces and boilers, railway locomotives and thermal power stations. Two other important uses are carbonization and gasification, whereby coal is converted into solid fuels, gaseous fuels and liquid fuels. It is also a source of a wide range of coal chemicals, fertilizers and synthetic liquid fuels. 1.1.5 Semi-Anthracite Coal Its properties lie between that of bituminous and anthracite coal. It is harder than the most mature bituminous coal, and ignites more easily than anthracite to give a short flame changing from yellow to blue. Some of the properties of semi-anthracite are: 1. Moisture: 1-2% 2. Volatile mater: 10-15% 3. Calorific value: 8,500-8,800 kcal/kg It is non-coking coal. 1.1.6 Anthracite Coal This is the most mature coal; hence is of highest rank. Thus high carbon content (8595%) and low volatile matter (<10%) coal is hard, non-coking and burns without smoke with a short non-luminous flame thereby imparting intense localized heating. It ignites with difficulty due to low volatile matter content. The calorific value may be up to 80008500 kcal/kg which is slightly lower than that of bituminous coal due to its lower hydrogen content.
It has sub-metallic luster, sometimes even a graphite appearance. Anthracite is characterized by low volatile matter (3-10%) and high carbon content (over 92%). The air dried moisture is 2-4%. The hydrogen content is 2.8-3.9% and calorific value is 8,400 to 8,700 kcal/kg. Anthracite arenon caking. The chief uses of anthracites are in boilers, domestic ovens and metallurgical furnaces. It is also used in small quantities as a component of coke oven charges. On calcining it gives thermo-anthracite which is a raw material for the production of carbon electrodes.
Class
1.2.1 Proximate Analysis The proximate analysis determines the moisture, volatile matter, fixed carbon, and ash in the coal. The analysis is an essentially practical tool providing an initial indication of 5
the coals quality and type. The methods for performing these analyses have been standardized by all the major standards institutions These standards, though similar in nature, are different from one another in, for example, the temperature specified for determining the volatiles content, so it is important when providing data to specify the method used. Moisture is determined by drying the coal under standard conditions for 1 h at 104 110
O
C. The method determines the sum of all moisture; that is, both the surface
moisture caused by rain and so on, and the inherent moisture. The inherent moisture is the water that is very loosely bound in the coal. It can vary from a few percent in anthracite to 6070% in brown coal. Volatile matter is determined by heating the coal in a covered crucible for a defined time at a defined temperature (e.g., 7min at 950oC ASTM). The loss in mass, minus the mass of the moisture, represents the mass of the gaseous constituents formed by the pyrolysis under the conditions mentioned. Ash is the inorganic residue that remains after combustion of the coal. It consists mainly of silica, alumina, ferric oxide, lime, and of smaller amounts of magnesia, titanium-oxide, and alkali and sulfur compounds. Fixed carbon is determined by subtracting from 100 the mass percentages of moisture, volatile matter, and ash. It should be remarked that fixed carbon is an artificial concept and does not mean that this material was present in the coal as pure C in the beginning. Although the proximate analysis already tells the expert a lot about the coal, for gasification it is mandatory to have also the ultimate hydro carbonaceous part of the coal. 1.2.2 Ultimate Analysis For the ultimate analysis the percentages of carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, sulfur, and nitrogen are determined. In the past, oxygen was sometimes reported as by difference. If at all possible this should not be accepted, as it makes it impossible to have any control over the quality of the analysis. Proper balances are the basis for a good 6
process design and a good operation of plants, but a good balance is equally dependent on a good elemental analysis. The relevance of sulfur in the coal for gasification is the same as for oil derived heavy residual feed stocks, which generally contain more sulfur than most coals, and sulfur contents in coal range from 0.56 wt%. In coals with a high sulfur content, most of the sulfur is generally present in the form of Pyrite. Note that the quantity of pyritic sulfur is an indicator for the potential abrasiveness of the coal. The nitrogen content in coals ranges from 0.52.5wt%. Only part of the nitrogen in the coal is converted into ammonia and HCN upon gasification, whereas the remainder is converted into elemental nitrogen. The presence of the coal-derived nitrogen in the product gas is one reason why it is not always essential to gasify coal with very pure oxygen (>99 mol%), even when the gas is used for the production of syngas or hydrogen. The percentage of the nitrogen in the coal that is converted into elemental nitrogen upon gasification will depend on the type of nitrogen compounds in the coal.
2. In the reactor chlorides can react with the hydrogen present to form HCl, which will decrease the pH of the wash water or condensate. 3. Chlorides may also form NH4Cl with high nitrogen feeds. With such feed stocks the chloride deposits as NH4Cl in the economizers at temperatures below about 280 0C. Further, as an aqueous solution this leads to severe chloride stress corrosion in stainless steels that are used, for example, in burners and instrument lines. Coals also contain phosphorus, but this has less significance for gasification than, for instance, for the steel industry.
Where C, H, O, and S are the mass fractions of the elements obtained from the ultimate Analysis. There are other formulae for calculating the heating value from the ultimate And/or proximate analyses. HHV(MJ/kg)34.91C 117.83H 10.34O 1.51N 10.05S 2.11Ash It is always useful to calculate the heating value from these analyses, as it is a good cross check on measured values. If the deviation is more than a few percent, all analyses must be checked. [1] 1.4.2 Caking And Swelling Properties Another important property of a coal is the swelling index. The swelling index is determined by heating a defined sample of coal for a specified time and temperature, 8
and comparing the size and shape taken by the sample with a defined scale. There are a number of different scales defined in, for example, ASTM D 720-91, BS 1016, or ISO 335. The swelling index is an indicator for the caking properties of a coal and its expansion on heating. Softening/caking does not occur at a certain temperature but over a temperature range. It is an important variable for moving-bed and fluid-bed gasifiers. For the gasifiers of entrained-flow systems, the coal softening point has no relevance. However, the softening point may limit the amount of preheating of the pulverized coal feedstock used in dry coal feed gasifiers. 1.4.3 Hardness Physical properties are not very relevant for the operation of a gasifier as such. The hardness of the coal is, for example, mainly important for the milling and grinding up stream of the gasifier. The hardness of a coal is usually dependant on the nature and quantity of its ash content, although some coals, such anthracites, are also hard. A high ash content or a very high hardness of the ash in the coal can make a feedstock un attractive for gasification because of the high cost of milling and grinding. Ashes with high silica and/or alumina contents have a high hardness. The hardness is generally characterized by the hard grove grind ability index. 1.4.4 Density The density is primarily of importance for the transport of the coal. In this connection, it is important to discriminate between the particle density and the bulk density of the coal. The bulk density is always lower, as is shown in table 1.3
Fuel
10
of less than 25 Pas is required. The temperature required to achieve this viscosity (T 250) is therefore sometimes used in the literature. Some slags are characterized by a typical exponential relationship between viscosity and temperature over a long temperature range. For others this relationship is foreshortened at a critical temperature (Tcv) at which the viscosity increases very rapidly with decreasing temperature. For a slagging gasifier to operate at a reasonable temperature, it is necessary for the slag to have a Tcv<1400 OC. The relationship between ash-melting characteristics and composition is a complicated one and is dependent largely on the quaternary .In general, slags that are high in silica and/ or alumina will have high ash-melting points, but this is reduced by the presence of both iron and calcium hence the use of limestone as a flux. However, the SiO 2/Al2O3 ratio is also important, and where the calcium content is already high, there can be some advantage to lowering the ash melting point by adding SiO2. In dry ash moving-bed gasifiers and in fluid-bed gasifiers, coals with a high ash melting point are preferred, whereas in slagging gasifiers, coals with a low ash melting point are preferred. The caking properties of a coal and the melting characteristics of its ash are the reason that there are forbidden temperature ranges that have to be taken into account, both in design and during operation. In entrained-flow gasifiers only the ash properties are important. The ash that is produced in gasifiers always has a lower density than the minerals from which they originate, due to loss of water, decomposition of carbonates, and other factors, and the presence of some carbon. The bulk density of the ash in particular may be low due to the formation of hollow ash particles. This means that special attention has to be given to the transport of such ashes. Slag is very different from ash as it has been molten and is in fact a fusion-cast material similar to glass. Ideally, slag becomes available as an inert, fine, gritty material with sharp edges due to the sudden temperature drop upon contact with a water bath. Because Lumps of solid slag will form during process upsets, a slag breaker is sometimes installed between the water bath and the slag depressurizing system. 11
1.4.5.2 Coke
Coke is a material consisting essentially of the fixed carbon and the ash in the coal. It was in the past a common fuel in water gas plants, but as it is more expensive than coal, anthracite is now often the preferred fuel. It is virtually never used in gasification plants. Coke plays a very important role in blast furnaces, which may be considered to be very large gasifiers. One of the main reasons to use coke in blast furnaces is that it is much stronger than coal.
Btu/ton (29.6 MJ/kg). Some coke making processes produce valuable by-products that include coal tar, ammonia, light oils, and "coal gas". 1.5.3 Production Of Ethanol Coal and natural gas are both abundant in nature and available at a very low cost compared to other resources.
