Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
(cont.)
Copyright 2010 McGraw-Hill Australia Pty Ltd
PPTs t/a International Finance: An Analytical Approach 3e by Imad A. Moosa 11-3
Slides prepared by Afaf Moosa
Commodity arbitrage
*
Pi SP i
(cont.)
Copyright 2010 McGraw-Hill Australia Pty Ltd
PPTs t/a International Finance: An Analytical Approach 3e by Imad A. Moosa
Slides prepared by Afaf Moosa
Definition of arbitrage
(cont.)
Copyright 2010 McGraw-Hill Australia Pty Ltd
PPTs t/a International Finance: An Analytical Approach 3e by Imad A. Moosa
Slides prepared by Afaf Moosa
Two-point arbitrage
S A ( x / y) SB ( x / y)
(S A )0
( S A )1 ( S B )1
(S B )0
Dy Dy
Qy Qy
A B
Two-Point Arbitrage: Example
• Suppose that
Sydney – 3.5780 (AUD/GBP)
London – 0.5120 (GBP/AUD)
Invert the exchange rate in London, which gives
(AUD/GBP) = 1/0.5120 = AUD1.9531
The equilibrium condition is violated because the GBP is
more expensive in Sydney than in London
Arbitragers buy the GBP in London at 1.9531 and sell it in
Sydney at 3.5780, making a profit of
π=3.5780-1.9531=1.6249
The effect of arbitrage is to raise the price of the GBP in
London and to lower it in Sydney, until they are equalised
somewhere between 1.9531 and 3.5780
Two-point arbitrage with bid-offer spreads
Sb , A x / y S a , B x / y
S a , A x / y Sb , B x / y
S ( x / z)
S ( x / y)
S ( y / z)
or
S ( x / y ) S ( y / z ) S ( z / x) 1
• No-arbitrage condition if S ( x / y )
S ( x / z)
S ( y / z)
S ( x / z)
• If S ( x / y ) ,
S ( y / z)
possibility of arbitrage profit arises by following the sequence
x → z → y → x.
S ( x / z)
• If S ( x / y ) ,
S ( y / z)
possibility of arbitrage profit arises by following the sequence
x → y → z → x.
Profitable/unprofitable sequences
(a) Unprofitable sequence (b) Profitable sequence
x x
S ( x / z)
S ( x / y)
S ( y / z)
z y z y
S ( x / z) S ( x / y)S ( y / z )
1 1
S ( x / y)S ( y / z ) S ( x / z)
S ( x1 / x2 ) S ( x2 / x3 ) S ( xn / x1 ) 1
Foreign Domestic
investment investment
Converting at
spot rate
K
S
Investing in
foreign assets
K
(1 i )
S
Reconverting at
forward rate
KF K (1 i )
(1 i )
S
i i* f
and
F S
i i*
S
Implications of the CIP Condition
• The currency offering the higher rate of interest must sell at a forward
discount
If i > i*, then f > 0
The foreign currency, which is offering a lower interest rate, must sell
at a forward premium
– The foreign currency becomes more expensive to buy
The domestic currency, which is offering a higher interest rate, must
sell at a forward discount
– The domestic currency becomes cheaper to buy
If i < i*, then f < 0
The foreign currency, which is offering a higher interest rate, must sell
at a forward discount
– The foreign currency becomes cheaper to buy
The domestic currency, which is offering a lower interest rate, must
sell at a forward premium
– The domestic currency becomes more expensive to buy
Covered interest arbitrage
Borrowing Borrowing
domestic currency foreign currency
1 unit 1 unit
Converting at Converting at
spot rate spot rate
1
S
S
Investing at Loan Loan Investing at
foreign rate repayment repayment domestic rate
1
(1 i ) S (1 i )
S
Reconverting at Reconverting
forward rate at forward rate
F S
(1 i ) 1 i 1 i (1 i )
S F
Covered margin Covered margin
F S
(1 i ) (1 i ) (1 i ) (1 i )
S F
i* i f
Covered Interest Arbitrage
• In an arbitrage from a foreign currency to the
domestic currency
The covered margin is the difference between the
foreign currency value of the proceeds and the loan
repayment
S
(1 i ) (1 i * )
F
or approximately
i i* f
Covered Interest Arbitrage
New York
One year Today
Finish: Start:
6. Repay$1,070,000 (the loan plus 2. Convert the $1 million to pounds at $1.75/£ for
interest) of out of the $1,075,200. £571,428.57
5. Collect the £640,000 and deliver 3. Invest the £571,428.57 in London at 12%,
it to the bank’s foreign exchange (receiving £640,000 by year end)
department in return for
$1,075,200.
