discrimination Is it easy for people to dislike others? Blue eyes versus brown eyes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hqp6GnYqIjQ
We have all experienced some form of stereotyping, prejudice or discrimination Skin color (race/ethnicity) Gender Disabilities Marital status Perceptions of inequality We think in terms of in-group versus out-group Those that are like us and those that are not like us We always want to be not on the bottom
We are risk averse (prospect theory). Losses feel worse than gains feel good
Our understanding of society depends on framing of the relative wins and losses by groups White people are losing ground versus Blacks are gaining Perceptions of inequality When message framed as minority gains, no differences between whites and non-whites.
When message framed as White losses, Whites perceived more progress towards equality than non- Whites.
When messages framed as White losses and minority gains, Whites perceived much progress towards equality, whereas non-Whites indicated the least progress. 4.85 4.7 5.45 4.64 5.69 4.39 WHITES NON-WHITES P r o g r e s s
t o w a r d s
e q u a l i t y
Minority gains White losses Minority gains and white losses Stereotyping Important vocabulary:
Stereotypes: Cognitive component Beliefs about what group members are like
Prejudice: Affect component Feelings about certain groups
Discrimination: Behavioral component Differential treatment of people based on group membership
Thought question: Is discrimination always conscious? Is it always done in an exclusionary or hostile way? Stereotypes include: Traits Physical appearance Abilities Behavior Can either be positive or negative Can either be accurate or inaccurate
Ideas about stereotypes can lead to differential access to powerful positions Glass Ceiling Glass Ceiling: A barrier that prevents a person of a minority group to advance to top positions. e.g., Think manager think male.
Minority individuals who reach leadership positions Tend to have lower evaluations of work performance Experience more discrimination at work (and for women, sexual harassment).
Violation of expectations Glass Cliff Glass Cliff: Admittance of minority individuals to a position of power When crisis occurs Position is precarious There is greater risk of failure
Research has also found that such individuals are more likely to get fired. Seeing a few instances of successful minority group individuals leads to the belief that less change is needed Tokenism Distorts perceptions that conditions are equal Performance suffers, when people know they were selected for their token status and not for their skills.
Speaking out against stereotypes and discriminations If as a member of minority group: Viewed negatively, regardless of whether complaining was justified Viewed positively if taking personal responsibility How do we judge people from different groups?
We have different standards depending on peoples group membership Use different reference groups to judge performance same rating does not mean equal rating
Stereotypes: Schema, used for organizing, interpreting and recalling information Stereotypes are schemas for groups of people Outgroup homogeneity effect
Not all stereotypes are recognized Single versus married
We may also encounter exceptions to the rule Subtyping Protects the stereotype
Stereotypes may change when the relationship between groups change More on this later
Prejudice: Feelings towards social groups Negative feelings people have towards groups In the presence of a group member Thinking of a group member
Believing that groups have underlying essences (perhaps biological) Justification for differential treatment
Different types of emotions leads to different types of reactions Reducing negative emotions = reducing discrimination Three perspective on why prejudice exists:
1. Prejudice happens in response to
Strength of identification with group membership matters (The Rocky example) When made to think of a joint identity (e.g., Americans), threat and thus prejudice is reduced.
Threat to self-esteem Derogation and sabotage of target group Maintenance of group position and self-esteem restored 2. Competition for resources Zero-sum outcomes Realistic conflict theory Robbers Cave https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6QGNxRGgBwM
3. Social categorization Us versus Them Social identity theory We want to feel good about the group we belong to Not all stereotypes are conscious Implicit associations: links between group membership and evaluative responses.
Study in which participants were flashed images: Black or White person Gun or no gun
Participants reacted quicker to seeing Black and gun, or White and no gun 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 Black White R e a c t i o n
t i m e
No Gun Gun Discrimination: Prejudice in Action Modern Racism: Subtle beliefs and feeling Minorities seek more benefits than they deserve Discrimination does not affect minorities
May be measured using tasks that get at implicit associations Bonafide Pipeline: Quicker responding when seeing White and positive words Quicker responding when seeing Black and negative words But does it really measure prejudice? People want to maintain a self-image of being good. Social comparison to extreme cases of prejudiced people (e.g., Ku Klux Klan). Collective guilt Moral disengagement Motivated forgetting
Ways to Reduce Prejudice and Discrimination Social learning theory says we that we pick up attitudes through significant people in our lives. Must strongly identify with these significant others
5 ways of reducing prejudice 1. Contact hypothesis 2. Re-categorization 3. Guilt 4. Just say No 5. Social Influence Contact Hypothesis Increased contact allows for the recognition of similarities Direct contact as well as indirect (knowing that someone else knows a person of the other group) lessens prejudice
Re-categorization Shifting the boundaries of Us and Them Common ingroup identity model
Guilt Collective guilt, even if oneself has not behaved in a prejudiced manner Framing White advantage versus Black disadvantage Viewing ones ingroup as the beneficiary may lessen prejudice
Just say No Training people to break stereotype associations (e.g., Black and negative). Can also teach to make external attributions
Social influence When receiving information that others see the minority group positively, people change their attitudes to be more positive. When receiving information that others see the minority group negatively, people change their attitudes to be more negative.