Coke which represents about 80% of coal reacts with natural gas producing ethylene gas. Ethylene Hydration provides ethanol. Product ethanol outweighs other liquid fuels for its availability and low cost. The reaction itself is obvious, a simple addition reaction where one mole of carbon reacts with one mole of methane gas producing one mole of ethylene gas. 1.5.4 Gasification Coal gasification can be used to produce syngas, a mixture of carbon monoxide (CO) and hydrogen (H2) gas. This syngas can then be converted into transportation fuels like gasoline and diesel through the Fischer-Tropsch process. Alternatively, the hydrogen obtained from gasification can be used for various purposes such as powering a hydrogen economy, making ammonia, or upgrading fossil fuels. High prices of oil and natural gas are leading to increased interest in "BTU Conversion" technologies such as gasification, methanation and liquefaction. 1.5.5 Liquefaction Coal can also be converted into liquid fuels like gasoline or diesel by several different processes. In the direct liquefaction processes, the coal is either hydrogenated or carbonized. Alternatively, coal can be converted into a gas first, and then into a liquid, by using the Fischer-Tropsch process.[2] 13
14
Coal Resources (million tonnes) Province/ coal field Sindh Lakhra Sonda- thatta Jherruck Others Thar Sub- total Balochistan Kohst-sharig-harnai Sor-range/degari Duki Mach-abegum Pirismailziarat Chamalong Sub-total Punjab Eastern salt range Central salt range Makerwal Sub-total Grandtotal 21 29 05 55 4,008 16 08 24 12,113 02 09 11 87,189 145 81,144 235 184,575 145 235 13 15 14 09 02 01 54 11 02 13 63 19 25 14 08 05 134 16 16 76 50 50 23 12 06 217 244 60 106 82 3,407 3,898 629 511 310 303 10,323 12,076 455 2197 907 1881 81,725 87,165 932 80,051 80,983 1,328 3,700 1,323 2266 175,506 184,123 Measured Indicated resources Interred resources resources Hypothetical resources Total resources
15
Province/Coal Field
Coal Quality Proximate Analyses (in percent) Moisture Volatile Fixed Ash Total Matter Carbon Sulphur
Lakhra Sonda-Thatta Jherruk Ongar Indus East Meting-Jhumpir Badin Thar Khost-ShahrigHarnai Sor Range-Deghari Duki Mach Abegum Pir Ismail Ziarat Chamalong-Bala Dhaka Salt Range Makarwal Hangu/Orakzai Cherat/GullaKhel
9.8-38.2 8.9-31.6
1.2-14.8 0.2-15.0
15.058.8 24.132.2
0.4-7.7 2.9-5.1
29.6-55.5 1.7-11.2 3.9-18.9 3.5-11.5 7.1-12.0 6.3-13.2 1.1-2.9 3.2-10.8 2.8-6.0 0.2-2.5 0.1-7.1
23.1-36.6 9.3-45.3 20.7-37.5 32.0-50.0 34.2-43.0 34.6-41.0 24.9-43.5 21.5-38.8 31.5-48.1 16.2-33.4 14.0-31.2
14.234.0 25.543.8 41.050.8 28.042.0 32.441.5 19.342.5 19.4478.1 25.744.8 34.944.9 21.849.8 37.076.9
2.911.5 9.334.0 4.917.2 5.038.0 9.620.3 10.337.5 9.136.5 12.344.2 6.430.8 5.343.3 6.139.0
0.4-2.9 3.5-9.55 0.6-5.5 4.0-6.0 3.2-7.4 4.0-5.5 3.0-8.5 2.6-10.7 2.8-6.3 1.5-9.5 1.1-3.5
Kotli *mmmf
0.2-6.0
5.1-32.0
26.369.5
3.350.0
0.3-4.8
7,33612,338
16
17
1.7.3 Brick Kilns Presently, coal is commonly used for making bricks and roofing tiles, as it is an ideal fuel for kilns, especially for heavy clay products. In Pakistan, about 50% of coal production is used in the brick kiln industry. Therefore, a large market for indigenous coal is available in Pakistan for interested private investors. 1.7.4 Cement Production In many countries, coal is used as fuel in the cement industry. Previously, coal was not used as fuel in cement plants in Pakistan, but now the cement industry has started using indigenous coal. The Government of Pakistan is now conducting a feasibility study to convert gas-based and oil-based cement plants to run on indigenous coal. It is expected that, in future more and more cement plants will be using indigenous coal as fuel. This constitutes another market for indigenous coal for private investors. 1.7.5 Coal Briquettes Yet another industrial use of coal is in the form of smokeless coal briquettes which can be used as domestic fuel, and would have special application in reducing deforestation in the Northern Areas of Pakistan. Pakistans Fuel Research Centre has developed smokeless coal briquette of good quality in its pilot plant at Karachi. 1.7.6 Coal Gasification Electricity generation in Pakistan is severely affected by rapidly escalating gas and oil prices in the world. IGCC power plants have the potential of being economically
competitive by using gas produced from indigenous coal. Furthermore, catalytic coal gasification is developed as a more efficient and less costly process to produce gas from coal. Methanol or synthetic gas can be produced from Thar coal at the coalfield and can easily be transported by pipeline throughout the demand centres. 1.7.7 Underground Coal Gasification A technology is also available for insitu conversion of coal into gas, which can be used for power generation or for conversion into higher value products such as diesel fuel, 18
methanol, and ammonia. Underground coal gasification can be applied to both horizontal and inclined coal beds. Coal not recoverable by conventional mining methods, can be accessed for insitu coal gasification. Private investors can use this new technology where coal beds are thin and steeply dipping, and not economical for mining by conventional mining methods [5]
19
2 Coal Gasification
Gasification is a process that converts organic or fossil based carbonaceous materials into carbon monoxide, hydrogen, carbon dioxide and methane. This is achieved by reacting the material at high temperatures (>700C), without combustion, with a controlled amount of oxygen and/or steam. The resulting gas mixture is called syngas (from synthesis gas or synthetic gas) or producer gas and is itself a fuel. The power derived from gasification of biomass and combustion of the resultant gas is considered to be a source of renewable energy, the gasification of fossil fuel derived materials such as plastic is not considered to be renewable energy. Gasification is the most versatile of the coal conversion processes having applications in almost every sector of energy demand. In industrial installations and power generation systems, for example, a low calorific value gas or a medium calorific value gas may be used. A medium calorific value gas may also be converted into liquid fuels or chemicals and in this case is often referred to as synthesis gas. Finally, a substitute natural gas; high calorific value gas can be manufactured as a direct replacement for natural gas. The composition of the gas obtained from a gasifier depends on a number of parameters such as: 1. Fuel composition 2. Gasifying medium 3. Operating pressure 4. Temperature 5. Moisture content of the fuels 6. Mode of bringing the reactants into contact inside the gasifier etc.
20
21
In regions of the gasifier where oxygen is in excess, combustion may also take place. Combustion reaction [3]: C+O2 Shift reaction: CO + H2O Methanation reaction: CO + 3H2 CH4 + H2O CO2 + H2 CO2
2.1.3 Acceptor Reactions In some gasifiers, limestone or dolomite may be used to retain the sulphur. If the acceptor is calcined before feeding to the gasifier, carbon dioxide may also be retained. The reactions for calcined limestone are given below. Sulphur retention: CaO + H2S Carbon dioxide acceptor: CaO + CO2 CaCO3 CaS + H2O
Reaction of sulphur is also possible using dolomite or unclaimed limestone 2.1.4 Heats of Reactions An important factor affecting the choice of reactants and gasifier operating conditions is the heat released or absorbed by the above reactions. In a gasifier the net heat release has to be just sufficient to bring the reactants to the design operating temperature. Heat 22
therefore has to be supplied to supply to meet the sensible heat requirements and those for the endothermic boudouard and water gas reactions. In a gasifier the net heat release has to be just sufficient to bring the reactants to the design operating temperature. Heat transfer has to be supplied to meet the sensible heat requirements and those for the endothermic boudouard and waste gas reactions .The most designs that is achieved by the combustion and partial combustion reactions although systems using the methnation reaction, the carbon dioxide acceptor reaction or an external heat source are also under consideration. 2.1.5 Equilibrium Considerations An indication of the effect of the temperature and pressure conditions in a gasifier on the product gas composition may be obtained by considering the theoretical composition if the reactions were allowed sufficient time to reach equilibrium. In the presence of an excess of carbon, the equilibrium for the combustion and partial combustion reactions correspond to extremely low oxygen concentrations and for practical purposes it may be assumed that the oxygen content of the product gas is zero for most gasifiers. 2.1.6 Reaction Kinetics The time taken for some of the above reactions to reach equilibrium can; however be considerable and the design of gasifier has to take into account the speed of the reactions. For gas solid reactions (including all the main gasification reactions) the
reaction time is, in general, determined by two processes either of which may be rate controlling. These are the diffusion of the gaseous reactants and products to and from the particle surface and the chemical reactions at the particle surface. In practice, diffusion is a comparatively rapid process and conditions under which diffusion becomes rate controlling in general provide reaction rates that are high from the view point of gasifier design. For gas phase reactions, such as shift and methanation, chemical reaction rates are generally controlling unless the reactions are promoted by a solid catalyst [6] 23
24
2.2.2 Fluidized-Bed Gasifier In this gasifier, coal with 1/8- in. in size enters the side of the reactor and is kept suspended by the gasifying medium. Similar to a fluidized-bed combustor, mixing and heat transfer are rapid, resulting in uniform composition and temperature throughout the bed. The temperature is sustained below the ash fusion temperature to avoid clinker formation. Char particles entrained in the product gas are recovered and recycled back into the gasifier via a cyclone. Acceptance of a wide range of solid feedstock (including solid waste, wood, and high ash content coals) It has Uniform temperature. Oxygen and steam requirements are moderate and extensive char recycling.
25
2.2.3 Entrained-Flow Gasifier Entrained-flow systems gasify pulverized fuel particles suspended in a stream of oxygen (or air) and steam. Residence time in this type of gasifier is very short. This gasifier generally uses oxygen as the oxidant and operates at high temperatures. In this gasefier. Temperature is well above ash-slagging conditions, to ensure high carbon conversion. Ash in the coal melts at the high operating temperature of the gasifier and is removed as liquid slag. The product gas and slag exit close to the reaction temperature. Entrained-flow gasifiers have the following characteristics: 1. Ability to gasify all coals regardless of coal rank, caking characteristics, or amount of coal fines, 2. Feed stocks with lower ash contents are favored. 3. Uniform temperatures. 4. Very short fuel residence times in the gasifier; 5. Very finely sized and homogenous solid fuel required; 6. Relatively large oxidant requirements; 26
7. High-temperature slagging operation 8. Entrainment of some molten slag in the raw gas 9. Their use for biomass gasification is rather limited, as it requires the fuel particles to be very fine (in the order of 80 to 100 m). 10. A number of manufacturers offers commercial entrained bed gasifiers for largescale applications, such as Texaco, Shell, and KoppersTotzek.