F
which gives (1 i ) (1 i )
S
1 i
F S *
1 i
The CIP Forward Rate
• Here, F is the implied interest parity forward rate,
which is the value of the forward rate consistent
with no arbitrage opportunities
If CIP holds, then F F meaning that the
interest parity forward rate is equal to the actual
forward rate
The CIP Condition – An Example
• Suppose that
The current spot rate is S(AUD/GBP) = 3.8000
The 3-month forward rate is F(AUD/GBP) = 3.7800
The 3-month (annualised) interest rate in Australia is
7%
The 3-month (annualised) interest rate in the UK is
5.50%
The CIP Condition – An Example
• We must convert the annual interest rates into
quarterly interest rates
S
The CIP Condition – An Example
• Qualitatively, there is a violation in the CIP
condition, because the British pound, which is
offering a lower rate of return, is selling at a forward
discount
The currency offering a lower rate of return must sell
at a premium, for equilibrium to hold
• Quantitatively, the interest rate differential is greater
than the forward spread (discount)
Funds would flow from the UK to Australia
This will eventually lead to changes in interest rates
and exchange rates in both countries
Covered arbitrage with bid-offer spreads
• Arbitrager is a price taker and the banker is a market
maker in the foreign exchange market, therefore an
arbitrager
Buys at the (higher) offer exchange rate
Sells at the (lower) bid exchange rate
• As price taker in the money market
borrows at the (higher) offer interest rate
lends at the (lower) bid interest rate
Covered arbitrage with bid-offer spreads
• Arbitrager borrows domestic (foreign) currency funds at
the domestic (foreign) offer interest rate, ia (ia* )
• Convert borrowed funds into foreign (domestic) currency
at the spot offer (bid) rate, Sa (Sb), obtaining 1/Sa (Sb)
foreign (domestic) currency units. This amount is invested
at the foreign (domestic) bid interest rate, i * (ib)
b
• The foreign (domestic) currency value of the invested
amount at the end of the investment period is (1 / S a )(1 ib* )
(Sb(1+ib))
• Reconvert this amount into domestic (foreign) currency
( Fb / S a )(1 ib* )
at the forward bid (offer) rate, Fb (Fa), to obtain
domestic ((Sb/Fa)(1+ib), foreign) currency units
• The value of the loan plus interest is (1+ia) domestic
(foreign, (1 ia ) ). currency units
*
Covered interest arbitrage in the presence of bid-
offer spreads
Domestic foreign Foreign domestic
1 unit 1 unit
1 Sb
Sa
Loan Loan
Investing at foreign rate repayment Investing at domestic rate
repayment
1
Sa
(1 ib* ) Sb (1 ib )
Reconverting at forward rate Reconverting at forward rate
Fb Sb
Sa
(1 ib* ) 1 ia 1 ia* Fa
(1 ib )
Fb Sb
(1 ib* ) (1 ia ) (1 ib ) (1 ia* )
Sa Fa
Covered arbitrage with bid-offer spreads
• In an arbitrage from the domestic currency to a
foreign currency, the covered margin is calculated as
Fb
(1 ib* ) (1 ia )
Sa
Since Fb/Sa=(1+f)/(1+m), where f is the forward
spread and m is the bid-offer spread, it follows that
ib* ia f m
i i* f
Covered arbitrage with bid-offer spreads
• In an arbitrage from the foreign currency to a
domestic currency, the covered margin is calculated
as
Sb
(1 ib ) (1 ia* )
Fa
ib ia* f m
Covered arbitrage and the consistency of cross
forward rates
• Through covered arbitrage in the spot market, it is
possible to maintain the consistency of cross forward
rates, meaning the cross forward rate between 2
currencies is identical to the forward rate that is
actually quoted in the market.