27
high temperatures (1500-1800oC) in a flame similar to that of a pulverized fuel combustion furnace. The hot gas leaves the reactor via water cooled, vertical duct. About half of the ash is entrained in the gas stream as particles of slag that cool and resolidify by radiation to the vessel walls. The remainder of the ash is removed as slag from the bottom of the reactor into a water quench bath. The gasifier can handle most ranks of coal including lignite and strongly caking coals. 2.3.4 The Winkler Gasifier This is a fluidized bed gasifier that operates at atmospheric pressure. It was originally designed to use lignite but bituminous coal, although less reactive, can also be used. The feed material is crushed to a maximum size of 10mm and is delivered to near the top of the bed by a screw feeder. The bed is fluidized with steam and oxygen (or air) and ash is removed from the bottom of the bed. The temperature of the bed is maintained at 800-900 oC to avoid sintering of the ash. However, at this temperature the gasification reactions proceed slowly and it is necessary to inject additional steam and oxygen (or air) above the bed. The reactions above the bed increase the gas temperature to more than 1000C and the ash is therefore cooled to below the resolidification point by radiative heat transfer to a boiler before leaving the reactor. Ash and unconverted carbon are removed from the gas stream by cyclones.
29
2.4.1 Raw Materials Following are the raw materials used in the manufacturing of syngas from coal: 1. Coal 2. Superheated Steam 3. Pure Oxygen 4. Selexol 5. Process Water 6. Catalyst 2.4.2 Steps Involved The major steps involved in the formation of syn gas from coal are: 1. Coal Feeding 2. Gasification 3. Gas Cooling 4. Gas Purification 2.4.3 Process Equipments The major equipments used are as follows: 1. Rotary Dryer 2. Fluidized Bed Gasifier (Winkler) 3. Heat Exchanger 4. Cyclone Separator 5. Scrubber 6. Absorption Column 7. Compressors
30
2.4.4 Process Description Coal Feeding Coal from crusher and breaker is fed to the screening system. Here the 1/8 in (3mm) particle size material is separated and fed to the gasifiers. Gasification (Winkler Type) We have selected Winkler type gasifier because it can operate at 1 atm pressure. The Winkler process is operable with practically any fuel. Commercial plants have operated on brown coal coke, as well as on sub-bituminous and bituminous coals. Coal preparation requires milling to a particle size below 10 mm but does not require drying if the moisture content is below 10%. The feed is conveyed into the gasifier or generator by a screw conveyor. The fluid bed is maintained by the blast, which enters the reactor via a conical grate area at the base. An additional amount of blast is fed in above the bed to assist gasification of small, entrained coal particles. This also raises the temperature above that of the bed itself, thus reducing the tar content of the syngas. The reactor itself is refractory lined. Operation temperature is maintained below the ash melting point. Most commercial plants have operated between 815 and 980C. At
maximum load the gas velocity in a Winkler generator is about 5m/s. The flow sheet incorporates a radiant waste heat boiler and a cyclone to remove the ash. The ash contains a considerable amount of un reacted carbon over 20% loss on feed. Oxygen Supply Oxygen required for the gasification of coal is produced in an air separation plant and then compressed to coal gasifier pressure. Steam Supply Superheated steam for the process is supplied.
31
Gas Cooling The crude gas leaving the gasifier immediately enters a heat exchanger and waste heat boiler to generate low to medium pressure steam. Cyclone Separator A cyclone separator removes most of the entrained fly ash and dust. About 85% of solids are removed in this unit. It is a reverse flow cyclone. In a reverse flow cyclone the gas enters the top chamber tangentially and spirals down to the apex of the conical section; it then moves upward in a second, smaller diameter, spiral, and exits at the top through a central vertical pipe. The solids move radially to the walls, slide down the walls, and are collected at the bottom. Absorption Column Gas from coal gasification contains a large amount of CO2 and H2 S, organic sulfur, and other impurities. These impurities can be removed by using selexol as a solvent. Selexol. . It uses dimethyl ethers of polyethylene glycol (DMPEG). The typical operating temperature range is 040 oC. The ability to operate in this temperature range offers substantially reduced costs by eliminating or minimizing refrigeration duty. On the other hand, for a chemical application such as ammonia, the residual sulfur in the treated gas may be 1 ppmv H2S and COS each (Kubek et al. 2002) which is still more than the synthesis catalysts can tolerate. This is not an issue, however, in power applications where the sulfur slip is less critical. The ratio of absorption coefficients for H2S, CO2 is about 1:9 in descending order of solubility 2.4.5 Catalyst Selected Catalyst selected was iron with potassium oxide and molybdenum as promoters. Reasons for selection are as follows:
32
1. Iron catalyst is cheap as compared to others. Although cobalt has very good selectivity but it is 230 times more expensive than iron 2. Shelf life of iron catalyst is more. 3. It is easily available in market [8]
gases to product gas. In particular, the higher steam conversion obtained under slagging conditions can lead to a significant improvement in throughput. For operations at slagging temperatures the reaction kinetics are fast and differences in coal are less important than that non slagging temperatures. The ash type should be such that a sufficiently mobile slag is obtained at the operating temperature. In particular, ashes with a higher fusion temperature are generally unfavorable for slagging operation. 2. Pressure Gasification process may be operated either at atmospheric pressure or at elevated pressure. Equilibrium considerations indicate that operation at elevated pressure tends to discourage the decomposition of carbon dioxide and steam and the formation of carbon mono oxide and hydrogen. At higher pressures the formation of methane by the hydro gasification reaction is favored by equilibrium considerations. Pressure of at least 80bar is generally regarded as necessary for hydro gasification based processes. Many of the downstream units operate at elevated pressure, usually in the range 10 to 30 bar. In general there are therefore two process design options; either the reactants are compressed and the gasifier operated at elevated pressure or the gasifier is operated at atmospheric pressure and the product gas compressed for further processing. The advantages for the process efficiency and throughput are generally are regarded as favoring pressurized operation in large scale applications. For this reason most of the current development effort on coal gasification is being directed towards elevated pressure systems. 3. Reactant Gases The three basic reactants for gasification process are oxygen, steam and hydrogen. These can be used in a number of ways in practical schemes:
34
Oxygen/steam In gasifiers using oxygen and steam the heat absorbed by the endothermic water gas reaction is provided by the combustion reactions between oxygen and coal giving an overall heat balance within the gasifier Air/steam For applications in which the presence of nitrogen in the product gas is not a disadvantage, air can be used instead of oxygen thereby saving air separation costs. In this case the stream requirements are lower because more sensible heat is needed to bring the air to the reaction temperature. Air At slagging temperatures it is possible to satisfy the heat balance requirements using air alone as the gasifying agent, the heat released by the combustion reactions being balanced entirely by the sensible heat required to bring the air to reaction temperature. Steam may, however, be required in small quantities for control purposes to maintain a heat balance if the air is preheated or if oxygen enriched air is used. Under non slagging conditions air may be used alone if heat is removed from the process by other than the endothermic stream carbon reactions. Steam The capital and operating costs of air separation plant are substantial and this factor has encouraged interest in processes that produce a nitrogen free gas using steam alone. In this case the heat absorbed by the water gas reaction has to be provided by a method other than oxidation in the gasifier [5]
35
The conversion of carbon dioxide to carbon mono oxide by the Boudouard reaction is somewhat slower still (typically by half an order magnitude) with the hydro gasification and methanation reactions being slower than the Boudouard reaction by about a further two orders of magnitude. The diffusion rates very comparatively little with the type of reactants. The main factor is the molecular weight, hydrogen diffusion quicker than the other species. In practice, for gasification processes using oxygen or air, the oxygen is consumed rapidly at the beginning of the reaction zone and other reactions occur more slowly as the resulting gases pas through remainder of the reactor .Both the combustion and partial combustion reactions can occur at the surface of the coal particles. The term pyrolysis covers a variety of reactions that may be either chemical rate controlled or transitional at non slagging temperatures. At slagging temperatures, pyrolysis reactions are generally diffusion rate controlled and are comparatively fast. The other reactions- Boudouard, hydro gasification, water-gas, shift and methanationare generally chemical rate controlled under non slagging conditions [5]
37
Fluidized Bed Gasefier In fluidized bed gasifiers the reactant gases are used to fluidize a bed of particulate material containing the coal. The bed can be regarded as being well mixed in order to avoid sintering of the ash and the consequent loss of fluidization, fluidized bed gasifiers are restricted to operating at non-slagging temperatures. Fluidized bed gasification is illustrated in figure.
38
2.7.2 Molten Bath Molten bath gasifiers are similar to fluidized bed systems in that the reactions take place in a well-mixed medium of high inertia. In this case, however, a bath of molten slag, metal or salt is used. The operating temperature depends on the type of bath; for slag or molten metal baths, a high temperature (1400-1700 oC) is necessary but temperatures as low as 1000 C can be used with molten salts. The reactant gases may be injected from above as jets which penetrate the surface of the bath or may be fed to the bottom of the bath. In either case a good gas-solid contacting is obtained. 2.7.3 Entrained Phase In an entrained phase gasifier coal pulverised to less than 0.1 mm is injected with the reactant gases into a chamber where the gasification reactions take place in a flame similar to that of a pulverised fuel combustion system. This approach is used in the commercial Koppers-Totzek process. It appears that a non-slagging operation in an entrained phase gasifier is attractive only for hydro-gasification processes where partial conversion of the coal is acceptable
39
3 Material Balance
3.1 Material Balance on Dryer
H2O = 0.3
DRYER
Overall balance F0 = W + F1
40
W 0 100% 255.3191
F1 94% 6% 744.6809
41
F3
F1 F2
GASIFIER
F4
F1 F2 F3 F4
= = = =
Thar coal composition (dry basis) XC XH2 XN2 = = = 0.621 0.069 0.003 42
XO2 XS Ash
= = =
THAR COALCOMPOSOTION (WET BASIS) XC XH2 XN2 XO2 XS Ash = = = = = = 0.58374 0.06486 0.00282 0.2632 0.00188 0.025 .94
Mass flow rate of Coal = F1 = 744.68 kg/hr. Cp(carbon) = 0.709 KJ/kgK Cp(H2) Cp(N2) Cp(O2) Cp(S) Cp(gas) =14.304 KJ/kgK =1.04 KJ/kgK =0.918KJ/kgK =0.71KJ/kgK =2.728 KJ/kgK [9]
XCO XH2
= =
? ? ? ?
XH2S = XN2 =
Reaction 3C + H2O +O23CO+H2 Let suppose the conversion of the reaction is B=80% in the gasifier. Carbon moles in feed K moles of carbon in feed = F1XC/MC= 36.22496 k moles Steam Moles in Feed 3 k moles of carbon react with = 1 k mole steam 1 k mole carbon react with = 1/3 k moles of steam 44
36.225 k moles of carbon react with = 36.2250.33 k moles of steam 36.225 k moles of carbon react with = 12.06291 k moles of steam So, 217.1324 kg/hr. of steam is required. H 2O Available = 44.64 kg/hr.
Actual required= required H 2O - available H 2O Actual Required H2O= F4=172.4924 kg/hr Oxygen Moles in Feed 3 moles of carbon react with 1 k mole carbon react with 1 k mole of carbon react with = 1 k mole of oxygen = 1/3 k moles of oxygen = 0.333 moles of oxygen
36.225 k moles of carbon react with = 36.2250.33 k moles of oxygen 36.225 k moles of carbon react with = 12.06291 k moles of oxygen So, 386.0132 kg/hr is required. Oxygen available = 196 kg/hr Actual required = required oxygen - available oxygen Actual Required Oxygen=F2= 190.0134 kg/hr Carbon Balance F1XC/MC=n CO 36.225=n CO eq no 1
45
Sulfur Balance F1XS/MS=nH2S nH2S= 0.04374995 k moles Hydrogen Balance F1XH/MH+F4+nH2S=nH2 nH2=36.06496712 k moles Nitrogen Balance F1XN2/MN2=nN2 nN2= 0.074999914 k moles
Table 3-2: Summary Of Material Balance On Gasefier
Stream
F1 F2 F3 F4 Total
----
1107.185
1107.185
46
47
Gas
Mole fraction
Mole wt
28 2.016 34.016 28
48
CYCLONE SEPARATOR
S2 SOLIDS
Inlet composition (outlet of gasifier=F5=1090.01743 kg/hr = 72.37014613 k mole/hr Solids= S1 = 30kg/hr (assumed) [10]
=? =?
Gas entering cyclone separator= F5 = F3 = 1090.01743 kg/hr Solids particles entering into cyclone= S1=30 kg/hr Efficiency of cyclone separator for removal of particles larger than 10m= 80%= 0.8 Kg of solids cyclone removed=S2=S1Efficiency= 49 24 kg/hr
Material solids removed S2 Gases leaving cyclone separator F8 solids in gas stream S3
50
G1 SYN GAS IN
Scrubber inlet (outlet of cyclone separator) = G1= 69.67015 kmole/hr Syn gas composition=YI Syn g=1-XCO2= 0.98 Y1 CO2at inlet = 0.02 Kg of solids entering=S=6 kg/hr Kg of water entering=L1=? K mole of gases exiting =G2=? Kg of water leaving=L2=? CO2 in leaving liquid=? Assuming equilibrium condition At 760 mm hg and 25 degrees centigrade 100 kg H2O absorbs 1.5 kg CO2 Equilibrium partial of CO2 and H2O 51
PH2O= 10 mm hg P CO2= 12 mm hg P (atm) = 760 mm hg So the composition of exiting gas (G2) Y2 CO2=P CO2 / P (atm) = 0.015789474 X2 H2O = 0.013157895 Syn gas composition =y2 Syn gas=1-Y CO2 = 0.984210526 Syn gas balance Gas in = gas out
G1*YI Syng= Y2SyngG2 G2=G1Y1syng / Y2syng = 69.37209588 k mole/hr Composition of H2O and CO2 in liquid leaving L2 at equilibrium 1.5 kgCO2 / 100kg H2O YCO2= 0.014778325 XH2O= 0.985221675 CO2 Balance Molecular WT of CO2= 44 kg/k mole G1Y1CO2MCO2= G2Y2CO2MCO2+XCO2L2 52
L2= [(G1Y1CO2MCO2)-(Y2CO2G2MCO2)]/YCO2 L2= 887.4064596 kg/hr Water balance L1=G2X2H2O+L2XH20 L1=875.2048692 kg/hr Solid balance All solid will be removed in the scrubber Solid enter=solid leave Solid leave with liquid = solid at the exit of cyclone separator
= 6 kg Table 3-4: Summery Of Material Balance On Scrubber
H2 H2S N2
53
250 K
210 K
258 K
Mass flow rate of gas in, Gin or mass flow rate out of scrubber = 1061.3931kg /hr H2S in gas from previous data H2S in gas from previous data in moles Suppose the percentage of H2S gas removed from gas H2S removed = 0.9H2S in gas Mass flow rate of gas out =G0= Gin H2S removed 54 = 1.4874983 kg/hr = 0.04375 kmol/hr = 90% =1.33874847 kg/hr =1060.05435kg/hr
To find out flow rate of selexol, we have to apply energy balance around H 2S absorber for gas Cp of gas Temperature of gas in Temperature of gas out Using the relation Q = 2.05 kJ/kg0C [11] = 210.3107 k = 250.3107k
Q = GO Cp T = 24.14568245 KW
For selexol Cp of selexol= 2.0 KJ/Kg Temperature of selexol in = T in = 298.15 K Temperature of selexol out = Tout = 258 Using the relation Q=F (m)CpT
Solving above equation for F (m) SO, mass flow rate of selexol in, F (m) = Fin = Q/Cp T =-0.294459542 kg/s SO, mass flow rate of selexol in (m) = Fin =-1060.054352 kg/hr
Mass flow rate of selexol out=Fout= -1061.3931kg/hr Negative sign shows that energy is being transferred from selexol to gas. selexol is getting Cool. It does not represent negative magnitude of masses or flow rate.
55
56
4 Energy Balance
4.1 Energy Balance on Heat Exchanger
F6 H2O IN
F3 SYN GAS IN
HEAT EXCHANGER
F7 STEAM OUT
Temperature of syn gas outlet=T2=363 k Flow rate of cooling water=F6=? Temperature of cooling water=T3=298 k Flow rate of steam outlet=F7=? Temperature of steam outlet=T4=?
57
Using formula Q = m cp t CP gas = 2.75509 kJ/kg oC CP H2O = 4.625 kJ/kg oC For gas, Q gas= m gascp gast gas Q gas=614.8005115kw (divided by 3600 for conversion in sec) As, Energy given by gas = Energy gained by water
Assuming 70% heat transfer, Q gas=430.360358KW As temperature difference between in and out of gas is = 1200-363=837k.
Efficiency of exchanger is 70% means 70%of energy will be transferred to water. So rise In Temperature of water will also be 70% of the temperature difference, i.e. 70% of (1200-363). Rise in temp of water=T rise=585.9 k Temp of water out =T4=883.9k for 70% efficiency
Flow of water in=F6=? Latent heat=s=1569.15 kJ/kg oC [12] Heat given by gas=heat gained by water Q gained by water =Q gas 58
QH2O= [m cp (t4-t3)] +s Or m=QH2O/ [(cp*(t4-t3)) + s] For 100% efficiency of exchanger F6 (m) =517.2503317 kg/hr F6=F7= 517.2503 kg/hr Heat loss Heat in - heat out =184.44 KW (multiplied by 3600 for kg/hr)
59
Product
DRYER
F1 = 744.68kg / hr T3 = 303K
Calorific value of coal in F0= 29396 KJ/kg Calorific value of coal in F1= 25227 KJ/kg Specific heat of air at T1= Cp1= 29.14 kJ/k mol K= 1 kJ/kg-K Specific heat of air at T2 =C pA= 29.08kJ/k mol-K = 1 kJ/kg-K Specific heat of water at T2=C pw= 4.169 kJ/kg-K 60
Reference temperature =TR= 298 K Heat In Heat in by F0 Q0= F0 C.V = (1000 29396)/3 = 8165 kW
Heat in by A Q1=AC p1 T =A 1 (328 - 298) = 30A kW Heat Out Heat out by A+W Eq no 2
Q2 = F2 C P2 T
C P2 = ( C PA + C PW )/2
= 2.5845 KJ/kg-K
61
Heat out by Q3 Q3= F1 C.V = (744.68 25227) = 5218 Kw A Calculation Total heat in 8165 + 30 A = Total heat out = 5218 + 49.1(A+ 0.103)
8165 - 5218 3.476 =(49.1 - 30) A A =54.11 kg/s = 554799.6 kg/hr Then A+W= 555054.79 kg/hr Q1= 4623.3 KW Q2=7570.3KW Heat Losses Heat Losses = Total Heat in Total Heat Out = 12788.3 1278 = .3 kW
62
1100 K
F4 STEAM
F2 O2
F1 COAL
353 K
(80 c temperatures is maintained. Because spontaneous does take place if temperature rises due To oxidation) Ambient temperature = Ta = 298 K
63
Energy in coal=mCpt Energy in coal= 55977.18603 KJ/hr Energy in coal = 15.54921834KW Energy in oxygen Amount of oxygen = 190.013kg/hr
Temperature of oxygen= 883.9 k Room temperature= 298 k Cpair= 0.918 KJ/Kg K Energy in oxygen= 102199.6701 KJ/hr Energy in oxygen= 28.38879726 KW Total energy in gasifier=E1= 43.9380156KW Heat generated in gasifier 123456CO+1/2CO2 CO2 H2+O2 H 2O C+H2O CO+H2 C+CO2 2CO2 CO+H2O CO2+H2 H2+S H2S H1 H2 H3 H4 H5 H6 = = = = = = -393.77 KJ/k mole of carbon 742 131 172 KJ/k mole of H2 KJ/k mole of carbon KJ/k mole of carbon
64
K mole/hr
kg/hr
CO H2 H2S N2 F3
Calculation of heat of chemical reactions From reaction Heat evolved from reaction =R= k moleH/3600 Heat absorbed from reaction no1 =R1= 7.433390445 KW Heat absorbed from reaction no1 =R1= 2.624728163 KW Heat absorbed from reaction no1 =R1= 0.42242375 KW Heat absorbed from reaction NO1 =R1= 0.520938414 KW Heat of reaction H2= 11.00148077 KW
65
Heat in flue gases Cp of flue gases Temperature of flue gases Reference temperature Mass of flue gases Energy in the flue gases Energy in the flue gases E2= 662.4447707 KW = 2.728 =1100 k = 298 k = 1090.01743 kg/hr =mCpT =mCpT kJ/kg k from literature
66
H2O IN AT T7
SYN GAS IN AT T5
Temperature of gases entering scrubber Cp of product gas= Cp=2.75509 KJ/kg .k Cp of water Temperature of water entering scrubber
= T5 = 363 K
Temperature of exiting gases from scrubber=T6=? Temperature of exiting water from scrubber =T8= 308 K T8 is supposed to be 308 k as our own choice because by controlling water flow we can control Temperature. Less flow rate of water will cause more temperature of water and more flow rate Of water will cause less increase in temperature of water. Flow rate of gas entering is average of = m gas = 1061.39kg/hr 67
values are
Average flow rate of water entering= m H20 = 881.3 kg/hr Energy balance for water Q= m Cp T Q= 10.23287222 k w Energy balance for gas Energy taken by water Q gas =-10.23287 K Because energy is being released by gas to water Q =m C p T OR T6 = (3600Q/m Cp) + T5 = Energy given by gas divided by 3600 for conversion into sec.