This can be calculated as
1 ix
S ( x / z )
F ( x / y) 1 iz F ( x / z)
1 i y F ( y / z)
S ( y / z )
1 iz
Reasons for interest in CIP
• The reasons for the increased interest in CIP are
It can be used as a measure of capital mobility
It links the term structure of interest rates with the
term structure of forward spreads
f = (F – S)/S ≈ i – i*
It implies optimal resource allocation in a market
economy
It has implications for financing and investment
decisions
Deviations from CIP
• Deviations from CIP are indicated by a non-zero
covered margin
CIP has been found to hold precisely in the integrated
and unregulated Eurocurrency market
This is not surprising, because these markets come
close to satisfying the notion of a perfectly competitive
financial market
Very low transaction costs
Minimal taxes
Very little capital controls
Measurement errors tend to give rise to non-zero
covered margins
Deviations from CIP
• There are a number of factors that make covered
arbitrage opportunities unprofitable or unattractive
Transaction costs
Political risk
Tax differentials
Liquidity differences
Other factors, such as capital controls
The PPP and CIP
S t S t 1 ε t
It is not possible to make a profit by speculating in
the foreign exchange market
The exchange rate follows a random walk
It has no systematic pattern, and hence, is
unpredictable
Spot and Forward Market Efficiency
• The concept of forward market efficiency
encompasses both the spot and forward markets
or
S F ζt
e
Carry trade
S(USD/AUD) 0.60
E(e) = p
= (F/S) – 1
= (0.63/0.60) – 1
= 0.05 or 5%
Se
1 i (1 i )
*
S
This states that the gross domestic return on an
investment is equal to the gross uncovered foreign
return
The UIP Equilibrium Condition (cont’d)
*
i i S e
Implications of the UIP Condition
• The currency offering the higher rate of interest must
be expected to depreciate
If i > i*, then S 0
e
6 4
i i 0.5%
*
4 4
Three months from now, the US dollar should
appreciate 0.5%
The level of the exchange rate 3 months from now
should be 1.005 x 1.80 = 1.8090
Return on Investments
(with Uncovered Position)
Investor
(K)
Foreign Domestic
Investment Investment
Converting at
spot rate
K
S
Investing in
foreign assets
K
(1 i )
S
Reconverting at
expected spot
rate
KS e K (1 i )
(1 i )
S
Uncovered Interest Parity
Domestic foreign Foreign domestic
Converting at Converting at
spot rate spot rate
1 SS0
S0
Investing at Loan Loan
Investing at
foreign rate repayment repayment
domestic rate
1
(1 i ) S0 (1 i )
S0
Reconverting at Reconverting at
spot rate spot rate
S1 S0
(1 i ) 1 i 1 i (1 i )
S0 S1
Uncovered margin Uncovered margin
S1 S0
(1 i ) (1 i ) (1 i ) (1 i )
S0 S1
Uncovered Interest Parity
• To illustrate the mechanics of UIP, assume that
You have $AUD1 to invest in an Australian interest
earning asset
You are a resident of Australia
Earn a domestic interest rate equal to i, which is 5%
You can invest in a US-denominated interest earning
asset
Earn a foreign interest rate equal to i*, which is 6%
Uncovered Interest Parity
• UIP states that the currency offering a higher rate of
interest should depreciate i i* S e
When this is not the case, then there are arbitrage
opportunities
Assume the US asset which is offering a higher return, is
not depreciating
As such, the UIP condition is violated, and so open
arbitrage opportunities exist
Australia US
12 month interest rate 5% 6%
To invest $AUD 1 $AUD 1
S(AUD per US) 1.35
Amount invested $AUD 1 $USD 0.74
Value at end $AUD 1.05 $USD 0.79
Expected exchange rate 1.45
$AUD Value of Invest A$1.05 A$1.14
Combining PPP and Interest Parity
• An expectations form of PPP can be derived from
the relative form:
S P P
e e *e
iP i P
e * *e
The Real Interest Parity (RIP) Condition
• The Fisher effect states that the nominal interest rate r
is made up of two components:
A real required rate of return
An inflation premium equal to the expected amount
of inflation
• The ex ante (expected) real interest rate is obtained by
subtracting the expected inflation rate from the nominal
interest rate
r iP
e e
The RIP Condition
• The Fisher effect would only work if the nominal
interest rate changes in proportion to inflation so that
the real interest rate remained unchanged.
• However, some empirical studies have shown that
real interest rates are not constant because nominal
interest rates do not adjust in full to changes in
inflation.
The Real Interest Parity (RIP) Condition
• RIP is used as an indicator of
The efficiency of goods and financial markets
The degree of integration of goods and capital
markets across countries
The degree of capital mobility
International Arbitrage and Parity Conditions
• The main macroeconomic variables are all linked by a series of
relationships
PPP
links the domestic goods market with the foreign goods market
Unbiased efficiency
Prices reflect all currently available information so that there are no
systematic patterns in the forecasting error
CIP
links the domestic financial market with that of the foreign financial
market, without any exchange rate risk
UIP
links the domestic financial market with that of the foreign financial
market, with complete exchange rate exposure
RIP
links both domestic financial and goods markets with that of the
foreign financial and goods markets