Because mass in kg/hr so energy should be in hr Also, T6= 350.4023605 K Q H2O= 36838.34 KW Q gas= 36838.332 KW
68
5 Equipment Design
5.1 Fluidized Bed Gasifier Design [13]
(From chemical process equipment by couper)
Weight of mixture of particles Bed is supposed to hold Density of particles= p Volumetric flow rate of gas
=744.68 kg
=1.42902kg/m3
D m wt fraction
252 0.088
178 0.178
126 0.293
89 0.194
70 0.113
50 .078
30 0.042
10 0.014
ut(m/s)
3.45
1.72
0.86
0.43
0.27
0.14
0.049
0.0054
with dp=84.54 And density difference of = 1698.57098 kg/m3 Material appears to be in group a of fig 6.12 of chemical process equipment by couper
70
Using eq 6.136 Umb = (33)(dp)(/) ^ (-0.01) Umb = 0.002911249 m/s umb/umf= 0.561944832 Using eq 6.138 Umb/umf= ((82)(^0.6)(^0.06))/ ((g)*(DP^1.3)(p-)) Umb/umf= 1.510541123
71
3. Voidage at minimum bubbling (From 6.139) mb^3/ (1-mb) = (47.4)((g)(DP^3)(p^2)/ (^2)) ^ (-0.5) mb^3/ (1-mb) = 0.231110476 Put mb mb =0.5 it approximately satisfies equation = 0.5 eq no 4
Operating gas velocity Ratios of entraining and minimum fluidizing velocities from two smallest particle sizes present are 16.83126162 for 30m and 1.042336706 for 10m. Entrainment of smallest particles cannot be avoided, but an appreciable Multiple of minimum fluidizing velocity can be used for operation [14] Say ratio is 5 so that Uf = 0.025903338 m/s
Bed expansion ratio from figure 6.10c with dp = 84.5404 m =0.0033 in And Gf/Gmf= 5 R = 1.16 by interpolation by full lines
From equation 6.140 ratio of voidages is mb/mf mb/mf = (Gmb/Gmf) ^0.22 = 1.424863957
Fluctuations in levels From figure 6.10d with Dp The value of mmSO r =exp ((m-(Gf-Gmf)/Gmf) r = 1.083287068 = 0.02 =0.02 = 0.0033 in
TDH from fig 6.10i at chemical process equipment by couper uf uf =umf(for 30m)-4(umf) =0.02827733 m/s 73
4. Vessel diameter Vessel diameter=D= ((vol flow of gas per sec4)/ (0.3053.14)) ^ (0.5) Vessel diameter=D= 0.394066888 m from 6.10i using D &uf in cm/s TDH= 1 approx 5. Bed Height With charge of 10000kg of solids and a voidage at minimum bubbling of 5 the height of Minimum bubbling bed is L= (wt of mix particles) / ((density of particles)(1-mb) (3.14/4) (D^2)) L=7.186893649 m This value includes expansion factor which was calculated separately above but not the fluctuation parameter. With this parameter bed height is bed height Lb = Lb=Lr =7.785468947 m 6. Vessel height The vessel height is made up of this number + TDH OR Vessel height=Lb+ TDH Vessel height= 8.785468947 m
74
Equipment No. 1 Function: Gasification of Coal GASIFIER Sheet No. 1 Operating Data Height No. of Units 8.78m 1 Type Connected Performance of One Unit Circulating fluid coal steam oxygen Syn gas In (kg/hr) 744.68 172.492 190.013 ------Construction of Gasifier Vessel diameter Bed height Minimum fluidizing velocity 0.394m 7.78,m 0.02827733 m/s Out (kg/hr) --------------1107.185 Fluidized Bed Vertically
75
HEAT EXCHANGER
LENGTH OF TUBES=4.88 m
Feed flow rate in Feed flow rate out Mass flow rate of cooling water in Mass flow rate of cooling water out Temperature of gas in Temperature of gas out Temp of cooling water in Temp of cooling water out Specific heat of water
= F1= 1090.01743 kg/hr = F2 = 1090.01743 kg/hr = F3 =? Kg/hr = F4 =? Kg/hr = T1 = 826.85 oC = T2 = 89.85 oC = T3 = 24.85 oC = T4 =610.75 oC = cp= 4.625 kJ/kg oC
76
1. Heat load on heat exchanger Q = m Cp T For gas Q = m Cp T Q = 614.8005115 KW = 614800.5115 W For water Q =mCpT m = Q/ (CpT) m = 0.226881448 kg/sec m = 816.7732124 kg/hr 2. Log mean temp difference LMTD=Tlm= ((T1-T4)-(T2-T3))/ ((ln ((T1-T4)/ (T2-T3))) Tlm =125.7747515 0C
3. Overall heat transfer coefficient Assume overall heat transfer coefficient U= 80 W/m2C 4. Heat transfer area Q=UATlm 77
A=Q/UTlm A=61.10134429 m2 5. Exchanger type & dimensions Shell and tube heat exchanger Standard dimension of exchanger Inner diameter of tubes= i.d= Di=16 mm= 0.016 m Outer diameter of tubes=o.d=Do= 30 mm= 0.03 m Length of tubes Area of one tube A= DoL = 0.459696 m Tube pitch Tube pitch=Pt=1.25Do Pt = 0.0375 m cupro nickel =L= 4.88 m
Number of tubes Nt =Number of tubes Nt = heat transfer area / area of one tube = 132.91685 Bundle diameter Db = Do(Nt/K1) ^ (1/n1) Using triangular pitch and two passes 78
K1= 0.249 n1= 2.207 Db= 516.3066323 m Shell diameter Diameter of shell =Ds=Db+ clearance
Using split ring floating head type: Clearance Ds = 36.604 mm = 552.9106323 mm 6. Tube side heat transfer coefficient (H2O) Tube side heat transfer coefficient can be calculated as Mean gas temperature = Tm= 458.35 OC
Tube cross sectional area Ai= (Di^2)/4 Ai Tubes per pass = Tpp = 0.00020096 m2 = Nt / 2 = 66.45842501 Total flow area Total flow area = At=TppAi At = 0.013355485 m2
Gas mass velocity = Gs= mass flow rate of gas/At = 81615.71239 kg / m2.hr Water linear velocity= Ut H20 79
Hi H2O= (JhRePr^0.33Kf(/w) ^0.14)/Di ReH2O= UtDi/s = GDi/ H2O = 1000 KG/m3 H2O = 0.8 mNS/m2 Kf H2O =0.59 W/m.C Viscosity of gas = gas Density of gas = =0.01258589 Ns/m2 = 0.77026 kg/m3
Thermal conductivity of gas= Kfs= 0.0125 W/mOC Re H20= 58807.67129 Pr H20 = Cps/Kfs = 6.271186441 L/Di =305
By using graph 12.23 coulson vol 6 we can find value of transfer factor jh JhH20 = 0.036 hi H20 = 80010.14719 W/m2.C
80
7. Shell side heat transfer coefficient (gas with lagged shell) De shell = equivalent diameter De De = (1.10/Do)(Pt^2-0.0917Do^2) = 0.0485364 m
G (GAS) = mass flow rate of gas / As Cp gas = 2.75509 kJ/kg .0C G GAS gas = 59425.42679 kg/m2 = density of gas = 0.77026 kg/m3 Gas = viscosity of gas = 0.01258589 NS/m2 Kf gas = thermal conductivity of gas = 0.0125 W / m .0C Re gas = gUgDe/g = G gDe/g = 314743.9603 (multiply by 1000 for per hr calculation)
81
Pr gas
= Cpg/K fg = 2.774020774
Baffle cut=20 to 25% optimum Heat transfer coefficient jh By using the graph find value of heat transfer coefficient factor jh. Jh =0.1
hs=shell side transfer coefficient hs hs = (JhRePr^0.33Kf gas(/h20) ^0.14) / De [10] = 6347.127367 W/m2 0C
Fouling coefficients Hid = Tube side fouling coefficient Hid = 9000 W/m2c Hod =Shell side fouling factor Hod = 7500 W/m2c 8. Overall heat transfer coefficient Thermal conductivity of cupro nickel alloys=K= 50 W/m2 0C 1/ Uo =1/Hs+1/Hi+ ((Doln (Do/Di)/2K)) + (Do/Di)(1/Hid) + (Do/Di)(1/Hi) 1/Uo =0.000405502 Uo = 2466.081172
82
9. Pressure drop Tube side From fig 12.24 graph value of friction factor=Jf Jf Np = 0.002 = number of tube side passes = 2
Pt m
83
Equipment No.2 Heat exchanger Function: Steam Generation Sheet No.2 Operating Data Size
61.101 m2
Shell Side Fluid Circulating In Gases Water Temperature Pressure Drop 512.195kg/hr 298K Out 512.195kg/hr 883.9k In Water
1090.017kg/hr 1100k
1.91014N/m2
9.61011 N/m2
Construction of Shell
4.8m 16mm
--------------
-----------
84
2. Inlet duct area of gas The optimum velocity of separator having range 10-20 Let U Inlet duct area Ai =15m/sec = flow rate / u =0.6672 / 15 Ai =0.04448 m2
This is too large compared with slandered diameter of 0.203 m therefore multiple cyclones should be tried. 4. Length of upper section Lc = 1.5Dc = 1.0003m 5. Length of lower section
Zc
= 2.5Dc =1.6672m
Total height = Lc + Zc = 4Dc = 2.667m2 6. Outlet duct area of gas D0 = 0.5Dc = 0.3334m
A0
Dd
=0.5Dc =0.33345m
86
=7.7610-3 m/sec Dc is too large compared with standard diameter of 0.203 m therefore multiple cyclones should be tried. Flow per cyclone Viscosity of gas = 530.008715 kg/hr =2 = 0.01258589 Cp
Particle size m
50
40
30
20
10
90
75
65
55
30
10
87
d2/ (d1) = ((((Dc2/Dc1) ^3)(Q1/Q2)(1/2)(2/1)) ^1.2) Diameter of standard cyclone =Dc1 =0.203 m
Standard flow rate for high efficiency design = Q1 = 223 m3/hr Solid fluid density difference in standard condition =1= 2000 kg/m3 Test fluid viscosity (at 1 atm 20 c)=1 Scaling factor = d2/d = 0.018m Ns/m2 =3.422583401
The performance calculations, using this scaling factor and fig 10.4a are set out in the table below
88
Particle size
% age in range
Collected
% At exit
Percent in rangeefficency/100
10 15 10 10 25 20 6 4
11 10 7 5 3 2 1 0
94 93 88 85 75 50 30 0
89
12. Pressure drop calculations From 10.44 a & b Coulson vol 6 pg 450 Area of inlet duct= A1 = 0.0254863 m2
rt/re =((0.5Dc+0.2Dc+0.2Dc)-(0.2Dc/2))/(0.5Dc) rt / re=1.599970596 From figure 10.47 coulson vol 6 u1 u1 =0.8 = vol flow of gas (in m3/sec) / A1 (m2) = 7.499559261 m/s
Area of exit pipe= (3.14((0.5Dc) ^2))/4 Area of exit pipe= 0.050013924 m u2 u2 = vol flow gas (in m3/sec) / area of exit pipe in m2 =3.821656123 m/s
From equation 10.9 coulson vol 6 P = (( gas) / (203))((u1^2) (1+ (2(^2)((2(rt/re)-1)) + (2(u2^2))P = 7.048064493 mille bar
90
Equipment No.3 Cyclone Separator Function: Heavy Particle Separation Sheet No.3 Operating Data Height No of unit 2.667m 2 Type Category Cyclone Centrifugal Force
Process Data of One Unit Material solids removed Gases entering Gases leaving cyclone solids in gas stream Optimum Velocity Terminal Velocity Pressure Drop Flow Rate(Kg/hr) 24 1090.01743 1066.017 6 15m/s 7.7610-3m/s 7.048 mille bar
91
Technical Data
Diameter of Cyclone
0.6669m
Upper Section
0.04448 m2
0.3334m
1.0003m
Lower Section
0.25m
1.6672m
92
DIAMETER 0.49838 m
Flow rate of liquid in = 875.20487 kg/hr Flow rate of gas out = 1066 kg/hr Flow rate of liquid out = 887.40646 kg/hr Temp of gas in Temp of gas out Temp of liq in = 363 k = 255.3728 k = 298 k 93
Temp of liquid out Density of syn gas Viscosity of gas Heat capacity of gas Density of water Viscosity of water Heat capacity of water Mole wt of liquid
= 308 k = 0.77026 kg/m3 = 0.012586 NS/m2 = 2.75509 kJ/kg 0C = 1000 kg/m3 = 0.0035 NS/m2 = 4.625 kJ/kg0C = 18 kg/k mole
1. Packing specification Packing type intallox saddle (ceramic) Packing size=dp Packing factor = fp = 0.038 m = 170 m^-1
Porosity of packing factor= c = 70 Surface area of packing =a= 194 m2/m3 2. Column area required Column area required =Ax =? Ax = V / Vw First we find out Vw FLv= (L/V) ((gas density / liq den) ^ 0.5) FLv= 0.022786163 K4 = 1.9 for 42mmH2O/m packing 94
At flooding K4 =6 3. Percentage flooding Percentage flooding =(((k4 at 42mmH2O/m packing) / (k4 at flooding line)) ^ 0.5) 100 Percentage flooding= 56.27% For Vw Vw = ((k4 density gas (liq den - gas den)) / (13.1fp((visliq / den liq) ^ 0.1))) ^ 0.5 Table 11.3 for 38 mm packing 1.5 inch intallox sadlles Fp = 170 m^-1 Vw = 1.518674281 kg/m2 sec Column area required=Ax= 0.19498 m2 4. Column diameter Column diameter=d= (4Ax/3.14)^0.5 d = 0.49837954 m
Ratio of packing size to column diameter = Ax / packing size = 5.131052629 5. Height of overall gas phase transfer unit HoG HoG =HG+ (m(Gm/Lm))HL HG HL =Gm/ (KGawP) =Lm/ (KLawCt)
aw/a=1-(exp((-1.45)((c/L)^0.75)((Lw/(aL))^0.1)(((Lw^2a)/(L^2g))^95
0.05)((Lw^2/ (LLa)) ^0.2))) c= 0.061 mN/m L= 0.0247 mN/m g = 9.81 m2/sec Lw*= L / Ax w* = 4488.690484 kg/m2 sec aw /a= 0.998393899 aw= 193.6884164 m2 6. Liquid mass transfer coefficient DL= 1.7E-09 m2/sec Dv= 0.0000145 m2/sec KL((L/(Lg))^0.33)=(0.0051)((Lw/(awL))^(2/3))((L/(LDL))^0.5)((adp)^0.4) KL((L/(Lg))^0.33)= 0.088123835 KL= 0.002964057 K5=5.23 (KG/a)((RT)/Dv) (KG/a)((RT)/Dv) =(K5)((Vw/ (av)) ^0.7)((v/ (vDv)) ^0.33)((adp) ^-2) = 0.701608509
KG= 7.75506E-05 k mole/m2.sec.bar 7. Gas film transfer coefficient HG=Gm/ (KG a P) Gm=Vw / mole wt Avg mole wt of gas = 17.63 kg/k mole Gm= 0.086141479 Pressure of column = 101.325 K pa HG= 5.652179469 HL = Lm / (KL aw Ct) Lm = Lw / mole wt Mole wt of water Lm = 249.3716935 Ct =L / mole wt Ct = 55.555 HL = 7.818607187 m AS HOG=HG+ (m (Gm/Lm))HL m (Gm/Lm) =0.7 TO 0.8= 0.75 HOG =11.51613486m = 18kg/ k mole
97
8. Height of packing Z =Height of packing Z = HOG NOG Mass fraction of particles = mass of particles / total mass
Mass of particles entering scrubber seen from material balance on cyclone= 6 kg/hr Mass fraction of particles in = 0.005628518 Considering 90% removal of particles = 0.90 mass fraction at inlet of scrubber = 0.005065666 y1 So Fraction of particles at outlet of scrubber = inlet fraction - removed fraction = 0.000562852 y2 y1 / y2 =9
Using graph 11.40 of Coulson vol 6 NOG Z =4.85 =55.85325407m 1. Height of scrubber Height of scrubber = height of packing + HoG + HL + HG Height of scrubber = 80.84017558 m (15)
98
Equipment No.3 Scrubber Function: Separation of Gases Sheet No.3 Column area Percentage flooding Packing type Height of packing Scrubber height HOG
0.19498 m2
57% Intalox saddle
55.85m 80.840 m
11.51m
99
ABSORBER HEIGHT 26 m
DIAMETER 0.59 m
Temp of gas in Temp of gas out Temp of liquid in Temp of liquid out Density of gas=gas
Pressure of column= 101.3k pa = 1.013 bars R T M =15.3 kg/k mole Viscosity of gas = Heat capacity of gas Density of liquid = Viscosity of liquid = Heat capacity of liq Mole wt of liquid 1. Packing specification Packing type intallox saddle (ceramic) Packing size = dp Packing factor = Fp = 0.038 m = 170 m-1 = 0.012586 Ns/m2 = 2.75509 KJ / kg 0C = 1031 KG/m3 = 4.7 Ns/m2 =2.05 KJ / kg 0C = 178 kg/k mole =0.083143 bar.m3/kg mole k =254.23035 K
Surface area of packing = A=194 m2/m3 2. Column area required Column area required =Ax=? Ax = V/Vw
First we find out Vw FLv = (L/V)(( gas/ liq) ^ 0.5) Density of gas = gas = 0.77026 kg/m3 FLv = 0.027301116 K4 = 1.9 At flooding K4 = 6 3. Percentage flooding Percentage flooding = ((k4 at 42 mmH2O/ m packing/k4 at flooding line) ^0.5)100 = 56.27314339 For Vw Vw = ((K4v( L- gas))/ (13.1Fp((L/ L) ^0.1))) ^0.5 Table 11.3 for 38mm 1.5 inch intallox saddles Fp = 170 m-1 Vw = 1.077359006 kg/m2sec for 42 mmH2O/m packing
Ax
102
Ratio of packing size to column diameter =AX / packing Size 5. Height of overall gas phase transfer unit (using Ondas method) HoG =Height of overall gas phase transfer unit HoG =HG+ (m (Gm/Lm))HL HG HL =Gm/ (KGawP) = Lm/ (KLawCt) =7.201611951
aw/a = 1-(exp((-1.45)((c/L)^0.75)((Lw/(aL))^0.1)(((Lw^2a)/(L^2g))^0.05)((Lw^2/(LLa))^0.2))) C g L Lw* Lw* = 0.061 mN/m =9.81 m/s2 = 0.0247 mN/m =L/Ax = 1.076097207 kg/m2sec
(KG/a)((RT)/Dv)= (K5)((V w/ (av))^0.7)((v/ (vDv))^0.33)((adp) ^2)(KG/a)((RT)/Dv)= 0.551724047 (KG/a = 4.57512E-07 KG = 8.87574E-05 k mole / m2.sec.bar
Gas film transfer coefficient HG HG Gm Gm HG = gas film transfer coefficient =Gm/ (KG a P) =Vw/mole WT = 0.061109416 kmole/m2.sec = 3.503421355 m
Lm Ct Ct HL AS
HOG =HG+ (m (Gm/Lm))HL m (Gm/Lm) =0.7 TO 0.8=0.75 HOG =3.714349746 6. Height of packing Z Z Y1 =Height of packing = HOG NOG = mole fraction at inlet = 0.3125 k mole/hr of H2S Y2 = mole fraction at outlet = 0.03125 k mole/hr of H2S YI/Y2= 10 Using graph 11.40 of Coulson vol 6 NOG=5 Z =18.57174873 m m
105
7. Total column height Height of absorber Height of absorber = Z+ HoG +HL+HG = 26.07075768 m [15]
Equipment No.4 Absorber Function: Separation of Gases Sheet No.4 Column area Percentage flooding Packing type Height of packing Absorber height HOG 0.416m2 57% Intalox saddle 18.59m 26.07m 3.714349746m
106
6 Instrumentation
Instrumentation is carried out to monitor the key process variables during plant operation. And instruments may be incorporated in automatic control loops or used for the manual monitoring of the process operation. There may be manual or automatic computer data logging system. Instruments monitoring critical process variables will be fitted with automatic alarms to alert the operators to critical and hazardous situations. Industry pursuit of increasingly stringent process control and safety requirements led to an early adaptation of computational techniques in this field. Today, a wide range of computing devices, ranging from imbedded microprocessors to dedicated computers, is commonly employed throughout the industry. This class explores the technical foundations of process and control instrumentation in use, and covers the practical aspects of its deployment and control [17]. Measurement Instrumentation can be used to measure certain field parameters (physical values).These measured values include: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. Pressure Flow Temperature Level Density Viscosity Radiation Frequency Current 107
6.1 Control
In addition to measuring field parameters, instrumentation is also responsible for providing the ability to modify some field parameters to keep the process variables at a desired value.[8] 6.1.1 Incentives For Chemical Process Control A chemical plant is an arrangement of processing units (reactor, heat exchanger, pumps, distillation columns, absorbers, evaporators, tanks etc.), integrated with one another in a systematic and rational manner. The plants overall objective is to convert certain raw materials into desired products using available sources of energy, in the most economical way. In its operation, a chemical plant must satisfy several requirements imposed by its designers and the general technical, economic and social conditions in the presence of ever-changing external influences (disturbances). Among such requirements are the following: Safety The safe operation of a chemical process is a primary requirement for the well-being of the people in the plant and for its continued contribution to the economic development.
108
1. Production Specification A plant should produce the desired amounts and quality of the final products. Therefore, a control system is needed to ensure that the production level and the purity specifications are satisfied. 2. Environmental Regulations Various federal and state laws may specify that the temperature, concentrations of chemicals, and flow rates of the effluents from a plant be within certain limits. 3. Operational Constraints The various types of equipment used in a chemical plant have constraints inherited to their operation. Such constraints should be satisfied throughout the operation of the plant .e.g. pumps must maintain a certain net positive suction head etc. 4. Economics The operation of a plant must conform to the market conditions, that is, the availability of the raw materials and the demand of the final products. Furthermore, it should be as economical as possible in its utilization of raw materials, energy, and capacity and human labor. Thus it is required that the operating conditions are controlled at given optimum levels of minimum operating cost, maximum profit and so on [18]. 6.1.2 Elements Of Control System In almost every control configuration, we can distinguish the following hardware elements. 1. The chemical process 2. Measuring element or sensors 3. Transducers 4. Transmission lines 5. Controllers 6. The final control element 109
1. The Chemical Process It represents the material equipment together with physical or chemical operation that occurs. 2. The Measuring Instruments or the Sensors Such instruments are used to measure the disturbances, the controlled output variables, or the necessary secondary output variables and are the main sources of information about what is going on in the process The measuring means depend upon the types of variable, which is to be measured, and these variables must be recorded also. Following are some typical sensors, which are used for different variables measurements. 1. Pressure sensors 2. Temperature sensors 3. Flow rate sensors 4. Level sensors Characteristics example of these types of sensors is as follows. 1. Thermocouples or resistance thermometers for measuring the temperature, also used for severe purpose some radiation detectors may also be used. 2. Venturi meters also flow nozzles for flow measurements. 3. Gas chromatograph for measuring the composition of the stream. A good device for the measurement depends upon the environment in which it is to be used. Like a thermometer, it is not a good measuring device, as its signal is not rapidly transmitted. So signal transmission is very important in selecting the measuring device. So the measuring device must be rugged and reliable for an industrial environment.
110
3. Transducers Many measurements cannot be used for control until they are converted to physical quantities such as electric voltage and current a pneumatic signal. For example, stream gauges are metallic conductors whose resistance changes when mechanical strain is imposed on it. Thus they can be used to convert a mechanical signal to electric one. 4. Transmission Lines These are used to carry measurements signal from measuring device to the controller. In the past, mostly transmission lines were pneumatic nature that they are using the compressed air or liquid to transmit the signal but with the automation of industry and advent of electronic controllers, electric lines have over-ruled the pneumatic operations. Many times the measurements coming from a device are very weak and these must be amplified to get the things right. So it is very often to find amplifies in the transmission lines to the controller. For example the output of a thermocouple is only a few milli-volts so they must be amplified to few volts to get the controller. 5. Controller This is the hardware element that has intelligence. It receives the information from the measuring device and decides what action must be carried out. The older controllers were of limited intelligence, could perform very limited and simple operations and could implement very simple control laws. The use of digital computers in this field has increased the use of complicated control laws. 6. The Final Control Element This is the hardware element that implements the decision taken by the controller. For example, if the controller decides that flow rate of the outlet stream should be increased Or decreased in order to keep the level of the liquid in a tank then the final control element which is a control valve in this case implements the decision by slightly opening or closing the valve.
111
6.1.3 Modes of Control There are various modes in which the process can be controlled. The different modes depend upon the types of controllers and the action it takes to control any process variable. Actually the controller action is dependent on the output signal of the transmitter (sensor with transducer). This signal is compared with the set point to the controller and the error between these two is used to control the process. Different controllers react in different manner to control this off-set between the controlled variable and the set point. Different Types of Control Actions On the prescribed basis, following are the different types of control actions: 1. On-off control 2. Proportional control 3. Integral control 4. Rate or derivative control 5. Composite control Composite Control Modes Also there are combined control actions of different types of controllers. Actually in different operations, it is very rare that only one of the above control actions is found but a composite control action is the more often practice. Following are typical composite control modes, which are usually used: 1. Integral-Integral controller (PI-controller) 2. Proportional-Derivative controller (PD-controller) 3. Proportional-Integral-Derivative controller (PID-controller) In general the process controllers can be classified as: 1. Pneumatic controllers 2. Electronic controllers 112
3. Hydraulic controllers While dealing with the gases, the controller and the final control element may be pneumatically operated due to the following reasons. 1. The pneumatic controller is very rugged and almost free of
maintenance. The maintenance men have not had sufficient training and background in electronics, so pneumatic equipment is simple. 2. Pneumatic controller appears to be safer in a potentially explosive atmosphere
which is often present in the industry. 3. Transmissions distances are short pneumatic and electronic
transmissions system are generally equal up to about 200 to 300 feet. Above this distance electronic system beings to offer savings [18]. 6.1.4 Selection of Controller Actually in industry, only P, PI and PID control modes are the usual practice. The selection of most appropriate type of controller for any particular environment is a very systematic procedure. There are many ways and means that how a particular type of system may be controlled through which type of controller. Usually type of controller is selected using only quantitative considerations stemming from the analysis of the system and ending at the properties of that particular controller and the control objective. Proportional, Integral and Derivative control modes also affect the response of the system. Following is the summarized criterion to select the appropriate controller for any process depending upon the detailed study of the controller and control variable along with process severity. 1. If possible, use a simple proportional controller: Simple P-controller can be used if we can achieve acceptable off-set with not too high values of gain. So for gas pressure and liquid level control, usually a simple proportional controller may be used.
113
2. If a simple P-controller is not acceptable, use PI-controller: A steady-stat error always remains for proportional controller so in systems where this off-set is to be minimized, a PI-controller is incorporated. So in flow control applications, usually PI-controller is found. 3. Use a PID-controller to increase the speed of the closed loop response and retain robustness: The anticipatory characteristic of the derivative control enables to use somewhat higher values of proportional gains so that off-set is minimized with lesser deviations and good response of the system. Also it adds the stability to the system. So this type of control is used for sluggish multi-capacity processes like to control temperature and composition. In short best controller is selected on following basis; 1. 2. 3. Severity of process Accuracy required Cost
6.2.1 Feed Back Control Loop Feedback is a mechanism, process or signal that is looped back to control a system within itself. Such a loop is called a feedback loop. Intuitively many systems have an obvious input and output; feeding back part of the output so as to increase the input is positive feedback; feeding back part of the output in such a way as to partially oppose the input is negative feedback. In more general terms, a control system has input from an external signal source and output to an external load; this defines a natural sense (or direction) or path of propagation of signal; the feed forward sense or path describes the signal propagation from input to output; feedback describes signal propagation in the reverse sense. When a sample of the output of the system is fed back, in the reverse sense, by a distinct feedback path into the interior of the system, to contribute to the input of one of its internal feed forward components, especially an active device or a substance that is consumed in an irreversible reaction; it is called the "feedback". The propagation of the signal around the feedback loop takes a finite time because it is causal. Its disadvantage lies in its operational procedure. For example if a certain quantity is entering in a process, then a monitor will be there at the process to note its value. Any changes from the set point will be sent to the final control element through the controller so that to adjust the incoming quantity according to desired value (set point). But in fact change has already occurred and only corrective action can be taken while using feed back-control system. 6.2.2 Feed Forward Control Loop A method of control in which the value of a disturbance is measured, and action is taken to prevent the disturbance by changing the value of a process variable This is a control method designed to prevent errors from occurring in a process variable. This control system is better than feedback control because it anticipates the change in the process variable before it enters the process takes the preventive action. While in feedback enter system action is taken after the change has occurred. 115
6.2.3 Ratio Control A control loop in which, the controlling element maintains a predetermined ratio of one variable to another. Usually this control loop is attached to such as system where two different streams enter a vessel for reaction that may be of any kind. To maintain the stoichiometric quantities of different streams this loop is used so that to ensure proper process going on in the process vessel. 6.2.4 Auctioneering Control Loop This type of control loop is normally used for a huge vessel where, readings of a single variable may be different at different locations. This type of control loop ensures safe operation because it employs all the readings of different locations simultaneously, and compares them with the set point, if any of those readings is deviating from the set point then the controller sends appropriate signal to final control element. 6.2.5 Split Range Loop In this loop controller is per set with different values corresponding to different action to be taken at different conditions. The advantage of this loop is to maintain the proper conditions and avoid abnormalities at very differential levels. 6.2.6 Cascade Control Loop This is a control in which two or more control loops are arranged so that the output of, one controlling element adjusts the set point of another controlling element. This control loop is used where proper and quick control is difficult by simple feed forward or feed backward control. Normally first loop is a feedback control loop. We have selected a cascade control loop for our heat exchanger in order to get quick on proper control (19).
auctionary control loop is used to control temperature inside the reactor. Temperature is controlled through flow rate of steam. The heat generated is also removed by the coolant, which flows in the jacket around the reactor. The control objective is to keep the temperature of the reacting mixture constant at a desired value. Possible disturbances to the reactor include the feed temperature and the coolant temperature, the manipulated variable to these two disturbances is the coolant flow rate. We have employ cascade control loop by measuring temperature inside the reactor, and taking control action before its effect has been felt by the reacting mixture. Thus, if coolant temperature goes up, increases the flow rate of the coolant to remove the same amount of heat. Decrease the coolant flow rate when coolant temperature decreases.
117
TC
H2O IN
TT
HS
TT
GASIFIER
TT
COAL
FT
SET POINT
H20 OUT
DESIRED RATIO
FC
FT
OXYGEN
O2
118
COMPRESSOR
FC
SYN GAS IN
The discharge of a compressor is controlled with a flow control system .To prevent the discharge pressure from exceeding an upper limit, an override control with a high switch selector (HSS) is introduced. It transfers control action from the flow control to the pressure control loop whenever the discharge pressure exceeds the upper limit. Notice that flow control or pressure control is actually cascaded to the speed control of the compressors motor.
119
GAS OUT
GAS IN
FC
FT
SELEXOL OUT
Here a simple feedback control scheme is employed. Whenever the pressure drop becomes high or low, it will be sensed by the differential pressure sensor and will be controlled by the raw syngas flow rate. The control valve will accordingly become partially open or closed.
120
COLD H2O IN
TT
TC
TT
TT
HEAT EXCHANGER
TT
TT STEAM
121
Symbol Used
Description
TT
Temperature Transmitter
TC
Temperature Controller
TTTTT
Flow Transmitter
FT
FC FC
Flow Controller
PT
Pressure Transmitter
PC
Pressure Controller
SC
Speed Controller
LSS
122
7 Cost Estimation
7.1 Total Purchased Cost Of Major Equipment
7.1.1 Cost Estimation Of Heat Exchanger
Heat transfer =61.1 m2 Pressure = 5 bar Cost index of 2004 = 444.2 Cost index of 2011 = 635.8 As material of construction of shell and tube is carbon steel. The purchased cost can be calculated by using following method Purchased in 2004 Purchased cost = (bare cost from chart)(type factor)(pressure factor) Bare cost from chart= 30000 $ Type factor =1
123
AS Cost in 2004/cost in 2011= cost index in 2004/cost index in 2011 So Cost in 2011 = 42940.11706 $ Cost in 2011 = (purchased cost in 2004 cost index in 2011) / cost index in 2004
7.1.2 Cost Estimation Of Cyclone Separator Diameter of cyclone separator=0.58 Height of cyclone separator= 2.019 m Index of 2004= 444.2 Index of 2011= 681.7 Material of construction is carbon steel Purchased cost in 2004 Purchased cost in 2004= (bare cost from chart)(material factor) (pressure factor) So, Bare cost from chart Material factor= 1 pressure factor= 1 Purchased cost in 2004 = 6000 $ Purchased cost in 2011 Cost in 2004 /cost in 2011=cost index in 2004/cost index in 2011 = 6000 $ m
124
Cost in 2011 = (index of 2011purchased cost in 2004)/index in 2004 Cost in 2011 = 9208.014408 $
7.1.3 Cost Estimation Of Absorber Diameter of absorber= 0.7678 m Height of absorber= 26.06 m Index in 2004= 444.2 Index in 2011= 681.7 Material of construction is carbon steel Purchased cost in 2004 Purchased cost in 2004= (bare cost from chart)(material factor) (pressure factor) So, Bare cost from chart= 30000 $ Material factor= 1 Pressure factor= 1 Purchased cost in 2004= 30000 $ Purchased cost in 2011 Cost in 2011 = (index of 2011purchased cost in 2004)/index in 2004 Cost in 2011= 46040.07204 $
125
Now Packing cost Packing cost of packed column with packing of "intallox saddle" & packing size of 38mm Will $ 1020 per m3 Volume of packing =3.14r^2l Radius = 0.019 m Height of packing Volume of packing Cost of column packing Cost of column packing = volume cost per unit volume Cost of column packing = 21.47083456 $ Total cost of column = cost of vessel + cost of packing Total cost of column = 46061.54287 $ 7.1.4 Cost estimation of scrubber Diameter of scrubber= 0.49837954 Height of scrubber= 80.84018 Index in 2004= 444.2 Index in 2011= 681.7 As material of construction is carbon steel the purchased cost can be calculated using following Method m = 18.57 m = 0.021049838 m3
126
Purchased cost in 2004= (bare cost from chart) (material factor) (pressure Factor)
As two scrubbers will be installed therefore height of each absorber 40.42009 m Bare cost from chart = 100000 $ Material factor = 1 Pressure factor = 1 Purchased cost 2004 =100000 $
As there are 2 scrubbers thus cost of two scrubbers will be 200000 $ Purchased cost in 2011 Cost in 2004/cost in 2011= cost index in 2004/cost index in 2011 Cost in 2011= (index of 2011purchased cost in 2004)/index in 2004 Cost in 2011= 306933.8136 $ Packing cost of scrubber with packing of "intallox saddle" & packing size will be $ 1020
Volume of packing Volume of packing=3.14r^2l Radius = 0.019 m Volume of packing = 0.091635578 m3 Cost of column packing = 19.38 $ Total cost of column = 306953.1936 $ Total purchased cost of equipment (PCE)
127
Total purchased cost of equipment (PCE) = cost of reactor +cost of heat exchanger +cost of Cyclone separator + cost scrubber + cost of absorber So, Total purchased cost of equipment (PCE) = 420162.8679 $
AS 128
Total purchased cost of equipment = 420162.8679 $ Total physical plant cost (PPC) =PCE (1+F1+F2+F3+..+F9)
Total physical plant cost (PPC) = 1428553.751 $ Now we will find the fixed capital Fixed capital=PPC (1+F10+F11+F12) SO, Fixed capital = 2071402.939 $ Total investment required for project AS, Total investment required for project = fixed capital + working capital Suppose the working capital is 10%of fixed capital Now, working capital = 0.10fixed capital Working capital = 207140.2939 $ Total investment required for project = 2278543.233 $ Total investment required for project =fixed capital +working capital
Laboratory cost Supervision cost Supervision cost Plant overheads Plant overheads Capital charges
Local taxes =0.02fixed capital Local taxes =41428.05878 $ Royalties=0.01fixed capital Royalties= 20714.02939 $ Total fixed costs= 618736.7054 $
130
7.5 Utilities
Water required =H2O required for gasifier + H2O for scrubber+H2O for absorber+ H2O For exchanger H2O mains Cooling H2O Steam Compressed air N2 =27346.89 kg/hr = 889.66 kg/hr = 310.19 kg/hr = 551.448 kg/hr = 2397.6 kg/hr
Cost of 27346.89 kg of water mains= 1367.3445cents 100 cents I cent 1367.345 cents 1367.345 cents Cost of cooling water 1000 kg 889.66kg 889.66kg 100 cents =1$ =$(1/100) =$(1/100)1367.345 =13.67345 $ IN 2004 =1cent/1000 kg =1 cent = (1/100)889.66 = 8.8966 cents =1$ 131
8.8966 CENTS 8.8966 CENTS Cost of steam 1000 kg steam 1kg steam 310.19 kg steam 310.19kg steam Cost index in 2004 Cost index in 2011
= (1/100)8.8966$ = 0.088966 $ in 2004 =12$/1000kg =12$ = (12/1000) $ = (12/1000)310.19$ =3.72228 in 2004 = 1178.5 = 1490.2
Cost in 2011= (index of 2011purchased cost in 2004)/index in 2004 Cost of water mains in 2011= 17.28992379 $ Cost of cooling water in 2011= 0.112496507 $ Cost of steam in 2011= 4.70678121 $ Utilities= 22.10920151 $ Variable cost= 120736.1386 $ Direct production cost=total fixed cost +total variable cost Direct production cost= 739472.8439 $ Now Sales expense=0.3direct production cost Sales expense= 221841.8532 $ General overheads=10000 $ 132
Research & development= 20000 $ Annual operating cost=direct production cost +sales expense over heads + research & development Annual operating cost= 991314.6971 $ [15]
133
References
1. Higman, Christopher and Maarten De. COAL GASEFICATION. Newyork : Elsevier, 2003. 2. A.Meyers, Robert. A HAND BOOK OF SYNFUELS TECHNOLOGY. s.l. : McGraw, 1984. 3. [Online] htp://www.pakistanenergy.com.ok/year_book_pdf.htm. 4. [Online] htp://blogs.princenton.edu/chm333/f2005/group2/03_chemistry. 5. G.speight, James. The Chemistry and Technology of Coal.second Edition. Newyork : Markel Deckner , INC, 1994. 6. William, a,Pourkashanian. Combustion and Gasefication of CoaL. Newyork : s.n., 2000. 7. Gupta, O.P. Element of Fuels, Furnaces & Refractories 4th edition. s.l. : khanna, 1990. 8. [Online] htp://www.Gasefication.Org. 9. [Online] http:// en.wikipedia.org/wiki/heat capacity. 10. [Online] htp:// www.slideshare.net/Shambhudayal/design-Theory-Cyclones. 11. [Online] http://en.wkipedia.org/wiki/specific. 12. [Online] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/latent_heat. 13. Couper, Penny and M. Walas. Chemical Process Equipment Selection and Design Second edition. Burlington : Elsevier, 2005. 14. Peter, M.S. and Timmerhaus. Plant Design And Economics For Chemical Engineering 5th Edition. s.l. : Mc-Graw- Hill, 1999. 134
15. Coulson, J.M. and Richardson,J.F. Chemical Engineering.4th Edition Volume 6. s.l. : Butterworth Heminann, 1991. 16. Kern, D.Q. Process Heat Transfer. s.l. : Mc-Graw Hill, 2000. 17. Stephanopoulos, George. Chemical Process Control. s.l. : Elsevier. 18. Perry, R.H and D.W. Green. Perry's Chemical Engineering Handbook , 7th Edition. Newyork : Mc-Graw Hill, 1997. 19. A, Smith and Carlos and Corripio, Armando B. Principle And Practice of Automatic Process Control. .
135